SPEECH BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC ON THE OCCASION OF NEW YEAR'S WISHES TO HEALTH ACTORS.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

6 January 2023 · New Year's wishes to health actors

Context
Macron addressed healthcare professionals at the Sud Francilien Hospital Center on January 6, 2023, delivering New Year's wishes and outlining commitments to France's health system.
Main themes
Healthcare system reform, hospital resilience, cybersecurity attacks on hospitals, caregiver recognition and fatigue, post-Covid crisis management, public health solidarity, long-term health policy, New Year commitments to health workers
Duration
~85 min
98th percentile
Words
10,230
98th percentile
Sentences
430
98th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
9th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 71%71%
  • Economic 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

430 sentences in 72 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Gentlemen prefects,

Mr. President of the Departmental Council,

Gentlemen mayors,

Mr. President of the Supervisory Board of the Sud Francilien Hospital Center,

Madam Director General of the Île-de-France Regional Health Agency,

Mr. Director of the Sud Francilien Hospital Center,

Madam President,

Ladies and gentlemen healthcare professionals,

Ladies and gentlemen in your ranks and capacities, I say, it’s a generic formula, otherwise I could spend half an hour naming everyone and I would end up offending someone I might forget.

Listen, I wanted to thank you for your welcome and for the exchanges I have had with several of you since this morning, and indeed, I wanted to be in a hospital center such as our country is fortunate to have at the beginning of this year, to address you directly, who, throughout the year, care for our fellow citizens. Every day and especially during this holiday season, when the Nation has been able to count on your dedication and professionalism.

After two years of Covid, after a series of epidemics that have accumulated in recent weeks, you continue to hold strong, and your efforts inspire the Nation's esteem. And on its behalf, I wanted to thank you this morning. And I wish, at the beginning of this year, to extend my most sincere wishes to you, to your families, to your loved ones, and to try, if I may say so, through you, to have wishes for our hospital, our health, and to try to say a few words about the prospects that together we can build.

In addressing you today, of course, I want to pay tribute to the commitment and exceptional professionalism that is yours and that of your colleagues everywhere, but I also had to mention, because here as in some hospitals in France, we have suffered a serious cyber attack, and you have held on, if I may say so, because it is not always clear to everyone; but in this hospital, the system was completely damaged. I want to not only thank the IT teams, of course, all the logistical support that made it happen, but all the caregivers. Because I know that everywhere, you had to resume manual work; you continued, in addition to everything else and the epidemics, with even more constraints to ensure care. And so I wanted to thank you here, to tell you that we are aware, of course, of these attacks that are multiplying, that we have begun to reinvest in our information systems to resist cyber attacks and that we will continue the work. This comes in addition to everything else. We sometimes talk too little about it in public debate. But as you have experienced it, if I may say so in your daily life, I wanted to say it here and also tell you that we will move forward on this issue as well.

So, if it were needed, Covid has shown that health is not simply a public policy among others, but that it somehow enables all the others. And you are on a daily basis the visible trace of what holds a Nation together, of this solidarity and of what allows everything else to happen. And so, in presenting my wishes to you at the beginning of the year 2023, beyond the personal wishes I have just expressed, I know roughly what we all wish for: to be able to respond to the concerns of many of our fellow citizens, to be received, treated in a timely manner, with quality care.

Concerns they sometimes have for their children or for their parents. And the concern, the anxiety, the fatigue that also exist among all caregivers. I had the opportunity to see several before the holidays and we exchanged again this morning. But I know the personal and collective exhaustion, the feeling sometimes of a loss of meaning that has settled in and the feeling, at the bottom, of moving from one crisis to another, and as we had just come out of Covid, to face crises again and never to emerge, in a way, from this endless day of crisis, with the idea that there is no perspective. And so I wish us collectively to respond to it.

And fundamentally, for me, addressing you today is to try — the diagnosis, I will return to it very quickly because we know it — to build short-term actions but also long-term together, to give a new impetus at the beginning of this year for our entire health system, and particularly our hospital, and to do it with, if I may say so, a lot of determination, trying to push things, sometimes the walls, and to go faster and stronger, but also with a lot of humility because I know with you that things do not change overnight and that sometimes some of the projects we will launch will take time, that they will require checkpoints, that perhaps we will make mistakes in the implementation of certain ones and that we will need to revisit them and adjust them together. And so, what I want to tell you today is not simply wishes but also a commitment over time to stand by your side.

You know the diagnosis perfectly. Would I dare to say that, in a speech I gave in 2018 at the Élysée to announce “My Health 2022,” everything was more or less laid out. I say this because it’s a way of saying that we had seen things; it’s a rather cruel way of saying also that, if the diagnosis was correct, the treatment was evidently, independent of Covid, probably not sufficient. But it’s important to keep this in mind because, at the bottom, the crisis we are experiencing, I mentioned it with Mr. Mayor earlier, is not simply a crisis of resources, because in fact we have already responded a lot on resources. And I say this to all the caregivers you are, it is multifactorial. It is actually much more complex than if it were simply a problem of money. Because we made the largest financial effort in the history of our health system at the time of Covid and in the aftermath of Covid. It’s much more complex than that; it’s a problem of organization of our system. It’s also a problem of the evolution of our society. We all live in a society that is moving, that is evolving, where preferences are not the same. And so we must be clear-eyed about this observation if we want to provide the right answers.

