PRESS CONFERENCE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC ALONGSIDE PRIME MINISTER EDI RAMA.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

17 October 2023 · Joint press conference with Prime Minister Edi Rama

Context
Macron held a joint press conference with Albanian Prime Minister Edi Rama during France's first-ever presidential visit to Albania on October 17, 2023.
Main themes
Franco-Albanian bilateral relations, European security and terrorism, cultural and linguistic ties, economic cooperation and investment, EU integration of Albania, energy transition, tourism and hospitality training, combating crime and trafficking, French development aid, digital education
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,505
93rd percentile
Sentences
235
92nd percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

235 sentences in 65 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen ambassadors,

Ladies and gentlemen.

I can say that I am happy to be here, without any diplomatic precautions or reference language. Happy to be by your side today in such a difficult moment for our Europe, which is undergoing a shift in the world, with the return of war on its soil as we have seen in Ukraine for a year and a half, with the return of war in the Caucasus, and unfortunately the return of terrorism on our soil. I want to think of our Belgian friends and our Swedish friends, as yesterday Brussels was indeed attacked and two Swedish nationals were affected by terrorist attacks. So I have a particular thought for our Belgian and Swedish friends at this moment.

I said being by your side today marks a form of re-engagement of France in this region and in your country, because it was in a way a deep aberration that since 1912 and the establishment of our diplomatic relations, there had never been a President of the Republic to come not just to visit but to walk together. It was time. This official visit therefore has something of a repair, if I may express it that way, in any case of a deep re-engagement and a reinvention of our relations.

But I do not want to look too much at the past but rather at the future, and the delegation accompanying me testifies to the will that is ours. First, to assume what binds us very deeply, which is our cultural, intellectual, and linguistic history. You are the living example of this, Mr. Prime Minister. We saw it yesterday, and I was very happy and very proud to be able to present the insignia of Grand Officer in the Order of the Legion of Honor to Ismail KADARE. We were able to have magnificent moments of culture with Angelin PRELJOCAJ and Tedi PAPAVRAMI during the dinner you offered us, with several musicians also in the foreground. All of this marks, testifies to, and translates the strong relationship that exists between our cultures. The agreement that was signed on cinema today is an important step in building a Franco-Albanian and fully European imagination, and working together. This is also the meaning of the KubFrance project to which we will go - and thank you for reserving this prime spot for us in the pyramid - and of Villa 31 supported by the Art Explora foundation, where we will also go shortly, which is a true audacity on your part and a willingness we have to move forward with you.

I hope that we can continue this path by investing even more in the French language, by better supporting our Alliances Françaises and our network, and we will move forward together for the French high school in Korça, count on me.

What we wish to do is also to explore new territories, at least in areas where we have been insufficiently present. The minister came a few weeks ago with an important delegation from MEDEF, and as you recalled, we are signing several structuring and new agreements in the field of energy, renewables, photovoltaics - Voltalia is a step forward. Infrastructure, the water sector, agriculture, innovation, logistics, and airport retail, we will also sign there shortly, allow us to continue to advance, to explore. And I wish that we are by your side in the ambition you have for tourism - and having a leading French group in this regard by our side is important today - and that we can not only help you open leading establishments but also train even more, and we have long discussed the fact that France will commit alongside you to train young Albanians in the professions of hospitality, catering, but also all those who would be interested in future professions in your country. This is also why we have this desire to open a School 42 for digital professions. So training in all these sectors is also a project on which we want to advance.

Then we have just seen it, with the French Development Agency, we will support Albania in its economic reforms, its energy and environmental transitions: 210 million euros of financing have already been committed since 2019 for the implementation of four projects, and more than 650 million euros will be committed by 2027 for reforms, new projects on your priorities.

So we can see that the bilateral agenda is transforming, and our will is indeed to prepare in the coming weeks a government-to-government agreement that will structure this relationship and allow us to go much further. And I am also pleased with what we have been able to build together over the past few years in terms of cooperation on issues of combating crime and all trafficking - I want to sincerely thank you for being remarkably effective in this area - which has allowed us to build not just an agreement in 2018, but to implement it and make it an example that has since been replicated in several other European countries.

