DEBATE ON PENSIONS IN RODEZ

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

3 October 2019 · Rodez, France

Context
Macron addressed citizens in Rodez on October 3, 2019, for a public debate on pension reform, opening with condolences following a fatal attack at the Paris Police Prefecture earlier that day.
Main themes
Pension reform, universal pension system, Paris Police Prefecture attack, national tragedy and mourning, public debate and citizen engagement, regional press partnership, government responsibility, police officers and public safety
Duration
~317 min
99th percentile
Words
38,080
99th percentile
Sentences
2,158
99th percentile
Readability
64
94th percentile
Grade
8.6
8th percentile
Syntax
2.74
16th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 37%36%
  • Institutional 24%23%
  • Ceremonial 19%18%
  • Economic 18%17%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

2,158 sentences in 247 paragraphs

Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. I wanted – before we start speaking – to just say a few words. First, I want to apologize because last week this debate was initially scheduled. And on the very morning of that day, President Jacques CHIRAC passed away. And I obviously had to make the decision to postpone our exchange at that moment. So I really wanted to apologize to all of you for that postponement. Some had signed up, and I know some had already started to come. We discussed it with the organizers, and I believe it was the right decision to make. I hope you all understood that. But I wanted to express my apologies for this delay. And today I come before you a bit late because, of course, this afternoon, a real tragedy occurred in our country, in Paris. And I wanted to apologize for that delay, but also to share with you what happened. This afternoon, indeed, an individual who worked at the Paris Police Prefecture killed four of his colleagues. He was then shot by a young police officer. I cannot say more today. An investigation is starting. But I immediately wanted to go to the officers who had to endure this tragedy and this shock to be by their side, to provide support along with the Prime Minister and the Minister of the Interior. And that is why I spent these two hours with them and arrived a bit late before you. Nevertheless, I considered it important to come and have this exchange. First, because I spent this time with them – as you can imagine, they are in a state of shock – they are police officers, officials from different services of the police prefecture, extraordinarily brave people. But it is one of their colleagues who shot four others. I leave you to imagine what that would do to each of us. The emergency services reacted extraordinarily – the country can be proud of that – and are therefore by their side. The government is doing its job regarding what is its responsibility, and justice has taken up the case. The preliminary investigation has begun and will clarify the facts. I cannot say more at this moment. But I felt it was important to come to you now. First out of courtesy, because you made the effort to come, and then because I felt that in this moment I had done what was useful as President of the Republic to be by their side in emotion and suffering, and that the government was doing what it had to do, and justice too, but that our country is facing great challenges, great transformations, great projects, and that tonight's debate is an important debate that will occupy our country for several months and that I had to be by your side this evening here in Rodez. What I would simply like to ask you – because I see your faces and I can tell you that I spent two hours with remarkable women and men at the Paris Police Prefecture, who every day, day and night, do everything to protect us, not just the Paris region but the whole of France – is that before we start the debate, we all stand and observe a minute of silence for them, for their families, for those who have fallen, their families and their colleagues. Thank you.

Thank you. Thank you for the debate, and I want to thank the La Dépêche group for organizing all of this.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, Mr. President of the Republic. Good evening to all. Welcome to Rodez. It is an exceptional event that we are offering you this evening, as you know, a meeting between the President of the Republic, Emmanuel MACRON, and citizens, voters, readers, subscribers of Centre Presse, La Dépêche du Midi, Midi Libre, L'Indépendant, regional newspapers belonging to the Groupe Dépêche du Midi. My name is Olivier BISCAYE, I am the editor-in-chief of Midi Libre, and I will be hosting this meeting. This evening, you are nearly 500 people who have come from all over the Occitanie region. You signed up to participate in this great debate and especially to exchange with the President of the Republic on the topic of pensions. A subject, as you know, that raises many questions and requires clarifications and pedagogy, even as the President and the government are considering a new universal pension system. To explain, to dissect, to reassure perhaps as well. That will be the principle of this evening. So the questions will come from the audience, right here, Mr. President, in this town hall of Rodez, but also from readers of 20 titles of the regional daily press that are partners in our operation. These questions will be relayed to us throughout the evening by our teams. The great debate is also being broadcast live on the websites of the regional daily press titles and on news channels. And you can obviously comment on these debates and this evening on Twitter throughout the evening, especially with the hashtag #LeGrandDébatDeRodez. Without further ado, Mr. President, a first question I wanted to ask you before taking questions from the audience: you chose Aveyron, you chose the regional daily press – I want to say the press of the territories – why this decision?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. Hello, and I will take this opportunity, perhaps, to outline some of the major objectives. I chose to have this direct debate first because I believe that the topic we are going to discuss is essential for the life of the nation today and even more so tomorrow. And it justifies being able to talk about it, to construct public decision-making a little differently, to explain and clarify misunderstandings when they exist, to hear anxieties and concerns when they are present as well, and to illuminate the decision through direct exchange. It happens that the country has gone through a difficult time with what we called the yellow vest crisis. As you know, I decided at that moment to launch this great debate that was no longer with elected officials. I sometimes made it just with citizens. And I also saw the contribution of what it could... what it could bring to each person, and to me first. To make decisions that are sometimes more constructed and better thought out. So I chose to come to Aveyron because it is a department I wanted to visit. I have been here several times before becoming President, and I am attached to it. Then, because it was a way, I would say, at the heart of our history, to talk about a subject that concerns all of France and to take a bet on a regional daily press that explains everyday problems in the most educational and factual way possible, and I would even say to ask this daily press to select readers to have this exchange without filter. So, just in a few words, I wanted to simply tell you why we are making this reform. That could be the first question. And to advocate one simple thing, which is that I do not see it as a reform. We have used this word a lot for decades in our country. Retirement, for me, is at the heart of the nation's pact. That is to say, it is how we live in society and how we protect our elders so that they can live with dignity. That is the essence of retirement, and we have historically built it, as well as the way to respond to other risks, through a solidarity that the nation has constructed for itself. And I want to first say that our French retirement system – we can be proud of it – it has a lot of strength. It is a good model. I am not one of those who say, "everything should be thrown in the trash." That is not true. It is a good model. Simply, I think it is a model that today has created injustices and is no longer suitable and has somewhat betrayed the promise, if I may say so, of the founders, and in any case, is becoming less and less adapted to the world we live in. I will try to explain why. Retirement, as I said, is a pact of the nation with itself. That is to say, it is how those who work help those who, at a certain point, we consider to be of a certain age and should stop working because they have given enough for the life of the nation, the economic life, or for others. We keep that, and it is really an absolutely key principle. It is solidarity, and solidarity between generations is an intangible aspect of the system that I want for the France of tomorrow in which I believe. It is very French. There are many countries that do not do this. There are many countries where you pay for your own retirement. This system that we call distribution, this system where, fundamentally, those who work pay for those who are retired, is our strength today, and we will keep that in the future model. We absolutely must keep it. It is a strength; it is what binds the nation and what connects generations to each other. The issue is that our demographics have evolved. We are living longer and longer. We are living longer and longer in good health, which is a very good thing, but the balance between the active population and retirees – this is what has justified, by the way, for 20 years, each time, the reforms that consisted of slightly raising the age, each time painful reforms, if I may say – the system must be designed to find its balance. Essentially, we are in a country where we are entering the labor market later and later – which is actually very good because we study longer – and where we tend to live longer and longer. So we must think about that in its balances to maintain the capacity to finance the retirement of the elderly with the money from those who work, their contributions. So we will keep that. And why do I say that the system is no longer quite suitable and that it has been somewhat perverted? After the Second World War, what our predecessors wanted was a true universal system where all those who work would finance the retirement of all those who stop working. And the system has gradually evolved in a somewhat different way. And I think we should not divide ourselves on this issue. It is a historical fact. We now have 42 retirement schemes. 42, and it is the result of our history. There have always been good justifications for creating them, but we have created specific schemes for civil servants that are not the same as for employees, for the agricultural world, and then for special categories because there were conditions of difficulty in work, etc. We should not approach this question by blaming the people who are currently in these categories for this system. It is the fruit of our history; it is that at one point we found it legitimate. Simply, we find ourselves in a situation where the system is no longer universal since you have 42 schemes, which means 42 categories. And these 42 categories have created their own imbalance, which means that it works well as long as the demographic balance exists within the category. Then, when the imbalance occurs, what do we call for each time? National solidarity. So the system is no longer transparent for anyone; it no longer holds, and it is no longer quite fair because the professions have developed. And the differences that exist between these schemes are no longer quite justified. Typically, we have cited this example several times, but it would apply to many other categories: if you are a nurse, if you are self-employed, you have a retirement scheme that is profoundly different from that of the public service. Your retirement age is not the same, and the calculation methods are not at all the same. It is not totally justified by the function itself. Sometimes you are also paid less when you are a civil servant. We need to rethink that. I will return to this in the discussion. Similarly, when you drive a bus and you are at RATP – because RATP was built like that; it is not, I would say, the fault of the RATP agents – you retire much earlier, with a better pension than if you drive a bus and you are a territorial civil servant, or a territorial agent, or an agent of a company that contracts with the city. So you see, this is what has created injustices in our system and what makes people, all of us, say each time, "it is not normal that we did the same job, and the neighbor retires at a different age, and he does not have the same calculation methods." This has created distrust in our retirement system, towards our retirement system, which makes people find it rather unfair today and that people are increasingly doubtful. The other element I wanted to emphasize is that the world we are in has changed; careers are no longer linear. We may regret it. What we are fighting against is unemployment, but I do not want a retirement system that compensates for unemployment. Unemployment must be addressed in the world of work. The same goes for precariousness. But careers are no longer the same. The idea of spending your entire life in the same company, which was, I would say, for the generation approaching retirement today, somewhat the rule, is no longer true for young people; it is no longer true. And the system as it is designed, because it is like a pipe organ, creates a lot of inequalities and misunderstandings when moving from one system to another. And fundamentally, you can have a career that goes from public to private, from one company to another. You can have a gap of several hundred euros per month in retirement. If, for example, the same bus driver I mentioned finishes his career at RATP or if he finished it with a contractor while he would have done 30 years before at RATP. Because the calculation rules at the end are no longer the same. So this creates inequalities, a lack of understanding, and great difficulty, by the way, in calculating one's own retirement when you are 25, 30, 40 years old, and sometimes even a few years from retirement when you try to go and look at the acquired rights. So this creates a lack of clarity. It is no longer adapted to life. That is why the system in which – it was the commitment I made before you, I would like us to be able to enter – is a system 1/ as I said, that remains a universal system of solidarity and distribution. That is to say, it is still the active population that pays for the retirees. I do not want a system where everyone pays for their own retirement; that creates inequalities. 2/ It is a system where you acquire retirement rights, not by quarters contributed, but by points. And the points, in a way, you buy them through contributions today. Why? Because at that moment it is much more transparent, because the rest of the quarters today is not transparent, since the rules are not the same between these schemes. So it is about unifying the same system where, regardless of your other sector of activity, each point that you contribute, that you buy, gives you the same rights when you reach retirement. What you contribute is always to pay for the retirement of the elderly. But the rights that you accumulate through this contribution are the same regardless of your sector based on the points you buy, you contribute. So it is more readable, more transparent. The key will be how we set the value of this point. That is the whole debate that must take place, the negotiation that will be established with social partners, the national debate, and we will set golden rules to fix this point. With a clear commitment that the standard of living of retirees must not be degraded: it must remain the same and continue to progress. What is proposed, by the way, by the report of Jean-Paul DELEVOYE, whose work I have been praising for two years now, is to have a rule for indexing these points that is more generous than today. He proposes to index it to salaries, whereas today it is indexed to prices. And all this has been put into the current debate. So you buy your points, which then give you the right to a pension. It is a more universal, fairer system. Then it is a system that I consider – and this is part of the principles I wanted to emphasize at the beginning of this discussion – that is also more supportive because the basis is that the minimum contribution will be set at 1,000 euros. It is currently at 970 euros, which means that anyone who contributes and will have their points will have a pension of at least 1,000 euros. We cannot have, when one has contributed their whole life, less than 1,000 euros. Because today one of the major problems we have is that we have people who have contributed, paid into the system, who have pensions that are degraded, very degraded. We will probably come to that in the discussions. And so the points system has the advantage of being more readable; we will set the minimum contribution at 1,000 euros, and then we will establish rules of solidarity that will better compensate for periods of life accidents: when you are unemployed, when you are incapacitated, when you are ill, today you are somewhat compensated, but not sufficiently. This means that when you have a fragmented career, you are a loser in the current system. In the future system, you will have fewer points than when you contribute while working. Which is normal, because it is normal that those who work acquire more points for retirement. But you will have points, which allows, by the way – all the simulations have been done and show it – to have, when you have fragmented careers, rights that are better preserved. It is a system that will also, in doing so, be more favorable to women – because today the system is unfair when you work and you are a woman; it is even more so when you are retired because we have maternity leaves that are poorly taken into account by the system; in any case, they are taken into account, and the increases occur after three children. The proposal that is made, but which is up for debate, is to do it from the first child and thus have a much clearer, more readable compensation and to have a target system that is favorable to gender equality in statuses. This is the system we are projecting, and we will return, I think, to all the questions about the modalities, how it works, etc.

How then will we make it live? I want there to be a governance that is very simple, that involves all social partners and parliamentarians, because in the end you will continue to finance the system through contributions for the majority, and for a minority through taxes, national solidarity, because maternity leave, sick leave, unemployment benefits will be financed by national solidarity. Perhaps one last point is the transition. Because I hear a lot of things. There is a lot of fear, and that is normal when you want to change a system. This system, we are not proposing to implement it overnight. That would be impossible because everyone is at a different stage in their career development and they are thinking: how am I going to manage? First, we say the system will come into effect in 2025. All those who are retired are not affected by the system. We will not catch up with them. So when you are retired, you are not impacted by the system. When you are 5 years away from retirement, you are not concerned by the system. You will continue to live under the current system. And all rights acquired by 2025, that is to say you, you have contributed, etc., all acquired rights are preserved. So the principle of trust is that what you have acquired in the current system is maintained and safeguarded. And what needs to be debated is how we build the transition. And so it starts in 2025. All those who retired before are not affected by this new system. All rights acquired by workers until 2025 are preserved among workers, and then we will look at how the transition will take place, which will essentially happen over 15 years. Because there may be systems that will transition very slowly. There may be things that we will need to smooth out. It is certain that there are also careers that we will need to modify. We will undoubtedly come back to this. For example, in the public sector, I have often mentioned teachers, nursing assistants, nurses, police officers, etc. We cannot move to the new system without changing the career paths; modes of progression and so on. Here are some of the principles I wanted to emphasize to set the stage for the debate. When you are retired, you are not concerned. When you are a few years away from retirement, you are not concerned. And that is roughly where we are heading. And I believe that this system, what we want to do with it, is first and foremost to build it collectively through this debate. To be able to adjust things to address anxieties, questions, concerns: to do it at the right pace. But it is also about rediscovering the original promise of 1945. That is to say, the promise of a true universal system where workers pay for retirees and no longer have a distinction, if I may say so, between different categories. A few final words. This system will take into account the different working conditions you may have. I do not particularly like the concept of hardship because it gives the impression that work is inherently difficult. But there are working conditions that are not the same. There are risks at work that are not the same. When you work at night, it is not the same. When you are exposed to chemical risks, when you are exposed to activities that cause musculoskeletal disorders, it is normal that we have, in a way, bonuses, that we can retire early. But that will be done on a case-by-case basis. And that is part of the discussion. It has been worked on by the minister with all the social partners, but it will be less about status by status. Here are some of the points I wanted to clarify before we exchange views. You can see it clearly, it is really a societal project. That is to say, we will do it at the right pace. This is not a reform that will come into effect in two months. It is a societal project whose ultimate goal is also to collectively rethink work. And I think we will come back to that because the key when we think about retirement is to think about work and how we organize work in our society. That is the challenge for me. Now I am here to answer all your questions, but I just wanted to lay out these few points of principle.

Thank you, Mr. President. One question before the questions from the audience. You have often spoken about co-construction. You talk about citizen consultation, about dialogue. Does this mean that in the coming weeks, the feedback from citizens could lead you to evolve your orientations and your direction?

Yes! So, I will be very clear. First of all, there has been work done over 18 months by Jean-Paul Delevoye as High Commissioner, which involved meeting all the social partners, the different professions, and which led to a report presented in July that, based on what I had committed to, made proposals and really dissected the issue. But this is a subject that affects everyone. So it cannot just be what we have drawn together in the hands of people who have technical mastery. So for me, we are entering a double phase. There will be work that the Prime Minister has launched with several major projects being worked on with the unions, employer organizations, and various professions to get into the technical details with the High Commissioner and the different ministers and discuss some key points. How do we construct the financial balance in 2025? How do we build the value of the point? The governance system? I could go back to each of these points. But there is this work being done. And I wanted us to have a great public debate because what comes from our fellow citizens must be able to inform the decision. And so, very clearly, what I feel – I have started to read to you, I have also seen concerns and others – is that in the debate, for example, the idea of revaluing the minimum, what we call the contributory minimum, the smallest pension for someone who contributes at 1,000 euros, was born from the debate. It was not a proposal. It was not a commitment I had made. It is from the debate with citizens that this idea was born. And so the debate we are starting today, which will continue in the coming months, must allow for me to first clarify misunderstandings when there are any, to clarify points also in governance, to provide guarantees in the system that will live on and to change things. After that, I will be clear.

It does not remain completely open, however.

What is clear is that I want us to move towards this system that builds the future. I am not going to tell you that the debate all of a sudden will reveal that we will move on to something else and that we will remain with the system of 42 regimes and then make a financial reform just for the next two months. It is the commitment I made to the French people, the program I built and which was validated. It is also what I owe democratically. On the other hand, on all the subjects I have opened, all those you want to open, the debate will allow for adjustments and changes, modifications and corrections.

That is the principle of this evening. Exchanges, we said it. So I will take five questions at a time, so that the questions, Mr. President, are very numerous and the answers as well. So I say this for the readers who will intervene. You simply raise your hand, we have four people who have microphones and who will come to you to give you the floor. Do not forget to stand up, to give your first name, your last name, your profession, and where you come from. I remind you that we are here, in this banquet hall, and to put no pressure on anyone, we are being broadcast on news channels and on all the websites of the regional daily press, so there you go. Short sentences, simple sentences, so that the debate is as fluid as possible. Let's start, who wants to ask questions? So listen, the people with microphones, there you go, I see there are questions here, Madam, the microphone will arrive.