But the observation, despite everything, is there. For decades, we have trained fewer and fewer caregivers and we thought we would save money on the system and that it would gain in innovation, in efficiency, by training less. So we trained fewer caregivers, we have fewer caregivers available, we have restricted their number, sometimes also part of the equipment. We have also transformed the organization — I say this for the hospital — and the volume of their work with the 35-hour workweek. And I think that the 35-hour workweek has profoundly disrupted the hospital, which is, moreover, the last place where we have not deeply reformed the organization of working time, as we have done elsewhere in almost all other systems, whether public or private. Because we also have a governance that has become heavier, which has rigidified many procedures, because we have a city-hospital division that has settled in, which comes from very far, which is cultural, but which is there with insufficient cooperation, even if there are counterexamples because there are people who have managed to shake up habits. We mentioned this earlier with the president of the CPTS here.

On top of all this, because it turns out that caregivers and incoming caregivers do not want to have the same life as their elders. I say this very directly but also because society has changed. And in a society where teleworking has developed, where choices of life, of organization of personal and professional life are there, we can no longer ask doctors, nurses, nursing assistants, health managers, manipulators, stretcher-bearers, stretcher-bearers, that is to say you. Your life does not change. You will work like your parents, your grandparents in terms of work rhythm; it doesn’t work. And when we say that people leave the profession to change it, it is also the result of that. We experience this in the hospital, as we experience it, by the way, in private practice, in city medicine, we know well, or when, whether it is the city doctor or the country doctor retires, the one who succeeds him does not want to have the same rhythm, and we do not replace one for one.

In parallel to this evolution that I describe at a gallop, it turns out that we are a country that is aging, which is a chance. We talked about it, there is the elderly and we are a country that is trying to better take into account children as well. And so, fundamentally, we have more and more chronic diseases, we have more and more vulnerabilities that we want to take care of. And where our system had been historically designed for more acute and sporadic pathologies, in a way, the need has been for, fundamentally, more and more complex chronic diseases that we want to take better care of.

You also have, particularly in your territory, very precarious populations that arrive or are directed to your hospital with even more complexity. And we can see that this situation is what makes it untenable and fundamentally, the hospital. And in the hospital, the services that are exposed to what we call nicely unscheduled care are at the heart of the problem, because that is where everything has exploded for several years now. And despite what we have started to do, I will return to it, Covid has somehow, as you told me very well earlier, doctor, revealed this divergence that has settled over several decades. There you have it, that is the observation.

So once I have said that, the big problem is that the answer is not simply more resources. I will return once again to what we have already done because we do not train doctors in one or two years. And everything I have just said, we will take a decade to change it, in reality, in depth. And we will live in the coming years, at least your servant in the role that is his for sure, in a situation that will rather deteriorate in terms of medical supply, because in addition we have the demographics of our doctors, and it turns out that many of them are reaching an age that is rather that of heading towards retirement. And so, there is no miracle recipe that will say: in one fell swoop, we will create a wonderful health offer to respond to what we have, to the mistakes of the past or to the poor planning and to this changing society.

Our collective challenge is, in the short term, to free up doctors' time with patients, caregivers' time with patients, and therefore to completely rethink our collective organization. In the city, in the hospital, to think about it cooperatively and I insist on this. By also learning from what we collectively did during the Covid period. And I say it — the professor who spoke to me earlier said it very well — there is one thing, a treasure we had during the Covid period that made us hold on, that we must not lose during this period, it is the cooperation among all. And the solution to build the future lies in the cooperation between administrative and healthcare staff, between paramedical caregivers and between the city and the hospital. All those who want to build solutions by pitting one against the other will waste our time and, in a way, make the system even more ineffective.

It is through cooperation and the encouragement of cooperation and the fact that we build a complete team that we will succeed. And so our short-term objective is really to free up caregivers' time with our fellow citizens to move towards a perspective, because I want to give them long-term resources, which is what? Which is to have a medicine that prevents better. For the first time, you have a Minister of Prevention and Health. And that is essential because everything we prevent is obviously what we avoid treating later. And it is a profitable investment for the Nation and profitable for collective health. We need to have a system that prevents better. What we have started collectively to do in recent years with vaccination, screening, and diagnostics.

But we need to go much further, much stronger - to have a medicine that will be individualized, personalized, and that will become more predictive thanks to innovation and organization. That is the objective. And by breaking down barriers much more, improving prevention, health, and medicine will allow us to limit unnecessary procedures much more and to reduce avoidable mortality thanks to both prevention and the better organization of a whole care chain, as early as possible, by competent personnel recognizing their competence up to acute crises. That is our collective perspective. But in the short term, we can only hold it if, of course, we manage to withstand the shocks we are currently experiencing because the situation may be even more serious today.

So, in light of this observation that has been made — and what I am saying is the objective that is ours — we have already acted collectively. I say this because I want to repeat the figures here. We have invested 19 billion euros in our healthcare system with the Ségur, particularly in hospitals, for very good reasons, because it is to the hospital that all difficulties flow back, which is still the case and what you are experiencing. In three years, the budget that our Nation allocates to health has increased by 50 billion euros. And this considerable catch-up, and I emphasize catch-up, was necessary, and many have told me, everyone recognizes what has been done with the Ségur in terms of remuneration. There is also a significant catch-up effect of what had not been done previously. I am aware of that. That is why I am not saying that this is a final settlement.

