Speech by President Emmanuel Macron at the swearing-in ceremony of the new judicial auditors.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

9 February 2024 · Swearing-in ceremony of the new judicial auditors · Bordeaux, France

Context
Macron addressed the 2024 swearing-in ceremony of judicial auditors in Bordeaux, coinciding with the death of Robert Badinter, marking the largest ENM graduating class since 1958.
Main themes
Swearing-in of judicial auditors, tribute to Robert Badinter, justice reform and investment, judicial vocation and oath, rule of law and republican values, magistrate responsibilities, largest ENM graduating class in history, abolition of death penalty legacy, judicial ethics and deontology, service to the French Republic
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,246
79th percentile
Sentences
131
75th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.14
65th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
63rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 68%67%
  • Ceremonial 23%23%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

131 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen Members of Parliament,

Mr. Prefect,

Mr. First President of the Court of Cassation,

Mr. Attorney General at the Court of Cassation,

Mr. Senior Member of the Superior Council of the Judiciary,

Madam and Sir Heads of the Bordeaux Courts, who have enabled the organization of this swearing-in ceremony,

Mr. Mayor,

Madam Director of the National School of the Judiciary,

Ladies and gentlemen distinguished guests in your ranks and capacities,

Dear judicial auditors of the 2024 class,

Dear families of the said judicial auditors,

Ladies and gentlemen,

On this day when I have come to Bordeaux to speak of justice, on this day when you, judicial auditors, come to take your oath, the Nation – as you just reminded us – has learned of the passing of Robert Badinter. This day, which you will remember for the rest of your lives, will forever be marked by the imprint of this lawyer of character and profession, who fought throughout his life for Enlightenment, for justice, for France, which for him was three times the name of his ideal.

As a lawyer, he stood by the outcasts, the accused, the condemned, with that same burning thirst for justice. As Keeper of the Seals, he abolished the death penalty and worked for the renovation of our judicial authority. As President of the Constitutional Council, he was the guardian of the laws in all their strength and grandeur. He knew in his flesh what injustice, inequity, and laws stripped of their humanistic principles meant. The Nation has lost a great man; a national tribute will be paid to him.

Yes, this day, you will remember for the rest of your lives, for the rest of your careers as magistrates. This swearing-in ceremony completes years of study, work, and sacrifice – as you have perfectly recalled. It is the culmination of a momentum, it seals a passion.

After the time of hope, and before that of your careers, at the heart of what unites you all, your vocation to serve justice, our justice, that of our Republic, of our nation. Nothing, thereafter, will be acquired; the profession lies ahead of you, in its rigor, in its joys, with its demands but also the share of judgment, ethics, deontology, humanism – this was just recalled. But already, this vocation has materialized.

And seeing your families with you, I know their legitimate pride. A son, a daughter, a partner, a spouse, a parent who is a magistrate is never trivial. It is knowing that the one you love will spend their days, sometimes their nights, in a work often obscure to many of our compatriots but decisive. He is, now, for all those who will come to place a dispute, a pain, a sorrow in his hands, the face of the Republic.

Yes, you will remember this day for all your lives because you have pronounced these words of the oath, you have sworn, your right hand raised, "to keep professional secrecy and to conduct yourself in all respects as a worthy and loyal judicial auditor." It is an oath made to the French people, whom you now serve.

An oath made in the name of the republican conception of our justice: authority that applies the laws chosen by the people, in respect of the fundamental principles of our law, in the light of our traditions and values.

And it is also an oath to yourself: to be faithful to the judicial auditor that you are at this moment with its share of doubt, this untainted supplement of ideal, of desire to serve, free of all prejudice, all weariness, all compromise, resolved to work, to think sometimes against oneself, independent of everything, esprit de corps, public passions, personal feelings, only guided by the sense of your function.

I wanted to be among you today to say all this. And because it is also a major day for the Nation. You indeed constitute the most important class in the history of our Republic. Such is the meaning of this class: to rearm our justice, which has been underfunded for too long.

It is a massive, unprecedented effort. And in an institution where it is common to say that there is a lack of space, indeed, justice had to push the walls and hold this swearing-in ceremony here, in the Palais des Congrès rather than at the Bordeaux Court of Appeal, so important is this class of the National School of the Judiciary, the most important since the creation of the school in 1958.

Here you are, 459, when in some years – not so long ago – classes counted only a little over a hundred judicial auditors. This is the result of your work – and many of you contributed to it, and I thank you for that – those of the Estates General of Justice, which subsequently led to commitments I was able to make – promises kept. As many future deputy public prosecutors, judges who will support magistrates of the public prosecutor's office and the judiciary in all jurisdictions of France within thirty months.

This effort of the Nation undoubtedly represents an opportunity, but also for you a responsibility: to constitute the vanguard of this transformation of our justice that the Nation carries.

