Speech by the President of the Republic to the defense community in Sweden.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

30 January 2024

Context
Macron addressed Sweden's defense community on January 30, 2024, emphasizing European sovereignty, the war in Ukraine, and Franco-Swedish defense cooperation during a state visit.
Main themes
European sovereignty, Russia-Ukraine war, European defense cooperation, NATO expansion, Sweden-France partnership, military spending, strategic autonomy, support for Ukraine, European security architecture, defense industry mobilization, transatlantic alliance
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,385
80th percentile
Sentences
170
85th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 59%58%
  • Ceremonial 22%22%
  • Economic 11%11%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

170 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen Parliamentarians,

Ladies and gentlemen officers and officer cadets,

Ladies and gentlemen, dear friends,

Everything has already been said, and perfectly so by Your Majesty and by Mr. Prime Minister. I do not wish to repeat it, and I will strive to be brief and direct, perhaps much more so on the situation in Ukraine. And I suggest we respond to your questions and then have a more interactive session.

But I have often recalled the necessity of having a more sovereign Europe, and it was, for many people, a kind of paradoxical mystery to speak of sovereignty in reference to Europe. And indeed, I insist on this notion. What does it mean? To have more autonomy and to decide on the cooperation we want to build, but without depending on others for what is fundamental to us. This sovereignty is today stronger than it was a few years ago. And, fortunately, Russia's aggression against Ukraine has been part of the trigger point towards more sovereignty in Europe.

We have indeed improved sovereignty, and we are building it together. And with the partnership - Mr. Prime Minister, you have perfectly referred to this document - from our defense industry to our nuclear energy, our research, etc., we are building stronger cooperation, in service of a stronger and more sovereign Europe. But very clearly, we have today a much more sovereign Europe. We are ready to conceive and carry out operations abroad together. That is what we are doing in the Red Sea today, that is what we did together in Africa thanks to Takuba. We have designed a much more European defense, the European Intervention Initiative, which has created more intimacy between our armies - and you have joined this initiative, and it is around such a framework that we have worked together in Africa. We have established a European defense fund; we have established - you referred to it - a European Peace Facility, which is a great success and was entirely new, to provide equipment and funding to third parties such as Ukraine. Just a few weeks after the start of this war, we designed a common program for sovereignty. We called it "the Versailles Action Plan." We are all together to reduce our strategic dependencies.

But in technology, energy, defense, economic capabilities, we have decided precisely to work together in close collaboration, to have more European responses. We have clearly begun to reverse decades of military spending cuts. We started after Crimea in 2014, and we have accelerated in the last two years. And, overall, we are spending more and more money, we are establishing capabilities and joint projects among Europeans. And your decision to join NATO fits into this strategic awakening. And I want to reaffirm here our full support and congratulate you on the fact that this decision is absolutely crucial, to have such an important member join our alliance today.

Moreover, we reacted very quickly, right after the aggression. We imposed sanctions together, we preserved our unity as Europeans, and we succeeded in sending support funding to Ukraine over the past two years. In parallel, we put our defense industry on a war footing, we increased attrition rates, we reopened production lines, placed new orders, and reduced administrative constraints on our industry to produce much more, and much faster. And we have been fortunate to have a partner, the United States, very involved with all of us.

These are just a few remarks to highlight how we were stronger and more sovereign in general. And all these fundamental decisions were not taken for granted by many people two or three years ago. So, clearly, the last two years have been characterized, after Russia's aggression, by this strategic movement and by all these reactions. That said, the war in Ukraine will be a long-term effort, and it is clear that this is now a test, a decisive moment for all of us. You both mentioned the importance of the challenge, and I want to emphasize that, even though we can be very proud of the recent decisions and actions we have taken, I firmly believe that we must do much more.

First, we must be ready to act, to defend, and to support Ukraine no matter what happens, and regardless of the decisions of the United States. I think we are very fortunate to have such a partner, such an ally. But, very clearly, we must be clear-eyed about the fact that Ukraine is part of the European continent. And, whatever the United States decides, we must make the right, courageous decision to help Ukraine and the Ukrainian people.

And we must follow the line of the current strategy, that it is impossible for all of us to see Russia win this war, because there is no longer any framework or security architecture on our continent if there is a Russian victory. What is the future of our eastern flank, what is the future of all of Europe, what is the future of the Caucasus, what is the future of Central Asia if the result of such international involvement is a Russian victory? Therefore, the cost, the real cost, of a Russian victory in the short and long term is too high for all of us. That is why the reasonable response is to place ourselves in a position of support for Ukraine, this year and in the years to come. Whatever it costs, and at all costs, this support must take the form of weapons and ammunition, training programs, and everything they need to resist Russian aggression and to place themselves - I mean the Ukrainians - in a position to negotiate a lasting peace, that is, a peace decided by the Ukrainians, and a peace that respects international order and international rules. That is why, whatever we have decided and done, clearly, we will need to accelerate and intensify our effort in the coming months. In terms of production, let us be clear, and perhaps in terms of nature, this will require many national decisions.

