Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Newspaper Congress of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers e.V. on September 29, 2014, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

1 October 2014 · Newspaper Congress of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers e.V. (60th anniversary) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 60th anniversary congress of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers in Berlin on September 29, 2014.
Main themes
Digitalization of print media, quality journalism, newspaper industry challenges, media democracy, press freedom, structural transformation, online competition, advertising revenue decline, minimum wage for newspaper deliverers, publisher economic viability, media trust, press merger law
Duration
~23 min
71st percentile
Words
2,718
71st percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 32%31%
  • Social 29%28%
  • Economic 28%27%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

159 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Heinen,

ladies and gentlemen,

especially dear colleagues from the parliaments,

I am pleased to be here with you right now, on the occasion of your 60th anniversary, to simply say congratulations. I just heard that you have a record participation. That is a good thing for an anniversary.

You are looking back on 60 years that have always been full of challenges. But you are also looking to the future. Let me recap: You emerged from the Gesamtverband der Deutschen Zeitungsverleger and the Verein Deutscher Zeitungsverleger. From this, a powerful federal association has developed, which is probably the most important representative of newspaper publishers and a competent partner for us in politics. When interests are bundled, it is always very helpful for politics.

The work of the association, like that of other publishers' and journalists' associations – I know this from many conversations we have had – cannot be reduced solely to economic aspects. Because the media industry is not just any trade; it fulfills a very important and indispensable role in our democracy and for our democracy. This is clear to everyone.

Recently, it was reported that the German newspaper publishers themselves are to blame for the decline in circulation. Some media researchers say that the publishers have failed to respond to societal changes. They have not sufficiently engaged with new target groups such as migrants, urban singles, or poorer people. The concept of the "newspaper for all" no longer works. Furthermore, publishers must abandon overly high profit expectations.

You suspect correctly that I do not subscribe to these arguments. I believe that such one-sided blame is really inappropriate. The challenges are of a different nature. You, as publishers, have been facing significant economic and, above all, enormous structural challenges for years. Many can only dream of double-digit returns, as may have existed at some point in the past.

Digitalization is certainly the great challenge for print providers. It offers opportunities, but it also carries a multitude of risks. Traditional media have faced competition. Value creation has increasingly shifted from print advertising, which was once a main source of financing for daily newspapers, to the internet. Relevant discussions are being held – and they must be held – to enable fair access for advertising.

However, I see, above all, that publishers have been facing the new challenges for years. This is evidenced not least by the expansion of offerings from many – I would say, the overwhelming majority – of publishing houses. I am convinced that traditional media also have significant importance when digitalized on the internet. Smartphones and tablet computers open up opportunities to offer newspapers and magazines digitally. In this context, paid media content is, of course, in competition with free offerings of various kinds. But I believe that appealing offerings and high-quality journalism, if they remain the order of the day, will also find their buyers in the future. This is a new path. Many of you are taking it. It is the right path.

In my conviction, publishers should not succumb to the economic temptation to jeopardize journalistic substance through massive cuts in the editorial area. Because print media still enjoy a high level of trust across all age groups, which is also crucial for success in the online sector. The trust you have can be very helpful to you in expanding into the online area.

This trust does not come from nowhere; you have earned it through quality journalism. Therefore, without investments in demanding journalism, the core competence of publishers is lost and is then very difficult to rebuild. That is why my plea would be to strengthen and further develop this core competence. Most of you are already doing that.

You rightly expect us to ensure the necessary framework conditions for this and that we do not close ourselves off to the legitimate concerns of publishers. Now, I would say that we have not done so in the area of minimum wage either. Mr. Heinen has just pointed out in his few sentences that, from his perspective, things are still not properly regulated. But I think I can say that you have one of the few exceptions. The wages for newspaper deliverers will gradually rise to the legal minimum wage of 8.50 euros by 2017. We have therefore taken the special concerns of the press companies into account. Unfortunately, no amicable solution has been reached. Therefore, we may have somewhat different opinions on this, as I gather from your words.

Already in the last legislative period, the then federal government made significant adjustments to the framework conditions for publishers. For example, we have moderately eased the possibilities for mergers in press merger law to enable newspapers to have a better economic basis through mergers.

