Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Workers' Congress of the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group on May 15, 2017, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 May 2017 · Workers' Congress of the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group's Workers' Congress in Berlin on May 15, 2017, speaking on the transformation of work in the digital age.
Main themes
Future of work, digitalization and Industry 4.0, artificial intelligence and automation, social market economy, electric mobility and automotive industry, employer-employee partnership, works councils and collective bargaining, technological change and uncertainty, Internet of Things, precautionary principle in policy-making
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,699
83rd percentile
Sentences
179
86th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
3.08
58th percentile
Vocabulary
1.94
5th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 48%47%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Economic 17%17%
  • Technological 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

179 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Dear Ms. Hannack, I greet you just as I do all participants,

I am very pleased that you have organized this congress on the important topic of how we respond to the changes in our world. The whole world is talking about change. Everyone knows that the world of work will undergo profound transformation. We must try to shape this change. In doing so, it is very important for us to keep an eye on the employment situation.

At the moment, we have a very good economic situation, yet there is great unrest because people naturally feel that something is happening and that many things in their companies are in a state of change, which raises the question for everyone: What does this mean for me as an employee, as a worker?

The value chains are changing. Production processes are becoming interconnected. They can, so to speak, communicate with each other. One thinks, for example, of the so-called Internet of Things. It took me a while to understand this. But once it was explained to me that these things can communicate with each other, I got it.

The question arises, of course: What role does the human being play in this process, and what are the overall consequences? When one reads and hears the dramatic analyses about which professions will soon no longer exist and how many people could lose their jobs, I think one often finds that these are more like Cassandra calls than something that has to do with reality. I have tried very intensively to understand what Industry 4.0 and digitalization mean. Last year, I visited several companies. Everywhere it was actually clear: Yes, the types of employment are changing, but the number of employees needed is not changing dramatically.

Nevertheless, the industrial structure of the Federal Republic of Germany is focused on certain key areas: mechanical engineering, the automotive industry, and others. In the automotive industry, three revolutionary developments are essentially taking place in parallel – regarding drive technologies, autonomous driving, and the question of whether, in light of interconnected mobility concepts, I still need my own car or whether car sharing is sufficient? This is associated with tremendous changes. It is completely clear that people, especially in the supply sector and in the automotive industry, when they work on drive systems, for example, are asking themselves: What does the breakthrough of electric mobility mean for me one day?

We must try to set the political framework correctly to make this change possible, but at the same time not to do what you just mentioned – namely, to act as if we know the future exactly and perhaps always do the wrong thing with rigidly prescribed concepts. I think that if we reflect on the principles of the social market economy, there are many wise ways for the state to intervene helpfully without dominating in a way that destroys or complicates the strengths of the social market economy, including the cooperation between employees and employers.

It is very important that we continue to have a partnership between employers and employees. That is why I firmly believe that wherever we have a works council, and wherever we have structures for cooperation between employers and employees, we can do without some regulations because we can entrust that to responsible hands. On the other hand, we must also see that in many areas, especially in the service sector, the level of collective bargaining or works council representation is no longer as high as it once was. We cannot leave everything to the general development. Therefore, it is important to take concerns seriously and seek dialogue with one another.

I believe the greatest uncertainty lies in predicting the pace at which changes will actually occur. We set ourselves the goal of having one million electric cars by the year 2020. As it currently looks, we will not achieve this goal. However, we also know from the spread of smartphones and other products that certain technological developments suddenly occur exponentially after a certain point. If one is not prepared in any way for what is happening, then it is too late. So: How can we properly apply the precautionary principle?

Now, it is of utmost importance that we also make it politically very clear what the position of the human being is in the production process. Internet of Things and Industry 4.0 notwithstanding – it remains true that neither work will run out nor will humans lose their central position in the work process, but that work is done for people. This will remain the case in the future. We need not worry about that.

