Brief statement from the President following his visit to Argentina.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

17 November 2024

Context
Macron addressed journalists following a working visit to Argentina ahead of the G20 summit in Brazil, discussing bilateral deals and France's opposition to the EU-Mercosur agreement.
Main themes
EU-Mercosur trade agreement opposition, French agricultural interests, food sovereignty, bilateral France-Argentina relations, critical minerals and lithium, energy transition, defense contracts, French industry promotion, European trade policy, CETA comparison
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,220
78th percentile
Sentences
210
90th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
8.9
10th percentile
Syntax
2.69
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 43%42%
  • Economic 28%27%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

210 sentences in 77 paragraphs

Mr. President, we imagine that you spoke with President MILEI about Mercosur. Farmers are starting to protest in France. Can you guarantee them that you will be in a position not to finalize this agreement that worries them?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you first for being here.

Indeed, I made this working visit before the G20, which will be held in Brazil, to stop here and, for several hours, have in-depth exchanges with President MILEI and several of his ministers. One of the objectives is obviously to defend our economic interests.

Initially, I came here to defend several important contracts that also help support Argentina in its development, but also to defend our interests in critical metals, for lithium extraction, Eramet has important investment contracts. And this is important for us because, as you know, lithium is one of the resources we need to produce electric batteries and several key elements of the energy transition over the long term.

Then, we have several companies that have recently confirmed investments. And then, in terms of defense, we have contracts that are progressing, particularly the high patrol boats. We discussed several other contracts that will be finalized. I wanted to defend French industry, French interests during this fruitful visit, particularly in terms of extraction, energy transition, and defense.

I also told the Argentine President very sincerely and clearly that France, today, would not sign this Mercosur treaty in its current state. I have been saying this for several years, and it has been repeated by the Government as well as by all previous governments. And this firmness we have is simple; we do not believe in the pre-agreement as it has been negotiated. First, because it comes from very far away, and second, because it does not take into account all the developments we have made ourselves in our own markets. And as I told him, for Argentina, it would be very bad for its reindustrialization, and for us, it would be very bad for our agriculture. I will be straightforward; we cannot ask our farmers in Europe, French farmers, but this is true for all European farmers, to change their practices, to do without certain phytosanitary products, to have, which is our pride, an agriculture of high quality, and at the same time open our market to massive imports of products that would not meet the same criteria. This is exactly what we defended several years ago when we finalized a negotiation with Canada and put in place measures that prevented the entry of beef when it used certain products, particularly hormones or antibiotics. It worked, which means that the agreement that is already applied with Canada is very favorable to our agriculture.

We do not have these guarantees today with Mercosur. And so yes, France opposes this agreement. And I will tell you, President MILEI himself told me that he was not satisfied with this agreement and that he was not satisfied with the current functioning of Mercosur, which is one of the points on which we converged. I believe that I leave these discussions with the conviction that we are not there. And so I want to reassure our farmers here.

Journalist

But you say "we will not sign," but the problem is that Europe is capable of signing without France.

Emmanuel MACRON

Well, I first have Argentina saying that it is not happy with the agreement itself.

Journalist

Perhaps for opposing reasons.

Emmanuel MACRON

For opposing reasons, which shows you that we are not at an agreement. If each side is asking for more, it shows that we are not at an agreement.

Then, I will be very clear, the position that France has occupied for several years has allowed, all these years, for seven years I have opposed this treaty. And I speak to our farmers eye to eye.

Since I have been President, have I not kept my commitments? Never. When we signed with Canada, we obtained guarantees. And I told you that this agreement would be good for you. Five years after the provisional application of the agreement with Canada, it is good for French agriculture, contrary to what all the lies circulating may say, that is to say, we export more milk, more cheese to Canada and many other agricultural products, and that what was described to us as the invasion of meat that did not meet the same criteria upon arrival did not happen, because we had put in place guarantees. And here, I tell you, these guarantees are not there today with Mercosur. That is why we will continue to oppose.

First, I note that there are several countries within Mercosur that are not satisfied with this agreement. And then, there are several other European countries that are not satisfied. So, we will continue to work firmly to defend our model. And why? Because I am consistent. When I spoke to the French people in the spring of 2020, in the midst of COVID, saying "we would be crazy to delegate our food supply to others, and food sovereignty makes sense." That is to say, we want to be able to produce, in Europe and particularly in France, what is important for us, our food. This is true today. And so, I do not want us to give up our food sovereignty. And French and European agriculture is not a factor of adjustment to bad agreements.

Journalist

Mr. President, you say that France is against it, but it is alone; this is not the case for other countries in Europe.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, not at all. We should not be alone, you are right. We should not be alone; we need this work of persuasion, but we must also avoid caricatures. Here, we consider that Mercosur in its current state is a bad agreement; we oppose it.

