European Council of December 14 and 15, 2023.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

15 December 2023 · European Council of December 14 and 15, 2023

Context
Macron addressed press at the December 2023 European Council summit, summarizing key decisions on Ukraine, EU enlargement, and budget negotiations.
Main themes
Ukraine support and EU accession negotiations, European Council outcomes, EU enlargement, Hungary's obstruction, sanctions against Russia, multiannual financial framework, EU institutional reform, Moldova and Georgia accession, migration and asylum policy, European sovereignty, hostage crisis condolences
Duration
~52 min
94th percentile
Words
6,196
94th percentile
Sentences
326
96th percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.94
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.71
99th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 39%38%
  • Institutional 33%33%
  • Economic 13%12%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

326 sentences in 58 paragraphs

Hello ladies and gentlemen, thank you for being here.

We are coming out of this last European Council of the year with several structural issues for the long term and European sovereignty. But first of all, allow me to express our condolences to the family of Elia Toledano, as one of our hostages, who, as you know, remained a source of hope, was found this morning, unfortunately deceased. So I want to extend our most sincere condolences to the family of Elia Toledano. We still have three hostages who are held by Hamas, and I want to reiterate here France's determination to do everything possible to secure their release.

As I mentioned, this European Council addressed several issues. But obviously, the heart of these discussions was the question of Ukraine and our political and financial support for Ukraine and Ukrainians in the context we all know.

In this regard, we continue the essential work that, in my view, is an achievement of the last two years, which is the unity and very clear support of Europeans for Ukrainians. This is what we initiated under the French presidency, with immediate decisions on sanctions and support. This is what we were then able to carry forward with the European perspective recognized at the Versailles summit, followed by our tripartite visit with Germany and Italy, which subsequently allowed for the recognition of Ukraine's candidate status for the European Union.

The Council allowed, on this subject, on the one hand, to establish the principle of opening accession negotiations. Today, six of the seven conditions that were set for Ukraine have been met, according to the Commission, reaffirming our willingness to maintain military support in Europe in the short term and to realize our security commitments quickly.

Maintaining pressure on the Russian war machine through the adoption of a 12th package of sanctions against Russia, which allows for better combating circumventions and specifically targets diamond trade and diplomatic support for the Ukrainian peace plan and Kiev's efforts to persuade third countries.

This is a political message from the European Council, which was made possible by also deciding to open accession negotiations for Moldova and to allow progress for Bosnia and Herzegovina and Georgia. Bosnia and Herzegovina, too, when the conditions are met, like Moldova, and the candidate status recognized for Georgia.

This step is important, and the decision to open accession negotiations with Ukraine, as I said, has been made. It also responds to the reforms that Ukraine has continued to implement and the progress measured by the Commission. Hungary chose not to participate in the decision regarding Ukraine and thus not to block the unity of Europeans. This step will now be followed by the adoption of the negotiation framework, and then by the holding of an intergovernmental accession conference. But this was the first step that allows us to send this positive signal to Ukraine.

The European Council also sent a very clear signal regarding the reforms to be undertaken in parallel with enlargement, and I emphasize this point that France has consistently defended in recent years. We are acknowledging both a movement of enlargement that has its own merits and responds to a geopolitical logic, but also our willingness to reform our European Union to improve its effectiveness and capacity to act. This is essential, if I may say so, already today. It has become even more so with the prospect of enlargement.

We have therefore asked the Belgian presidency of the Council of the European Union to work on adopting a roadmap by the summer of 2024 to provide a common political vision of what an enlarged Europe should be and of these concrete measures, of these concrete transformations of the functioning of our Union.

On the multiannual financial framework, there was an agreement among the 26 on the negotiation box and thus the possibility on climate priorities, migration, sovereignty, defense, and a few others to proceed with redeployments, but also with additional funding and aid to Ukraine. The box provides, as you know, for 17 billion euros in grants and 33 billion euros in loans. This box was blocked by Hungary. That was the choice made yesterday. And essentially, we decided to freeze this negotiation box of the 26 and to postpone the discussion on it to the very beginning of next year, considering that we could have more favorable discussion conditions and obtain an agreement from the 27 on this basis, which seems to us to be the most balanced and conducive. The balance that has been stabilized allows us to meet our objectives of implementing the asylum migration package, and in particular to act jointly with the countries of origin and transit. And what is planned on migration is very important for the effectiveness of our policies. Obviously, continuing support for Ukraine and financing defense, innovation, etc. In any case, we have the means; they have been planned — I mention this elsewhere, and I can come back to it if questions arise — to continue to ensure in the coming months support for Ukraine and Ukrainians, which is not blocked by today's decision. I want to emphasize this here.

