SPEECH BY EMMANUEL MACRON AT THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE IN STRASBOURG

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

1 October 2019 · Council of Europe, Strasbourg

Context
Macron addressed the Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly in Strasbourg on October 1, 2019, marking the organization's 70th anniversary during France's presidency of the Committee of Ministers.
Main themes
Council of Europe anniversary, human rights and fundamental freedoms, rule of law, European unity and brotherhood, democracy, France's commitment to European values, authoritarianism and democratic backsliding, Turkey and Russia concerns, death penalty abolition, freedom of expression, European humanism, erosion of democratic norms
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,534
93rd percentile
Sentences
279
94th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
48th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 32%31%
  • Social 27%27%
  • Geopolitical 25%24%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

279 sentences in 59 paragraphs

Madam President of the Parliamentary Assembly,

Madam Secretary General of the Council of Europe,

Mr. President of the Congress,

Mr. President of the European Court of Human Rights,

Madam Commissioner for Human Rights,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Ladies ambassadors, gentlemen ambassadors,

Ladies and gentlemen.

Thank you first and foremost, Madam President, for the words of friendship you have just expressed for France and President CHIRAC. I am extremely touched by this, and I want to tell you how much these words resonate with me and with the entire nation. I also thank you for the support for the actions being undertaken and congratulate you on the determination you have just displayed.

If I am here today before your Assembly, it is primarily to pay tribute to it and to the institution that welcomes us, the Council of Europe. I thank you for your invitation, and I would like to acknowledge the work of Secretary General Mr. JAGLAND and extend my best wishes for success to Madam BURIĆ, who succeeds him. I am very pleased that the French presidency of the Committee of Ministers gives me the opportunity to stand before you, the representatives of 47 member states, representing 830 million citizens in this year marking the 70th anniversary of the organization.

I wish to reiterate the unwavering commitment that France has to our organization since its inception. Charles PÉGUY said that freedom is a system of courage. And this perseverance of freedom and dignity in the face of all adversities is at the heart of this organization. Born in this city, three times torn apart by fratricidal wars, I do not believe in coincidence, as if unity could only be conceived where the wounds had been the most acute; this organization is the product of European humanism, an act of faith in the possibility of reconciling our continent around respect for the human person and the sacred nature of their dignity, at a time when nothing suggested it was possible.

This act of faith was ours, and it still is. The Council of Europe has indeed advanced the respect for fundamental rights, democracy, and the rule of law in Europe. It has enabled the near-total eradication of the death penalty on the European continent, making its abolition a prerequisite for membership. It has reduced torture through the prevention it exercises in places of deprivation of liberty. It has facilitated the adoption of texts on the protection of children from exploitation and on the prevention of violence against women. It gave birth to the European Convention on Human Rights, imposing, under the impetus of René CASSIN, that a jurisdiction be responsible for ensuring compliance by states with the binding force of its rulings. It has advanced social rights to housing, health, education, employment, and free movement guaranteed by the European Social Charter. It has supported the construction of the rule of law, as it does today in Moldova through the Venice Commission. It has played a visionary and pioneering role in biodiversity as well as in the protection of personal data. It has made our continent more democratic through election observation, the fight against corruption, and the defense of freedom of expression. It has made it safer by defining common rules to combat terrorism and cybercrime.

I would be remiss to attempt to enumerate 70 years of struggle, 70 years of achievements that are the treasure of our organization. We have forged here, on a continental scale and despite all headwinds, a common architecture in the name of the great European brotherhood that Victor HUGO dreamed of, with the will to build the common European home, mentioned by Mikhail GORBACHEV before this assembly in 1989.

Thirty years after the fall of the Berlin Wall, the walls of this common home are, however, cracked. They are cracked by the questioning of fundamental rights on our continent that we must confront, debating them in this chamber.

In Turkey, where the rule of law is receding, where judicial proceedings against human rights defenders, journalists, and academics must be the subject of our utmost vigilance.

In Russia, where the repression of protests this summer raises numerous and legitimate concerns that France shares and on which it has clearly expressed itself.

