Exchanges with farmers in Réunion.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

22 April 2025 · Exchanges with farmers in Réunion

Context
Macron met with farmers in Réunion on April 22, 2025, to address urgent agricultural challenges following Cyclone Garance and discuss the island's food autonomy strategy.
Main themes
Réunion agricultural model, cyclone Garance recovery, food autonomy, sugarcane sector support, emergency agricultural aid, climate resilience, agricultural diversification, overseas territories policy, fruits and vegetables sector, livestock sector
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,836
73rd percentile
Sentences
128
74th percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 56%55%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

128 sentences in 20 paragraphs

Hello, ladies and gentlemen,

I am happy that we can meet again. And thank you, by the way, for adapting, because we were initially supposed to meet for much less time. But given the situation and what happened with Garance and what your sectors have experienced, we thought it was probably more relevant. So thank you for welcoming us and for being able to take stock of all the sectors, to look with you at the concrete difficulties we have in the very short term, and to also try to project ourselves collectively.

I must say, and I have defended this each time, I consider that the Réunion model is quite specific, because you have succeeded, like few others, in a model that has gradually diversified. We have rightly supported its scope, but there is a food autonomy that is unprecedented in our overseas territories, and which is the result of diversification, of a capacity to produce. Now, there are, at the same time, obviously, the uncertainties that come with the region, and you have not been spared. So I want us to be able to revisit this, which obviously weakens certain sectors, and I want us to be able to speak the truth to each other.

I really want to thank the minister for spending time with you and all the state services, and the Minister of State, the Minister for Overseas Territories, who came several weeks ago and who has come several times to also take stock with you, but let’s look a bit at what we can reasonably do in terms of urgency with the sectors and what we need to do. And then also how we look ahead with you, all the sectors and the local authorities to continue to take a new step because we know well that we need to continue to create value, succeed in transforming, and indeed take new steps in the food strategy. And that is one of the objectives of this meeting for me. I will not be longer.

I wanted to thank you for adapting and to tell you that the time we will spend here is, in my eyes, very important and should help us face the urgency and project ourselves. And by definition, solutions do not fall from the sky, but we always manage to find them when there are men and women of good will, which is the case here. So, we will succeed.

[Participants' interventions]

Emmanuel MACRON

Well. Thank you very much and thank you to the ministers who have spent time in previous trips and just before with you. So, listen, we will try together to address the issue by having the right method and starting from the right observations. You have all made the observations. I want to say here very clearly that it is understood, heard, and supported by the members of the Government, whether it is the Minister of State, Minister for Overseas Territories, or the Minister of Agriculture, the Réunion model has its specificities, and it is not just about one of the sectors being disrupted or weakened, particularly sugarcane, since that is the heart of the discussion we are having today given the difficulties regarding aid, because it is indeed the pivot of an agriculture that has then managed to diversify and move towards food autonomy. So that is an achievement, we do not call it into question, and therefore we will fight for it.

The second thing, I also want to be very clear and explicit here, no one here underestimates the exceptional nature of what you experienced last February. That does not remove a challenge that is ours, but I would say it is even worse, it is that we must adapt recurrently to these events. And that is the whole challenge, by the way, that is ours for the entire region, to see how we adapt our agricultural models and our food production so that they are much more resilient and because they will have to face, and you said it very well, cyclones, you know them. But here, you had, I would say, a triple problem, the cyclone last year, the drought, and a completely unprecedented cyclone, and therefore, for us, it is very clear, I also say it, Garance, it is an exceptional situation. And so, the idea is not to deal with the usual mechanisms.

Once these two elements are established, how do we move forward? The ministers have come back, and I will not repeat it here, we have a series of aids that have been put on the table, we have about 244 million euros of aid that have been allocated for Réunion, which represents 45% of all overseas territories in the agricultural sector, and of these 244, 145 go to the sugarcane and sugar sector, with the efforts being made by the two ministries. So, there is an effort being made. I believe I can say that it allows for support for part of the sectors, I speak under your control, and that there is then a desire to structure, particularly in fruits and vegetables, to better protect, in any case, better integrate into the regional space on arboriculture and to consolidate what has been done in the meat sectors. But so everything that has been announced by the minister on fruits and vegetables, livestock, the transversal elements are confirmed. That, to take your phrase, is the first level.