The European Council then took a long look this morning at the situation in the Middle East. Europeans, it is no secret, do not have a unanimous view on what is happening in the region. But I believe we have objectives that are unanimous: the security of Israel, peace and security in the region, and the defense of international law and humanitarian law. Simply given the sensitivities and diplomatic histories that I respect and that everyone respects, the consequences that each draws from these principles that we all share, from these objectives that we share, are not quite the same, which is why we chose a statement from the president.

But France continues to have an extremely clear position that I will reiterate: priority to the release of hostages and a peace and security initiative for all that involves joint work on combating terrorism, Hamas, and all groups that threaten the security of Israel and the region. In this regard, I proposed that we better coordinate our action to combat terrorist actions in the Strait of Hormuz and the Red Sea.

You know, a few days ago, it was the French navy that intercepted Houthi drones that were about to strike a Norwegian ship. So, this is within the framework of the operations we are conducting. Several other Europeans, the Americans as well, are conducting operations. I believe we would benefit from better rearticulating our arrangements to truly enable this response in terms of security because today, if a terrorist group outside of Hamas is very active in the region and destabilizing not just Israel, but Americans and all of us, it is the Houthis, and therefore, it is very important that we contribute to this. This also lends credibility to the proposal that France made as early as October to have a security pillar in the response to the regional situation. I made this proposal this morning. It was taken up by the president of the Council and several members and by the High Representative. And so we will work on European coordination for action precisely to improve our operations at sea and combat these terrorist actions. We also continue, of course, to act against the various militias and destabilizing actions.

I will myself be in the region in a few days, alongside our forces that have been deployed for several years, since we have been fighting against Daesh, in Jordan.

We then insisted on the humanitarian aspect, which is the second pillar of the French initiative regarding the importance of coordinating our efforts.

We have sent several tens of millions of tons of humanitarian and medical freight to the region, and we have increased our aid to UNRWA by several tens of millions. We also have ad hoc initiatives, such as the deployment of the Dixmude, which is currently on the Egyptian coast, just at the border, and which, as I speak to you, is hosting about thirty children and adults who are sick or severely injured and thus contributes to this humanitarian offer. We also have coordinated action with the Jordanians, the United Arab Emirates, and Qatar in southern Gaza for health operations and hospital deployment. And I proposed that we have a coordination among Europeans on this subject because there are several initiatives being undertaken by the Italians, the Greeks, the Cypriots, and several others. I believe we would benefit from structuring them.

Finally, there is a shared desire among all members to advance on the political response. And here too, several of us have proposed that there be coordination of work to precisely advance towards the two-state solution and engage with all partners in the region. We also exchanged views on European security and defense to affirm our sovereignty. This is one of the ambitions in the continuity of the Versailles agenda and the strategic compass, to finalize under the French presidency.

We must make a much more substantial industrial effort to strengthen our production capacities, the resilience of our production chains, and our ability to provide long-term support to Ukraine. And to encourage industries to invest massively, the challenge is very clearly to legitimize the existence of a European demand through the adoption of a European defense industrial strategy that the Commission will present in early 2024, through a European defense investment program, and through an assumed European preference within the instruments and the establishment of joint acquisitions. And these are the building blocks, if I may say so, that we have consolidated in recent years and that the Versailles agenda has allowed us to accelerate.

We also had an exchange on migration in the face of the increase in irregular crossings of the European Union's borders and as the number of asylum applications is at its highest level since 2016, the response must be collective and European. On this subject, I want to say, at a time when our country has many debates that are entirely legitimate on the subject, all the national debates we may have should not make us forget that the heart of the response to combat immigration is European. And we, who are rather a country of secondary movements as they say, have in this regard a struggle linked with the countries of primary arrival. And this is the whole philosophy of what France has carried under its presidency, by unlocking part of the asylum and immigration pact and allowing progress. It is this whole set that we are finalizing. And I hope that the coming days will allow us to achieve this because we wish to have a more robust policy that enables us to better control the flows. What we are finalizing as Europeans is very important because it is fundamentally the capacity to much better register the people arriving on European soil, to have much more secure procedures, to have much more secure information exchanges, to have much clearer filtering, and to have much more effective return procedures than those we have today. So, it is a reform of this aspect that is key. At the same time, we have the primary arrival aspect, we have the external aspect, and on this we also have ambitions that we have begun to deploy by using the levers of European Union funding, as exemplified by what we are doing towards Tunisia or Egypt, with also ad hoc funding and the desire to better control the flows.