We will therefore continue to advance with this dynamic because I am convinced, as you know, your country is anchored in Europe, not just in this region where there have been several attempts to confine you, while you have your uniqueness, that of the Western Balkans, but also in our Mediterranean and thus at the heart of our continent. So beyond the bilateral agenda, being with you today is also to acknowledge an important moment in this historical time that our Europe is experiencing. And it is experiencing it somewhat gropingly in recent years, but we are entering a new era, that of the reunification of our continent. About twenty years ago, several countries joined the European Union, and you marked an important milestone in 2022 with the first intergovernmental conference. It is a step on which you have worked hard, which has precisely marked this now inexorable path of Albania towards the European Union. And I want to salute here the agenda of reforms, transformation, and ambition that you carry. You said it yourself, you are a country and a people who loved and wanted Europe. I think that is the essence of this time of reunification.

This reunification is not a process imposed from Brussels or other capitals that would come to give lessons in reform to sovereign peoples. If we approach it this way, it will mean nothing and will build resentment. But we are at a moment where we must both give you and the entire region historical visibility: yes, your future is fully in this Europe. The respect we owe to a sovereign people: yes, it is you who choose the path, who assume it, who lead it; and yes, we mark this path with a political investment. This is what we wanted with the European Political Community: a meeting among peers that is not a kind of conference held once a year where the Western Balkan states come to Brussels as if going to Canossa, explaining all the reforms that have been made, being lectured by a few others because it is terrible; but rather a meeting among peers where respectfully, we talk about the issues we have in common: defense, migration issues, energy, geopolitics.

I say this from France, this European reunification is good for us. Because who can speak of a Europe of power if we leave countries in the middle of Europe to be influenced, shaken by powers that simply want to dismantle Europe? Who can speak of a Europe of power if we decide that our energy, migration, defense, or technology issues would follow the map of a political institution that is not finished? Just look at it. If Europe wants to think of itself as a power, wants to have a geopolitical destiny, it needs to reunify.

And in this regard, I say this here also with much humility and ambition: it is not a gift made to Albania, to its people, that of the process that has begun; it is good for you, it is good for us. It is a geopolitical choice and a common will. Because you have the intelligence and the will to carry this ambition, to courageously lead the reforms, and I do not underestimate what that means in a country that has lived for so many decades under the yoke of totalitarianism and ideology. But there is here a love for human dignity, for the founding principles of our Europe that are its very essence. So this path, you will lead it; and our duty is to accompany it with respect, but also with proofs of love. That is to say, concrete investments, that is to say, a commitment and the possibility of giving you a full political place. The European Political Community is a first step, but I hope that in the coming months, we Europeans will find the path of reunification that allows us to make this movement totally inexorable and powerful. The risk, otherwise, in the entire region, is that these processes that never end will end up discouraging the most pro-European public opinions by giving unclear objectives, which become too bureaucratic, and a horizon that keeps receding. That is not what I want, and that is why I have always been sincere about this mechanism, and I want it to be more political than technical, I want it to be more loving than bureaucratic. Because that is the life of peoples. We live in times of passion where if faced with the blows of current events, we end up with a Europe of such a chapter after such a chapter that is opened, we build nothing.

So I want our Europe to be the means for your country to continue to advance on the path of culture and emancipation, to continue to advance on the path of energy transition, to continue to advance on the path of fully sovereign military equipment, to continue to advance on the path of technological independence. And it is together that we will do this.

So you have understood, I am among you today convinced that the era that is opening, in which you have an eminent role to play, Mr. Prime Minister, is that of this reunification of our Europe, which will require knowing how to resolve several tensions that exist in the region, those that we know between Belgrade and Pristina, those that must lead us to resolve all the disputes that concern us but on which there is a path, a will. We have shown it with, for the subject I mentioned, the Franco-German roadmap laid out in recent months and on which we will continue to advance.

