Speech by the President of the Republic in Le Creusot on the future of nuclear energy.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

8 December 2020 · Speech on the future of nuclear energy · Le Creusot, France

Context
Macron addressed workers, executives, and officials at Framatome in Le Creusot on December 8, 2020, to outline France's long-term nuclear energy strategy.
Main themes
Future of nuclear energy, decarbonization and ecological ambition, French industrial sovereignty, nuclear sector workforce and revival, energy transition, CO2 emissions and climate, Hinkley Point contract, industrial reconversion, pandemic context and economic anxiety, CEA and EDF leadership
Duration
~28 min
79th percentile
Words
3,320
79th percentile
Sentences
137
77th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
12.9
56th percentile
Syntax
3.18
70th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
43rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 37%36%
  • Environmental 25%24%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Geopolitical 12%12%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

137 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, Minister,

Members of Parliament,

Madam President of the Regional Council,

Mr. President of the Departmental Council,

Mr. Mayor, my General,

Admirals, General Officers,

Mr. General Administrator of the CEA,

Mr. Chairman and CEO of EDF,

Business leaders,

Mr. Prefect,

Dear friends, employees of Framatome and partner companies, dear friends,

I am very happy to be with you today in Le Creusot. Very happy to be in this beautiful industrial region that we care so much about. And before I begin and dive into the subject, I would like to express my friendly and committed thoughts for your colleagues and companions in Belfort. We talked about it with Madam President of the Regional Council because some are experiencing the anxieties that we have known here in other professions, and I want to tell them that the State, the government, represented by the minister and the various industrial sectors, are with them, and we will continue, along with the elected officials of the territory, to fight for this other great industrial territory to have the future it deserves. But today I am happy to be with you in Le Creusot, Mr. Mayor, we remembered it, first because four and a half years ago I was here among you, Mr. Deputy remembers it too, and the period was rather one of anxiety.

The controversies were numerous about the difficulties in the sector, restructurings were underway, and doubts loomed. And I believe, I am even sure that I told you at the time that either we manage to secure a major contract on the other side of the Channel, or there would surely be layoffs. We secured the major contract on the other side of the Channel, and it is part of your daily life; it is Hinkley Point. You fought hard, and I really want to commend you, Mr. Bernard FONTANA, for your commitment at the head of this company, commend the commitment of your group, of the entire group, of all the work that has been done by EDF, Jean-Bernard LÉVY remembers it to take over, restructure with Philippe KNOCHE and a few others who were there at the time, and to truly revive the sector.

And this result and the situation we are in today, where you were able to give me the figures, the 1,000 days without an accident, the hiring that has resumed, here and in the rest of the group, is the fruit of a collective commitment, but it is first and foremost the fruit of your work here in Le Creusot and everywhere in the group. And for that, I want to congratulate you. We believed in it, we secured the contracts, but you worked hard to ensure that the appointment was there. And I am also happy to be in Le Creusot, as you told me, Mr. Mayor, upon arrival, dear David Marti, because 33 years ago to the day, François MITTERRAND, as President of the Republic, right here in your city, announced major industrial conversion projects at a time when questions were also being raised about the industrial future of the country. He chose Le Creusot; he was already talking about the long term of the great industrial sectors and made some commitments, the fruits of which, by the way, were only visible for some 15 to 20 years later. So, it is no coincidence that we are here together today because we believe in this new French future.

And in this period where doubt looms, where the anxiety related to the pandemic is present, where the constraints are multiple, and you experience them in your daily work as well as in your home, where obviously the short term can sometimes become our obsession, we also need to look far, to look at the horizon, to build the future of the country, to offer this French future to all our fellow citizens. This French future involves a decarbonized industrial ambition, the reconciliation of our ecological and industrial ambitions, our ability to rearticulate the sovereignty of our industry and the necessity of meeting our environmental requirements. The ministers present here with me know this and carry it out daily, and it is possible. And in this context, the nuclear sector plays an essential role. And through you, workers, engineers, researchers, leaders who forge it daily in large public groups, state administrations, industrial groups, SMEs, and ETIs that weave through all our territories with all their employees.

