Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the presentation of the 2014 Annual Report of the National Regulatory Control Council on October 6, 2014, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

7 October 2014 · Presentation of the 2014 Annual Report of the National Regulatory Control Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the National Regulatory Control Council in Berlin on October 6, 2014, at the presentation of the Council's 2014 Annual Report.
Main themes
Bureaucracy reduction, regulatory control and oversight, legislative burden quantification, better regulation principles, legal certainty, European regulatory harmonization, energy saving ordinance, federal government accountability, compliance cost reduction
Duration
~14 min
50th percentile
Words
1,717
50th percentile
Sentences
89
57th percentile
Readability
46
53rd percentile
Grade
11.3
37th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 71%71%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

89 sentences in 19 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Ludewig,

dear members of the National Regulatory Control Council,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

ladies and gentlemen,

Mr. Ludewig has already mentioned it: Bureaucracy is often seen as a hindrance, as a draining and time-consuming burden. This perception, by the way, is not new. Bismarck already said: "It is bureaucracy that we all suffer from." The perception on this issue has not changed much. Those who speak with citizens, those who speak with entrepreneurs, those who speak with representatives of associations get an impression: Bureaucracy generally has a negative image.

Nevertheless – to join Mr. Ludewig's plea – it is in a way essential for a state to function. Central principles such as the principle of equal treatment require certain regulations. It is about avoiding arbitrariness and ensuring that decisions are not made solely on gut feeling. This means that there are indeed good reasons for a regulated framework.

For example, the issue of legal certainty is certainly one that investors demand. Therefore, one must consider very carefully: To what extent is legal certainty necessary on one hand, and to what extent are procedures superfluous on the other? Some procedures may have outlived their usefulness and are no longer urgently required. The question is: How much bureaucracy do we really need; what is necessary, what is superfluous; what is intended, what is unintended bureaucracy? When one, as a member of parliament – in my case – sometimes sees how a law that was actually well thought out ultimately reaches the citizen, one comes to the conclusion that it is quite good that many of us have a constituency and know what we have put forth. This means that some things also require a review in practical implementation.

Answering these questions concretely is also necessary because there is no universally valid answer. In this respect, the Regulatory Control Council is a very useful invention. When we decided to establish the Regulatory Control Council, the question arose: Can bureaucratic effort also be quantified? Today, it can be said: One can certainly quantify much more than is commonly thought.

Therefore, we can also say that since the Regulatory Control Council has begun its work, many things have changed substantially. I agree, however: This has not yet reached the broad public among citizens. This may also have to do with cumbersome terms or the fact that the monitoring of reporting obligations and information is initially something that plays a significant role in the economy, but is only a subset of perceived bureaucracy. Therefore, it is also good that the mandate has been expanded.

Since 2006, the federal government has been putting laws and regulations to the test and asking: How can we reduce burdens to what is necessary and lower costs? One may also say on such a day: We have achieved a lot. Through a firm integration of the methodology into the legislative process, the federal government commits itself to reducing bureaucracy and better legislation as an independent political goal.

Now it may be quite fortunate that the periods of work of the Regulatory Control Council do not coincide with the electoral periods. You have already encountered a new federal government that is not yet fully established, and you have persistently made your presence felt in your kind and empathetic manner, and now you yourself say that the start can now be considered successful. Perhaps you have made a more lasting impression than the ministers thought. They will not forget you now.

We also have partly competing goals. For example, when I think of the amendment to the Energy Saving Ordinance, I find that from the perspective of the Regulatory Control Council, it has been an absurdity. On the other hand, it is of the highest quality in its political objectives. Nevertheless, it is not wrong – I would even say: it is right – to take stock in such a case of positive political content, which we also want to pursue further – we have indeed decided on this Energy Saving Ordinance – in order to get a sense of what the fulfillment effort entails. When one considers the fulfillment effort, it becomes clear that one must focus on the truly important political goals. Also, where market-based incentives can be created, it is often a valuable experience that a similar result can be achieved with less effort.

