Extraordinary European Council of February 1, 2024.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

1 February 2024 · Extraordinary European Council

Context
Macron addressed press at the conclusion of the extraordinary European Council on February 1, 2024, announcing a landmark 50 billion euro aid agreement for Ukraine.
Main themes
EU financial support for Ukraine, extraordinary European Council agreement, 50 billion euro Ukraine facility, EU unity and enlargement, Hungarian opposition resolution, military support for Ukraine, European defense industrial base, Middle East crisis and Gaza ceasefire, frozen Russian assets, EU migration pact funding, European sovereignty instruments, multiannual financial framework review
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,660
83rd percentile
Sentences
165
84th percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
34th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 46%44%
  • Geopolitical 25%23%
  • Institutional 23%21%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

165 sentences in 32 paragraphs

I am happy to see you again at the conclusion of this important extraordinary European Council, which follows the one held last December.

In December, we reaffirmed the position we have held since the beginning of the war: the unity and very clear support of Europeans for Ukrainians. This was reflected in a decision to open accession negotiations for Ukraine and Moldova, which sent a clear political signal about our shared destiny with these countries.

The agreement we reached today confirms the clarity of this choice. Indeed, the outstanding issue, as you recall, concerned the economic and financial aspect of our support for Ukraine. We had reached an agreement among 26 on the review of the multiannual financial framework, and Hungary was unable to accept that agreement at that time. Since then, we have worked to enable an agreement among 27. It was essential because our support for Ukraine since the beginning of the war has been united and unanimous. It is in this spirit that we have succeeded today.

We have therefore reached an agreement among 27 that will allow us to allocate 50 billion euros for the reconstruction and support of Ukraine: 33 billion in loans, 17 billion in grants and subsidies, 9.6 billion euros to implement the Asylum and Migration Pact and to act jointly with countries of origin and transit - thus supporting the decisions that were finalized at the end of last year - and 1.5 billion euros for the European Defense Fund within the STEP Facility, which foreshadows an instrument of European sovereignty. This agreement thus allows us to act until 2027 and provides predictability to our support for Ukraine through a long-term economic and financial commitment. The message is clear: Russia cannot count on any fatigue from Europeans in their support for Ukraine.

The European Council agreed that the Commission will present an annual report on the implementation of the Ukraine Facility. On this basis, we will hold a debate each year to provide the necessary guidance, and if necessary, the European Council may, in two years, invite the Commission to present a proposal to review this Facility, particularly in the context of the next multiannual financial framework of the European Union.

The Council also allowed for an update on our military support for Ukraine. We are making commitments at the bilateral level. This is one of the objectives of my upcoming trip to Ukraine. France is providing, in this regard - as you know - critical capabilities that can make a difference on the battlefield: Scalp missiles for air defense, among others, Caesar guns for artillery.

And beyond this bilateral support, our support must also continue at the European level. This is also a matter of coherence that was reaffirmed very clearly this morning. For this, we need to equip ourselves with European instruments that preserve European solidarity and the sustainability of the effort towards Ukraine. This is the case with the European Peace Facility that we must continue to mobilize and evolve towards a logic of joint production and acquisitions. The representative made useful proposals, which have been validated, that will allow us to succeed. And in February, the Commission will return to the European defense strategy and the associated investment program.

Beyond that, we wanted to advance on capability coalitions. On January 18, France hosted an important meeting of the artillery coalition - which we co-chair with the United States of America - which mobilized many countries to coordinate efforts in production, delivery, and donations related to artillery and its presence in Ukraine. These efforts must indeed go hand in hand with strengthening the European defense industrial and technological base. This is why we must assume a European preference, whether in the transformed European Peace Facility or in future instruments. We will have the opportunity to revisit this at the next European Council. We must find the financial and budgetary means to guarantee this support.

We have taken an important step by deciding to separate the interests of frozen Russian assets. The second step will now be to decide how to use these interests and their allocation, and we will also have the opportunity to return to this.