This future of the nuclear sector, for me, rests fundamentally on three lines of force, three convictions. The first is that our energy and ecological future passes through nuclear power. I am aware, of course, that many of our fellow citizens think that nuclear power pollutes the air and emits greenhouse gases. The image of smoke coming from the reactor is hard to shake.

However, and you know it here better than anywhere else, it is quite the opposite. Nuclear energy is the non-intermittent energy that emits the least CO2. The IPCC confirms it, the European Commission highlights it. Several European countries, such as Finland, Poland, the Czech Republic, or the Netherlands, have committed to this path by studying the realization of new nuclear reactors to achieve their climate goals, not to mention our British friends, who have decided to leave the European Union but nonetheless chose it, giving us a lot of work. Yes, nuclear energy, when it comes to producing non-intermittent electricity while respecting and protecting the climate, is relevant, provided that we make progress on waste management and safety. And I know you are fully mobilized on that front as well.

Nuclear energy is a decarbonized energy, a safe energy. We have begun, through structuring research projects, with the commitment of all the actors in the sector, to continue this work, to improve safety each time. France is, I believe I can say, without a doubt, one of the countries with the highest safety standards in nuclear matters in the world. We are continuing to make progress in waste management, both in France and abroad, with major projects at stake. And we will continue to advance on the essential research, particularly on all issues related to closing the cycle. And so, while I have never been a proponent of total nuclear energy, because it is necessary not to depend on a single source, I believe and have always maintained that if we need to rebalance our energy mix by reducing the share of nuclear energy, the atom must continue to be a pillar of it for the decades to come.

We have committed to reducing the share of nuclear energy in the production of the energy mix, particularly electrical, since the laws enacted under François HOLLANDE's mandate, then updated in 2018. But this ambition must not go without a renewed ambition, and we held an Ecological Defense Council this morning on this subject, to complement our nuclear ambition with the production of absolutely essential renewable energies, regardless of the scenarios, which must increase significantly. Because France today is not meeting its commitments or ambitions. Developing renewable energies, onshore and offshore wind, solar, hydropower, biomass, geothermal energy, and several others, and we are doing so ardently in compliance with the multiannual energy programming that we published in April 2020.

In this regard, we have removed a large number of obstacles and barriers since 2017 to accelerate the deployment of projects and develop these low-carbon electricity sources. We will continue to do so by validating, as we did this morning, pathways for wind energy and continuing to document all scenarios. France must also meet this ambition because our entire renewable sector, I say this here with great emphasis, is an industrial sector, upstream and it will be downstream, it is a sector on which we have begun to regain production sovereignty. And we must continue to do so there as well. But renouncing nuclear energy entirely or too quickly would be to open, as other countries have done, coal or gas power plants, or to import carbon-intensive energy. And we have refused to do that.

We made the choice of nuclear energy in 1973 to gain energy independence, and contrary to some voices I have heard recently, France has not done everything wrong in its past. It has also been able to build robust strengths on which it must rely for its future.

This is also true of the model of the French army that we believe in and which we reaffirmed through an ambitious law at the beginning of the five-year term. And it is the same for the nuclear ambition that is ours, which has allowed us to significantly reduce our dependence on international sources and, as I said, to reduce CO2 emissions from electricity production. While it is very difficult to say today which will be the best technology between nuclear and renewable energies to replace our existing nuclear fleet by 2035, we must therefore look at all the possibilities. No one today, honestly, can say how in 2040-2050 the technological changes ahead of us will allow us to build the best electrical mix. We must therefore prepare our country responsibly by pursuing several paths.

