SPEECH BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC ON THE OCCASION OF THE CLOSING OF THE GENERAL STATES OF DIPLOMACY.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

16 March 2023 · Closing of the General States of Diplomacy

Context
Macron addressed French ambassadors and diplomats at the close of the General States of Diplomacy on March 16, 2023, outlining reforms and future ambitions for French foreign policy.
Main themes
French diplomacy reform, diplomatic profession and corps, resource allocation and ministry funding, General States of Diplomacy, senior civil service reform, international crises and evacuations, European sovereignty, career pathways for diplomats, interministerial cooperation
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,580
89th percentile
Sentences
174
86th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
3.26
79th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 36%35%
  • Geopolitical 34%33%
  • Ceremonial 15%14%
  • Social 8%7%
  • Economic 7%6%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

174 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. President of the Senate Foreign Affairs, Defense and Armed Forces Committee,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Mr. General Rapporteur of the General States of Diplomacy,

Madam Secretary General,

Ladies and gentlemen directors,

Ladies and gentlemen ambassadors,

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am very happy to be among you today, and it often takes a pandemic or some massive evacuation of nationals for you to see a President of the Republic in these walls. I also wanted to be here today, outside of exceptional situations and disasters, to testify because indeed, you are the armed arms of our international action, and you have amply demonstrated this by ensuring a courageous and effective presence in war-torn countries, from Afghanistan to Ukraine, to name just a few, by repatriating hundreds of thousands of French citizens and sometimes other European nationals stranded abroad by COVID, by negotiating historic agreements with other powers, or by enabling unprecedented diplomatic breakthroughs, such as the International Treaty on the Protection of the High Seas just a few days ago, or by promoting our vision of European sovereignty.

Diplomacy is a profession, moreover, whose specificity and constraints I fully recognize. A profession of commitment that lives to the rhythm of crises and does not count its hours. A profession of passion that also has its burdens, where the constant obligation of mobility, with its uncertainties and sometimes difficult destinations, weighs on spouses and families. But I come, aware also of the questions that have been yours in recent months. It must be said, for it is at the root of many things.

The Ministry has also experienced, and before the questions that may have arisen in recent decades, a profound attrition of its resources, which were already among the weakest when compared to other major European powers, and particularly of its human resources, which now number only 13,600 agents. This has been accompanied by a reduction in its premises and even, to some extent, its place in the State. It is not the parliamentarians present here who will contradict me; they know it. Allow me, however, to note that it was indeed during my first term that this long decline was finally interrupted starting in 2020. I want to acknowledge the work of your predecessor, Madam Minister. Some would have liked us to adapt, in a way, our ambitions to the weakness of resources or to their attrition. I have simply come to tell you that I intend to make the opposite choice: to align resources with our ambitions.

I have also heard the concerns regarding the reform of the civil service and the senior civil service that have arisen on this fertile ground of doubt, because resources were increasingly reduced. I want to reiterate this with great clarity: I believe that this reform is good for the State, and I believe that it is particularly good for your Ministry and for its agents. I want to be very clear here: as true as I recognize the existence of a profession, a profession does not need a body to exist. I speak to you with great simplicity, I who, coming out of the ENA, joined a profession and a body, have fully assumed the decision to abolish that same body. It has nothing to do with it. And in all the best diplomacies in the world where the profession is recognized and exists, it exists within a professional pathway with peer judgment, careers that must be safeguarded; that does not mean that a body is necessary for that, it is different. So yes to the profession, no to the body, in other words, but we will defend the profession well.

I believe that this reform will affirm and highlight the already open position of this Ministry. And being one of the most open ministries, you have a great interest in this reform. I have already been informed that more than 60% of eligible agents have expressed their intention to join precisely the State administrators, which is an encouraging sign of engagement in this interministeriality. I have asked the minister to further enrich the reform, and it will be necessary, in particular, to sustain the career progression perspectives decided last year for the secretaries of Foreign Affairs.

