Interview with Emmanuel Macron, President of the Republic, on the 8 PM news.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

26 August 2019 · G7 summit in Biarritz · Biarritz, France

Context
Macron gave a live TV interview on France 2 following the G7 summit in Biarritz on 26 August 2019, discussing Iran diplomacy and summit outcomes.
Main themes
Iran nuclear crisis diplomacy, G7 Biarritz summit, French mediation role, Iran-US tensions, nuclear non-proliferation, de-escalation efforts, international sanctions, multilateral negotiations, France's foreign policy, Iranian Foreign Minister visit
Duration
~68 min
97th percentile
Words
8,203
97th percentile
Sentences
563
99th percentile
Readability
57
82nd percentile
Grade
8.8
10th percentile
Syntax
2.45
3rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.33
79th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

563 sentences in 231 paragraphs

Good evening, Mr. President of the Republic. Thank you for accepting the invitation from France 2 and the 8 PM news to take stock of this G7 summit in Biarritz, an event marked by the spectacular arrival of the Iranian Foreign Minister. Was it a gamble, a pressure tactic? Did you hope he would meet Donald Trump?

Good evening to you, happy to see you again in this place. Indeed, as you very well said, two days ago, we were with the 6 other leaders who were invited. No, it is not a gamble; it is, I believe, the role that France must play in trying to make our best efforts. We have not resolved everything regarding the Iranian issue, far from it, but we had, as you very well mentioned in your report, a very good discussion with President Trump when he arrived. We then had a dinner here, where we talked for more than an hour about Iran, which is a subject that seems very complicated, that seems very distant, but fundamentally, we all agree on two things: we do not want the Iranians to have nuclear weapons, and we do not want escalation that could lead to war. That was very important because the Americans have put themselves in a position to agree to negotiate under certain conditions, and what I decided to do after this dinner was to invite the minister, telling President Trump, to test and try to move forward based on hypotheses that are just trials that France is making. So it is not a gamble. It is, if I may say so, efforts that we are making. It is the role of France trying to mediate. General de Gaulle said: "diplomacy is trying to hold together broken windows"; sometimes, that is what puts them back together. We tried, and we succeeded in taking an important step in this G7 on the issue of the Iranian crisis.

Is it diplomacy, the discussions initiated by the French, by you, that have influenced the Iranian president, or are they the American sanctions imposed?

Undoubtedly both. I told you, it is very important for our country that there is no nuclear weapon in Iran. It is also very important that we do not have conflicts in the region because when we have conflicts, it fuels terrorism that then affects us. Let us never forget that in November 2015, the attacks carried out in France were organized in Syria. Then, we did not have the same strategy with President Trump. We said: we remain in this nuclear agreement because it gives us visibility, it allows us to have control, and then we will try to achieve more. He said: that is not enough. He withdrew and imposed sanctions. These sanctions, of course, have an impact on Iran. Iran is in recession, the population is suffering, there is pressure on the regime, so it changes things. But we are at a breaking point, if you will, meaning that if we stay here and let things go, the Iranians will gradually continue to withdraw from this treaty. And so what they are about to do, and what they will do automatically otherwise, is that they will resume enriching uranium to try to obtain nuclear weapons. And at that moment, we will tip over to the wrong side of pressure because it would become escalation. If they do that, the Americans will surely retaliate. Other powers in the region that are concerned, Israel, Saudi Arabia, may retaliate, and we could have an outbreak. That is why I have spent a lot of time in recent weeks, as president of the G7 and because it is also the role of France, we signed it, we are a permanent member of the Security Council, trying to convince both sides to find an agreement because I do not want this escalation. France is testing these ideas on both sides, and we see what can work with our British and German partners because we have worked a lot with Chancellor Merkel and Prime Minister Johnson to try to build an agreement. We are not there yet, but what we managed to achieve during this G7 on this subject is: 1) we have reduced the pressure, which is very important. 2) There was this opening that you noted. Each of the presidents said: "I am ready to meet the other under certain conditions." And then 3) we had very technical, very confidential discussions with the Iranians, with the Americans, and the British and Germans, and we are gradually seeing what conditions could be met in the coming weeks. So now, there will be very technical, very diplomatic work. We must preserve all this; it is fragile, so we must be very careful.

There are progress, we can see them, we are pleased. There is no agreement, you say. You said at the beginning that you wanted a useful summit. Will we have to settle for small steps today?

