Argentina will not default on its restructured debt and is willing to negotiate; what it does not have is the willingness to be subjected to extortion.

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

16 June 2014

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the Argentine public on June 16, 2014, responding to the U.S. Supreme Court ruling validating Judge Griesa's decision favoring holdout creditors.
Main themes
Argentine external debt crisis, vulture funds and holdout creditors, U.S. Supreme Court ruling on debt restructuring, debt restructuring and sovereign debt, history of Argentine debt, IMF and financial fraud, blindaje and megacanje operations, judicial extortion, global financial system risks, dictatorship-era debt origins, sovereign rights and international solidarity
Duration
~28 min
79th percentile
Words
3,304
79th percentile
Sentences
95
60th percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
15.6
80th percentile
Syntax
3.56
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 92%81%
  • Ceremonial 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 4%3%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Institutional 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

95 sentences in 34 paragraphs

I address all Argentines today regarding what is already public and well-known, which is the ruling of the Supreme Court of Justice of the United States, validating the ruling of Judge Griesa, at first instance, contrary not only to the interests of our country, the Argentine Republic, but also to the 92 percent of creditors who believed in Argentina and restructured their debt, 92 percent of the creditors of Argentina's external debt and also – why not say it – of what is the system and the functioning of the global economic and financial system. Why do I say this? For a very simple reason, not in vain have countries like France; Mexico; Brazil, including more than a hundred British parliamentarians, among other personalities, supported the Argentine Republic before the Supreme Court of Justice as amicus curiae precisely because they understood that this was not solely a cause of Argentina, but of the entire world.

But I believe this merits a brief prior reflection, and that is what constituted in the history of Argentina the external debt, which began to grow exponentially, since the dictatorship of March 24, 1976, constituted – without a doubt – the most formidable stranglehold that attacked the growth, the development of Argentina and generated poverty, unemployment, backwardness, lack of investment in infrastructure, in education, in research, in science and technology, the history, ultimately, of the last decades of our country.

That debt not only grew during the dictatorship, it also grew in democracy, it grew during the 1980s and it also grew exponentially during the regime known as convertibility, where with the fiction that one dollar was equal to one peso, the country became terribly indebted in international markets, to sustain precisely that fiction that one dollar was equal to one peso.

But that was not the end of it, when the government that had installed the convertibility regime finally changed and another government came in, it not only continued to uphold convertibility, but also two formidable financial operations were carried out that some call the greatest financial fraud in history: the so-called "blindaje" and "megacanje."

The "blindaje" – and I remember this very well because I was a national legislator – took place at the end of 2001, constituting a fictitious operation, a sort of handover of 40 billion dollars that the International Monetary Fund lent to the then government, to take charge of the debt that the government had, and that it could not pay and that was in reality a handover or a mere accounting entry, because the money entered the country, but immediately left the country to pay the debts of the capital that had entered with extremely high international rates to our country. This in exchange, also, for a formidable adjustment, which was discussed in Congress: reduction of PAMI, ANSES, reduction of the State, of educational budgets, in short, what constituted the adjustment that had wide dissemination and a broad discussion in the Argentine Parliament, of which I also, at that time, as a parliamentarian, was a protagonist.

But that would not be the end of it, as could not be otherwise, the "blindaje" also failed and then came what constituted the last act of the great tragedy of the Argentine debt: the "megacanje." The "megacanje" was an idea, its intellectual author was a former Secretary of the Treasury of the United States of America, David Mulford, who at that time was the CEO of Credit Suisse, who proposed to the then Minister of Economy and the then President to exchange 46 existing debt bonds at that time for 5 debt bonds.

