Meeting with Villa Priests, Priests in Option for the Poor, and sisters, both religious and lay.

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

15 September 2022 · Meeting with Villa Priests, Priests in Option for the Poor, and sisters

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed Villa priests, sisters, and lay workers in her first public activity after surviving an assassination attempt on September 1, 2022.
Main themes
Gratitude and faith, assassination attempt aftermath, social order and family values, inflation and economic hardship, YPF and Vaca Muerta gas investment, democratic covenant since 1983, political dialogue across differences, violence and hate speech, poverty and neighborhood needs, Peronism and Argentine politics
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,813
73rd percentile
Sentences
142
79th percentile
Readability
67
96th percentile
Grade
8.8
9th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 42%38%
  • Social 22%20%
  • Economic 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 16%14%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

142 sentences in 10 paragraphs

Well, I want to thank you all for coming. I wanted my first public activity, so to speak, or outside of an office, to be with you. I feel that I am alive thanks to God and the Virgin, truly. So it seemed to me that if I had to thank God and the Virgin, I had to do it surrounded by priests for the poor, by priests from the villas, and by lay sisters, by religious sisters. I would have liked my friends, the Carmelite sisters from San Nicolás, to be here, but they cannot because they are cloistered. Yes, I invited them and then I realized they couldn't come, but we talk a lot, we send each other messages. And they send me honey from the Basilica of the Rosary of San Nicolás. And well, they also send me pecans and little things like that. I love them very much and they love me very much. That's it.

That's why I wanted my first activity to be with you. I would have liked to be the other day at the Basilica of Luján, but there was going to be a lot of security and I didn't want to hinder what was a very special moment with my presence.

You know that Pope Francis called me very early the day after that Thursday, early Friday he called me. We talked on the phone and he said something like that acts of hate, acts of hate and violence are always preceded by words and verbs of hate and violence. First, it is verbal, right? The aggression, and then that climate grows, grows, and grows, and finally it produces well...

But I don't want to talk about that, about that day. No, no. I want to talk about my country, about our people, about what you see and live alongside the people in the neighborhoods. Ignacio mentioned it, from inflation, from prices, from the needs of the people, from what the sister just said, that people ate and they ate as a family because people didn't have to go... To school, you went to study and they also gave you a computer. And they also gave you a computer. And people returned to eating at home because that is what the family wants, to sit down at noon or at night, or at night if the parents work and are outside, to eat as a family.

I always say that is the order because I also like to live in order. We all like order, right? But for me, the order that we established in our government was this: the order that the family eats together, that the kids go to school to study, not to eat, that the workers have their jobs in the factory, the seller in their business, the merchant. The order that everyone is doing what they know and what they have to do, that is the order. At least for me, that is the order. The order of the shovel, the stick, and the bullet does not seem like order to me. Besides, those are orders that last a short time. We have all had experiences in history; I have been a militant since I was very young and I have many years already, and all the experiences of violence and wanting to impose things with the most extreme, most terrible violence ultimately failed. And not only did they fail, but they left tragedies, sequels, wounds that society still has.

