Speech by the President of the Republic.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

30 March 2023

Context
Macron addressed elected officials and regional representatives in southern France on March 30, 2023, to present France's national water management plan amid worsening drought conditions.
Main themes
Water management policy, climate change and drought, water quantity and scarcity, French water governance, IPCC projections and scientific modeling, agricultural impacts, groundwater and aquifer management, environmental challenges, water quality and pollution, basin management, local and regional stakeholders
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,199
92nd percentile
Sentences
243
93rd percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
38th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 52%51%
  • Economic 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

243 sentences in 56 paragraphs

Mr. Mayor, thank you for welcoming us and for those very strong words; you have reanchored us, if I may say so, in a history and geography that give full meaning to what we have been discussing for some time now.

Ladies and gentlemen, members of Parliament,

Mr. President of the Regional Council,

Mr. President of the Departmental Council,

Ladies and gentlemen, Presidents of Departmental Councils, because many elected officials from this beautiful region are indeed here, but the Savoyards are here too, along with several others,

Ladies and gentlemen, Presidents,

Ladies and gentlemen, in your ranks and capacities,

I am very happy to see you again and to have the chance to be among you. So, talking about water is to talk, as you have perfectly said, in a region that has always lacked it, about subjects that have made up a good part of the literature of the 20th century, particularly in French literature or in this region. Pagnol, like Giono, to make a nod to a neighboring department, Madam President, speaks only of battles over water at that time in this beautiful region. But our country has invented a true water policy, of management, of sharing, and an unprecedented model. You are all, in fact, the custodians of this. It is a strength, and what we will collectively do is still to rely on this strength.

This policy that our country has created is an innovative water policy dating back to the 1960s, with basin management that brings together, from the source to the ocean, all water stakeholders — elected officials, farmers, industrialists, energy producers — who have been able to build major projects. I say this because sometimes, when we look at our current situation, we forget, and you have perfectly reminded us, what we have been able to achieve in the past; otherwise, we would have faced real tragedies in every respect. And Lake Serre-Ponçon, which is not just a hydroelectric dam, but indeed a water management project from the peaks of the Alps to the valleys of Provence, is the realization of this great policy.

This French water management policy has been particularly well-suited to address all our major environmental challenges regarding water that arose at the time, particularly the issue of quality, the fight against pollution, which was at the heart of the battle. Then came major water laws: 1992, the Water Framework Directive in Europe in 2000, the 2004 law that transposed it, and with each time the development, I would say, of a French model. It is there. So we are not starting from scratch, and with the involvement, as I said, of the local basin actors, the municipality, and the stakeholders who have the uses.

The challenge we face is that, fundamentally, much of what has been thought out and structured was about fighting pollution and ensuring quality, but we had less pressure on quantity. The observation has rigorously changed. The minister has provided the figures, and that is what you are relying on. We have a renewable water resource that has significantly decreased: -14% in metropolitan France already, when comparing the period 1990-2001 with the period 2002-2018. Droughts are becoming increasingly frequent. This climate disruption leads to the effects that the minister has perfectly described, so I will not dwell on the situation that has changed.

When we look at all the scenarios, those provided by the IPCC and all the experts who then elaborate on them, we see that scientific models tell us we will have -10 to -40% of river flow, -15 to -25% decrease in summer rainfall, -10 to -25% decrease in groundwater levels, and with soils that will be drier and thus have lower humidity and a capacity to absorb these precipitation that will be profoundly different. With this climate change, and even if it sometimes rains more in winter, our aquifers, which are truly the strategic water stocks, will take longer to fill and will fill less. And so, to prepare for all scenarios, we are integrating the latest IPCC work into our scientific models, and all these results will be available during the year.

But I will be clear right away without being definitive in detail: none of them tell us that the situation will improve. So, last year — the minister also mentioned this — we had an exceptional drought compared to what we knew, but it will not be exceptional compared to what we will experience. And so, it simply indicates to us, perhaps more quickly than we thought, that the changes are indeed here with these 2,000 municipalities that faced supply difficulties; about half of them resorted to temporary solutions for drinking water supply — bottles, tankers; 93 departments, as has been said, were under water restrictions and faced very difficult consequences for many of our farmers in many of these territories; a grass growth deficit of 24%, take the figures, which caused much suffering for many operators and breeders as a result; a corn production that is the lowest since 1990; a yield of spring cereal crops down by 28.4% in 2022. The figures are there to show the difficulty. And at the beginning of this year, we had another worrying record with 32 days without rain, and our country is in an unprecedented episode of winter drought.