The operation, in which seven banks intervened, and also the AFJP generated commissions, that is, payment for the intermediation of exchanging bonds, of 150 million dollars, of which 20 million went to David Mulford and the rest to the banks and the AFJP that had intervened. The interesting thing – in addition to the 150 million dollars in commission – is that the banks that had intervened in that operation and the AFJP put and I say put in quotation marks, 27 billion dollars, but in reality only 7 billion because 20 billion they already had in their portfolios. This means that they charged commissions on what they already had. This originated a formidable criminal case, with accounting expertise, which prescribed. What does it mean that it prescribed? That the passage of time and the inactivity of judges, appellate judges, and prosecutors led this past June 6 to David Mulford, who was never able to be interrogated or investigated, nor do I know if anyone asked him to come to the country or insisted too much that he come to the country, to be dismissed and also other people who intervened in that operation. It is curious and I say this because it is curious the speed of some judges, some appellate judges, and some prosecutors who have the speed of the Road Runner, that character from Beep Beep, in some media and political cases, I cannot forget that summer of the reserves when a judge prevented us, through a precautionary measure, from paying with reserves of the Central Bank the debt that we had contracted as Argentines and I cannot help but compare that speed and those different speeds with this inaction, for years, on the part of prosecutors, judges, and appellate judges that allowed a case that caused the country a loss of 55 billion dollars to prescribe.

It is also remarkable the difference in how a Justice – like that of the United States – acts in defense of just 1 percent of the vulture creditors of Argentina and I will explain why the term vultures and how Justice acts, or at least some judges, some prosecutors, and some Argentine appellate judges. I say this because it is necessary to clarify things and call them all by their name.

The truth is that this operation of the "megacanje" culminates and the Argentine external debt was already around 160 percent of the Gross Domestic Product becoming something truly unpayable. Unemployment had reached double digits, almost 25 percent; poverty at 54 percent; indigence at 30 and it skyrocketed, as could not be otherwise, the default. The default that skyrocketed in 2001, and that is the largest sovereign debt default in memory. Default that accumulated, as I said, reiterating debt contracted during the military dictatorship, during democracy, convertibility, "blindaje," and "megacanje."

In 2003, on May 25, Néstor Carlos Kirchner assumed as President of all Argentines, with just 22 percent of all votes, who dedicated himself precisely to the task of renegotiating the debt of Argentines, because we knew it was an insurmountable stranglehold. Then a negotiation began, a hard renegotiation that finally culminated, a first part, in 2005, with an adherence of almost 76 percent of creditors, with a very significant haircut and what he had said was fulfilled: "allow us to grow so we can pay, because the dead do not pay." And Argentina, without access to the capital market, for the first time began to eliminate the financial bicycle and began to pay its debt with genuine resources, with its own resources, with resources from its economic growth and development.

In parallel to the payment of that debt, millions of jobs were generated, retirees were incorporated into the pension system, pensions began to be increased, collective labor agreements returned, factories opened, industrial parks. It was a payment of debt with growth and social inclusion.

Then I had the opportunity to assume as President of all Argentines, in 2010, the second bond swap also took place, reaching 92 percent adherence. One thing to keep in mind: the majority of countries, the internal legislation of a country, in ours too, when there is a bankruptcy of a company, a default would be the bankruptcy of a country, it is enough that 66 percent of the creditors agree with what the debt payment proposal is, for that bankruptcy to be lifted and the debtor can begin to pay. This is the percentage that is normally required everywhere, including also, in the United States itself. But we lack, at the international level, a global norm that establishes rules in case of default or countries that go bankrupt. Also, during President Kirchner's administration, payments were made and the debt to the International Monetary Fund was settled with its own resources. For the first time in history, since Argentina joined the International Monetary Fund in 1957, it ceased to direct the destinies of the economy and of Argentines. Based on all these things, we can explain the things that have also happened in our country in recent years.

