Press conference of the President of the Republic and President Zelensky.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

16 February 2024 · Press conference of the President of the Republic and President Zelensky · Paris, France

Context
Macron addressed a joint press conference in Paris on February 16, 2024, following the signing of a bilateral security agreement with Ukrainian President Zelensky.
Main themes
France-Ukraine bilateral security agreement, support for Ukraine against Russian aggression, Russia's strategic failures, international law and sovereignty, European security, NATO enlargement, death of Alexei Navalny, Russian imperialism and destabilization, liberal democracy defense, G7 collective commitment to Ukraine
Duration
~26 min
78th percentile
Words
3,171
78th percentile
Sentences
163
83rd percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
41st percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

163 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Mr. President, dear Volodymyr,

Ministers,

Ambassadors,

Ladies and gentlemen, in your great qualities.

I am very happy, dear Volodymyr, to welcome you again today in Paris. This is the third time since the beginning of the conflict and the Russian aggression against your country. It has been many times, because I do not forget your first visit to these places. You were then a candidate in the second round in Ukraine, and it was the first time we met. In welcoming you today, it is through you that we want to first express our admiration and especially our determination to continue supporting Ukraine over the long term. This determination is as strong as on the first day, and I want to tell you here that our commitment to your side will not waver. This is also the meaning of the bilateral security agreement that we have just signed. It concretizes a commitment we made with all the G7 countries at the NATO summit in Vilnius last July. It not only enshrines our support over the long term but also in a collective approach and logic, since the United Kingdom and Germany have already concluded a comparable agreement and that, in the long run, all the other G7 countries and 25 other countries will do the same. As we are about to enter the third year of this war that only Russia wanted in a few days, I do not forget, dear Volodymyr, our exchanges in the early hours of that fateful day of February 24, 2022.

I want to think of all Ukrainians, for all those whom the war has torn from their homes, from their families, for those who are fighting on the front in Avdiivka in particular and elsewhere. Ukrainians today are fighting not only for their freedom but for European security, for the strength of liberal democracies, and for the defense of international law.

Dear Volodymyr, we are determined to stand by your side to thwart Russia's war of aggression. The courage of Ukrainian resistance, the surge of unity that your just struggle has inspired has already led to a series of strategic defeats for Russia. Two years ago, Russia explained to us that it was conducting a special operation that would conclude in a few weeks. It has been reduced to emptying its prisons to replace the colossal losses it is suffering on the front. We were told that Russia had a certain future. Many young Russians have preferred freedom to war and find themselves in Belgrade, Tbilisi, Istanbul, or Paris. Russia has lost its talents. It prefers to finance a useless, unjust, and cruel war rather than provide basic services for its own population or subsidize the price of eggs for low wages. Russia had returned since the 1990s to various international formats. It has lost that place and its credibility on the international stage. It has lost it because it is no longer invited. It has lost it because Ukraine will join the European Union and I hope also NATO. It has lost strategically, it, for whom access to the seas is so decisive. By pushing Finland and Sweden to join NATO and, in doing so, making the Baltic Sea a sea where the Allies have a predominant place today, it has lost strategically finally, because it puts free spirits in the Gulag, condemning them to death, like Mr. Navalny, whose memory and commitment I salute. I think tonight of his wife, his family. He who refutes the decline of courage against which Solzhenitsyn rightly warned us. Yes, the death of Mr. Navalny speaks to the weakness of the Kremlin and the fear of any opponent. Facts are stubborn, but they must always be recalled. There is an aggressed, Ukraine, and an aggressor, Russia.

And if this aggression primarily targets Ukraine, it has many other victims: the Order and international law, the stability of the world, the entire planet due to the imbalances that this aggression has created, particularly in terms of food. Russia, despite its setbacks, has embarked on a headlong rush over the past two years, and particularly in recent months, has accumulated and hardened all aggressive postures, not just against Ukraine, but against all of us. Today, a new phase is opening. Vladimir PUTIN's Russia has become a methodical actor in the destabilization of the world, which does not hesitate to threaten its environment, but also, more directly, our interests. Russia has become an imperialist power that denies the sovereignty of Ukraine, its right and ability to make its choices, to choose its alliances, in short, to exist. And fundamentally, what Russia seeks is an order based on force. What Ukraine defends and we, with it, is respect for the fundamental principles of international law. Russia has increasingly become a revisionist power in recent years. The statements made recently show that this appetite to rewrite history knows no bounds. It is not only the countries it has recently invaded, like Ukraine or Georgia, that have reasons to be concerned.

Russia is currently building, I should rather say the Kremlin regime, because I do not want to engage an entire people here, but simply a few decision-makers who have decided precisely to change, for the worse, the fate of their own nation. The Kremlin regime is currently building a fantasized narrative to challenge the borders inherited from the Soviet Union by renouncing its own word and its own commitments, notably those made in Alma-Ata in 1991, which is a threat to Europe, the Caucasus, and Central Asia. It must know that the world is watching it, that everyone has the right to ask what new truncated and fabricated piece of history it will invoke to pursue its agenda, which new country will be its prey, which other country, tomorrow, will be tempted to imitate it.