In the coalition agreement for this legislative period, we have committed to ensuring that the possibilities for business cooperation among publishers are sufficient. We will implement this project.

We also want to maintain the reduced VAT rate for newspapers, magazines, and books and work at the European level to ensure that the reduced VAT rate can also apply to e-books, e-papers, and other electronic information media in the future. We will do this with determination.

One issue that has occupied not only you as newspaper makers but also politics for years is ensuring neutral and non-discriminatory press distribution. This is somewhat awkwardly phrased, but you know what I mean. We agree with the publishers' associations and the Bundesverband Presse-Grosso that the Grosso system has proven itself over decades. It contributes to the preservation of the unique journalistic diversity in the German press landscape.

Therefore, in the previous legislative period, we introduced a competition law exemption for industry agreements in press distribution. It is not surprising that this competition law exemption is currently subject to judicial review. We will have to wait and see whether this regulation is sufficient to secure the press Grosso or whether it needs to be supported by press law protection. In any case: a clear commitment to the press Grosso.

The press law protection lies, as you know, in the competence of the states, as it primarily concerns the preservation of press diversity. This means that as Federal Chancellor, I can document my good will, we can also make proposals, but the conversation with the states must be conducted in a partnership manner, as we are used to.

As provided in the coalition agreement, it is time to adapt copyright law to the challenges of the digital age. We have already spent a lot of time on this. Now is the time to act. It is important to find balanced solutions that meet the concerns of all stakeholders, users as well as authors and exploiters.

The protection of intellectual property is a core issue for the development of the creative economy, whose economic significance for Europe is impressively documented by numerous studies. It must also be possible in the digital age to generate income from creative work. Copyright-relevant services must be valued and effectively protected. Therefore, compliance with copyright law must not be misunderstood as a voluntary service in the future.

We have already done quite a bit in the last legislative period. The law on the use of orphaned and out-of-print works, which came into force this year, can be described as a milestone in facilitating access to our cultural heritage. It provides libraries, museums, archives, and also institutions of audiovisual heritage with legal certainty in the digitization and publication of cultural assets.

Since August of last year, the ancillary copyright for press publishers has been in force. The development of this law was anything but trivial. It provides publishers with an independent legal foundation to enforce their rights on the internet and thus improves the framework conditions for the press, in our view. I think there have been some quite controversial debates in your circles – I see Mr. Heinen – but it is something we consider to be right. I regard the realization of this project as an important step because it is a key element of a fair legal framework in the digital world.

I do not hide the fact that all of us, when we set the legal framework in this digital world, will certainly also learn again and again. It is, as far as securities are concerned, uncharted territory that we also have to work our way through, as I have said before. But it is certainly not a space in which there can be no legal regulations at all. Because otherwise, we would partially destroy the foundations on which we live. That must not and cannot be. We will therefore closely monitor the development. Therefore, the further development of copyright law is a major concern of this federal government.

An important task currently is the national implementation of the so-called EU Copyright Directive by April 2016. This directive establishes a legal framework for the activities of collecting societies in Europe. This is a great opportunity. But the implementation will certainly also involve a good deal of work.

Why is it so important that we get such a European legal framework? I think it can be said that the easier it is to clarify rights across borders and grant licenses, the greater the advantage for both authors and users. Stable and efficient collecting societies, which remain committed to their cultural and social mission, are also in the interest of newspaper publishers in exercising their ancillary copyright.

In addition, copyright contract law is one of the topics that the governing parties have explicitly set out in the coalition agreement. The last revision of copyright law dates back to 2002. Since then, not only has the world changed, but we have also experienced long and arduous negotiations between authors and exploiters. Recently, however, there have also been industry agreements. After ten years, it is certainly time for us to examine whether copyright contract law functions as it was intended back then, and if not, to consider what we need to change so that it can achieve the intended effect.

In all these legislative initiatives, I also say: It is very important for us that we receive the appropriate advice from you and, of course, also a certain level of support. Because you know, digital expressions of opinion are generally short but intense. This means that one may also need short but intense support from other, sometimes very legitimate sides. But you are a powerful association; why shouldn't that succeed?

