Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the inaugural event of the European Research Council on February 27, 2007, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

27 February 2007 · Inaugural event of the European Research Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the inaugural event of the European Research Council on February 27, 2007, in Berlin, marking the ERC's formal establishment.
Main themes
European Research Council inauguration, research excellence and independence, climate change and energy sustainability, European competitiveness in innovation, Germany's research and technology policy, small and medium-sized enterprises research support, Seventh Framework Programme, translating ideas into commercial success, global research leadership, European Institute of Technology
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,586
82nd percentile
Sentences
167
84th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%43%
  • Economic 20%20%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Environmental 9%9%
  • Social 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 4%

167 sentences in 62 paragraphs

Dear Professor Kleiner,

Dear President of the European Research Council,

Secretary General,

Dear Annette Schavan,

Commissioner Potočnik,

Ms Niebler,

Dear colleagues from the parliaments,

and above all you, the guests of this two-day symposium on the founding of the European Research Council,

I am delighted to be able to lay a milestone in European research policy with you today. For the European Research Council - also called the "European Research Council" or "ERC" for short; however it may come to be established in the various languages - will, or so I at any rate hope, bring together the research in the European member states, which can certainly be described as excellent, into a "Champions League" of research and let it shine.

In doing so, we are crossing the borders of national research and networking excellence across the member states in a new way. We do this out of the understanding that research and new technologies are the driving forces of economic dynamism, indeed, so to speak, the foundation for our ability in Europe to grow economically, to maintain and increase our prosperity and to be competitive worldwide.

What the Lisbon goal essentially expresses, namely that Europe wants to be a continent of ideas, innovation, creativity and competitiveness, and the best continent in this respect, is something we may not quite achieve by 2010. But having this goal is, in my view, something essential. For we also know: whoever sets no goals, whoever has no idea of their own self-image, should not be surprised if they then achieve nothing.

How can Europe become such a continent of ideas and innovation? European research policy rests on three foundations:

on excellence,

internationality

and the idea of freedom of research.

The work of the European Research Council will be guided by these in particular. Above all, it will be a matter of reorienting basic research, of paying special attention to the promotion of young talent in Europe and of providing greater support to young researchers.

I will not hide the fact that we are a little proud that the start of the European Research Council - for it was, after all, constituted some time ago - falls within the German EU Council Presidency. Some would have wished for the whole thing to have got under way earlier. But now we feel proud to hold the German Council Presidency precisely at this time and to witness this start. Because the preparatory work took a while, some of you may also have thought: "Good things take time." The fact that we are in the German Council Presidency also makes us a little happy because we believe that, from the German experience in research policy and research organisation, we were able to contribute a great deal to the founding of this European Research Council.

Now the expectations of everyone involved are high. For it is a body distinguished by two special features that have not existed in this form in European research funding before.

First:

The Research Council is independent.

And

second:

It is committed solely to excellence.

Now, I do have two ears that can still hear reasonably well, and I know that it is precisely these two special features that are the source of your concerns: will we manage to preserve them?

When I say that this is something new, that does not mean - to say the positive thing first - that European research policy has so far had nothing to do with excellence and did not also include projects developed by researchers. But we all know that a multitude of criteria had to come together for excellence and a good idea to end up as a project worthy of funding. That has certainly led to the integration of the various research nations. But as is always the case when you have additional boundary conditions, the main condition sometimes comes under some threat. That is why we - I say this at any rate for us as the Federal Republic of Germany - will make sure that excellence and independence remain the criteria of this European Research Council.

I assume that Mr Potočnik, who is also familiar with times in which excellence and independence did not play a very large role, will be something like a patron saint of these ideas of the European Research Council. For he holds responsibility in the Commission for somewhat longer than a single Council Presidency lasts.

So I consider excellence and independence to be the essential prerequisites. I can only report that, as far as independence is concerned, Germany has had really good experiences with its German Research Foundation, and that we - even if politics perhaps sometimes finds it difficult - have more or less come to terms with the fact that science itself can judge relatively well what excellence is. Since we are now not in national hollows but in a European web of excellence, there should always be enough independent reviewers from all directions to ensure a truly independent review. We have therefore set up a "Scientific Council", to which 22 scientists of the highest rank have been appointed. It is a body that should be able to decide independently of the political and administrative levels, not only on projects but also on strategic and personnel decisions, because these are of course also connected.

I would advise you, if at the beginning you feel aggrieved, to state these grievances clearly so that wrong patterns do not become ingrained. I promise that we will talk about it openly - I say this very particularly also on behalf of my colleague Ms Schavan. For it is in our own interest.

The

first

point: research needs freedom. We know that. Basic research in particular depends on not being subjected to the pressure of immediate exploitation. In a time when the accounting for what has been done moves ever closer to the start of the actual project, and one should ideally have finished the project before even hinting at what one intends to do - in such a time you also need the support of the public. For the result of basic research is often something unexpected.