Nevertheless, the phenomenon of artificial intelligence is, of course, something interesting. Not only was Garry Kasparov defeated by a computer in chess 20 years ago. We also see today with robots or "cobots," that is, robots working alongside humans, that the precision, endurance, and many other aspects of machines can be remarkable. In this respect, their use is, on the one hand, a relief, but on the other hand, it also presents us with challenges because people with less education certainly have good reason to worry that simple tasks will increasingly be replaced.

This brings us to the most politically exciting topic. By the end of the next decade, that is, by 2030, we will have about six million fewer people of working age than we do today. The question is: How can we develop the skilled labor potential so that it aligns with the qualifications that are required and needed? A very large task lies ahead of us. I would like to mention a few points.

The first point is the relationship between dual education and university education. We have now gone through a phase in which we have increased the proportion of those with a university degree to around 40 percent. This has been repeatedly demanded of us internationally. It may also be okay; we have thus created a good cushion for the next decade. However, I have the feeling and impression that we must do everything we can to strengthen the second pillar, namely vocational training, and also to enable permeability in all areas of education.

The big question is: How can we actually convey to students today in which fields they should pursue their vocational training without violating the principle of free choice of profession? The promotion of mathematical, engineering, natural science, and technical professions must continue. We must repeatedly say that we need to do more here. I recently had the Girls' Day at the Federal Chancellery. The proportion of female students who started a degree in engineering last semester was 24 percent; that is still far too little. When I hear how many programmers and software professionals we could potentially need – especially in medium-sized companies – I conclude that we should always encourage young people to take an interest in these areas.

This, in turn, means that we must start in schools – with the equipment of schools, with the training of teachers. Because how am I supposed to develop an interest in certain professions if I am not also confronted with that in my own schooling? I believe that a focus of the Federal Minister of Education and Research will also be to help more in the next legislative period, for example, by providing schools with teaching clouds for the further training of teachers. I do not believe that we as a federal government should take on the task of providing computer equipment in individual schools directly, as that would involve far too much service work, but I consider it very important to provide start-up opportunities, connect schools to broadband, provide teaching content, and further train teachers.

We also have an exciting situation in cultural terms. This reminds me a bit of the time after German reunification. At that time, many younger trainers and retrainers from the old federal states came to the 40- or 45-year-old employees in the former GDR companies; suddenly, one had to learn something from younger people. Culturally, this was not practiced, as we had a very hierarchical development structure. Today, company managements also have to learn a lot. One must fundamentally trust the youth and not perceive it as a loss of authority, but simply as an opportunity for lifelong learning, to which we all must open ourselves. By the way, we in politics must do this too; otherwise, we will not know what is actually happening and will not be able to make the right laws.

The starting point is therefore the school, and then also the vocational school when it comes to orienting oneself towards promising career paths. I believe that today we can still adapt training in many professions so that it is aligned with Industry 4.0. The profession of mechatronics technician, for example, is also gradually changing. First, we had CNC machines, that is, computer-controlled machine tools; today we have networking through the Internet – but there will still be mechatronics technicians. However, if we postpone the adaptation of vocational training, we will naturally be dealing with increasingly revolutionary or disruptive processes. Therefore, it is right to implement this step by step today.

It may be that we need to be faster in developing new occupational profiles in some areas; we are not one hundred percent convincing in that regard. I believe that we should perhaps do a bit more regarding modular training options. This is also very important in the context of refugee integration, as sometimes the entire vocational training can be daunting because it is indeed very demanding. But if one can work their way up step by step, then that is good. My impression is that trade unions and perhaps also employers are sometimes a bit hesitant in this regard because they fear that it might somehow lower the quality. However, I believe that if it is motivating, then one should not resist such things.

I myself am still not entirely sure – even though we have already changed the Meister-BAföG and improved its status – whether it is right that one can obtain a "Master" without any fees while the "Meister" still has to be financed by oneself. In a country that places such great value on the equivalence of vocational education and academic education, we should perhaps reconsider what we can do in this regard.