After that, trade in general is good for French agriculture. I remind you at the same time that France has a trade deficit, which we are trying to improve through all the reforms we have made over the past seven years to be more competitive, to reindustrialize. This deficit is negatively due to the fact that we are very dependent on our energy.

That is why we are making this transition for me, importing hydrocarbons that we do not produce ourselves. But we have two or three major sectors where we are good at exporting: aeronautics, luxury, and agri-food. We must never forget that.

So our French agriculture should not also have the image of itself or that we should have the image that it should be closed. It must be open. And so, it is normal that we import products that we do not produce ourselves because we also want to export. And our wheat producers, our grape producers, and behind them our winemakers are very happy to have export markets, which are sometimes essential for their outlets. So we are for an open agriculture, but for trade agreements that are fair. What is very important to understand is that we defend international trade; we defend the French agricultural model, which is of very high quality and is undergoing its transition with a lot of effort, which we defend in openness, but we want for our producers that the rules are fair, that there is fair competition.

When we ask, well, that we do without certain phytosanitary products, that we respect rules, which is an effort we ask of our producers, we ask the same of those who come to import into our market. It is fair and it is common sense.

Journalist

Do you think that Europe could trample on the voice of France, which is a founding country?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, I do not believe so.

I do not believe so. And I recognize to President VON DER LEYEN a great respect for the word of France, for our position. We, I just say, here is what we want, is that there are fair rules. They are not fair in the agreement as it stands. And so we will continue to work with everyone. I think that the right framework with this region, which is very important strategically for us, Argentina, Chile, with which we have made an agreement that is fair, that is why we supported it. But Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay, Bolivia, all the countries that make up Mercosur, what do we need to do?

To have an agreement that defines a good investment framework, that opens certain areas where we have interests, that allows for partnerships on critical materials. But it must not sacrifice European agriculture. That is what we are saying. If we are all reasonable, there is a possible path. But it will not be at the expense of our farmers.

After that, you know, the difficulties that our farmers are experiencing today have nothing to do with Mercosur, since it is not even signed. They are related to difficulties sector by sector that are linked to epizootics. On this, the Government supports, as all previous governments have, farmers so that they are compensated, so that we can vaccinate each time.

Finally, I apologize, this anger is explained by very poor harvests. Also a consequence of climatic regulations and a model in certain regions that needs to be reviewed. A regulation that is too burdensome, that is why a whole plan was made at the beginning of the year by the Government of Mr. ATTAL, which has been rolled out and implemented throughout the year and which, by the way, continues to be implemented by the Government of Mr. BARNIER. All commitments by successive Governments have been kept, and I salute their commitment. And it allows us to simplify the lives of our farmers.

What do they want? That we help them face epizootics, that we help them face the consequences of climate change, that we simplify their lives, that we maintain a strong Europe, because without Europe, we do not have an agricultural model, that we allow them to have trade and to export, to import, but that we do so while protecting them when it is inequitable. That is what we are doing with Mercosur. So, we are always there for our farmers because we believe in French food sovereignty, but today, their difficulties are not related to Mercosur either.

Journalist

Mr. President, there is a lot of speculation about a possible exit of Argentina from the Paris Agreement on climate, their negotiators left COP29 in Baku. Have you received any assurances in this regard? Were you able to convince President MILEI?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, we have agreements and disagreements; we know that. It is not a surprise. He did not confirm to me these choices to exit the Paris Agreement, but we do not have the same vision on climate with President MILEI. I explained in detail why we consider that in terms of climate and biodiversity, it is absolutely essential to move forward, to have international coordination, that the policy we are implementing within the framework of the Paris Agreement in France, well, it produces results, it allows for innovations, creates jobs, and reduces our emissions. And over the past seven years, even as we have created more than two million market jobs in France, that we have reindustrialized by creating a net more than 300 factories, well, it has allowed us to do more than quadruple the reduction of our CO2 emissions. When in 2017, we reduced our CO2 emissions by 1%, we reduced them by 4.3-4.5% in the last two years. So, we can have results, and it is not true to say that climate commitment is decreasing. So there you go, we had a debate, but we do not agree. However, France will continue to engage with Europe, with its major partners to continue on this path because it is the one our planet needs; it is the one that allows us to have harmonious development models, and it is also the debt we owe to future generations.

Journalist

So the exit of Argentina is still a risk? Because you would not have…

Emmanuel MACRON

It is obviously something that is not in France's hands, so I will not presume for others.

Journalist

On Ukraine, Mr. President, your counterpart, Mr. SCHOLZ, the German Chancellor, spoke to PUTIN last Friday. ZELENSKY said it was "opening Pandora's box." Do you share Mr. ZELENSKY's opinion, or do you think that talking to PUTIN right now could be useful?

Emmanuel MACRON

I think above all that today, Ukraine has suffered an attack that is one of the most intense since the beginning of the conflict. I obviously first have a thought for the Ukrainian people, its armies, and its leaders. And to reiterate that in this context, I believe it is clear that President PUTIN's intentions are to intensify these fights. We have seen it for several weeks.

