In Orange, President Emmanuel Macron comes to engage with the staff of the Argensol vocational high school.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

1 September 2023 · Visit to the Argensol vocational high school · Argensol vocational high school, Orange, France

Context
Macron addressed staff at the Argensol vocational high school in Orange on September 1, 2023, to present a major reform of France's vocational education system.
Main themes
Vocational high school reform, school dropout reduction, youth employment and insertion, educational inequality, national investment in vocational education, program relevance to job market, social determinism in education, fundamental knowledge vs. trade skills
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,041
76th percentile
Sentences
108
67th percentile
Readability
57
82nd percentile
Grade
12.0
46th percentile
Syntax
3.23
75th percentile
Vocabulary
1.87
2nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 49%49%
  • Economic 30%30%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

108 sentences in 10 paragraphs

Thank you very much, Mr. President of the Regional Council, for your words and the announcements that are indeed very important and will directly affect the high school. Thank you very much, Madam Principal, for your words, the comprehensive presentation you made, and for the welcome. And I obviously want to acknowledge the presence beside me of the ministers who are carrying out all this work, this reform, and beyond; the presence of our parliamentarians who are here beside me, of the President of the Departmental Council, of Mr. Mayor and the elected officials, as well as the state services, Madam Prefect, Mr. Rector. Thank you very much. First of all, I really want to thank you because I am aware that we are arriving at a day that is still important, a bit stressful, which is that of a pre-return where you will organize the coming months or the schedules are revealed where it is necessary… or not yet, then. So we have added to the burden, but it is still rather to highlight the importance of your daily work and to try to support it with additional resources. And the second thing, I also wanted to thank all the partners who are here from the economic world because they are indispensable partners and obviously all those who also keep your high schools running, whether it is security, canteens, maintenance, etc. and the regional staff, among others. So, we are arriving in a somewhat particular context, that of a pre-return, to indeed carry this transformation of vocational high schools. We had not touched this sector for decades, and I think that, by the way, if it affected many more children, political leaders, media figures, or others, we would have done it much earlier. And that is why I spoke of a national cause because we celebrate every year our results in the baccalaureate. But we always forget to remind that if we have these results in the baccalaureate, it is because one third of our high school students are in vocational high schools, one third. But when we look, without bad puns, when we open the hood and really look at what is happening and what is your daily life, the situation is unacceptable. Because it is that, at the bottom, of the assignment to residence that I denounced six years ago, of many injustices and family determinisms. We know well that many of our young people are directed to vocational high schools, not always by choice, but because they have not actually succeeded in middle school and that they are the fruits of a dropout that started before. This means that the first problem we have in vocational high schools is that the dropout rate is higher. We talked about it with the minister; we have one third of high school students in vocational high schools, we have two thirds of dropouts in vocational high schools. It is not their fault, it is not the fault of the teachers, it is just the fact that there is a determinism that is there and that we have, as if mechanically, by fatality, too often directed them not by choice, saying: "You have no ideas, it’s not working? You will go there." That is not acceptable. I will return to the response.

The second difficulty is that we still have many of our programs that either do not lead to a diploma or do not lead to a job. That is a reality. And we look on average, we will have 40% of our young people who will have a job in the 6 months following their diplomas, including when they go to BTS. So there, you cited a very particular case which is the fact that many young people, you cannot get them to continue. And that, of course, is something to which we will provide a response through openings. But even when we manage to get them to go to the end, regardless of the level of the diploma, we have 40% who find a job. And that means that we have, in a way, a real social and educational waste, that we have not succeeded in properly orienting them because sometimes we have put them in programs where there was not actually so much future. So, in the face of this, the strategy we have set for ourselves, which is a real investment of the nation, has been said, in addition to what is already there, we are putting 1 billion euros into vocational high schools, it is fundamentally to try to reshuffle all the cards and to give you the means to aim for 0% dropout and 100% insertion. And fundamentally, to also get out of an old debate that we often had among us which was to say: we should choose between learning fundamental knowledge well and learning a trade well. No, we must do both. It is often caricatured by saying "I believed in 'at the same time'." It is not confusion the "at the same time." It is to say sometimes, we do not have to choose. And our young people have the right to do both. And we have the duty to give you the means to do it fully.