As publishers, you compete with numerous other media actors for a scarce resource: the attention of citizens. Search engines and other platforms can play a key role in the digital world. It is therefore really important to us to ensure non-discriminatory access to content on dominant platforms. I want to state this explicitly. The question of how this will happen in detail is highly controversial. But this is a firm common position of the federal government.

The Digital Agenda 2014 to 2017, which the federal government has adopted, will contribute to this. For the first time, we have established a cross-departmental program for the digital policy of this legislative period, in which the Minister of Economics, the Minister of the Interior, and the Minister of Transport and Infrastructure are primarily involved. Now, the whole thing must be brought to life through the corresponding individual measures.

This will be a difficult task. I only mention keywords like net neutrality and anonymity. Beyond the question of broadband expansion, a multitude of measures will need to be regulated. We are determined to make the corresponding decisions or to push for the European Commission to make them in Brussels. In this respect, I see it as a very good coincidence that the German Commissioner Günther Oettinger will in the future bear a high degree of responsibility for these digital issues.

What does all this mean for the future of print media? The Austrian political scientist and television presenter Armin Wolf said in 2013 that he bets that in thirty years no daily newspaper will be printed on paper anymore. He justified this by stating that in thirty years there will be no reason for people to read news that is twelve hours old. As we know, he is not alone in this view. However, I personally do not find the assumption that print media have no future chance due to their disadvantage in timeliness compared to electronic media particularly convincing. This overlooks the fact that timeliness has long ceased to be the domain of printed newspapers. This has been the case at least since we have had radio and television. They have existed for many decades, and yet people still enjoy picking up a newspaper. I certainly do, and many others do as well.

I am convinced that the strengths of newspapers and magazines do not necessarily lie in the timeliness of news, but in the analyses, background reports, commentaries, evaluations – in all that helps people understand and contextualize current events within a societal or political context.

This contextualization will become even more important in the future in light of the endless flood of available information. I also believe that there will always be people who do not have the entire day to look at the latest events and simultaneously deal with their contextualization. Rather, there are certainly cases where one is occupied with other matters throughout the day and then must engage with the contextualization of many other things at a certain time.

If newspapers and magazines are aware of this strength and nurture it, then they will continue to find their readers despite the internet – certainly not exclusively in printed form, I want to make that clear. Because the number of people reading a newspaper on a laptop or tablet will increase. However, if they find the quality of traditional printed newspapers there, then there will also be a willingness to pay for it and thus maintain an essential characteristic of the newspaper.

I am 60 years old. I have known newspapers since childhood, and I have loved them even more since German reunification, when they became freer. This generation does not need to be convinced of the value of newspapers anymore. Rather, it will be crucial to convince the younger generations of the advantages of this medium. Demographic influences on media usage behavior are likely to increase. Therefore, it is a societal concern that the survival of newspapers and magazines remains not just an economic factor. We in politics are also convinced that it is good for there to be newspapers and magazines.

That is why we launched the National Initiative for Print Media back in 2008, to engage young people in the critical reading of newspapers and magazines in the future. To align this initiative more closely with the digital age, the participating associations and institutions, together with the Minister of State for Culture Monika Grütters, have agreed to open this initiative more to quality journalism online. When we consider that most print newspapers and magazines have digital editions and online offerings, we understand that this is only consistent.

I know that the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers has long been involved in the National Initiative for Print Media and has also made significant contributions to its realignment. For that, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks. Of course, this thanks comes with a request: I ask you to continue to support this initiative actively. I believe that in this case, associations and politics must work together to maintain a fundamental prerequisite for quality journalism – namely demand. Without demand, there will be no quality journalism.

In this sense, I wish you not only a successful Newspaper Congress 2014 – I have looked at the program, and it is all very interesting and exciting and presents Berlin in a good light – but I also wish you much strength and success for the coming decades. I do not know what it will be like in thirty years. But I am convinced that such an association event will still exist. How exactly the newspaper will look then, we will see. The future is exciting, but certainly full of opportunities, also for your industry. Thank you very much and all the best for the time ahead.