So, what is a useful summit? First of all, the very principle of having open discussions among the 7 main industrialized countries that share democratic values is useful. These summits do not work when we do not have a real discussion, when we annotate prepared notes from others, when we avoid problems. Here, I believe I can say that we talked about everything with a lot of freedom. Sometimes we agreed, other times we did not, but that has a utility because it prevents us from going down various paths.

So we must still lower our ambitions regarding not changing the world, not resolving crises?

No, the world has never been changed either at a G7 or at a summit. You know, the world is changed at a summit when we are at war and we make peace at that summit. Here, it is much more complicated; it is sometimes about avoiding the worst and then building the best step by step. What is useful? 1) This exchange. 2) What we obtained on Iran is very useful for the reasons we just mentioned. On crises like Libya, which affect us because it is about migration, the stability of Africa, we also succeeded, with our African friends, in agreeing on two important upcoming meetings, and in any case, to stop fighting each other by proxy on Libyan territory. On trade, as you very well recalled in your report, there were a lot of tensions. We recalled two very important things. We agree on an international tax; it is very complicated, but we will do it, and on the subject of trade balances, we are trying to reduce the conflict. On the Amazon, useful summit, we committed...

We do not see progress on the United States and China; we do not see it because tensions reached an extreme level just before the summit, with new tariffs promised by Donald Trump for December on certain Chinese imports, including this call for American companies to leave Chinese territory. We have gone very far. There has been no backtracking. We just said: we continue to dialogue, but really nothing concrete.

No, but that is normal because a dialogue is done between two parties, and one of the parties was not there today. It is not the purpose of the G7 to do that. President Trump explained what he wanted to do with China. So that is normal. I still note that there were rather positive messages that came from the Chinese this morning. No, what we did on trade, which, in my eyes, is, even if it is less spectacular, very important, is that we agreed, including with the United States of America, it is the small text we released, to say that the problems we have in trade matters, we must manage them together by changing our world trade organization. And that is a real change because President Trump started from the premise that the United States of America had significant trade deficits. That is true.

And they are even more so today, that’s what he says. There you go.

That cannot be resolved simply with tariffs, but it is true. He said: "I will resolve it by having bilateral discussions, that is to say, by talking with China, by raising my tariffs, by hardening things, by talking with Europe." It is an approach; I respect it, but I am not sure it will produce many effects. Above all, it can create a lot of unnecessary tensions and remove growth, and that is not good for us. So what we agreed on together is that we said: we understood the problem and we share it. It is our problem too. Global trade has not respected intellectual property enough. We have allowed counterfeiting to happen too much; it destroys jobs in our countries. We have sometimes allowed unfair competition to happen, meaning companies competing with ours when they did not have the same conditions, when they were sometimes supported by their states, which we no longer do. That is not normal. So all these things that have sometimes disadvantaged the United States as well as us, we need to resolve them much faster, to modernize our rules. That is what we decided to do, and so our ministers will have this work in the coming months. That means we decide to do it together. That is what we call multilateralism, and it is better than deciding to resolve these problems through confrontations against each other.

Do you think we will avoid a tax on our wines? It was not clear at the time of the press conference, Donald Trump.

No, that is normal. He always wants to keep, if I may say, things... He had a very positive and friendly message for French wine by referring to the First Lady.

And that spared him from answering the question.

Of course. Why? Because as long as there is no agreement, he does not want to say that he will not do it. First of all, it is complicated to link taxation, the issue of digital taxation, and the issue of a tariff; it is not the same thing. Then, it was a threat. I did not overinterpret it because we need to see its effectiveness. You know, I took a very simple example. Two years ago now, I believe, he decided to tax Canadian lumber because wooden houses in the United States were made only with Canadian wood and not American. He imposed a tax. It did not decrease Canadian lumber sales by a single cent, but it increased the price for consumers because, simply, Americans did not know how to produce the same wood for these constructions.

There, French wine producers are still worried.

Of course they are worried, rightly so. But I still look at the sales, their dynamics, and I want to say that all those who export, if there were a tax imposed, I am not sure it would cut them off from the market.

Especially the more expensive ones, but perhaps for the cheaper ones, it might be more complicated.

But even look at the dynamics on the details of wines like rosé. I was in the south of France; they are up 30% every year. So people are ready because it is very good wine, so we must be careful: tariffs do not mean we prohibit wine.

Of course.