But this reform is just one aspect of the broader reflection on the future of our diplomacy. That is why it seemed so necessary to me, as I told you at the end of last summer, to conduct the General States, this work of introspection and projection into the future that has been carried out under the authority of the minister and whose work we have followed closely; it is an unprecedented exercise in which you have engaged.

I would like to particularly thank the minister, the team of the General States, starting with its general rapporteur, Jérôme BONNAFONT, and all those who have worked with him. You have, in essence, all conducted this exercise with the right spirit, I believe, and have made an unflinching assessment, a solid reflection, and credible proposals. The future ministry that you are outlining must be profoundly renovated. I believe that this is a necessity, and each of our trips shows it. If we project ourselves, what is the diplomacy that our country needs on the horizon of the decade? I will not revisit, in essence, the doctrine and what I have been able to deploy, particularly during the last speech I made at the conference of ambassadors. I would simply like to highlight four dominant traits that stem from these convictions established in recent years, from the major work pursued alongside you in recent years, and from the General States.

The first is a deeply renovated core profession. The world is changing, no one is waiting for us, the geopolitics of our century will be a contradictory system, made up of shifting coalitions and inevitable polarizations, a world that is fundamentally quarrelsome and tempted by renationalization. So we will have to compete with both coherence and agility to find our place. We must be constantly on the alert, capable of assembling circles of solidarity: Europe, of course, and this strategic autonomy that we have imposed on the landscape in recent years, and the alliance, of course, but also the Indo-Pacific to be at the pivot, to ensure our sovereignty, our freedom of maneuver, and many other alliances that we are also in the process of rebuilding in completely renovated regional frameworks. Our diplomacy will therefore need to equip itself for this.

We will need to strengthen the analytical capacity of political departments, consolidate our strategic culture, and equip ourselves with anticipation capabilities. And for all this, it is a cardinal point, to further value innovation, to question our habits, to revisit our dogmas, to use artificial intelligence and the processing of open sources. In essence, if I may say so, to consolidate what I believe is a strength of our model, namely the very deep expertise that exists in the departments, and to gain in agility and capacity to reshape our organizations through project teams, task forces as perhaps some neighbors do.

Behind all this is our duty to build partnerships and, in a way, to align all the operators of our action: the French Development Agency at the forefront, but all operators, so that when we decide on partnerships, there is a very high degree of political coherence. And that is indeed what I see in the exercise of oversight — I will not revisit debates that we know by heart, and I see the director general here — but I believe that the AFD is a strength, and that it is a strength that must work in synergy with the Quai, and that good oversight is strategic oversight, not nitpicking oversight that seeks to do the same job or duplicate it. However, we must collectively gain in coherence to redeploy partnerships at 360° whenever we decide on new strategies.

Africa is a formidable theater of operations. When we decide on a coherent action in the Sahel, we must all align in that same coherent action and not, I would say, play with variable geometry. When we decide to re-engage with such or such country and to say that, fundamentally, we have a new partnership, that security is no longer primarily dominant, we must re-engage more effectively with the entire palette. We must do it and do it quickly, and it must be visible. I believe that this is at the heart of strategic clarity and execution strength. Let us keep the lines of expertise that are ours and the professional cultures, but let us gain in agility, in coherence in this profoundly renovated world. I believe that this is what will make us stronger, more readable for our partners and allies, and more readable also for the countries with which we will defend our interests and build coalitions.

The second trait is a diplomacy that is structured around the capacity for influence. My first term was marked by an unprecedented increase in our international solidarity action. The target of 0.55% of our GDP has been reached, and we have regained our place as a great power of solidarity. And here too, we have put an end to years of decline in our solidarity investments. From the DRC, where we were a few days ago, to Vanuatu, from Ukraine to Syria, we are present where we need to be, with our humanitarian actions and all that we finance through this investment.

