Middle East Mediterranean Forum in Lugano: message from President Emmanuel Macron.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

29 August 2020 · Middle East Mediterranean Forum · Lugano

Context
Macron delivered a virtual message to the Middle East Mediterranean Forum in Lugano on 29 August 2020, addressing regional crises and Mediterranean geopolitics.
Main themes
Mediterranean regional stability, Lebanese crisis and explosion, Syrian and Libyan conflicts, Middle East peace process, youth and civil society dialogue, Western and NATO withdrawal, Turkish and Russian regional influence, terrorism, national sovereignty and pluralism, pandemic economic impact, migration and environmental crises
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,417
66th percentile
Sentences
98
62nd percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
32nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 52%52%
  • Social 18%18%
  • Economic 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

98 sentences in 17 paragraphs

Hello everyone,

I regret not being physically present, but I wanted to first and foremost thank Gilles KEPEL for inviting me to say a few words at the opening of this forum in Lugano, which this year virtually brings together the youth and civil society of the Middle East and the Mediterranean. I am deeply attached to these spaces of dialogue and exchange where the future of our common mother is woven through the meeting of ideas and aspirations of the projects of the generations that have and will inherit it.

Our Mediterranean, which has nourished our common history, shaped our identities, carried our myths, and irrigated our cultures, has once again roared this summer with all its violence and strength, and has been rumbling in the background for several years now.

First, because the pandemic that is affecting the whole world is hitting the peoples and economies of the entire region hard, generating tensions and also awakening fractures at the heart of society. Because our common mother, shaken for so long by migratory, security, and environmental crises, is today at the center of several rivalries, a reorganization of this entire space. In essence, if we look at our Mediterranean Sea today, we see that those who ensured its stability and security, largely the American presence and the structuring by NATO, have gradually disappeared, or at least have significantly withdrawn. We then see that it continues to be marked by the shadow of the peace process in the Middle East, which, for several years, has entered what I would modestly call a state of tension, a kind of impossibility to find a solution, the fait accompli, the non-respect of international law, and this summer has shown again a recomposition of the forces at play, through an American mediation that profoundly changes the game.

We see our Mediterranean caught in conflicts for several years that have also profoundly changed the balances of the entire region. The Syrian conflict, the Libyan conflict, which, we must look at with great humility, are characterized rather by the multiplication of errors by Western powers that have failed to build their peace and to substitute either a sovereignty that they contested with imperial solutions that they contested, or the fight against terrorism with inclusive solutions. And we see rather in these two theaters of conflict, Syria and Libya, a situation of endless war that is the theater of the re-emergence of two great regional powers (Russia, Turkey), each with their own agenda. We see rather terrorist movements thriving, even if the international coalition in Syria has provided an initial effective response, but incomplete. We see the destabilization and the difficulty of finding forms of inclusive national sovereignty, which, for the past 100 years, was what we collectively contributed to try to bring forth, and I believe that these two hotspots, these two ongoing wars, are for us a theater of reflection and action that is absolutely essential if we want to see the role that the West has to play, the role that Europe has to play, but also the model of development and political balance that we want for the Mediterranean and the Middle East, and what is at stake under different forms, with different histories, in Syria as in Libya, is the capacity to bring forth national sovereignties in a pluralism, whether ethnic, religious, or political. That is what is at stake. And if the coming years give rise to models of ethnic-religious, familial, or clan domination, we will have profoundly failed in this region.

The region has also been marked in recent weeks by the explosion in Lebanon. I was in Lebanon on August 6, two days after the explosion in the port, and this explosion was essentially a metaphor for the Lebanese crisis. The investigation will reveal where this explosion came from. It is likely the result of successive negligence, an inability to manage, of small decisions or non-decisions that led to this explosion. But it speaks to all the misfortune of this great people who today are like prisoners of the political structure of the last decades. And more than that, obviously, the explosion is now the humanitarian crisis that we have to manage, that we will manage, that we are managing with the United Nations and all the countries that have mobilized around Lebanon, with President AOUN who was present at the international aid and support conference that France organized a few days later. But it is also the political crisis that we must try to resolve, by the Lebanese, with the Lebanese, without compromise, in a way. That is to say, without getting used to a system of clientelism and corruption that has largely blocked the country and of which the first victim has been the Lebanese people. But here too, what is at stake in Lebanon, in my eyes, is two things: once again, the capacity to maintain a unique model. Lebanon has always been greater than itself because it is the synthesis of this vision of the Mediterranean, of the Near and Middle East, that is to say, a model where we manage to make religions, different peoples coexist within a nation. If it can no longer produce the common good, it is failing, and thus the Lebanese political crisis is a crisis of the pluralistic model and the inclusive model, and therefore a whole test. Then, it is a test for the international community, because it is in a way our capacity to extract Lebanon from all the great tensions of the powers in the region, particularly obviously Iran, which has cast its shadow over this country, this people for several decades, and thus our capacity to disengage from international conflicts on which sometimes multilateralism has collided, to say the least, and thus succeed in dissociating Lebanon from the rest of the region and its great tensions.

The entire region is then marked by deeper tensions, but which I am convinced will structure it in the long term.

Obviously, the religious factor. I mentioned it through these simple crises that, in Syria, Lebanon, and Libya, mark our agenda, our way of reacting, tensions with neighbors. The crisis that Islam is experiencing, religious tensions deeply traverse the region and its structure. And so it is our capacity to make coexist particularly the great religions of the Book, to also move beyond this crisis that Islam is going through and the violent forms of a distorted Islam that have led to forms of terrorism, to forms of political, radical, and violent Islamism. The entire region depends on our collective capacity to recognize all religions and to make them coexist in this broader space that is not a single country, but this region of the Mediterranean, the Near and Middle East.