Once I have my vocational training, the next topic is further training in the workplace. I believe we need to find mechanisms that allow us to focus on further training in employment and not wait until someone has lost their job to start retraining. This has also been part of the political debate. The big question is: How can we do this properly? I believe there is little doubt that this can be well discussed with large companies, that it is well planned and runs smoothly. There are outstanding collective agreements that are pioneering in terms of further training. The question will therefore be: Can the state perhaps promote or support something like this, beyond what is currently available?

Furthermore, the question arises: To what extent should the Federal Employment Agency (BA) get involved in the sense that smaller companies may not be able to do this, or because certain occupations may no longer be needed and therefore a reorientation is truly necessary? If I understood the new chairman of the BA correctly the other day, we are on the way to finding intelligent ways for employees to inquire in the future whether their profession has a chance and what else is recommended. The Federal Employment Agency is thus an information hub in a comprehensive sense. However, I advise against concentrating the entire further training landscape solely on the Federal Employment Agency without operational support. I believe we need a collaboration. This must be examined on a case-by-case basis.

We are now at an exciting point that changes our political approach. We are used to passing laws for large groups, and indeed for 20 years; it should not be touched for that long. Digitalization brings with it that people suddenly receive individual offers. Everyone can put together their own muesli, everyone can buy custom sneakers. I recently heard an interesting story that sneaker production is returning from emerging countries to Germany because the degree of desired customization in sneakers is so high that it can only be met with digital technology. People will get used to individual offers and say: Why do you want to address us in large groups of millions? I am used to getting exactly what I need and what I specifically require.

How can we create laws that are flexible enough to meet the individual wishes of people without ending up in a situation where there is no longer any force that can truly represent the interests of employees? In the field of education, we can actually start to experiment with this now – by having institutions, by providing state subsidies, but without directing and saying "You must do it this way or that way," but by offering various options from which one can choose. I believe that labor market policymakers – I am not a specialist – are not yet at the end of the discussion, but still need feedback from companies about what is desired, what is needed, and what is truly helpful.

I believe that during this legislative period, sensitivity to what is happening has massively increased, even down to small and medium-sized enterprises. I am very grateful to IG Metall, which has very profoundly and very early begun to deal with the world of work 4.0. However, I am still not entirely sure whether we have all fully grasped the complexity of the world of work. We are still very much stuck in old thinking. I am curious to see what will happen to the Working Time Directive in the future. Today I hear that the 12 or 13 hours of rest time and so on are not a problem. However, we must be careful that in the end we do not have a situation where everyone knows with a wink that things are being circumvented because otherwise it simply cannot be done and is not even desired, but we are not able to change the corresponding law. This would lead to the entire system being under too much pressure in the end.

But this is certainly a topic that we cannot conclusively regulate here today. I also do not want to be quoted as wanting to undermine the working time regulation and have the corresponding headline tomorrow; that is not my point. Therefore, I ask the representatives of both the employers' and employees' sides to help us. Practice should not degenerate into exploitation and permanent availability, but must also meet the wishes of employees. We must not allow individual employees to drift into semi-legality, so to speak. Perhaps there must also be different conditions in small start-ups and larger companies. In any case, we need demand-oriented and needs-based solutions.

We have already taken some initial steps regarding qualification. The federal government promotes vocational qualification in close cooperation with the economy. There is the education premium. We support those who cannot easily afford further training with their income. As I said, we have also done some things with the Meister-BAföG, although I believe that we have not yet reached the end of the line in this regard.

The decision of the employee group on further education in the digital age goes, I believe, in the right direction. It is a valuable contribution and clearly tells us once again: Vocational education and further training should primarily take place in the workplace. It would be, to be honest, downright absurd if we are so proud of our dual education system, which includes the components of theory and practice, and then say: But in the context of further training, we do everything outside the workplace again. Wherever possible, we should conduct this in the workplace. But just as there is the topic of "extracurricular training" in vocational education, there can naturally also be modules and components that cannot be provided in the workplace. There can also be situations where a traditionally producing company does not have too much expertise in the skills and abilities of the further training service. In this case, one can and must also bring in other specialists.

