Micro-statement from the President of the Republic in El Arich.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

8 April 2025 · Press remarks in El Arish

Context
Macron addressed journalists in El Arish, Egypt on April 8, 2025, during a diplomatic visit to discuss Gaza ceasefire efforts and humanitarian aid with Arab leaders.
Main themes
Gaza humanitarian crisis, ceasefire negotiations, humanitarian aid access, protection of humanitarian workers, international humanitarian law, Palestinian governance, hostage releases, Hamas demilitarization, Gaza reconstruction, Trump-Netanyahu talks, Arab partners coordination
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,579
82nd percentile
Sentences
232
92nd percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.70
13th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 61%56%
  • Ceremonial 18%16%
  • Social 11%10%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

232 sentences in 92 paragraphs

Mr. President, did President Trump respond to you yesterday regarding the proposals and ideas you put forward with your Arab partners on the points you mentioned? And the second question I would like to ask you concerns a concern that you have certainly heard from NGOs, regarding the militarization of humanitarian aid delivery in Gaza and the West Bank, that is to say, the fact that Israel would ultimately choose the NGOs that could deliver aid protected by the Israeli army, etc. This is a significant concern. It is a violation of international law. What do you say to that?

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, we presented this proposal to President Trump, and we had an exchange before he met and spoke with Prime Minister Netanyahu. So we were able to express our very strong concern given the situation, our conviction that the solution is political, and President Trump is going to the region in a few weeks. If a political solution can be built, it can only be done within the framework of a ceasefire. And so there was a long exchange, about twenty minutes, I believe you heard, there is a lot of work underway, discussions that have taken place in recent hours, and I hope that the next hours will at least be marked by a resumption of humanitarian aid, which, once again, is my top priority.

Because we were told earlier, both the UN agencies and all the NGOs have been very clear. There has never been such a situation, and we are two to three weeks away from a break in terms of drinking water… we are beyond the strict minimum for living but from what has never been lacking until now, while everything was already lacking. So I hope that in the coming hours discussions will continue. So that is really the urgency, but we will do everything we can so that in the coming hours and days, we can also make progress on the ceasefire.

I have heard and I share the concern of both the United Nations agencies and the non-governmental organizations. Humanitarian aid has rules. It has rules that are precisely those of non-discriminatory access because we come to help women and men, children, elderly people, regardless of who they are, where they come from, because that is the very principle of international humanitarian law. And so it must not be an instrument of war, under any circumstances. And I think it is our duty, it is our duty, all the nations that have a responsibility within the United Nations and who believe in what has been our international order and what must remain, and it is our responsibility as a permanent member of the Security Council. And so very clearly, we will defend this limit.

Journalist

But Trump mentioned yesterday discussions about a ceasefire that have resumed with Israel. Did you mention these discussions?

Emmanuel MACRON

That is what we are pushing for, yes, absolutely, that is what we wished for. That is exactly what we discussed. And so we pushed with President Sisi and the King of Jordan so that we could, as quickly as possible, obtain a ceasefire of 40 to 50 days with new releases of hostages and unfortunately the return of bodies and the resumption of discussions on the terms I just mentioned. That is to say, during this 40-day period, we can resume work on the demilitarization of Hamas, on governance and security in Gaza the day after, on the political transition and the evolution of the Palestinian Authority, and on the reconstruction plan for Gaza.

Journalist

15 humanitarian workers were killed near Rafah on March 23. Videos show that they presented themselves as humanitarian workers. Do you condemn what happened, which at the very least resembles a blunder?

Emmanuel MACRON

Of course I condemn it, and I had the opportunity, upon arriving here, to express my condolences to the organizations present here and through them, to their Palestinian colleagues, all those Palestinian Red Crescent workers. But as I said, many agencies, many programs and organizations, unfortunately, have been suffering this in recent months. And so I expressed my condolences to them, the condolences of France. We obviously strongly condemn these attacks, and it is essential that the truth be established as it should be, because the world has rules, and that is a good thing. And above all, humanitarian workers must be protected when they intervene, because they are not parties to a conflict. They are there on behalf of the international community to help those in need. And so, it is absolutely essential today to accept no concession on the protection of humanitarian workers.