Finally, we exchanged views on a European strategic agenda that we will adopt after the European elections to guide the work of the European institutions for the next five years. We have seen it in recent years, the Union has experienced crises, unprecedented transformations, the pandemic, Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine, and obviously today the war in the Middle East.

It has led to profound transformations, those on climate, with the agenda, the Green Deal, and our common agenda and our common regulations and investments, and obviously the digital transitions. The response so far has been as rapid as possible and united. But very clearly, the years ahead will further increase the challenges and the necessity of having unity and a true European sovereignty policy. That is why this strategic agenda is, in my view, essential. I will have the opportunity to return to it in more detail in the coming weeks.

In this context, and to conclude, I would like to say a word to congratulate the conclusions of COP 28, which took place in Dubai and concluded in recent days. This COP was important, it was risky, and it allowed for very clear progress on, at least, an international commitment to phasing out fossil fuels. France, as you know, supports this phase-out agenda, first from coal, then from oil, and finally from gas by 2050. We have also worked to legitimize this agenda at the European level, and we must adhere to the complete phase-out of coal by 2030 for wealthy countries and do everything possible to curb the increase in coal power plants in the coming years. This is the heart of the battle. In this regard, COP also allowed for a clear agenda regarding the increase of our renewable and nuclear capacities, which are the two pillars of our energy strategy and which we have also managed to defend at the European level in a more neutral manner than was initially envisioned, and which I believe are key for Europe to be both sovereign, competitive, and carbon neutral by 2050.

I will now answer all your questions.

Journalist

On Ukraine, are we not witnessing a façade victory given that Viktor ORBAN has just said he wants to correct the decision and still has several vetoes in the accession process? And you said it yourself, we do not yet have an agreement on the 50 billion for Ukraine. Secondly, a somewhat more national question, what do you say to the French, particularly to French farmers, who are worried about the enlargement to Ukraine, which is a large agricultural nation? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

On the second question, we are very far today, in any case, from that; we have always defended an agricultural policy that has actually modernized a lot and that allows us to support the transition of the sector. I am committed to European agricultural sovereignty. And so, we defended it during the last CAP and we will continue to defend it, meaning supporting our capacity to produce quality food that meets our climate and biodiversity objectives. We are very far from an effective enlargement to Ukraine. And I have said that, in any case, any enlargement will require a profound reform of our rules. And so, it will only be possible either with a massive increase in funding or with a change in the rules and mechanisms that we currently have. So it will not be at the expense of our agriculture. That is a certainty. I have seen that the argument was indeed used deliberately by Mr. ORBAN, but that should not prevent us from thinking geopolitically. Can Europe today think without this perspective? No.

This allows me to link to your first question. I did not declare victory if you heard me correctly. I think we had a risk, which is that there could be, in a very difficult moment for Ukraine, a political response that has no legal value. The legal response is the opening of the intergovernmental conference. But politically, we could have had a no. We got a yes. And I believe in this regard that Prime Minister ORBAN did what he told us he would do, and he said: "I will not block unanimity." But the question is how we move forward collectively. And for me, the coming months are decisive for Hungary and for us. For Hungary because I believe that no one can say, and I say this to our Hungarian friends: Hungary was respected during this council. It has a voice represented by its Prime Minister. That is normal. He defends his interests. He was listened to; he requested a strategic debate. We had it. His voice was respected. This respect implies responsibilities, and so, I expect from Viktor ORBAN in the coming months precisely, that being respected, with his legitimate interests taken into account along with his duties, he behaves as a European and does not hold political advances hostage. If the conditions that are objectively set and measured by the Commission are not met, there will be no opening of negotiations. And we have always been clear. This is a process based on merit. However, if these rules are met, and I asked him the question, he told me he would not block if that were the case. If the 7 rules are met, then we must be able to open discussions. Similarly, on the budget, we will need to find an agreement. We have always managed to do this, and I think that in February, or at least at the beginning of the year, I do not want to preempt the date, it will probably be easier. I want to collectively believe that he will be able, beyond postures, to show responsibility as he is respected. And then we, as Europeans, will have a moment anyway, the question of truth. And I think we must not yield to our strategic interests, nor to our values, nor to our foundational texts when there is a desire to completely block us, and indeed our treaties allow us, ultimately, to continue to move forward, that’s it.