And we must not yield to all threats. We have pacified things; I think it is no longer on the agenda. Now we need to find this agreement on international taxation. And that shows you that we have made progress; now we must implement it concretely. All this is very complicated, and I understand that it may seem insufficient or just small steps.

Because in fact, you have relied on work already underway at the OECD?

No, but we launched it. Until now, we had never agreed among ourselves as 7, particularly several states around the table had opposed this work. So that is why this is a real change. But the world we live in is in full transition; things are changing very quickly and very brutally. Digital technology is developing; ten years ago, we were not there, and so it creates very profound changes for our economies. It destroys a lot of jobs and creates others, and it creates imbalances. It is normal that it takes time to agree at the international level, but if we do not do it, we accept that large American companies can almost do hotel work without paying any taxes; and alongside that, people who have their hotels and pay all the taxes are being competed against by them.

You are referring to Airbnb.

Here, I will not name names but... This shows you that it has been a very rapid change, we must succeed, and that is the whole point of these meetings, to agree to provide a response together, to rebuild on an international level. It is the same with climate, biodiversity, the world has never changed so quickly. Our economic and social organization is completely tipping over. And so we must decide for our countries, but since our world is open, is interdependent, we must also agree together. And on this subject, there was a useful advancement today.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

We must now hope that Donald TRUMP does not sweep away all your efforts with a tweet when he gets home, that has already happened to him.

Emmanuel MACRON

You are right, we must always have this humility. I believe that what has been different, what I wanted to do very differently from usual, is that I spent a lot of time with him when there were misunderstandings. He mentioned it himself. And then I did not make a 15-page statement that no one read and that was written by others than us, which means that journalists can always, rightly, say “At this point, they said this” and someone wakes up saying “But no, I do not agree!”.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

There was only one page, but you took your time to detail it, you went into...

Emmanuel MACRON

But yes, because we wrote a page on everything we agreed on. Everything we just said is in that page. And that is very important because he wrote it with us, read it, and we held the press conference together.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

I was mentioning a possible tweet from Donald TRUMP, presidents are increasingly expressing themselves via tweet and it is not always a good idea, we have reached an unprecedented level of violence and insults with Jair BOLSONARO, it seems serious, will relations between France and China become extremely difficult? What is the future of these relations?

Emmanuel MACRON

France and Brazil.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Uh, Brazil, sorry.

Emmanuel MACRON

So allow me to emphasize that I do not take part in these discussions because one might get the feeling when things are sometimes presented that it would be a dialogue between President BOLSONARO and me. Not at all. I consider that the mandate given to me by the French is to represent them, to defend our country, to try to do the best for it to progress, and to carry the voice of France in the world. I must be respectful towards my counterparts, whoever they may be. And so I have never made a statement that was disrespectful towards one of my counterparts. The same cannot be said of President BOLSONARO, I said it earlier and I have obviously condemned it, regretted it. We cannot accept it. And so I always distinguish the peoples from the leaders: the Brazilian people are a great people, Brazil is a great country, the attitude he had and that you recalled towards my wife, the attitude he had towards the Minister of Foreign Affairs a few weeks ago...

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

By refusing a meeting or by pretending...

Emmanuel MACRON

Are not worthy, are simply not worthy of a leader. If I were to do that, the French would justifiably be ashamed. And so I think of the Brazilian people today, I think they deserve better behavior and I hope we will reach those better behaviors.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

What you tweeted was “Our house is literally burning” a few hours before the G7 summit on the fires in the Amazon. Is Jair BOLSONARO responsible for these fires because he encourages the...

Emmanuel MACRON

Not at all. It would be false to say that he is responsible and that is why, by the way, I did not target him when I made this message. But what is the Amazon rainforest? It is essential, it is the largest part of what we call primary forest on the planet, that is to say, really a type of very dense forest with unique biodiversity properties. It is the lung, when we say it is the lung of the Earth, what does that mean? It means that we have trees that absorb CO2, that release oxygen and it represents 15% of the CO2 absorbed on the planet, so it means that while we are trying to reduce our emissions, the Amazon rainforest helps us. It is an incredible biological diversity. When it burns, not only can it no longer have that function, but in burning it releases all the CO2 it had captured, so it is double punishment. There are 9 countries in the Amazon, 9 countries including France because we have...