The question of further education for academics also arises, and to what extent universities and colleges can further promote lifelong learning with their competencies. We must, of course, ensure that we do not anchor entirely new opportunities for further education and lifelong learning in areas that are already overcrowded today. But otherwise, there is certainly still more that can be done than is currently the case.

E-learning is also a topic. Digitalization is, of course, changing the way we learn. If I can believe young people, it is much more natural for them than it is for us old hands who think everything must be asked in person. This is very exciting today and sometimes even playful. This must also be taken into account.

A certain unease that I feel regarding the whole topic is actually based on the time component. I believe we are in the process of capturing everything correctly. But are we getting everything organized quickly enough, and can we also manage it in the depths of small and smallest companies? As far as large companies are concerned, I have the least worries. Therefore, I believe it is also a great task for large companies to talk to their suppliers – not just to exert pressure to be cost-effective, but to find out how educational measures regarding the networking of the Internet of Things can be utilized equally by all, so that there are not only skilled workers at the top level, but also truly digitally educated people deep within production.

Last point: What can the state do – in addition to support, funding, incentives, and a well-organized Federal Employment Agency, which is of course self-managed but, let’s say, is a bit guided and directed – what else can be done? I believe we need to focus much more on the issue of long-term unemployed individuals in the next legislative period. There is very good placement in work in the area of unemployment benefits I. However, regarding the issue of long-term unemployment, the circumstances due to mixed responsibilities are quite different nationwide, I believe; I say this with all caution and respect for the municipalities. In the case of option municipalities, it is a bit different again. I am not saying that anything is bad, but we need to bring more transparency into it.

I also ask you once again to provide us with insights regarding the group of single parents. There is today a legal entitlement to a daycare place. There is today a legal entitlement to a kindergarten place. However, for three years, until the child is three years old – which is even split a bit – there is virtually no availability for the labor market. I do not want to organize this as availability now. But young mothers are left for three years – or, if they have a second child, perhaps six years – without any counseling conversation. During this time, the world of work changes. Therefore, I would consider it very reasonable if we offered a counseling conversation once a year and perhaps said: Look, we have a part-time training opportunity, we have a part-time job, we could do this and that, we now also have options for childcare. If someone has been completely out of the whole mechanism for six years with two children, it will not be easy to reintegrate into the modern world of work. I do not want to force anyone, but I believe that simply leaving this group to themselves and having no legal offer could still be changed.

The second point is: As a state, we can of course promote the path of digitalization by making better digital offers ourselves – starting with the health card to all contacts that citizens have with their state. I would say that if you try to get appointments at the citizens' office here in Berlin, you only have short-term experience with the internet because the appointments are usually booked immediately. But it would be even nicer if you could complete the entire business process online. Therefore, in the context of the discussion about federal-state financial relations, we have also agreed that the federal government and the states will work on a citizen portal. Many other countries around us are already further along than we are.

I believe that the more naturally we bring digitalization into public life, the more naturally people will perceive the changes in working life. It is already the case today that employers can sometimes connect very well to the smartphone experiences that employees have in their leisure time, and thus they start with a certain basic knowledge. However, this should not mean that individuals must acquire all the necessary knowledge privately and then bring the latest smartphone to vocational school because the vocational school does not have it; that would also not be right. Therefore, the issue of equipping educational institutions and qualifying trainers and trainees is, in my view, a major focus for the upcoming legislative period.

Overall, this is a very exciting topic because it also significantly influences our prosperity of tomorrow. We as politicians can set an example by continuously learning to know what is actually going on. In fact, we should always hold a class in the faction or in parliament where we learn relevant facts. Otherwise, one day we will no longer really understand what is happening in companies. As politicians, we must at least be able to ask the right questions. However, if we do not know the technical terms and do not know what it is about, we cannot formulate reasonable questions, and then it becomes somehow difficult.

Further education is therefore a topic that will continue to occupy us. Thank you for the initiative of the employee group.