Journalist

A question about Viktor ORBAN precisely, since you mentioned him. What does it say, ultimately, he left the room, the decision was made without him, what does it say about European democracy and your relationship with Viktor ORBAN? It seems that it will be a bit of a trade-off? What makes you think that he will indeed do what he said he would do in the coming months?

Emmanuel MACRON

The possibility of abstaining on decisions to avoid blocking them is something we have already used, I would say, at the very moment we distributed the most important jobs around the table of the council; it has happened to us, because I remind you that Chancellor MERKEL herself could not participate in the vote for the presidency of the European Commission, not having the agreement of her coalition partners. I say this for the record. We end up being old. So it has already happened, it exists. And… Of course, she abstained. He also specified, it is an abstention. And so on this aspect, I believe that it corresponds to what he himself had said; he could have blocked. He did not do so. So he allowed Europe to send a positive political signal to Ukraine. Which, in this regard, is, I believe, an important element, and he did not decide to veto. But he had indeed said so in the columns of your French colleagues a few days ago; in this regard, he is consistent. I think we must continue to move forward, work tirelessly. I believe in the virtue of dialogue, work, and a sense of responsibility. And so, I think our debates today have helped to clarify ambiguities that may have existed. They have allowed us to delve into the details of the conditions that had been requested from Ukraine, the report from the European Commission, the feedback that was provided. So there is in-depth work. There are differences of opinion that we reduce in doing so. And so I think this council has been useful for the substantive discussions it has allowed on this subject. And that is what makes me confident about what we can achieve at the beginning of the year. So we will, with several colleagues, with the presidency of the Council and the Commission, engage to achieve a result. So I think we must continue to move forward and work tirelessly. And I have confidence in the spirit of responsibility and our ability to reach an agreement.

Journalist

You were one of the last Western heads of state to continue dialogue with Vladimir PUTIN after Russia's invasion. Yesterday, at a press conference, he responded to our correspondent by blaming you for the rupture of exchanges between France and Russia. "We do not decline contacts," he said. "If there is an interest, then we are ready." First, what do you think of his statement? Under what conditions would you accept to resume dialogue with Vladimir PUTIN, and above all, on what topics do you think this would be useful? Thank you very much.

Emmanuel MACRON

I will be very simple. It is not me who unilaterally triggered the war and broke the treaties that I had decided. And it is not France that decided to commit war crimes in northern Ukraine, making discussions almost impossible. Well, we need to be serious. And so I have a simple phrase. I have not changed my number. And if President PUTIN has serious proposals, a willingness to re-engage in a dialogue that allows for building peace respectful of international law, France will always be a power that will help and will not spare its efforts to achieve a result as we did during all the years preceding the conflict by being one of the mediation powers of the Minsk disagreement in the so-called "Normandy" format. And as I did for several weeks, even several months after the outbreak of the war in February. And so, if President PUTIN has a desire to dialogue and serious proposals to move forward and exit the conflict and build a lasting peace, that is, respectful of international law and therefore of Ukrainian interests and sovereignty, I will take the call.

Journalist

A question about the political situation in France. You have made it known that you do not wish to use Article 49.3 to pass the immigration law. Why this change of position on an article that you have always supported, regardless of the type of text? And then, moreover, your government appears divided in recent days. You do not have the guarantee of your majority's support on this text. Whose fault is it? Yours? That of the Prime Minister? That of the Minister of the Interior? Does he still have your confidence today? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, I have always defended Article 49.3 and the use of constitutional texts because I think it is a good thing. Now, there are contexts, and it is simple. The game of oppositions, and I want to say here the immense responsibility taken by two historical governing forces. I say historical because they have decided not to be anymore, by not coming to the Saint-Denis Meetings and choosing to vote with La France Insoumise and the National Rally; the Socialist Party and The Republicans have decided to join and thus refuse any dialogue. And as true as I have assumed the use of Article 49.3 for the final vote on a pension law that was one of the most debated in the fifth, it would not be serious to pass a sensitive text under 49.3 when the oppositions have done everything to prevent a debate. You see, I try to be consistent. In any case, I think it has been a game of obstruction and refusal of dialogue that the French cannot understand. So I do not understand either. Because we can agree or disagree, but I find it strange not to dialogue. Now, I am for results and pragmatism. Our country needs to improve its rules to better combat illegal immigration, traffickers, and ultimately all those who profit from the misery of the world and weaken our system by putting too much pressure on it. And so, we need to improve our rules.