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

And it does not burn in France.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, it does not burn, but we are concerned in Guyana. The question that is posed to all of us is whether we should say this only concerns each country or that it concerns us all? Well, both at the same time. And so each country is concerned because it is first and foremost its territorial sovereignty; but given the stakes and what the Amazon rainforest represents, we are all concerned because it is a terrible imbalance for the planet. So what can we reproach President BOLSONARO for? The first thing is that he has been very clear in all his messages and supported economic projects that are contrary to the interest of the Amazon rainforest.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Deforestation.

Emmanuel MACRON

Massive deforestation.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

...of the Amazon rainforest for farmers, for crops like soy, and we import how much, 3.5 million tons of soy produced in Brazil?

Emmanuel MACRON

You are absolutely right.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

I believe that Europe imports, it is the largest buyer.

Emmanuel MACRON

Europe imports a lot. I will indeed respond to...

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Do we have a share of responsibility?

Emmanuel MACRON

We have a share of complicity.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Complicity is responsibility.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, but of past complicity, I will explain to you very precisely why for soy because everything is connected, all this is complicated, it needs to be explained point by point. But what he is doing or wants to do, what is serious is that first, I look at things from one year to the next, more than 90% increase in fires, so something has been unleashed. That is not good. Then, he has not been clear on reforestation and on that, it is not just his responsibility, it is also, given this issue, ours. And that is where we sent a very clear message saying “We respect your sovereignty, it is your country, it is Brazil” and on that, I want to be very clear, I have never been ambiguous. But be careful, this issue of the Amazon rainforest is that of the entire planet and so we can help you reforest. We can find ways for your economic development that respect these balances, but we cannot let you destroy everything. That is why this morning we launched, and this is a real advancement related to this G7 and which was made possible by everyone, particularly the Chilean president whom I invited because he is very engaged on climate, we launched a strong initiative on the Amazon. By doing what? We are mobilizing 20 million euros to help all the states that are having their forests burn, because it is not just in Brazil, there are several other states. And the second thing, we are putting in place at least 30 million, and we will finalize that in a few weeks in New York when we are at the United Nations General Assembly, to help with reforestation, to develop agro-ecology, that is to say everything that allows for economic activity while being respectful of the planet, with governments but also with regions and with indigenous peoples.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

What you have also done...

Emmanuel MACRON

And so that is very important, it is a real advancement and it shows that when we are here together we know how to mobilize, we put money in, we move forward. You asked a very good question about soy and so I will explain to you how I plan to move forward. We need soy today in Europe because it provides, in particular, protein that we often use to feed animals or for other productions. And we do not produce it. It is the result of an old balance that was struck in the 1960s between Europe and the United States of America and at that time we accepted a dependency in terms of proteins. And I consider that it is a very bad choice and above all it is bad because for the great balances it makes things travel that we could produce on our territory; and then, on the level, I am very attached, as you know, to European sovereignty, that is to say that Europe should also be able to manage by itself, have partners but not be too dependent, and so what I announced a few months ago and which is at the heart of the European project I believe in is that we must recreate what we call the protein sovereignty of Europe. That means that Europe must be capable of reproducing its own proteins for itself, for consumption as well as for farmers.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

But then precisely the Mercosur, the free trade agreement, you ultimately decided not to give your approval to Mercosur. But two months ago you still wanted to sign it. So is it just a gesture of pressure on Jair BOLSONARO or have you changed as you said and do you believe that this agreement is bad for nature, for climate change?

Emmanuel MACRON

So I will tell you very clearly, Mercosur, first we have, as you very well said, daily exchanges with all the countries that are in what we call Mercosur: Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, etc. Every day, we import and export, so let’s not give the impression to our fellow citizens that all of a sudden, we are going to open all the doors. That is not true, every day we have exchanges with these countries. It is an agreement in which we said “We will facilitate exchanges in certain areas to create more growth on both sides” and then by setting quotas. And so I was a bit tough in the negotiation with Europe for months, France has been the toughest, that is often the case, to protect our agriculture and protect the climate. And so I said: I do not want on certain, on meat, on chicken, on sugar, because this region is for us, that we import too much with too much ease because otherwise it will imbalance our agriculture. We therefore set quotas and then we put what we call safeguard clauses. That means that if all of a sudden it upsets our agriculture, we no longer apply it.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

So you still believe in this agreement?