This Council also allowed for an exchange on the situation in the Middle East. It is now more essential than ever to advance on the humanitarian, security, and political aspects of the crisis. In this critical moment, France's objective is to accelerate the ceasefire in Gaza, to secure the release of all hostages, and to prevent a dangerous regional escalation. This is the purpose of the efforts we are deploying today, with all our partners, particularly in the Middle East, and I believe this should also inform a genuine European offer of peace and stability for all in the region. This is also the meaning of the European initiative we are finalizing in the Red Sea.

Finally, this Council provided an opportunity for an in-depth exchange on the European agricultural situation. I was also able to have a discussion with the President of the European Commission today, as I had in recent days and weeks. We are indeed experiencing an agricultural crisis in Europe that has persisted for many months. After significant movements in the Netherlands, Germany, and now in Belgium, Romania, Poland, and France, we are seeing significant protest movements rising across Europe. This is happening in a context, as far as France is concerned, which I wanted to revisit after the Government has been able to express itself and after the main union leaders have called for the lifting of the blockades that had been organized.

We have done a lot in recent years, particularly over the past six years, for our agriculture in Europe and in France. First, by defending a common agricultural policy that - I remind you - a few years ago was not guaranteed. Everyone saw it declining, everyone. Everyone thought that the consequences of both Brexit and the context would lead to a decrease in CAP amounts. We fought for it, and we maintained them. This represents about 9 billion euros per year.

In addition, we launched, as early as 2017, an accelerated and in-depth work of the General States of Food, two successive laws - I will return to this - mechanisms that had been awaited for decades by our farmers - such as crop insurance, to face major climatic hazards - support plans for several sectors - some of which have been reconfirmed or taken again, whether in viticulture, livestock, or others. We have profoundly changed our balances. Without this, it is certain that the situation would be much more serious.

Nevertheless, we must not underestimate that the acceleration our era is experiencing, the great geopolitical destabilization, the war following the Russian aggression in Ukraine, and obviously the Covid pandemic have led to massive disruptions that deeply affect the European agricultural model. And this is what we are facing. Times are changing; we are experiencing a collective revolution. We must face climate change, the war in Europe, and geopolitical destabilizations. Therefore, we must also profoundly change the rules and go further than we have been able to do.

So, what do our farmers want? They want to live decently from their work, and they are right. It is more than legitimate. This is the whole purpose of this CAP through the measures we have taken - I have said and confirmed in my time - these 9 billion euros per year, which are also paid much faster than they were a few years ago. I remember the last CAP; I was recently elected President, and there were years of delays in payments. We no longer find this situation. This is also the meaning of Egalim 1 and Egalim 2 and what the Government announced in recent days and particularly in recent hours: to ensure the income of farmers and that, precisely, the fair remuneration for their work reaches the farmyard. The reduction of charges - with what we have done on TODE, which will be confirmed for the coming years - sector supports - livestock, viticulture, etc. - the decisions that have been made on GNR, water, and other cost elements; this is everything we have been able to do sector by sector, and we will continue this work to improve things. And if we need to modify the law again to improve tripartite contracts between producers, processors, and distributors, we will do so.

Next, we must intensify controls. Many controls have been implemented, and teams have been strengthened. We will be uncompromising with the largest industrial players and, in particular, with the largest distributors who do not play by the rules of the law. The Government will also strengthen the proper control of commitments in collective catering.

Now, to go further, beyond national improvement measures, there is clearly a European battle to be fought on this issue. This is what I have asked the President of the Commission to work on in the strategic review that has just been launched, to establish a European Egalim: that is to say, to ensure at the European level that there is no circumvention of what we have done at the French level - which has inspired several others - by these large European purchasing centers. However, what we have seen organized in recent years is that some distributors have organized themselves at the European level through purchasing centers and are seeking to circumvent French law with these. Ultimately, we need a stronger, more concrete Europe to protect the income of our farmers; this is where part of this new battle is being fought.

What do our farmers want? They want to be able to produce quality food. We have one of the best in Europe, but in Europe, one of the best in the world. Working towards our agricultural sovereignty, which we have defended all these past years, which we have further strengthened, particularly in the protein sector.

