Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel before the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe on April 15, 2008, in Strasbourg:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

15 April 2008 · Address to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe · Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, Strasbourg, France

Context
Merkel addressed the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe in Strasbourg on April 15, 2008, marking her first speech before that body as German Chancellor.
Main themes
European unity and integration, Council of Europe, democracy and rule of law, human rights and human dignity, shared European values, globalization and interdependence, German-European relations, history of European cooperation, parliamentary democracy, enlargement of the Council of Europe
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,109
77th percentile
Sentences
175
86th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.83
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 36%35%
  • Geopolitical 32%31%
  • Social 22%22%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

175 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President,

dear members of parliament, dear colleagues!

Thank you very much for the invitation to Strasbourg. It is no coincidence – I feel it again now – that Strasbourg is referred to as the capital of Europe. After all, there are two parliaments here that decisively shape and influence Europe, and they have done so in recent years as well.

I am pleased to speak here today for the first time before the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe in Strasbourg. The Parliamentary Assembly is a special place. It was the first of its kind in the history of Europe. Today, representatives from 47 national parliaments are represented in the Parliamentary Assembly. This shows our diversity. It is therefore a particular pleasure for me to be here with you today.

The Assembly becomes a place of political exchange across borders in Europe simply by the fact that parliamentarians from 47 countries consult with each other here, indeed, an indispensable political exchange precisely because the individual nations are increasingly growing closer together in times of increasing globalization. We feel that. But we also feel, of course, in many discussions where differences and various perspectives can be located.

Political decisions made by individual countries increasingly have an impact on what happens in other countries. We are increasingly facing the same challenges. We have the same problems to solve. That is why we are experiencing that foreign policy is increasingly becoming domestic policy, or that domestic policy is increasingly becoming foreign policy. This means that the classic dividing line, as we once had it, can no longer be drawn at all.

From this develops a consciousness of shared responsibility for a thriving coexistence in Europe. This consciousness is developing in a very special way in the Parliamentary Assembly. In doing so, you have made an invaluable contribution to the coming together, to the unification, and to a common understanding in Europe over the past years and throughout your existence.

The Council of Europe has existed for almost 60 years. It has stood for democracy and the rule of law, for freedom and peace, for diversity and tolerance, for justice and solidarity throughout this time. I believe these are precisely the values that hold Europe together at its core.

Certainly, Europe is also based on shared historical experiences and on the will to shape our future better. Over time, many joint projects have developed from this, such as the internal market, the Schengen Area, and the Euro. However, it was only on the basis of recognized common values that a historically new coexistence of larger and smaller states could emerge in Europe – a coexistence characterized by trust in one another and by respect for one another. We know that this has led to a period in history in which armed conflicts have become much less frequent.

We also know that almost all states of Europe are gathered in the Council of Europe. They are united by the pursuit of common values. We will strive with those who are not yet members to ensure that they also become members of the Council of Europe.

Germany joined the Council of Europe in 1951. In that year, the first Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, Konrad Adenauer, delivered a speech before the then Consultative Assembly of the Council of Europe. In it, he said: "It means a lot for the political development of Europe that we have here in the organs of the Council of Europe a platform where the representatives of Europe regularly meet, exchange their concerns and needs, their wishes and hopes, try to develop common criteria for assessing their needs, and generally work together in a spirit of fairness and good neighborliness; in other words: We have here the European conscience."

For almost 60 years, the Council of Europe has watched over our common values as the "European conscience" – values that ultimately rest in the dignity of each individual person. Thus, the Council of Europe has helped to place the actions of governments under the mandate of upholding human rights. It is a permanently valid mandate that forms the basis for the coexistence of people and for the relationships between people and the state.

It is true that human dignity is indivisible. It holds the same value in all countries of Europe. It is also true that there are different manifestations and practices in the protection of human rights. This is, of course, also due to different historical experiences and traditions. Presumably, this is one of the reasons why Pope John Paul II remarked in his address to the Parliamentary Assembly in 1988: "The European identity is not an easily graspable reality."

Since 1988, when Pope John Paul II spoke before the Parliamentary Assembly, Europe has changed significantly. Today, a European identity is much clearer than it was 20 years ago. The fall of the Iron Curtain and the end of the Cold War have ended the unnatural division of Europe. For the first time, the beginnings of a pan-European identity have emerged on the basis of the European Convention on Human Rights.

I spent the first 35 years of my life in the former GDR. During the regime of the SED, there was no possibility to address discriminatory and unjust treatment by state authorities before the European Court of Human Rights. This changed dramatically in Germany with the fall of the Wall and the reunification and through the arrival of freedom in many parts of Europe.