Good evening Mr. President, my name is Claudie Savin, I am 53 years old, I am a nurse, I live and work near Villefranche-de-Rouergue, an hour's drive from here. So 53 years old, I have spent almost 30 years with a set of rules that seems to be evolving. I hear that the system must be fair and I understand and agree that it should be equitable. But the older I get, the more age recedes for my retirement, I find myself worried. I also think of long careers and I have a thought for the health and social sectors.

Mr. President will come back to you, go ahead.

Are you in the hospital, are you in private practice?

Not at all, I am currently in a company.

Ah, okay. And do you have children?

I have three children.

I will move on to another question Mr. President, that way you will have several. Sir, who is right here, there is a microphone, Quentin will come to you with the microphone. Go ahead, Sir, ask your question.

Mr. President, my name is Anthony Quintard, I am a farmer, a young farmer. I was wondering about the cumulative employment-retirement, which is part of your reflections. We are questioning ourselves as young farmers who work on the installation and renewal of generations in agriculture, whether ultimately the cumulative employment-retirement will not be something negative for us, since will it not ultimately undermine all our work of transmission, which we do daily to support farmers in their desire to pass on their working tools? Will a retired farmer still be able to continue agricultural activity, or will it ultimately undermine all the lands and activities in the territory and thus no longer allow young farmers to settle?

Thank you very much. We move on to a third question, Madam you have a microphone, go ahead.

I come from Castelginest, 15 km from Toulouse. I am a skills development facilitator at La Poste, currently on cessation of activity. I am 60 years old and my question is, I understood well that in everything you said, it goes back to the principle of equity that the same profession will give the same retirement, I heard that well. So this necessarily involves a complete overhaul of the world of work, I also understood that. However, where, since this is what I am experiencing, from the age of 55 in the world of work, we are considered, we are considered much less, we are quickly put aside, I can say that, despite the investment in an entire company and so what I want to raise and I hope that this question that is close to my heart, is the employability of seniors. Because in fact I am on cessation of activity, but it is almost against my will.

Thank you Madam for this question. So I would like to have a question here, do not worry everyone will be able to ask questions, Sir just here, here, Quentin if you would kindly give the microphone, here very well, and I saw here on this side. Go ahead Sir, please.

Good evening Mr. President, I introduce myself Char Ben Moussalem, 25 years old, I come from Rodez and I would like to address the subject of extending the contribution period for pensions. Is it not likely to create losers among the young, for example, who start late? Let's say a young person starts at 25, I just finished my studies, he will have to retire around 68. And certainly, you said we live longer, but that does not mean we live better. What will be the living conditions of the French in 45 years, no one knows that. So is it not likely to create losers among certain categories of French people? And a reform cannot really be a reform if there are losers and winners on one side.

Thank you Sir and I move on to a last question, there will be others obviously throughout the evening, we have a certain time. Go ahead Sir.

Good evening Mr. President, thank you for coming to Rodez, my name is Trabelsi Kacem, I am retired, I want to personally thank you for coming to Rodez as a Ruthénois. Now I thank Centre Presse for allowing me to come and ask you if it is possible for you and Mr. Delevoye, one simple thing: I have children and grandchildren that I try to help, but unfortunately sometimes I have difficult months to get by. If it is possible, Sir, I ask you, because I have difficult months, I have overdrafts sometimes that I would like if possible and I sincerely ask you, can you help us? You do like the complementary pension, it is paid on the 1st of the month. Is it possible for the Social Security pension to be paid from the beginning of the month and not on the 10th? I am forced, Sir, to lose euros, every time I have overdrafts and I really have to make an effort to manage. I ask you please, I hope to have a possibility and this, I draw your attention to a specific fact, when Mr. Sarkozy presented himself, it was in his program.

So it is not Nicolas Sarkozy here, but he will still try to answer the question, Mr. President. I will take your microphone back but perfect, thank you very much.

Thank you in advance.

Thank you. Excuse me Emmanuel Macron, but well, we lighten the atmosphere as we can… You have five questions, so there are five questions and I await your answers now.

Thank you very much. So you have asked several questions, and you are right, that is also why we want to rebuild the system, so that it does not change all the time. So you said I have a set of rules, will it change for me? At 53 years old, you are, I would say at the limit of those who will enter the reform. No, but the first point that is important for you is that all acquired rights will not change. So that is the first issue. The second point, anyway, you today, if I take the rules, that is why I asked you if you were in a company, the three children, under the control of the High Commissioner you cannot retire before 62 years old today, and that is indeed one of the, so to speak, injustices, so the structures afterwards are not the same in terms of salary and I do not stigmatize anyone at all, compared to anyone else, but if you were a nurse in the hospital, you could retire at 57 if you had 17 years of active career. So that is also something that is no longer so understandable. So today you retire, you do not have the right to retire at 62 years old, the legal age is 62 years old. In the new reform, or rather the change of system, the legal age will not change, the legal age will not change. The question posed for your generation is whether we will have to contribute a little more, so that the system is balanced in 2025. I do not have the answer today, the question has been posed by the Prime Minister to what we call the COR, which is an independent body, where there are social partners, experts, parliamentarians, which is responsible, you may have heard of it, the Council for Retirement Orientation, which says what we need and the funding shortfalls. So you, the rules of the game will not change regarding the legal age, we will keep it at 62 years old, it will not change. I cannot tell you for your generation what will be required, it depends on what the COR tells us in terms of funding needs, because one of the key points we have set is that the new system that starts in 2025 must start balanced, which is normal. So that means that if the COR tells us there is a shortfall of 8-10 billion, we will have to say we need to work a little longer, that is absolutely true. If it tells us, it is balanced in 2025, we will not need to make any effort. That is the first point. Then, and so that also takes into account your children. Regarding long careers, well, I do not know if you are eligible for the so-called "long careers" scheme, I do not know at what age you started working.

Yes, so that relates to the question from Mr. I will return to it in a moment. But the term "long career" has a meaning, I say this for all those who started working very young, who did not have long studies or internships. There is what is called the long career scheme, which has existed since 2012, which corrected the 2010 reform that allowed those who started working before the age of 20 to retire at 62 even if they had not contributed all the required quarters. We are keeping that; that will not change. So I say this for all those with long careers, who may be your age, younger, or otherwise; this scheme remains because it is a matter of justice. Then, where you are right, and this relates to the point made by another of you, and I will return to it, is that we must take into account, you spoke about medical and social careers, and this will be my last point in response to your question, the three components that I noted. Your sectors, in any case, we will have to reform them very deeply, reform them to take into account more the difficult working conditions and to be able to respond better than we do today to the conditions of remuneration. We cannot do this in six months, I will not lie to you, because it is a complete overhaul. We see the crisis that is currently affecting hospitals and emergency services; it is a crisis that has deep roots, stemming from 20 years of tightening budgets, which had justifications to keep the accounts in check. I do not criticize anyone, but we have today health professionals, regardless of their qualifications, their roles in hospitals, or in the medical-social sector, who are currently suffering. Therefore, the pension reform for these professions must first and foremost integrate a profound overhaul of the career, its financial revaluation, but also the way we think about careers. We cannot continue to do physically and emotionally demanding jobs, such as nursing assistants or night nurses, until retirement; especially as time goes on, that is not possible. We must rethink careers. One can do it for a time in one's life; it is part of the tasks, especially when done at night, that justify having bonuses and retiring earlier. But we, I say this as the State employer, but all those in this sector, must rethink these career categories. So that is one of the projects we have; when I told you that thinking about retirement is thinking about work in reflection, it is that we will have to change careers and revalue them. Then you asked me a question, Anthony, is that right, about agriculture and the renewal of generations. It is one of the technical discussions that we are having with agricultural unions to see how we can have a transfer clause and better value non-cumulative work. I am closely following the agricultural issue, which is dear to me. My concern today is not the one you describe, to be honest with you. When I look at the next ten years, our country will need 150,000 young people to engage in agriculture. Historically, we have a number of older individuals who will retire. Therefore, the key is rather to install, to give young people a sufficient foothold, that is the main battle. I look at this year; I checked the figures not long ago, and I believe we reached 13,000; we need 15,000 to really have the minimum renewal. I want us to continue to be a great agricultural nation because I want us to produce as much of our food as possible. It is a form of sovereignty, and I think our citizens want it more and more. So, one, the answer to your question is that we will take it into account in the construction of the career; that is what we are doing with your unions, so that there is a transfer clause and that it is encouraged. Two, to help young people establish themselves, the key is much more on the support for establishment and the premium for taking over land, because the truth is that there are not so many older individuals who are doing cumulative employment-retirement; there are not that many, but there are many older individuals who sell their farms to younger people at quite a high price because it is the retirement payout, including when it is family-related. And so what is very hard today is that the young person starting their career in agriculture pays the market price, which is quite high, for the farm because it is often the retirement of their father and mother. And so that is what we need to work on; we have a system that is being finalized. We started with subsidized loans; it is something we are working on with young farmers, but it is about providing even more comprehensive support for the purchase of the farm and agricultural land. And the third element, I mentioned it at the fair last year, is to help access to land; that is key. But I no longer see a risk on these issues, the purchase price of the farm and land, than on the cumulative employment-retirement of older individuals. On this subject, we will integrate it into the system through the transfer clause; that is indeed part of the discussions. Then I had Marie-Thérèse, I believe, from the Post Office. Well, you said it, and you said it with a lot of emotion regarding your situation. And what you said is true. I have two remarks. I am not in favor of delaying the legal retirement age for some of the reasons you mentioned. I think, depending on what the experts tell us, we may need to contribute more. As we live longer, common sense will lead us to say that we will have to contribute for a longer time. We must not deceive ourselves collectively. The question is: how do we make it fair? That is what we are collectively debating, but it is not true that when you are told you can retire at 60, that is not true. We cannot continue to gain quarters of healthy life, arrive later and later in active life, and say that we will retire at 60. At some point, someone pays. It is simple; retirement is three things: the duration of contributions, the level of contributions, and the level of pensions. So when you are told "the earlier you retire," it means: either you contribute more when you work, which is a loss of purchasing power for employees, or you reduce benefits when you are retired, which is a loss of purchasing power for retirees. The only thing that does not result in a loss of purchasing power for retirees and employees is to contribute more. The system is built that way; there is no magic solution. It is the nation that sustains itself. Regarding your concern, when I look at the last ten years, we have made significant improvements in the employment of seniors. Today, the unemployment rate for seniors is lower than the average unemployment rate in the nation; it is 6.1%. So when we say, "be careful, be careful, all seniors are unemployed," that is not true. We have improved on that. Where you are absolutely right, and that is what you express, is that when one is a victim of unemployment after 55, it is very difficult to find a job today. Therefore, one of the battles we must fight, but which is not related to retirement, which is the battle we have in terms of work, is to continue to train or retrain our fellow citizens, regardless of age. By the way, that is what we decided; in the 15 billion euros we allocated to training, we also train seniors because you could find yourself at 53, 54, 55 years old, having worked for 30 years in a company, it closes in the region, there are job offers, but you need to do six months of training in something else. Until now, you were not trained in something that lasts six months. Now, we have allocated the money, and we are retraining you. And then we collectively need to change the mindset of our companies. There are some... Yes! But it is a job, and we are doing it. We are in the process of doing it. It does not go through the law. It is about saying that someone who has accumulated this experience does not do the same thing as someone who is 35 years old. They may cost more because they are further along in their career. They do not do the same things, but they have acquired experience, reflexes that are a treasure accumulated, which is worth something in the company. Exactly. And so that is also something we are working on branch by branch, and it is part of what we must continue to improve. But there is no inevitability regarding the employment of seniors; senior unemployment has decreased. The key now is to continue to change the mentality; some companies have started to do it, but it is too rare, and to continue to train those over 50-55 years old because we can still have years and years of active life. There are those who also want to work beyond the legal age, who want to continue to have work or who want to have a retirement that is still enhanced and therefore work even beyond 64 years old. So we will continue to do that. But where you are right, I hold a lot to what you said, is that it is a profound overhaul of work. You give an example with the employment of seniors; we had an example regarding medical-social professions. Charles, regarding the extension of the contribution period, yes, what you said is true. But is it an injustice? The system is such that you have life periods where the nation... I do not like to talk about expenses when we talk about health or education. It is a debate I have had with several; I stand by talking about investment. The nation invests in you so that you are healthy and well-educated. There, it is national solidarity that generally pays, at least a good part of your studies, and then it will ensure that you are healthy and reach a certain age. Then, it is you who contributes to the life of the nation by paying taxes through national solidarity and contributions when we talk about health or pensions, since that is the subject of our discussion today. It is normal, if we want the system to hold, that it is fair in terms of life cycle for everyone. So if you choose to enter the active life later, it is normal that it somewhat delays the start of that active life to return to a life where, again, the nation will give you back what you have given it through retirement. Because if I say "you can enter later and it has no impact, you will always retire at the same age," I further reduce the contribution period. You can see that it is impossible to have more and more... We are living longer and longer while receiving from the system, but those who contribute remain in it for less and less time. That will not work. However, to correct the effects you describe. Well! One, we keep the legal age at 62; that means you have the right to retire at 62. That is the legal age. That will not change. But at 62, today, you retire, and you may not have your full pension if you do not have all your quarters. If you enter at the age you mentioned, you can retire at 62, but you will not have your full pension. It is a choice; it is free. Tomorrow, it will be the same. You have contributed your points; you will still be able to retire at 62, but you may not have all your points, especially if you entered the system late. That is why we often talk about a pivot age. The pivot age is the one that cancels all penalties. It is, even if you do not have all your points today, all your quarters, there is an age at which we consider that you have your full pension. It is the famous 64 years of pivot age today. That is why you have a legal age and a pivot age. Whether we choose to have a new pivot age in the system, whether we choose that it is simply a number of points, thus equivalent to the duration of quarters, tomorrow. In any case, the later you enter, the longer you will have to contribute. But you will have an age below which it is not possible to retire; it will remain 62 years, and an age that we must define in the debate, which is the one at which you have fewer penalties compared to your system. Otherwise, it would not be fair to those who start working earlier. Mr. TRABELSI, thank you for your enthusiasm. No, the point you raise is a real issue, and it is a subject that seems technical but is very important for many of our fellow citizens. That is why we implemented withholding at the source, you know. We did withholding at the source because, for many people, the tax authorities were a hassle. We used to do it ten days before; you know that well. So now we synchronize everything with the moment the pay comes in. You could, even when those who were monthly paid, it would come around the 20th, and we would set aside and say, "Damn, that is when we were overdrawn." We reduce overdrafts and over-indebtedness.

And so what we want to do is simplify things and have them fall on a known and fixed date. Therefore, withholding at source allows us to move in that direction since it occurs on the day you receive your payment, and we will look at... It has nothing to do with the reform; we can do it with the current system, it's about saying, as you mentioned with the complementary payments: we choose the beginning of the month, the first day of the month to give you a reference point. I think that makes a lot of sense. You will tell me on the day you have it because I understand that... Otherwise, you will come back in 10 years to say...

Mr. TRABELSI

The former president had said that.

Emmanuel MACRON

You will put that down to Nicolas SARKOZY, but you will say: "he told me in his program..." But we will look into it, and we will try to do it.

Mr. TRABELSI

I will just say a little word, I promise you, I give you my word, I know the mayor very well, I will tell him.

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, thank you very much. But I will be honest, the mayor is not to blame. But we will look into it.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Emmanuel MACRON, two questions I would like to take from the PQR, regional daily press. A practical question but it is useful for everyone, we have had many questions. A question from Paris-Normandie, Alain BERTRAND, 55 years old: will we be able, before the vote on the law, with the help of a simulator, to compare the amount of our pension before and after the reform? I believe there are plans for platforms, is that right?

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes. So on this, we need to agree. The individual simulator, we need to have set the parameters. So first, I tell you, when I sometimes see simulations that are done, there are newspapers that have published them, there are people who create websites, it’s complete nonsense. It’s stuff, it’s people who put forward assumptions that do not exist, they are not set. The fixed assumptions are those that I have given you here. So we have not, for example, set how we calculate the value of the point. That is one of the projects that is under negotiation. So we need to continue the work. We have set ourselves a deadline until the end of the year, January. I think we need to be reasonable. It’s January/February, we will be able to have those parameters. If we manage to converge… I think we need to take the time on this subject and do it well. If in January/February, we have clear ideas, that we see real convergences, we know that there are people who do not agree at all with the reform. I respect that, but we need to have all spoken honestly, to have clear ideas. If in January/February, on what allows for a simulation, that is to say the number of points, the value of the point, etc... The main rules, we know how to set them up, at that moment, we will be able to set up a simulator. My goal is that we can set it up at that moment and that people can start to find a reference point. Will it be individualized? He shows me something, Jean-Paul DELEVOYE, saying "impact study." We will continue to do it in the meantime. The great difficulty of the system is that since it starts to live in 2025, it is very hard to compare it to a situation today. It’s the collective effort we need to make, it’s to project ourselves. And when people talk about winners and losers, it doesn’t make much sense compared to what we are living today because we are talking about a system that will start, for some, to live in 2025, and which will be fully deployed in 2040. So I mean, we need to look at what your situation would be with the current system, given career accidents, etc... So there will be, yes, if in January/February, we manage to have all these conditions, the objective I pursue is that we can present the main terms of what would be a framework law. How do I see this reform collectively? It’s that we arrive, through this work, all together, to converge and find the main principles. On this basis, we will be able to have a somewhat general impact study and have simulation mechanisms. Will we manage to do individual simulations, the cases being so specific? I cannot tell you, we will try. But that everyone can at least locate themselves by major categories and understand the future system and the pace. One of the points we will need to clarify between January and March is the pace of transition. I said it, there are certain careers, we talk about nurses, nurses, it’s not true that we will do it overnight. I will be clear, I will not be able to do it. We cannot, in 2025, switch everyone over, because careers are built that way. Today, when you are a nurse, I said it in the hospital, you are not well paid but you have compensations related to the fact that you can retire at 57 if you have your 17 years of active service. It’s unfair. All those who have that, we need to let them keep it. Those who do not have it completely, it would be unfair to tell them: "all of a sudden, you lose all that." So we will implement a transition. We will also provide transparency from January to March. Then, we will have a framework law, and what needs to go to a vote is a framework law that sets in some way the main principles...

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

For the summer, is that it?