The consequence is that today, 80% of our aquifers are at low or very low levels, whereas we were, before the drought of 2022, at a level of 50%. So, the challenge is there, it has accelerated further, and we must respond to it.

First, we must prepare for next summer. This is the first element on which I would like to outline some key points. As early as September, we drew lessons, launched work, as the minister recalled, building on what had been done five years ago: the first Water Assizes, the second Assizes, and the Varenne, with already some initial actions and reinvestments thanks to your involvement, all of you. Initial orders have been issued by the prefects. We have about fifteen departments, including the Hautes-Alpes, that are already on alert, with communication and information tools directed at individuals and professionals to encourage everyone to save water.

We then have about ten departments that are already on alert or heightened alert in certain areas. I clearly distinguish these two phases. And in this ten departments that are on heightened alert, there are restrictions in place for farmers, watering, etc.

But to succeed in preparing for this summer, which looks difficult, we must all go much further. And so, we will set up by early May an instrument like we did with Ecowatt for energy, a Water Ecowatt that will be established by the ministry, shared with all stakeholders, which will allow everyone to take responsibility. Because when drought is looming and difficulties are present, every action counts. You have said it very well; it is exactly the same — the president of the regional council recalled it — as what we did for energy. And so, in each territory, depending on the available water resources, the prefects have set rules for sharing and proper use of water. And as we did during the winter for energy, we will have this tool available from the beginning of summer so that every French citizen, every farmer, every mayor, every business leader can know the appropriate actions in a very transparent manner and the evolution of the situation to see that everyone contributes to part of the solution.

Next, the second short-term element, as we have also done for energy, we will ask each sector for a water sobriety plan by summer. The ministers will meet in the coming days across all relevant sectors: energy, industry, tourism, leisure, agriculture. It works well when everyone knows the evolution of the situation, when everyone is held accountable, and when we know that efforts are shared, so that is how we will proceed. Local authorities, of course, will be mobilized, as will the state administration and state buildings, and I thank the region for committing to this dynamic.

They will be equipped with water-saving devices that can reduce consumption by 30% on their own and with rainwater recovery mechanisms whenever possible, in order to water green spaces with rainwater rather than drinking water. Because we have situations that continue to be incomprehensible for many of our fellow citizens, also due to the rules we historically set and that need to be evolved.

Alongside this, obviously, we know there will be difficulties, and I want to be very clear: not all crises will be avoided this summer because we have very challenging situations in certain municipalities. In the summer of 2022, we have the issue of these 2,000 municipalities that the minister and I just spoke about. We have 200 that were supplied with bottled water, 340 with tankers. We have already initiated work to secure these municipalities because for many of them, it was due to historical under-investments or significant connectivity difficulties due to topography and indeed their own geography.

After the summer drought, we have already mobilized 100 million euros in addition to what has been done, which has allowed for the urgent financing of 500 projects. And so, this is what has been done since the summer of 2022 and will be completed before next summer. But we know very well that due to the specificity of certain territories, the isolation of some municipalities, it cannot be ruled out that we will have situations of great stress again next summer, despite this emergency plan and our consumption reduction and thus sobriety.

To support the most vulnerable territories, this is the third point I wanted to emphasize, in the short term, we will mobilize, in addition to all these investments, 180 million euros to prioritize treatment in these 2,000 fragile municipalities, those in the most critical situations, as well as what we have called the 170 black spots identified across the territory, that is to say, all areas where leaks are very significant. This is the case in your municipality, Mr. Mayor. You have indeed initiated, with these co-financing, works. The municipalities that lose more than 50% of the water do so due to aging infrastructure and the difficulty of the locations. And we can see that this is also an absurd situation that we must urgently correct.

And so, we will work with all the mayors who have water management responsibilities to do everything possible before summer and accelerate these works, with these additional 180 million euros that will also allow us to respond to the urgency. But beyond this urgency, the heart of the plan — and the minister will detail it tomorrow — is the result of your collective work, of all those who are indeed engaged in the basin committees, of Jean LAUNAY and all those who are the daily actors. This water plan, therefore, with its fifty measures, is above all a plan for sobriety and efficiency for water in the long term.

I think of setting a course for our Nation with a goal for 2030, which is to achieve a 10% reduction in water use across all sectors. This is an unprecedented modernization of our water policy. It is to integrate the relationship to quantity and the changes linked to climate disruption to fully incorporate into this ecological planning the issue of climate change.

There are five axes that I would simply like to illustrate here: accelerate sobriety everywhere and in the long term, combat leaks and modernize our networks, invest massively in the reuse of wastewater and the mobilization of new resources, plan water uses based on the future availability of resources, and support the transformations of our agricultural model, as you mentioned, Mr. President, and implement an appropriate water pricing everywhere.