This rearmament is the concrete translation of our will to give justice the means it has been sorely lacking. Since 2017, the means of justice have increased by half, and by 2027 we will have increased the justice budget by 60%. In seven years, we have already recruited 1,000 magistrates and 1,050 clerks. Since 2020, we have recruited 2,400 contract workers who support magistrates and clerks; these contracts are being converted into permanent positions; and we have created the position of judicial attachés. By 2027, we will recruit an additional 1,500 magistrates, 1,800 clerks, and at least 1,100 judicial attachés.

Never has the Nation made such an effort. We have put an end to thirty years of under-investment and, in doing so, of human, budgetary, and financial abandonment. But, where our compatriots legitimately demand security, a peaceful life, it had often been forgotten – it is obviously necessary to rearm our internal security forces, which is being done in parallel with a programming law, a guiding law, but at the same time, we must allow our justice to be able to investigate and judge. No security, no peaceful life, without such investment.

This judicial rearmament has been accompanied by the modernization of our law to gain in speed and effectiveness of penalties: abolition of the reminder of the law, increase in resources allocated to community service, creation of the juvenile justice code, and so on.

We are going through – as you just recalled – a turning point: major technological, geopolitical, and climatic mutations that create turmoil and increasingly provoke violence in our society. We need, more than ever, a sense of purpose, rules, and the restoration of order without which no progress is possible.

Order and progress are indeed at the root of our Republic, of its very principles. That is why I have initiated this rearmament of the State: rearmament of our internal security forces, with the programming law, rearmament of our armed forces, rearmament of judicial authority.

Our institutions are plagued by doubt, and let us be clear-eyed, our compatriots – you also recalled this – doubt their justice. When 60% of cases are not those that make the headlines, in the daily life of the country, justice seems too slow and too fragile. I think of those cases of consumer law, family law, alimony, parental authority, guardianships, the protection of minors. I think of those daily delinquency incidents – this delinquency that is called "petty" or "medium" but whose consequences are immense for each victim. Each time, it is the case of a lifetime for the litigants, for whom they await a response from the State.

So, to reconcile our fellow citizens with judicial authority, to be worthy of the moment we are going through, our Republic must render justice with speed, efficiency, and responsibility.

Speed first because, in a time of acceleration, the time of justice is, by its very nature, too long. We must keep this long-term vision; it is essential. But if justice does not gain in efficiency, proximity, and speed, then, let it be said, everyone will always find other means to judge disputes, everyone is already finding them: through media opprobrium, social banishment, in disregard of the presumption of innocence, in our public life, or through vengeance, abuse of power, and violence in daily life. Yet our Republic was built on the opposite ideal – very clearly – that of rights and freedoms, that of public services that protect and uphold the Nation.

We must therefore halve the delays of our justice by 2027. This is not a goal; it is an imperative, an imperative carried by the Keeper of the Seals. It is not an imperative coming from political power, but from the French people, on behalf of whom justice is rendered. When so many resources are allocated to such an important public service, our collective responsibility is that these resources yield results. French citizens could not understand the opposite, and trust would further erode.

In this spirit, I wanted, with the Keeper of the Seals, that we make progress on the simplification of criminal or civil procedures, particularly for the latter with the more widespread deployment of amicable procedures. We have also continued, accelerated, the digitization. Here too, it is work – you have perfectly recalled – that must not take away the humanity of the function, but so much time is to be gained, for our police officers, for our gendarmes, for our clerks, our magistrates, through the digitization of complaints, of procedures – what we are currently deploying with unprecedented modernization – 50% of criminal procedures will be dematerialized by the end of the year, while online complaints will be fully generalized by summer, etc. etc. I have also set the goal that in first instance, by the end of this term, judicial decisions be rendered in less than a year; this is already the case in several courts, and it must soon be the result everywhere in France. Speed, therefore, not for the sake of haste, to allow time for the most complex cases, for which it is legitimate, but to keep in mind that this speed is a source of legitimacy.

Rendering justice with efficiency and effectiveness. This is the very word I used a few years ago – in Agen, when I spoke before several of you – I am not obviously talking about judicial auditors; you are too young for that – about punishment. A strong justice, indeed, is not an blindly repressive justice; it is a justice of proximity and efficiency, whose penalties are effective.

To this end, we have abolished automatic sentence reductions, and we are also making rapid progress on the delivery of the program to build 15,000 places, which we have even raised to 18,000, with the delivery, since 2017, of 19 correctional facilities – one of which is very close by. This is also the meaning of the colossal work undertaken on community service, the number of places for which has doubled. A sanction must be applied, a penalty must be executed, a judgment must restore republican and democratic order.

And looking at the penal response to the riots of last summer, our justice has risen to this demand for firmness and efficiency. The figures are there to demonstrate it, the facts are there to demonstrate it; and we must not allow any misleading commentary to settle in. This demand must push us to go even further, particularly in terms of restoring authority among delinquent minors and more broadly by continuing to reform and transform the penitentiary administration, community service – and the Keeper of the Seals will have the opportunity in the coming weeks to revisit these topics.

A strong justice is not a justice frozen in forms or ideas of the past; it is a justice that knows how to modernize, and we have done so, in line with the legitimate concerns and aspirations of the time.

