Bilateral press conference of Emmanuel Macron and Stefan Löfven, Prime Minister of Sweden.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

17 November 2017 · Social Summit and informal meeting of heads of state and government on education and culture · Volvo, Gothenburg, Sweden

Context
Macron addressed a bilateral press conference with Swedish PM Stefan Löfven in Gothenburg on November 17, 2017, following the EU Social Summit.
Main themes
European Pillar of Social Rights, social Europe, posted workers directive, wage convergence, bilateral social agreements, European social standards, skills transformation, European labor regulation, Franco-Swedish cooperation, European Commission initiatives
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,533
68th percentile
Sentences
79
52nd percentile
Readability
33
21st percentile
Grade
16.6
87th percentile
Syntax
3.42
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 51%49%
  • Economic 23%23%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

79 sentences in 41 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT: Before a bilateral session in a few moments, we will meet with the Swedish Prime Minister and go to Volvo, then we will sign a partnership for innovation and an agreement for common social action.

I wanted to report to you on the summit that took place today in Gothenburg on social issues, followed by the informal meeting of heads of state and government on education and culture.

We have come here to Gothenburg to talk primarily about social Europe. This was an initiative led by the Swedish Prime Minister and the President of the European Commission, which resulted in the signing of an important document that constitutes one of the foundations of our unity, which is precisely this pillar of social rights for our Europe. It is the result of several months of work that has allowed us to define one of the important pillars on which I have had the opportunity to speak.

This morning, we had multiple discussions based on the texts prepared by the Commission and all the different member states, which allowed us to make concrete progress.

This work, for me, is part of a process that was initiated several months ago and that allows us to move forward in a proactive and concrete manner on this social Europe. We first revised the framework regarding the posting of workers to make it more protective and fair for all European workers. In this regard, the fact that the revision of this directive gathered a very large majority in the Council on October 23 – and the minister did not spare her efforts, for which I thank her – was an important signal.

While for several years it was considered impossible to revisit the framework of the posted workers directive, we have succeeded in obtaining this agreement. It is now essential that the trilogue can quickly reach the necessary agreements to implement this first agreement found, but above all that we implement everything related to bilateral or intergovernmental cooperation.

We have already signed eight bilateral agreements, including agreements with Poland and Romania to increase and strengthen mutual controls to combat illegal posted work. Therefore, beyond what was signed on October 23, which is a fundamental step, we continue to make very concrete progress.

This morning, I discussed in a bilateral meeting with the Dutch Prime Minister, who expressed his agreement to sign the ninth bilateral text to strengthen our control mechanisms. The text of the directive will allow for the creation of a European authority that will further strengthen these controls.

But this is an extremely important point. Therefore, I set myself the objective that in the coming months, we finalize the signatures of bilateral agreements to strengthen control and combat illegal posted work, which will complement this agreement, and that in 2018, we can finalize the additional texts as quickly as possible and complete the European authority that the Commission is also advocating.

Today, we marked a second important step for this social Europe, which is the proclamation of the European Pillar of Social Rights. It is a symbol, but it is also very concrete legislative initiatives to recognize and strengthen social rights throughout the European Union – for example, the rights of caregivers – and these are several important principles that are precisely shared by all member states.

As I mentioned at the Sorbonne, the central challenge is that of social convergence and that of transforming skills, and I spoke this morning on these two important subjects. Regarding convergence, we must indeed establish common standards. This pillar is beginning to do so, but we must go further, particularly in defining a minimum wage whose level and evolution would be adapted to the economic reality of each country.

This is not about defining a unique minimum wage that is monetarily the same for all European countries, but about placing all European countries in a process that allows us to move in this direction. Each country has its tradition: there are countries for which the establishment of a legal minimum wage makes no sense, particularly the country we are in, which, despite having very high social standards, has always functioned through collective negotiation, which has proven to be more effective than law.

So it is not about standardizing or over-standardizing all of this, but about placing all European countries in the convergence of such reflection and such work, and my wish is that we can, within a horizon of 10 years, define a process of convergence, as we have done in the past on monetary and economic issues.