That is why the multiannual energy programming provides that the government conducts a comprehensive work program with the nuclear sector to study all these options without any taboos. We need to first study the technical feasibility of an electrical mix with a very high level of renewable energies. A report commissioned from the International Energy Agency and RTE will be published at the beginning of next year. We conducted a transitional review this morning in the Ecological Defense Council, which will specify all the conditions for implementation to achieve this by 2050. At the same time, we need to ensure the conditions for a decision on the potential launch of a program for the construction of new reactors and on the EPR2. This study work on the construction of new reactors is essential, and I want it to continue and be completed in the coming months so that all the necessary elements are available before the end of the five-year term. Then, based on this documented work that will be shared with all the French people, we will be able to choose with full knowledge of the facts, choose in perfect transparency. As I indicated, the final decision on the construction of new reactors must be prepared and made no later than 2023, when Flamanville 3 is put into service. Our environmental future therefore passes through nuclear energy with scenarios that we will need to refine together in the coming months, but with investments and studies already launched, as I just mentioned.

The second conviction, the second line of force is that our economic and industrial future also passes through nuclear energy. 3,000 companies, 220,000 jobs, including 10,000 in this region, 5,000 recruitments planned in 2021, despite the difficulties that everyone knows. Few sectors offer as many prospects, particularly for our youth. You recalled the figures for several of you that I questioned earlier; the entire sector is meeting these commitments, particularly regarding the recruitment of young people. A presence, particularly through the network of subcontractors in all regions of France, also strengthens the economic power of this sector. Few sectors are thus anchored everywhere in the territory. With also know-how that is exported all over the world and a trade surplus of 7 billion euros. Few sectors are thus at the forefront among global leaders, with this capacity to export our know-how as well as our productions.

This major asset, which has been shaped over the long term of decades, we must consolidate. That is why, within the framework of France Relance, we have chosen, with the Government and the ministers present here, to invest nearly 500 million euros in the nuclear sector. First with an investment fund endowed with 100 million euros that will be set up as early as 2021 to help consolidations and support strategic players. The sector needs it for the most fragile actors, to help with regrouping, to provide visibility. It is essential. It will be complemented by a modernization fund for industrial companies in the sector, endowed with 70 million euros, also allowing for modernization and gaining competitiveness across all our sites and helping, in doing so, the relocation process that was presented earlier by several of you.

Finally, the investments from France Relance will also support the French SMR project. These small nuclear reactors full of promise will be brought to fruition. We have developed several projects, and EDF, along with the entire sector, is carrying them out with great courage and commitment. We know all the difficulties we have faced with the EPR. We understand the necessity to continue, as I mentioned, the studies and to already commit ourselves to this segment that is full of promise. With a budget of 50 million euros, the recovery plan invests over two years in the realization of a preliminary project and thus engages France in the global competition for SMRs. We must quickly catch up on the delay, also consider all possible partnership options, and position ourselves in this segment.

Through this ambition, we will also train those who will carry our excellence high tomorrow by creating several training and excellence centers, particularly in welding in Bourgogne Franche-Comté, and by establishing a university for nuclear trades. This is also an organization that allows us to go further in terms of learning, in terms of training, including throughout life, to enhance skills, improve quality, and continue to attract our youth, and I say this here with great strength.

It is important that the young people who are graduating today are sometimes in retraining. They need to hear clearly the message that the nuclear sector is hiring, that it is hiring workers, technicians, engineers, researchers, that we need this youth, and that we are also giving ourselves the means to continue training them in our territories under the best conditions. When I say that nuclear also forms part of our economic and ecological ambition, I want to emphasize how essential the nuclear sector is to the development of the hydrogen ambition that is being promoted by the Government. Today, as we are developing it, no European country can produce hydrogen with a decarbonized electricity mix as we can do thanks to nuclear power. All those producing green hydrogen today in Europe are doing so by massively sourcing renewable energy from abroad, conducting operations to produce hydrogen abroad, thus incurring massive transport and logistics costs to re-import the hydrogen produced back onto European soil.