So, the first battle is to help you move towards 0% dropout. So, if I may say, the battle starts earlier. That is what we are doing from primary school with the means we are giving ourselves precisely for the return of fundamental knowledge, with more hours, with also the pact, I will come back to it, for your colleagues who are in primary, with evaluations every year, which we will systematize in our local CNRs and the fact that we will fight against what builds dropout, which is arriving in CM2 without knowledge, and even more so in 6th grade, these fundamental knowledge that allow you to be spotted and to continue. So that is all the investment we are making in fundamental knowledge from primary school and throughout middle school.

The second battle that is also being fought and that is before, is that of orientation. It is to allow young people — and I will answer all the questions afterwards if there are any, of course — it is to allow our adolescents to know the trades. And this is where, by the way, we will need the partners from the economic world who are here, it is that we will set up this half-day to come which will allow young people and their families to know trades from 5th grade and to be able to, therefore, choose, including choosing then vocational programs with full awareness, by passion, and because they will have seen that there are opportunities, that it interests them, whereas their families or their teachers in middle school, which is normal, did not know them.

Then, at the level of vocational high schools, we will give you the means to fight against dropout thanks, precisely, to the recognition sometimes of work that is done within the framework of the pact, I will come back to it later, but also with a new organization that will allow taking smaller groups, thus splitting, for fundamental knowledge, the students, sometimes providing individualized support, fundamentally choosing and having much more freedom at the level of the establishment by having these means, to follow and really have, 1) A systematic evaluation at entry, 2) A support with more means to take them in small groups and be able to support them on these fundamental knowledge and fight against dropout.

And then, alongside that, we have set up a mechanism that comes from the ground, it is not an invention that was thought up in an office in Paris, if I may say, open rights, which is to say, many of you, we have dropouts, we identify them very quickly, we see that it is not going to work, because in fact, they have been directed there, they arrive in second grade, but they are much too far behind, and fundamentally, they will need to be directed towards second chance schools, towards EPIDE or others. And that is to allow not to wait… We were losing a year until now. We had to wait until the end of the school year to be able to re-enroll them or direct them with the family towards these devices. It is to do it right after the evaluations and when you evaluate them, and it is on a collegial basis that is done by the teaching staff in connection with the family, they remain enrolled in the establishment, but immediately, we allow them to have access precisely to these devices that are more suited to their level of difficulty or dropout. So, there is a set of solutions, I do not want to be too long, but which will allow us to fight against school dropout by giving you more hours, more means, having more pedagogical tools and being more adapted precisely to the needs, beyond what we do before.

The second element is indeed to aim for 100% professional insertion. So the first battle to do this, you said it, is the famous training map. And this is where we need our regions, but also the entire economic world. The regions, and I really commend the commitment you have just made, Mr. President, play a very important role because they finance the buildings, the security elements, the technical platforms, and it is a very large investment. But when we look at things at the national level, we have actually created a completely transparent system, we look, we follow the students and we say where we have training where students, fundamentally, will be very… Well, will be much below the national average in terms of access to training and a diploma or access to a job. And we see that we have 15% of our training programs that are fundamentally in difficulty or need to be rethought. That is to say, we have 15% of our training programs that, when we follow the young people, they have access neither to higher education nor to a job. So that is not good. Now, these training programs, that does not mean that they should be automatically closed. It means, I have used this term well, they need to be rethought. Some, we need to close sometimes. We need to have the courage to do it. These are decisions we are asking for by the end of the year because it is in December that we will finalize the decision which will be made by the presidents of regional councils with the rectorates, but which will be informed by the economic world and the teachers because we will say, there, it is no longer working, there is no longer a need. Others, we will rethink them. This is exactly what you are doing here with the metalworking and nuclear sectors. You said it very well, by the way. We have somewhat less good results in terms of professional insertion. The reason is that we have many young people and that we had a downstream sector that was saturated, so we will respond to the needs by opening new places in vocational baccalaureate, but in fact, we have industrial needs in the region, we just need to be a bit more adapted to industrial needs. The nuclear jobs that exist in Tricastin and that will continue to exist over time. And so it is this work that requires looking at our results, having an exchange with the economic world. And fundamentally, we will look, for this training map, at our students' access to higher education, students' access to jobs, but also the needs we have for existing jobs and future jobs. And we have needs in almost all sectors. I was looking at the map of needs in your department, there are needs in agricultural jobs, there are needs in industrial jobs, there are many needs in personal service jobs, there are needs in jobs that we know very well today, jobs that we are in the process of consolidating like those in nuclear, future jobs like cybersecurity and others. So we have a range because we have an improving economic situation, we just need to adapt it.