Emmanuel MACRON

Wait, I will explain what has been done because it has been caricatured. We do not do just anything. Then we said: we also set rules in terms of controls and ecology. I had set all these unprecedented conditions. In particular, I said that I want the Paris Agreement to be respected by all those who sign, because I knew that Mr. BOLSONARO had campaigned against the Paris Agreement. When we were in July in Japan, we were told: political declaration. That is why we must always be cautious and see what is behind it. It is good, we are all in agreement, let’s go. I said at that moment: I agree since everything I asked for is fulfilled, everything that France wanted. But I said: I expect to see the text and I expect to see that everything is respected. Then, two things happened. We received the text, it now needs to be worked on because it is not sufficient. I said it, the Mercosur text does not provide me with the guarantees that correspond to what I wanted.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

So it is not completely buried, the Mercosur, in your mind? It is not void?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, these are things... We must react responsibly. I said that as early as July. I never gave my final approval because I did not have a final text.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

So you have not changed that much, that is what I mean.

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, because I will give you the second reason.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Nicolas HULOT was delighted that you stepped back from Mercosur when you announced it in retaliation.

Emmanuel MACRON

But he is right, because I will provide my second response, but I explain to you that sometimes we talk about things and we no longer know what we are talking about. The first point is that I have always been cautious in saying: "I do not have the details." When we talk about the agreement we made with the Canadians, what we call CETA, we improved the agreement a lot. We went into detail before ratifying. Here, we are very far away. We haven't even officially signed and initiated the procedure. So I have never given my full agreement. I was not comfortable with everything. I have always said: an agreement is a whole, and the condition that I have always reaffirmed is that we respect our climate commitments. What has happened since July? Mr. BOLSONARO has sent back the scientists who were conducting independent assessments on the subject of the Amazon rainforest. He has sent several messages clearly stating that he would, in any case, effectively withdraw from his commitments, and so I say this very clearly, it is not me who has changed, it is simply him who has not kept his word. And I must, on behalf of France, ensure that our interests, our principles, our values, what we stand for are defended. So in this state, I will not sign the Mercosur.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

There is a failure at the summit.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, the Mercosur, I hope that is clear, these are complicated subjects.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

It is clear. There is a failure at the summit, it is Brexit. Boris JOHNSON said it himself when leaving: there is a deep disagreement between Europeans and Great Britain. He has fallen into the arms of Donald TRUMP, who promises him a wonderful trade agreement. Are you not afraid of this hard Brexit that is looming? We have the impression of having taken a step further towards this hard Brexit, which would also be a catastrophe for the French economy, not only...

Emmanuel MACRON

For the British, above all.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

And for us too. Our largest trade surplus is with Great Britain.

Emmanuel MACRON

I find you, on this subject, a bit harsh, because Brexit was never on the agenda of this summit, and for a simple reason.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

You talked about it with Boris JOHNSON.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, I talked about it when Boris JOHNSON came to Paris on Thursday.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

And not since?

Emmanuel MACRON

Not at all here. But no.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Brexit was not mentioned at all during the G7?

Emmanuel MACRON

I promise you it was not mentioned for a single second between us to talk about it.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

That's surprising. Isn't that a mistake?

Emmanuel MACRON

But no, because we must also know… We must be respectful with everyone and know what we are talking about. The European Union is today 28 member states. The G7 consists of a few industrial powers. Do you think our European partners would be happy that a few Europeans, around the table because they are the biggest, negotiate on their behalf? It does not work like that, the European Union, and fortunately, that is our strength. How do we manage Brexit at the level of the European Union? We have defined a mandate with 27 that we have given to a representative, who is Michel BARNIER and who acts on behalf of the Commission, and we play together, we decide together. So it was normal and good practice that we do not mention it in that format. It does not concern Canada and Japan. We are not going to air our dirty laundry in front of others. And then it concerns us. Then, what is Brexit? Again, it is the British people who have sovereignly decided to leave the European Union, never forget that. It is not us who are driving them away. The second thing is the British government, with a mandate from the people, which for two years has been discussing an agreement with the European Union and which has come to an agreement. And now it is a British government that cannot ratify this agreement in Parliament. So today, Brexit is a British political crisis. We are clear on that.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

But with heavy consequences for Europeans and for France.