The second element after the religious factor is obviously the demographic factor for me. Today, the Mediterranean is no longer seen in one direction, that is to say, the migrations from the southern shore or the war theaters of the Middle East to Europe. This is not in line with the history of the Mediterranean. We cannot think of it that way. And so we need to rethink another form of European demography, one where we will succeed in making the cycle of Europe work, to rebuild real projects, a circulation of talents, to bring talents back, and thus it is a whole project, you can see, of university, cultural, but also technological, industrial, economic, political development on both shores. We need to rethink the circulation of women and men and a common demography, and not simply the demography imposed by the routes of necessity or crime. This requires addressing some issues such as the issue of goods that has been marked by human trafficking and contemporary slavery, but also finding a common logic in terms of cultural development investment between the two shores. It is also for this reason that for me, this demographic aspect is obviously completely linked to the educational, cultural, economic aspect and the capacity that civil societies have, thereby leading their governments to find new solutions. And in this regard, the Summit of the Two Shores is for me a source of hope and an element to think differently about the peoples of our Mediterranean and this demographic fact differently.

The third structuring fact of the region is the energy factor. The Mediterranean is becoming a transit route again, particularly for energy transits. This is what, moreover, creates all the tensions in the Eastern Mediterranean, these are the routes, or the drilling for oil and gas. We also see it in this somewhat legal war of mutual recognitions, of the delimitation of sovereignties or exclusive economic zones. And on this aspect, I believe that we also have a collective challenge. We cannot engage in this kind of forward rush that would subject us to this deeply incoherent agenda with a sustainable development of the Mediterranean. We cannot also say that we will deprive countries or peoples in a situation of great poverty of the resources that are today theirs. And so, we need to build a kind of Pax Mediterranea around this energy issue. We can see well that many have an interest in this energy issue not appearing in the Eastern Mediterranean. Russia, which is primarily seeking access points in the Mediterranean because it is a historical obsession and which has its own resources to flow to Europe, the rest of the world, and which wants to maintain its hegemony. We see all the attention that Turkey is nurturing, in addition to everything else in the region in this regard. But we see the opportunity that this represents for Lebanon, Egypt, which has just discovered significant deposits, and many other countries. We cannot also allow these countries to exploit this energy without considering that the Mediterranean cannot now become the theater of pipelines or extractors. And so, how to reconcile these energy and thus economic opportunities with coexistence in this very restricted space and our sustainable development objectives and in a way a clean Mediterranean? I believe this is a collective and regional challenge. And we all have to think about it with civil societies, with scientists, to prevent this energy issue from being exclusively a subject of conflict, but rather a subject of cooperation coherent with our agendas.

And then, the fourth issue, I mentioned it in my introductory remarks, after the religious, after the demographic, after the energy, is obviously the political. Because there is an American and NATO withdrawal, in a way, because we see regional imperial powers returning with the fantasy, in a way, of their own history. I am thinking primarily of Turkey. We need to find forms of political cooperation in the Mediterranean. They do not exist. The successive attempts have ended in failure. A little over two years ago, I wished that we go through civil societies. This is the whole belief I have in the Summit of the Two Shores that I mentioned and that we will continue to push. A new ambassador has been appointed. For me, there are many perspectives on many subjects behind this project. But it is not exclusive of what states, political powers can and must do.

I believe that the Mediterranean cannot become the theater of confrontations between great powers nor one that, in a way, rediscovers the Eastern crisis of the 19th century. I think we need to build mechanisms of political cooperation there too. This is the whole challenge of the coming months. I set this for myself. And it is for me one of the key challenges in the relationship of the European Union with its neighborhoods. This cooperation will guarantee much of the stability of the European Union with the Western Balkans, Russia, Turkey. It will also guarantee much of the capacity for sustainable and balanced cooperation between Africa and the European Union.

What political governance can we find for our Mediterranean, our Near East, our Middle East? An inclusive model of stability, but with new forums. However, today, everything is blocked. Europe is functioning today better than it has been able to function with real solidarity towards Southern Europe. The European success of July has shown this again. The Maghreb does not function as a political entity. There is distrust that remains, we know it, territorial conflicts. Egypt today has a strong power that contributes to the stability of the region, but which is distrustful of both Turkey and partly of what is happening today in Libya. And so, all these points of fixation, adding to the two wars I mentioned and the Lebanese situation, obviously lead us today not to make this common space function. And so I think that we have, in this reinvention of contemporary multilateralism, to try to build the foundations of what Mediterranean cooperation is.

These are just a few sketches, but around these four axes, and I have not been exhaustive because I do not want to be lengthy, and above all, I am eager to read your thoughts. But I believe that we have in this part of the world, which has so much history, which has been the space of so many dramas, which is still nourished by Greek tragedy, but also the capacity to build a future in which I deeply believe. And in saying all this, being aware of the crises we are going through, I say it with a great deal of optimism, but I believe in a positive agenda, a concrete agenda of projects for employment, for the environment, for equality, but also, in a way, in a capacity to gather the energy of youth to try something unprecedented yet to be invented. This is also why I believe that the forum that is yours is so interesting and can inspire so much hope. There you have it, that is a quick sketch from the end of August that I wanted to share with you, regretting once again not being physically among you or in your exchanges in a more interactive way.

But our Mediterranean, Braudel was right, it is always a thousand things at once. I have only shared a very small part of how I see it today, but also a few lines on how we might approach it.

So thank you. Good dialogues. Speak, build, imagine. We need you, and we are and will continue to be there by your side.

Thank you very much.