Thus, after 1990, many countries in Central and Eastern Europe gradually bid farewell to a party dictatorship and developed into democracies. They embarked on the path to a free society with democratic stability, in most cases with a multi-party system, with an effective opposition, with an independent judiciary, with the separation of powers, and with free media. Everyone knows that all of this was and is nowhere a given and must be fought for repeatedly, and that care must be taken to ensure that all of this is not called into question.

I have experienced the change in my own country. That is why I say with full conviction: Even if change seems hardly possible, it is nonetheless possible. All of us sitting here have experienced many changes that we would not have thought possible 20 years ago. That is why I am deeply convinced that the success story of European unification can serve as a signal for other regions of the world – regions where stability may seem hardly conceivable today, but based on our experience and therefore our conviction, must not remain merely a vision.

We are in Europe – this also belongs to the consideration of reality – certainly not yet at the end of this success story. I believe it can be said that Europe is a permanent task. There is always something to improve at the House of Europe. We succeed all the more the more we all identify with the European project.

The European identity is still in the process of being formed. Its strengthening was always a focus of the German EU Council Presidency last year. In connection with the celebrations marking the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Treaty of Rome in Berlin, we adopted a declaration. In it, we once again emphasized what connects us in Europe: Our values, on the basis of which we politically shape our future.

Our political actions show whether we uphold these values. It is a question of our values whether we succeed in giving globalization a human face. It is a question of our values whether we manage to confront climate change resolutely. It is also a question of our values whether we prioritize trade interests over human rights or whether we agree that economic issues and human rights issues must not be opposites. Therefore, fundamental rules must also be adhered to in trade matters.

In short: Upholding our values is nothing abstract, nothing for Sunday speeches. The challenge of living our values presents itself anew in our political actions every day – whether at home or on the European stage. Despite all the successes of the Council of Europe, it will therefore continue to be a guardian of the values of Europe.

I would like to illustrate this with two examples – firstly with regard to the fight against terrorism, and secondly with regard to the protection of minorities.

First, regarding international terrorism. At the latest since the attacks in Madrid and London, we know that the fight against terrorism is also being waged in Europe. It is important to ensure that the legitimate security needs of people are aligned with the protection of individual fundamental rights. Security interests and the protection of our legal principles must always be carefully weighed. We all know how difficult that can be in individual cases. It may not always proceed unambiguously. All the more important it is that our democracies are based on the separation of powers, on balancing interests, and on participation, so that we can always find the right path when entering uncharted territory.

In this context, I would like to expressly highlight the role of the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe. Thomas Hammarberg visited Germany in the autumn of 2006. Germany is aware of the importance of constructive critical examination from the outside. Being open to this helps to look beyond one’s own horizon. It highlights deficiencies and shakes us to eliminate these deficiencies. I would like to add expressly that it is not always easy to live with such criticism. This is certainly true for everyone. But that is part of democracy.

That is why it is good – I want to emphasize this point explicitly – that there is an obligation in Europe to intervene mutually when it comes to human rights. In matters of human rights, there are no internal affairs of a country that can shield it from judgments, for example, from the Commissioner for Human Rights.

From this arises a special role for an institution like the Council of Europe. I believe you take on this role very confidently. With a system of mutual control of state actions, the Council of Europe does not shy away from repeatedly pointing out the wounds when necessary. It guarantees that citizens can claim the observance of their fundamental rights before an independent court. In this way, it helps ensure that politicians make appropriate decisions in the fight against terrorism and do not excessively restrict freedoms.

For the Council of Europe to be successful in this function, its various instruments and organs – the Parliamentary Assembly, the Committee of Ministers, and the Court – must above all do one thing: In the awareness of the common commitment to the values of Europe, they must work together as closely and smoothly as necessary to tackle the tasks at hand.

This applies equally to the treatment of minorities. This issue poses a significant challenge for Europe and also for European foreign policy. We are dealing with unresolved minority conflicts worldwide and also in Europe. On one side is the desire of individual population groups for cultural and political self-determination. On the other side is the interest of states in maintaining their territorial integrity. In this case, too, we are dealing with areas of tension where we must try to resolve them in the specific case.

How do we achieve the balancing act between aspirations for autonomy and national cohesion? There is no one-size-fits-all solution for this. One thing is certain, however: Violence must never be the answer to controversies. Violence is incompatible with our fundamental values.

The key to preventing cultural conflicts lies in dialogue. Only through dialogue can social integration and participation succeed. I know that this is easier said than done in individual cases. For how do we deal with the growing number of migrants in Europe? To what extent do they fulfill their desire to maintain their cultural identity? How does this reconcile with the claim to integration? We all know that our societies become more diverse through migration. Upholding social peace requires integrating new citizens into our society. This naturally also applies to those who have a different faith than the majority.