Emmanuel MACRON

Afterwards, Mr. JOHNSON, he is doing politics, he may be playing poker, he is intelligent, and he is coming. I had a very good discussion with him. He wants to simplify things on the Irish border, all of this is very complicated, I am not sure we should get into all the details tonight and that we have the time. But it is very simple. We want an agreement that allows us to protect Europe. If we do not have an agreement that protects us and if we do what Mr. JOHNSON wants today, it means that tomorrow, through Great Britain, any goods can arrive that do not comply with European rules. So if I accept what Mr. JOHNSON is asking, tomorrow I will come to you and then you will tell me: how is it that we, in Europe, ban GMOs and because Great Britain allows them, they come in through Great Britain and there are no more borders? That is what he wants. We cannot accept that because I want to protect consumers, citizens, and be a real market. So he must accept that there are terms of agreement. After that, I think we all need to be smart. If they are technical modifications that do not change this agreement, it is up to Michel BARNIER, with him, to discuss it. That is what I told him. I hope that we find an agreement. If there is none, at that moment, it will be a no-deal exit. That is what you call no deal or hard Brexit. A no-deal exit, we are ready for it. It will be hard. It is not good, it is not what I wish. But wait, in the end, those who will always have the possibility to avoid it are the British. They can withdraw this project. So we must defend our interests. We must not give in just because we are afraid of that. What we have done, we have passed laws, we have prepared, we have hired customs officers, we have hired veterinarians to carry out checks if they need to be done. We will support, we will be alongside our fishermen to defend them...

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

We are preparing for the worst.

Emmanuel MACRON

We must prepare for the worst. It is my responsibility and that is what I have asked the government. Work has been done, and we will be alongside the regions or professions if that were to happen. I will do everything to ensure that it does not happen, but that everything cannot mean being weak with the British against our interests.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

You also received Vladimir PUTIN before the G7 when you welcomed him at the Fort de Brégançon a few days ago.

Emmanuel MACRON

Two weeks ago, top chrono.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Exactly one week ago. He mentioned the management of the yellow vest protests. He explained, basically, that he did not want that in his country. You then yourself mentioned unacceptable injuries during the yellow vest protests, during a press interview, nearly 2,500 injured on the protesters' side, 1,750 on the law enforcement side, 24 blinded among the protesters, 5 had their hands torn off. Unacceptable. Does that mean you acknowledge an unacceptable use of force? Was law enforcement poorly managed and deficient?

Emmanuel MACRON

First, we must remember what we experienced, unprecedented violence that shocked us, that shocked all of us, which sometimes shocked the whole world, which was not good for our image either. But that is what we experienced, that is to say that we experienced scenes of extreme violence against law enforcement, against sometimes citizens, journalists, against commerce, against symbols of the Republic and our country, the Arc de Triomphe in December 2018. I say this with a lot of clarity because it is essential and at the heart of the matter. There is no freedom if there is no public order. Public order is not arbitrariness; it is the order that protects everyone's freedom.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

But what did you mean by "unacceptable injuries"? Because the defender of rights had been asking you to react on this for 8 months, to change, he was shocked by that.

Emmanuel MACRON

But of course. The first unacceptable thing is violence. There has been a whole effort, which has consisted of changing what we call the doctrine of maintaining order, that is to say the way of maintaining order, particularly in Paris, which has made us more effective in containing all of this. What we ask above all from the government, and that is why there has been a very significant effort from the Minister of the Interior, the Secretary of State under him, all of his teams, the police prefect, the Prime Minister who has been strongly committed to this issue, what our fellow citizens ask above all is that there be no disorder. So what has been unacceptable above all, the first, the most unacceptable, is the violence of the protesters, the black blocks, of all those who, in essence, have distorted what this movement was...

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

You understand that I am talking to you about the unacceptable injuries that you yourself mentioned because it is new, it is a new element.

Emmanuel MACRON

I come back to that. But I allow myself, because the life of our country is a set of things. I do not want to caricature. And so do not forget that during all these months, our law enforcement has done a remarkable job that was requested. We have sometimes been criticized for not being strong enough, but it should be noted that no country has had to experience such moments of violence and that the consequences are much more limited than what we have experienced in other cases.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

It is that you have been criticized for not having hit hard enough, you have been criticized for having hit too hard as well.

Emmanuel MACRON

I come to that too.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Notably by sending law enforcement that were not adequately trained in maintaining order and who used the infamous rubber bullet launchers too easily.