They are also cracked by the fascination that authoritarian regimes exert even within the European Union. Because our democracies in crisis have failed to provide our citizens with the protections they aspire to. They have finally fractured under the illusion that freedom would impose itself mechanically everywhere, that the peoples of Europe would eventually unite in a set of rules and norms, in which the weight of their past and deep culture would eventually dilute.

The return of History has perhaps put an end to this belief, I would say, this hope. That is why the times we are living in, these times of fissures that I have just mentioned, call for a certain strength of spirit, that of lucidity, I believe deeply, and of courage. I believe that for the future we must ensure that we set at least two requirements on which I want to elaborate here.

The first is to ensure, or even to rebuild here, the unity of our continent on the foundation of our common values. This is what France advocates within the European Union to build, with its partners, economic, digital, ecological, and strategic sovereignty. It requires primary, full, and complete solidarity among its members. It requires the strengthening of the rule of law within the European Union, and therefore the consideration of the work done by the Council of Europe, and the accession of the European Union to the ECHR.

There is no incompatibility, no competition between projects and organizations; on the contrary. I am deeply convinced that this European sovereignty will be all the better supported if we can lay the foundations on a continental scale of a trust based on the values that unite us within the Council of Europe.

Building Europe is never natural. It is not a given. It is the conquest of the last seven decades, on the bed of millennia of conflicts, of European civil wars as well as conquests from outside. I believe very deeply that it is within the Council of Europe that the fractures of our continent can be repaired because we have been able here to precisely overcome the scars of war, the divisions of the Cold War, because it is the place where European consciousness is built and debated.

This will not happen today, as it did yesterday, without tensions, and I am aware of the profound debates that have taken place this year in this assembly regarding Russia's place in the Council of Europe. Your Assembly and the Committee of Ministers have chosen to maintain Russia's membership in the Council of Europe. Without the joint work we conducted with the Finnish presidency, without the commitment of our countries and this assembly to move forward together towards a return to normal functioning of the Council of Europe, the crisis could not have been overcome and would have led, I believe very deeply, to harmful consequences for our peoples and the protection of their rights.

I fully support the choice that has been made to keep Russia in the Council of Europe because I believe that the Russian people fundamentally identify with European humanism, because they have participated in its construction, because the geography, history, and culture of Russia are fundamentally European, and because when one of our members strays from the foundation of our common values, division and exclusion would be yet another failure that would ultimately condemn us to impotence, which would only be the victory of those who do not believe in this foundation and our values.

The doubts and criticisms are audible, legitimate. But what would have happened if we had done nothing? Let us never forget all that Russia's entry into our organization has tangibly and concretely brought to all Russian citizens. The moratorium on the death penalty, individual recourse, and mandatory jurisdiction, the possibility for Russian citizens to defend their rights before the European Court against their government.

Your Assembly made the sovereign choice to re-welcome the Russian delegation, without which the risk was indeed, sooner or later, to see Russia simply leave the Council of Europe. Then Russian citizens would have been deprived of the right to recourse, of the very possibility of having their rights respected. This decision you made, and I support it without any naivety whatsoever. Aware that the role of the Committee of Ministers and this assembly is not to substitute for the governments that are themselves responsible for bringing the Minsk agreements to fruition, the Normandy process, or importing other legitimate debates, but already to preserve the rights of all citizens.

This decision, I believe very deeply, does not weaken our common determination in any way, and does not imply the existence of multiple standards within the Council of Europe. This decision does not weaken, on the contrary, our determination to put an end to frozen conflicts that are still such painful scars of the divisions of our continent, in Ukraine, in Georgia, in the Caucasus, in Transnistria.

This is not a gesture of complacency. It is a decision of demand. A demand towards Russia to fully respect its obligations and fulfill its duties towards the Council of Europe, a demand towards our organization so that we are collectively stronger and more effective in the face of such situations, with more predictability, responsiveness, and credibility. This is the purpose of the new joint procedure that your assembly and the Committee of Ministers have decided to initiate. I hope it will be operational by next January. We must have credible and strengthened tools to enforce the decisions of the Council of Europe and ensure that each member state fully respects its commitments and duties.