Emmanuel MACRON

If it can even be presented before... I want to say, the sooner we provide transparency, but it should not go after the summer. It then needs to be debated by Parliament, which may want to modify it, amend it, etc... But we need to have this framework law that allows the new system to be implemented. And then, we will have governance, meaning that we will not freeze the system for 20 years. I believe that is also the strength. We will set absolute rules, 62 years for the legal age, the rules of values, so that no one decides in 5 years, in 10 years, to say: "we tear everything up and decide to collapse pensions." We will prevent that to protect the purchasing power of retirees. I want us to put it in the golden rules, because we have seen how sensitive it was. And then, we will have a rule of collective organization where, every year, the social partners, the unions, therefore the representatives of employees, the representatives of employers, the representatives of the nation must meet. Because the nation will contribute, there will be roughly 70% of contributions and 30% of taxes to finance everything. So there needs to be some kind of independent college that can debate this every year, saying: "here is the direction we need to move in and here is how we gradually evolve the system over time in a transparent manner." And thus an independent authority that will, every year, say: "here is how the population is evolving, here is how life expectancy is evolving," that will be transparent, an independent authority that will provide information to everyone. And then everyone will have to take their responsibility, social partners, legislators, to say every year if they need to evolve the system, because perhaps the system will last like this and the rules we set this year may evolve, but who can do it while holding everyone accountable. But what I do not want is for us to have a system frozen forever. That would not make sense. I do not want us to have an automatic system that operates without decisions being made. I do not want us to have a system that is solely in the hands of the government, because at least 70% of its funding will come from employees, and therefore social partners must have a responsibility in the system. And a responsibility means that we are also co-responsible for its balance. We cannot say: "we let the deficit run," because in the end, there is always someone who pays.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

A clarification with a quick response, please. On the pivot age, 64 years, you mentioned it, we saw that there might be, I don’t know if it’s wavering, confusion. It was requested in a report. Do you maintain it, do you go back on it? What can you tell us?

Emmanuel MACRON

First, I will not purge the debate. It’s one of the major projects that is with the social partners. I said, how does our system work today? 62 years is the legal age, you cannot retire before, except when you are in a special regime or you are what we call an active category, you can retire depending on whether you have generally done 17 years for active categories, and then according to the regimes, you can retire at 52, 57 years. Otherwise, it’s 62 years, the legal age. Then, you have... If you retire at 62 years, and you do not have all your quarters, you have what we call a discount, that is to say that compared to the full pension you should have, you have a discount of 5% per year when you retire at 62 years without having that full rate. 64 years is the pivot age, which means that, even if you do not yet have all your quarters, the discount is canceled. And so, you have your pension at the full rate, for a good category. And then, you have a bonus system. The problem we have is that when you have had a career that has been very fragmented, this system is not fair either. So, I come back to it right away because… Exactly, women in particular, in many professions, whose careers are interrupted, they do not generally have the full pension before 67 years. They will seek the equilibrium age and the cancellation of any discount at 67 years. And we have 20% of women who, today, in our society, work until 67 years to have the full pension. So, when I am told: the retirement age is 62 for everyone, that’s false. 20% of women will work until 67 years, because they have had a fragmented career, because the system does not take maternity well into account, because the system penalizes them rather, not just in terms of salaries, that is already true, but also in terms of taking into account the quarters. So, we want to correct that. So, regarding that, in the upcoming system, we will keep 62 years. And then, we have two possibilities: either we move the reference age, which is indeed the proposal of the report, which is to say, you can, even if you retire at 62 years, even with the new system, if you have under-contributed, you cannot have the full pension. And the reference age is set according to the financing needs of the system. So, in the short term, it will depend on the response that the famous Council for Retirement Orientation will give us at the end of November. And then, based on this expertise done each year, we will have to evolve it. There is another way to do it, that some specialists proposed, which is to say: you eliminate all reference age, and you only take the duration of contributions, and therefore the number of points. There, it needs to be debated. Because one might think it is fairer to only take the duration of contributions. For example, if I am provocative, Charles, who told me earlier: "I will enter the labor market late. I studied, I made the choice to study, etc..." If I only take the duration of contributions, it is no longer fair, because I will make him work for a very long time. There is no reason, he seems to be in good health. Since he has done long studies, he will probably have a job that is less demanding than those who stopped studying earlier, etc... I provoke you, I do it on purpose. But I go to the other side, if I only look at the duration of contributions, I continue to have people who have very fragmented careers, who will continue to work very late to have the full rate. The interest of this pivot age is, at some point, to say: we cancel all discounts and we say, you can retire at full rate at that age, because there are enough life accidents. There you go, so that’s up for debate, but it’s to help you understand that the two mechanisms do not exclude each other. It’s, afterwards, a collective choice we will make based on the references we want to set in the new system.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, Mr. President. Now, we move on to a new series of questions. Here, I have many questions. So, I saw you here, Sir. Don’t worry, everyone will be able to ask questions. Short questions, I repeat. Stand up, name and surname. Go ahead, Sir.

Christian MEUNIER

Hello, Mr. President of the Republic. Christian MEUNIER, retired, active, president of an association called Aéré 46, in Lot, which supports chronic and respiratory patients. As you can see, the volunteer world is growing, and at the same time, it is also getting tired. And it’s many people who have, therefore, this career broken by a chronic and serious pathology, and I can take my personal case. I have 480 members in my association, who are also in this hardship, and who automatically find themselves on sick leave due to the pathology. They will give themselves as volunteers. Would it be possible, possibly, to value the time of volunteering they do, to help others? There you go, Mr. President of the Republic,

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you for your question. I move on to a question here. I saw you, Madam, and here, on this side. Sir. The microphone is working, go ahead.

Anthony DELOBRE

Good evening, Mr. President. Anthony DELOBRE, 30 years old and manager of a construction company with my brother, in Rodez. So, my question is simple: since we were little, we have been told that we young people will never have a pension. So, with your system, what will happen?

Specific question. Thank you very much. Come this way, Madam, right in front. Can the microphone come over here? Go ahead. Please ask your question and introduce yourself, Madam.

Michèle SITURE-DELMAS

Hello, Mr. President. My name is Michèle SITURE-DELMAS, I am a retired teacher, but I am mainly the mother of four children who work a lot. They contribute a lot, especially my 25-year-old son, who is a dairy farmer, and he has many questions because he is on the actual system, but in agriculture, there are still two regimes, with the flat-rate system and the actual system. He contributes a lot, and with the significant decrease in the number of active workers, he is wondering what amount of pension he will have, even though he will have contributed a lot. That's it.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you for your question. A question here, and I will take questions over there. Madam, I saw you, don't worry. Sir, here, has a question. We have time, we still have a little time ahead of us, I believe, Mr. President, so we can still take questions. Go ahead.

Patrick MAVIELLE

Hello, Mr. President. Patrick MAVIELLE, general practitioner from Aveyron and firefighter doctor. I just wanted to ask you, a little bit like with volunteering, but this is about volunteer firefighters: where do you stand on the pension point bonuses for the work of volunteer firefighters, I would say the hardships faced by volunteer firefighters?

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, sir, for your question. Madam, your question, please.

Annabelle MONTEL-ESTEVE

Good evening, Mr. President. My name is Annabelle MONTEL-ESTEVE. I am 43 years old and I have been a lawyer at the Aveyron bar for 18 years, of which I have been the president for 2 years. You are aware of the concerns of the legal profession, of the 60 lawyers in my bar, but especially of the 70,000 lawyers in France, as well as the vast majority of liberal professions in this country, who have already expressed their concerns, which are entirely legitimate. The liberal professions in this country, Mr. President, feel mistreated by this project. We have the impression that you want to confiscate our pension schemes, our funds that are autonomous, which therefore do not cost a euro to the State or to society, and which are also supportive, since the National Fund of French Bars pays almost 100 million euros per year to the general scheme, a scheme to which we are not entitled. We feel, Mr. President, that this scheme will create additional burdens for lawyers, burdens of extreme weight, since it is planned that they will be gradually implemented over 15 years, which means they are extremely heavy. I wanted to tell you, Mr. President, that in my bar of 60 lawyers, I already have 2 colleagues who have confided in me, both angry and with tears in their eyes, because they deeply love this profession that we practice in rural areas. We ensure this territorial network where the State has not taken responsibility for years. We provide access to justice that is sometimes, very often, needed by vulnerable populations. And these colleagues told me today: if the system as you have planned it goes through in these terms, they will have to stop their profession. You spoke about women, Mr. President, indeed, the lawyers who will be most affected are the young ones, the women with less linear career paths, as well as the lawyers who intervene under legal aid, to guarantee equitable access to justice for the most vulnerable. The question, Mr. President, is the following: will this pension scheme make hundreds of lawyers disappear in France? Is that your intention?

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, Madam. Mr. President, 5 questions, 5 answers.

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, so your first question, Christian, thank you very much, about chronic illnesses and the consideration of volunteering, which related to Mr.’s question. So, this is indeed one of the areas we are working on in our system. The more we take into account non-contributory elements, the more we need to finance them through solidarity, at that point. So, let’s be clear: this is the part that we will no longer finance through contributions, but through taxes. What is true is that our country today has a tremendous treasure, which is its associations, its volunteers, the volunteer firefighters, and you mentioned it. But also, I want to say it here because, perhaps we will mention it, but the role of what we now call caregivers, who may not be in associations, but who are volunteers for their family or loved ones, and who, if they were not there, in a way, the person they help, whom they take care of, would be a burden on society. Today, our system is indeed blind to them. So, we have started, by the way, in the draft social security financing bill for next year, for the first time, we will take into account the situation of caregivers, and enhance, precisely, allowing them to have a bonus, a leave, and to value that. I am very much in favor of taking this into account in the pension system. Simply, it needs to be taken into account, and we must accept that it is taxes that will finance this. Because if we want there to be solidarity, and that those who help, those who volunteer and commit, have in a way a bonus, we cannot ask other workers to contribute for that. We can ask for it from national solidarity, and at that point, it is a tax. This is part of the topics that are up for discussion, but I consider that it is part of the intelligent topics. Will we be able to take into account all volunteering situations? I cannot guarantee that, but at least we can better value volunteering, and to immediately respond to Mr.’s question, volunteering, yes, we know that it is one of the real debates we have with volunteer firefighters, who spend a lot of time. We already have a system today that enhances, we know that, but not sufficiently, in any case, it is part of the discussions that are ongoing. I am very sensitive today, precisely, not only to the movement, but finally to the commitment around this, so it is part of the things that are up for discussion, and that we must clarify by January. Simply, each time, what I ask is that, in the face of new concrete rights, we are collectively honest with the resources we put into it. Otherwise, I would be completely demagogic, to tell you this evening: “we will take it into account.” Because someone has to pay for it, and so, that is the solidarity part of the system. But I am in favor of it, and I am also very much in favor of caregivers. I think of parents who have a dependent child, who have people in a situation of dependency, a scenario that we have more and more, or a spouse. When they take care of this person, we probably need to have a bonus in the points system, compared to someone who would not work at all. Because it is someone who has an activity that is not currently valued in society as work, but which is, fundamentally, work, and which, by the way, can sometimes be very exhausting, which requires respite. And so, that is a reflection we need to have. Because for the community, it has value. And I think we can ask the question of volunteering. So afterwards, I am attached to the fact that, for volunteering, we also keep a free part. There needs to be a valuation, but the meaning of free action for the nation also means that there is not necessarily compensation. Because it is a commitment we give. I think that is important. Anthony, what you said is exactly why we are doing the reform, this transformation, that we are rebuilding things. I have looked, for years, at a young person entering the system, he says, I have heard since I was born, and I am 10 years older than you, but I assure you, I am in the same situation, we hear every time: “the system is going to break, we need to reform, and we need to extend.” I think we may need, depending on what the experts tell us, to work a little more, but in any case, the system, if we want it to be fair one day and to give visibility to all young people, needs to be rebuilt on a pact of trust. This pact of trust is, I believe, the system we are proposing. And so, the young person you are, he has acquired everything he has acquired in the current system, he will continue for 5 years, but then you will have a readable system, where all the points you buy, that you contribute, will be points that are acquired. You will have your account, it is a right. This money will go to finance your elders, but you, this right, it is a right that you contract with the nation. It is inalienable, and that will be included in the golden rule. And so, it will be included in the law, with an extremely strong value. That cannot change, it will no longer be negotiable. And in the golden rule, there will also be the mechanisms for valuing this point, which will allow, once this golden rule is passed, to see how the point is valued from year to year. And the only thing that the partners can then change, depending on what the experts say, are other parameters, which can indeed be the duration, but they will have to explain themselves in light of what the experts say, the contribution elements, but nothing that will be in the golden rule. So, the system we are going to rebuild will be more readable, it will be the same for you and all those of your age, regardless of their sector of activity. You will be able to follow it, there, it will not be with a simulator, but with an online account, which will give you at every moment of life, where you are, which gives credibility, and with in the golden rule things that are inalienable and that we will no longer be able to change. So, that is why I think it is a system that will allow us to rebuild trust, where today, people, as they say “the system, I no longer understand it”... And then, I take your example, your company, if it does less well, tomorrow, you will go to the city of Rodez. They will hire you, you will change your pension fund overnight, moving to another system. Then, you will take up an activity for another employer, you will change pension funds again. We have pathways today, where you have 4, 5 different pension funds, with different rules, with acquired rights that are not the same, which you lose when you move from one scheme to another, which is profoundly unfair and unreadable. That will end with the new reform. Michèle, then, about your son, since the question you asked was not for you, but for your son who is a farmer. Today, our farmers, this relates to Anthony’s question, our farmers have small pensions, because for a very long time, they have either not contributed, or under-contributed, and for a long time, they had an extremely unfair system. This has been corrected in recent decades. It remains extremely low with a system that is specific. And your son and you will see that I will use this example to also respond to you, master. In a few moments for the lawyers. He is in a system, that of farmers, where if I look back 40 years, I took the figures to not tell you nonsense, but farmers at the beginning, today, we have three workers for ten retired farmers. But 40 years ago, it was completely the opposite. And so we have a demographic inversion. So today, if I stay with the current system, in fact, there will be a pension that will remain low but it is national solidarity that will pay for it. It is not his contributions. The contributions of those who will work behind. It is the taxes that everyone pays today. Which is both a form of injustice and what is not satisfactory and what creates anxiety because everyone sees the demographics of their profession. When we see that we have three workers for 10 retirees, we say, the system is going to break. I will not have my pension. That is not true because we have not let anyone fall. But what I say for farmers is even truer for miners. The miners of yesterday who were many more than retirees. Today, over 80% of our retired miners, and God knows they have a difficult life. There are some in the region. There are some in the region that we cherish with Jean-Paul DELEVOYE. It is national solidarity that pays their pensions. It is no longer the workers. That is why the system can no longer work like that. With different regimes whose demographic balances are shifting. So in the system we propose, your son will enter like all the others and he will earn points. He will enter a pension system where he will acquire. And then he is young, he is 25 years old. Points, he will have behind the reductions as if he is also like the other independents who go with. There are contributions that will decrease. I was looking at that too and I cannot tell you nonsense about farmers. The minimum contribution that must be paid to acquire a quarter will decrease in the new system because today the system as it is under-balanced, the MSA, which is not at all its fault, has managed something that no longer holds. It rebalances by over-contributing compared to the target systems. The contributions for farmers will be lower in the new system and he will find himself in a system where he, in addition, starts to contribute from the beginning of his career or he will not be able to retire before 62 years. If he has all his quarters, all his points, he will be able to retire at 62 years and he will not have less than 1,000 euros. When I look at the pensions of our elders in agriculture, sometimes it is at 400/500 euros because they do not have all their quarters. Because above all, we have women who have never contributed, who have helped on the farm for decades, who have never been recognized and who therefore have a pension that is not even at full rate. That is finished in the new system. What we call the minimum contributory pension will be at 1,000 euros. And so your son in the new system will not have less than 1,000 euros. And 1,000 euros, as I committed, will be in the golden rule. So on that, the new system because it has precisely more to look at the demographics of his profession within it. You can be assured, he does not have to have his anxieties and look, he is a young person with many retirees. I also hope that there will be many young people who become farmers, I said because we need them. I know there have been difficult years. We are fighting over milk. We will continue to fight for the purchase price to be good and for it to return to the farm. It is better than it was 18 months ago but it is still very hard. But it is fragile, it is very fragile. But it is also what we are trying to do with the General States of Food. I will have the opportunity to talk about it with our farmers, but we will continue to fight. I have answered about the enhancement of volunteer firefighters, that is part of the system but we need to put in place, as in finance, with taxes. So then the subject of lawyers. First, I understand very well your anxiety and I understand it. I mean, there is sincerity that is expressed in each one. We need to have it in this period and so we need to have an extremely calm debate with each profession. And never with me do I want a harmonious society. The goal is not to eliminate a profession or to be unbalanced by this reform, I assure you. And I am committed to access to law. I am committed to access to law in our territories and so we need our lawyers as we need our presences everywhere in the territory contrary to what has sometimes been said about the ongoing justice reform which has not been a reform of the judicial map but a real reform that has precisely allowed to modernize all that. Now we need to do, we need to look as well. I look at the profession of lawyer today as it is. I talk about work and then I will talk about retirement. Today I have 25% of lawyers who leave the profession before 10 years of practice. 25%, many of whom are women. But why? Because we also have not looked at the demographics of the profession. We have created more and more. We have more and more lawyers who depend on legal aid so who are very poorly paid, who are very poorly paid. I agree but you say: Mr. President of the Republic, invent us a public system, we want to become civil servants. At that moment, I could tell you, we will continue to hire. I am committed to legal aid for access to law. But at some point, we also need to maintain balances and perhaps question the demographics of the profession.