In the same way, we have put an end to the decline that had been occurring for years in hospital tariffs. I claim this decline; how is it? Stabilization began in 2018 after years of decline. To tell you, I did not wait for Covid to see that there was a problem in hospitals. And then, thanks to the Ségur, we have revalued the staff beyond the investment I mentioned, with increases that have changed lives in many places, from 180 to 400 euros per month. There has never been such an investment from the Nation.

Simply, we need to be clear. Where it changes the life of, for example, a nurse, a nursing assistant, or a doctor in a provincial hospital where the cost of living is not extreme, where there was already some stability, it is much less true in large cities or in a region like ours, here today, where the cost of living, transportation constraints, and housing costs are such that, in fact, even with 180 euros more per month, it does not allow you to buy a home near where you work or to compensate for the additional expenses you have. And so, we have a real problem of attractiveness. This is particularly true for hospitals, despite the Ségur in large cities or regions where the cost of living is higher than in others. There you go.

And then, we have ended the numerus clausus in recent years. For 20 years, as I said, we have not trained enough caregivers, and we have put an end to it because I want to remind you of the figures. In recent years, we have lost about 6,000 general practitioners. We are now just under 100,000 general practitioners today. The problem is that we will have about 80,000 general practitioners in 2025 if all those who are due to retire leave. And we have, according to the figures from the National Health Insurance Fund, almost half of the doctors today who are over 60 years old. That is why you have probably seen that in the latest financial texts, we have taken a measure that facilitates and encourages the combination of work and retirement because fortunately, not everyone retires at the so-called age, and we want to facilitate and somehow make the combination of work and retirement more attractive because we will need to keep as many doctors as possible who are willing to do so, who would be of retirement age, to make it very incentivizing. I just say this, but despite the opening of the numerus clausus, what we have done in recent years, we will not see the results in the next 5 to 8 years. So we will have to work together on a strategy and therefore reorganize, break down silos, and succeed in freeing up medical time.

So, in a way, that is both the observation I wanted to make. To reiterate what we have done, the perspective we must move towards. But today, we must go much faster, much stronger, make radical decisions, but collectively, also play on collective intelligence and the freedom given to the field. I want to thank all those who spoke to me this morning because in addition to the activity, there are many very concrete ideas already implemented and a willingness to find, in a way, responses on the ground. We need to give you the means and possibilities.

So, the first objective for me at the beginning of this year, for us, is to somehow gain medical time. I told you that we are not going to invent or create doctors en masse. We will all try to better organize ourselves to, in a way, allow for more medical time for our compatriots in hospitals as well as in the community. In this regard, we will accelerate the recruitment of medical assistants for doctors. We currently have nearly 4,000 medical assistants who have already signed a contract, which is one of the real successes. For once, I was critical of myself regarding the "My Health 2022" strategy, which we launched in 2018. This is a real success of the policy launched since 2018. Everywhere we have organized this capacity to organize communities of caregivers in the territory, these famous CPTFs, we have succeeded in implementing medical assistants; it is a real effect. It frees up medical time, allowing for better organization.

So, I tell you, we have nearly 4,000; we must reach 10,000 by the end of next year, and that is feasible. I want us to generalize them. We will continue, and therefore, we will increase funding to do so, encourage more, and it allows us to relieve peripheral tasks from care. And what I want is for us to also apply it to hospitals where we will transfer administrative, logistical, and technical staff closer to the services to allow caregivers to focus on the core of their profession.

That is what Sandra, I believe, I do not want to mispronounce her name, was telling me earlier in pediatrics. Thanks to the hospital director and to Madame the president for what has been done in terms of support. We have given you this position, and that is what we need to generalize; it is exactly the same thing. What you have invented in your service is what we need to generalize everywhere because it allows nursing assistants, nurses not to perform administrative or logistical tasks and to have administrative jobs. However, we have many administrative jobs because we are always told: "you administer the system too much," which is quite true, but they are not always in the right place. They are sometimes too much at the heart of the hospital's administrative services. They are in our ARSs, which have done remarkable work throughout the period and still do, they are in central administration; we need to better reallocate our resources to sometimes place them closer to the field and in service to the caregiving teams, and that is what we will do collectively. I think that also gives meaning to everyone in the work we do; it allows very concretely to free up caregiver time and redeployments. Finding useful care time means, more specifically for hospitals, also strengthening the teams that are at the bedside of patients. So to achieve this, we will first give some breathing room to the teams through reinforcements of professionals and more paramedics.

Now, I will be very clear: we have started to significantly increase the number of places opened for nurses, plus 20% in 3 years, and with the regions, and I thank them for their commitment, we must go even further to train more. Because there, the training time allows for outcomes, but I will be quite clear because I have heard all your doubts. I give you figures with pride, saying we have done plus 20%, I am very proud of that. We were right; we opened positions. I listened to you this morning, and I listened to all those who work every day, and I thank them for their management; the problem is that we have far too many who drop out during training. We have about 30% of students who drop out during training, and we have about 10-15% who fail at the end of these trainings. This means that even when I tell you: we have done + 20%, great, we will continue; when we say we train 100, we open 100 trained positions, we actually have 55 who arrive on the ground, and then we also have the problem of some who redirect and say at the end of their studies: ultimately, I will not go, it’s too hard; and others will immediately do temporary work. So we will continue to open positions, but what do we need to do?