Before joining you here, I was with Oleg SENTSOV. He is here today in Strasbourg, free. This is the result of the progress made by the prisoner exchange that took place a few weeks ago between Russia and Ukraine, which also allowed for the release of the 24 Ukrainian sailors. Others are still waiting. We owe them the strength of our commitment to dialogue and reconciliation on our continent. Oleg SENTSOV is one of those who believe, as BERNANOS once said, that the freedom of others is as essential to us as our own, one of those who believe that it is pointless to have ideals if one is not capable of fighting for them, against all odds, in the thickness of history and in the course of our lives. This makes him a great European.

Because being European, fundamentally, is never to resign oneself in the fight for freedom and dignity. And it is to work, as we have just done and as we will continue to do, for the unity of our entire continent around these values and to give them their full effect, as philosopher Simone VEIL said.

The second requirement we must set for ourselves is to build here the thinking of human rights, freedom, and democracy in the face of the great contemporary challenges. I will not be exhaustive here either, but I wanted to share some unfinished reflections as a head of state. And I fully own them with you regarding the collective situation we are experiencing today, which I believe is unprecedented.

This is perhaps the main challenge of European humanism in the 21st century because the principles and values that unite us within the Council of Europe are not only threatened by our divisions. They are challenged by the great transformations we are experiencing. Contested from the outside by a savagery of the world, the return to an era of brutal exercise of power in which violations of fundamental rights, of the most basic humanitarian law are no longer punished or sanctioned and are even increasingly less subject to explicit condemnation.

The era we are living in – David MILIBAND referred to it a few weeks ago as a new age of impunity – is a historical regression in the respect for human rights, humanitarian rights on the main theaters of war and in many of our societies. Where we thought until just about ten years ago that this movement was unstoppable. That its direction was always towards the extension of rights, the completion of democracy, the conquest of human rights, the victory of new inches of democracy and the rule of law.

That is no longer the case. This is explained by an unprecedented weakening of the multilateral system and constitutes a profound source of insecurity for all and would fundamentally call into question the very existence of our organization as well as that of Europe, the construction of peace based on cooperation between nations and respect for the rights of each individual.

Our principles and values are also being challenged from within. In the great acceleration of history that we are experiencing. They are impacted by the terrorist threat, digital, climatic, and demographic transformations, the crisis of globalized capitalism that has failed to address the issue of inequalities. All these phenomena have logics, dynamics that are sometimes profoundly different, but they are occurring together in our societies and mark the return of great fears that we see rising everywhere. And with them, irrationalism. Fear of decline, loss of bearings, fear of the world; loss of confidence in who we are, in our relationship with the world in the very truth of facts, sometimes in the rule of law.

In the face of this, two radically opposed paths are asserting themselves today.

The first is what I would call the path of disintegration. It is the path of those who claim that protection against the upheavals of the world comes from shrinking the space of our rights and freedoms, retreating into oneself, rejecting the other. Those who accept elections but refuse pluralism and are wary of counter-powers that limit the exercise of their authority. Those who use the argument of the fight against terrorism to silence their political opponents. Those who fundamentally believe that the response to contemporary challenges and the construction of a strong state involves deconstructing what we have built. This path exists. It has triumphed in some countries in Europe. And it is increasingly strongly represented in our countries. It would be profoundly to forget who we are, we Europeans. And like you, I unfortunately see the polls that show the growing fascination of our population, of our peoples, for authoritarian regimes and who are sometimes ready to make all concessions, saying perhaps that authority is more effective in responding to these fears and threats. I believe that this would be a historical mistake. It would lead us to lose ourselves and take the risk of disappearing.

The second path, sometimes carried by some of their opponents, is what I would call the path of illusion. It feeds on a form of dryness of reason that claims or would claim to erase the bite of history. It is taken by those who, most often sincerely enamored with freedom and rights, would like the world not to be as it is and the peoples not to be as they are. Who would like to say: "the people are wrong, their fears are illegitimate" and respond only with a discourse of reason, sometimes of exclusion or sermon, must not forget that the rule of law is a fragile construction that must be cared for, understood, and persevered in every day, which is tested in contradictions. It would condemn the thought of fundamental rights to a form of magical thinking, incapable of embodying itself in history. In the service of the women and men of our time. It would forget that human rights are fundamentally an unfinished struggle but that with humility we can only be, as René CASSIN, to whom we owe so much here, said, we can only be the foot soldier and not just the fussy guardian. The foot soldier, yes. Because it is a battle that is fought hand to hand by understanding its fears and the extreme situations they can produce.