A significant part of the regulations is based on European decisions. Nevertheless, it must be said: European legislative procedures do not take place in a vacuum. European parliamentarians are involved in this. But there are always also heads of government, ministers of a government, and parliaments involved, who then have to implement the whole thing. Therefore, it is important that we try to establish a common basis. That is why work is continuing in Europe. Because while the Stoiber Group was hard-won, it has not yet managed to achieve a status at the level of the European Union that the Regulatory Control Council has here at home.

I would like to remind you once again: The highest patron of the Regulatory Control Council is not the Federal Chancellor, but the Federal President. This means that if things go wrong, the Regulatory Control Council, which has a complaints mechanism, can first complain – which we of course want to avoid – while the European Commission has still not been willing to accept an independent body that can provide its qualitative assessments without being influenced by the federal government. I find myself in agreement with Mr. Ludewig and the members of the Regulatory Control Council: It would be very desirable if we could achieve greater independence for those dealing with bureaucratic costs with the new Commission. I believe the approaches are good. With Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, we have – not only Germany, but also the United Kingdom, Scandinavian countries, and the Netherlands – frequently discussed this topic. In particular, the activities we have undertaken as a group of countries, which have already led to the REFIT initiative in the European Commission, can be expanded. I believe that both the Commission President and the Vice President are quite open to this.

The work of the Regulatory Control Council can only be comprehensive – as Mr. Ludewig has indicated – if the federal states also participate, because the enforcement of laws in Germany often takes place through the states or municipalities in a federal structure. Therefore, I would like to thank the Regulatory Control Council for engaging in discussions with the heads of state chanceries. I would also like to thank State Minister Braun for accompanying this and coordinating the work of the Regulatory Control Council within the federal government, which, like your work, is not always just a pleasure but sometimes also means drilling through hard boards. We will continue to talk with the states – I thank you for doing that – so that we can achieve more transparency. Because we could never reflect the experience of the citizen if we only acted at the federal level and did not inquire about what is happening locally in the municipalities and how it affects the people.

With that, I am already at the very welcome expansion of the work of the Regulatory Control Council. In this context, it is no longer just about reporting obligations, reporting, and the costs of laws, but in the future, it will also be about everyday life situations. These life situations are selected in a very practical manner. This way, every citizen can relate to them. What happens if I become unemployed? What happens if I have a new apartment? What happens if I want to register a vehicle? – These are practical questions from everyday life in which everyone can find themselves.

If one can achieve a quantification of such questions, one will also be able to discuss further reduction targets in connection with very concrete life situations. It is certainly also sensible that we actively address the citizens and ask them about certain life situations: What does this mean for you, and what ideas and feedback can you give us, the federal government, or the Regulatory Control Council? One may not need to bring up all 20 life situation-related projects at once, but starting with one or two projects and reaching out to the citizens seems reasonable to me. We have agreed earlier that we will deal with this more intensively.

We will also take another look at the "one in - one out" proposal. We are currently in the complicated situation that there has been some European experience in reducing information and reporting obligations, and it was known: If you agree on a reduction target of 25 percent, that is feasible. However, regarding the fulfillment effort of a law, we have not yet developed a real sense of what "one in - one out" means. But I signal openness to revisit the topic. Once you have worked through and quantified the life situation-related matters, I believe we will be able to come up with conceivable reduction targets for some of these life situations. Thus, I believe that the end of the work is not yet reached, because not everything is good yet, but that the real work only begins when citizens are to feel an effect. The same applies, of course, to companies.

Your work is very specific. It requires perseverance. It means drilling through a thick board. It demands what we actually want in politics, namely sustainability. I want to tell you: You work sustainably, with commitment, and with a keen eye for the infinite details. Therefore, I would like to extend a heartfelt thank you to all members of the Regulatory Control Council and also to those who work for and support the Regulatory Control Council – including State Minister Braun. Your work is very important. It is very meaningful. It is gladly used as an argument in the parliamentary sphere to improve laws once again. In this respect, your reputation in Parliament is at least as high as in the federal government. Thank you for that – also for always thinking ahead and pushing things forward. Thank you, of course, for this interim report, which we take seriously not only in terms of follow-up costs but as a whole report.