In recent years, in recent decades, there have been more and more of them. And it is in certain places that have become less and less viable for professionals, with people stopping earlier and earlier. For the 25% I mentioned who stop before 10 years, many of them are women, and these are people who, for many today, do not properly value the rights they have acquired in this fund. That is the first point. And when I also look at things. Your fund. So I will say two things regarding your case. The first is that we will not take from any particular fund the resources it has accumulated. It is legally impossible. It is impossible. And whether it is lawyers, whether it is doctors, whether it is all liberal professions, the independents who may have funds, who have contributed, who have reserves. Sometimes, by the way, they have purchased land. They have valued it by investing. We will not take it back. It will be used for the professionals until the rights of these professionals are extinguished. So this principle is an acquired right and it is constitutionally protected. So on this, I have read a lot of things that are nonsense. It is impossible. This even falls under the property law that is yours in relation to this system. So that is not true. We are not going to confiscate the reserves to balance the system. False. I fully reassure you, this will not be done. The second point, I hear the lawyers who are fighting today because they say, we have a good demographic balance. I looked at things, it is true. Your system is still balanced. But today's lawyers, be careful, they will be the farmers of tomorrow and the miners of the day after tomorrow. We are still. We are an extraordinary country where we do not want to associate with others as long as we are beneficiaries. But the day we start to lose, we turn to the community, we say come here through taxes. It is like what we have done all the time. So 15 years ago in your profession, there were 9 contributors for one retiree. Today there are 5 contributors for one retiree. So in a few years, I do not know how demographics will evolve but at some point there will be one contributor per retiree and then there will be fewer. Farmers 40 years ago did not want to associate with others. Because there were actually many more active than retirees. Miners at the time when there was a system that worked well, the same. At some point, it is national solidarity. And this system, it is unjust to the square. You can see that. It is not viable for the community, for the pact with the nation. Because it is not fair to say my reserves are mine as long as my contributors are not retired. More the day when I no longer have enough... you, you are young. I will not tell you if the contributors will pay your retirement. You or your retirement, there is a strong chance that a significant part will be paid by national solidarity and that is taxes. And you will be very happy at that moment to have national solidarity and to be in a system. So all this will be done in transition, it will be looked at. And then there is a point regarding the fears about contributions. That we will lower for all independents. The CSG by 4 points. No, but we have done the simulations. They are in the report. When I look at things for many independents at least it balances out. And there are even some who are in favor. There are others when they have a system that is quite advantageous in relation to their contributions. The system can be a losing one for a time. We need to look. But we should not reason during a losing time. We just need your system, it will not hold in the long term with these mechanisms. It will not hold. So, one, I will reassure you. We are not going to go and take the reserves. Two, we will not explode the charges because there is the decrease in CSG and in any case your charges today your contributions today, it is the contribution to the points of tomorrow. And so that will be part of the discussion. Three, your profession like other professions, it must engage in a dialogue on how I contribute and how I decide to value my point and have something that is viable. There you go, and I just wanted to remind you of these few balances. I am very sensitive to this. I do not want us to lose our lawyers. I do not want to weaken the profession. So I want to remind you of some demographic realities and the constraints we all have. Because all professions have their specificities. So now the profession must engage through your representatives with the High Commissioner, the Keeper of the Seals in a dialogue to find the right valuation of the points and to look at the matter because indeed if in certain categories the 4 points of CSG do not compensate everything, how do we decide to do things and play on the parameters that are in our hands? But under no circumstances will we put people, we will suffocate lawyers. That, I really want to reassure you. And I know that there are many lawyers who today live in conditions that are sometimes very difficult. I was talking about lawyers who depend on legal aid. It is obvious, and of course they are often lawyers, on these subjects, there will be particular attention because they are the actors of access to law. And I care about this as much as you do. There you go, I wanted to remind you of these points but I also wanted to tell you my commitment, that of the Keeper of the Seals and the whole government to be very vigilant on this point. Do not have... that you have concerns yes, do not have unfounded fears.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, Emmanuel MACRON. We will move on to our series of five questions, perhaps before two questions from the regional daily press, which is a partner in our operation, as you know. This is Dominique GAUTIER, he is 65 years old and retired in Saint-Gervais la forêt in Loir-et-Cher. Is it true, Mr. President, that you have already committed to preserving the special regime for police officers? Perhaps you could answer right away before a second question, maybe?

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, we have committed to nothing, to nothing because if we start, there will no longer be special regimes as such. It is not possible in a system that is universal by points. Police officers are a profession that - at this moment, by the way - expresses all its difficulties, and I want to tell them that not only the government but the President of the Republic is behind them because we need them for our country. I know how much they sometimes have difficult conditions today, and I want us to also ensure that we catch up on things for active police officers in terms of equipment and others, but our police officers today are part of what we call these active categories. That is to say, when they have 17 years of service, they can retire earlier and they have advantages. They have advantages, but it is a security profession. They are exposed to high risk. So we are not going to keep it. If I start to say, we keep a special regime for one, it will fall like dominoes. Because behind it, I will be told you do it for the police, so for the gendarmes. Then I will be told: you do it for the gendarmes, why not for nurses and nursing assistants? And then we will redo special regimes. In two shakes of a lamb's tail, we are there. No. The question is how we take into account the reality of the career and its difficulties. First for the police. There too, a transition period. Police officers who have acquired their rights or who are completing their 17 years of active service, we cannot call into question what has been done. So for those who have the 17 years of prerequisite career, they must be able to retire at 57 years old, those who will have it by 2025. We must not skimp. Then it is also a profession with which we must work with their representatives. The career is what they are asking for, by the way. And I say this because for many of these issues, the state historically has done what. The state was an employer that did not want to manage careers, that did not want to revalue salaries and told teachers, schoolmasters, nurses, nursing assistants, police officers. You will be poorly paid. The career is quite flat, but the pension system is good, and therefore the difference between your pension and your salary will be better than in other categories, and you will be able to retire earlier. That’s how we did it. And so if we put everyone in a universal system, it is the obligation to revisit these careers. I cannot ask today’s police officers with their engagement careers to switch overnight to the new system. So there will be no special regime for police officers, but we must work with them to transform their careers to better value the career, to, one, maintain the acquired rights of all those who are there. Take into account the specificities of the job and its risks. I was saying earlier for those who work at night, those who have risks. Those who are exposed to the risks of interventions, at night, on patrol, in public order, in the fields. Finally, those who are on the ground. And that is a condition to discuss with the unions. We must value them. They cannot leave. They cannot leave like everyone else. There should be bonus points that they accumulate when they are on the ground. And when I say we must rethink careers, we must also, we who are not good employers in terms of police, from a certain age, be able to remove them from the field more quickly. Because if I say everyone must work a little longer. It is not true that one can be in the BAC. It is not true that one can be CRS. It is not true that one can be in very difficult intervention functions for years more. There is an age where one also wears out over those years. We need to be able to return sooner to an office where we will be protected from exposure in intervention. So no special regime but a specific discussion like with other professions. The preservation of acquired rights, a transition period, and a transformation of the career.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Now a question from L'Est Républicain. Stéphanie Le Cardonnel. She is a speech therapist. She is 45 years old. She lives in Frauville in Meurthe-et-Moselle. I am a speech therapist. If my retirement contribution goes from 14 to 28%, my annual benefit is cut by 20%. Do you find that interesting for me, given that my retirement will not double, I think?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, first because, on the points, she will have less CSG. She is part, I think. She is an independent speech therapist if I take the figures. So first, the percentage is, at this stage, indicative. There is a discussion profession by profession. This relates to what we were saying with lawyers. Then, she needs to take into account the fact that she will have, like all independents, four points of CSG less. That is the balance she needs to make. So, today, it is quite true that for independents, the system will change and it is a completely specific discussion because there are categories of independents who under-contributed and had systems that were very poor and very unbalanced. I have had debates with retirees, with liberal professionals who told me “I have a miserable pension,” yes! Because the system has been a system of miserable contributions. So we put everyone in a form of common law, but they will have the 4 points of CSG less, and that is part of the discussion and the balances.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

I will now move on to another series of questions, so I saw that there were questions over here, sir? Christine, could you perhaps pass a microphone to the gentleman, stand up, name, first name, short question. There are a lot of questions, go ahead.

Stéphane BULTEL

Stéphane BULTEL from Rodez. Mr. President, you gave the impression in the first part of your term of favoring a category of people who — you made an assumed message — you said “we must free the workers and ensure that we lower the tax pressure while they are working.” Is it — I have a proposal — is it not the time at retirement to reverse a bit the solidarity, to ensure that those who earned much more during their working life really contribute much more, and I ask the taboo question, is it not time to cap the amount of pensions?

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you for your question. Madam, you have a question here, the microphone will just arrive, do not worry, we still have... there... a little time, I will take all the questions, go ahead, Madam.

Solange PRUNET

Hello, Solange PRUNET, from Aveyron and originally from northern Aveyron, a place you know, I believe. So I wanted to ask a question regarding... if you intend to promote complementary pensions since indeed collective solidarity is present in your reform and we thank you for that, but for small salaries who will receive, I think, at the end of their career 1,000 euros, since that is the minimum, how to encourage them to contribute to complementary pensions in your opinion? Simple and clear proposals, please, to be able to respond to an additional pension for them because they will still be the most disadvantaged.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, Madam. Here, sir, there is a question, here is the gentleman, go ahead.

Jean-Louis GRIMAL

Yes, hello Mr. President.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Speak into the microphone, please introduce yourself.

Jean-Louis GRIMAL

Yes. Hello Mr. President of the Republic. So I am retired today, I am nevertheless the mayor of a small municipality and president of the association of mayors of the department. My question is as follows: today, of course, regarding the pension reform, you spoke of the threshold of 1,000 euros for today, however, there will be salaries, salaries today that are not too high, especially in this rural department of Aveyron, how do you think to manage tomorrow, that is to say these retirees who will have acquired points but of course they will acquire fewer points than those who have the means? Secondly, we have not talked about...

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Well, perhaps keep your question because there are other questions...

Jean-Louis GRIMAL

I will be quick, it is regarding the hardship at retirement age. The hardship and the retirement age. Finally, how do you think that tomorrow... do you think tomorrow to create an independent national body to manage the value of the point knowing also that governments change and we know what happens. Thank you, Mr. President.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you very much, sir. Just behind you, there is a gentleman who had asked for the floor, very well, go ahead, and then Madam. Go ahead, sir.

Thomas

Hello, my name is Thomas, I was born in Rodez and I study in Toulouse. You mentioned earlier that it would start in 2025 with a transition until 2040, is that right? How can you plan so far ahead when your reform does not take into account ecology or anything? Since the beginning of your term, you have communicated on this with hashtags, etc., but nothing has been done. How will you address this issue, knowing that for young people like me, retirement would rather be about saving the planet and not contributing, etc.? Thank you.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, sir. Go ahead, Madam, short question, go ahead, introduce yourself.

Marie-José MOYSSET

Good evening, Mr. President, I am Marie-José MOYSSET, I am retired from teaching, so not concerned by the pension reform, but I am also the president of the Departmental Union of Family Associations, and therefore the reform, the proposed pension reform raises some concerns, particularly regarding family rights since you announced finally... that you would take into account the first, the second child, but — which is a good thing, of course — but the problem is, there will be a regression for parents who have had three children, particularly regarding bonuses. Currently, it is 10% per parent, in the future, parents will be either the mother or the parents, both parents will decide to share the bonus, and it will no longer be for parents of three children that 7.5 for each parent, so this raises concerns. So, can we not improve the situation of some without altering the situation of others? And then the last question, what about survivor's pensions, which also raise a lot of concerns? Thank you, Mr. President.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you very much. Mr. President, I will take two more questions if you allow, we will already be at seven. Madam over there, I see... here who is raising her hand, and then here, sir, and then we will move on to your answers. Go ahead, Madam.

Mathilde MARGAILLAN

Mathilde MARGAILLAN, 30 years old, health executive but above all a representative of a Network of Young Economic Chambers of Occitanie. So Mr. President, my question is as follows: at a time of the Europeanization of powers, norms, decisions, and budgets, at a time of posted workers and nomadic jobs, would it not be necessary to reflect on the European harmonization of pensions — time and duration?

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you. A question here, go ahead, sir.

Fabien KALA

Good evening, Fabien KALA, from Rodez, 43 years old. I am responsible for an association supporting business creation called BGE, and I would like to quickly return to the word universality that you mentioned regarding the pension system reform. And I wonder how it could apply to professions that are both exercised by independents and by employees, for example, an independent earthmover or an employee earthmover have the same work hardship, and how to take this difference in status into account? And the second thing, since we are talking about universality, perhaps it would also be the time to make the protection systems universal, for employees and independents. Thank you.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you very much. Mr. President, I will let you respond to these questions before moving on to a new series of questions.

Yes. So it was Stéphane from Rodez on the contribution at the time of retirement for the wealthiest. First, may I say that I tried, it’s painful. Because the increase in the CSG at retirement relates to what you were saying, it was poorly received. So I’m not sure I would do it again right away because it turns out that when you are retired, you pay less CSG than when you are active. I was thinking we would do something intelligent, we would lower the contributions for the active workers because we need that to free up work, and we would increase the CSG for everyone, all workers would benefit from this reform. What is true is that retirees did not benefit because they no longer pay contributions. Afterward, we corrected it up to 2,000 euros, but for retirees over 2,000 euros, I must say what it is, I took from them... I increased their CSG rate. So it’s not unfair, it relates to what Mr. was saying, it’s not unfair in regard to the nation because it puts them at the same CSG rate as employees. But I simply tell Mr. that it’s an idea we like to debate like this, the day we did it, people liked it less. In any case, I experienced it, I can tell you people do not like it. And then they think it’s my idea alone. No, I will now quote you! I will do like Mr. TRABELSI, I will say it was Stéphane from Rodez who suggested the thing!

Stéphane BULTEL

(inaudible)

Emmanuel MACRON

Excuse me?

Stéphane BULTEL

(inaudible)

Emmanuel MACRON

So we come to the ceiling. It is that beyond... I was talking about taxes and I was joking because I said it’s never easy after all. With... what is proposed at this stage but which is subject to discussion, we will nevertheless move towards other balances because in the future system we will have a ceiling that will be set at 3 passes, I don’t want to be technical but it’s the ceiling of Social Security, that is to say 10,000 euros. This means that we will make high incomes contribute more than we did until now, which is an important point. And then, in fact, in the new system, we will make them contribute more up to a certain point and then we will cap pensions at that moment. The question then, I will come back to it because it was asked of me regarding the most modest pensions but it applies to everything, is that people will then have the system they want and if they want to go for additional pensions they can have it but it is no longer the contributory system. So I believe that by raising the ceiling — that was the commissioner’s proposal, but that too is up for discussion because some criticize it, it is part of the exchanges with social partners — it goes in the direction you mentioned because we include in the collective system, in national solidarity, people earning up to about 10,000 euros in salary. But at the same time we cap the right to a pension per month and we also cap the pension they will be entitled to. There you go. So on the taxation part, on large pensions we have done the work, on the part now of the ceiling it is part of the negotiation but you are right that it is one of the points that allows for rebalancing. And you are right to say that in certain liberal professions it is already a point that allows for certain solidarities between levels of remuneration. And so it is something that we need to keep. When I was talking about transitions on certain schemes it is something we want to keep. So whether it concerns lawyers, I know that accountants also care about it and others, it is part of the concerns that were raised, when I said several things that are specific will be preserved, these mechanisms will be preserved at least during the transition period and perhaps even in the target system. But your idea, your proposal is very relevant and is one of the points but it needs to be made transparent as we have done here because afterwards it needs to be clear for everyone. So precisely, Madam, on retirement, on this term of complementary, additional retirement, I speak under the control of the high commissioner, the complementary retirement system is integrated into our system. So here we have a universal system, everyone will be in it. However, what is true is that it does not prevent people from contributing additionally to improve their retirement. But I believe first that if we want to have a true solidarity and universal system, everyone must have a decent pension through the general system. And I care a lot about this because if we start saying you will have small pensions but you can... It’s not true. People with fractured careers, people with modest careers, it is not true that they will improve their retirement by contributing on the side, they often cannot. Well. So that’s also why I insist on having this contributory minimum of 1,000 euros which is currently at 970 euros because we need to maintain this purchasing power through solidarity. Then in a recent law that was enacted last summer called the so-called Pact law, we developed a system of indeed additional retirement, retirement savings mechanisms that you can have elsewhere, that the company can do, that it can contribute to. This can be very good for our employees, it’s good for the economy because it’s savings that is then reinvested in the economy and allows our companies to operate, to invest, that’s very good. But I’m not going to tell you that I base the system on that. I want first that we base it on solidarity because otherwise it would recreate other injustices. The retirement savings system that we can have, it is good, we have improved it, we have simplified it, we have enhanced it. So that goes in your direction but we need to be careful because afterwards it can create other types of injustice. If you are self-employed, if you are in a small business, very rarely will a company help you. You are self-employed, it’s just you, when you are in a small business, well the company does not have the means to help you move towards a system. When you are in a large group or when the boss is more affluent, he will help you, he can contribute to a retirement savings system. So it’s very good that it exists but I don’t want our citizens’ pensions tomorrow to depend on a retirement savings system. It should come in addition when we can, when the company can, that’s very good, it’s good for people, it’s good for the economy, but the heart of the system and its balance must rest on the universal regime that we are creating. That is very, very important to me because otherwise over time people will degrade the pension by saying you just have to do something on the side and there, there, that would be a lie. Because then we would enter a system that, year in and year out, would become what we call a capitalization system where we would tell people that in fact you build your pension on your own. That is not what we want to do, that is not what we are doing. We remain in a distribution system, you earn rights but it is the workers of tomorrow who will pay you and that is very important. Then, Mr. Mayor, Mr. President, first of all, we must not be mistaken, today’s pensions as well as tomorrow’s pensions are a reflection of active life and therefore it is according to what you earn, what you contribute, that you have a projection in terms of retirement. So the pension system is not a mechanism for territorial planning or for over-correcting these inequalities, it is absolutely impossible. So the territories that are the poorest where there are workers who are struggling, it is true that it is those where you then have retirees who are the most in difficulty. But I cannot ask the pension system to correct that. I will improve this situation, we will collectively improve it by revaluing small pensions, that is an important point, by bringing everyone into the system. Because you were rightly talking about rural areas and I mentioned it briefly earlier, in our rural areas today, today’s retirees are retirees from a system that was still very poorly designed where often they did not contribute or they under-contributed, and therefore your retirees today in rural areas are retirees where often the pension is below the contributory minimum, sometimes below the minimum old-age pension, which is madness. I say this for all the elderly, all those who know them, they need to be told to go and apply for the minimum old-age pension. And very often they do not do it because they are afraid of the inheritance tax. But at some point, one must be able to live. It is not normal for someone to live with 450 euros of pension, alone. If he is alone with 450 euros, he is entitled to the minimum old-age pension, he is at 970, we have revalued it. So very often, the retirees you have today, they had under-contributions when they were artisans or merchants. When they were farmers, they had a system that is much less generous than the current system, and therefore they have very small pensions. Tomorrow’s retirees, even in the most rural areas, will not be in this situation because they will all be included in the new system so they will all have at least the contributory minimum. It is true that some may complain when we say: "you will contribute more equally." But they will enter a system where they will also have more equal rights, so that is a very important point. After that, the way to correct on the territory is to have a real planning policy, and it is in territories that are in decline, as I was talking about earlier with your parliamentarians or other mayors, to have accessibility through digital means, through roads, to open up. That’s it, it’s about giving energy back to the territory, it’s the fight you are leading. But it is not the pension system that we should ask to correct this point. Then, you asked me about hardship. Hardship will be integrated into the system. I have said it, I do not love this word because it gives the impression that work is hard. But what does it mean? It means that there are working conditions that are not the same, there are risks, difficulties, stress that are not the same. It has already started, the 2014 reform allowed for advances on this point. We have already taken 4 criteria out of 6 that are already integrated. Now, in what we are doing and in the system, we will have to integrate all of them, but refine them. And for me, when I say that it is a deep reform, we have mentioned it several times, of work, it is that when I look at our country today, the stress we have in many professions, the difficulties, let’s speak frankly, we have a crisis of work. And for me, that is almost the most important thing, and it is what lies behind this anxiety about pensions. We have the crisis linked to the unemployment rate, we are the only major country in Europe that has not won against mass unemployment. We are in the process of reducing it, we have made reforms at a rapid pace and we are investing in training. But there is today, we must recognize and see it, a form of malaise at work. Many people are losing the sense of work. I mean by that that they no longer understand the meaning of their work, they have a discomfort, and the development of digital technology, the fracturing of work has created this. What we call burnout is developing and it is a reality. And careers have not evolved enough and are managed as they were 20 years ago. And so we have, in our country today, to rethink work, to rethink it in daily tasks, to give it meaning again, all of us. That is a societal project, it will not happen with a snap of the fingers either. It is perhaps about giving ourselves rules so that people understand what they are really doing, that in a company, we fully share the project, that we address issues of stress at work, and that everything we generically call hardship is taken into account, taken into account in career development and then in retirement. I insist on this because it is not just about retirement. If you do not take into account in career development these risks, these situations of malaise, it does not wait for retirement. That is what creates situations of suicide, stress or sick leave. When we say that there are many sick leaves in a company or in a particular sector, it is because people are unhappy in their work. No one wants to be unhappy in their work. And so it is that we, collectively, as employers, whether it is the State or a company, a small business, we have a problem, so we need to talk about it and put things back on the table. That is for me one of the projects that must start to be discussed now, but which is an essential project for the coming years. So yes, in the next system, we will take into account to calculate the pension your exposure to risk, night work, the physical risk you may take in certain situations, whether you are a soldier, gendarme, or police officer. They cannot have the same careers as others and that should provide a bonus. And thus allow for much shorter careers because there is a particular risk. People who are exposed to chemical substances, we have seen it in the news. I always think of the employees when we talk about these risks. We experienced an industrial disaster in Rouen which fortunately today has not resulted in any casualties. Finally, the first exposed are the employees, there too. We must be able to take into account in career management and in retirement. So all of this will be integrated into the system, and I do not want it to be fixed for that matter. It must evolve because it changes, and we are also smarter, but we must be able to integrate it into the career, public as well as private, I will come back to that in a moment. Because today, since it is a system that will be unified, we must integrate it everywhere. But our system lacks a deep social dialogue. Essentially, we have placed social dialogue issues, it seems to me, in the wrong places in our country. We have insufficiently nourished social dialogue, the dialogue of social partners, between social partners and the State, on this subject which is for me the primary subject. I have seen many union and employer leaders in recent weeks, I have talked a lot with them, and I know that they are carrying it. We have differences in perception, but everyone is ready to engage on this and therefore it must be integrated into the new system.