Journalist

President Trump, in the Oval Office with Prime Minister Netanyahu, spoke about Gaza in real estate terms, mentioned annexation, and talked about population displacement. Does that mean that all of this is leading, for now, nowhere?

Emmanuel MACRON

Listen, the priority, I repeat, for everyone to keep in mind, I am happy to comment every day on things that are said, but the reality is that you have 2 million people who are trapped. 2 million. After months and months of bombing in a terrible war, tens of thousands of people have lost their lives, where you have tens of thousands of children who are maimed without families. That is what we are talking about when we talk about war. It is not about a real estate project. And what we experienced this morning, you were with me, are women, children who have experienced tragedy and I do not know how these children will grow up. Can you imagine for a second what they have already experienced? You see the level of hardness, of violence that can exist when one has only experienced bombings, atrocity. But all have said one thing: "As soon as I am on my feet, I want to return to Gaza" because they themselves are the children, the grandchildren of women and men who have lost everything to stay in Gaza and who had sometimes been pushed from other territories.

And we cannot erase history and geography. Because if it were as simple as a real estate project and the acquisition of space in a building program, there would never have been war. And so, here we are, and we must hear that, and we must hear two things that are essential for there to be peace in the region: the legitimate right of the Palestinian people to have a state, a territory, and to live in peace, and the legitimate right of the Israeli people to see their state, Israel, recognized by all its neighbors as well, and to live in peace and security. And the denial of one or the other is enough to destabilize the entire region.

Journalist

Have you made progress on the recognition of the Palestinian state? You have long said that it needed to create an impact for it to advance. Given the hardening of the Israeli government, does that seem like a viable option in the short term?

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes.

Journalist

Given the hardening of the Israeli government, does that seem like a viable and sustainable option in the short term for you?

Emmanuel MACRON

My priority is first humanitarian aid, the ceasefire, the resumption of work. Then, there is a whole process that we are working on, including with the Israeli government, with partners in the region, with the entire international community, which must lead us to this conference co-chaired by Saudi Arabia and France next June. I spoke about it eight days ago with Prime Minister Netanyahu, and so we will work with Israel on this path. And I believe that it is a path we must build together, because recognition must also go hand in hand with recognition by Israel's main partners and above all the possibility of having, fundamentally, a regional security organization that preserves the security of all and stability.

Journalist

Mr. President, during your conversation with President Trump, did you discuss the issue of tariffs? We see that the economic consequences in France and around the world are already quite devastating in just 48 hours.

Emmanuel MACRON

I brought it up, I had brought it up before, and we will bring it up again in the coming days. The situation is simple. France, Europe have never wished for chaos or an increase in tariffs. We believe it is a bad idea and a bad response to the issues of trade deficits. We have also always said that we would defend our economy. And so, if there were tariffs, if they are at 20%, there would be a response. The European Commission is carrying out this work within its competencies. First, to respond to the initial tariffs that have been imposed on steel, aluminum, mobile, and then to prepare in a few weeks a response. And the objective we are pursuing is to protect all our economic sectors and all our compatriots who work in these sectors. But it is to reach a situation where President Trump reverses his decision. And so the objective for us is simple, it is the dismantling of tariffs and to reach a situation where free movement and prosperity can occur. But if it has to go through a moment where we have to explain that we are ready to respond, we must be prepared to do so. This is what we have built at the level of France with the Prime Minister and the Government last week by bringing together representatives from all sectors, and this is what will be worked on at the European level. But we believe that the priorities today are elsewhere, that if we want to do more trade, gain market shares, we need to be more competitive, we need to continue labor reforms, we need to invest in innovation and focus on these projects rather than imposing tariffs. So our desire is for there to be a reduction in these tariffs.

Journalist

Mr. President, regarding the aid packages that could not be delivered. Why did France stop the air drops of aid?

Emmanuel MACRON

Well, we have always done what was relevant at the time it was done. You are right. France committed from day one. I said: we have always maintained this line. We lost compatriots in the attack on October 7. It was the deadliest terrorist attack for France since the Nice attacks. We strongly condemned the terrorist attack by Hamas, mourned our children, and called for the release of all hostages.

