CFK at the UNASUR Summit 2009

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

10 August 2009 · UNASUR Summit 2009

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the UNASUR Summit on August 10, 2009, urging fellow South American presidents to convene an emergency meeting over rising regional tensions linked to US-Colombia military base negotiations.
Main themes
Regional belligerence and security crisis, UNASUR presidential summit proposal, Colombia-US military base agreement, political over military solutions, regional diplomacy and dialogue, invitation of President Uribe, US relations with South America, FARC and Colombian internal conflict, Latin American democratic stability, role of defense ministers vs. presidents
Duration
~9 min
32nd percentile
Words
1,082
32nd percentile
Sentences
28
16th percentile
Readability
32
20th percentile
Grade
18.0
94th percentile
Syntax
3.77
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
62nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 64%64%
  • Institutional 32%32%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

28 sentences in 3 paragraphs

I am going to refer to the current situation and the strategy we should have. I believe that an unprecedented, unacceptable state of belligerence is being created in the region. I think the last state of belligerence was due to the military dictatorships between Argentina and Chile, and then I believe it was the war between Ecuador and Peru. But having overcome all that, with the economic growth, the development that our region has experienced, and the resurgence and strengthening of democracies, that entire stage had been surpassed. But the truth is that due to endogenous or exogenous factors, a situation of unprecedented and unacceptable belligerence is being created, if I may add an adjective to the issue.

I believe we must hold this meeting of defense ministers, but I also think, and we all know, that a defense minister will not have the authority or the analytical and decision-making power to make a determination; in any case, they will bring the background strictly related to the military issue, but the problem is not military, we all know it is not military, because we know that when conflicts arise it is because politics has failed, and ultimately we know that the problem is political. And the political problem can only be resolved or not by the presidents of the different countries.

That is why I believe that without dismissing the meeting of defense ministers, it is essential, Rafael, to convene a meeting of presidents immediately afterward. In this sense, I absolutely agree with President Lula, and I also agree with him on the need to question, if I may use the term, to ask, if it seems too aggressive to question; to converse if someone wants to be more gentle in their expressions, because it seems that everything hinges on the timing or the expressions, whether they are sweeter, more benevolent, or stronger. But I believe we should not be confused by either benevolent speeches or exalted speeches; I think what we need to state exactly is what is happening. The result is that a situation of belligerence is being created in the region that could lead to situations that absolutely no one wants. We have the responsibility to address the problem; I expressed this to President Uribe, and I believe that ultimately Colombia must also be interested in addressing this problem, so as not to be seen as a factor of disturbance in the area, which is why I think we should invite President Uribe to that meeting, because he also needs to be there; he is the other inevitable interlocutor. I remember when we were in the Dominican Republic, at the meeting of the Rio Group, when the conflict over the invasion of Ecuadorian territory by Colombian armed forces was raised. So I believe it is essential that in that meeting of presidents we invite President Alvaro Uribe; he must be there as a member of UNASUR. CORREA.- He was invited to this meeting, but he says he will not come due to a lack of guarantees because we have shown hostility towards Colombia. PRESIDENTA.- Yes, but we can hold a meeting in a place where President Uribe does not feel that there is hostility towards him, whether it is held in Quito or Caracas. Let us choose a location wisely. What we need to do is eliminate excuses; we need to separate each of the excuses so that ultimately the truth of the situation is stripped of excuses and speeches to place it in its true context. CORREA.- Could we hold the meeting in Buenos Aires? PRESIDENTA.- Yes, I would be delighted, Rafael, to host all the members of UNASUR in Buenos Aires; I commit to personally inviting President Uribe, because I believe he is also interested in having that meeting and providing his explanations. I do believe, as President Lula says, that we must once and for all address the situation with the United States, to finally define what the relationship with the continent will be, because it seems there is a degree of autonomy in certain sectors of the U.S. administration where some decide, and it is not clear who one should ask why such or such a decision was made. So I absolutely agree with Lula in the sense that once we have gathered the presidents of UNASUR and made a resolution, in which I believe President Álvaro Uribe must also be included, I would not feel right as a member of UNASUR if he were not present; I think he must be there; he will not refuse to go to Buenos Aires at all; I will personally take care of it, and Lula will surely accompany me, along with the other leaders, to invite him, so we can do it there and reach a conclusion. I told him what my feelings were; Colombia has made significant progress in the fight against the FARC, and today they are practically reduced to a minimal expression, as President Uribe himself has stated on numerous occasions, and I really think that is very important. That is why I believe it is necessary for him to explain to each and every one of us the reasons he has for renewing an agreement that, according to him, dates back to 1952, but if it dates back to 1952, what is the need to expand it, modify it, or address it? I do believe that we all need to make a very great effort to avoid adjectives and stridency, which normally then serve to bring out stridencies or fiery speeches and not to present it rationally, because when one presents things without adjectives, the other is left with the explanation and has to explain without responding to stridencies or adjectives or qualifications. I think that would be an intelligent way to address the problem; from now on, Buenos Aires is the home of all of you; wherever the President defines the invitation, we are at your disposal; I think it is very good that it is so, and then proceed in the direction that the President of Brazil proposed. But I reiterate that we cannot allow, in addition to having exported the economic crisis, the Swine Flu, and I don’t know what other things, now they also present us with a belligerent situation in our region for this reason; it is highly concerning and I would say highly distressing for our societies and our governments. That is all, thank you very much.