So first, making water savings in all sectors and in the long term is the goal we must set because climate change will deprive us of 30 to 40% of the available water in our country by 2050. We must therefore embed sobriety in the long term. So this concerns all sectors, and some are particularly mobilized.

The first sector is electricity production. It accounts for 51% of withdrawals, 12% of consumption with nuclear and hydroelectric power. And so, on this, I have asked, under the supervision of the Prime Minister, and the ministers have begun work with the major players, to change practices there too, and so we will invest. To be sober, it is about innovation.

On nuclear energy, we must adapt our nuclear power plants to climate change by launching a vast investment program to save water and enable them to operate much more in a closed circuit. A major difficulty... Today, our plants use water and discharge it, and therefore it does not have an immediate effect on the level. It affects the temperature and conditions, and given the conditions that the minister just mentioned, it impacts the level over time and at certain moments and periods of the year. And when we have the pressures we know, it is a real challenge. So we will launch this investment plan to transition our plants to a closed circuit.

Next, we have hydropower, as we must adapt the rhythm of our dams to the challenges of climate. You know this perfectly well here; in our largest artificial lake in France, water has multiple uses. You reminded us of this, Mr. President, just now. You all mentioned it. Therefore, our intention is, through a cooperative territorial dialogue, which you have initiated over the past few weeks with these questionnaires, to define in each territory the rules most suited to the different uses and the sharing of this common good that is water.

The second major sector after energy is industry. The ministers of Ecological Transition and Industry will organize a meeting of the 50 industrial sites with the greatest potential for reducing water consumption to work with them on an investment plan for these water savings. We want to continue to reindustrialize the country; it is one of our victories in recent years. We must continue to create industrial jobs, but these industrial sectors must be increasingly decarbonized and frugal in their use of our water. For this, there are also investments. From battery production to hydrogen production, which are activities that need, as we know, significant amounts of water to produce green goods, we will integrate water efficiency and reduction compared to current consumption into investment strategies.

The second major axis is the fight against leaks and the modernization of our networks. In many territories, we have water networks that experience very significant leaks. On a national scale, we lose 1 liter out of 5 due to leaks. 1 liter out of 5, which is unacceptable. In some territories, we lose 1 liter out of 2. This is the goal, as I mentioned, of the mobilization of 180 million euros that are already confirmed, which will be reaffirmed each year to address our notorious black spots and allow us to make progress. All of this was very well identified during the second Water Assizes.

And beyond this funding for our black spots, which is the priority, we will also mobilize the Bank of Territories and the Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations to launch a major plan for our infrastructures. Because all of this is the result of what? Of historical under-investments. And why do we find ourselves collectively in this situation? It is because for a very long time, we got used to not investing in our water networks and not really paying the true price of water—if we are honest with each other—collectively, at the territorial level. Some have adapted faster than others, but that is the reality.

And so, this is what we must gradually change and modernize our networks. Modernizing them also means doing so in a way that is appropriate with smart meters. We can only save what we consume well, and therefore I wish for us to work with local authorities to generalize smart meters, starting, of course, with the largest water users. The region has embarked on this work, and I thank them for it, but this will allow us to organize efficiency as close to the ground as possible and thus also combat leaks and modernize our networks.

In this plan, I want to say a special word for our overseas territories, which have a particularly difficult situation. I think of Guadeloupe and Mayotte, where we launched massive reinvestment plans four years ago. We will therefore unlock an additional 35 million euros per year for water in overseas territories because there we have an increased need to accelerate work on the networks.

The third axis is to invest massively in the reuse of wastewater, and more generally in all uses. Before moving on to wastewater, rainwater, as you mentioned, Mr. President, I commend the effort you are undertaking to enable our individuals and economic actors to better collect rainwater. I wish that in this context, the Government could work in connection with the mechanisms of the regions to help and support individuals in equipping themselves to better collect rainwater. The reuse of treated wastewater allows for very significant water savings. You mentioned the case of Israel, but there is also the case of Spain, from which we must draw inspiration because we can do much better and much more strongly.

I will give you just one example: today, in France, less than 1% of wastewater is treated for reuse. This is 10, 15, or 20 times less than some of the best comparables in the world. Our ambition now, it is reasonable given what others know how to do, is to increase from 1% of treated wastewater to 10% by 2030. For this, we have decided to launch 1,000 projects over five years to recycle and reuse water. We have the capacity to do it; we have industrial actors who know how to do it deployed across the territory. We have French innovation; we have women and men in our territory who know how to do this. We must now build these projects and trigger them through these funding mechanisms.