From that day on, we have supported Israel and its security. But after a few weeks of efforts and special operations against Hamas, we also clearly stated that the response could not be a massive indiscriminate war on Gaza given the population there, its density, and the very structures. That is why, from October 2023, we called for a ceasefire. That is why we organized the first humanitarian conference in Paris in November 2023, on November 10. And that is why we multiplied operations.

When Jordan or the United Arab Emirates offered us air drop operations, we did it. We conducted ground operations, along with Qatar and Egypt. We brought in, from the very first weeks, the Dixmude, with its hospital, precisely, its military hospital and its capabilities and logistical support. This military ship, with its health capabilities, was mobilized. And all of late 2023 and early 2024 allowed us to treat thousands of children, women, and men who had serious injuries. We provided 1,200 tons of humanitarian freight. I brought more with me this morning, and several hundred million in aid.

France has never ceased its effort. We simply did it with partners each time, in the most operational, most suitable way, so we continue.

Journalist

Not the air drops.

Emmanuel MACRON

The air drops if the operations are considered to be able to resume, and all of this requires a security framework, NGOs to receive, and agreements with the Israeli forces and the government, we will do it.

Journalist

Without Israel's agreement today?

Emmanuel MACRON

Today, you cannot drop in the middle of nowhere. If there are not people behind to receive and therefore NGOs to work, you potentially create riots, you immediately create controversies because the accusation that will be made against you is that the drops were made for Hamas, we all know that discourse. So it must be coordinated with the Israeli forces and the political authorities and coordinated with the NGOs and the United Nations that operate on the ground.

Journalist

Regarding your work since October 7, 2023, do you regret at the time those remarks about a military coalition to destroy Hamas?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, not at all. Because you can see that it is becoming an issue. I think there has been a complete rejection. But, excuse me, if we say that the only ones who can fight Hamas are Israel, we put ourselves in a situation where, in fact, as soon as there is a problem with Hamas, they tell you: we will handle it.

That is exactly what they are using. And so, I think we are wrong not to take the entirety of the terrorist problem in the region into account and to consider that it must be the result of a coalition mobilization. Clarity leads us to say that I have not been followed on this issue.

But there are many ways, and we can see it, that have been done through the coalitions we have managed to form regarding other terrorist groups. Operations to which we contribute militarily, for example, Operation

Inherent Resolve

we are not talking about what is not comparable, but Hamas, what it has done is a group that justified a response and coordination. But with Operation

Inherent Resolve

against the Daesh group, we have had effectiveness. We are not going to deactivate our presence. We continue to carry out operations. And unfortunately, we see it in certain parts of Syria and Iraq, it justifies so much.

Journalist

Regarding Iran, what do you think of the prospect of a direct negotiation, perhaps indirect, between Americans and Iranians, about Iran's nuclear and military program? Do you think it could be a good initiative on Mr. Trump's part, even if Europe is clearly no longer in a position to act as a mediator?

Emmanuel MACRON

First, we need to be clear. Europe is in a position, at the beginning, if we revisit the history, in the summer of 2015, on July 14, 2015, the famous JCPOA was signed. It was largely negotiated by the Americans. The Europeans came in at the last minute. They actually improved this negotiation, including France, which provided a framework. Then, the Americans unilaterally withdrew. Change of administration. The Europeans remained. The extraterritoriality of certain sanctions meant that, objectively, we were not able, first, to have effective oversight of the program without the Americans, even though the IAEA and we did our utmost.

What was, in a way, the agreement, if the Iranians maintained the program, was very tenuous from the moment the Americans cut off and sanctioned anyone who would help. So we have in our hands something important that had been negotiated, which is this famous snapback mechanism. It is a strong diplomatic instrument and, if I may say so, the deadline is at the end of summer. It is a very good thing if there is a return to negotiation. This is what we pushed for in 2018 and 2019. This is what you heard me advocate at the United Nations, in the actions we carried out in parallel and during the French G7. To resume direct negotiations, to include the nuclear program, the ballistic program, and the regional proxies.