That is why, in turn, it is very important that politics does not force you into too many discussions about priorities. I always say jokingly: since I myself stopped working as a scientist, people like me always take the essential new directions of research from the arts and culture pages of the national newspapers. But once they have arrived there, perhaps at the level of basic research you are already talking about quite different things. That is why we must be very careful about believing that by reading the newspapers diligently one already knows where research is heading.

That means: we know that excellence can be promoted by politics, through framework conditions. But politics must not restrict the inventive spirit, the pioneering spirit of scientists. We have to live with the fact that you are given free space. We have to live with the fact that we do not know when you will develop and invent something, and we naturally hope that nevertheless something will come out of it now and then - I will not hide that either - which will in turn delight us and excite us.

The

second

point: we need young researchers. We need a broader research landscape in Europe. It is indeed one of the truly regrettable findings - we recently discussed this in Cabinet with the Research Minister - that, in order to reach the goal of spending three percent of gross domestic product on research and innovation, we do not at the moment even have the number of scientists or engineers needed. This is not only a German phenomenon, which already seems odd enough to us - for we actually think that we are a country in which many good things have been invented - but in Europe as a whole 700,000 researchers are lacking. That means we need more young people who choose research and development.

With your "Starting Grants" funding programme, I believe, a precondition has been created for launching a promising and also novel kind of support for young researchers. If young people are given the opportunity to work at the level of established scientists, to publish and to hire scientific staff themselves, that is, if they are also given a certain advance of trust, then this should once again promote the attractiveness of European research. That is why I wish you particularly good luck in these efforts.

It is about motivating researchers from Europe. It is about perhaps bringing back researchers who have moved from Europe to other continents. And - something I think is very good, also with a view to the openness of the European Union - it is about bringing excellence to Europe, so that after a few years people here may perhaps be able to say: in Europe there is a climate of innovation, creativity and curiosity; here is everything we need for research. That would of course then enhance Europe's reputation worldwide.

I would therefore also like to encourage all those responsible in universities and research institutions to take up the challenge and offer an attractive home to researchers worthy of ERC funding. For the ERC itself cannot create a research environment, but can only make opportunities for it available.

Basic research, as I have already said, cannot be planned as far as the insights to be drawn from it are concerned. It must therefore be selected sensibly and meaningfully by experts and must not be prescribed by politics. Room for basic research is important - for all the application orientation that we of course also need. We know - I really do not need to say this in this circle, because it would be carrying owls to Athens - that many inventions known to us today, whether X-rays, penicillin or much else, came about rather by chance, rather incidentally, rather as products of other lines of research. That is why protecting free space is so immensely important.

We expect that those who work in the research areas selected by the ERC will push their own limits, take pleasure in research and of course have to hold their own in the competition among applicants. That is clear. That is why, Professor Winnacker, I wish you too many applicants rather than too few. I also wish you a firm hand in the sorting-out. For if once again three countries have got together to do something or other, they can go elsewhere within the Seventh Research Framework Programme. With you, only excellence is at home. I think you will still have a number of discussions within the Seventh Research Framework Programme on this. I also encourage Parliament to keep a sharp eye on ensuring that personal acquaintances and long-established beneficiaries of earlier research programmes do not develop a kind of customary right to be involved in the new research institutions as well.

We have a multitude of areas in which we need insights. If I now single out two examples, this is not - I say this right at the outset - to be understood as prejudging what we expect of you. - I will come shortly to the European Institute of Technology, where we can perhaps exert a little more political influence. - But I believe that there are great challenges for us. Merely as an example, I mention here the question of energy research and climate research.

I mention these examples because next week at our Council meeting we will devote ourselves very particularly to these two topics, and because I believe that the global changes to our environment can of course leave us anything but cold. The question of how energy supply can be ensured sustainably, both in the sense of ecological sustainability and in the sense of security of supply, is also one of the questions that greatly preoccupies us as representatives of the industrialised countries, or of the countries committed to the industrial and knowledge society.

We need better efficiencies. We need CO2-free technologies or technologies that are CO2-efficient. We need the development of renewable energy and, overall, an efficiency revolution. So that means that we as Europeans will have a field here. If we cultivate it, we have the chance in the coming decades also to be exporters of technology and innovation to other regions of the world.

Europe accounts for 15 percent of total CO2 emissions. As politicians, we are therefore often asked: why are you getting so worked up? Why is this such an important area in Europe? To that I can only say: it has two components. The first is: we will not convince the emerging economies if we do not set an example ourselves. The second component is: whoever develops new technologies today will tomorrow also have the profits and the leadership in the export economy. That is why it is certainly important for us Europeans to set an example. On the other hand, we know that without a worldwide consensus, since climate change is an important issue, Europe alone will not be able to achieve anything. That means the task of politics is to position Europe as a continent that is a pioneer.

I say quite clearly that a considerable change of awareness on this issue is taking place in America. Once the Americans start on something and consider it important, the Europeans have to hurry to keep up. In this respect, I believe, a much greater competition is emerging. But it is good and important that we are also active, so to speak, in favour of international agreements.