First, we need to think about the right orientation. For health, we need it urgently; we must improve the Parcoursup system, which is not optimal, which does not allow today to properly measure motivation.

The second thing is that we need to review the organization and functioning of our studies. There are many ideas; some have been given to me; it is a project that I am condensing and that we must finalize by summer. It is essential.

And third, we need to put in place a system that is more accountable upon graduation. And there, for everyone, we cannot have caregivers conforming, regardless of their qualifications, who immediately go into temporary work or replacements. It is not possible because otherwise, we will discourage everyone. We need to say that we should have, for X years, a time where we choose a position, a function, etc. This also goes along with the revaluation that we will continue to do, and it is a way to be collectively attractive. The desire for optimization, if I may say so, has also largely exceeded the initial idea, and we also have professionals who, as a result, have suffered, and that is what has created many departures from the hospital. In addition to this training, what I want to say is that we must also, in the short term, do everything to keep the staff who are there. This is the challenge of the coming months. And in this regard, I hope that by June, we can focus on a whole body of work that allows for more serenity and security for caregivers with patients. This means that we must work together on a better organization of working time.

What is not working in our hospital today? It is that, as I said, it is the last place where, legally, the 35-hour workweek still functions. It is a hyper rigidity. If I say this, many will jump on me saying, "But I do not work 35 hours; he is nice." That is entirely true. So the system only works through overtime that is allocated in a completely heterogeneous manner according to the services. This does not create good collaboration between services and has also created a lot of heterogeneity according to territories, specialties, and services because there are overtime hours that are really paid, there are overtime hours that are put on accounts that are not paid immediately, which create a lot of differences despite all the revaluations and the Ségur we have done, in terms of paid hours, in terms of the constraints required. So we will be clear; the system, we have over-constrained it. So we can say we will put more resources, etc., but on a system that is over-constrained and not working well, where, it must be said, we are also not collectively using the instrument that is the hospital well, are we using our operating rooms sufficiently well, the equipment that is collectively ours? The truth is no, because we have created too many constraints in the organization of working time, and therefore we have not optimized the time collectively either.

We need to give everyone visibility to say, "We are not stopgaps," and therefore we also want to have workload plans on which we provide visibility. This system needs to be completely overhauled, and I ask that it be done by June 1st so that with the small project team that will do this with the minister, we can rebuild a system that is objectively more coherent with the reality of your daily lives. Otherwise, I tell you, we will constantly be filling in crises on this subject, and we will constantly be making bonuses, revaluations, so we will always have systems where it is not sufficiently utilized, where there is a shortage of caregivers because we need to rethink the organization in the hospital, the organization of working time, the organization of workload plans. We need to do this more broadly, between what is done at home, in outpatient care, and in traditional hospitalization.

Next to that, and this is the second major point I wanted to focus on, we need to reorganize hospital care to regain a human scale. And I have been struck in recent years, before Covid, even more during Covid, and I would say that the period we are experiencing in the aftermath of Covid is even more worrying in this regard. There is a need for remuneration; we have started to address it, it is true that we are not done yet, but there is a need for recognition and meaning, and that is also why I am here before you this morning, because I am not naive, I hear you. What you are saying is, "We were applauded every evening at 8 PM when it was Covid, and then everyone forgot about us, and for us, it is sometimes even harder in certain departments than it was during Covid." Which is true. So how, beyond the recognition that I am here to testify to today, are we going to do this in the long term? By somehow restoring our collective organization to a human scale. I believe that beyond a system of recognition, this is what allows us to give meaning and a better collective organization. In the hospital, I believe I can say, under your control, that one of the springs of disenchantment is a team organization that, through rationality, has lost predictability and humanity. It is nobody's fault. It is the fault of many well-meaning people who wanted to save money, to better organize things, but at some point, the system became rigid. But the truth is that because of the organization of working time that I have already mentioned and an organization that we have massified around sometimes very heavy poles, but especially by having the same organization everywhere in the territory, we have sometimes discouraged. We have also created situations where we have, for the caregivers who remain, created impossible schedules where within one pole and from one department to another, you are told from one day to the next, "You have to do this shift, you have to come fill this need or that one." That is the reality. Many of our caregivers aspire to revisit their schedules, their time patterns, to find more time for patients, more time to train, more time as a team. And that is fortunate because it is exactly what we need to meet the challenges I mentioned. If we want to succeed in doing this, we must also allow more freedom of organization. I want every hospital to have engaged and finalized discussions with all teams, all social partners to adapt schedules and work organizations by June 1 at the latest, as I said, and to be able to do so at the service level as well. Each service must be able to seize this freedom to organize autonomously and responsibly with maximum freedom in the construction of schedules under the leadership of managers and heads of services. The service must become the organic and human unit to be able to organize things. Then, creating cooperations by poles, there are many models, and there are places where the poles work well because they are coherent, and there are places where it is a disaster. I tell you this as I have seen it. We must allow this possibility to reorganize things, but by June 1, we must have this dialogue done, and a real autonomy of teams for their organization because it is what will also allow us to say: Below a certain threshold, when we have a problem, we must make complete organizational decisions. We restore predictability to everyone, and that is key, and we restore humanity because people know each other, because they can organize things among themselves. More broadly, by June 1, public hospitals must find everywhere the scale of the service to make daily decisions in the heat of action, in the following days and nights, it is because we know each other that we support each other, that we can gain in efficiency. Then, if the poles are chosen and maintained, there must be a stronger freedom of organization. So, what is wonderful in our collective organization is when I said this: I want it to be done by June 1, I was first told: "It is totally impossible, we need a law text, and therefore it will never be ready by June 1." And then I was told: "In fact, the law text is already taken, but no one is aware of it." That is a reality. So we can already do it; the law has opened the possibility of organizing at the service level. I say it urbi et orbi, everyone must seize it to find these latitudes and especially that we can seize the organizational field that I have just opened on working time, the allocation of the corresponding remunerations, and that we collectively seize it. It is not rigidity; we have the right. We must regain this possibility to organize things in the most suitable way. In any case, it is open.