To facilitate the development of projects, we must also—this has been mentioned by one of you—facilitate and accelerate administrative procedures and remove some barriers, which should not be excluded from being administrative as well. Ultimately, we want to reuse 300 million cubic meters, or three Olympic swimming pools per municipality, to give an example, or 3,500 bottles of water per French person per year, which is no small feat and is feasible and will also create economic activities.

The fourth axis is to plan water uses and the transformations of our agricultural model. Water, as we know, is essential to our agriculture, which is profoundly weakened by climate change. The water plan is therefore organized in this regard around three pillars. First, all new agricultural installations will be adapted to the climate of tomorrow. A water, soil, and adaptation diagnosis will be integrated into installation aid. I made this commitment in front of the Young Farmers at the Terres de Jim, at the launch of consultations on the renewal of agricultural generations. And so this means that when we build for the agricultural future law, we will support each young person who is starting out with such a diagnosis to adapt production choices and the organization of new infrastructures to this diagnosis.

The second element concerns irrigation. We will continue to provide aid to save water. We will also transition to drip systems where possible and necessary, using smart systems. 30 million euros will be dedicated to investing with farmers in these models, which also involves all the work that has been largely started and is at the heart of the adaptation plans for sectors and territories. I want each territory to openly ask itself this question. It is not a neutral question; it is not simple, but I tell you frankly, we must ask ourselves today.

Are today's sectors still adapted to the climate of tomorrow? I can already tell you, I believe in our agriculture; I have shown for six years that we are fighting for it and making progress, and I believe in our food sovereignty. But it is evident that we will have territories that will need to shift towards other cultivation schemes and other agricultural models; that we have agricultural productions that we know in certain territories that will likely migrate to other territories that do not practice them today, and that we will need to reinvent agricultural models in other territories of our Republic.

This is obvious because soils are changing, because the climate system is changing, and therefore we must adapt our cultivation methods. If we do not anticipate this, we will suffer the consequences, and we will put our food sovereignty at risk because this means that we will have territories that will no longer have the capacity to produce and that will not have prepared for their change, and others that could have taken over these crops will not do so. It is always very daunting to think, if I may say so, of such transformations, but we must do it to support them.

The third axis of this change in the agricultural model is to evolve the logic of water storage. The priority is to maximize the capacity of our main water storage tool, which is our soils. Healthier soils with more trees, more hedges that store water better and promote the recharge of aquifers. This is the most coherent choice wherever possible.

Next, it is to use existing structures and improve infiltration into our aquifers to facilitate access to water. In this regard, I wish for a fund for agricultural hydraulics to provide access to all solutions and accelerate projects. And then, concerning new structures, because there are places where new structures may sometimes be necessary due to territorial particularities, the framework must be very clear, and I want to remind you of this here. It is not about privatizing water or allowing some to appropriate it. The rule is indeed sharing among different uses, between farmers, with the new generations of farmers who will settle, and sometimes with other uses that may be tourism-related or for the residents of the municipality.

Therefore, new reservoirs must first be included in concerted territorial projects, obviously with local authorities, and based on scientific projections. Local authorities can play a greater role in taking charge of certain projects. For example, planning for a water reserve available for farmers who wish to settle. Secondly, having multiple uses. For example, clearly providing services to biodiversity. Rivers and wetlands, for instance, can also be places for both electricity production, with solar panels placed on the water. There are, as we know, innovations underway that will be integrated into this strategy. And thirdly, these reservoirs must be conditioned to significant and individualized changes in practices, particularly water savings, the reduction of pesticides, and therefore agricultural transition schemes, which are being implemented by several of your colleagues.

Recent news has mentioned certain reservoirs. It is exactly in this logic that farmers across the basin have committed. I want to say this here. We must be clear: water is essential for agriculture. It is therefore essential for our food sovereignty. And we will have more irrigated areas in the coming years; this is evident. Therefore, we must, where we had an agricultural model that concentrated heavily on a very small part of our useful agricultural areas, irrigation. We must do everything to reduce this irrigation through better practices and innovation, adapting crops. But we will extend our useful agricultural areas that need irrigation, obviously, but with solutions that must be innovative because overall, we must not extract more.

Our food sovereignty is non-negotiable, and the water plan establishes a simple principle: we must do more irrigation with the same amount of water that we use today. This means innovation, sharing, better organization, and supporting our farmers when they have practices that are beneficial to water quality. That is why we will also mobilize an additional 100 million euros per year to finance these virtuous practices to protect water quality. To meet these ambitions, we will obviously provide the necessary resources.