Currently, 22 of the 28 countries in the Union have a minimum wage, but in 10 countries, this wage does not reach 50% of the median wage. Therefore, the current situation is not satisfactory from a social point of view, and we must not be mistaken about it. That is why this issue of convergence is of particular importance to me, and it must permeate all our reflections.

That is why I wish that during the upcoming financial discussions, we can integrate social convergence criteria into our reflections, particularly regarding cohesion aid that we have with the different countries. Today, the cohesion fund or the various instruments of the European Union are sometimes used to continue to support models of tax or social optimization, which is not at all the spirit of the European Union.

I would like to remind you of Jacques DELORS' beautiful phrase that Europe was built on competition that stimulates, cooperation that strengthens, and solidarity that unites, and we sometimes forget the second and third pillars of this adventure.

In the same way – I emphasized this point this morning – this social convergence, this common requirement must permeate our work on industrial or trade policy, and we must integrate these criteria into the fight against dumping in the face of certain other powers or in the negotiation of trade treaties.

Regarding skills, we know that within 10 years, one in two jobs will be transformed. There are still 15 million dropouts in Europe and 70 million Europeans who do not have basic skills. In France, there are 1.3 million dropouts, and there are between 1.5 and 2 million French men and women who do not have basic skills. This situation makes a genuine public investment in human capital indispensable, that is, in the women and men of our country so that they can find their place. And this is the essential complement to a competitiveness policy and labor market transformation that the government is currently conducting.

For France, this is at the heart of the reforms that the government is undertaking, particularly the minister's efforts to reform apprenticeship and vocational training, but also which will lead during the five-year term to invest 15 billion euros, on the one hand, in the Youth Guarantee and its multiplication for dropouts, and on the other hand, primarily for all workers and unemployed individuals who need retraining and to regain essential skills to find a place in the labor market given the profound changes it is experiencing.

We are conducting this French work. It requires fundamental reforms and deep investment, but it also requires being relayed at the European level – this is what we discussed this morning – through concrete initiatives that must be reflected in our financial perspectives.

ERASMUS and ERASMUS Apprenticeship are essential instruments to combat dropout rates and build an indispensable foundation. I will return to this shortly regarding culture. In this regard, I mentioned this morning that nearly one in two young people who apply to the ERASMUS program receive a negative response due to a lack of resources allocated to this policy.

I fully support the doubling of resources proposed by the President of the European Commission, Jean-Claude JUNCKER. I believe this is a very good initiative, and we will defend it coherently during the discussion on financial perspectives. This investment is essential if we also want to truly build an ERASMUS for Apprenticeship that corresponds to the ambition I just mentioned.

I also wish that we could simplify the instruments we have today, which are the indispensable complements to the economic transitions that Europe is experiencing, and in particular, that we have these training criteria integrated into the functioning of the European Social Fund, which is one of the main instruments to finance these transitions, that the JUNCKER Plan, which is currently largely mobilized for capital infrastructure investments, could be partially oriented in its second generation towards investment in human capital and training, and that the European Globalization Adjustment Fund be reviewed upwards and simplified in its criteria.

Today, there is a restructuring threshold of 500 employees that deserves to be lowered and that fits completely into the logic of territorial contracts and the transition contracts that we want to implement in French territory.

Lunch was then devoted to an informal discussion among heads of state and government on cultural and educational issues. The Commission has done a great deal of work on this subject in line with the exchanges we had and the speeches of Jean-Claude JUNCKER as well as the one I delivered at the Sorbonne. We have taken up the agenda that I presented in September in this regard, and several convergences have emerged on important subjects.

First, the need to move towards a simplification of secondary education in Europe, not to make it more homogeneous, but to allow for more exchanges and transitions between European educational systems. Indeed, it is very difficult in middle and high school, at least the equivalent of these French cycles in the rest of Europe, to have exchanges. This, on the one hand, hinders the mobility of workers, and on the other hand, hinders exchanges for younger people between European countries.

