A new global financial order is essential.

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

16 July 2014 · BRICS leaders' meeting

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed BRICS and UNASUR leaders at a South American summit in July 2014, urging global financial reform amid Argentina's vulture fund crisis.
Main themes
Global financial order reform, vulture funds and sovereign debt, BRICS development bank, Argentina debt restructuring, peace and sustainable growth, multilateral institution reform, Israel-Palestine ceasefire, South American regional cooperation, international financial speculation
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,846
73rd percentile
Sentences
80
52nd percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
16.1
84th percentile
Syntax
3.62
97th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 75%66%
  • Geopolitical 13%11%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 11%

80 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Good morning to all the leaders of BRICS who are visiting our region, some of whom we have already met, such as the President of the Russian Federation, Doctor Vladimir Putin, who visited our country on an official State visit this past Saturday, and we expect, this Friday, the President of the People's Republic of China, Xi Jinping. Thank you all for joining us here in South America; to the other Heads of State, old friends with whom we have shared hard and difficult moments in UNASUR, and as President Dilma Rousseff just pointed out, we have resolved, peacefully and without conflict of any nature or kind, conflicts that reached critical moments; truly a flagrant contrast to what is happening at this moment in other regions of the world, such as the Middle East, where I cannot help but express my wishes – as President of the Argentine Republic and fundamentally as a global citizen – for a ceasefire in what is happening today between the State of Israel and the State of Palestine.

We believe it is important to make a statement in this regard, because it is our duty – as citizens of the world – when we talk about the need for sustainable growth. There is no sustainable growth without peace and security, and there is no sustainable growth without a fundamentally different global economic-financial organization or order than the one we have today.

That is why we warmly welcome this decision by the BRICS to establish a development bank, a bank that focuses on commerce, infrastructure, and also, why not, to bring order to absolutely chaotic international finances. Many times we have called for this in this forum or in broader ones, such as the United Nations, in the G-20 as well, the essential reform of multilateral credit organizations and also of political multilateral organizations, such as the United Nations or the Security Council, etc. But really, these demands, these claims have not been heard, and I believe it is a very positive sign; no one can interpret this attitude of the BRICS as a matter of negativity, but rather as an alternative construction in the face of the lack of responses that all the citizens of the world should have already received.

And perhaps Argentina more than anyone can speak on this issue at a time when it is suffering a severe speculative attack from so-called vulture funds. As you all know, Argentina defaulted on its sovereign debt in 2001; it was not during our administration, it was not during our government, but obviously the legal continuity of States imposes the responsibility to take charge. And Argentina, during President Kirchner's administration, in 2005, restructured part of its external debt, and then, during my administration, in 2010, reached a restructuring of 92.4 percent of the total bondholders of Argentine debt. This has meant that since 2005 to date, we have paid more than 190 billion dollars, not only to bondholders but also to multilateral credit organizations, such as the Inter-American Development Bank and the World Bank, which should also be development banks and which today, unfortunately, are failing to fulfill this role of development banks, and we have the novelty that development banks are governed by risk rating agencies, as if they were commercial banks or investment banks. That is why we believe that this decision to create a development bank by the BRICS is a more than adequate response.

Now, the debt remains with a very small group that did not accept to enter any of the exchanges, neither the one in 2005 nor the one in 2010. They have filed more than 900 lawsuits, litigated around the world, and even managed to seize our flagship vessel: the Frigate Libertad, in the State of Ghana, on the African coast, in an unprecedented and unusual act violating all norms regarding international law, obviously what pertains to the Convention of the Sea. Of course, after two months and an intense trial, we recovered our frigate.

What have they done now, in the face of an unusual and unprecedented jurisprudence from the state of New York, given the impossibility of continuing to seize or litigate? They have seized what does not belong to them, they have seized what is the property of the 92.4 percent of bondholders who entered the debt exchange, of the resources that Argentina deposited and did so once again, in a timely manner, on June 30, when the bonds were due, one of the series of discount bonds, for more than 900 million dollars, in the account of the Bank of New York, which belongs to the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic. There are the funds, and there have been disparate provisions regarding what to do with them. They do not know exactly what to do with them. For example, some bonds with Argentine legislation were paid; CITIBANK, which did not want to pay the bonds, appeared before the judge, and CITIBANK was authorized to pay the bonds; the Bank of New York was not; Euroclear neither; Eurobank neither, that is, not even a minimum, regular, legal behavior of equality.