The economy of water, I speak, under the control of Mr. Minister, is about 20 billion euros per year. It is, if I may say, triggered by about 2 billion 200 million euros of public money. We know that we need to accelerate and do more today. And so, what we have decided to do is, essentially, to increase the budget of our water agencies, which is just over 2 billion. It is 2 billion 200 million, to increase it by 500 million euros per year. This is the effort we need to trigger a total of about 6 billion more in the water economy each year, with the same multiplier coefficient that I just mentioned. And so, it is a real effort from the Nation, both on the sobriety of uses, the renovation of networks, the reuse of wastewater, and water quality. And so, in total, 500 million euros additional that we will mobilize each year through the water agencies to implement these ambitions. The spending cap of the water agencies will be removed, which will also allow them to co-finance with local authorities all actions to adapt to the consequences of climate change.

Finally, to support all this, this is my fifth point. We need to establish a pricing system that I would qualify as progressive and responsible for water. Water is a common good. And so, we need a pricing system that is progressive for that. The objective of the plan must be to guarantee all French people access to quality drinking water for their essential needs. Since 2017, we have launched experiments on this water pricing, and we wish, in consultation with elected officials, for this progressive and responsible water pricing to be generalized in France. This does not mean that the price of water will increase.

In fact, it is currently average when we look at the price of water in France, but with a simple logic that we wish to rethink. The first cubic meters are billed at a modest price, close to the cost price. This is the evolution we are heading towards. It is this progressive pricing for everyone. It corresponds to the water we all need for drinking, washing, and practicing daily domestic uses. Then, beyond a certain level, the price per cubic meter will be higher, and that is normal for what I would call comfort consumption and to encourage sobriety. This falls under a certain common sense that I am discussing, but it is not entirely the rule on which we base pricing today. And so, this progressive and responsible pricing is what will allow us to acknowledge that water is a common good and to organize an incentive for sobriety that we all need.

Finally, to conclude, I will say a word about governance. In our country, water is a largely decentralized competence. It is a choice that I consider wise, closest to the territories, their geography, the consumers as well, closest to biodiversity and its challenges. Elected officials are on the front line, and the spirit of the plan is to strengthen their role. The minister will detail all these measures with you because, as you have understood, with climate change, water has become a strategic issue for the entire Nation.

And so, if I am here before you, it is because we must essentially enrich our historical model, which has been a strength. Through this new logic, this plan for sobriety and investment at the national level. But we must maintain this territorialization. Elected officials on the front line, basin committees in responsibility, water agencies in traction. This is the testimony of the trust, by the way, that I just mentioned, which is this raising of the spending cap of the water agencies and this release of a joint investment from the State and local authorities.

Our real problem in many cases is the isolated municipalities that are sometimes at risk. And so, we need to be very flexible and calming on this issue, to work together. Sometimes the model of intercommunal cooperation is the right choice in our decision. We need to mutualize differently, and so I hope we can move forward. I heard the elected officials in Nanterre. And so, the minister will carry out a transparency exercise by putting together the map of all these troubled points and the most critical solutions. I hope we can consolidate wherever it is accepted, the model of intercommunal cooperation and then find the right solutions for mutualization. New possible syndicate, chosen intercommunal cooperation. But in any case, an acceleration of this investment with a plural, differentiated model, based on the intelligence of local elected officials and the diversity of the territory. This is how we will move forward effectively, and I hope we can strengthen this French model of water and this planning that we need in the face of climate change.

I will not be longer. I wanted to thank you, Mr. Mayor. I wanted to thank you and through you, thank your residents and perhaps also the elders because we are in a municipality that has shifted by a few dozen meters. But I do not underestimate what many have experienced in their daily lives, in their flesh, in their landscapes, in their intimacy. They did it for the common good. And it reminds us that there is no collective solution that exists for a country if we do not first have a shared strategy in the face of change. There are always constraints, but we must explain them, share them, try to plan them, hold everyone accountable, but also recognize everyone's effort.

Here, 62 years ago, there were women and men who accepted the effort of sometimes moving the farm or the house they had had for generations to allow us today to have water, to live, to have projects. The efforts we ask of each person today are not the same. Generations have changed, but we will all have efforts to make, small intelligent efforts. But to allow our children again to choose, and I say this responsibly, whatever the subject.

Those who explain to the Nation that nothing should change to live well are like those who would have decided, 62 years ago here, not to move anything. We would probably not be here to talk about it. The land would be dry, there would probably be no project, nor would there be any downstream. We are a Nation that knows that it is through collective intelligence and the sense of effort, sometimes for the generations to come, because it is not always for us, that we build great things. And so, thank you for this lesson given by the inhabitants of your municipality, and thank you all.

Thank you, Mr. Mayor.