You spoke to me about an independent authority. How will the system be regulated? For me, there are three things. First, the framework law that the parliamentarians will have to vote on must define golden rules, intangibles. It must state: the system must guarantee this for retirees, guarantee such a base value for the point. The mechanism, for example, even the indexing of the point must be in the golden rule, in my opinion. We must agree in advance on its modalities, but the calculation bases for the point, the legal age, and the fact that there is a financial balance must be established. We will say: we will not launch a new regime if it is unbalanced, so it must be at zero. But in the golden rule, it must be stated that the regime must always be balanced, because we are taking responsibility. That’s the first point, the golden rule must be voted on by the parliamentarians. The second point is that every year, there must be an independent authority that states where we stand. It must say exactly whether the system is balanced or not, and why it is not balanced. Is it because contributions are decreasing due to unemployment? Is it because there is an increase in life expectancy and therefore retirees are living longer? The why is important. We have just been told about a state of imbalance, but the independent authority, not the government, not social partners, independent, and it will be defined by law, must say every year: here is whether there is an imbalance or not, and therefore whether the system needs to be adjusted or not, and here is why there is one. Let me explain. If we enter into mass unemployment again, if we have an economic crisis. Personally, I do not want us to adjust the shortfall we will have by telling people: "we are going to lower your pensions." That’s why this is in the golden rule. I have heard recently, I was talking about it yesterday with Philippe MARTINEZ who came to my office, he told me: "in Sweden, there are more poor retirees than in France." He is right, but why? Because the Swedish system is not at all the system we think it is. It is a system that is, partly by the way, based on capitalization, where pensions can decrease. In Sweden, at the time of the 2007 crisis, they automatically adjusted the system, it is not at all the rule I am stating, by lowering pensions. That’s how they created even more working poor. We will put that in the golden rule by saying: we block, we are not allowed to do that, because otherwise it would be unfair, it is the retirees who pay for mass unemployment. So at that moment, we need to ask for an additional contribution either from companies, or from the remaining employees, or state solidarity in the system to get through this period, or decide to work longer but keep the fundamentals. So, one, golden rule. Two, independent authority. Three, a college that will have to monitor every year and make decisions. When I say college, I think it is necessary, to monitor and be able to make decisions each year. First, every year, parliamentarians must express themselves in the finance law and the social security financing law. I see the chairwoman of the Commission who is here and several parliamentarians at the back of the room. It is legitimate because the new system will have a part of national solidarity. It is normal that it is the elected representatives of the nation who decide it, so every year, they will have to express themselves. But then, since the system also largely relies on contributions, contributions are paid by all of us as workers, it is normal that the social partners, those who represent the workers, are around the table in a responsible manner. And it is a real new management when we talk about social dialogue. For me, it is a new social contract that we are inventing in this pension system. It has no equivalent, it has never existed in our country. But I want there to be a real co-decision taken in this college, by our parliamentarians, who must be selected from all political backgrounds, and the representatives of employees, of all those who will make it live. So that is also to be invented, and they will have to make decisions every year. Regarding the solidarity part, obviously, it is normal that it is the legislator who, on the part dependent on the State, takes it. Here’s how things will evolve but that does not mean… We will overhaul the system, that’s it, we are inventing a new system, it is more transparent and fairer, but it will evolve as needed according to clear rules that will be taken by the community and no longer by the government alone. It is no longer possible. We share responsibilities. So, Thomas! Thomas did not really ask me a question about pensions but fundamentally about ecology, rightly so. First of all, you are right. You gave me a huge jab from behind by saying that I only did hashtags and that I didn’t care. I argue that this is not fair, but it must be argued through actions. You know, your generation that is coming into citizenship, my generation that is in political responsibility, is the first that has concrete things to do. We paid tribute to Jacques CHIRAC, who was a great president, who was the first to express ecological awareness when he said "our house is burning, we turn our heads and look elsewhere." That was nearly 20 years ago. Today, it is no longer the time for indignation and awareness. That was the time of Jacques CHIRAC and those who were a bit behind him. Then, there was the easier time for those who had to pass laws for the future. In the last 5, 8 years, we were making great laws and saying: in 2040-2050, you will see what you will see. We, we are not lucky, you and I, you as citizens and I as president, we must make decisions now. I cannot let you say that we have done nothing. That is not true. No. If we take climate change, I will still defend my cause and my piece of the pie, if we take climate change, France has a situation… I am speaking in front of your mayor who is a former EDF employee, we have a chance, our nuclear fleet, because nuclear energy, along with renewables, is what allows us to produce the cleanest non-intermittent energy. It is clear, and I look at our neighbors who have sometimes shut down nuclear power, like the Germans, they have reopened coal and they pollute much more. So we have this trajectory. What have we decided to do next? For the first time, we committed in the five-year term, I did not speak for the future, we said: "we will close all the coal plants that we have left." There are 5. I can invite you, if you want, to come with me and go talk to the employees. When you have in Saint-Avold, when you have in Le Havre or elsewhere thousands of employees to whom you say: "we believe in ecological transition, we want to reduce emissions, guys, tough luck, we are closing the plant..." That’s it, we are in practical work now, we are in practical work. So we are going through it, it must be done. I will not let you say that we are doing nothing, that is false, but it is difficult. We must rather help the government to do it and explain it. And behind, what we do each time is to build coherent projects and therefore projects that are in biomass, projects that are in renewable energies or reconversion. But it does not happen with a snap of the fingers, that is not true. Secondly, we have banned all new explorations and exploitations of hydrocarbons on our territory. I had no one with me who came to explain to the Guyanese: "oh, friends, all your neighbors have oil wells, they are exploiting them, we tell them it’s the new Mexico, but you, it’s over." I fully own that because I believe in it. Don’t tell me that I don’t believe in it. But that, we need to go tell the people. So we have a problem too, it’s that we are always wanting more, but no one looks at the transition. That’s about CO2 emissions. We talk about biodiversity. I want us to get rid of pesticides. Don’t tell me that I haven’t done anything and that I only do hashtags. If France had not been there, we would have been back to 15 years on glyphosate, because we fought for 5 years, we are even trying to do it in 3 years. But I am not going to explain to the son of Madame that I am going to ask him to do it in a year and a half or to get rid of glyphosate immediately, while 500 kilometers away, there is a Spanish or German competitor in his sector, by the way it would be more Dutch, who is allowed to go for it, I kill him. So I need to get other Europeans to move at least as fast as I do. That’s life. So what I often say, the youth’s indignation on this subject, I need it to make us all move collectively. But we are in the time of practical work. I need an indignation that contributes and helps, that helps to clean up polluted rivers, that helps to educate in schools to raise awareness about selective sorting, that helps to raise awareness and push for change on all these issues, and that helps me explain to people to whom we are asking for very tough changes. Otherwise, we end up in a crazy world where there are, on one side, people saying "you are never going fast enough, you are not doing enough on ecology, you are only doing hashtags," and on the other side, people saying: "you are killing us with your ecology stuff because I am a farmer, I can’t even make a living, I am in a company and you are closing everything." So our nation needs to know how to come together to say: we will be uncompromising, because for your generation, we must get out of dependence, reduce CO2, be our objectives and go faster and faster. But we need to change behaviors. So my message is: you are completely right, it is at least as important as pensions, and for me, it is very important. There is a citizens' convention that, for the first time, is being established on Friday. No country has done what we are doing. We randomly selected 150 citizens to help us find concrete solutions and move faster. But it must be an agenda of solutions now, it can no longer be an agenda of incantations or indignations, first because it is too easy to be indignant. It’s too easy. I need the energy of everyone. If you are indignant, come help me. What’s next?

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Three questions.

Emmanuel MACRON

Then I have a very important and technical question about family rights. Dear madam, women, as you said, today the system is quite unfair because if you have one child, two children, you have no rights to this pension. No rights. With the third child, you have a massive entitlement, and there is even one for the couple. So what is true is that what is being proposed, which is up for debate, seems to me to be a fairer system and it allows, I think, to respond to what you are looking for since there will be points awarded. I am looking to be precise and not to say anything foolish. For each child and from the first child, it will ensure that there is no discrimination based on the number of children because there is nothing that justifies going from 2 to 3 and jumping from 0 to 10%. And so it is 5% from the first child. And so what is true is that, in some cases, there are people who will not have the same increase as they had before, but it is more linear. If I can use that term. And so I think it is fairer, it seems to me. So that is a point to be debated and it has been discussed with family associations, and I thank you for your commitment because these are associations that do a lot, but I believe we are creating family rights that are fairer. It starts from the first child and not this threshold effect, and it also allows for a valuation throughout the career and avoids, it also allows both in terms of increases and in terms of bonuses related to children to be fairer. Then on the survivor's pension. It is better for women, of course. Now where he is right is that, as you said yourself, the system today is one that is very favorable to men. The system, yes. Beyond 2. The current system is one that will no longer create bias between one, two, or three children. It is linear, it is just related to the number of children starting from 1. And it is true that it is a system that will be less favorable to men than the current system, which creates a small bias when you are above 3. Survivor pensions. There have been many concerns on this subject.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

And many questions.

Emmanuel MACRON

First, survivor pensions, I will be clear. All those who have them - it happens that it is mostly women who have survivor pensions - will continue to have them. Those who are retired and have survivor pensions, no change. Nothing. The system for all those who are retired or at 50% of retirement, it lives its life, it does not move anymore. It does not move anymore, it goes until the end. It accompanies each person until death. So it will not move anymore. In the new system, we will keep the survivor pension. We need it today. The retirement inequality between women and men is 42%. Imagine. Survivor pensions correct this, and through survivor pensions, it is only, it is only, it’s 30%. So they have a redistributive effect. The system we propose on survivor pensions also seems fairer to me. Moreover, it has been debated and it has been, I must say to be perfectly honest, proposed by associations and representatives. And it allows to preserve the standard of living, it is calculated on the household alone. When we look at the situation today, 90% of survivor pensions are for women, because they have a longer life expectancy and spouses who are on average older than they are. The survivor pension increases the monthly pension by an average of 650 euros. That is the reality today. So we want to keep that for those who have this system. But what we want to do is to calculate the survivor pension of tomorrow based on the standard of living of the household and to guarantee - as proposed under his control by the High Commissioner - 70% of the standard of living, because there are situations that were a bit unfair, where the wife sometimes earned a good living, the husband’s pension was about the same, the survivor pension was quite low, but the lost standard of living was significant. When you receive nothing, the survivor pension did not quite allow for the same life because it is still a share that is quite reduced from your deceased spouse's pension. Divorce, moreover, is indeed a final settlement. What we are doing is looking at the standard of living of the household and saying the survivor pension must guarantee you 70% of the household's standard of living and thus a system that will allow for redistribution but we keep the principle of the survivor pension. We have calculation rules that are also clearer, fairer, between the schemes and that are part of the subjects to be debated to refine it technically. I refer you to the report that was submitted in July and that details all this with typical cases, but which shows that it is a very good system. However, I do not want people who today receive it, who are sometimes under stress, to get confused. Zero consequences, no change for those who already have the survivor pension.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

You have two other questions over here.

Emmanuel MACRON

Sorry, yes, excuse me, you are right. Yes, there is Mathilde who asked me the question about the European system. You are absolutely right on this subject. First, what we need to do at the European level is to create convergence. The problem in Europe is that we have created a single labor market, we are 28 today, we will be 27 tomorrow. With social systems, rules that are very different. We have already fought on posted workers, it affects those in agriculture or construction, because we had many employees coming from other European countries legally but working under very derogatory conditions. We have already started collectively to converge in this way. We said, 'You do not have the right to work below the minimum wage of the country and we check your working conditions, so that we cannot finance. And thirdly, we can carry out inspections, we stop the worksite if these conditions are not met. So someone coming from Bulgaria where the minimum wage is much lower than in France can no longer come to work in France with the Bulgarian minimum wage, that’s over. Then there is the issue of contributions that are not the same and that create another injustice for the employer. And so what we are doing. What we proposed, which was at the heart of the European project that I defended, is two things. It is to say we must move towards a European minimum wage and we must move towards a convergence of our social systems so that systematically, we have started to do this with some, it is not systematic, when you work in the country you pay the equivalent of the social contributions of the country. And then we compensate between our countries for the differences. We arrange among ourselves. But to avoid creating bias and to avoid, pardon the anglicism, social dumping, that is to say that basically you come from a low-cost country and you come to take the jobs of others. So that is what we advocate. It is the reform that needs to be done. For me, that is the priority because if we manage to do that gradually, we will achieve a convergence of economic and social systems. The second thing to do. I have also advocated that when we give structural funds to a country, we ask it to improve the social system. For about ten years, we have diverged from our logic in Europe. Europe was that the poorest countries would converge towards the standard of living of the richest countries. And we have countries that sometimes chose to use structural funds not to improve their social situation but to maintain things and engage in dumping. It turns out that today we have a problem. The situation you denounce that several are experiencing, those people no longer have a workforce at home. You have countries where today they have lost 20, 30% of their active population who went to work elsewhere because the salary was better. So I agree with you on retirement but that will be a step that will come just after. I think the priority is already to have a system of work and social rights that converges and that reduces gaps, biases, inequalities so that people can move freely and that we do not have the dysfunctions we have known. If we achieve that, we have a retirement system that will increasingly align with one another. Then on this retirement system, I have a problem, I look at all our neighbors, they are almost all at a legal age between 65 and 67 years. So it is not like we are going to say we will all switch to the same system. So here too, when we say no we must evolve, we must look at how our neighbors do and where they are. We are very out of step compared to many others, very out of step. We have a system where the legal age is one of the lowest in Europe and where most systems are at legal ages of 65, 67 years, and so in the dynamics, this is something we must consider. Some want to go back. I am not saying that we should align with the highest. Not at all. I think we need to choose our system with these balances. But we must acknowledge that our system is not viable with its balances. We know it, that’s why we are moving. But I think we have others who have gone too far and created systems that are too unequal. There are countries in Europe where there is really a situation of retirees for. And that will come later. I think we first need to build a good system. Then the last point that goes in your direction and that will allow me to answer the last question from Thibault. It is this. Sorry Fabien, excuse me. Fabien. It is to say that we are creating a real universal system with this reform. This means that you will be able to locate yourself today when you leave the country, you were talking about Europe, when you go to another European country, good luck to redo your rights. The portability of rights goes with a universal system because you never leave the system since everyone. And it also helps to bring things closer together. Because when you have to switch from one system to another constantly, it is less readable and there is no real Europe of pensions. Here are the few elements I wanted to bring to your question. Last point, what you denounced is exactly why we want to make the reform. The idea of saying that it is not fair that there is a difference in hardship depending on the category or status you are in, that it is not fair that retirement rights are not the same between two workers depending on their employers. It is linked to the fact that today you have 42 systems. That’s it. You have exactly denounced the current situation. With a lot of clarity. It is not fair at all. So what we are doing precisely with the points system is to bring everyone into a unique system that means that the worker who has the same activity as another worker, regardless of their city, regardless of their employer, will be in the same system and will contribute in the same way, and will have the same retirement. And then what we want to succeed in doing is by integrating risks, what we call today hardship, elements of difficulties. If you have a worker who works at night, it is normal that he retires earlier than one who works during the day, because he is exposed to other risks, it is more difficult, and he will do that regardless of his employer. What you denounced, which makes it impossible to calculate rights, that there are injustices even though we did the same job, that we can no longer find our way, and that hardship is not taken into account in the same way. This is exactly the problem of having 42 systems. And so moving towards a unique points system. This is what allows us to address this injustice or this lack of clarity. Since you will only have one system. The one where you contribute sometimes.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Mr. President, we have about twenty minutes left, as we had considered that we could debate until 10 PM.

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

I have four rapid-fire questions from DDNA, from the South-West, from Le Parisien, from Dauphiné Libéré. Stay with me since it concerns you particularly. Are parliamentarians, deputies, ministers, senators, and the president affected by this reform?