Regarding the management of our hospitals, I truly thank all the work that has been done and the remarkable work done both by the administrative team director and the medical team. I think we all experienced during Covid something that broke down barriers, and that is why I said: I do not believe at all in opposition. For a long time, it was said: It should not be the caregivers who run the hospital; it should be the administrators. Then we said the problems are the administrators who run them. It works when it is together. I wish, and we have several law texts carried by our parliamentarians that will allow us to go in this direction, that the minister leads a consultation that will allow us to specify the organizational modalities but that we can put at the head of our hospitals an administrative and medical tandem. A real tandem that, based on a project that is submitted, also gives a whole place back to the board of directors of our hospital, can build a project, that the best project is chosen, and that it is a tandem that is put in place. I think it is a good thing for everyone to work well together, hand in hand.

Finally, to restore the hospital to a human scale, we will change the funding for all public and private establishments. Indeed, health needs are evolving, and no one can bear that establishments engage in harmful competition. We know this well, and many debates are tense around this famous activity-based pricing. We had the debate, by the way, for pediatrics at the end of last year. And fundamentally, it is an exclusive logic in activity-based pricing that has created many dysfunctions in the system. First, because there is a part of the private or non-profit private system that cooperates wonderfully, and I thank them for that. And here, by the way, you have very good examples. There are also some establishments that do not cooperate at all; that is a reality. The remuneration model we have created only values the act and therefore, to a large extent, we know very well, it poorly takes into account unprogrammed care, it poorly takes into account the most complex activities, which will take time — pediatrics being a very good example, but there are others — and fundamentally, it harms the core activities that find themselves in public hospitals also because many others no longer want to do them. I will not tell you that we will gradually exit T2A. It happens that I already said this in November 2018, so I have a sense of both the ridiculous and the sense of responsibility. When systems have been established and we say we will change them gradually, it does not work. We must proceed differently. We must exit activity-based pricing as soon as the next Social Security financing bill to move towards a new funding model that we must rebuild based on in-depth work and a consultation that relies on remuneration based on public health objectives. What does that mean? It means that for public hospitals, private establishments, and healthcare professionals in the liberal sector, there must be a structuring part of the remuneration that is based on public health objectives that we negotiate at the territorial level. How do we take care of the population that is given to us? This creates more cooperation, and it is the reality of what territories experience.

Then, there must be effective remuneration for the missions carried out by each, taking into account the mission and its complexity, and finally, a part of remuneration for activity that is entirely legitimate and must continue. This project must absolutely be done because it is the one that will allow for greater cooperation between the public and private sectors, to better take into account the specialties that are the most complex, which are sometimes the poor relations, and above all to create more cooperation — you will see me coming — at the territorial level. That is exactly what we want to do. This new funding will concern both public and private establishments, but also the remuneration of cooperation between the city and the hospital to promote collective work in service of patients. The profound transformation of the organization in hospitals will do a lot, but it will not do everything, through these few texts. These are very structuring elements that I have just mentioned, but we will need to go further, and there too, manage it as closely as possible to the ground. Because I know, I mentioned it briefly earlier, but there is meaning, there is the organization of work, the meaning we give to this work, and the ability to have visibility on one's work plan and to do one's job well and to have this satisfaction, what you all ask for, but there are also the living conditions, and the living conditions can still be difficult, even very difficult for many of our caregivers who have heavy days, often atypical hours, and I mentioned it in living areas as we now say, where housing is expensive and where sometimes one has to live far from where one works at hours when public transport no longer exists. That is the reality. It is exactly what you are experiencing, and therefore on this, what we are going to launch as close to the ground as possible, and many hospital directors, mayors have already launched initiatives in this direction, and I know that it is underway at APHP. I know that you have launched it here too, but with the minister, the ministers, we will support you massively. It is a great initiative with local elected officials to define a shared action plan by next summer. What does that mean? It means redefining a dedicated housing stock because it does not work in social housing. I will say it right away; it is not true; it does not work. It does not work for very practical reasons. First, many social housing stocks in these areas are already saturated. It does not work because it is very hard to get people out of social housing, and we cannot attach it to the function; it is not made for that. But we need a dedicated housing stock for staff who need it, and so we need to help those in these areas where housing is very expensive. We also need to have, on issues as clear as support for travel, parking, etc., very concrete things. It is not the President of the Republic who will decide them, but there needs to be a support plan so that everywhere in the territories where there is a crying need, by next summer, we also have new solutions provided.