I believe that our collective task here at the Council of Europe is, all together, to yield to neither of these two paths but to try to build another. And on the contrary, to think in order to realize it. The space of freedoms and rights in our world as it is with questions that seem simple but which are precisely the questions that are posed to us. How to protect our fellow citizens from terrorism while preserving their rights and individual freedoms? How to defend freedom of expression in the face of the proliferation of hate speech? How to respond to the violence that is increasingly expressed in our societies by making our democracies stronger? How to protect the right to asylum while responding to the legitimate demand for control of migratory flows? What new right must we build in the era of digital technology, of artificial intelligence in a world where human life is increasingly dematerialized? These are some of the questions, along with others, that we must confront here without any easy solutions.

The challenge, in my eyes, is to give a grounding, a factual, historical reality to the construction of rights and freedoms, to concretely oppose all those who no longer believe in them and see in the edifice we have built here only the past of an illusion. The challenge is to make our democracies stronger by rediscovering the very meaning of what makes us Europeans. The conviction and above all the demonstration in fact that our strength in the face of the transformations of the world lies not in weakening but in defending our rights and freedoms.

This first requires clarity of mind. It is always easier to criticize liberal democracies than authoritarian regimes. Always easier. One can make appeals against liberal democracies. And one can indeed make even more appeals against liberal democracies that ratify the most treaties that allow for these appeals. One can make as many criticisms as possible in liberal democracies that allow them. But let us guard against playing into the hands of authoritarian and illiberal regimes.

No, it is not the same thing to maintain public order and to repress a demonstration. It is not the same thing to protect one's borders and to infringe upon the right to asylum. It is not the same thing to fight against hate speech and disinformation and to restrict freedom of expression and opinion. Let us be careful about the accuracy of language, about precision in the analysis of facts. I say this for all of us. Democracies can exhaust themselves in the confusion of minds. And therefore, everyone must show great responsibility by avoiding all easy solutions.

This also requires the courage to face the great challenges each in our countries by accepting the debate here at the Council of Europe. I therefore want to mention to you a few examples that have been the subject of discussions, even criticisms in this assembly. And these criticisms nourish us because they are the sap of this democratic dialogue, of the very construction of our law. Moreover, the answer exists neither entirely here nor entirely in the countries that are discussed, criticized, or judged but in this dialogue, in the existence of this dialogue and in the dialectic it produces.

The first question, which I mentioned briefly, is that of the fight against terrorism in democracy. I mentioned it two years ago before the European Court of Human Rights. There is no distinction to be made between protecting our societies from terrorism and defending rights and freedoms. It is one and the same struggle since precisely the terrorists want to destroy in our societies the rights, the freedom. This way of living freely. The objective is therefore to make our democracies stronger in the face of terrorism while reinforcing the guarantee of the rights of our fellow citizens. It is the very notion of security that must never be confused with a security obsession. It is in this spirit that the law reinforcing internal security and the fight against terrorism of November 1, 2017, was prepared, debated, and adopted in France. It allowed France first to exit the state of emergency and thus return to the common law of the European Convention on Human Rights by exiting the provisions provided for by its Article 15. I could answer all the questions that arise on this subject, but I believe that this law has allowed a return to common law and to respond to the challenges posed by the fact and the only fact of terrorism in our societies and to preserve the safety of each.

The second example I wanted to mention to you is the question of maintaining order in our democracies. Like other countries, France is facing a profound mutation in the conduct of demonstrations in public spaces. Here too, this phenomenon does not tolerate any shortcuts, any confusion. And I want to say this here. We have examined very seriously and attentively the work of the Council of Europe on the use of certain so-called intermediate weapons. The government has responded in detail and publicly to the observations of the Commissioner for Human Rights. But it is also true that this new situation we are experiencing, these unprecedented violences we have faced, which did not start yesterday but have increased, themselves organized during these last years in France as in other countries, must lead us to rethink our own organization with much humility, pragmatism, and attachment to all our principles. This situation therefore implies a deep reflection on how to respond to these new forms of violence. Here too, without shortcuts or overly easy attacks against one another, starting with the law enforcement forces whose very reason is to preserve public order without which there can be no freedom that can be exercised. If we do not do this, it is the freedom of demonstration itself that would ultimately be called into question.