We are talking about absolutely unusual and unprecedented interpretations of clauses, such as pari passu, which they have interpreted as meaning that those who never negotiated, those who never entered the exchange, must be paid the same as those who did. And what is worse, those who never lent to Argentina.

They never lent money to the Argentine Republic; they bought it for cents, 48 million dollars, and Judge Griesa's ruling recognizes, between 2008 and 2014, a return in dollars of 1,680 percent. We are talking about sustainable development, we are talking about investments to generate work and employment, we are talking about investments to generate trade; what example is there in the world that someone who puts 48 million dollars only through a lawsuit obtains a return of 1,680 percent in just 6 years? Vulture funds, which also have their domicile in tax havens and which also have special communication forces, such as the American Task Force, and I want to refer specifically to it. American Task Force – remember this name – is a group of lobbyists that influences American politicians, publishing defamatory and slanderous ads against Argentina, and yesterday, I also want to read, on their website, American Task Force published a very curious article that caught our attention, because in one part, and I will read it verbatim so as not to make a mistake, it says: “a financial ticking time bomb is ticking.” And it refers to a very fundamental issue that has also been addressed here: natural resources.

You know that Argentina has the second largest shale gas reserve in the world and the fourth largest shale oil reserve in the world, which will make us approximately self-sufficient by the year 2017 or 2018, and perhaps even capable of exporting energy.

What was published on the American Task Force website? It says that instead of finding a solution for the agreement and for future investments, Argentina has been revolving around the option of default. This comes from an administration that is guided by ideology; it prefers to continue importing fuel forever or perhaps mortgage Vaca Muerta to China and Russia.

Yes, gentlemen, it refers offensively to two very important members of the world, two very important actors who are members of the G-20 who are sitting here today, such as Russia and China.

And it also alludes to the investment that another important American company, Chevron, currently has in Vaca Muerta, which has invested 3 billion dollars and threatens that if a deal is not made as they want, Chevron will withdraw from Argentina.

So, one wonders, as a neighboring president of the Oriental Republic of Uruguay said, and as another important president across the seas also told me. Do you really believe that the problem is legal, that the problem is for 1.5 billion or 10 billion dollars? Or is what is really intended to bring down the restructuring of Argentina's external debt – I repeat – of which we have already paid 190 billion dollars?

If the restructuring of Argentina's debt were to fall, if this were to happen, if we pay more to those who were left out of both exchanges, in this case the vulture funds, because obviously there is a good faith clause, those who were left out of the exchange cannot receive more than those who voluntarily accepted the exchange; these are globally accepted rules. It is impossible to restructure sovereign debt in any other way; this applies, even, in the internal legislation of each country, when a bankruptcy occurs, the legislation requires a minimum or maximum percentage of creditors, 66 percent, for that agreement to be mandatory for the others.

So, the truth is that the question one raises when explicit mention is made, precisely to two countries whose presidents have visited, one, on Saturday, a significant delegation went to Vaca Muerta, when another very important global actor, such as the People's Republic of China, is also going to visit, when it is threatened that Chevron's investments will be withdrawn.

Today they publish an ad in all the newspapers in the world and also in our country, promising that if we pay the vulture funds, the rain of dollars will fall in the Argentine Republic. And I have heard this story, gentlemen, not as President, I heard it as a deputy of my country, as an opposition deputy sitting in my seat in 2001, when we were told by the International Monetary Fund that with the mega-exchange and the shielding, where they made us an accounting entry, that they lent us 40 billion dollars and increased the debt by 55 billion dollars more, we finally ended up in default, in misery, with a lack of work for millions of Argentines.

I have already heard this story, and millions of Argentines have heard it and suffered it, which is much worse.

So, we are facing a situation that goes beyond even global financial issues. We are asking ourselves if we are not facing a geopolitical issue, if we are not facing issues of domination or not understanding that there is a different multipolar world than the one that existed in 1989, where some believed that history had ended. And history does not end; history continues because the peoples continue. And the emerging countries here in South America, and the emerging countries in other regions, have been able to emerge from their situations and incorporate millions of compatriots into health, education, housing, and basic rights.

Well, that is why they come. They come again to want to impose an over-indebtedness on a very rich Argentina, an Argentina that, in addition to being the eighth largest country in territory in the world, has only 40 million inhabitants, which, having the second largest gas reserve and the fourth largest oil reserve, and also being one of the most important producers of food worldwide, makes it a very coveted prey for all.

