Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the joint memorial event of the Federal Government and the Central Council of Jews in Germany on the 70th anniversary of the Night of Broken Glass ...

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

10 November 2008 · Joint memorial event of the Federal Government and the Central Council of Jews in Germany on the 70th anniversary of the Night of Broken Glass

Context
Merkel addressed a joint memorial event with the Central Council of Jews in Germany on November 10, 2008, marking the 70th anniversary of Kristallnacht.
Main themes
Kristallnacht anniversary, Shoah and Holocaust remembrance, German collective silence and indifference, Jewish persecution and disenfranchisement, Nazi escalation of violence, responsibility and moral duty, eyewitness testimony, acts of individual resistance, antisemitism in history, German historical memory
Duration
~17 min
58th percentile
Words
2,034
58th percentile
Sentences
118
71st percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
10.2
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
62nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 69%69%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

118 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Madam President, dear Ms Knobloch,

Mr President of the Bundesrat,

Mr President of the Federal Constitutional Court,

Dear colleagues from the Cabinet and the German Bundestag,

Distinguished guests of honour,

Ladies and gentlemen,

Today, on the 70th anniversary, we commemorate the pogrom night of 1938. We commemorate a dark night that stands for the darkest chapter of German history: the Shoah. In this night from 9 to 10 November we commemorate an unprecedented, systematically escalating process of exclusion and deprivation of rights.

At the beginning, on 10 May 1933, books burned. On 9 November 1938 synagogues burned – 1,400 across all of Germany within a few hours. And soon afterwards all of Europe burned. We commemorate – as the historian Dan Diner put it – the "catastrophe before the catastrophe". The pogrom night was not the first crime against the Jewish community. And it was not the last. It was a further stage of escalation on the road to the organised murder of six million Jews.

Even before 9 November, Jews in Germany were systematically deprived of their rights and discriminated against. They were barred from their professions, and they were permitted to marry only with restrictions. But 9 November made all the dams burst. In full public view, Jewish fellow citizens were murdered by members of the SA and the SS, synagogues and houses of prayer were burned down, Jewish shops and homes were destroyed.

These flames of 9 November across all of Germany – they could not be overlooked. Yet no loud storm of protest against the Nazis followed when the Jewish neighbour was driven from his home. What followed instead, among the great majority, was above all one thing: silence, shrugging of shoulders, looking away – from the individual citizen right up to large parts of the churches.

Yes, it is true, there were exceptions, such as police first lieutenant Wilhelm Krützfeldt. Together with some colleagues, he prevented the New Synagogue in Berlin from being burned down. Or the Protestant Elisabeth Schmitz. She wrote a memorandum against the persecution of the Jews. Later she resigned from her post as a teacher of history, German and religion. In doing so, she resisted the ideological charging of lessons. She too was an exception to the rule of silence.

Without doubt, there were many reasons for the silence of the others – first and foremost, of course, fear of repression. And it is truly not for me today to slip, as it were, into the role of judge; I can neither do so, nor do I wish to. But it is very much for me to point out the consequences of this silence. It is for me to point out our responsibility today. We owe that to the victims. Some of them are among us today.

We have with us today contemporary witnesses who experienced for themselves, 70 years ago today, what inhuman acts people can be capable of. I thank you most sincerely for being here with us today. You, members of a persecuted minority, had to watch as a silent majority failed to find the courage to protest openly against barbarism and injustice. For on 9 November the National Socialists saw two things. Certainly they saw: there is no enthusiasm. But they also saw: there is almost no resistance. From this they concluded: the anti-Jewish terror can continue. And it did continue, ultimately to its murderous conclusion, to systematic annihilation. Auschwitz and the Shoah were that murderous conclusion.

Martin Niemöller once said: "When the Nazis came for the communists, I remained silent; I was not a communist. When they locked up the social democrats, I remained silent; I was not a social democrat. When they came for the trade unionists, I remained silent; I was not a trade unionist. When they came for me, there was no one left who could protest."

One could add to this and say: when they came for the Jews, I remained silent, for I was not a Jew. When they came for the Sinti and Roma and so many other people, I remained silent, for I was not one of them. I was not affected.

It is precisely this false belief – not feeling affected when it strikes one's neighbour but not oneself directly. This false belief leads us ever further into disaster.

We cannot undo the injustice of the Shoah, however much we may wish to. But we can do something else: we can take responsibility. We can take responsibility by showing that it affects us all when some of us are humiliated and excluded. We can show that the freedom and human dignity of all of us are in danger when the freedom and human dignity of some of us are exposed to danger.

Protecting freedom and human dignity – that means xenophobia, racism and antisemitism must never again have a chance in Germany and Europe. In times when the peoples of Europe did not recognise this, Europe was all too often the scene of terrible violence and wars – culminating in the rupture of civilisation that was the Shoah. Only since we have recognised this have we Europeans been united, to our good fortune, in peace, freedom and human dignity. Xenophobia, racism and antisemitism must have no chance in Europe, nor beyond the borders of Europe – no more in the Arab world than in other parts of the world.