In Germany we have taken a new path to advance the subject of research - I mean not only energy and climate research, but also research concerning high, advanced technologies as a whole - which I believe is very promising. Our Research Minister has succeeded in developing a joint strategy with all the ministries in which departmental research takes place - and in a federal government there are many of them. Much as I would wish for Europe, she has made clear in Germany, using 17 strategies:

Where do we stand?

What must we do, if we are not already world leaders, to become world leaders?

Where are we ahead?

What means can the state offer to improve and strengthen these research areas and to break new ground?

How can we develop new instruments to achieve a better combination of state funding of research with industrial research and industry-funded research?

Germany has - at least that is how we see it - always been very good at developing ideas and often still at patenting them, but we have repeatedly had weaknesses when it comes to marketing. It still rankles with us today that, although Konrad Zuse built the first computer, the really big computer manufacturers today produce quite far away from Berlin. It rankles at least as much that, although the MP3 player was developed in a Max Planck institution, the really big production does not take place in Germany. In this respect, in our own research policy - now leaving the ERC aside for a moment - we naturally attach importance to finding instruments with which we can also put promising ideas into practice, in order then to develop lasting jobs from them.

Since Germany's economic structure is strongly shaped by small and medium-sized enterprises, I believe that in particular the so-called research bonus, that is, support for medium-sized enterprises that award contracts to research institutions, in particular universities of applied sciences and universities, will be a very interesting combination with which we can enrich German research policy.

The founding of the European Research Council comes at a time when the Seventh Research Framework Programme is also beginning. With over 50 billion euros, this research programme has an enormous volume. One can say it is the largest research programme in the world. But that alone does not guarantee quality. With it, however, we have a chance to create really important material conditions for European research. The European Research Council has about 6.7 billion euros of this at its disposal. This must be spent according to the criteria I have described. But you should by no means drift along as an "island" in this Seventh Research Framework Programme; rather, you should not shy away from forging contacts with the other areas too. There must be interweaving. It cannot be that somewhere here a little island of independence and excellence floats and, as its counterpart, everything else carries on as it always has. Instead, I would also wish for the founding of the European Research Council to fertilise all European research activity and the handling of the Seventh Research Framework Programme.

That is why I would like to say a heartfelt thank you, because even before its founding the European Research Council kindly dealt with another European idea, namely the "European Institute of Technology" - not loved by everyone from the very first hour, viewed by the European Research Council with the utmost scepticism, and always associated, when dealing with it, with the question: if we once get involved with it, won't we get our hands a little dirty and already be almost part of it? I nevertheless thank you for having delivered an opinion on it. You will also never be associated with it if it should perhaps not yet work the way you want it to, for we are fighting bravely, esteemed Commissioner Potočnik. - Warm greetings to Commission President Barroso, so that the good idea of a European institute of technology can really be implemented through a good design.

In this - and I want to leave this here too - the idea of the network is the decisive idea. There is no point in founding a new institution of which we then hope that one day, like a phoenix from the ashes, it will appear as a university that we admire. Only from the existing excellence of research institutions in Europe, through interesting networking and concentration of certain research areas, also in the field of technological development, can we gain an excellence that develops, so to speak, into something that is also admired worldwide. But all of these are products grown from the base. That is why we - and on this we are very much agreed in the Federal Government - will at times also be uncomfortable partners in Europe; but not because we want to bring something down, but because we really want it to become a success.

If we are honest with one another, we have also had experiences in Germany - and there are such experiences in Europe too - where something was founded with good will that afterwards was so rigid that it had to undergo a permanent process of review and benchmarking and was not dynamic enough to bring about truly excellent developments.

If there is on the one hand the European Research Council and on the other a breathing, dynamic system in a network structure in which really interesting technological developments take place, then these could be two things that complement each other well. But if it goes according to the principle "Who hasn't got an agency for a long time and now needs a place again to found something or other", then the thing will be a "shot into the oven", as we say in Germany. Then it will not meet expectations. On this I say again: Europe is not doing so well worldwide that we can afford another 20 faulty designs before we jointly find a proper design.

That is why I can only encourage all those who are friends of the European Research Council - and there seem to be a great many of them, judging by the number of people present here: get involved in the European research discussion. It is not always immediately transparent in Europe. On closer inspection, the system always reveals itself to anyone who has worked their way into it. One just has to be careful not to have been so bent out of shape by the familiarisation phase that one can only think in the direction of the European institutions.

That is why you should also keep a certain distance, Mr President and Mr Secretary General, and do your thing. We will enquire after a fair amount of time. There is now the institution of the trio presidency. That means that after us the Portuguese and then the Slovenes will take over the EU Council Presidency. At the end of our trio presidency, that is, in about a year, we will ask how you are getting on and what experiences you have had. If Mr Potočnik agreed, this could be done jointly with the Slovenian Presidency, not by way of a commissioned report, but by way of a kind of symposium, and we could discuss with one another quite openly and quite honestly.

I tell you - and I say this, I believe, on behalf of many, not to say all, member states - as President of the Council: we wish you every success. It is not only important for you that you spend your time sensibly and that you can give people opportunities for research; it is important for the standing, the strength and the vitality of the European Union. Therefore every success, good luck, much strength, strong nerves and a bit of fun!