In this context, we must keep our commitments to the Ukrainians, that is to say, allow them to conduct this war of resistance, deliver weapons, equipment, do as we have just done, and the soldiers are leaving French territory. We have trained and equipped a brigade. These are commitments I made last February in Paris. The Anne de Kiev brigade is on its way to Ukrainian soil to conduct this war of resistance and to provide the equipment that Ukraine needs to resist. And then, in terms that will be determined by the Ukrainians, respectful of international law, a lasting peace must be negotiated, that is to say, a peace that addresses territorial issues, but also guarantees the security of a Ukraine that can endure. I believe that today, if we need to know what Mr. PUTIN's intentions are, what he has just done on the ground clearly signals them. Regardless of his statements, he does not want peace and is not ready to negotiate it. I believe that our duty is truly to push Russia to cease fighting in order to negotiate peace on terms that respect international law.

Journalist

Was it necessary to speak to him?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, but you know, I am not here to comment. I think that every leader is completely free to take initiatives; it is always a good thing to take initiatives, to be able to discuss with one another, and then to coordinate. I am not here to comment on one another. We must remain united.

I want us to stay united with the British Prime Minister, the German Chancellor, all the European leaders, but also all the world leaders who are with us. We must remain united with the Ukrainians and, in this agenda, for true peace, that is to say, a peace that is not the capitulation of Ukraine. All comments that divide us are unwelcome.

Journalist

And you, do you wish to speak to Mr. PUTIN again in that perspective?

Emmanuel MACRON

I have never ruled that out; I have done it for a long time, but when the context and conditions allow it. With what is happening today, we must first equip, support, and enable Ukraine to resist. That is the key for the coming days and weeks.

Journalist

Have you discussed this with Mr. SCHOLZ then?

Emmanuel MACRON

I will see him later, so we will have the opportunity.

Journalist

For you, the contact is not broken?

Emmanuel MACRON

I will not comment on what is being done. I consider that the agenda is clear on what we must do. And then, we also need to prepare, of course, for the future. That is to say, it is absolutely essential to give visibility to the Ukrainians regarding security guarantees and support. They have asked us very clear questions. Are you ready for us to be a permanent member, an invited member of NATO? Well, invited permanently, sorry, of NATO. Are you ready for us to join NATO? What security guarantees are you ready to provide us? That is what we must work on together for today and for tomorrow.

Journalist

Will this be on the G20 agenda or not?

Emmanuel MACRON

You know, it will be discussed at the G20, just like the situation in the Middle East, and there, obviously, in Gaza, in Southern Lebanon, just like all the topics. But we know, and I say this also to remind the framework, because we tend to forget it, the G20 is the meeting of the 20 largest economies in the world that was awakened from a very long sleep at the time of the financial crisis of 2008. And so, these are countries that are there to coordinate essentially in terms of economic regulation and the major issues that affect trade and international balances. But we know that these 20 countries are not always aligned in terms of values or diplomatic agendas. And so, I think we need to move away from a kind of permanent choreography where, before each G20, we say it’s terrible, they don’t agree on Ukraine, it’s terrible, they don’t agree. We are not going to agree on Ukraine at the G20; there is Russia. It’s terrible, they don’t agree on Israel and Palestine. It’s terrible, they don’t agree on human rights, gender equality, or this or that. Yes, because, by the way, it was not designed that way. As much as the G7 is a group of democratic countries, which constitute the main economies and are therefore aligned in terms of values, the G20 is not. You have very different regimes. You have Gulf monarchies, you have China. Well, so we are not going to rediscover, we are not going to reinvent the wheel.

Journalist

Two years ago, there were discussions about Ukraine.

Emmanuel MACRON

That is absolutely true, because you have moments.

But obviously, because you have moments also when leaders change. But you know by nature that these countries, the language that was used two years ago, you considered it did not go far enough on Ukraine. And it went much less far than what we were doing in the G7 or in Europe, obviously. And so, the work of our teams is to, as we say, preserve the language, that is to say, to ensure that at least what has been defined as agreements remains. But that is not the primary objective of the G20. The objective is to have this coordination on these issues. And then, it is an opportunity to discuss other topics. And that is why we must accept to discuss, sometimes to share disagreements. And that is the usefulness of these forums, because when we discuss, including these disagreements, we avoid exacerbating them and we avoid heading towards, precisely, an escalation. Just for that, it has a virtue. There you go.

And what I mean by that is that we should not see the result of these forums simply in the communiqué, but through the discussion and understanding of agreements and disagreements, there is a path. And that is indeed the very path of diplomacy. Diplomacy is talking with people with whom we do not agree, even with people with whom we are at war. Otherwise, we only talk among ourselves, and that allows us to move forward.

I will now go to Brazil. See you later. Thank you very much.