So let us sum up the lesson of our history in one sentence: we must not remain silent. We must not be indifferent to what happens. We must not remain silent when rabbis are insulted in the open street. We must not remain silent when Jewish cemeteries are desecrated. We must not remain silent when antisemitic crimes are committed. In the first nine months of this year alone there were 800 nationwide. We must not remain silent when antisemitic prejudices surface – whether clearly recognisable or, increasingly often, in disguised form, for example when Israel's action against terrorists in the Gaza Strip is labelled a "war of annihilation".

In all of this we must not remain silent, for antisemitism and racism threaten our fundamental values: the values of democracy, of diversity and of respect for human rights. Human rights have one essential feature: they are indivisible. They apply to all, to every single individual, regardless of descent, sex, language, origin and faith. They are the foundation of our free basic order. Anyone who does not recognise this, anyone who permits even the smallest exceptions, destroys this foundation as a whole.

What is at stake here, then, is nothing more and nothing less than the core of culture, civilisation and democracy. History has shown time and again: this core can be lost. It is our task to keep it alive. What does that mean? We must not be indifferent when extremists try to march through the Brandenburg Gate. We must not be indifferent when right-wing extremists sit in our parliaments.

Indifference and silence are very closely connected. If silence is perhaps still the fear of voicing one's own insight, then indifference is already the first step towards putting indispensable values at risk. We must never forget: democracy, the rule of law and respect for the dignity of every single human being are anything but self-evident. The 9 November of our country reminds us of this in a very special way.

Respect for the dignity of every individual is therefore a treasure that we must defend when it is attacked. Politics can make an important contribution to this by proving itself capable of action time and again – capable of action on a shared foundation of values, and capable of action also in its willingness to compromise when it comes to rejecting those who put our shared values at risk. The means for this are law and order, education and upbringing, promoting the political and social integration of minorities, and standing up for a democracy able to defend itself.

When this framework is in place, the whole of civil society can also make its contribution. Every individual can and should do something and set an example – against exclusion and discrimination, for acceptance and belonging. What do we need for this? We need the ability to see the world through the eyes of others as well. We need the ability to understand diversity as richness and to recognise the value of tolerance.

Tolerance, incidentally, is not arbitrary; that would be misunderstood tolerance. Tolerance is bound to values. The line is crossed where hatred is preached, prejudices are stirred up, or violence and terrorism are accepted as means. Quite concretely: when, for example, the security of the State of Israel is threatened by Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran, then there cannot and must not be any tolerance. Protecting Israel's security is part of Germany's raison d'état. This arises from our everlasting responsibility before history and for shaping the future. In the present, it arises from the shared awareness of being partners, on the basis of shared values, in the globalised world of the 21st century.

I know it is anything but self-evident that, after the rupture of civilisation of the Shoah, Jews in Germany have been able to place their trust in our country again. I know it is anything but self-evident when synagogues are consecrated in Germany, when Jewish communities rise again, when rabbis are ordained and services, weddings, Bar and Bat Mitzvahs are celebrated. All the more do I rejoice at this, all the more grateful am I for it. Jewish life must have a good place and a good home in Germany.

Fostering Jewish religion and culture is and remains a special obligation for every federal government. It is reflected in the state treaty between the Federal Republic and the Central Council of Jews in Germany. It is reflected in numerous federal government projects for civil courage, for example in the prevention-oriented programme "DIVERSITY DOES GOOD. Youth for Diversity, Tolerance and Democracy". It is reflected in an active politics of remembrance that conveys the significance of Jewish life to the younger generation in particular. It is reflected in the youth exchange between Germany and Israel, which we promote. It is reflected in the expansion of school curricula to include topics on Jewish life, Jewish history and present-day Israel, on the relationship between Israel and Germany and between Israel and Europe as partners with shared values and interests.

Europe – that was and is the longing for peoples to live together in peace and freedom. On the way there, over centuries, we had to suffer terrible catastrophes. We had to overcome tensions and learn from one another. Against this background, today's day of remembrance, the 70th anniversary of 9 November 1938, reminds us of the responsibility we bear for an open and free society. We have the responsibility to see the world through the eyes of others as well, not to remain silent when we witness racism, extremism and antisemitism, to work for a climate in Germany and Europe that strengthens and fosters civil courage, and to stand up everywhere in the world for democracy, freedom and the rule of law, for a dialogue of cultures and religions. We must live up to this responsibility – not only on 9 November, but every day, 365 days a year.

The systematic exclusion, deprivation of rights and removal of the Jews, which in the night from 9 to 10 November 1938 became visible to anyone who wanted to hear and see, and which ultimately led to the rupture of civilisation of the Shoah, imposes on us Germans an everlasting responsibility to stand up for a country that places the individual human being and his dignity at its centre, that wants and supports diversity, that strengthens civil courage and solidarity, that becomes aware again and again of the value of the treasure of democracy and the rule of law and never takes note of attacks on it in silence and indifference, and that recognises in the everlasting remembrance of the Shoah a precondition for being able to shape the future of our country. That is our responsibility today; it is our obligation, 70 years after 9 November 1938.