Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the presentation of the annual report of the National Regulatory Control Council on September 16, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 September 2021 · Presentation of the annual report of the National Regulatory Control Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the National Regulatory Control Council in Berlin on September 16, 2021, at the presentation of the council's annual report marking its 15th anniversary.
Main themes
Bureaucracy reduction, regulatory control, "one in one out" principle, administrative burden on economy, EU acquis communautaire, digitalization and agile legislation, COVID-19 pandemic regulations, information obligations, state competitiveness, legislative quality, administrative resilience
Duration
~10 min
36th percentile
Words
1,241
36th percentile
Sentences
79
52nd percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 67%67%
  • Ceremonial 19%19%
  • Economic 10%10%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

79 sentences in 20 paragraphs

Mr. Ludewig,

dear members of the National Regulatory Control Council,

Mr. State Minister, dear Hendrik,

ladies and gentlemen,

the challenges change with the times, but it seems that bureaucracy is a timeless phenomenon. This may also be due to the nature of the matter, because a state that knows no rules would not be a good state. This means that for coexistence and cooperation, we need a certain amount of rules – on one hand. But when, on the other hand, the regulations continue to pile up, when the, as one would say in Europe, acquis communautaire never decreases but only keeps adding more, then a thicket arises that is no longer comprehensible, and then the acceptance of the state suffers.

Therefore, it is important to carefully weigh the costs and benefits of regulations. And this weighing process has been carried out by you in the Regulatory Control Council for 15 years now according to certain guidelines. It is also in the nature of the matter that you have been a critical companion in this process. We have guaranteed independence through the construction and the role of the Federal President in the area of the Regulatory Control Council.

The adoption of the NKR Act in mid-2006 and the subsequent establishment were marked by quite a bit of skepticism: Are old regulations now only being replaced by new ones? What will this turn out to be? Nevertheless, it was good at first. I still remember the time when we first had to sift through all the information obligations. At that time, I thought it could not possibly work, but somehow everyone participated. Then we were able to make the whole thing transparent and measurable.

Of course, the information obligations, as a specific burden for the economy, are not the only ones, but they are quite interesting. Today, we can say: The information and reporting obligations have been reduced by 25 percent. This has eliminated billions in costs for the economy. Cost developments could be made transparent. In the initial phase, it was primarily about decluttering.

But it was also about avoiding the emergence of unnecessary new burdens. Therefore, you also took a critical look at legislation. This was partly also extensively utilized by Parliament. Since our legislative periods always unfold differently than we intend, you had many times when you had to quickly assess hasty legislation. Sometimes you grumbled, but often you also recognized the urgency. I think that we have been faced with extraordinary challenges, especially now in connection with Corona, but also during the times when particularly many refugees came to us, or in other situations. This has led the Regulatory Control Council to think, in addition to what I just described, about how administrations can be made more resilient to external shocks. This will certainly continue to occupy us in the future.

So it has always been about the bureaucratic consequences of new regulations and the resulting expenditures to fulfill them. Therefore, it is about reducing bureaucracy and preventing bureaucracy – that is, to reduce bureaucracy, but also to prevent new bureaucracy from arising. This has certainly changed the thinking of lawmakers. We must approach legislation step by step differently due to the agile working methods in times of digitalization. Focusing on what the person for whom the law applies must fulfill has certainly helped us.

Now, reducing bureaucracy is not an end in itself. Because there must be some regulations. This means that ultimately it is about comprehensibility for the economy as well as for the citizens. Therefore, you have repeatedly dealt with the question of what actually reaches people and how this can be understood.

In 2015, nearly a decade after it all began, you imposed the "One in, one out" principle on us, which I initially thought would not be easy to implement. However, it turned out to be better than I had thought with my initial skepticism. It can really be called a bureaucracy brake. I read now that we have exceeded it and that there is something about "one in, three out." Is that really correct?

But – it also has weaknesses – it has not yet been applied to the burdens from EU law. Therefore, we must continue to discuss these matters in the European Commission in a joint persuasion process, which has already progressed significantly. There is indeed a new way of thinking. Because when I entered politics, eventually became Minister for the Environment, and first dealt with European regulations in the environmental sector, the so-called sacred principle of the acquis communautaire prevailed, that nothing could be taken away. This has dominated thinking in the European Union for a long time. But we must also see that we need to remain competitive. Therefore, "one in, one out" is also very important in Europe.

The Corona pandemic has particularly challenged us and necessitated a multitude of laws. I think, for example, of the Federal Emergency Brake. A lot of effort, even though everything was over again after just a few months. From the perspective of the Regulatory Control Council, this is a good example. However, the regulations of the states now apply again; and you have not yet sifted through them. – Or will they also be sifted through? Good. – In any case, I thank you for your willingness to work quickly and together. I would also like to say that we were able to work well because we have already internalized your involvement. We almost think of you as part of the process. You may not notice it as much, but it is so.

The OECD is also quite satisfied and has accompanied the entire process. This means that we can be proud that we have set a good example. We have not only influenced the European Union, but much has also reached the OECD level.

Since I will no longer be part of the next federal government, I can only sincerely thank you. So that you do not fall into a void now, we have come together in coalition once again and given you an extension until a new federal government is formed, which will then have to deal with these matters.

I want to thank you for your commitment, especially you, dear Mr. Ludewig – 15 years of chairmanship speak for themselves – and also the members and the staff who have contributed. It has been good for our state as a whole. The legal basis does not expire. It cannot simply be abolished, but one can only consider what else can be added.

It has always been a pleasure – sometimes also a challenge – to work with you. I have not read every statement on every law; it was probably better that way. When things got really thick, someone in the CDU/CSU parliamentary group would present what you had written. Whether the laws, however, always became much better in the parliamentary process remained to be seen. The parliamentarians were not so keen on having everything critically examined again, as we have done.

In this respect, I would say: We have respected your independence, we have given you a courageous legal basis – and what was the third? Willingness to engage in dialogue – that is, of course, self-evident.

So: Thank you for the work. I hope that, alongside the work, it has also brought you a bit of joy to participate in this part of the state.