The second challenge is obviously to find internships more easily, which is the goal of the business office. It is truly a support for both your technical platform and workshop directors, your teachers, etc., to strengthen the contact with the business world, to ensure that we have internships and to ensure follow-up. Because one of the points we will also launch with the reform is to systematize the calling of students who have graduated to precisely carry out this follow-up. And this is something that is also part of what is in the Pact but that we will systematize, where the business office will have a particular role, which is to ensure that we properly follow the young people in their next steps, whether in terms of training or in terms of employment. It is then about developing short courses. You have said it very well, because you have young people who need to be kept a little longer, because you have companies that can tell you: we need them to go a little further in technical preparation. It is obviously about supporting internships. It is the Avenir Pro system that will mobilize all the levers of partnerships to better support students during and after, and allow you, this will also be recognized in remuneration, including supporting them in their BTS and following them. And so, here too, we are putting in place new means: the card, the business office, all these systems that are in your hands, also positions for associate professors that will allow for more technical qualifications that we do not necessarily have in the teaching team, to ask partner companies to detach professionals for a few hours to come and teach and to come and help and to fully value the adventure, which is at the heart of what we believe for this profession, which is to strive for excellence and outcomes. And this is what we value with the WorldSkills that have been mentioned. I know that you have champions in this field here, trainers and award winners. Congratulations for that. And so, on this second challenge, we are also giving ourselves the means in a very pragmatic way by looking at what has worked and what has not worked in recent years. And to do this, beyond these openings, these means that we are putting in place, we will obviously support the regions to open new platforms, because sometimes it involves investments. If we say: we need to open in a certain industrial profession, we know that it is much more expensive than opening in a tertiary training that we had until now, which will need to be requalified. And so we have, in our France 2030 plan, funding that is planned to train our young people in this framework. And then we will obviously continue to promote everything related to WorldSkills and excellence in this area, because I believe in the excellence of all the sectors that are present here.

And obviously, the last point is the compensation for internships that you mentioned, which I believe is an element of recognition for young people and their families, a form of valorization, and which is also a way to align with what we have been able to do regarding apprenticeships. We do not confuse the systems, but we are gradually starting with a very progressive system to move, I believe, in the right direction.

And finally, we are doing all this while having a pact. And here I turn to the teachers who are here, which is also an exceptional element because beyond the unconditional base revaluation that affects all teachers in the National Education, as it had not affected the teaching profession since the early 1990s, in its part that is unconditional, there are all the elements, if I may say, optional, meaning that all those who will engage and who are at the maximum of the pact, they will receive, I speak under the control of the ministers, 565 euros net more per month. Which, I think, is not insignificant. When one commits to the missions I just mentioned. And so there is a part that is obviously totally unconditional, as everywhere. And it can go up to more than 550 euros net per month when one commits to these missions, which is also, I believe, the recognition of a commitment. And you said it very well, some of them, by the way, many were doing it, they were not taken into account, they were not recognized, they were not compensated. But I want us to also mobilize all energies, to have full recognition of the work you do and to be fully sure that everyone is recognized when there is this maximum mobilization. There you go, I could be longer since if there are questions, I want to be able to answer them. But at this start of the school year, even if we are disturbing your pre-school year, there is an unprecedented commitment from the nation for the sectors, the students you serve because I consider it to be the most beautiful mission there is and it is also the one that prepares our future and that there is no inevitability in saying that, in vocational high school, we should keep the same number of dropouts, we should keep the same insertion rates. This is the battle you have been fighting daily for years, sometimes even decades. And it is the one that we must now help you to multiply, and that is why I said that it is truly a cause in my eyes and not a reform. I will not be longer. In any case, thank you for your commitment, thank you for taking care of our youth, and we will put all the means, the heart, and the commitment to implement it on the ground. Thank you very much.