Of course, these questions also concern my government. I have deliberately placed a government commissioner for migration and integration issues in the Chancellery because these questions are one of the most challenging focal tasks. We have initiated a dialogue with representatives of citizens with a migration background in Germany, the so-called Integration Summit. Here we learn to articulate mutual expectations, to openly address wishes and criticism.

Whether in Germany or in other countries: There are no simple answers to questions of integration or migration. The most important thing, however, is that we first talk to each other, get to know each other, and understand each other better in order to be able to solve things. Therefore, I explicitly welcome that you have initiated intercultural dialogue in the Council of Europe. I believe this is a very important signal for our national activities as well.

Counter-terrorism and integration are just two examples among many that demand a values-oriented policy. The values orientation of the countries represented in the Council of Europe is primarily expressed in the Human Rights Convention. This is, so to speak, the platform on which we all work.

It aims to ensure protection from state arbitrariness for the 800 million people in Europe. This allows them to file complaints against violations of their fundamental rights before the European Court of Human Rights. I believe we can say that such a human rights protection system is unique in the world. After all, over 50,000 citizens make use of this opportunity every year. This is an impressive testament to the trust that the Court enjoys throughout Europe.

This morning, I was able to get a picture of its work. President Costa described to me the great work that the judges of the Court are doing. I also visited the registry, where the complaints are filed. There, I was able to convince myself that the Court has reached its capacity limit.

I believe we agree that the Court needs a more suitable form. This is crucial for the credibility of the entire human rights protection system in Europe. Because if one is allowed to file a complaint, but the complaint is never processed, then the rule of law system is certainly not a convincing system. Therefore, I want to make it clear: We must not block the reform of the Court. Those who do so ultimately put our shared values at risk.

During the German EU Council Presidency, I spoke with President Putin about how necessary a swift ratification of Protocol 14 to the Human Rights Convention by Russia is. I also discussed this with the President of the Duma. The topic has been raised very frequently by the Federal Government.

I believe that this protocol opens up possibilities for the Court to work more efficiently and quickly. Since I know that representatives of the Duma are present today, I would like to thank them for their efforts to ensure that this protocol is ratified in the Duma. I hope that in the new Duma, the time has come to look at Protocol 14 from a different perspective and achieve ratification by Russia. I would very much welcome that, as it would be in the interest of all.

The European Human Rights Convention existed long before we discussed a Charter of Fundamental Rights in the European Union. This is also part of the historical truth: The European Union in its current form would be unthinkable without the groundwork laid by the Council of Europe. Every EU member state was previously also a member of the Council of Europe. The Council of Europe and the European Union are different, but they are complementary.

During the German EU Council Presidency, it was fortunately possible to conclude a "Memorandum of Understanding" between the European Union and the Council of Europe. I think we need closer cooperation between the European Union and the Council of Europe. That the Chair of the Committee of Ministers is also a member of the EU Foreign Affairs Council and is present today shows how it is possible to improve this cooperation.

Another important step in the collaboration between both organizations will be the accession of the European Union to the European Human Rights Convention. This is provided for in the Treaty of Lisbon. For this reason, we have worked hard to achieve legal personality for the European Union. That was not easy at all. I hope that all states will ratify the treaty so that we then have the opportunity to accede to the European Human Rights Convention. This will underscore our common platform for our work.

The citizens of the European Union will then be able to individually bring actions before the European Court of Human Rights against Brussels legal acts if they feel their fundamental rights have been violated. This is also a new quality that does not currently exist. The Brussels legal acts are not yet subject to the possibility of complaint before the European Court of Human Rights. Of course, we hope that this possibility will not have to be used constantly, but it will then be available.

The Council of Europe is a great European success story. It has earned historical merits for democracy, human rights, and the rule of law in Europe. However, these are merits that each generation must earn anew.

I say this because sometimes there is a danger that all of this becomes automatic. Therefore, each generation must be made aware and familiar with the forms of our cooperation. It must live them anew, expand them, and further develop them. That is why I believe that the merits are at the same time a mandate and obligation to continue working towards a Europe that has the task of serving the well-being of its citizens.

Therefore, my appeal to you is: Continue to get involved, continue to shape the European debates with your contributions. This way, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe will remain an important driving force for a united Europe in peace, freedom, democracy, and perhaps also an example to the world of how to find hope and solutions in seemingly hopeless situations. There are many places in the world where this still needs to be achieved, so that we, the Europeans, can set a good example with relatively manageable problems compared to the issues in other regions of the world.