In any case, I want to thank you for your welcome, your friendship, but more than that. For what I feel, I fully measure here by being among you, for the strength of the European dream. To quote an author who is not Ismail KADARE, whom I quoted a lot last night and who is from another part of this Europe at a time separated, Milan KUNDERA, who left us just a few months ago, you are part of this kidnapped West, of a country that has always looked to Europe, that has always thought of itself as European and Mediterranean and that the vicissitudes of history have several times robbed of itself. A bit like in the myth of Europe, to try to take it to another shore, that of the Ottoman Empire, then that of a totalitarian ideology that evolves to be less and less European and less and less in accordance, by the way, with this identity of Europe, by denying the dignity of women and men and the sovereignty of the people. It is all of this that you have restored by yourselves over the past few decades. It is all of this that makes you resolutely, terribly European.

Thank you.

Journalist

Mr. President, you have been able to watch the video of Mia SHEM, broadcast by Hamas. Her mother has just pleaded with world leaders to have her released. What was your reaction and can you tell us if there have been any advances for the release of hostages?

Secondly, several of your counterparts including Joe BIDEN and Olaf SCHOLZ are visiting Israel and the region these days. Do you plan to go there as well, particularly to the summit organized by Egypt on Saturday?

And finally, do you think it is possible to eliminate Hamas without causing a bloodbath among civilians and igniting conflict in the region? And if so, how?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much.

Listen, yes, like you, like all of us, I have watched this video and I want to express here, of course, to Mia SHEM's family our support, our affection, and to all the families who have children or loved ones missing. The minister had the opportunity to meet with the families during her visit on Sunday. France has fully mobilized to do everything possible to secure their release. We have contacts, first with the Israeli authorities, and we also have contacts through several friendly intermediary powers with Hamas to obtain the release of our hostages and the release of all hostages. France has always condemned these practices with the utmost firmness. But taking civilian hostages, as well as military ones, and taking hostages of all nationalities and using blackmail during this period is absolutely heinous and unacceptable. Therefore, we are indeed putting in place everything within our power to achieve this release. I want to be very cautious here. You will understand that I will not say more in order not to create expectations that could be disappointed, and, above all, to avoid jeopardizing the intense discussions we are currently conducting. But they are progressing. We are monitoring these discussions hour by hour.

I want to say to Mia SCHEM's family and to all families that we are doing absolutely everything in our power to secure her release, as well as that of the other hostages. I had the opportunity, in the first hours, to exchange with Prime Minister NETANYAHU, with the President of the Palestinian Authority, with President HERZOG, and with all the leaders in the region. And I have done so several times over the past ten days. I was able to first express our solidarity with Israel and the Israeli people in the face of the terrorist attack they suffered. And to express all our support for Israel to defend itself. And then, in recent days, I have also been able to send alert messages calling for respect for humanitarian law, international law, and for the civilian populations in Gaza, in the West Bank, and for the non-escalation of the conflict in Lebanon. And we remain extremely vigilant and committed.

I will travel to the region. I have asked the Minister of Foreign Affairs to do so. She has done so through a regional tour. For my part, I will go to the region as soon as I consider that we have a useful agenda and very concrete actions to carry out there. I will continue consultations and discussions, but my intention is to be able to travel there when we can achieve a concrete agreement, either on non-escalation or on humanitarian issues and more broadly on everything. And I have said that for France, the security of Israel, the fight against all terrorist groups, but also the peace process and the political solution are an inseparable whole. And it is this agenda that we need to recover. And I think that this extremely difficult moment for the Israeli people today, for the Palestinian civilians, and for the entire region shows that those who may have believed that, fundamentally, the issue had become merely economic and security-related have overlooked the fact that it is also political and that it cannot be resolved without re-engaging ambitiously in the peace process. This is what we are working on, and it is on this basis that I will travel to the region, perhaps in the coming days, perhaps in the coming weeks. It is a criterion of utility and effectiveness that I will retain.