Sur la deuxième question, ce n'est plus le cas. Il y a des matériels qui ont été livrés au moment du conflit et que nous discutons d'ailleurs. Et c'était des discussions aussi que nous avons favorisées entre l'Ukraine et ces pays pour pouvoir obtenir ces capacités. C'est ce que nous sommes en train de faire aujourd’hui. Mais dire qu'aujourd'hui, il y a des obus ou des canons qui sont livrés à ces pays, c'est faux. Vraiment, on priorise à la fois nos propres capacités à nous régénérer parce que nous avons, nous, besoin aussi de maintenir nos propres capacités de défense. Donc ça, c'est, je dirais, le premier point.

Ensuite, livrer pour l'Ukraine. Il n'y a pas aujourd'hui de flux qui va vers ces pays. Il y a l'objectif face à ce qu'ils avaient accumulé dans les années précédentes. Et ça, c'est un travail que nous faisons en Européens, en lien avec d'ailleurs les Allemands, les Italiens et d'autres, pour pouvoir récupérer certains de ces matériels et pouvoir les diriger vers l'Ukraine. Et c'est là où il y a des résistances parce qu'ils ont peur du risque et que la tension qui s'est accrue ces derniers temps ne les conduise pas à se désarmer. Mais c'est ça la discussion, ce n'est pas du flux nouveau.

Ensuite, sur l'économie de guerre, nous ne sommes pas au bout de notre travail et là-dessus, je fais un point très régulier avec le ministre des Armées qui y passe beaucoup de temps. Certains industriels ont réussi à produire beaucoup plus vite, ce qui permet de répondre aux demandes importantes des Ukrainiens, mais aussi aux nôtres. D'autres restent sur des rythmes et des capacités qui sont encore insuffisantes et donc on a encore un très gros travail à faire. C'est pourquoi aussi, ce que nous avons fait en Européens aujourd'hui, ce sur quoi nous avançons, est clé parce qu'on peut emmener nos industriels à produire beaucoup plus vite si on leur donne de la visibilité sur nos commandes. Et c'est aussi pour ça qu'on a besoin d'acheter en Européens ce qu'on produit en Européens. La faiblesse de l'Europe a été que très longtemps, elle n'a pas suffisamment produit sur son sol et qu'elle a acheté du matériel non européen.

Sur votre première question, pour être clair, ce qui s'est passé ces deux jours : on a eu quelqu'un qui est sorti et qui n'a pas pris part au vote, qui s'est abstenu sur la décision liée à l'Ukraine, et le même qui a mis un veto sur le budget. Si on est très clairs. Donc on a eu deux situations différentes. C’est ce qui permet de dire pour l'une, il n'a pas bloqué, c'est un succès politique et on a pu avancer ; sur la deuxième, on est bloqué.

Alors on a des mécanismes pour se débloquer, on le sait bien. D'ailleurs, l'Europe, je pense, sous le contrôle collectif, l'a utilisée pour son propre budget du temps où les Britanniques étaient encore parmi nous et où David CAMERON avait bloqué le budget et il y avait tout un mécanisme de contournement. Donc nous savons faire. Et je vous renvoie à ces péripéties. Ça suppose quelques gymnastiques. Donc, nous saurons faire de toute façon.

Après, je pense que ce n'est pas bon et ça crée un système de défiance. Et la référence que je fais aux Britanniques montre qu'ensuite on se met dans des logiques, y compris nationales, qui sont plutôt des logiques centrifuges. Donc, je ne pense pas que ça doit bloquer tout le système et en tout cas, moi j'y tiens. Donc, on a des réponses institutionnelles et procédurales qui nous permettent de ne pas être totalement bloquées. Mais moi, je pense que ça a beaucoup de valeur de garder les gens engagés avec nous et de se dire : « on a des différences, on les connaît. » C'est ce qu'on a su faire pendant la pandémie, ce qu'on a su faire dès le début, depuis deux ans. Et donc c'est aussi pourquoi je crois à la valeur du dialogue respectueux. Et c'est l'investissement, je dirais politique et humain, que je fais avec le premier ministre ORBAN. Et donc pour le futur et l’avancée, ce qui m'importe, c'est : « qu'est-ce qu'on veut faire exactement ? » J'aurai l'occasion d'y revenir.