Russia has also, in recent years, accumulated interference in elections. I do not forget that I myself, during the 2016-2017 electoral campaign, suffered very direct attacks from Russia. I had the opportunity to explain this during our first meeting with Vladimir PUTIN. In recent months, everywhere in Europe, these disinformation maneuvers, manipulation of information, and cyber attacks have deeply multiplied, systematized, and intensified. Russia has indeed crossed several thresholds in this regard, towards European democracies in recent weeks and months. This is what led us, with Germany and Poland, to reveal and attribute several of these attacks, and we will continue to do so. This change in posture clearly marks a will to aggression towards us.

Finally, Russia has also multiplied zones of confrontation and destabilization in Africa as well as in the Near and Middle East. There is not even the space where serious questions do not arise; I remain cautious here, but the concerns expressed by some in recent days about the possible deployment by Russia of nuclear weapons in space only add to this picture. If these facts were confirmed, they would be so grave, so illegal, so destabilizing for the world and concerning for citizens that Russia must provide explanations without delay. International institutions must clearly take this up.

All this clearly shows that if in recent years, Russia on several of these points had a form of continuity - imperialism, revision of history, destabilization of our democracies - the intensification of these aggressions, the change in nature, and the thresholds crossed mean that it is time today to say: this change in posture of Russia demands a collective awakening.

A clear message from Europe, that we will not let this happen, but also very clearly, a signal from the international community. Because these aggressions affect the entire stability of the planet and concern all countries that have eminent diplomatic responsibilities.

Let things be clear, France is not at war either against Russia or against the Russian people. France has indeed done everything to prevent the war in Ukraine. But we are determined to thwart Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine and all the aggressions that Russia could commit. If Russia thinks it can weaken our determination, betting on this or that election or on our weariness, then it is mistaken.

Before you, dear Volodymyr, I want to reiterate that France will continue to support Ukraine over the long term. This is the meaning - I said it at the beginning of my remarks - of the agreement we have concluded for a duration of 10 years, which will remain valid as long as Ukraine has not joined NATO.

Under this agreement, France has committed to providing up to 3 billion euros in additional military aid for Ukraine in 2024, after 1.7 billion euros in 2022 and 2.1 billion euros in 2023. This aid aims to continue providing Ukraine with the means to defend its sovereignty and territorial integrity over the long term. France also commits to continuing the support it provides to Ukraine on all fronts: provision of military equipment, cooperation between defense industries with the development of co-productions, training, intelligence, civilian aid, etc. By helping our Ukrainian partners to defend themselves, we are investing in the security of Europe, strengthening the industrial, technological, and defense base of Europe.

All this already represents a lot, but we are determined to do even more, including shaking up habits, the comfort of certain certainties. I particularly wish that France and the European Union continue to adapt to the new context that is ours. This will require a resolute effort of rearmament in terms of doctrines and means. This is a new test for the European Union.

But the outcome of Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine will be decisive for our interests, our values, our security, and our model of society. From the Versailles summit in March 2022, convened under the French presidency of the European Union, we demonstrated our ability, together, to change paradigms. Helping Ukraine defend its sovereignty goes hand in hand with our own sovereignty and our strategic autonomy. And our endurance, our determination will be tested again, but we will find the energy and resources to continue transforming ourselves.

This is also why I want to reiterate my support for the proposal of the Estonian Prime Minister, Kaja KALLAS, to issue the necessary funding over the long term for our support to Ukraine and to mobilize our European industrial base. Yes, Europe must invest more, on an even larger scale, and over the long term.

This is what I wanted to say today, Mr. President, dear Volodymyr, our determined support until the end, our willingness to stand by your side, and the conviction that, not only in doing so, we defend Ukraine, but we also defend what binds us on the same continent in service of the same values. You will find France by your side today as well as tomorrow, and I want to thank you once again for being in Paris today with our support for today, tomorrow, and as long as necessary. Thank you.

Journalist

Good evening. The question is addressed to both presidents.

We had a very fruitful day for Ukraine: earlier, a similar agreement was signed with Germany. I am interested to know what the difference is between the agreement signed in Germany and today in France and the agreement signed in Great Britain. What is special that France has proposed to Ukraine that does not exist in the agreements with other partners, except for the Caesar guns, of course?

Emmanuel MACRON

In a word, I fully agree with what the president said. First, these agreements and those that will come, as I said earlier, complement each other. It is in this complementarity that there is utility for Ukraine. Then, these agreements, we wanted them at the Vilnius summit to say: there is now a path to NATO, but we cannot leave a void, so these agreements aim to provide visibility on military engagement with figures, but also behind that, the details of capabilities. And you mentioned it, whether it is cannons, shells, missiles, training, other actions across the entire spectrum that are useful to the needs expressed by Ukraine and its armies. And finally, it is mainly that we have learned from history. Ukraine, in the past, had agreements, but they were too vague, they were somewhat insufficiently binding for the states. Here, we are committing to agreements that are concrete, and that is what I want you to remember. That is to say, it is not a principle agreement like what may have existed in the past which, as we have seen, in 2014 first, then in 2022, did not have any effects. Here, these are agreements where we commit to specific means, to figures, and which provide real guarantees to the Ukrainian army to be able to conduct its defense and the reconquest of these conquered territories.