Finally, it is the question of careers, and whether it concerns hospital practitioners, nurses, nursing assistants, we have a subject of career evolution on which I wish that by the next PLFSS, we can see the points that remain to be addressed to fully retain those who are in fragile situations and there too, consolidate beyond what I have already said the attractiveness, because it is also in the management of careers, training, good remuneration after training, the recognition of these trainings in the responsibilities we give, that we will improve things. We have collectively made progress in recent years on IPAs; we talked about it earlier with one of you; we can go, we will go much further, but we must generalize and improve it across the different categories I mentioned.

Next, and this is the third area I wanted to address. We must redistribute efforts to ensure the permanence and universality of care. Essentially, what does this mean? It means we need to better break down the barriers between the city and the hospital, to address two major problems we all know: the issue of medical deserts on one side, and the issue of thrombosis, unplanned care in pediatric emergencies or elsewhere in recent weeks at the hospital, in areas that are very strained. This massive release of medical time in the system that I just mentioned must be accompanied by a better distribution of skills and a fairer allocation of responsibilities. And here too, it must be done in an extremely cooperative manner, respectful of everyone. I am counting on the commitment of each and every one, because continuity, quality, and permanence of care must be the concern of all. I know that many of our nurses, doctors, health personnel, and paramedics in private practice also care about this and want to participate. So, for the permanence of care in establishments, what everyone calls "emergencies," we will do several things. On one hand, within the hospital, we need to open discussions on the remuneration for night work and permanence. I will say it as long as we have not rebuilt things, the so-called emergency measures planned until March will be maintained. This is essential, because we cannot, at the moment when exhausted people are coming out of the peak of the crisis, say: we are going to disconnect you from what I believe are also measures of reparation for night work and weekend shifts. On the other hand, this is part of the entire overhaul of work organization in hospitals that I mentioned. We must value this, we must take it into account.

We must also have a real debate on the difficulty of these missions because they are not the same. And the great difficulty of these lies in the daily routine, in remuneration, in the organization of time, and in the consideration within the pension system for the categories of workers that you are.

Furthermore, I have asked the minister to initiate work immediately so that clinics and hospitals can participate with the same intensity in this fundamental mission. And as soon as an establishment is funded by public money, it must take its full share in the health needs of the territory and the continuity of care. As I said, this is already the case for many of them. We need to better encourage this cooperation and therefore have a remuneration system that better incentivizes, rewards, if I may say so, private and non-profit private establishments that participate in the continuity of care in a territory and is less generous with those who do not participate. That is how we must proceed.

For the permanence of care in the city, because everything is interconnected and many have told me in the services that are yours: when it is poorly ensured or no longer ensured, everything arrives at the hospital and thus, everything is interconnected. And it is not simply at the hospital that we need to allocate resources. We need to re-empower and encourage the permanence of care in the city. The French must easily find a doctor on call. Now, I know that there are many initiatives. I have seen them myself on the ground, in large cities, in rural areas, to move in this direction, and I really want to commend the commitment and dedication of many doctors and paramedics in this regard.

Our famous National Councils for Territorial Health Refoundation have allowed us to identify what is already working, which we will generalize quickly. With more resources and incentives. And we cannot have, I say this very clearly, on one side, doctors who exhaust themselves beyond reason to do weekend shifts, to take a patient during lunch hour, to do more and more, and who feel responsible, in a way, for a population at the scale of a territory and who do not want to limit themselves to their patient base. And to say that we will have exactly the same approach with them as with doctors who say "I can no longer take on a single patient" and who reorganize their time differently, which I totally respect, certainly, it is everyone's freedom. But there must be another choice of life, which is not necessarily in cooperation with the rest of the territory. And as a result, these professionals are no longer doing quite the same job with the same commitment. When we remain with a pricing system that is only fee-for-service, it is not the fairest.

And so we will better remunerate the doctors who ensure the permanence of care and those who take on new patients that we have defined. And so this is a demand from our fellow citizens, it is a real response both to the permanence of care in very strained areas and to medical deserts. And it is, I say, where we will concentrate the financial effort of the contractual negotiations that are set to conclude at the end of the first quarter. So yes, we will put more resources, we need to put them, we need to put them in the right place. We cannot revalue in the same way. Simply, we need to do things more intelligently, in accordance with what we are saying. So we need to better remunerate, in a way, those who will be willing to train young people and take interns with them, to take on new patients, to help during peak times when they exist, to participate in a healthcare offer in the territory. This is what we need to better support, better remunerate.

You see that this is very coherent with the generalization of our famous CPTS that we want to see developed. As we have provided them with medical assistants, it is on the professionals who are willing to organize in a territory with others and ensure the permanence of care that we will allocate more resources, it is fairer. And so we will do with them exactly as we will do with the hospital, that is to say, we are moving away from fee-for-service funding to mission-based funding, in terms of health responses for a population.