That is why I say that the day I arrived, I had been here in the Senate until about eight-thirty, and the truth is that I was happy because that day we had a meeting with the people from YPF and with the people from the Malaysian company, Petronas, with whom we had already had an agreement back in 2014 when we recovered YPF and Vaca Muerta. And they are going to make a very important investment in Argentina that will allow us to have exports with gas and... I was coming happy because, finally, now that we have to import gas, we are finally going to export gas in four or five years, and this was going to mean foreign currency. And well, what happened happened, but I believe that the most serious thing is not what could have happened to me. For me, the most serious thing was having broken a social agreement that had existed since 1983. I feel that the recovery of democracy was not only that we could return to vote and elect authorities. I understand that recovering democracy was recovering life. Recovering life, life and the rationality that we can discuss in politics, Peronists, Alfonsinists, renewing Peronists, traditional Peronists... What democracy was from 1983, eradicating that violence. And the truth is that what happened the other day was something more, it was a rupture. A rupture of that which we must urgently rebuild because, moreover, Toto, moreover Ignacio, that passion that we all have for people to be able to eat again, to be able to have a job again, we will not achieve by only talking among those who think one way. That was... when I met, which got so much press, with Melconian, that no one can think that I have the same ideas as Melconian in politics. But that is the point. The point is not to meet with those who think alike. The point is to meet with those who think differently and see if at least in economics, we can have a minimum agreement. Because everyone talks about inflation. The problem is that inflation comes because we don't have currency, which is what I think, you saw in the conferences I was giving about bimonetary economics and whatnot, about the dollar and bam, bam, bam. It's that, we have to come to a reasonable agreement on that to rebuild. And the truth is that when I went to talk to him, I did it with that intention and I continue with the same intention as always. First, because it is true that all political leaders want to be President, as the priests say that they all want to be Pope, right? Yes, the truth. Well. What priest doesn't want to be Pope? Obviously. We talked about that once with Jorge and he laughed. In the end, I was right. In the end, I was right. And the truth is that in my case, I have already been President twice. So: the highest ambition that a politician, a political figure in Argentina has, which is to be President, I have already had it twice. And besides that, my partner was also President. So those are not the things that seduce me or the things that encourage me. What encourages me is to see if we can really get out of this.

And, look, I said... because there is a whole thing that is normally said about anti-Peronism, Peronism, the divide. No, no. Look: I brought here, now I will explain what this book is. I want to tell you something because it is something that can help us understand the problem that, to some extent, we Argentines may have and that we drag in history, in the 200 years of history.

On December 24, 1929, there was an assassination attempt against the life of Hipólito Yrigoyen. Hipólito Yrigoyen was the President of the Argentine Republic. He had won in 1928, the previous year, by more than 60% of the votes. But the crisis of the 1929 crash, of the New York stock market, and what was the Great Depression starting in 1930, had driven up food prices in Argentina. There was a lot of inflation. Workers' wages had lost purchasing power due to the global crash, and there was very fierce opposition to Hipólito Yrigoyen. They had held an event the day before at the door of his house. And on December 24, when he was accompanied by his security detail, a person attempted against his life with five shots. He injured the police chief who was with him, Yrigoyen came out unscathed, and the assailant was shot by the police. But I want to show you because, obviously, if I tell you, well... it could be a biased opinion of Cristina what she is saying. I want, this book... This book is from 1929, it is the diary of sessions of this Senate. Diary of sessions of this Senate. The assassination attempt was on December 24, but on January 21, 1930, there was a session, and obviously, the senators... there were no female senators at that time. They were all men. Eva Perón had not yet arrived with women's suffrage. So look, guys, girls, they were all men. And then a radical senator, Senator Del Valle, requests the floor to make a statement precisely about what had happened. And look at what he says: “I say this on behalf of the radical representation. With complete awareness and tranquility. That assassination attempt was nothing but the consequence of the intemperate and outrageous attitude of the press, of parties, and even, Mr. President, of the honorable Senate itself. On the very corner of Dr. Yrigoyen's home, a platform of scandals and threats was erected.” In other words: they went to hold the event at the door of Yrigoyen's house as well. Any similarity is not a coincidence. “And that unfortunate person who attempted against the life of the first executive and who had his activities nearby, perhaps heard there for the first time the incitement to crime.” And he says: “The country witnessed the shameful scenes that had this chamber as a stage. All the clumsiness, all the possible irreverences against the first executive. Some senator spoke of dictatorship, of despotism, of tyrants, who recalled the French Revolution and spoke of the guillotine.” Of the guillotine, 1930. It will be a century and there were already threats of guillotine for not sharing a political opinion.

What does the opposition respond? Senator Vidal from Corrientes. “This act of the assassination attempt against the President of the Republic has been mixed with current politics, it has been related to the beneficial action of the opposition and with the just and healthy criticism of the independent press, which is a true madness to condemn, etc...”. At that time, the press was the newspaper Crítica. The newspaper Crítica had been created in 1914 by Natalio Botana and it reached a sale of one million copies daily, one million! There were 10 million Argentines at that time. Imagine the power of someone who in a society of only 10 million people, concentrated mostly here in Buenos Aires, sold one million copies daily. And the most remarkable thing about all this is that Peronism did not yet exist, that is, you see that now they say “no because what happened in the last 40 years of Peronism,” “that Peronism is responsible,” “that Peronism...”. Peronism did not exist; here Evita was 11 years old and had not yet left Junín.