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes. Yes.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

I must confess that on this subject, we have of course dozens of questions.

Emmanuel MACRON

I saw it in your newspaper when I came in that morning. There is a lady, I don’t know if she is in the room, who said, ‘I am sure they will find a way to shield themselves from this.’

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

That’s about it.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, I say there is a system. Sorry. Nonsense. No, there is only one system, there is only one system. So obviously all the elected officials, the parliamentarians, and all the bonuses that exist - I say it, I am quite clear - I am the first President of the Republic who has resigned from the jobs and securities he had. I am alone. There has never been anyone before me. I resigned from the civil service and all my securities because I believed that one cannot be credible in saying ‘we must take risks, we must change, and transform the country, if we do not take risks ourselves. But that was not the case before. But I just say that all the elected officials, the whole system, there is a unique system. So we are not going to start doing - I had earlier, there is not a special regime for such and such a regime - there will not be one for the elected officials.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you for your answer.

Emmanuel MACRON

Moreover, I say this because the elected officials who worked with the High Commissioner carried it themselves. Finally, I think everyone is aware of that. And I also say, if I may take just a minute on this - the mayor said it, there are other mayors in the room whose faces I recognize - we need to be careful in our country on this subject, because we do have a tendency to think that everyone is corrupt, which is not good for the Republic in general, it does not do anyone any good. There are people who behave badly in all professions, that is true. There are in all professions, and it is not written that a profession is immune from having thugs, from having people who behave badly, who are twisted, even people who go mad. It is the human soul, but for goodness' sake, let us be careful collectively. We need the elected officials of the Republic, they are people who commit themselves. You speak of elected officials in a generic way, when one is mayor of their municipality it is rare that one makes a living. There is a majority of elected officials who are volunteers of the Republic. Whatever we say implicitly, they are always privileged without masters. There has been a past system with bonuses that may have existed and that was constituted, not just for the elected officials. For many systems, when, fundamentally, when the system was generous, when the country was doing well, when we were in the thirty glorious years, we sedimented a lot of things. It is not the end, that is to say, the people who benefited from it are responsible. I refuse to divide the country like that, it is not the people who have special regimes today who are, by doing so, building for themselves. This country built that at one point, we must change it because the country has new realities. We must not divide, but we need the elected officials of the Republic, they will all be concerned by the reform, but the implicit behind this question is still a bit to say ‘they are always apart, they have a better regime, that is not true. Moreover, I say it. The municipal elections are coming soon. All those who want and can engage, that is sometimes part of volunteering. The Republic needs it. And you will see. It is not a sinecure.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, Mr. President. Now we will move on to a final series of questions. We have 20 minutes left, hands are going up. We will have about thirty questions that have been asked. So, Madam, you have a question over here, Madam too, come, come, do not worry. Go ahead, Madam here first, then after that, Madam. Go ahead, Madam, ask your question. I see you, I see you. Do not worry.

Sandra

Hello, Sandra, I am 39 years old, I am from Rodez, the question I had is the impression we have is that with each government, there is its reform on retirement. You were talking earlier about the imprescriptibility of the elements of your new system, I wanted to know how you can and plan to guarantee this imprescriptibility? What will prevent another government in 10, in 15 years from modifying this system, from making a new reform like you are going to do in your mandate in the coming months? Thank you, Mr. President.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you very much. I will pass the microphone just next to you because you have been wanting to ask a question for a long time. Go ahead.

Christine

Hello, Mr. President. So I am part of the first company in France, my name is Christine, I am a metalworker in Espalion, it is true that your comments about keeping long careers are reassuring. It is also reassuring for young apprentices who commit themselves from the age of 15-16 in our trades. The question of hardship has also come up already, and so I will not go back on it even if somewhere I have difficulty seeing how you will be able to implement the fact that people who work in a more physically difficult way will be able to benefit from more advantages without creating new pensions or new systems... And also the question that I think is a bit of a tease for all artisans is about the auto-entrepreneur regime, will you also align them with our regimes which are much more unfavorable in this regard? Thank you very much.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you very much, Madam. I see there is a question over there, Sir with the blue sweater, can a microphone reach him here? Very well, Julien. Short question, Sir, introduce yourself.

François ARVORDE

Yes, François ARVORDE from Cransac, I would like to question Mr. President about the management of complementary funds, you see. In the context of the pension reform, can you put an end to this opaque management of complementary pension funds, of the Agir-Arrco regimes that are now merged? Can you also encourage the complementary pension funds to align their management with that of the Cnav by allowing substantial economies of scale that would benefit future retirees? One billion euros saved per year is not negligible. Simply two things, there are in the complementary funds about 1,400 administrators who go to Paris 3 or 4 times a year plus the gifts and all that you see, can you not do something?

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you. I have a question over there, go ahead, Sir. Short question, likewise.

Jean-Philippe COUDERC

Good evening, Mr. President, Jean-Philippe COUDERC, I am a merchant in Rodez. Well, I will not talk about my profession, I think there are people who do much more complicated work than mine. What I would like to tell you is that I would like to talk about the nation in general because I am worried about the head, I am worried about the environment, I am worried about work. That is to say, if our country, our region, or our city is not rich, no one will benefit from it, that is the first thing. After your method, well I find it interesting because it is important to dialogue with someone like you, but I find that your method, on the other hand, is old-fashioned because for me the social partners are no longer representative. And I think we need to find another method, more modern. And then those who have big privileges at the moment, especially the big pensions or those who left before, are the least favorable to share at the moment.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Go ahead, Mr. President will respond to you, I have a question here, Sir over there, can a microphone, please Quentin, thank you very much. Go ahead, Sir, likewise, short question.

Rémi AGRINIER

Hello, Rémi AGRINIER, a farmer in the municipality of Aguessac, near Millau. So my main question would be about the increase in contributions. Today as a farmer we contribute 21%, we will certainly go to 28%: what temporization then over what period will this increase take place because we cannot do this overnight? And about the future of our MSA, today the single window is very much envied by all the competitors, so to speak, and will this simplification tool remain, what will it become?

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, Sir. Madam over there, go ahead.

Sarah VIDAL

Sarah VIDAL, I am an elected official in Rodez. Mr. President, we know that the level of retirement pensions is linked to the care of dependency and the fifth risk. The lower the level of retirement pension, the higher the cost of care through the APA for a resident in a nursing home is for the State and the departmental councils. Today we know that accommodation exceeds an average of 2,500 euros when the average pension does not exceed 1,330 euros per month. There is therefore a need to maintain a level of pension allowing future retirees to pay for their stay in EHPAD or home care services. The future pension reform will therefore have an impact on the care of dependency and in this context, and as has been mentioned in a parliamentary report, could the government consider allowing establishments to practice differentiated prices based on the retirement pensions of residents through a system that could resemble that of early childhood structures with a progressive scale? Thank you.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you very much. Mr. President, I will let you respond and then we will see if we have a little time to move on to other questions.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, that was the first question, and you are absolutely right about why the system shifts every time it is out of balance. Because the system has not been balanced for a long time with contributions, which is not shocking because we have made choices of solidarity, for example family policy, for example survivor pensions, and so at some point, since there is solidarity, it is the tax that contributes, it is the State that comes to contribute, and the system can build imbalances. And then there is the evolution of age. So the system we built with rigidities has had regular crises, jolts that have justified reforms each time. These reforms have always been the same, which is to say we have a financial problem, we need to make you work longer. There is the reform of the early 1980s for retirement at 60, and then since then reforms that change either the contribution period or the legal age, according to the last two examples, the 2010 reform changed the legal age, the 2014 reform after the long careers decree is about going back but accelerating the increase in the contribution period. What is the justification? No one woke up saying I am going to reform the system because everything is fine. It was the demographic and economic imbalance. We are doing what is not a reform, what is a re-foundation. I believe this is the real difference with everything we have been doing for over 20 years. It is when we acknowledge that the system can no longer balance due to demographics, because it has become too complicated with 42 schemes, because the work life is changing, that people are moving from one system to another. So we are re-founding this system with new rules, we are doing it like in 1945. If you take from 1945 until the end of the Glorious Thirty, the system hardly changed, hardly changed. By the way, I remind you that at that time the legal retirement age was higher than today with people who retired and lived much shorter lives. And that was the case throughout the Glorious Thirty. But the system did not change for decades because it was well thought out, well balanced for a society that was catching up, a society of long industrial risks where there was no unemployment. We are rethinking it, we are re-founding it transparently after discussion and according to the rules I just mentioned earlier. This system we say will start in 2025 at balance, which has never been the case with other reforms. They wanted to build for the future balance and then each time they were caught by the patrol, you know that well. They made reforms for 5 years, 10 years. I made the choice, and I stand by it, not to make a reform that brings me benefits during my term. Some are actually reproaching me for this, saying you are not saving enough, it is not going fast enough. I made this long-term choice because I no longer want to find ourselves with people like you just said or like you who tell me we no longer believe it, anyway you are doing your reform, you are making us work 2 more years, in 5 years you or your successor will come back to us and do the same thing. So I choose to say this reform is not made for the immediate, it will bear its fruits, it will start in 2025 and will bear all its fruits in 2040. So because it is a deep transformation, because we are re-founding the system if we re-found it well we will no longer need to change it because it will have integrated the parameters. Second point, what has never existed in the current system is that we create transparency for everyone, we create the same system so we immediately recreate some leeway because everyone contributes for everyone. There are no more silos which were a huge rigidity but I immediately state the rules for the evolution of my system. And so why I will not need, I bet that we will not come back to you soon to shake it up because first we will set the highest level, we will look at the legislative level that we will choose with the parliamentarians the golden rule but because we create a system that each year will give rise to independent expertise and responsibility of social partners and parliamentarians to evolve the parameters of the system transparently. So basically the complete balance of the system, its structure will no longer need to change and there will be no more new reforms. And what were the old reforms will be carried by everyone in a co-responsible manner in the natural evolution of the system. If we gain on average 2 more years of life over the next 15 years it is obvious that we will have to evolve it, it is obvious but it will not be again a law, it will be a decision of this college based on the independent authority. Because the authority will say, your system is no longer balancing, everyone is working longer. That's fine, you have solved the unemployment problem, things are getting better but people need to contribute more or longer or a little more. These are balances that will be created as many countries have succeeded in having a coherent system. So the instability that you rightly denounce is linked to the fact that we tried to do makeshift work and correct a system that no longer held because the foundations were no longer solid. Here we are recreating the foundations that are clear in terms of demographics, they are based on the report of the Council for Retirement Orientation which will be delivered at the end of November which will tell us exactly what we need for the regime to be at zero in 2025, based on the rules we set for ourselves and that we will have debated and the evolution. There you go. This does not mean that it is a system that will never change but it will change through negotiation and responsibility on an annual basis to gradually evolve according to needs. That was my answer to your question. Christine on craftsmanship, so on apprentices you are absolutely right. We believe in it a lot, we have a level of apprentices that has never been reached in the country because we have simplified the rules and everyone is playing the game — artisans, industrialists, large and small companies — and it is a tremendous success. It is a tremendous lever for integration into work, into responsibility and others. And so our apprentices, as soon as they enter apprenticeship they start contributing, it is recognized and they enter the long careers system. Regarding hardship, to be concrete how do I see things? First, there are the criteria that have started to be discussed by social partners, the famous six criteria we have, four of which exist today in the system since the 2014 law. The real difference with the current system, your question which is very pertinent is to say with hardship you are going to recreate special regimes. No, no because we are taking care of the functions, the everyday jobs and no longer a status. Today when we created the system of special regimes it was very hard to be a railway worker. We had, we drove a train in difficult situations, we boarded trains that were not at all in the comfort of today, we even had at the time what we called the escarbille bonus because we could get hit by sparks while circulating and so we took into account the hardship of railway workers and we took them as railway workers, in a status. And by the way, progressively, regardless of the function of the railway worker, even one who no longer drove a train but who was sometimes in administrative functions, he had the same status as the one who drove and therefore had the right to the same retirement, which for that matter is no longer quite fair. We slipped and lost the logic of hardship that initially led to the creation of special regimes by creating statuses. And this status creates two problems: first, hardship is not the same in a company, the one who drives the train, who repairs the tracks at night does not have the same hardship as the one who is in an office yet he has the same regime today, here the railway workers. And I say this it is not the fault of the railway workers, it is us who collectively made the system. And then there is another inequality, what we said, is when you drive a bus at RATP or outside of RATP you do not have the same conditions at all. Here we put everyone back in the same situation but we will give you bonuses in a way of points when your employer and you declare that you have working conditions that tick the boxes of these bonuses if I may say, to be very concrete. You work at night, we are in the same company, you work at night, I work during the day, you will accumulate more points than I do in the six months we will work together. And so artisans are the same depending on the conditions, that is what will be worked with the chambers, we will look at the reality. It will be declarative, there will be controls, we will also better involve occupational medicine. When I say we need to rethink work, we need to re-engage occupational medicine which is also experiencing a crisis and needs to be remobilized on this subject. But for people who are in situations that are more stressful than others, who are working at night, the time they are exposed to these situations will have a bonus. The real difference that makes us not recreate a status is that it is not attached either to the company or to the sector but to the reality of your work and that this bonus system lasts as long as you have this exposure. If tomorrow you no longer work at night but you go back to working during the day, you no longer receive the bonus. If tomorrow, you are no longer exposed to the same materials and you had a risk bonus, you no longer have it. So the system is much more transparent, and it is based on reality, if I may say, as we would say for taxes, as we know. There you go how we avoid recreating that. On self-employed workers, it is a subject, you can be sure, that the High Commissioner has been overwhelmed. I know the subject by heart, President STALTER did his job and shook us on the subject. Self-employed workers, not everything is bad, it is a regime that allows you to get a foot in the stirrup. From a fiscal and social standpoint, I think we need to keep things. On the system, it is not good in the long term, because we cannot have people who would never contribute, including for themselves. So I think what we need to aim for with the self-employed system is a system where there is a time when we get a foot in the stirrup, but for retirement, after a period, we must enter the system and contribute and earn points. This allows for a start, and then we enter the system. And I believe that is fair, otherwise we will recreate systems where people will not acquire points and will find themselves at 62 or 63 years old with nothing, with very small pensions. So I do not want, with today's self-employed workers, to recreate what we experienced with yesterday's farmers or yesterday's artisans. Then, François, well, you did not hold back on the complementary funds. So there, you dressed them for winter, operating costs, etc. Well, first I will still… You mentioned Agirc-Arrco. I will allow myself to make a small plea for Agirc-Arrco, in what they have done in recent years. They have been braver than us, because when I look at how the Agirc-Arrco regime, and I will come back to the question of one of your colleagues shortly, managed solely by social partners, complementary regimes, they have been braver than the government and legislators. They have sometimes made tough decisions on de-indexation, to balance the system, and they have managed to hold it together. So honestly, when I look at things, they have been quite brave in the past, sometimes more than us. However, where you are right, it was the heart of your question, the more regimes we have, the more we have regime managers, the more we have regime managers, the more we have operating costs. It is obvious. The more we bring people together, the more we reduce these operating costs and we manage to make intelligent savings, because these are not savings on benefits, these are savings on management, on operation. And so, the very spirit of what we want to do, by having a single points-based regime, is to converge all this little world, in the transition period, and indeed to have a single manager, a single fund. So, we will indeed, you said it very well, one of the advantages of the reform is that we will make a lot of savings on operating costs, because we will manage everyone in a unique way. So you will no longer have people in silos and many duplicates according to categories, and sometimes duplicates to manage the same career, because someone who moved from the independent regime to employee, then became self-employed and ended up hired in a local authority, good luck. So there, there will be a single manager. So we respond to your point, and I can reassure you. Jean-Philippe had a question that was related.