More broadly, we need to build a new pact with liberal medicine, a pact of rights and duties. We need our liberal medicine. I want to be clear, I believe in the importance of this model, in the strength of the French model, which has all the functions, all the choices of life and organization. But we must put an end to a divergence that has developed. It is not true everywhere and for everyone. But we need to better reward, better incentivize all those who want to work together. And so in each territory, it will be about building a form of collective solidarity.

For specialist doctors, it is about, for example, conducting advanced consultations in under-dense areas; for general practitioners, participating in the management of scheduled care, welcoming interns for training, as I mentioned. And so what we want to do, and this is where we will concentrate our needs, is that by the end of this year, every citizen should have access in their living area to a healthcare offer. So let’s call it a territorial network. We have had plenty of acronyms, plenty of names already in recent decades, I do not want to add to that. I want to be simple and understood. We need that when we live in a place, we can have someone as a reference. It is a doctor or someone who works with them in this network, who can be a paramedic, depending on the needs and what we have identified, who will be a specialist, who will be in the city or at the hospital. And so we want to create, at the scale of a territory, a health solution by encouraging health actors in a territory to cooperate with each other. So, you understand, in the funding of the hospital, the funding of the city, that is where we will allocate resources.

And the method is simple, it will be precisely our famous territorial CNRs that we will now systematize across all living areas. And these territorial CNRs are not meant to discuss; no, it will be to build a roadmap by the end of the year and to say how we organize ourselves. And this will lead either to new CPTS or to networks, between existing CPTS, hospitals, and others. And all health professionals will commit to a response in terms of care to ensure the continuity of care for all our compatriots and to say: here is what we need, the resources we need in order to contract on these resources. This is the best way to break down the barriers between city and hospital, but above all to also reward all those who are in this strategy of cooperation.

General practitioners must thus be able to focus on health and nothing but health in this context, and this is a bit the fourth axis that supports this third one. Indeed, our general practitioners are, for the French, the most familiar face of our healthcare system. And that is why I also want to enhance their role, first by helping them take on more patients with the remuneration we will put in place, with the multiplication of aids and, as I mentioned earlier, the widespread multiplication of the medical assistant system that we have created.

I also want us to continue to eliminate all unnecessary tasks, such as certain certificates, that we can develop tele-expertise, telemonitoring, which is a good thing. And in this regard, I say very clearly, the threshold of 20% for teleconsultations that has been set is not a good idea. It is the marriage of the desire to save money with the desire not to lose patients. But it is not as if there were problems with patient bases. The problem is that there are too many people who do not have doctors. So we need to free up this issue and then regulate the excesses. But we must not create prohibitions ab initio, which is always our tendency. We need to simplify things and enhance them. And then within the framework of the contractual negotiations that opened in November with health insurance, and according to the pact of rights and duties that I have described and which also applies, we will allocate resources.

We must therefore also evolve the skills of other health professionals to strengthen our capacity to care for our compatriots. In this territorial offer, these networks that we want to set up, these coalitions of health, so to speak, that we will build together this year, we will also involve all other paramedics, all other professions. We will thus more massively develop advanced practice nurses. We will inform the French about the possibilities available to them: such as going to an orthoptist starting in January for a renewal of glasses, a very simple and essential thing. This is now possible.

We will allow the French to consult other health professionals for prescription renewals for chronic diseases, for vaccinations, for screening, for therapeutic education that must be carried out by pharmacists, midwives, nurses. The delegation of tasks must be simplified, generalized, and there should be no conflicts between professions. If this is done at the level of a coalition or a network, it will encourage everyone to cooperate, and we will have paramedics who will be in contact with medical professionals. But it is essential that the training and skills of each are duly recognized so that everyone can focus on the tasks, the professions, the complexities for which they have been trained. Not on tasks that are sometimes a bit repetitive, simpler, which can be delegated to other paramedical professionals whose training we will also fully value.

This is what we must do; otherwise, we will not be able to solve the problem that is collectively ours. We already have experiences allowing pharmacists to welcome and direct certain benign everyday pathologies that are proving their worth, and we have several other paramedical professions that want to contribute. We must not waste time and generalize them. In this regard, the Minister of Health, with the parties involved, the most involved parliamentarians, must identify all these developments by March 1. We already have a lot of work underway that goes in this direction to be able to generalize and simplify them. Everyone must take their responsibilities, and I say this to all our compatriots as well. On this point, and I will conclude with this message of responsibility: it is essential, as you have seen, that everyone takes a greater part.

But our compatriots also have a role to play. And when we talk about health, the patient has a role in health, and this is at the heart of the logic of prevention, which is what we want to achieve through training. However, our system, by removing all barriers to access to care, which is a good thing and that we will maintain, has sometimes disempowered many of our compatriots. And in a way, since health no longer has a price for many of our compatriots, it no longer has value. And I say it, too much medical time is wasted due to excessive carelessness, with particularly missed appointments. To eliminate this waste of medical time, a collaboration will also be initiated with health insurance to hold patients accountable when an appointment or several are missed or when there are abusive recourse to unplanned care. We must put an end to a system where, in a way, we treat our health system as we do not treat anything else in our society. That is to say, we think that the right to access is absolute, endless, unlimited, that respect no longer applies because we never pay. This is not possible.