We are also at a turning point that requires us to add, fundamentally, to the grammar of solidarity, that of influence. Autocratic powers are attempting to rewrite the principles of the international system, to rally the vast world in favor of a certain fatigue with the West, a fatigue that we see here at home when doubt sets in. There is a kind of ambient relativism that is settling in, including in our own waves, including among those who are sometimes perceived as the voice of France abroad and who come to serve discourses of deconstruction or revision of what our own past and the actions of others would be. I do not resign myself to this. I do not believe, for my part, that autocracy has recently distinguished itself. From COVID to Russia's failure in Ukraine, this battle is not won only in facts; it is also won in minds. And in this area, we still have much to do, and I said it when I outlined the principles of the military programming bill: we must organize our capacity for influence, and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs is the linchpin for international action. It is now necessary to fully grasp this, to radically change the scale of our communication apparatus, but also to modernize our tools, to tackle the battle of social networks head-on, including against all kinds of manipulations, and to consider that it is a place of hybrid warfare. It is also a place, fundamentally, of the effectiveness of our own diplomacy. Many leaders look at what their peoples believe, read, and define their choices in relation to that, and when we lose the informational battle, we sometimes annihilate real efforts and concrete investments. And this is unfortunately a reality, and a reality that we see on the African theater and elsewhere.

I have just seen a very small sample of the teams that are deployed on this subject and who described perfectly better than I have just done everything they do on a daily basis and what you will continue to deploy. This means that we need to structure strategies around the effects of influence, impact, added value, also define very concrete strategies for allies on the ground and on social networks in almost all geographies, and move forward to be much more effective.

Finally, influence is not only played out in places of power. The Arab Springs have shown us that revolutions are not detected in palaces, and we must also be outside the walls, in the intimacy of the population, in its life, its networks. I know that this is at the heart of the commitment of many of you. But this means that we must multiply our efforts everywhere, across all geographies, I would say, to consider that the heart of action today is to go precisely to seek at the front lines those who are doing political action, but also public opinions, to delve deeper into the intimacy of countries and what is happening there, and perhaps better organize ourselves collectively.

I often say that there are several countries, and I will not name them because otherwise, I would create too much emotion. There are many countries where a lot of public money is invested, and when I look at things, the president, the ministers, the agency directors, the ambassadors, the service directors, the military, we see the same ten people. We know them very well; they all tell us the same thing. But that is not the whole country. So, for decades, we have seen the same ten people; we like them a lot, but that is no longer enough. And sometimes, by the way, it is in those same countries that coups d'état happen. If we have become accustomed to not seeing the rest, and to not seeing that, in fact, deep movements are working behind the scenes, and that some of our competitors, because everywhere now it is theaters of competition, have worked these countries, have worked them from the ground up, by buying local radios, by turning private security services, sometimes conciergeries — I speak very concretely because these are cases that happen and that we see on the ground — by working social networks, sometimes by obviously buying influencers or fake accounts, well, we find ourselves in the same situation as these ten leaders, meaning that we are no longer in their real country.

This is not how we will build our influence and especially the future of our presence. So, it is a huge undertaking. It is an organizational and cultural revolution, here and on the ground, but it must be at the heart of our action.

The third trait is a diplomacy that fully embraces global issues. This is not new; your ministry has already taken them on, you have structured a general directorate. But I believe I can say that the credibility of our nation, of our Europe, will largely depend on its ability to find a contract with the rest of the world for food, energy, climate, biodiversity, but also education, health, and major cultural issues. We saw this again a few weeks ago at the G20 in Bali during the Summit, and just a few days ago on forests in Gabon; these will be variable coalitions that we will need to know how to establish.

France, I deeply believe, has a central role to play because all these issues are primarily international issues that are objects of complex negotiation. Moreover, they are all interconnected, where we have expertise and credibility. We have shown this again on maritime issues. But this will require us to enhance our skills and adapt our organization. And on this, I say clearly, we must, if I may say so, recall the coherence of our action internationally.