That is why I asked the government to take into account all the observations made by the Commissioner for Human Rights but also all the discussions produced right here by the defenders of rights to rethink and propose a new doctrine that is currently being developed. A new doctrine of internal security and public order maintenance that will be debated and made public and transparent.

The third example. The European elections demonstrated the existence of massive campaigns to disseminate false information aimed at altering the normal course of the electoral process. While the civil and criminal responsibilities of the authors of false information could be sought on the basis of pre-existing laws, they were, however, profoundly insufficient. In France, as they are in many other states, to allow for the rapid removal of online content and to prevent its spread. The law of December 22, 2018, thus imposed a transparency obligation on Internet platforms to facilitate the detection work of the police authorities and to better inform users about the identity of the advertisers. This is just one example, and this work must continue. But it shows how much we need to think, there too, about a form of democratic public order on the Internet while obviously preserving freedom of expression, freedom of information, but everything in this new space, that of the Internet as well as social networks, has been designed, thought of as a new space where our fundamental values do not have to be respected. Imagine, it took a hard struggle, in recent months, after what happened in New Zealand, to obtain a response to the fight against terrorism on the Internet, through the Christchurch call that took place in Paris in May and was reinforced a few days ago in New York. There is no public order today that exists in social networks and the internet. And I say this to those who legitimately defend freedom, there is no freedom without public order. Freedom, as Montaigne said, is the freedom that is expressed in the laws that a sovereign people has endowed itself with. There is no absolute freedom that would express itself in the denial of the freedom of all others. That does not exist. And yet this is what we are living today. Freedom is not the freedom of the masked anonymous who uttered the worst hate speech, the worst information, or worse. This freedom is not freedom. It is the appearance of freedom, and it is even the opposite. And so we have, on this front too, to reconcile opposites.

The fourth example, I will stop here, is that of controlling migratory flows and protecting the right to asylum. The right to asylum is, today, threatened in Europe, by the discourse of those who want to confuse everything, who believe that Europe must barricade itself behind walls, no longer welcome those fleeing war and persecution, and who need its protection. The French Constitution, since the end of World War II, like our constitutional text here at the Council of Europe, enshrines the right to asylum, that is to say, the protection of the fighters for freedom. It is one of our most fundamental achievements. It is part of who we are. It was invented here on this continent.

But if we are not able to respond effectively to the migration challenge, if we do not have the courage to face the demand for control expressed by all our fellow citizens, if we do not have the clarity to see that, in many cases, the demand for asylum comes from countries that are profoundly safe, some of which are even seeking to open negotiations with the European Union, or with which we have complete freedom of movement. And that today, the demand for asylum is clearly the subject of a circumvention, if not a diversion. We would not be clear-eyed with ourselves. With our law, with the principles of that law, and with what our people are telling us, if we allow the right to asylum to become an object of trafficking diversion, it will disappear. It will not be the democrats who make it disappear. It will be the authoritarians, elected by peoples who will be afraid, and who will say, these people are not serious, they confuse everything, and no longer protect us from anything.

Our peoples, in choosing to protect the fighters for freedom from around the world, did not decide to abolish all borders. Legitimately, they have sovereignly decided things. They want to continue to decide sovereignly. Sovereignty imposes borders and the respect of a law. That is why France carries, both domestically and at the European and international level, a comprehensive agenda regarding major migrations. Major migrations do not primarily affect Europe. They are much more significant in Africa, and within Africa itself. But we must have a responsible development policy, a policy to combat all trafficking, but also, a protection of the respect for our European borders, of a European public order, an harmonization of our rules. And we must, there too, improve our own organization.