I therefore wished to launch the equivalent of the Bologna process, at least for high schools. This Sorbonne process, to use the terminology employed by the European Commission, will therefore be the subject of work and allow all member states that wish to engage in a process of convergence, at least of correspondence in our secondary education.

Next, we expressed this desire, and I believe everyone agreed on the idea of establishing in our educational systems the provisions that will allow each student to speak at least two European languages by 2024. We then had a long discussion on the development of European universities, as I had proposed, allowing for the creation of several European universities by 2024. I had proposed that we have 20 European universities by 2024, which would allow for real integrated curricula between several European university sites.

On this subject, I propose that we move forward pragmatically and that all member states wishing to advance on this subject can consult and, within the framework of an initiative whose legal terms and political framework we will define in December, we can, over the next two years, concretely establish a few universities at the European level.

There are already cross-curricular paths between several universities, structured exchange systems; this is an additional step we need to take, but it will be the condition, first, for building a true European culture of higher education, for real exchanges of teachers and students, and, on the other hand, it will increase the attractiveness of our universities in international competition and have real competitive and attractive poles and institutions on a global scale.

We have obviously revisited the importance of ERASMUS issues that I just mentioned, and I was able to reiterate our willingness, within the framework of financial perspectives, to support the initiatives of the Commission.

Regarding cultural issues, I emphasized the importance of this subject for defining one of the foundations of what unites Europe and the clear desire of France to define European cultural content as the very foundation of our common identity.

All Europeans, if there is one thing that unites them, it is having learned as children, having been moved by reading the adventures of Don Quixote or having encountered in our reciprocal cultures the great heroes of our literatures, our operas, our music. And thus, culture is indeed a foundation that transcends the political adventures we are currently undertaking. However, today, this European culture is at risk, and I believe we are greatly mistaken to consider that the debate on copyright is merely an anecdotal or defensive debate concerning the old economy. This is a profound error.

I have drawn a simple analogy: when we talk about oil or gas, we assign value to oil and gas and consider the pipelines as accessories. And we are indeed willing to pay very dearly for oil and gas to powers that are sometimes not friendly because we need them.

And when it comes to content, we decide to value only the pipes that are either Anglo-Saxon or Chinese properties, but we no longer value the content, and we are allowing ourselves to be influenced by an international doxa that is not ours, which would suggest that content no longer matters.

If the result is, in 50 to 60 years, to homogenize imaginations at a global level and, for our children, to have emotions or cultural references that are no longer European, but are either Chinese or American, we will have lost everything. And so, it is essential for all these reasons, because it is the very defense of our identity, of what makes us, in terms of political and cultural imagination, as well as in terms of our economic interests, it is essential to reaffirm the importance of the battle for copyright, and I hope that we will be infinitely more proactive, infinitely more offensive in defining a collective strategy on copyright, whether it concerns digital or otherwise.

Intellectual property makes sense in that it recognizes the share of creators, regardless of the arts, of those who create knowledge or transform it, of translators, journalists, of those who add value to content and who do simply something other than propagate the circulation of interchangeable information or symbols.

In the same way, I have defended the idea of the Heritage Forum that I proposed at the Pnyx in Athens, indicating that on this subject too, we must have a much stronger European strategy for enhancing our heritages.

Finally, I have supported the Italian ideas of a European student card, which seems to me extremely structuring in terms of the circulation of students in Europe, as well as the idea supported by Italy and Greece of enhancing our heritage through adapted economic mechanisms.

That summarizes the discussions we had this noon. All of these discussions will lead to concrete translations, on the one hand, in the conclusions of the December summit, but on the other hand, in rapid concrete actions that we intend to launch.

You have understood, the objective of the day, beyond the upcoming bilateral sequence, was to talk about what I called the Europe that unites in the Sorbonne speech, which is the second pillar of our European initiative, and to advance both on a dialogue that allows us to bring about common positions, but also on concrete actions essential to collective credibility. I will now answer all your questions.