And they want to be able to do this with a simpler life, meaning having more time to dedicate a bit to their family, but also to do their work in a more peaceful manner. For that, a drastic reduction in paperwork and complexity is needed. This is the project that has been launched with the Government; about ten projects that will now be implemented in each prefecture to simplify the rules, limit paperwork and complexities. This is the visibility we provide on the cost of labor and other points; it is the acceleration of deadlines - we must recognize that we have often been too slow. The decisions are good, but whether it is to support farmers facing an epizootic or those facing a storm or a hurricane, the implementation timelines are too slow, and measures to support our operators, on MHE or Ciarán or others, are currently being accelerated by the Government.

This is what we wish to do, also, through a resolute policy that we have been preparing for 18 months, to assist in the transmission and establishment for young farmers, which is a key point for producing more. This battle must also be fought at the European level. That is why we first obtained, yesterday, a derogation on the 4% fallow land. You may know that this was part of what is called "eco-conditionalities." In the CAP that was decided, there was a requirement to have 4% of the surfaces left fallow. We obtained a derogation last year. We have succeeded in obtaining it again this year, which allows for the cultivation of soybeans, alfalfa, fava beans, etc., on these surfaces instead of leaving them fallow. This is important for our operators and was requested by them.

Beyond that, we want the objectives we set for ourselves, particularly in Farm to Fork.

Let us review these matters through the lens of a sovereignty objective. Ultimately, we must take into account the geopolitical situation, the state of our continent, and place our food sovereignty at the heart of European objectives. We need to find flexibilities regarding pasture ratios to adapt them to the realities on the ground and allow for all necessary flexibility. Whenever overly complex rules are being decided at the European level, we must adapt them in light of a food sovereignty objective that should be integrated into the core of our strategy. This is what I asked the President of the European Commission in the context of the strategic review she has just launched, which is starting at a rapid pace and will have to make initial decisions in a few weeks. In any case, we will ensure, very scrupulously, that our farmers can continue to produce and acknowledge that production — and more production — is a necessity in the world we live in.

Finally, our farmers — and rightly so — want the rules to be the same for everyone, and I would say that this is a form of common sense, and we have always stood by them for that. This is a commitment I made back in 2017: no over-transposition. We have indeed had the opportunity to correct existing over-transpositions. What is over-transposition? It is when we, the French, tend to adopt rules that are even stricter than what is decided at the European level. This had been done in the past, but we have not taken any legislative measures in that direction since 2017. We have even corrected some. You may remember the famous debate on neonicotinoids; we will continue this work; there are still points that need to be addressed and improved. We also wish that when decisions are made by the French Agency, they are coordinated at the European level, and this is where differences exist that we will therefore correct. So, regarding all remaining over-transpositions, or decisions where French agencies move faster than the European machinery, this is the project that has been launched by the Government — we will adapt things so that France, in a way, always keeps pace with Europe and does not move faster.

In addition to that, I have also asked the Government to be more efficient in granting exemptions. Sometimes, it is provided for, even in European texts, that we can, for certain products, during certain seasons, grant exemptions — cherry producers know this all too well. We need to be able to do this quickly when necessary, and therefore decentralize the decision-making to the level of the prefects.

But here too, we need a clearer Europe, beyond what we will improve at the French level, and so I have asked the President several things. First, that there be uniform controls at the European level — and France has been fighting on this issue for five years. What does this mean, in very simple terms? When we have a European rule that is transposed in the same way across our farmers, it must be controlled in the same way in all countries. That is why we are calling for the establishment of a European health and agricultural control force, a European force that can prevent unfair competition that may exist within countries because there are too many differences in how the texts are applied. This does not exist today. It is left to differences between countries, which is not satisfactory.