Moi, je veux une Europe, en tout cas, un périmètre européen plus large, c'est un peu ce qu'on a voulu penser déjà avec la communauté politique européenne. Je pense que sur des grands sujets structurants, l'Europe doit être en effet dans ce périmètre large quand on parle de défense, de géopolitique, de sécurité, d'énergie, de migrations. Et après, je pense qu'on a besoin d'une Europe plus resserrée quand on parle de marché unique. Et puis, peut-être de politique, on décide d'intégrer davantage. La question qu'on doit se poser, c'est est-ce qu'on a besoin ? Il y a deux façons de le faire. Est-ce qu'on doit changer complètement les traités de l'Union européenne pour le faire ou est-ce qu'on doit utiliser au maximum les flexibilités que les traités nous offrent et inventer des traités nouveaux à l'extérieur ? Ça peut aussi exister. Je pense en particulier que sur des sujets clés, c'est ce que j'ai demandé pour vous dire les choses en exclusivité au ministre de l'Économie et des Finances, je considère que sur l'union des marchés de capitaux, ça fait maintenant presque 10 ans qu'on patine. Essayons de voir si on n'a pas à une proposition, on est prêt à avancer à quelques-uns. C'est le principe même quand on a acté un blocage des coopérations renforcées. Je souhaite qu'on puisse aller dans ce sens sur certains des points. C'est comme ça qu'on fera avancer l'Europe. Et donc, je pense sur les sujets-là du moment, il faut essayer de tenir notre unanimité, d'avancer, de discuter, de travailler. Mais après, pour l'avenir, je pense qu'on a des leviers pour être très innovants, sans faire un grand bigbang des traités, et pour inventer des choses aussi à l'extérieur. Je peux peut-être prendre une dernière question.

Journaliste

On a entendu là avec la démarche d’Olaf SCHOLZ dont ça a été l'initiative de proposer à Monsieur ORBAN de sortir de la salle pour éviter un blocage. On a beaucoup entendu dire : on vit « un moment SCHOLZ ». Après tous ces mois où on a dit : l'Europe, il ne regarde pas, il est concentré sur des problèmes intérieurs, et puis, ce n'est pas son truc. Est-ce que vous vous trouvez qu'on vit « un moment SCHOLZ » ?

Ma deuxième question sur le Proche-Orient : comment voyez-vous la position collective des Européens évoluer depuis le 7 octobre, sur le cessez-le-feu notamment ? Est-ce que vous sentez un mouvement ? Est-ce que vous pensez que cette dynamique va se poursuivre et qu'à un moment donné, peut-être qu'à 25, 26, je ne sais pas, on pourrait arriver à quelque chose ou pas ?

Emmanuel MACRON

Sur le premier point, je ne ferai pas de commentaire politique. Ce n'est pas mon rôle. J'ai toujours, depuis le premier jour, travaillé très étroitement avec le chancelier SCHOLZ sur toutes les questions européennes et il a toujours été un partenaire engagé, sincère, partageant accord ou désaccord. C'est le coeur même de la relation franco-allemande, mais en tout cas, veillant à bâtir ensemble des compromis. Et pour ce qui est de ce sommet, je crois qu'on a tous oeuvré ensemble, là aussi avec le président MICHEL, et la présidente du conseil MELONI, le chancelier SCHOLZ et plusieurs autres dirigeants, le premier ministre RUTTE pour qu'il y ait un débat qui s'installe en lien avec la présidence espagnole, un débat qui s'installe et que le premier ministre ORBAN soit respecté. Et à la fin, on est arrivé de manière concertée à proposer la solution qu'il avait lui-même susurrée. Je vous invite à lire ce qu'il avait lui-même dit dans les colonnes de vos collègues du Point. Il avait dit exactement ce que nous avons fait. Il n'y a pas de surprise de ce qui s'est passé à cet égard. Il dit qu'il était contre, mais qu’il ne bloquerait pas. C'est exactement ce qui s'est passé. Bon, ça nous permet d'avancer. C'est pour ça que je ne suis pas non plus triomphaliste aujourd'hui. Mais je pense que ça aurait pu être pire et c'est un bon point pour les Ukrainiens qui en ont besoin aujourd'hui. Mais ça veut dire qu'il faut continuer et que derrière, il faut continuer tous, à s'engager. Il aurait tort lui-même d'être triomphaliste aussi sur les autres sujets. On travaille. C'est un point d'étape qui a permis de lever des ambiguïtés et de préparer des bonnes décisions dans les mois à venir.