Finally, as I said, the primary care physician must be the entry point, but not the lock of our system. I indeed want us to clarify and simplify the organization on the ground. Why do we have today 6 million of our compatriots who do not have a primary care physician? For some of the younger ones, it is a choice. But the real difficulty in this figure is that we have 600,000 patients with chronic illnesses who do not have a primary care physician. And that is a real problem because it is a loss of opportunity, because many of them will be found later in more serious situations in your services. And this is collective. The Nation is not fulfilling its duty, it is not fair and it is not effective.

And so, the 600,000 patients with chronic illnesses will be offered a primary care physician before the end of the year. Or more precisely, I want these chronic patients to have access to what I would call a treating team, meaning that they can have access to these networks, these coalitions of actors that we will have identified and structured at the level of a territory and a team. And when there is not enough time from doctors, at least the doctors can delegate to paramedics, but we should not have people who have no access to anyone.

Today, what we have is that you have people in situations of chronic illnesses, who have long-term infections, who are in territories that do not have access to a doctor who, due to the rigidities of our system, cannot even have a prescription renewed by the nurse or the pharmacist. That is absurd and we have no right to do that. We must get out of this face-to-face situation. So we must say, there will always be referring doctors, generalists and specialists in these coalitions of territorial actors. It is up to them to organize themselves to find the time. If they are smart, they delegate the acts to paramedics, the acts that have the least value. And the logic is that many of our general practitioners should delegate two or three prescription renewals per year to the reference nurse, to the reference pharmacist, so that they only have regular appointments. And they will appreciate in dialogue with these paramedics how to find the right frequency. That is exactly what we want to build. That is what we must do. That is what some of you are already doing. It needs to be systematized because that is how we will free up real caregiver time in front of the patient.

But therefore, the objective I set for us is that these ground coalitions will have reference teams for our 600,000 compatriots who today have chronic conditions and just have no one in front of them. And we will thus be able to respond to their needs, guide them, support them. In the most serious cases, in the absence of a primary care physician, we will generalize — what we also launched in 2018 and which is, I must say, a real success thanks to your contributions — which is the access to care service. And so I wish that we can accelerate its generalization during this year.

Concretely, when one does not have a primary care physician or when that physician is not available, a patient who urgently seeks one must be able to call 15. And depending on their health status, they will be directed either to the emergency room or to a doctor identified by this service. Calls have greatly increased to these so-called SAS, these access to care services. We need to go further, make the system recognized by all French people, consolidate teams that answer and medically evaluate patients. The Minister knows this well since, in his previous functions, he contributed to thinking about it and implementing it. And so, we will thus have doctors who will welcome these patients using these so-called access to care services for unplanned consultations. And again, this will allow private practitioners and private structures to get involved and will help relieve hospitals of many unplanned care. This is how we managed to hold on last summer in many territories.

This also means that we must better compensate and that we will sustainably - let us be clear and honest with each other - continue to better compensate the professionals who play the game and participate in the co-management of unplanned care services. The SAS is the guarantee of an immediate and proportionate response and it will function all the better as we restore this universality, this revaluation of the continuity of outpatient care and the involvement of clinics as well as private practitioners.

There you go, I do not want to be longer on this day, but these are some of the key points I wanted to emphasize at the beginning of the year. So, I know this will change many habits. Several of the projects I have just described are massive projects that we have sometimes failed to carry out in recent years or that we have not wanted to carry out. As you have understood, and indeed, the financial texts voted at the end of last year have shown it. We continue to reinvest massively in our health and we will continue to do so. But we will continue to do so by profoundly changing the organization and habits. And this reform will also be articulated, and I will return to it during the semester, with other essential and twin reforms: that of the first 1,000 days of life for our children, because we have a huge job in terms of prevention and support for the youngest, on which we have also built many policies. But we must go much further and that of autonomy and the response to dependency and old age on which, again, in recent years, we have begun to provide many answers. In geriatrics in hospitals and for our nursing homes as well, but we must go much further and I have committed to home care offers and transition offers. And so, there too, we have a project that is partly medical, but which is also, if I may say, societal on which I will return. But all of this is interconnected.

In any case, you have understood that what I wanted to tell you this morning is that I will be alongside the hospital and all those who have, in recent years, particularly in recent months, helped it to hold on. We need you and so we will be with you. But more broadly, I will be alongside all those who care.

There are a few projects on which the President of the Republic, if I may say, has a particular vocation to get involved: ecology, education, health, I think, are a reasonable triptych because it is the triptych of the future of our children and a strong Nation. And if we do not invest as we should in humanity and everything that surrounds it, we can do whatever we want in other public policies. We will struggle to move forward. And so we must strongly break down barriers, simplify, better organize, enhance, and reconquer our territories. That is the meaning of what I have just told you and it is what I will return to your side today, but over time. There will be a dedicated team set up alongside the minister to carry out these projects and I know there will be the commitment of the minister and the delegated minister to do so.

But count on my personal commitment and regularly, I will come to your side to both continue to see what works and what does not work to ensure above all the implementation of what we agree on, but especially and above all to build the hospital and the health system that our country deserves and that our nation deeply desires.

Thank you all! And again, I renew my wishes for the year that is opening. Long live the Republic and long live France!