Now, a part of those who had these bonds, rather a part that bought bonds, after Argentina defaulted, because there were people who had bonds before Argentina defaulted on its bonds and there were people who specialize in the world in buying what? Buying bonds of countries that have already gone into default. They are bonds that are practically called junk bonds. Why? Because they are worth nothing in the market, they are bonds that from a nominal value of one hundred, can be bought – if it is worth one dollar – for 30 cents on the dollar, for 40 cents on the dollar because they are junk bonds. Who is going to buy bonds from a country that has defaulted on its debt and is not paying it, only someone who is going to speculate and has all the time in the world to speculate that that country recovers and then fall on that country. This is the case that is being dealt with today, and that was the case that the U.S. Court rejected and that was the case that Griesa accepted and validated, it is that of the NML fund, which it is very important to point out, has funds that it acquired in the year – I am going to show a card, if the camera accompanies me, please – are funds that it acquired in 2008 for 48.7 million dollars. Year 2008, remember that we had defaulted on the debt in 2001.

The aggregate return, by the year 2014, that is, how much it gained from those 48 million by 2014, 1,608 percent, in dollars. I believe that not even in organized crime is there a return rate of 1,608 percent in such a short time. This ends in 2014, where the U.S. Justice recognized NML 832 million dollars. I think that can be seen clearly. Well, it is good to remember that these bonds, 70 percent, are bonds issued by the "megacanje," the operation I just mentioned, for which Mulford was dismissed and that was carried out in 2001. And the other 30 percent are bonds issued during convertibility.

Now, what is the claim of the vulture funds? The NML fund, which represents 52 percent, is 428, original capital, and which Judge Griesa orders to be paid cash, one on top of the other, to put it in plain terms, is 1.5 billion dollars.

Let’s remember: they bought those bonds for 48.7 million dollars; today Judge Griesa orders to pay them 1.5 billion dollars, all at once, without deadline, now, cash, in front of 92 percent of the other bondholders who are also creditors who accepted haircuts, deadlines, waiting and to whom we have paid regularly.

Now, there are some who say: why not pay these 1.5 billion dollars and finish everything now? And because there is another problem that is much more serious that represents the 1 percent of those who did not enter the default, there is another 7 percent that if this criterion of paying NML 1.5 billion dollars is accepted, they would be in a position to charge Argentina already and now 15 billion dollars. That is, it is understood, I repeat, they would be in a position to demand that Argentina pay 15 billion dollars now. This is more than half of the total reserves of the Central Bank.

As will be seen, it is not only something absurd, but it is impossible for a country to allocate more than 50 percent of the total monetary reserves of its Central Bank in a single payment to creditors. But also, with the possibility that the other 92 percent, which is the bulk of the creditors, finds another judge who also says "well, but if you accepted a haircut, deadlines and it turns out that someone was benefited having 1 percent and received the total payment at once, you also have the right to the same for a matter of equity and equality." Whoever finds a Judge Griesa can find another judge who also gives them reason, with which we would also be facing the more than certain possibility that the entirety of the Argentine debt would be demanded and the restructuring carried out in 2005 and carried out in 2010 would fall like a house of cards and with it, obviously, the Argentine Republic.

I believe that Argentina's willingness to negotiate is more than demonstrated. We negotiated in 2005; we negotiated in 2010; we negotiated… just a few days ago we closed the agreement with Repsol, the main Argentine oil company, which had been expropriated and which we had a claim before the CIADI and we were able to close, negotiate, reach an agreement between the parties, close a deal and begin to fulfill it to the point that Repsol withdrew its claim from the CIADI.

But not only that, just a few days ago, we also definitively closed and for the first time in its entire history, the negotiations with the debt of the Paris Club. The Paris Club debt whose origin dates back to 1956 and that 8 previous governments to ours had tried to negotiate and had not been able to.

When this debt began to be incurred, this President was 3 years old, in 1956, it was the first loan requested for 700 million dollars, and the Minister of Economy, Axel Kicillof, who negotiated it in Paris with all the Ministers of Economy from the entire European Union and also from Japan, had not even been born. This means that Argentina has demonstrated more than an evident willingness to negotiate.