Because there are, in fact, two movements, and we are still in ambiguity today. The idea that technicality prevails over international competence. And, in fact, each time, there will be a kind of conflict between two types of professions. People who work on climate will tell you: "it's a profession." Diplomats rightly tell us: "it's a profession." And so, the question of where we place the center of gravity is a political decision. There are several choices; we can say: we will interministerialize everything, as we did on European affairs, for example. In the end, if we interministerialize everything, we recreate a government. We must accept, and I believe it is the vocation of your ministry, to have an interministerial culture and to be this interministerial vocation projected. But this means that we must continue and perhaps intensify first the coherence and to say that when we talk about international action, it is here that it is played out. But this means importing much stronger technical skills, continuing to do so, and your ministry, which is already so, must become even more a place of welcome and coordination of interministerial skills. It will need to exercise strategic oversight over the operators, shine more, and succeed in sending these good elements on mobility to key positions, to build technical skills in certain sectors.

That is why, in fact, diplomacy is a profession and perhaps multiple professions. Professions in sectors that will increasingly structure and professionalize. That is also why we need to equip ourselves with a continuous training instrument and a diplomatic academy, as you propose, at the service of the entire State, open to foreign diplomats. I see here many friendly faces from other excellent diplomacies, and I believe that this tool would be a wonderful means of both projection and debate, but also of training, precisely in the profession of diplomat and for all these sectors.

I think we also need to use, in this context, what we have started to build through the Paris Peace Forum, which has indeed built the first sectors and which must be in synergy with this academy.

The fourth trait is a diplomacy that is closer to the French people. For many of our compatriots, diplomacy is consular, passports, visas, crisis management. And I am immensely grateful for the remarkable work done by the teams, and it is true that I want to commend your action here. I started by mentioning these crises that make it easier to come here, but our consular system, which I want to commend for its commitment and efficiency, does more for our compatriots than many others, and when I look at comparable services, we truly have a service of excellence. But now, we must do even more, do better, simplify, and dematerialize.

There have been many very significant reforms launched in recent years, and I really want to commend all these efforts, but we must continue our efforts to double French education abroad, to succeed in better rooting ourselves in the territories, to complete this work of dematerialization and simplification, and also to work better with all the regions and our territories to particularly improve the export reflex and synergies with local authorities and others. In this regard, I wish that we could therefore strengthen this diplomacy in service of the French people in a concrete way, which comes, if I may say so, to reinforce a trend that has been at work in recent years, and in this regard, I wish that we also go to the end of the logic, through the creation of a citizen diplomatic reserve that will allow us to spread this culture. Here too, from the business community to those engaged in academic, cultural matters, to field actors, it will allow for greater proximity with the culture of the ministry, with its projection, and this is what will allow us to build a greater cultural intimacy with all our compatriots and with certain sectors that sometimes feel distanced from what diplomacy is, in my opinion wrongly.

All of this — and you understood that I was intentionally partial, but I simply wanted to outline these major axes — all of this must be based on a renewed management. The Ministry is a Ministry of human resources and must therefore place the agents at the heart of its management, whether they are category A, B, C, contractual, or local law agents. That is why I think that in this reform and its implementation, it will be necessary, and it is imperative, thanks to the means, and I will come to that, to give visibility to the contractual agents, much more than they currently have, and to allow for the building of career perspectives for all.

Renovating careers, professionalizing the HR function, anticipating appointments, and we will take our part in this with the minister, by starting in the coming days a movement of ambassadors and ambassadors. But we will also need to ensure recruitments, including with a sufficient number of agents from the INSP. And I said earlier, you are a Ministry much more open than is sometimes said, and perhaps you do not think so yourself. You must continue to bring in talents from elsewhere with, if I may say so, a spirit of conquest that you need; your qualities as organizers, negotiators, crisis managers, communicators, must also allow for better projecting all the agents of the Ministry outside, in the private sector, but also in the State.

And I said, it is the request I made to the various ministers, to the DIESE and to all the competent directorates, to be able to appoint more ambassadors and prefects, rectors, directors of central administration, or heads of public institutions. Trust will be established through these reciprocal movements.

As you can see, it is a vast task that awaits us, and for me, it is inseparable from the strengthening of our country’s sovereignty. Thus, I decided, as early as 2017, to replenish the means of our armed forces, and then this year, to significantly strengthen them with the LPM. And I think we must have a coherent approach with our diplomacy. So, I say this very solemnly before you today, I wish for a complete rearmament of our diplomacy, a rearmament in service of peace, in defense of our interests and our values, but also in coherence with the ambition that is ours.