Next, I support Israel's desire to defend itself, to fight against all terrorist groups. It is legitimate. I believe that this must be articulated. It is the honor and duty of a democracy, which is the uniqueness of Israel in the region. This must always be compatible with respect for international law, humanitarian law, and in particular respect for civilians and populations. And we have always made sure to distinguish Hamas, which is a terrorist group, from the Palestinian authorities, and even more so, from the Palestinian people.

Journalist

President MACRON, France, under your leadership, has been one of the countries that hindered the enlargement to the Western Balkans. Now, as you have changed your approach, can you say when Albania will become a member of the European Union, taking into account the latest regional and international developments?

Emmanuel MACRON

Well, that is absolutely true. In 2018, the Prime Minister was there. I was the one preventing things from moving forward. But because we were going in circles and it was leading nowhere.

There was a process that was underway. The meeting had taken place, we can say, in a certain indifference and total hypocrisy. There was a kind of bureaucratic review of the enlargement processes, and we were telling those who had been there for a long time: "this will take a long time," "you are at such and such chapter of the book." The horizon was impossible, and we were telling your country and others: "next time, I promise you, you will see, it will be great, keep going, move forward..." and we were saying nothing.

So yes, at that moment, I said: this process is not working. First, it needs to be much more political, which led to the reform of the process. We have not yet drawn all the consequences from it; they are starting to be drawn with what is being put in place and precisely this new growth plan for the region, which was to say, fundamentally, it should not be a bureaucratic process where we open chapters and articles. No one is happy to open a negotiation chapter because it changes nothing in the lives of Albanians. But we will say: we are opening a phase of transformation for our country, and at that moment, there must be a commitment and an investment from Europeans, which we were not doing. So we repoliticized the process, there is a real reform, and we must draw all the consequences so that it is tangible.

It is also in this spirit that I proposed two years ago to create the European Political Community to say: we must meet as peers: this is the mechanism of respect. So I wanted to put an end, in a way, to a mechanism that I found cold, hypocritical, and ineffective because I saw it feeding resentment among several of your neighbors.

You have neighboring countries, I think of Serbia, for whom I have a lot of respect, which has been engaged for years in a process that is progressing too slowly. And you can see that the accession to Europe is actually declining in these countries. So first, repoliticize it, secondly, say: "we, Europeans, must accompany these reforms with real investment," which we are going to do now, concretely.

On top of that, it was to say: we who are in the European Union, we must make reforms because it is not true that we can indefinitely expand with our current modes of operation, since this Europe does not always function optimally. Here too, we must be lucid. We must do it for ourselves, and it is a very good trigger. That is the spirit in which, if you will, I wanted to engage these transformations: we have improved things.

Have we reached the end? Not at all. We still have a lot to do for this new era of reunification that is opening up. It is for me one of the immense challenges for our Europe in the coming months, and we will have to do it by shaking up habits a bit and saying: we must allow countries that wish to move faster. We must allow for greater investment.

We should not wait for countries to be in Europe to put a lot of money into them so that they converge; on the contrary, we must anchor them geopolitically in our Europe by investing when they are on this path and maintain this attachment to the European idea.

You have it in your country at extraordinary levels, which very few countries that have been in the European Union for decades have, it must be maintained. And then we, at the same time, need to have the trigger and move. The date does not make sense. I tell you very sincerely. First, because if you have a democratic accident in your country, if suddenly you have leaders who come in and say: "I will no longer make any reforms, we have committed to a date." No. It goes with a commitment from the country.

You have a Prime Minister who is committed to a European agenda, who is there. As long as he is there, yes, as long as he maintains his reforms, yes. And then, it is based on merit, as your Prime Minister told you.