The second level, we cannot ignore that you have a concern — correct me if I misinterpret you so that we can act usefully — that we can move to the next level to prepare for the upcoming campaign and that you have a subject and cash flow. And so, what we need to do, under the control of the Minister of State and the Minister, is to move forward to improve the support per hectare in the areas that have been most affected. That is to say, today, there too, I speak under control, we have 40% of the additional costs covered in the East and North areas, which are very impacted, which amounts to 765 euros per hectare. What we are saying is that it is probably on this that, for you to face the 2026 campaigns, we need to increase this effort to around 1,000. Simply, what I propose is that, therefore, in an exceptional situation, we have an exceptional mechanism, under the authority of the prefect, with the department, the region, all the sectors, and the union representatives, that we can, in the coming weeks, sit around the table to verify that this is indeed the case, because perhaps we need to do something else and take another approach. And that by June, we build an emergency mechanism to have the second level, 2026. Because we are clear that you will not manage to get there. I also need the sector to help us. There are reserves that are there, perhaps we can mobilize them, not to replace investment in the tool, because I will come to the next point, the third level, but in the short term, so that we can do everything.

What is the constraint of the ministries? You know well, the financial and political situation of the country. And so, I will not propose here and tell you that everything is possible, because I am before you, I also try to take into account the constraints that are those of the ministers who are here, but we have heard you on the additional costs per hectare in the most affected areas, we need to move to a second level and therefore increase the aid to prepare for the 2026 campaign and perhaps also other mechanisms. So, we are completely ready to do that and to look at it.

And so, I wish that between now and June, there is this work that is supervised by the prefect with you: emergency mechanism, agricultural emergency Réunion, with, if we say so, a particular focus on, obviously, sugarcane, and that by June, we can come up with the right options. Now, the last level, the follow-up. The follow-up is that we manage to strengthen, with the sectors that are here and your elected officials, what has already been done and which is a success of the Réunion model. And I see it with, in a way, three axes.

The first, how do we build a new step in outlets and transformation? We have the securing of the upstream, that is what I want us to do by June for sugarcane, because we have the production declines that have been mentioned. But we must much better value the downstream. So, how do we consolidate our national and regional strategy with mechanisms that we sustain, the ministries by your side and all the mobilized local authorities? There is a second step, how do we build, and this is one of the objectives of this trip, indeed, with all the work and with the COI, a real regional strategy. And I subscribe to everything that has been said, but which is a bit of our schizophrenia collectively, from a regional point of view, that is to say that when we talk to our overseas territories and with our overseas territories, we always look towards Paris. We have always conceived our policies like that. What is good is to have the same thing as in Paris. And it is true because it is the sense of republican equality. But in doing so, we have ourselves contributed to creating constraints that separate us from the rest of the region, because you cannot be competitive with the same economic fundamentals as in Paris in the sub-region. And because you cannot have 100% of your food matching metropolitan standards when, in the sub-region, you know, we have talked about zebu, and indeed, when we had real food problems after Chido, what did the prefect do?

The first thing: he created flexibilities to be able to import much more easily. And everyone, when they travel in the sub-region, will consume food or product quality that I do not feel is inconceivable for us. And so, we must in good faith look at this model of what integration in the sub-region is. It goes beyond what is done at the first pillar level for the follow-up, which is to consolidate our autonomy. What can we do better at the sub-regional level? What can we better both export and import? What makes it so that when we do not produce it here, we go looking for it much too far and much too expensively? And that feeds into the high cost of living. And it is even truer with your Mahoran neighbors than in Réunion because they are even more dependent.