This will require a clear European decision, and we will follow up on Thursday with our dear colleagues in Brussels. This may require an innovative response, and I want to pay tribute to our colleague Kaja KALLAS, who is proposing a very bold decision for the strategy of our defense industry to have some sort of subsidy approach to raise more money to finance this effort. I want to say that I am ready to take all this appropriate decision and to build consensus, but very clearly, we will need to make an additional decision, and we will need to adapt to a larger production. Let us be clear, even if we are making a lot of efforts to produce more and faster, if we compare ourselves to the Russian effort today, it is not at scale and it is not at the right speed. They have managed to completely readjust their system, so we must react and even overreact to align ourselves alongside the Ukrainians. In parallel, I believe we must clearly follow the strengthening of this effort, the strengthening of production, be ready to make a national and European decision, and to preempt any American decision to not be dependent on any change whatsoever.

In parallel, I would like to emphasize a few essential points for me for the future. This will guide us towards strengthening our European defense. I have insisted several times on this issue. European defense does not replace NATO; it is even more important today for you than it was yesterday, but it is clearly an essential pillar of NATO. It is our way of taking our fair share, and it is a necessity because we are talking about our own neighborhood. So, in addition to all this, let us follow the strengthening of this European defense, meaning that we need more innovation, more joint programs, and clearer operational intimacy. What we have started with the European Intervention Initiative must be strengthened and deepened in the months and years to come to have a much more European operational approach, and interoperability based on NATO experience is an asset. We must also do the same with joint programs. I believe that our common partnership will allow us to do much more together, and with our defense industry, we will need to follow up.

Thirdly, we must follow and deliver our Versailles Action Plan, meaning that we need much more sovereignty and autonomy for our energy, our technologies, and our production capacity. And I believe that one of the wake-up calls we must not forget is that for years we believed that trading and exchanging energy with Russia was the best way to prevent war. That was a mistake; it was the best way to suffer from a war and to suffer from a unilateral decision. Therefore, we must not reproduce this approach. So, let us diversify our relationship, but refuse to depend on anyone else. When we talk about our energy, we must produce our low-carbon energy. More renewables, more nuclear, more efficiency. European solutions. This is part of our bouquet to ensure long-term security. When we talk about our technology, our artificial intelligence, etc., it is great to have a super partner, but we want to choose and design our future. So, let us work hard to preserve European solutions and European innovations. When we talk about space, and we both have the advantage of having the capacity to launch satellites and launchers with our bases, let us preserve European access to that space. That is the decision we made in Seville. And Ariane 6 is coming. But more importantly, the entire range of innovation, both civilian and defense innovation, is absolutely essential for this war and the years to come.

My last point concerns how to manage our neighbors and define our own architecture. I believe that part of what is happening in Ukraine is due to the fact that, probably, we were, as Europeans, in a situation of geopolitical minority. We were not and we did not put ourselves in a position to decide for our own territory. All treaties were decided by the former USSR and the United States. Everything concerning our territory was decided by the big bosses in the room, not by the Europeans themselves. And it seems that we were quite satisfied with this situation. I believe we must be part of the decision-making when it comes to the European Peace Facility, when it comes to deployments, when it comes to arms control, today and tomorrow. When it comes to designing our security architecture, it is up to us to decide. And this must be designed during this time of war. And that is why our involvement in favor of the Ukrainians is not only to prevent any Russian victory, but it is also so that we are around the table to decide our future, because Ukraine is part of our future, as it is part of our continent. There is no future for us and our children if we are not able to build the new security architecture, arms control, and neighborhood for the entire region. But it is up to us to decide for ourselves and not to delegate it to the great powers, even if they are very good allies, because they live on the other side of the ocean. It is probably easier. And I believe it is very important at this moment to keep in mind that it is because of our current involvement that we can put ourselves in a position to prevent any Russian victory. But we will also be legitimate to be part of it, to define and design this future architecture, which is absolutely essential. NATO will be part of it. But NATO must not have exclusivity over this architecture. And as Europeans, we must clearly be part of such a new architecture.

And I speak as a faithful partner, a military power with a solid expeditionary capability and a state with nuclear weapons whose vital interests have a European dimension. And we have proposed a specific dialogue on this. And for me, it is important to reiterate this point here, in front of you. I want to thank you for the opportunity to share these few remarks. But let me tell you how much we respect your country, your armed forces, your commitment, and the friendship you have had and the quality of the cooperation we have had over these past few years. And allow me to reaffirm here our support for your current project, but also for your project in the future. And each time, it will be difficult. Be assured that you can count on France. Thank you.

Mr. President, thank you very much for your strong message of friendship and unity, your message of determination, a more sovereign Europe with autonomous capabilities to defend its own interests, but also the courage to make the right decisions, particularly regarding Ukraine. Thank you very much. I am pleased to announce that we have a few minutes left for questions, and I am sure that you, officer cadets and students, are eager to learn more. So, please take a microphone, introduce yourselves, and keep your questions brief. Go ahead.