That these negotiations resume is a very good thing. We will play the role we must play, which is to defend our interests, our security, and to ensure the security of our major partners in the region. But I think it is a good thing if these negotiations can resume and if they lead to a rollback of the ongoing program, secure verification mechanisms, and the certainty that Iran does not acquire military weapons.

Journalist

And are you sure that Russia and China, who were in the original negotiation, are actually playing along, or will they seek to block, particularly to deactivate this kind of snapback mechanism?

Emmanuel MACRON

I am sure of nothing. I think the snapback mechanism is solid. But, I think that today, it would be too early to engage and especially to engage for others. The future will tell, I hope so.

Journalist

Mr. President, to extend my colleague's question about support for Israel after October 7, your words were of unconditional support. It is not a matter of questioning support for Israel, but in hindsight, given what the actions of the Israeli government, of Benjamin Netanyahu, some say that unconditional support was a way to...

Emmanuel MACRON

You have never heard that said in those terms. Many French political leaders have said it. For my part, no.

Journalist

You never said unconditional support?

Emmanuel MACRON

I never said it in those terms. Why? Because I have always considered that what was behind it, because we knew the risk that was there, that is why we took a position as early as October, and I have always considered that there is, in a way, a kind of collective failure, to say that we are for the security of Israel, but we do not want to deal with the problem of Hamas, because at that moment, you give a blank check.

And so that is why if we want to be coherent, as an international community, we must say that we need to help provide a response to address this issue, which is a security issue for Israel. But I have never given my unconditional support to anyone, in general in life, in any state whatsoever.

My unconditional support is for the French people. And after that, the rest does not depend on us. And so we are demanding, we have provided a lot of support. We provided fraternal support to Israel after October 7, and we continue to do so. And we continue to do so for all Jewish communities, and particularly for French Jews, in this moment which is also a moment of rising anti-Semitism. And yet, we do not confuse everything, and we consider that the Israeli government has responsibilities, which are also the responsibilities of a democracy. And we ourselves have had to fight against terrorism in our own country.

Did we do everything and anything to fight against terrorism? We submitted to constitutional oversight, to parliamentary control, to judicial oversight. We tried to do what our democracies must do when they fight against terrorism, which is not to forget what they are deeply.

Journalist

There was a connection with Benjamin Netanyahu today. Did you speak to him?

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, of course, I spoke to him just a few days ago, and I will continue to speak to him. I will continue to speak to him when I return, because I do not underestimate the difficulty they are facing. And so, they have also had, by the way, real successes in the region, which have allowed to change the situation and improve it in some countries. But I am a demanding partner, I always tell the truth to Prime Minister Netanyahu. But when it comes to Gaza, when it comes to southern Lebanon, to the sovereignty of Lebanon, when it comes to the importance of supporting the transition in Syria, well, France raises its voice. And so, we are engaged, we talk, we work together, but we can share disagreements. And so, I will speak to him again in a few days.

Journalist

Is this an amended version of the Arab plan?

Emmanuel MACRON

The Arab plan continues to be improved. I supported it because I think it was something very salutary as we were coming out of a proposal for forced population displacement. I am totally opposed.

But I think it was a very good first step. It is continuing to be worked on. And in particular, the question of Hamas, in this case, is important. That is what I told them.

I told them: you are several negotiating with Hamas. Obtain, in these cases, the removal of these military frameworks. But we must be collectively serious. And we return to the initial idea. We cannot leave people facing an impossibility of resolving their security problems. So, there is the question of Hamas, there is the question of governance in Gaza, there is the question of reforming the Palestinian Authority, of reconstructing Gaza. There is a very large amount of work that has been done by colleagues and friends in the region, and I really want to acknowledge them, and it is this work that will continue.

Thank you very much.

Journalist

In terms of inclusivity, is there the account with Al-Charaa?

Emmanuel MACRON

What matters to me now is that they do the work on fighting terrorism, the framework for the return of refugees, and above all, what we discussed at length last week in an important meeting, in an important phone call with President Aoun and colleagues, is that he also advances on the border with Lebanon that must be maintained.

Thank you.