Emmanuel MACRON

So I come to that. It was necessary and it was not possible for the government, I really believe, I looked at it closely and I ask you to trust me because I looked at it from where I am also as the guarantor of everyone's interest and as President of the Republic. What we experienced is something that deeply hurt me, because the French police, our law enforcement are not there for these scenes to happen and the police do not engage in policing to have to experience what they have experienced. And indeed sometimes to have to shoot at very violent people because they are violent with LBD and sometimes, by the way, when there are mistakes, and I will come back to this point, to do it on people who were not. But I must first say what public order and maintaining order are, and when, throughout this period, the violence was such that it was not possible to suddenly say "We stop the LBD, we disarm" because in what situation would we have found ourselves? Well, perhaps in the situation of no longer being able to hold such a prefecture that we wanted to burn. I was in the prefecture in Puy-en-Velay, I saw agents who almost died from the collective madness that at one point set in. So that was the moment of the country where we were. It was still necessary that order be maintained; it was not maintained in a way, if you will, where there were what I would call irreparable violence. The worst was avoided thanks to their professionalism.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Unacceptable but not irreparable?

Emmanuel MACRON

What I mean is that there is the very specific case of young Steeve in Nantes who is now in the hands of justice and I want justice to do its work in peace, serenity, and complete independence.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

He drowned during the Music Festival after an intervention by law enforcement.

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, at a festival, which we can question both the authorizations, the location, and after an intervention by law enforcement, so everything is complicated, I do not want to summarize it to a single responsibility and above all it is in the hands of justice. But throughout this period, there have been no deaths to be deplored, there is one lady and the investigation is also ongoing, in Marseille, who was on a floor and who is a suspicious death. But I want to put you back in place because...

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

I believe that has been well put in place...

Yes, but it is essential. And alongside that, there are all the injured that you mentioned: injured on the police side, injured on the side of the demonstrators, and of course these injuries are unacceptable. Therefore, what we must do is, first, conduct all the administrative investigations; they have been initiated each time by the minister, to be able to look at what has been done, if it has been done properly, that is administrative, and when measures need to be taken, sanctions should be imposed. Then, everything that needs to be judicialized should be. Neither you nor I can know if the person who was injured was in a situation where they put themselves in danger and threatened the safety of a police officer or if they put them in a situation that led to that. Nevertheless, I wish for us to begin a deep reflection on how we organize ourselves because we cannot remain in these situations. Therefore, I wish for us to start a process, and that is what I have asked the government, where we can sustainably avoid these situations because we cannot accept, in the literal sense, when we are the President of the Republic, as a French citizen, to see these scenes multiply. And so calm must return. We are a country where there is freedom to demonstrate, freedom of opinion, choice, and criticism; it is permanent. And to maintain it, we must not accept great violence. So I wish for us to do several things: to have a collective reflection and work to gradually eradicate great violence, meaning we need to be able to deal with these groups we call the black blocks, who have often been the reason for this, who infiltrate and cause the worst, and provoke us to find a sustainable solution. I do not have it in my pocket, but let us launch this reflection. And then let us look at how to change our way of ensuring security to significantly reduce the number of injuries that occur in these cases.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

The social return will be marked by demonstrations against the pension reform; there are already three planned for the month of September. The unpleasant surprise of the reform is the equilibrium age, the pivot age, 64 years, which is the age at which one can fully receive their pension. You promised to maintain the legal retirement age at 62; here we say there is a fish under the rock, an eel in the water, it’s pretty much the same thing.

Emmanuel MACRON

You are regional...

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Exactly. Is it a retreat of the retirement age that does not say its name?

Emmanuel MACRON

No. First of all, in terms of method, nothing is decided, nothing. There has been remarkable work done by Mr. DELEVOYE.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

When you say “nothing is decided,” does that mean we can still change this pivot age, this equilibrium age or not?

Emmanuel MACRON

But that means we are embarking on a deep reform whose stakes for me are more important than that.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

It is important...

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, it is important, but...

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Someone who has worked for 44 years...

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, but I will (inaudible) what I want to do, what we want to do. I made a commitment to the French people; I said we must refound our pension system simply. One, what has been the strength of France, what we call the post-war compromise of 1945, the solidarity between generations: in France, those who work pay for those who are retired. We maintain that, and we must cherish and replace it. Two, this system has been progressively transformed, damaged, and made unjust because we created about forty regimes, because we created what we call special regimes, small differences linked to past social discussions, and therefore the system is not really fair. There are professions where one retires at 50, 55 years.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

There was still an element of justice; it was the contribution time, the number of quarters, not for the special regimes.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, that is not true, not for the special regimes, no, no, no.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Today, someone who starts at 18 or 20 years old...