I would like to return to the death of the opposition figure Alexei Navalny and ask both of you what message you see in it for Europe, for the West? Is it a sign that Vladimir PUTIN feels all-powerful, and do you believe he is responsible for his death? And following on from this question, Mr. MACRON, more and more European leaders are expressing concern about a possible Russian offensive tomorrow, the day after tomorrow, beyond Ukraine. What is your analysis? Is a war with Russia possible?

Emmanuel MACRON

The sudden death of Alexei Navalny, which we learned about today, has shaken us all; I mentioned it earlier in my remarks, and it tragically reminds us of the reality of the Kremlin regime and its hardening. It imprisons; this is not new. In recent months, it has further hardened its stance towards opponents, but also towards associations, NGOs, and foundations. I think of Memorial, for example, which, throughout these last years, even in the most difficult times, had always been able to operate and which now finds itself in a very dangerous situation.

But I want, at this moment, to once again extend my condolences to the family and loved ones of Alexei Navalny. I think that said, what I expressed to you earlier is that yes, Russia has entered a new phase. And we must be clear-eyed about this issue. A phase of aggression towards European countries through disinformation actions but also cyberattacks, on a scale and with threshold crossings that change its nature, and a hardening within its own country, just weeks before an electoral deadline where, fundamentally, a form of impunity has settled in. They kill an opponent; they do it. They ban other candidates; they do it. I see this as a revealing factor.

Of course, we are asking Russia to shed full light on the circumstances of this tragedy. In any case, this tragic event will only strengthen our mobilization regarding the fate of political prisoners. And I also think of all those who today still face risks. I am particularly thinking of Vladimir KARA-MURZA, whose health has already deteriorated following two poisoning attempts in 2015 and 2017, and has continued to decline since his incarceration in April 2023, due to lack of medical care, and so many other opponents imprisoned for their convictions and their courage. I also think, I mentioned the NGO Memorial, of Mr. Oleg ORLOV, who faces three years in prison for denouncing the crimes of the Russian regime in its war of aggression in Ukraine. Very clearly, the conditions surrounding the presidential campaign, notably the very low number of candidates authorized to run, only confirm the degradation that has been underway for years and the change in nature that I mentioned. In this context, indeed, several European leaders have expressed the possibility of a Russian aggression against them. I will not use words here that aim to alarm or feed scenarios. That has never been my approach. But I will be clear with you. The Kremlin regime attacked Ukraine, a European country, two years ago. The Kremlin regime has intensified and hardened its aggressions against our country in terms of disinformation and cyber. And these are forms of conflict. And so, very clearly, there is a need for a European awakening but more broadly from our allies, our partners, and the international community. This is the very essence of my remarks. If we see things happening, if we see a new phase opening, we must have the clarity to open a new phase of strategic and operational reflection. This is what France desires.

Journalist

Hello. You announced your visit to Ukraine in February. When can we expect you in our country?

Emmanuel MACRON

I will be there before mid-March in your country alongside the President and the Ukrainian people. So you can expect me in the coming weeks for sure.

Journalist

Good evening. We see these bilateral security agreements signed in Germany, in France of course, by the United Kingdom as well a few weeks ago, multiplying, with new arms deliveries. I just wanted to know, Mr. ZELENSKY, and this is also a question for Mr. MACRON. Are the Europeans not going to have to do even more in the coming months, especially if the blockage persists in the American Congress regarding American military aid?

Are you expecting even more from France, from Germany? Would France and Germany, particularly France, be ready to do so, and also, in the event of a victory for Mr. TRUMP in the American presidential elections by the end of the year?

Emmanuel MACRON

Regarding your question, as far as we are concerned, through these various agreements, we are providing visibility on our bilateral military aid, in addition obviously to everything that is being done in terms of civil, humanitarian, and economic support, and in addition to everything that has been done. It is a way to provide visibility, regardless of everything, if I may say so.

These bilateral agreements are complemented at the European level by the agreement we reached at the last summit, the 50 billion euros in grants and loans that we secured at the European level, which also provide visibility and support. And I said, we are putting and we must put ourselves in a position to adapt this effort to the needs in terms of intensity and timing.

Today, we can only be pleased with the American posture, and I hope that Congress will unblock the additional funds, but the American posture since the beginning of the war has been alongside Ukraine and alongside its European allies. But this war is taking place on European soil, and therefore Europeans must also be able to carry the efforts so that the objective we have, which is that Russia cannot win in any case, is achieved. And so, we will adapt to all scenarios because the future of Europe cannot be contingent on the American election. This is my vision of sovereignty and strategic autonomy. These are not just words; they are actions. These are the actions we are taking.

Very well. I believe that this question concludes our press conference. Thank you very much, ladies and gentlemen.