Sur ce qui est du Proche-Orient, je pense quand même quand je vois les choses que juste après le dernier Conseil européen, la France était l'un des seuls pays de l'Union à voter aux côtés de la Jordanie, une résolution qui, pour la première, appelait une trêve puis un cessez-le-feu. Je constate que la quasi-totalité, à l'exception de quelques-uns, s'est abstenue ou a voté à nos côtés la dernière résolution qui va dans ce sens. Donc on est quand même tous en train de progresser dans la même direction. Et je me félicite que le choix que la France a fait parmi les premiers d'acter justement un cessez-le-feu, une demande de cessez-le-feu, enfin, une trêve immédiate conduisant à un cessez-le-feu. C'était le terme exact de ce que nous avions fait et d'engager une discussion avec l'ensemble des pays du Sud et de la région est suivie par de plus en plus de partenaires. J'ai insisté sur le point qu'il nous fallait très vite avoir une position plus cohérente sur ce sujet et avancer. Donc je suis plutôt confiant.

Maintenant, je pense qu’il ne faut pas en faire un objectif en soi. Ce qui m'importe plus, c'est qu’en Européens on ait une réponse très concrète et de coordination sur les questions sécuritaires. C'est la proposition que j'ai faite sur la mer Rouge et Ormuz. Qu'on ait une réponse concrète ensemble sur l'humanitaire et qu'on ait un travail commun sur la solution politique. Je crois plus à ça qu'à des textes communs. Et honnêtement, on est plus utile à faire cela qu'à faire des textes communs avec des mots. Parce que c'est la guerre.

Look, first, I do hope there is a possible consensus on a ceasefire. I think we should focus our energy on what makes sense and it is important for people on the ground. And this is why we work very hard to create the… I mean, broader possible consensus on our initiative, peace and security for all, release of hostages, coordination and cooperation on security. And I think what makes sense and is important is the cooperation of Europeans to fight against terrorism in the region and to coordinate ourselves in Red Sea, Ormuz, and so on in order to have concrete actions together. Work collectively and concretely to bring humanitarian aid and humanitarian support to help Gaza people and work together for a two-state solution. And I think this is our top priority and it's much more important. But France will support all the resolutions and will try to work hard beyond Europe to convince Israel to have a truce guiding to a ceasefire and building this international consensus.

As for the Europeans, I think let's be very precise. Yesterday, it was a failure of a revision of our budget because of the veto put on the table by Hungary. But this is not a veto, paradoxically, on the funding for Ukraine because we do have a mechanism to fund Ukraine. We have 18 billion we can raise on the market. It's a QMV decision. It's not unanimity. And it was what we negotiated last year. So, I think we can fund Ukraine if we are not totally blocked next year. So, I think the perspective in this regard, what Prime Minister ORBAN tried to present after yesterday, honestly, is dishonest. He blocked the whole box, meaning he blocked financing for migration. He blocked de facto grants for Ukraine, but we can have loans and financing for next year. And he blocked as well some very critical issues… our ability to finance interest rates and so on in a more sophisticated way, less expensive for countries. And he blocked some mechanism, for instance. I think, honestly, about Slovakia, because Slovakia was waiting this box to get concrete money at the end of this year, and it was blocked by the decision of Prime Minister ORBAN. I think it's a bad decision for Slovakia. And I do regret it. But we are not blocked for Ukraine, concretely. We are blocked to provide perspective on a multiyear framework for 4 years. But for next year, we are not blocked. This is why I think Prime Minister ORBAN has a strong incentive to converge and find with us a good consensus for our budget and the revision beginning next year.

Thank you very much, Ladies and Gentlemen. Good luck to all and I wish happy holidays to those I will not see again. Thank you very much.