Is it the case that the day a country moves faster, makes more transformations, it should be slowed down by such a regional crisis or another? Not necessarily. So the rigid date is somewhat contrary to that spirit. So perhaps we will have a geopolitical moment, a crisis, a kind of tipping point that will play out given the war on our soil and others; I do not exclude that, but the trigger will be more of an external geopolitical trigger than a date that we set as a deadline.

I would like to emphasize one point, if you allow me, in concluding this response. Do not underestimate the importance of the path itself. It is fundamental because you do it for yourself. And there are two things in the functioning of our Europe that are very important to grasp, I say this in relation to the words of the Prime Minister, at the moment you sit around the table, and I consider that it is already the case in the European Political Community, there are no longer grandparents and grandchildren. There are only egos. That is the genius of this Europe. It is that Europe has always lost itself in civil wars because it was a story of hegemony. It was said: there is one or two who will decide or one alone. France has contributed to this adventure of hegemony throughout its history.

In the European Union, there is no hegemony. Every voice counts. So afterwards, we can decide to vote by qualified majority, so we can make alliances. But everyone is respected among peers.

It is true that if we do not have the same culture, this sense of responsibility, it can block things, but no one can say: "I am the one who knows because I have a different history than you or I am a bigger country." And that is wonderful because it is the key to our new balance for the past 70 years.

The second thing is that Europe is a chosen transfer of sovereignty. Every word has its meaning. We decide to put things together, we sometimes decide sovereignly by putting it to a referendum of our peoples, or by asking our parliaments to choose it, but we transfer competencies. This means that we relinquish by our own choice to do things that we used to do ourselves. It is a very difficult choice and it must be made consciously. In countries that have experienced totalitarianism, in countries that have sometimes lived under the yoke of foreign powers or under dictation, when it comes too quickly, it is used by nationalisms to fuel the anti-European idea.

When I hear today, sometimes in Budapest or elsewhere, people telling us: this Europe is like Moscow: never in my life! You chose it, Brussels, you voted for it, you wanted it, it pays you. But you chose it sovereignly. It creates confusion in people's minds because the transfer of sovereignty, when one has lived for a long time without having full sovereignty and without exercising it democratically, can create a disturbance. This path is important because everyone must also be aware that the European adventure, we decide to put things together and therefore to transfer sovereignty. I believe that it makes us greater. It is totally compatible with national sovereignty and it creates a greater sovereignty that is European, but it must be well digested.

It is a path that is not good to take too quickly if it is not stated truthfully and if it is not shared with the peoples. I apologize for this long response, but I wanted to provide this insight.

Journalist

Hello, Mr. President. Three days after the assassination of a teacher in Arras, two Swedes were killed last night in Brussels in a terrorist attack. First thing, do you fear a wave of attacks in Europe? After the strengthening of borders, are you considering other measures to protect the French? Furthermore, you recently asked to comb through the files of radicalized individuals who can be expelled; does that mean there have been failures until now? And finally, will this be sufficient, and in the face of these threats, is there not, in fact, a form of powerlessness of the State today? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Listen, unfortunately, we saw it again yesterday in Brussels, all European states are vulnerable, and there is indeed a return of this Islamist terrorism, and we all have a vulnerability, it is the one that goes with democracies: states of law where individuals, at a certain moment, can decide to commit the worst.

I want to reiterate our solidarity with our Belgian friends here, and I will be very cautious about what has happened and about the qualification of terrorism. But we immediately took, in coordination with the Belgian authorities obviously, and as we do every time, follow-up measures. As you know, we have an exemplary security and judicial cooperation with Belgium, which has been further strengthened since 2015 and the attacks we suffered, which involved groups that had cross-border organizations. And I remind you, France, since 2015, has had border control that we have never ceased, which is allowed by the Schengen regulation, and that the security situation, we have always believed, has led us to maintain.

Furthermore, I also remind you, since the attacks we have been suffering for over 10 years, we have put in place a legal and technical apparatus that has first allowed us — I remind you because it is often forgotten — but since 2017 to exit the state of emergency.