We have an economic and environmental asset through nuclear power. It is that we can produce this decarbonized blue hydrogen thanks to the electricity produced on our soil. Finally, our strategic future, our status as a great power, depends on you, on the nuclear sector, deterrence, submarines, our aircraft carrier, everything that makes France an independent power, listening, respecting, relies on you, on your know-how, on what you design and produce in a factory like that of Creusot. We saw it again earlier in the parts machined here.

From this point of view, and you know it perfectly well here, opposing civil nuclear and military nuclear in terms of production, as well as in terms of research, makes no sense for a country like ours. The sector thrives on its complementarities, and it must indeed be thought of in its complementarities. And that is also why we must constantly think in the long term, the ability to preserve our technical, technological, and industrial skills across the entire sector to protect our sovereign production capabilities, both civil and military. One does not go without the other. Without civil nuclear, there is no military nuclear; without military nuclear, there is no civil nuclear. Factories like yours that produce for both power plants and naval vessels, organizations like the Atomic Energy Commission and Alternative Energies are living proof of this.

In this regard, bolstered by the work carried out since the beginning of the five-year term, the strategic review of the military programming law, the work conducted by the Minister of the Armed Forces, the Chief of the Defence Staff, the General Directorate for Armaments, and the CEA. I came to Creusot to give you perspectives.

Nuclear will remain the cornerstone of our strategic autonomy. It is of course deterrence in all its components, it is the propulsion of our nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines as well as attack submarines. It is also the nuclear propulsion of our aircraft carriers. The Charles DE GAULLE, as you know, will reach the end of its life in 2038. That is why I have decided that the future aircraft carrier that will equip our country and our navy will, like the Charles DE GAULLE, be nuclear-powered.

Your factory in Creusot, which has long produced essential parts for our navy, will produce among others several major components of the nuclear reactor for the future aircraft carrier by forging and machining them right here. This is a source of pride for your factory, your city, your region, and, I must say, for the entire nuclear community.

Through these choices, we confirm France's commitment to preserving its strategic autonomy, its deep conviction that we can continue to invest in industry while having a strong ecological ambition and continue to combine our civil industrial ambition with our military nuclear ambition.

Ladies and gentlemen, this factory in Creusot is a concentration of the qualities of French nuclear power. Dear André, Mr. Minister, you know how much, having always defended it, it is a centuries-old tradition here, as you reminded us, Mr. Fontana, just now, over 200 years of industrial history and a foundry that has preceded us here. But it is also a story of fears, doubts, and each time, courage to overcome them. Because there is this industrial history here.

The spirit of the place, in a way. The strength of the soul of the inhabitants, and there are know-how and skills. That is to say, what passes from generation to generation, what is written in books, learned, improved each time, but what is passed from hand to hand, from skill to skill, through these ancestral know-hows that we have never ceased to improve. And in this land of history, you also carry that pride which is ours, that French know-how in nuclear and industrial matters. We hold on to that. Some have sometimes doubted it; it has been threatened, and we want to emerge from this crisis with even more energy, reinvesting because this is the place for women and men to continue building the future of our country, to continue producing, to continue having pride in the industrial tool, in this know-how, and to say that their children, in turn, will be able to build their future here because there is a future here, in the sector that is yours, in the profession that is yours, with the know-hows that are yours. Because we reinvent them every day, but because we believe in them.

So, four and a half years after these moments of doubt, I am extremely proud and happy to be able to tell you that thanks to you and the commitment of the entire French nuclear sector, the choices that are ours, and the investments of the nation, we can look to the future with strength. Always with rigor because there will surely be difficult tomorrows ahead, and nothing is guaranteed, but in any case with a certain taste for the future, the one we have managed to wrest from work, from the years accumulated, and today this capacity to invest and to believe in it. We will succeed together because you have done it, because you have held on, and because we believe in it. Thank you.

Long live the Republic and long live France!