Emmanuel MACRON

No, no, no, you are mistaken.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Until 64 years old.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, wait, do you want us to get into the details?

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

No, we are not going to get into the details.

Emmanuel MACRON

There were special regimes that no longer had this retirement age, which was justified because there was a hardship in these jobs before, but which has also changed a lot, which we have not modernized. And there were real injustices between private sector employees and civil servants. If you are a civil servant, your pension is calculated based on your last six months of income; if you are a private sector employee, it is based on your 25 best years. So we created many injustices, and in the end, our system has become what we call corporatist. It is not true that it is universal. There are many differences depending on your sectors; it is not fair.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

But the pivot age was unexpected; it was not announced.

Emmanuel MACRON

But that is because it is not decided.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

It is not decided?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, what I would like to do, so I asked Jean-Paul DELEVOYE to do a job; Jean-Paul DELEVOYE submitted a report, it is in this report that he talks about this, he actually talks about it in more chosen terms. If we do a reform as usual, as we have been doing for 20 years, we say “We will shift the retirement age.” I said a few months ago I would not do that. Why is it not fair to do that? Because when you start working at 16 years old, if I shift your retirement age, then even though generally when you started at 16 years old, you have fewer diplomas, you are in more difficult jobs, it is profoundly unfair. Second thing, we are in an economy where there is still a lot of unemployment, there is a lot of unemployment among seniors, among older people; if we shift the legal age, we are telling people “Stay unemployed longer,” that is not correct. On the other hand, we must, it is our responsibility, to say “The system we are creating must be balanced.” Today we are living longer and longer, the system is no longer balanced, and it will not be. We are creating a new universal system; we will remove all these injustices after a very broad negotiation. What I want, to put it in very simple terms, is that we do two things: one, that the other system, when it comes into effect in 2025, is financially balanced; and two, that it is fair in terms of contributions. What does that mean? You said it yourself a bit in your question. I prefer that we find an agreement on the contribution duration rather than on the age because if you have an agreement on the contribution duration, well when you enter late into professional life, you finish later, but generally it is because you are retired because you have studied; and when you start early, you contribute longer but you retire earlier. That seems fairer to me. Now, in terms of method, he submitted this report, the Prime Minister will start consultations with all social partners next week, and on this reform issue, I want us to embody the change of method that I wished, meaning we will build this reform together. No one has the right solution. All together means that it is not the government that has the right answer alone, but we must share all the constraints. We want this system to remain solidary within the French nation; we want it to be fair, and we want it to be financially balanced because there are no magical finances; there is always someone who pays. And so there will be a great negotiation, and I say it...

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

There will be a consultation...

Emmanuel MACRON

There will be more than just a consultation. I care about the word; I want a great debate, and we will decide together. And I say this because there is a lot of concern. There are certain professions, if we did things mechanically, that would be disadvantaged: teachers, nursing assistants, nurses, particularly. I cite these three. There will be no pension reform until we have built together a real transformation of these professions. That means we do it together and we move.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Thank you very much; we have to interrupt.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, but just one word, Madame LAPIX, excuse me because we are in Biarritz; we talked about a lot of things at this summit, and I really thank you for the time and the pedagogy. I wanted to say just two things: I wanted to say first to the City of Biarritz, to the residents, to the merchants, to all the vacationers who were there, a huge thank you.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Who have left.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, many were there; wait until we leave, well. And so (inaudible) I wanted to say a huge thank you to them, thank you to the Basque Country, which is dear to you and which welcomed us. We have one thing; there is one thing, I say it because I had nothing to do with it, we successfully held this summit thanks to you. Why? Because there was remarkable law enforcement; thank you to all the law enforcement forces; because there is a beautiful and welcoming city; everyone told me they would return to Biarritz; and we had a population that was warm. We will compensate the merchants who suffered significant losses; I tell them we will set up a mechanism. But I can tell you that France has shone, and you can be proud of Biarritz, of the Basque Country, and of all of you because it is a tremendous job that has been done. And I wanted to tell the French people that during these two days, on their behalf, I tried to do my best; we will continue; that is what I have been trying to do from the beginning. We have not succeeded in everything, but I think we have done useful work for us, for Europe, and for the international community.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

Thank you very much, Mr. President of the Republic.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you.

Anne-Sophie LAPIX

(Inaudible) in Basque. This is the end of this edition.