And fundamentally, we have collectively built, and I believe this is a strength of France, a model that allows us to be as secure as possible outside of a state of emergency. Because we cannot live with a permanent state of emergency, which implies a suspension of certain freedoms for everyone even as the threat persists.

We have massively reinvested in our security, in our internal and external security services. We have implemented follow-up measures for individuals who are considered the most dangerous, which are the maximum we can do under the control of the constitutional judge, with several of the follow-up measures that have sometimes been censored, on which we have returned, including after prison detentions.

We have reinvested in intelligence services, including penitentiary ones. We have established national coordination, we have reinvested in our police, gendarmerie, etc. etc. And we have, also during the first term that I served, massively invested in monitoring the most dangerous profiles and in their expulsion. So on this, I have not seen any failure of our services and the Ministry of the Interior and all stakeholders during the attack that was carried out in Arras.

The great difficulty we have is the cooperation of countries to return these nationals and, in this case, the terrorist who has been imprisoned, the investigation is ongoing so I will not detail, comes from a country that is at war and with which all returns had been suspended during the period when it was established by the CNDA that he was not eligible for asylum. The list that was given yesterday by the Minister of the Interior, these are always problems of cooperation from countries for the return, not a problem of monitoring by the services and ourselves. And you will agree with me that when a country does not allow you to return one of its nationals to their home, it is quite difficult to… So there you go, we put as many as possible in incarceration when we have motivations that allow us to do so in accordance with what a rule of law can do. So we are simply reinforcing control, pressure on those in this context.

I want to say here that France has equipped itself in recent years with a solid legal system, that it has massively reinvested, and that we will continue to do so. Simply, we need in this period better cooperation from the countries of origin of several of these dangerous individuals, and that is what we will increase our work on.

Now, I want to say here with the greatest sense of responsibility that it will never be possible in a rule of law to have a system where the terrorist risk is completely eradicated. That is why we must live in a society of vigilance, permanent vigilance from those who have to exercise it. That is why, as there is today an increase in risk - I mentioned it when I spoke to our compatriots last Thursday - because minds are heating up, because we see the most active using the international context to push individuals to the worst, we must use everything we have put in place and in a way increase pressure in the system. So reinforced vigilance from all state services, from our security forces, from our police, from our magistrates, from all those who contribute with a lot of professionalism; vigilance also in all sectors of activity, and I think this is very important, the economic sector, all those who receive the public have a role to play to be even more vigilant in these periods; and vigilance from citizens to capture weak signals and help identify advanced signals and help us react to threats when they may arise. That is how we can hold together. Otherwise, it is a suspension of rights and that is, I believe, not what we want because it is the challenge that is ours: to live in strong rule of law states at a time when terrorism, in the name of the worst ideologies, is returning. And it would be an extreme defeat to consider that the response would be the suspension of the rule of law.

[…]

Journalist

I have a question for President Emmanuel MACRON: What is your attitude, what is your consideration regarding the attitude of Serbian President VUCIC concerning the tensions occurring in Northern Kosovo, and especially regarding what happened on September 24?

Emmanuel MACRON

As you know, we are closely monitoring the tension that exists between Pristina and Belgrade. France and Germany have made a proposal for a roadmap that I believe is solid and good, and what we expect is that it be respected by both parties. I think it is the responsibility of President VUCIC to condemn with the utmost firmness the acts of September 24, to contribute to restoring calm at the border, and then, the next steps and what we expect from the Kosovar and Serbian authorities is simple: the reorganization of elections in the municipalities where they were held under inappropriate conditions, the participation of Serbs in these elections and in the institutions, the recognition of the association of Serbian municipalities by the Kosovar authorities in that order completely and totally. And I expect a sense of responsibility from President VUCIC. I expect the same from the President and the Prime Minister of Kosovo, and I say this with great clarity: we have made a gesture of trust regarding the visa issue, it is suspended for France based on the respect of the word given and the word today is not being kept. And so, I expect a re-engagement from both of these authorities to move forward in the coming weeks. This is the very condition for peace in the entire region.