First by engaging in a proximity effort: by creating, during the previous term, the local courts, that is to say, by reopening judicial sites that were previously closed, in order to bring justice closer to citizens and by asking magistrates to multiply traveling hearings. Then by simplifying the processing of legal aid requests, to which there will soon be responses everywhere in less than five days.

We have been able to seize the issues that traverse our society, with the emphasis I wanted to place on violence against women, the fight against drug trafficking, and attacks against elected officials.

Finally, modernizing justice means opening it to all talents. Magistrates must reflect the country, in the diversity of their social, geographical, or professional backgrounds. It is an effort of openness that will be amplified with the simplification and diversification of recruitment methods.

Delivering justice with great responsibilities. I do not confuse independence with irresponsibility. In the Republic, the people are sovereign, and you will soon deliver justice in their name. However, the oath of a magistrate obliges them to "perform their duties with independence, impartiality, humanity" and to behave "in all respects as a worthy, honest, and loyal magistrate" and to "respect professional secrecy and that of deliberations." This requirement in the past, even if the cases are marginal, has not always been scrupulously respected, and the Superior Council of the Judiciary plays and must play an essential role in safeguarding the respect of the oath. This also concerns the trust that everyone must have in the impartiality of magistrates, but also in their strict adherence to their duty of reserve, which is a guarantee of their independence of mind and judgment.

The freedom of expression of magistrates is a constitutional freedom that no one thinks of calling into question. It must have as a corollary a systematic "recusal" on their part to judge a case whenever their previous public statements legitimately raise doubts for the concerned litigant that they will be judged by an impartial judge. On the issue of individual or collective public expression as well as the right to strike, the Keeper of the Seals has initiated a reflection, also within the framework of the development of the code of ethics for magistrates, as provided by the recent organic law of November 20, 2023. I hope that this reflection continues and amplifies to also adapt our framework to the media and technological society that profoundly changes practices. All of this is also the result of the Estates General of Justice, launched in Poitiers.

I have said it, today is a day you will not forget, a day that the Nation will not forget: the day when a new generation of magistrates has risen. But in turn, you will be, for many of our fellow citizens, the actors and witnesses that every litigant will never forget. A hearing, that of today, in which they were one of the parties, the settlement of their divorce, a testimony that they found the courage to share with you, a conciliation where their financial turmoil and their destiny will be decided - as I said earlier - yes, every time, in every case, it is the question of who we are, that is to say a Republic, that is at stake.

And in the Republic, the law must prevail, the expression of the sovereignty of the people. The law that protects against violence, abuse, the domination of the strongest over the weakest; the law that civilizes, punishes, and puts back on the right path; the law as a bulwark of rights to protect freedoms against slander or rumor, which only strikes after a judgment. The law, nothing but the law, but all the law. The right, nothing but the right, but all the right, in its procedures, in its guarantees, in its demands and scruples.

Our justice is placed on this thread, which weaves the meaning of your profession: a public service that our fellow citizens expect a lot from and quickly, an authority that cannot allow anomie and disorder to thrive, an institution that opposes rigor to passions, the hope of reintegration to vindictiveness, the vigor of principles against the outbursts of crowds.

This fertile contradiction will only be resolved with a justice that is more effective, more efficient, closer, and faster. The trust of our fellow citizens will therefore be, for you, for all of us, a permanent and constantly renewed struggle.

Historical means in the republican history of France, historical responsibility for effectiveness and proximity, historical threats to the rule of law due to authoritarian tightening elsewhere and the unraveling of the fabric of society here at home. Here, in a few words, are the challenges and opportunities of your generation of magistrates.

And since we are in Bordeaux, I will take up a word from François Mauriac: "the civilization of a people is measured by the state of its justice." A strong justice is the pride of our people. I also believe, to complete the theorem, that the trust of the people in their Republic is measured by the state of its justice. Trust in a public service that delivers well, quickly, and in the mirror of our values, a justice of everyday life. The Republic has confidence in its justice, and the means granted to it show this; and I have confidence in you because I know that you will rise to the height of these choices.

The bad winds are returning, and you will have to live in this era, where, in our Europe, there are regimes that challenge the rule of law. You will have to live, as magistrates, in a time when voices will rise to say that justice is the source of so many problems and seek to undermine your legitimacy. You will live in a time when some will try to explain that not respecting a court decision would actually be truly respecting the sovereign people. You will have to live in an era, yes, where the bad winds have risen again and where, taking root in doubt, some will seek to push you, and in doing so, to push us.

So, it will be up to you as authorities, as an institution - but each and every one of you as a magistrate - to stay away from these winds and these sad passions, to always doubt but to carry this part of hope for our Republic and our Nation, one that needs justice, its rituals, in service of our law, one that needs an independent, strong justice, to continue to believe and to live together. For that is what a Republic is, that is what our Republic and our Nation are.

And at this very moment, for these very reasons, I am proud of the investment that the Nation has made in our justice in recent years, I am proud that all of you embody it today through your promotion. And I know that each and every one of you will rise to one of these challenges, that of your generation: to stand firm in the service of the French Republic, in the service of France.

Long live the Republic. Long live France.