Based on the elements I have just outlined, in line with the doctrinal elements I have been able to deploy in recent months, I have therefore decided to respond favorably to the requests made by the minister, and in particular that of an increase over four years of the Ministry's staff by 700 full-time equivalents. I have also decided to increase the Ministry's budget by more than 20% for this period and to bring it to 7.9 billion euros by 2027. We must assume not only to put an end to decades of decline and weakening, which we have done since 2020, but to give ourselves the means to re-engage the necessary capacities, to be able to deploy new skills, and fundamentally, at a time when war has returned to European soil, where deep rearticulations are at work, to be able to give ourselves the means to serve our interests, to defend our priorities, our influence, and to give ourselves the capacities for the radiance of our country.

I know that you measure these means in a period of sobriety where we must constantly reform. If it were needed, today alone shows that, moreover, making intelligent savings in public finances is not a spontaneous movement, either of the nation or of the administrations, and requires choices that I assume elsewhere.

And I want you to measure the price of this trust. I will ask the minister to give me a report on the transformation of the Ministry every six months. But fundamentally, for me, this is an investment in service of a transformation. It is not more means to rebuild or in some way, to serve a nostalgia. No. It is to give us the means for a new action in service of a doctrine that I have already developed and the four major traits that I have just outlined here.

So, there will be, with this ambition on my part, many demands, but I know that I can count on each and every one of you to rise to the reforms to be carried out. And by the way, many of them are interministerial projects, and I thank all those who are engaged in the modernization of the State and the transformation of public action. You will have to demonstrate this at the major milestones of the coming months, and we will do it all together. The major trips in spring, particularly to China, the developments in the war in Ukraine, the summit on climate financing and the fight against inequalities in June, NATO in July, the G20 in September.

But we will have, especially in the months and years to come, turning points and moments of truth for our country. The year 2024 will be a decisive year. France will host the Olympic and Paralympic Games. It will undoubtedly be a key year regarding the conflict in Ukraine. We will have European elections, American elections, and we will have, fundamentally, essential questions because much of what is at stake behind — and that is also why I make this profound choice — is the question of the strength of democracies in a world, as you can see, that is being reshaped to determine whether autocracies or authoritarian regional powers are not more effective than we are. This is the summa divisio that is structuring things. And so, we do not have the right to lose this fight.

Then we have a fight to determine how, as Europeans, we emerge stronger, in a context that is much more difficult for us than for many other democracies. Because this war is on our continent, because it weakens our economic model more, and a prolonged war is more difficult for us to bear. It can be a source of divisions; I hope not, and we will do everything against it. And so, you can see that the months, and particularly the very next years to come, will be decisive for the very heart of what we are.

Democracy is its strength of influence and attraction in the world, our Europe is its strategic autonomy and therefore, the capacity of our country to maintain an independent and coherent diplomacy. And it is in service of this objective that I ask you for these transformations and that I have decided to allocate these resources, so that we may, because it is our duty, continue to know, to understand this world by ourselves and to make our great choices by ourselves and for ourselves, by deciding to have partners and allies, to build coalitions. But never out of necessity, always by choice. Because it is in this way, I believe, that France, including for our compatriots, thinks of itself, lives in the world, and lives for itself.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen, this is what I came to tell you today. This day has something symbolic about it and doing it on this day is also a manifestation of my consideration and my trust and to tell you that, perhaps, more than ever before, everything is connected. And the strength of a nation is its ability to make coherent choices for itself and to shape its destiny, but to make them understood by the rest of the world, to defend its interests, its foreign policy, and to build strong coalitions because it is a stable and responsible partner.

This is all that we will do together and which is in a way the result of your work over the past months. And so, you have understood, we will continue to modernize and transform public action and the State, but with a stronger diplomacy in service of its ambitions.

Long live the Republic and long live France!