So let us finally have this approach and that is all we are working on with the AFD, the IRD, but also CIRAD and research organizations. What we want to do is build a model where we raise the performance, the practices of the sub-region in terms of agri-food, but where we also try to create common standards. And I believe we have a lot to build. Because if we manage to create common standards in the sub-region, we create competitiveness and resilience for it. And the Indian Ocean region has an agricultural model that it must defend. And that has been very well said. There are niches today that exist. There are people who are managing to get by. Is the model, well beyond the Réunion question, today satisfactory for everyone in the region? No. And so, we have in a way two legs to succeed in this: our presence in this territory, but also all our solidarity investment, the work we do with our research institutes and the policy we pursue in terms of food and agri-food sovereignty with our partners. So that is the second axis where I really hope we can develop and build regional solutions that will allow us to address part of our problems and that will also create export markets for you. Because we must also see that food autonomy should not be viewed sector by sector. There are sectors that will export, others that will import, but it must be much more flexible in the sub-region.

My last point is Europe. It has been said. And so, the fight we are going to lead, the vice-president recalled perfectly, we fought, a little over 5 years ago, when our mechanisms were already threatened. I also believe that we have today a president of the Council who is much more attached to our RUP and I believe above all that we have to assert, in this geopolitical moment, we have a Commission, a Parliament, a college, finally for me, partners, who are much more lucid about the state of the world. Five years ago, when we talked about the Indo-Pacific and the vulnerabilities of the contestation we could have, we looked at you, we were not entirely sure we would follow you. Since then, we have experienced international pandemics, the war in Ukraine, a fracturing of the world that means that now everyone is lucid and we are a chance for Europe with these territories. It is that we give it feet in regions where it has interests to defend. And so, indeed, we will fight first for a good budget. But what we advocate is to have a budget that increases, with more own resources, and because the investment needs of Europe are there, so it cannot be a budget that is shrinking or even maintaining. We had succeeded five years ago, then we were told that with Brexit it would decrease. We maintained it. Now, it needs to be expanded. Yes, we need to both increase and modernize the POSEI which no longer meets today’s needs. And the minister knows how much on the issues that the minister will also have. And so that is the second axis we want to build.

On our outermost regions, we also want to make the instruments more flexible. And I will tell you very simply, it happens that fishing is not invited here, but I want to say a word for our fishermen. I want to say a word because I told my teams and ministers: I am ashamed of what we have done over the past six years regarding fishing. And I say this in front of Europeans, I know, convinced, but how do we create misunderstanding with Europe and make Europe hated? That is to say, we manage our fishing fleets with mechanisms as if we were in the Bay of Biscay. We are crazy. Six years ago, I had fishermen, it was at your place, Serge, by the way, if my memory serves me right, who came to tell me: "we need to renew the boats." We have not been able to respond to that. Now, we have fought, we are making progress in Guyana, I want at least Réunion to have the same as Guyana, that is to say, we need to have concrete and rapid responses now. And today we have constraints imposed on us even though you are in fishing grounds where competition is massive. So when I say we need to modernize the framework for the outermost regions, it means we need to simply take into account the ecosystem in which they operate. When you have competition in fishing from Madagascar and sometimes predation from illegal fishing by others that I will not name, we impose the same fleet renewal constraints as if we were in the Mediterranean. That makes no sense. And so that is the third area we will fight for at the European level.

I do not want to be longer. Those were the few perspectives I wanted to offer you here. But if I wanted us to take the time with the ministers to be by your side, changing the program to spend more time precisely, it is because I am convinced, first of all, that you have done truly extraordinary things in recent years. And I say this to you with a lot of sincerity and strength, because I am very sensitive to the message of distress expressed by many colleagues and operators who today have no means to live and who carry anger. And we hear that very deeply.

So, we will act together with these three phases. 1) The urgency. Under the authority of the prefect by June, emergency post-Garance measures. You have my word. And we respond at the second level of the rocket. 2) We consolidate our national sectors and then we fight in the Indian Ocean and Europe. You can count on us, and I thank the ministers who are fully mobilized. And I also thank the Chamber, all the state services that are here, your local authorities, and ODEADOM which is doing a wonderful job. Thank you all.