On each of these subjects, I want to, here, make you touch upon, fundamentally, what I would call the deep ethical tension that is crossing our democracies and that makes your work, our work, undoubtedly profoundly unprecedented. And historic, I believe that our generation no longer has to build solely the advancement of rights everywhere in Europe, the advancement of a foundation of rights that we would have built in countries that did not have access to them until then. And thus a geographical extension or simply the invention of new rights. No. We have to live the tension that new viral phenomena are bringing to play, in our societies, with existing rights, because these phenomena are so radical as terrorism, so profoundly new as the migration phenomenon in this magnitude. And in its characteristics so profoundly unprecedented technologically as social networks, the Internet that we must rethink our organization, without yielding to ease.

This assembly is not an assembly of jurists, with the utmost respect that I owe to jurists and judges, who have their role to play, we have a political work to conduct in the noblest sense of the term which is, at its core, the fulfillment in the public space of what ethical thought can be. And so we have to think about these extreme situations. This new framework, without any ease, never forgetting where we are speaking from. And what is happening all around us.

Here are some of the convictions I wanted to share with you. Ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, before answering your questions, the demand for unity of clarity but also the necessity to think about this new framework. I believe that this is the challenge of our council, of this assembly, of the committee of ministers, of the court. It is the challenge posed by artificial intelligence as well. I do not want to be long. I could have come back to it and we mentioned it a few days ago with all the European jurisdictions. This challenge is historic. It is the European challenge. And it is the one that we have to carry together.

In preparing my speech before you, I reread some texts to try to tell myself, what characterizes the great Europe that our organization embodies and carries? Undoubtedly, the capacity to meet these challenges, which, as we see, have incomplete and univocal responses everywhere else in the world, by assuming the tensions I just mentioned.

I found a text from 1992 in a work directed by KOSLOWSKI called "Imagining Europe." A work written by one of my mentors, to whom I owe much, Paul RICOEUR. And he called it "what new ethos for Europe." And I wanted to conclude my remarks with these few convictions that illustrate the debates we have had in recent months, and those that will guide us in the coming months.

At its core, he said, trying to qualify Europe. There are three pillars. It is a model of translation. I have often mentioned it quoting Umberto Eco, the European language is that of translation. It is true that what characterizes our great Europe this assembly illustrates wonderfully. It is, at its core, this form of linguistic hospitality that consists of accepting all the languages of Europe and no other continent has such a concentration of languages and cultures. Translation is accepting the other in their difference and welcoming them in my language. It is not the dream of an Esperanto that would reduce all differences. It is the capacity for hospitality and thus to accept our dissonances, our differences. Even if they are and especially if they are temporary.

Next, it is a model of the exchange of memories. And at its core, Europe is not yet a reconciliation of memories. And what we see in frozen conflicts shows this and the divisions that have occurred within this assembly have shown it. There are still fractured, divided memories. But in Europe, at least there is an exchange of memories, that is to say, they speak to each other, they tell each other. Many would like to make us believe that there is a fixed European identity. Sometimes even, we say a fixed European way of life. I deeply believe that there is, in Europe, to paraphrase RICOEUR, what I would call a narrative identity. There is a common history that we have told together. Sometimes, we have different versions. But we tell it, we write it. We are a continent. And it dialogues, it is made of the controversies of historiography. These controversies will continue. This exchange of memories is an irreducible. That is why the Observatory of the teaching of history that we support deeply is essential.

He finally said it is a model of forgiveness. Because when we have had so many wars, when we have divided so much, there comes a moment when the decree of Sparta must apply. It is forbidden to recall the evils of the past. As true as there is the duty of memory of history, there must come a time for a form of duty to forget, not a forgetting that erases traces, but a forgetting that allows us to live together. This model of forgiveness, constitutive of what we are, requires having what I would call the intelligence of the future. Because we have to live together. That is Europe, its fate and its treasure. We have to live together. We are here together.

Here, ladies and gentlemen, are some convictions I wanted to share with you. This great Europe is being made here. Sometimes, in its divisions, its traumas. But we forget, too often, in the time we are living in, that controversy is essential. It is profoundly democratic. And the incessant controversy is not a weakening. On the contrary, it is a luxury of democracy and the rule of law. May it live long. Thank you.