But I believe we must distinguish between what is negotiation and what is extortion. I think these are two absolutely different concepts. Every ruler, every country, every leader in the realm of politics and economics must be willing to negotiate; what no president of a sovereign nation can do, at least, is subject their country and their people to such extortion.

Today, I want to address not only the millions of Argentines who are surely listening to us, but I also want to fundamentally address the 92 percent of creditors who believed in Argentina, and I want to tell them that Argentina will fulfill its obligations. Argentina will not default on its restructured debt. We are also willing, as we have always done and because we have opened the exchange, to allow 100 percent of Argentina's creditors, of that 7 percent who still need to enter, to participate in that exchange. Because Argentina's intention is to pay; we have demonstrated this, we have been the only government that did not use financial tricks to continue incurring debt; the only government that paid all its obligations without accessing the capital markets; the only government that was finally able to close negotiations with the Paris Club.

I must also say that we had tried in 2008, when I had to announce the cash payment to the Paris Club, but at that time the collapse of Lehman Brothers and the global financial crisis that spread from Wall Street to the whole world made it impossible for us to fulfill this.

But the truth is that Argentina has shown and has a willingness to negotiate. What it does not have is, well, let’s say it, let’s say it clearly, the reason why it is subjected to such extortion. I believe that neither our country nor the bondholders, who are being prevented from receiving or having their funds seized that we have to pay at the end of the month, on June 30, with maturities of 900 million dollars, deserve this.

I have instructed the Ministry of Economy and all the technical bodies of the national state to provide all the instruments and all the necessary strategies so that all those who have trusted in Argentina receive their money, receive the dollars that we have committed to pay. But we want to do it with seriousness and responsibility.

This is not a cause that involves only the Republic of Argentina; it involves, as I said yesterday at the meeting in Santa Cruz, Bolivia, at the G-77+China meeting, the entire global financial system. That is why so many people accompanied us in front of the Court.

And I want to tell you something or confess something: the ruling did not surprise me, I expected this ruling.

When this morning I spoke with the president of the Central Bank, Juan Carlos Fábrega, he told me, “President, you were the only one who believed this would happen.” Yes, because this is not an economic problem, it is not a financial problem, it is not a legal or juridical problem; it is the validation of a global business model that, if it continues to be pronounced, will produce unimaginable tragedies.

Because as I said yesterday in Santa Cruz de la Sierra, Bolivia: why is it that someone who simply puts 1 dollar from their desk into a junk bond earns a return and a rate of 1,608 percent from 2008 to 2014? Why would someone with such incredible profitability decide to invest in a factory or in a business or in buying shares of a company or in doing any financial business? It is clear that a form of global financial domination of derivatives is being validated to subjugate peoples, and where it is no longer even necessary to exploit anyone, but simply, with exclusion, it is enough. It is enough for there to be governments willing to make mega-exchanges, for there to be governments willing to make shields, for there to be governments willing to negotiate commissions for this business to continue prospering with the blood, with the hunger, or the exclusion of millions of young people around the world who lack work and education.

We want to fulfill and honor our debts, and we will do so. But we also do not want to be complicit in this way of doing business, to not qualify it in any other way that some want to establish in the world.

That is why I wanted to address all my compatriots, with the calmness of knowing what was going to happen. I am not even angry; I am very worried. Very worried because life does not begin when one arrives in government or when one leaves; the life of my children, of my grandchildren, the life of the planet, of different peoples, is increasingly aggravated, and yesterday we discussed this with many leaders of this group that gathered us in Bolivia. And that is why I believe it is the duty of all of us who have government responsibilities to take charge of our obligations, and among our obligations is, among other things, to pay our creditors, but it is also to not allow ourselves to be extorted by those who have speculated and profited from misery and even want to harm 92 percent of creditors who did trust in Argentina.

I hope everyone reflects and we can not only honor, as we will do to the 92 percent, but to 100 percent.

Thank you very much and good night to all Argentines.