That is why it is also important to clarify that Argentina, despite the threats, despite what is today considered practically blackmail by these sectors, has paid its debt. On June 30, we deposited more than 900 million dollars in the Bank of New York, in the account of the Central Bank. And Argentina will continue to pay, because default is not paying, and only a country that does not pay can declare default or cessation of payments, as has happened on numerous occasions and as also happened in the Argentine Republic.

Argentina will continue to fulfill its obligations because it is a solvent country to do so and because it is convinced that it must honor its debts with 100 percent of creditors, but in a fair, equitable, and legal manner.

And why does this situation occur? Because they know that it is impossible to fulfill what they intend because one of the clauses, this is very important to emphasize for all attendees, one of the clauses printed on the debt titles that passed through the control and observation of the SEC in the North American Stock Exchange includes the so-called RUFO Clause. The clause that establishes that those who did not enter the 2005 or 2010 exchange cannot be paid more than what has been paid to those who already entered.

What do we say then? We offer these holdouts to enter the exchange because the exchange is open; they would earn a return in dollars of approximately 300 percent over 6 years. It is not that we are saying that we will not pay them anything; we will pay them under the fair, equitable, and legal conditions established by the Argentine nation's debt prospectuses and also the peaceful jurisprudence that exists at the international level.

It is good to remember that in Europe, by real law of Belgium and also European legislation, specific legislation was enacted that, precisely, protected the sovereign restructuring of debts from this same vulture fund that acted against Peru.

We are stating that Argentina will not go into default because Argentina will pay its debt as it has already done. Those who prevent the legitimate holders of those funds from receiving them must take responsibility, as Argentina is no longer the owner of those resources once it deposits them, and those resources are the legitimate and legal property of the bondholders from the years 2005 and 2010. Therefore, we will continue to pay, and banking institutions and those who must do so must take responsibility towards those bondholders if they are not allowed to receive their payments.

But also, I want to emphasize once again that one bank has indeed been authorized to pay bonds while others have not. The bank that was authorized, of course, is the American-origin bank; those that still have the funds blocked are Eurobank and Euroclear, which, as you know, is the European Union.

This reveals the absurd, unprecedented, and confusing nature of the entire situation we are experiencing. Not for us; we are not confused at all, on the contrary, since we are not confused, we did precisely what we had to do: on the 30th, we paid, because perhaps what they intended was for us not to pay, and then indeed, to fall into default for not having deposited, having the resources to do so and the open account at the Bank of New York in the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic for the amounts we owed.

That is why Argentina will not default on its debt; Argentina pays, and what we demand from multilateral organizations, what we demand from the world is precisely the establishment of a global financial order that allows for sustainable and global growth.

And we congratulate the initiative of the BRICS, because we must also say that the World Bank and now the Inter-American Development Bank, of which we are also net payers. What does this mean? That we are paying more than we receive in terms of loans.

Thus, ladies and gentlemen, Argentina, no matter how much they defame us or try to install the idea that we do not want to negotiate… How could we not negotiate! We have gone to New York twice. The only ones who do not want to negotiate are the vulture funds, who want to be paid 48 million dollars, 1.6 billion dollars in just 6 years.

We are always willing to negotiate, within the law, within justice, within equity, and that is why we invite them to enter the exchange.

And we call on all countries that have a fundamental commitment to our peoples and our histories to generate well-being, countries that for a long time faced severe difficulties, some due to indebtedness, others as a consequence of their own historical events, who had the strength to overcome that indebtedness, historical events, lack of democracy, as we experienced in the South American region, and in democracy and in peace, we have been able to guarantee growth with social inclusion, not just economic growth.

During the 1990s, during the height of neoliberalism, when Argentina was presented as a model student at the International Monetary Fund, where its president was invited to speak at assemblies, unemployment reached over 20 percent. There were growth rates, yes, but growth without people, speculative growth, which came to place, thanks to the fiction of the 1 to 1 parity, dollars with rates that, while the world was paying 2 percent, in Argentina it reached up to 14 and 15 percent annual rates in dollars.

This is also one of the origins of that indebtedness that culminated in the default of 2001, beyond all the indebtedness that also occurred starting from the dictatorship of March 24, 1976.

That is why the call to all countries is to join efforts in this true crusade for a new global organization in political, economic, and financial matters that has positive social, political, and cultural consequences for our peoples.

Thank you very much.