And then the other point is that the rules must be the same inside and outside, if I may say so. When we impose production rules on our farmers, they can understand them if they are for the well-being of the population. And we have asked them for many efforts; it is undoubtedly the profession that has made the most efforts and undergone the most transformations in recent years and decades. But what is incomprehensible, and what I myself cannot explain, is when we impose rules for what we produce in Europe and allow imports of products that do not respect these same rules and come from outside Europe. This is what we call mirror clauses. The rule that applies internally for production must also apply externally when we facilitate imports; it is simple, it is common sense, but we do not do it enough. It is for this very reason that today, in the state of the MERCOSUR texts, France opposes — and will continue to oppose — this free trade agreement with the MERCOSUR region. I made this very clear to President LULA a few weeks ago; I told all my counterparts; I reiterated it here, and I am pleased that the discussions based on the text that was submitted have indeed been suspended, as we requested, and that they were not concluded hastily as some threatened to do. Why? Because we simply ask that the environmental and health rules we impose on our farmers and several other professions be the same on the side of the countries to whom we are opening our doors; otherwise, it is not fair. France will maintain this position because it is a position of coherence, clarity, and solidity.

Next, what we have also asked the European Commission — and on which we will continue to fight — is that when such decisions are made, they are clearly implemented. I will take a very simple and clear example: we have prohibited the use of growth antibiotics for our chickens. For decades, this was done. A bad practice; there were health risks. We have banned it for all European producers. We have — this was a French initiative; we did not wait for what is happening now — nearly two years ago, adopted a European text that is a true mirror clause, stating: everything we import must also prohibit the use of these growth antibiotics. Simply put, today, we do not control it. And so, we have asked that this European health and agricultural force be established as soon as possible. And above all, that the mirror clauses we adopt be controlled. This is an essential fight for our farmers. It is essential for France. It is a fight for coherence; it is a fight for honesty towards them. It is a fight for sovereignty.

How to call for European food sovereignty? We have been fighting for it for six years. I have made speeches at the Agricultural Show since 2018 for this European food sovereignty. If we impose rules on our farmers and either we do not impose the same on the products we allow in, or we do not control them, it is not serious. And so, we will continue to fight so that when a rule is imposed internally, it is imposed externally and that controls are in place.

Next, I said, our farmers ask that the rules be the same for everyone, which obviously leads to closely examining the situation of agricultural imports from Ukraine — a debate that has been at the heart of many discussions in many European countries. We have thus obtained that stricter rules be put in place to prevent very clear abuses and destabilizations that we have seen in recent months. We have obtained that for cereals, there be a strengthened safeguard mechanism in case of market disruption, which would allow for intervention measures if the cereals coming from Ukraine, which are placed on the European market, significantly destabilize our prices or create unfair competition, with various mechanisms that may involve blocking, intervening on prices, or others. For eggs, chickens, and sugar, we have obtained protection mechanisms by taking into account the historical volumes of 2022 and 2023, and the first half of 2022, with figures that were more historical and which, beyond the defined volumes, allow us to restore customs duties. In essence, I will be simple: yes, to help Ukraine in a context of war, no, to create a situation of unfair competition that benefits a few billionaires or large industrialists who do not respect our rules. Here too, it is common sense. Well, this is what we have achieved by changing these rules.

You have understood, in recent days and hours, we have made substantial progress, whether it concerns the issue of fallow land, Ukraine, or MERCOSUR. More broadly, we have obtained the ability to launch a thorough review of the logic and European approach — and I thank the President of the Commission who heard this request and launched this strategic dialogue exercise. It will allow, by the end of February, to take simplification measures at the European level, as we are doing at the French level. But it will also allow us to integrate much better than we had done before, in a CAP that was conceived prior to this new geopolitical context, the change of mindset in which we live. The war is here, the world is transforming, and therefore we must have a simpler agricultural policy that takes into account the need to produce more, which, of course, integrates our environmental objectives, but does so while preserving fair competition, preserving farmers' income, and preserving our food sovereignty. This is the change of logic we want to promote at the European level, which we have begun to launch and initiate in recent hours, and on which we will not relent.

We have fought to achieve these initial results. We will continue to do so to have a stronger, more sovereign European and French agriculture and to continue to have one of the agricultures that provides quality food to the highest global standards. Because we must be proud of French European food; it is among the best in the world. So we must continue to fight for it and, in doing so, build our new agricultural model through investment, through changes, but also through common sense, simplicity, and will. The fight will therefore continue in this direction, and we will have the opportunity in the coming weeks and months to continue working to achieve concrete results for our farmers.

I will now answer all your questions.