Why do I bring this up? Well, because I think we need to examine ourselves, the self-perception that we Argentines have of ourselves. And what we are, because there have always been groups, perhaps not majorities, but small ones, yet with great power that want to suppress, eliminate those who think differently. Six months after this, Hipólito Yrigoyen was overthrown, and the first military coup in history occurred, founding what would later be known until 1983 as the Military Party. This happened in 1930. I believe this is to help us reflect; you know that I really like history, and it may be a common place to say that peoples who do not know their history are condemned to repeat it, but it remains true. And I wanted to bring this up because I believe that we Argentines have the obligation to resume a path that cost Argentina a lot, it cost a lot, a lot, a lot. And also to take the example; I know that many or others do not like it when we talk about the Grandmothers or the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo, but when I was also a senator and the unconstitutionality or annulment of the laws of Obedience Due and Full Stop was declared, I asked myself that time because the truth is I was sitting in the bench and I said, "I don’t know if they would have kidnapped a child of mine or tortured and killed me, if they would have stolen a grandchild from me, if I would have only been claiming justice and the application of the law as they did," because the truth is that this is the issue; when someone commits a crime, they cannot be killed, kidnapped, tortured, or anything, the law must be applied, and we all must have that civic example as Argentines. The other day when what happened occurred, it was the militants who apprehended the one who had tried to kill me, the militants, it was not the police, it was the militants who detained him. Not only did they detain him, they prevented him from trying to aim the weapon again after the first shot failed. And they did not take justice into their own hands, nor did they lynch him, nor anything. They did what democratic, Christian citizens should do. They handed him over to the police, to the law. And the truth is that I do not believe we need to sanction any special law; honestly, I do not believe that rebuilding what cost us so much to achieve since 1983 requires the sanction of any law. The ones that are already in force are enough and more than enough, they are enough and more than enough. What we need to put in place is a lot of institutionalism, a lot of democratic and civic respect to rebuild, because if we do not do that, do you think it is possible to rebuild the economy of the country? Or what is necessary for the people who cannot make ends meet? For those who have it! For those who have it, or who cannot pay the rent of the house, for those who can still pay rent. Or what Toto raised, which is one of the passions that our friend, Juan Grabois, has regarding land, right? The place to live. Those houses where you see that the family builds in front on the same land and there is no more room, so everything gets complicated. Can all this be done in a climate...? Can a country be rebuilt and the economy be rebuilt in a country where only insults and grievances are exchanged? Look, if the economy has problems, we need to discuss numbers and come to an agreement by discussing numbers. It is the easiest thing to discuss numbers; it is easy because two plus two is four, and there is no possibility that it is five or six. In anything else, politics, religion, it is what each one thinks and feels, but the great advantage that the economy gives you is that you can discuss numbers. So, I believe that when so many adjectives, so many insults, and so many grievances are used, it is because there is no desire to seriously discuss the economy. Because, well, there was a moment, the sister just recalled it, and it did not mean that it was Disneyland, nor paradise when I lived, when Néstor governed, or when I had the chance to be president, but there was work, there was hope, there was expectation, and I believe that is what we need to rebuild together, and do it with the attitude of talking to everyone, to those we like and to those we do not like, as Christ did, ultimately. I got a little mystical now. Yes, yes, let’s agree that I have reasons to be so, I have reasons to be so. And that is why I wanted to be with you today, because you are by the side of those who suffer the most, you are always bringing the word of God and of the Virgin and of the Gospel. It’s a pity that José was absent because he is my great consultant on the Gospel; we have José Mayans, a senator, he is a practicing and militant Catholic, seriously. No, no, seriously, I admire him and I care a lot for José. And I wanted to be with you because it seems to me that being with you brings me a little closer to God and the Virgin too. So thank you for coming, and I copied something from Francisco; now I say, "please, pray a lot, a lot for me," but pray a lot because I need it. Thank you, thank you very much.