First of all, I thank you because I must say that it has been almost two and a half years since I became President of the Republic, and this is the first time I have been told that I am outdated because I want to involve too many social partners. No one had ever said that to me. You have said it to me. Well, very sincerely, I will defend why we involve social partners and what they represent. I think we are in the process of reinventing the grammar of social dialogue and what I once called a contractual Republic. What does that mean? I believe it is a large part of the French malaise and our problems on many issues. After the war, we built a system that was based on insurance. The worker contributed to cover risks. These contributions could pay for those who were victims of these risks, work accidents, occupational diseases, illness, old age, and so on. This fully justified having social partners, since it was the employee who contributed, and therefore it was the representatives of the employee, who were the unions, who managed it. All of this was normal. Over time, we gradually created a system that has become what we now call more solidaristic. We moved from an insurance mechanism to a solidarity mechanism, because we covered social risks, because gradually, we said: it is the tax that will pay and no longer the contribution. And we changed the nature of the system. Health insurance today is much more financed by taxes than by contributions. As a result, we changed, the social partners are associated with the National Health Insurance Fund, but are no longer strictly speaking the managers. The manager is someone appointed by the President of the Republic. The government has taken a larger role. Parliamentarians, therefore, vote on laws, balances, what we call a national objective for health insurance spending. This is legitimate, because it is in the name of the nation, they represent the matter and they vote on this balance. It is no longer the social partners who hold it. On unemployment, things have changed. The social partners, and even this summer, said: "you have mistreated us, you have not involved us." Why? Because employees no longer pay contributions for unemployment. You have not paid contributions since the beginning of this term. This is the famous reform where we almost eliminated all unemployment contributions, for employees, to transform them into the CSG. So it is a contribution they pay and no longer the tax. They are still involved, but they can no longer represent the same thing, they can no longer be the decision-makers, and I take responsibility for this decision which better compensates work, but above all corresponds to a governance we had to have, because why did we have an Unédic imbalance? Because for years and years, we had a role that was no longer clear between the social partners and the government, because the social partners could continue to manage as before, as in the time of the Glorious Thirties, a system that was no longer balanced, and they called for the guarantee of the State. The State paid. We accumulated more than 30 billion in deficit. It is not the fault of the unions and the social partners. We entered a system of mass unemployment, the system became unbalanced, more and more unemployed people, more people to compensate, and therefore we called for national solidarity. But the reality is that it is the tax that finances, so it must be the government and Parliament that decide, and no longer the unions. So there, on unemployment, we indeed have, and I take responsibility... We must reduce the role of the unions, so that it is a management that is much more assumed by the government and Parliament, that is to say those who represent the national interest and who are legitimate to represent the national interest, because they are elected by the people, which is not the case for the unions. On the other hand, your pension system and the pension system tomorrow is and will continue to be mainly financed by the contributions you pay as workers, and therefore it is legitimate that workers are represented in this framework, and with them, since there is a contribution from employers, indeed, the representatives of employers. This is what we call social partners. Social partners are the representatives of workers and the representatives of employers. From the moment you have a majority of the funding of this system coming from contributions, they are legitimate and that is why I want them to co-decide. It is not outdated at all, it is empowering. Where I think we have weakened our social democracy in the country and social dialogue is that we have sometimes placed social partners in situations of irresponsibility by saying: "you have the keys, but if it is too hard, we will come and put in the money." Well, they never agree, too easy. Now, we will put them in a position of responsibility, we co-decide, but within the golden rule, we cannot be in imbalance. So you will have to, with us, take their responsibilities. And then, I tell you very sincerely, I think we need social partners, because we need to structure dialogue at all levels in society. It cannot just be the government, Parliament, and each citizen. So we need social partners. What we want is for them to be more legitimate, so we want to clarify their role. This is what we are doing with all these reforms. This is what I am telling you. We clarify the role of social partners, and as a result, we empower them, which, in my opinion, allows them to better play this role. By empowering them and clarifying this role, my hope is that we allow the unionization rate in our country to increase. One of the problems we have, if you want the essence of my thought, is that we have a unionization rate that is far too low. When you say that unions are not legitimate, it is because we have a unionization rate that is one of the lowest in Europe. So workers and non-workers, that is to say, workers, need to see the interest, once again, in joining a union, or even creating new ones, to understand that this union is the one that co-manages important systems for them and also provides services locally. We need to reinvent unionism today. But I think it would be a bad idea to say that it needs to be eradicated, we need to do something more modern. We will reinvent otherwise something that continues to weave... Simply, we need to place them in the right context. When it is a national interest, when it is tax, when it is a universal system with justice among everyone, which is financed by tax, it is the government and Parliament that must have a say. When it is contributions and it is workers and businesses that pay, the representatives of businesses and workers are legitimate to have their say, to be around the table, but must do so responsibly, and therefore by telling them: "here are your red lines." There is no State that is a blind payer. But I wanted to make this point because it is very important. You are right afterwards about selfishness. I think that our country, I believe very deeply, what I want us to launch on work and careers, what we are launching on pensions, what we are launching, what we launched a year ago on health and that we will continue... The situation is very tough in hospitals, very tough. We are in the process of rebuilding the foundations of our country. Since I have been aware, I have heard that my country is in crisis. It is not in crisis. We have put all the patches on an exhausted system. We are in the process of rebuilding a pact with the nation. We have never done this in our history in peacetime, never. We have always done this after a war. And so it is normal that it is frightening. Yes, there are selfishness and a lot of things that do not work, but we need to be able to talk to each other everywhere, to say things transparently, to rebuild trust. I am especially worried when I see people who doubt everything, even scientists. There is a kind of ambient paranoia that is invading the country. So we need to calm minds, to calmly debate the facts, to indeed go and unearth selfishness wherever it is, proactively, without dividing the country. But what we are doing is rebuilding this pact, and I believe it is absolutely essential. I then had Rémi, on livestock. First, the MSA, the MSA, it is intended to enter the single system. Here too, the management costs are very high. I will not lie to you. It is a good thing to do this. That does not mean that... No, but yes, in relation to the whole... I see a gentleman who may be from the MSA behind, or who contributes to it. But if we look at it in relation to the system, it is obvious, it has been proven, it is in the report, and it is normal, it is not a criticism of the MSA. If I manage 100 people, I will achieve economies of scale, I will have the same computer system to manage them, I will have an accountant to manage them. If I break these 100 people into 10, and I say: "there are 10 teams to manage each 10 people," each will have its own information system. It is obvious. So you have basic investments, which means that when you have 40 regimes, it costs more. And it is not at all a reproach against any regime whatsoever. What we need to keep is the quality of service, because the truth is that the MSA, like other regimes, does not only liquidate pensions. It provides services, it supports farmers and helps them with the transition, it helps with training, it helps with installation. So let’s be very clear, several funds, including the MSA, have built, through history, functions that are not just functions of pension liquidation. What we will bring into common law, with a single fund, is the management and liquidation function of pensions. The services provided by the MSA are services that must continue to be provided to the agricultural world, and therefore where you are perfectly right, this part must be kept, built, and that is all the dialogue we have with each one. It is something that is not reducible to this management. You will agree with me that the MSA, like many other regimes, does not only liquidate and manage pensions. It does a lot of things to support the life of the farmer. These functions, these services to the farmer, must be retained. And so there you go, we will transform the model so that it can do this and that we find the means to finance it, as the chambers of agriculture do useful work, as many other organizations do locally. That, we will keep. On contributions, as I said, today, you will benefit from the reform when you are a farmer, first because of the CSG measure, and then because of the smoothing... I refer you in a very technical way, I think that in the July report, the specific cases and on the website of the high commissioner, but farmers have nothing to worry about regarding tomorrow's evolution. There are professions for which we need to discuss the transition, and it is harder. Madame was right earlier about lawyers, there are other liberal professions, not farmers. So on that, you will not be overcalled, also because we have this decrease in the CSG. And then the last question on dependency... Dependency is another continent and... Sorry, where is Sarah? Sarah, I know her. She is a municipal councilor of Mr. the Mayor. And so what you are saying is very accurate. This is the dependency project. I do not want to confuse minds by saying that we will link it to the pension system, or have it financed by pensions. The key question, there has been a first report that has been made, it is a project that we are in the process of opening, is to know how we can indeed make access to necessary services affordable for everyone at some point. And so what you are telling me, which is very accurate, is when we have a small pension, how are we going to enter a facility that is medicalized, or paramedicalized, and pay for it? The truth is that today, it depends on the types of establishments, but if it is so medicalized, we have assistance. There is already the autonomy benefit, but it is not sufficient. Today, we support families who are completely non-contributory, but for someone, it is true, who has a small pension, who is in the contributory system, who does not necessarily qualify for minimums, he will look... He has a small pension... Let’s take a teacher, who will have a pension of 1,100, 1,200 euros. It can be more for some depending on the end of career they had. He arrives, he is 65 years old... Many have talked to me about it. He is anxious because he thinks: "in 10 years, the children are working, it is hard for them, I am already helping them. The day I want to enter a nursing home or a medicalized home, what is it? 1,500, sometimes 1,700 per month."

No, but here, if you are more than 1,700 or 1,800, you are dealing with something that is much more medicalized. You can enter at 1005, 1007. Of course. At 1007, you enter a nursing home. No, but I’m telling you. The mayor tells me, you see, he has one at 1005, even. I didn’t say it. We must be honest… No, but it’s an interesting debate. Around 1007, you have them. Some go much further, depending on the degree of medicalization. We also need to agree. If you are totally dependent and indeed need a medicalized service, it sometimes goes above 2,000, but don’t tell me that all nursing homes and all retirement homes are at 2,000. That’s not true. So you have them in Rodez, the mayor says, at 1005. I’ve done my tour of France, so I’m starting to know. 1007, 1008, that’s the beginning. I’m not saying we have everything; if we are very dependent and from a certain age, we have a problem. Nevertheless, it could be 1005; you already have a problem when you reach 1,200. So the question is how we have a mechanism where we also call for national contribution and solidarity to finance it. That has a cost. It’s your taxes that pay if it’s the person who no longer pays for it. We must not deceive ourselves. So the question is how we finance dependency and make it solvable. That’s the project we have started to open. It should not be the retirement project, meaning we must allow access to dependency to be solvable for all retirees and alleviate this anxiety, but how will that happen? 1) Lower the cost by industrializing the offer. We must open more and more. We must succeed in lowering costs in home automation and others, and in support, because it’s a sector that is developing, what we call the silver economy. It is not said that costs will remain the same forever. We can also lower costs, lower the cost of installation, operation, and home automation. 2) We must also support healthcare professionals because in many of these nursing homes, healthcare professionals today are under stress, suffering professionally. Why? Because I remind you that historically, we created retirement homes, then nursing homes, to get the oldest people out of hospitals. They were not designed for what they are facing today, with people entering who are older and older, with greater dependency and the need for medical or quasi-medical care, and therefore more nursing or quasi-nursing staff is needed in these establishments. And so that is something we must think about and finance with managers, organizers, and local authorities. That is essential, and if we do not do it, we will not meet the needs. The more we have an adapted response, the more we limit the cost, because the wrong response would be to reintroduce over-medicalization in all nursing homes; that would not be a good response at all. We need to have a different offer depending on your needs. You are elderly and can no longer manage alone at home, but you can get up to have meals; you enter a nursing home that can be at 1,500 euros, in my opinion, because there is lighter support. You start to be dependent; you need more medical staff because you stay in bed, need feeding, and basic care. When you start to be much more dependent, or demented, or with behaviors that are dangerous to others, or with physical problems, which means you need medical supervision, that costs even more; you need better-trained staff. So we need to continue to structure this; it’s the dependency report, and we need to make it solvable for everyone. And so that means that indeed, we need to call for national solidarity, and we need to rethink our dependency system. So we will not do that overnight; it’s another project, but I wanted to give some perspectives. You are absolutely right, but it’s broader. But for me, it’s not the retirement system; it’s the dependency system that we will finance.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Go ahead, ask your question. A short question please. I will take 3 or 4 questions before finishing, if you allow me. So, madam had a question. The microphone will come to you. Here, madam. Go ahead, ask your question.

Benoîte

Good evening Mr. President, Benoîte, I am 32 years old, I live in Rodez, I have a very short question. So today, as a young worker, we can wonder what the system will be like in the next 30 or 35 years. And my question is very simple: could we not go much further and establish a universal pension for everyone, the same amount for everyone whether it is a farmer or a lawyer, a civil servant or even the President of the Republic? It’s up to you to decide!

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

We said no taboo subjects, so thank you for the question. Madam? Do you have a question? Go ahead. Short question! Same! Introduce yourself.

Edith GUCCINI

Mr. President, hello. Edith GUCCINI, osteopath, living in Vézins-de-Lévézou and also a farmer. I contribute to the RSI, to the CIPAV, and to the MSA as a solidarity contributor. So I heard your response and there is the speech therapist who is not here to comment, but when we are at 10.10% contribution to the CIPAV and that already represents 6,500 euros in contributions, when we earn 20,000 in taxable income, when we are told 28.12%, 4% CSG if we can count pragmatically as you like to be, there is a shortfall for the 14 that need to finance others. I intend to discuss with you, so very willingly. Then, you talk about the number of active workers that may evolve favorably. Do you plan to take retirement contributions from automata? Because even in our stores now, we have cash registers without cashiers.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, madam. A question here. Short question, sir. Introduce yourself.

Grégory

Hello. I am Grégory POCZERNIN. Unlike many people who may have asked you the question, Mr. President, I am an employee. I am not a boss, I am not self-employed, I am not a merchant, I am an employee. There you go. I am an employee in the non-profit private sector in a health and social care establishment that is well known in the Ruthénois area with 850 employees. This means that my salary increases are not decided by the boss. It is not the State directly. I am not a civil servant, it is, as you mentioned earlier, the long-term national objective of health insurance spending. This has increased by 2.4% I believe this year, and you said that work is important, that we need to revalue work, a reform of work. By increasing the (inaudible) by 2.4, our salaries will not move; it would need to be increased by 6, 7, 8% for our salaries to evolve, which are below those of the hospital public service. There you go, that’s the first point. For them to increase, contributions need to be raised, there you go. So to increase, there you go because it’s the contributions that allow for solidarity, social security, there you go.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Ask your question.

Unidentified speaker

For that, we would need to find money; there is something that costs a crazy amount of money, it’s the CICE in particular, so do you wish to remove it, there you go? And for us to be well at work during work, do you wish to restore the (inaudible) in the private sector and maintain them in the public sector? Thank you.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, sir, for your question. Here, here we have a question being asked, the microphone is coming, go ahead, thank you. Short question, same on pensions, go ahead.

Hacène

Mr. President, forgive me, I am emotional and at the same time hoarse, my name is Hacène RABAH BOUGUERRA, I am an occupational psychologist. In the early 90s, with a colleague, I created a training organization called ADC, the association for the development of skills. We implemented social and professional integration programs from the State and the region. And we also implemented qualification actions, diplomas from the National Education, diplomas from the University of Cambridge, the DPCE, the diploma of the first economic cycle from the National Conservatory of Arts and Crafts, and finally the diploma for access to university studies, the DAU, which is, let’s say, the title that gives the possibility to realize one’s dreams.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Ask your question, sir.

Hacène

After 20 years, after 20 years of activity, my pension is 640 euros. This exceptional, dramatically exceptional result is the result of serious dysfunctions in the services of the State and justice. This exceptionally dramatic situation requires an exceptional decision, and you are the only one, Mr. President, who can make it.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you for your testimony. I will take a question here, go ahead, madam, the microphone will come, Julien if you would be so kind, Jean, sorry, the question here. Madam and then we will move on to the President's responses. Go ahead, madam, ask your question.

Madame JOUSSET

Hello, Madame JOUSSET (phon), I am 43 years old, I am a home helper paid in CESU, I am also a contractual employee in a town hall, so I am what we can call a precarious worker. Regarding the pension reform, apparently until now the 25 best years were taken into account for the calculation of the pension, from now on the entire career will be taken into account. This risks lowering our pensions, especially for people like me who have had a rather precarious activity.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, madam, and now I have one last question here, it’s your turn, Quentin, the microphone, thank you very much. Go ahead, madam, short question.

Unidentified speaker

Hello Mr. President, I am a teacher here in high school in Rodez and proud of my profession, I am passionate about my job and yet for 20 years that I have been teaching, I have seen the conditions of my work deteriorate. This has not prevented me from continuing and being always very active. However, when I see the pension you propose, I am very worried. Earlier I heard you say a pension of 1,200 euros for a teacher, that shocks me a little, maybe you made a mistake or I misheard, but we have a Bac + 5 and we regularly face young people, and our work is therefore sometimes a little complicated. We see it in the news as well. So I would just like you to reassure me and restore my confidence in this reform.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you very much, madam. Mr. President, I give you the floor.

Emmanuel MACRON

So what you are proposing is not a universal pension, it is a single pension, which is different. So that could be a system, that would mean fundamentally we cap the contribution and at some point we have to pay for it through contributions and income. Simply, this single pension would need to be set at a level, so that is a debate: what is the right level, what is the salary that everyone wants for the future? And then I will tell you what is going to happen, since I cannot tell you the single pension will be 5,000 or 6,000 euros because at that point otherwise we have to either multiply the contributions by X or work much later. If I take the current working duration conditions, contribution levels, and others, it will not be at that level, it will be rather between 1,200-1,500, we will have to see. What am I going to do? I am going to create a capitalization system, meaning that the single pension will be a unique basic pension that we can guarantee through solidarity and collective work, and then I will tell everyone to fend for themselves to build their pension if they want to have a good pension. Because the level of the single pension in many places will not allow you to help your children, it will sometimes not allow you to find housing, to choose your life. I think that the universal system, but which is not unique, which is transparent, which means that you earn what you contribute is fairer. So I do not want a system, that is what I was saying earlier to Madame, that is so low that it leads to recapitalization. Then it would also be a system that is not responsible because if I say everyone at retirement age has the same. Well! There are some who will ... Well! If that is the case: Welcome Panama! No but… And then no matter how much I say I believe in the value of work, I believe that we need to work again, people build themselves through work, we all have to go there, the nation needs… No, that will not work. We have a minimum old-age benefit that is a guarantee so that no one is in destitution and I stand by it, we have revalued it, we have raised it to 970. I want us to have a — excuse me? — I want us to have behind a contributory minimum that we raise and then I accept the differences. There you go, because I think they also correspond to individual choices and the viability of this system. Madame, so you said it, so you are typical of the current case which also suffers from the system, because by multiplying the regimes you multiply the unreadability, you are typically part of it, you are if I calculated correctly a polyactive so you will be tomorrow poly-pensioned so to reconstruct the career good luck with all the side effects. So the future system is a system that will simplify your life. After, there we said it, you ... do you have ... may I allow myself ... Excuse me! It is very incorrect to say that but the acquired rights in the current system you will keep and you will be able to benefit, I think from a simplification, in any case we will be able to converge you into the new system and have simplicity. But you will not have all the advantages that you would have had if you had spent your life in the new system. Where I want to reassure you, is what the high commissioner has started to initiate, on the levels of contribution. First, we are going to move to a system where we contribute points and buy them and we will not put any profession up against a wall that consists of having a ... Well! There are professions that given the decrease in the CSG will benefit from it like farmers. There are professions, I do not know what the share of your activity is as an osteopath, so since you are an osteopath and a farmer. The farmer in you will gain net, the osteopath in you may lose net. What is certain is that then I do not know how that balances because I do not know your individual case but on osteopaths like lawyers or others that is part of the discussion. We will not put any profession up against a wall and a surge in contributions that will make the system impossible. And so we will find the compensation mechanisms so that the thing is both fair and does not put professions in a system that consists of making them explode. The high commissioner if you do not hear him because he does not have a microphone but it is he who is at the helm said very rightly within the universal system, we are going to create a transition system so that there is a solution that is provided to each of these professions. The self-employed being in a situation, it is fundamentally a myriad of professions that have very particular cases. But the lives of people like you will be simplified with the upcoming system. Where you are right, well we are not going to ask for social retirement contributions from machines but where you are right, it is a debate that had indeed taken place in the context of the presidential campaign which had been raised by other candidates than me but rightly so. It is the question of how we make machines in sectors that come to replace work contribute and it is a reflection that we must also have. So we cannot make them contribute through contributions but through tax. We will have to balance the system anyway as I said also through a share of tax and so it is clear that we cannot remain in a system today where far too many things are paid for by work, and insufficiently by polluting activities or activities that replace work. Moreover, that is what we have started to do, with the decrease in unemployment contributions transferred to the CSG, which weighs on financial income, on all polluting activities in a much broader and indiscriminate manner. This movement, we will continue it, inevitably. And so, yes, we will have to make sectors that are automating contribute differently, to avoid biases and so that it contributes to the national effort. It is the same thing we are doing on software and the major players in digital, with the digital tax we have implemented in France. We must make all productive factors contribute. We need to remain competitive, but we must make them contribute to the system, otherwise, it is not fair. But they will not do it through contributions and the same thing. That said, on your specific case, the High Commissioner has several special ambassadors. I propose that they look into it, like one or two others who have mentioned their case here. Grégory, then, on salaries and your case, first, there too, you are a typical case of the injustices of the current system. Because you do not have, you, the advantages that someone doing exactly the same work, and who is in the public hospital service can have. Even if you have the same salary, your career structures are not the same. And your rights to retire are not the same. Generally, these are so-called active categories, they have 17 years of service, often, they retire at 57, which will not be your case. And with conditions that are also very different from the private sector. So, in your case, you will be part of all the health professions that will enter the points system, which I also believe is fairer, and which is important to value, for the case you mentioned. Then, the ONDAM, it is not intangible. I invite you, by the way, to look at the ONDAM under this mandate and under the previous mandate. It is much less harsh. Excuse me? No but I know, but I totally assume them, the needs. What we are doing is also, not just repairing, we will have to refound the hospital. I have spoken several times about psychiatry. We have entrusted a mission, we will anyway need a specific action on psychiatry. On emergencies, we are working on it, we will need to provide a very strong response. On the hospital, in general, otherwise, it is a general risk. Is the answer, for you, simply the ONDAM? Yes and no. The ONDAM, it is many other things, and it is not simply because I increase the ONDAM that I increase your salary. The ONDAM is the totality of health insurance expenditure. Now, where I agree with you, is that I think the logic in which we were until now, that is to say the monitoring of the entire health sector, and we have started to shift it, we need to change it. That is to say, it is normal that every year, the legislator asks himself: "how much do I spend on health?", and it is normal to continue to spend more because it is an investment. But 1. we are in the process of decreasing and we will gradually move away from activity-based pricing, which is a problem within this ONDAM, and 2. we must, for careers, whatever the nature of these careers, that is to say establishments contributing to public service, participating in public service and hospital establishments or complete private sector. We must rethink the sectors, the careers of the medico-social and not simply, we must, in a way, get you out of the simple mechanical constraint of the ONDAM. What is true is that your salary dynamic is not fixed by the point that I will put in... that we can move at the level of the public hospital service, or by a clinic that would be doing well if you were in the private sector. You are absolutely right but the system today is too constrained and I consider that the right answer is not simply to move the ONDAM. The ONDAM, anyway, given the investments we need to make in psychiatry, more broadly in the hospital and emergencies, is something we are in the process of moving and that we will continue to move. I will not lie to you, we already moved it last year. I made the decision to increase it by more than 200 million euros to invest in hospitals that needed it and we even moved it during the year by 0.2 points the ONDAM. So, it is not an intangible. I mean, what we have rather shown in the last two years is that we were not in a managerial logic. Where I agree with you is that we need to go faster on health. Excuse me? I know well, that is what I am telling you. But that is the careers. No but there, you cannot blame me for what has been done in the last 20 years. If I were not aware of that, I would not have tackled the issue of the hospital but do not tell me that it is this year's ONDAM that is the problem because it has rather been revalued but it is not just the subject of the ONDAM, but we need, indeed, to rethink these careers. Simply, the revaluation and restructuring of these health careers, I will come back to it later for national education, it will take time. It is not a transition that will happen in two years. I will not lie to you. On the "crazy money," as the other would say and the CICE. The CICE, I have good news for you, it has been abolished. No but why? Because there too, contributions made, made that the collective system rested only on work, and we were told every year: "you are no longer competitive, we are deindustrializing the country, work will go elsewhere." So, either we said: we lower the net salary, which I refuse, or we said: we need to lighten the contributions that are paid by the employer and the employee, which we did because you will note that under this mandate, we have lightened both. We have reduced your contributions as employees and we have reduced them for the employer by converting the CICE into reductions in charges. But it is not a gift, it is that the benefits that are there in front of that, we compensate for them through the state budget. What we have in front of that is the state that will fill this budget. And it is coherent, including with what Madame said about machines and the rest. It is that we lighten the part of our collective budget that we have financed by work, whether it is the employer's share or the employee's share, because it had become too heavy to finance, moreover, by CSG, by tax, by possibly taxes that also correspond to this new world we are entering, that is to say digital taxation, perhaps tomorrow on machines and others but I argue that this reform is good and by the way, we will continue to evaluate it. But it allows us to save and create jobs because the less qualified you are, the more you are a victim of the total cost of employment at the bottom of the scale. The victims today of the total cost of work are the young unqualified, that is the reality. Why do you think we are lowering unemployment, even though we have growth that is lower than it was, and we are lowering it faster? Because we have passed a few reforms that have boosted things and also because we have lowered the cost of work for the employer, for the youngest and least qualified people. Because we have lowered the charges at the SMIC and up to 2.5 SMIC through a wedge. But it is compensated elsewhere but it is not a gift. I really believe that it is a good measure: it lightens what work paid to the nation. Because I think that work cannot take everything. I am not telling you that I think it should be eliminated. On pensions, I think it should be the contribution, for a good part, and we keep the logic but it is not a gift.