Speaker

Mr. President, I represent the officer program. My question concerns what His Majesty mentioned regarding long-term perspectives. During the remaining period of your presidency, what measures, what relationships, or what processes do you consider essential to implement or achieve in order to forge and maintain a fruitful long-term relationship between France and Sweden, in terms of military cooperation, European intervention initiatives, or military-industrial cooperation? Thank you.

Emmanuel Macron

Thank you. Listen, I think we have, as I mentioned, significantly improved our cooperation over the past few years. You mentioned it in your question: we launched the European Intervention Initiative, and I believe we now have ten countries, or even twelve, that are part of it. And you have decided to join us, which has allowed us to build cooperation and joint operations.

In addition, you have a very solid production model, we have a very solid production model, and it is precisely because of this very particular context that we are starting to create bridges and joint programs. From equipment to weapons, missiles, and munitions, we are now working closely together to create joint capabilities for our armies and those of our good friends and partners. So I think, in light of what exists today, what we have managed to do in recent years, what we are doing in Europe, and the fact that your country has just decided to join NATO and will improve interoperability with other armies, I think that in the coming years, we have many ways to enhance the relationship and concretely improve the partnership between our armies.

First, with additional joint programs, and perhaps through your country's participation in existing joint programs in Europe. We have great creative capacities, many innovations, and I think that will be wonderful.

And I do not want to exclude it - we have not discussed this new aspect much - but space and cyberspace are clearly two conflictual areas for the future, where we will have much to do together.

At the same time, I hope we will have the opportunity to use this interoperability, but also this intimacy in terms of intervention, to have a common intervention on the ground, a common training program, a security program, in order to precisely anchor this link.

And thirdly, I think that what we are creating, with these new facilities, will allow us to create entirely new projects, and I firmly believe in the capacity to develop both our capabilities and operational projects together. This is notably what we have done with the Belgians, with the CaMo project: it is a complete model, and it is probably one of the models that we can develop and deploy with your army and your government.

Speaker

Mr. President, I represent the officer program. France has competent and powerful naval forces. It is also the only country in the European Union with an independent nuclear force. Does France feel responsible for the protection and maintenance of European security and unity, regarding the establishment of a new passage in the Arctic Ocean and its potential geopolitical influence?

Emmanuel Macron

Yes, certainly. Not in a way that provokes escalation, but by standing alongside our allies and European partners, in order to preserve the freedom, sovereignty, and essential liberties that should be guaranteed by our international law. So we feel this very particular responsibility.

At the same time - I reiterated this at the end of my speech, I was very clear, a few years ago - for us, part of our vital interests - what we conceive and define as our vital interests - has a European dimension, which gives us a particular responsibility, given precisely what we have and our deterrent capacity. We must be clear about this.

Speaker

Thank you. Mr. President, I am part of the senior officer program. You have spoken a lot about collaboration, and I have a question about that. I would like you to clarify your position regarding security in the Baltic Sea region and a possible strengthening of NATO's presence in this region. And, on the same theme, what is France's view regarding cooperation between France and the Baltic Sea coastal countries in general, and between France and Sweden in particular? Thank you.

Emmanuel Macron

We are very eager to have more cooperation. And I think you perceived that in the official session we had together. Our experts rightly emphasized that your country is perceived as a security provider for the entire region, in fact, and that it is among those who provide security solutions for the whole region.

It is clear that the security and stability of the Baltic Sea will be at stake or, at least, it will be a geography where we will be collectively tested. And I mentioned that, while we are all focused on a continental war in Ukraine, we must not forget that the maritime space, space, and cyberspace will likely be three critical areas. And if we take Russia, they will overexpose hybridity and multiply areas of confrontation to avoid being trapped in a single approach and in a territorial and continental war.

Thus, we are fully prepared to have this type of cooperation, and by the way, this will not depend on NATO: it could be framed and designed and, I would say, a necessary "breakthrough" object and cooperation. But we are already largely involved in this kind of cooperation. We launched a de facto cooperation with Romania a few days after the war began. We have an existing historical presence with a number of Eastern flank states, whether on land or through our air presence, and we are already obviously participating in many exercises in the Mediterranean Sea, in the Atlantic Ocean, and we are ready to participate in initiatives and operations in the Baltic Sea with you in order to send strategic signals or to have a very concrete intervention.

This is exactly what we are doing right now with some of our key players in the Red Sea, in a different context. We are talking less today about what is happening in Gaza and Israel, but one of the consequences, as you know, is the terrorist attacks from the Houthis. And we have decided to ensure a defensive presence and to preserve freedom of navigation in this region through this presence.

Also, to be very clear and direct with you, we are ready, and we will be very happy and honored to participate in this kind of exercise or this kind of operation in the Baltic Sea.

Moderator

Unfortunately, it is time to end this session. Please join me in thanking His Majesty, the Prime Minister, and especially our guest of honor, President Emmanuel Macron, who not only conveyed an important message of strength but also took the time to answer a number of very difficult questions posed by our students. Thank you very much.

Emmanuel Macron

Thank you.