Finally, regarding the CHSCT reform or others, there is a reform that was introduced in the labor ordinances at the beginning of the five-year term, and it needs to be implemented. It has allowed for a lot of simplification. They are currently being deployed, and we need to make them live and evaluate them. But I am not in favor of changing... but yes, but simply, sincerely, look at things branch by branch. I defended earlier the social dialogue and the importance of social dialogue in the company, at the branch level and at the national level. But we had a system that was extremely cumbersome, where there were far too many discharges, far too many structures. I mean, we also need to look at the figures that were there and the cost that it represented, sometimes unjustifiably, with meetings that had become very formal and with a system that had become much heavier. So now, we have a system where the competencies are linked to the CE, we have not removed any competencies, any protection for employees, nothing! We have clarified missions and grouped them together. Let's evaluate this, but sincerely, I think that the formality we had fallen into, all those who lived it, who participated in it said, was indeed a lot of meeting fatigue. So now, it is necessary, but it is essential that those who have rights, that the protection of employees in the company, as in all other structures, is always defended. We have not renounced any of these rights and we have not removed anything that was defended and what constituted the substance of the CHSCT. Simply, we have simplified the structures because I believe it was legitimate. There you go, we may not agree, but we will evaluate over time whether it is a good or a bad measure. I believe it is a good measure. I simply think that we need to integrate into the heart of management, of the conduct of the company, of public services, what is the meaning of work, the elements of hardship, the task. Often, we had included in the formality of these meetings things that should be managed in the daily conduct of operations, and that too is one of the things we want to change.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

There were three questions left.

Emmanuel MACRON

Hacène. Yes, but may I ask if you are married? And is your spouse in the same situation as you or do they have a better pension? No, I don't want to be indiscreet, but because we look at the couple's income. But if the couple's income is below a certain threshold, you are entitled to the minimum, which is the minimum old-age pension, so it is probably your income that means you are not entitled to the minimum old-age pension. No, but then I do not know your specific case. I heard your question, someone will come with the commissioner, we will come to see you to obviously take all the details so that your particular case can be addressed, sir. We will look into that. Rest assured, I cannot, with the information you have given me, handle it directly. I understood that there were both legal and other elements, so we will look at your file. I commit to that. Madam, then you, yes, it was the 25 years, first of all, you too, you are typical. You are also typical, first of all, of a multi-active person, for whom the system is very complicated because you are both paid in CESU, with the check that your employer gives you. No, but it is true that this system must be simplified. But the truth is that if we simplified it, it would mean zero, but you are absolutely right. This is one of the topics currently being addressed regarding personal employment. So you have that, you are, if I understand correctly, part-time, probably at the Caisse des collectivités locales. So, in addition, you are accruing rights, so you have at least two pension funds, maybe more if you have had other activities before. So there, you will also, I repeat, to make it clear, have a unique system, unique points, and not two or three accounts to manage. Then, in your case, which involves rather precarious or fragmented careers, the simulation system has been done in macro, and we will look at it on a case-by-case basis, and there, we can also look with you, the system, I think, in your case, will even be fairer. Today, you are absolutely right, when you are a private sector employee or a contractor, we will look based on your 25 best years but not the entirety of your income. I often hear this argument. 50% of income, 50% of the income from the 25 best years. So, in the upcoming system, it all depends on how we value the point over the entire career. The current system you are in, your acquired rights are valued by being indexed to prices, not to salaries. This results in a huge loss of purchasing power. In the proposed system, the accumulated rights will be valued based on salaries, the second thing, so it depends on how your career progresses, and if your career is very linear and you advance. It is true that the 25 best years, the system of the 25 best years, is rather better than the points system. On the other hand, for fragmented careers, the new system is better, beyond what I just said. Why? Because your points are contributed equally across the systems, and you earn points, even in a degraded manner, during your periods of unemployment or between two jobs. Where today, the system means that you are compensated in a very insufficient and very piecemeal manner when you are between two jobs, when you are in precariousness, and therefore, today, the main victims of our system are those with fragmented careers. And these are the women who have fragmented careers, the famous 20% of women who will work until 67 years old. In the current system, as it is more universal, simpler, and contributes by points, and there, the first simulations show it: even in your life accidents, you accumulate points and therefore, you earn rights to retire more than in today's system. If you have one or two children, you earn more rights to retire faster than in the current system. What needs to be looked at is the value of the point to compare it to your reference salary over the 25 best years. Not forgetting that today, we only take 50% of that salary. After that, it will be on a case-by-case basis, but the current system, let’s be clear, is very favorable to people, as I said, who have a continuous career and who constantly advance. It is very unfavorable to people who have a fragmented, disrupted career because at that moment, you contribute less and you will have to retire later. So, I argue that the current system is better for you.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Last question.

Emmanuel MACRON

This is the last one. There you are. First of all, retirement levels depend a lot, as you know better than I do, if you are a teacher, CAPES holder, agrégé, at what point in your career you left, etc. I was not taking the classic level, I was taking a reference level which, in my opinion, is not totally outrageous. Because when we look at the level, when you are a teacher, it depends on the share of allowances, of overtime that you do at the end of your career, which are more or less taken into account by your pension system, but we are between 1,000 and 1,200. In my opinion, on average, I think I am not far from reality, but we can check. Do we have the figures, Mr. High Commissioner? Yes, he will check. And then, there are those who have more when they finish as agrégés. Today, across the entire teaching body, the current system, and you mentioned it, is a system that I consider unsatisfactory because the career progresses little, because the career, and I have a thought for your colleague, the school principal, who has committed the worst, subjected to stress, etc., in an abominable situation because, as you say, Madam, principal, there are management functions that are not recognized enough. So that’s the second point, in a way, the implicit social pact we have made for decades in the National Education system is to say: we do not pay you very well, your career is quite flat but it can have jumps when you pass the CAPES, when you pass the agrégation, but you have vacations and you retire with a system that is better calculated than in many others because it is the system where we calculate based on the last six months, and then, there are also some others. That’s also why there is a great diversity in the teaching body. It depends on whether you do overtime or not. Which are now tax-exempt and can create significant income variations within the teaching body. That’s a bit of the social pact of the teaching body. This pact no longer corresponds to reality, which is desirable, I say this very sincerely. And that’s why teachers, like a few other professions, I cannot tell them overnight, you will move to the new system because their system is calculated based on the last six months. If I switch to the new system, which is throughout life, all teachers will be disadvantaged. So the transition to the new system for teachers can only go along with a transformation of the career, rethinking the career in all its components. And that’s why I take responsibility, for certain very specific categories, to have a transition period that may be longer because we need to think about salary dynamics and careers. So, I will correct myself immediately, live. But is that for teachers or for all retirees? I read what is given to me by the High Commissioner: 2,600 euros average pension for new retirees from education. Tenured teachers who left in 2017 received an average monthly pension of 2,600 euros. This average of 2,600 euros hides inequalities between public primary and secondary school teachers. It is the diversity that makes it so that perhaps you do not find yourself in it. In my opinion, 2,600, you will have to tell me how we find them, because teachers are part of it. But I think of my 1,200, I am not mistaken. Were you a teacher? So I am not mistaken. Madam was a teacher, she is at 1,140. Well, that reassures me. No, but that’s good, there you go.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Finished, Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, but when I told you 1,200 euros, I wasn't being delusional. No, but it's very important because wait. Right now, we're talking a lot about numbers. I still want to clarify things for you. She tells me: we will take the 25 best years. When you are in the private sector, like you, like you; we will take your 25 best years, but for those 25 best years, it will be 50% of the reference salary. When you are in the public sector, we take your last six months and it's 75% of the salary, that's the big difference that also creates inequalities that make it so that no one can make sense of it anymore. That's the current system. And when I look at the end-of-career salary of teachers, there are a lot of variations, but when I tell you that I'm around 1,100-1,200 euros, I think I'm not completely out of touch, compared to a teacher's end of career. Some earn much more when they do overtime, when they are aggregated or otherwise, some earn a little less, but I might be below average, but I am in reality and your neighbor shows it. So, first point, because that was your concern. You told me: 1,200 euros, I don't believe it at all. It clearly shows that our current system is not even readable for civil servants who should be able, in a career where you cannot be dismissed, to calculate your retirement. This means that a teacher today, in the state public service, does not know how to calculate their retirement and is afraid, first point. So I will try to reassure you, first by telling you: everyone will move to the same system, visibility and transparency. Second point: by telling you that this social pact I described for teachers will not end overnight, because we will give ourselves time, as for some medical professions I mentioned, for police officers, for gendarmes, we must give ourselves time because we need to rethink the career. That's what I want us to do over 5-10 years. This is also not something that can be done in six months; if I were to revalue, as I want to do, all teachers - when we talk about National Education in our country, we are talking about a million civil servants, it's the largest employer in the country. If I wanted to revalue, it’s 10 billion. We cannot put 10 billion tomorrow, it's your taxes. It's the deficit, it's the debt for our children, so it's investing in our education. We need to rethink the career, which means we need to ensure that the career progresses more, that we have a real dialogue with all teachers and their representatives to say how we can better advance the career, how we can pay better. How, consequently, because we pay better, maybe we also change the working time and the relationship to work. And I think that teachers of your generation are quite ready for this, and often do it outside of school hours, to support young people differently, that this should be valued, that it can be asked of teachers, that the profession changes, that we also look at vacation periods compared to others and then think about their career by valuing much more than we do today the periods of supervision. Today, when you are a director in primary school, a middle school director, it's terrible. It's undervalued, it creates very tough stress situations, and so maybe we should value that better. And then, we should also integrate that at certain moments in the career, we should no longer be in front of students because if we all say: we will work a little longer, well I'm sorry but it turns out that I know your job well, I have a grandmother who raised me and spent her life in it and I have a wife who did your job, it's not true that we can be in front of students innocently until 65 years old. It depends on temperaments, it depends on the classes we have in front of us, it depends on reality, but when we are in a difficult situation, when we have unruly kids, at 55 years old, we are fed up, we are worn out and so we need to be able to have a job in the rectorate or in functions where we will be less exposed to students. There are other places where it is much more pleasant. Teachers have smaller classes. It goes better. That is appreciated, that is called managing a career. That is called human resources management. We have done it insufficiently. We need to reinvent it, which means valuing careers, valuing career progression differently, taking it into account to allow teachers to enter the system and for retirees of tomorrow's system to find themselves at the same level as retirees of today's system, but with a more intelligent career. Because today, it is not a good system, where we tell teachers: "you will tighten your belts, you will be poorly paid all your life and your retirement will be better calculated than for others." We are no longer in a world where people accept that. So, on these subjects, what I want us to do is to open a real consultation that will allow us to think about the career, the investment we make, and consequently the transition time, and we will converge everyone towards new systems, as we manage to have a career that corresponds to a fairer system. But we will do it transparently. I am telling you my convictions, my intuitions because your question was very direct, I may also correct some preconceived notions that can be anxiety-inducing, which are false, but that will be one of the topics of discussion. And I take responsibility for the fact that on some professions we have discussed this evening, we will give ourselves time because these are professions where we need to actually change the work to allow the transition to the new retirement system.

Olivier BISCAYE (host)

Thank you, Mr. President. So, we haven't necessarily answered all the questions because I think we still had questions to ask you. But after three hours of debate, about thirty questions, including various cases that were addressed. I would like to thank you for all these answers, thank the entire team of the Dépêche du Midi group who participated and organized this evening, also thank all the titles of the PQR, Presse Quotidienne Régionale, who have relayed questions throughout the evening, and thank all the readers, subscribers who are present here and who have asked questions and who, I have no doubt, will reach out to you shortly because they surely have other questions to ask you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. Thank you to you. So, I will say a word. First, thank you very much for the debate and the quality of the debate and the questions. It shows that this is an extremely important subject. We need to understand that we are building the world of tomorrow and that we are not just thinking about tomorrow 2019-2020, we are building something that starts around 2025-2040. But we need to do it because our elders did it for us in 1945, and it worked very well, while keeping these fundamentals. The second thing is that the debate we had this evening, I want to tell you that it continues. There is a citizen platform that has been set up. I encourage you to go there to get information, look, ask your questions, and the parliamentarians who are mobilized with a lot of work that has been done for months and ambassadors of the reform in your territories, ask your questions, mobilize your parliamentarians as well so that they can work with you, because whatever their political sensitivities, they are extremely mobilized on this subject and they are working. I see, by the way, many parliamentarians, obviously those from Aveyron, but there are some who come from all over France who have worked a lot on this subject. And there will be regular updates and consultations around the High Commissioner with, as I told you, a time for everything to settle down, at the beginning of 2020, but this work continues, there will be other debates, dialogues, like this, ongoing. I will do others. The Prime Minister and ministers, obviously the High Commissioner will continue to do so because I think it is very instructive. We learn things, always, and we see what needs to be contributed, to think - a lot of what I told you, by the way, has been nourished by exchanges with one another. The last thing I would like to share with you before going to have a bite to eat with you and continue to talk informally, is that it is retirement we are talking about, that is, the protection of the 21st century. But it is also, and many of your questions have shown it, about work and I think that collectively, we need to seize this question of work. It's the conditions of work, career management, work stress, the valorization of it. We have provided answers in terms of contributions and taxation, but it is a project that lies ahead of us. That is what we need to invent and we are still far too much, there too, in separate pipes. We need to reinvent this work, we know it well, work is no longer the same. You are all, I see it, connected. Many, perhaps, have emails from the boss, work continues, stress. It is outside of working hours today, we no longer take it into account. The relationships of dependence at work are no longer the same. All of this needs to be rethought very deeply, that is also it. This project will take time. It is a real societal project, a project of civilization. When I said that it is a contract of the nation with itself, that is what we owe to ourselves, and what we owe to our children. Thomas is absolutely right. Ecology, that is absolutely true, but there is also: what is the work of tomorrow? What framework do we give it, what new protections, what new freedoms? We are not at the end of this project. Because so far, we have just adjusted. Now, we are refounding. I ask you to do it in trust, in demand, in transparency. In any case, I am the custodian of it. I will take responsibility for everything we do in front of you and so when there are difficult decisions to be made, I have always done it, I take responsibility for them and I have always told things as they are. I told you: the system, there will be no reform if the system is not balanced, and balanced in 2025. Maybe we will have to work more than we are told. There are subjects that will be difficult to carry, there are others that will be more generous, but we will do it transparently and all together. I count on you. Thank you very much in any case.