SPEECH BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC TO THE ACTORS OF FRENCH TECH

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

14 September 2020 · Meeting with the actors of French Tech

Context
Macron addressed French Tech stakeholders at a mobilization event in September 2020, reviewing the ecosystem's resilience during Covid and outlining recovery ambitions.
Main themes
French Tech ecosystem, startup growth and unicorns, fundraising and investment, economic recovery post-Covid, job creation, digital innovation, Bpifrance and investment funds, France as a tech hub in Europe, exits and valuations, Choose France initiative
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,689
93rd percentile
Sentences
265
94th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
10.9
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 53%53%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Technological 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Not in focus 1%

265 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Madam, Mr. Minister, ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians, Madam President of the CNIL, ladies and gentlemen directors general, dear friends, I am not going to give you a grand speech. I am trying to react to what has been said and first of all to thank you because we are demonstrating that we can continue to hold mobilization events and meetings during the Covid period, so it requires a certain discipline, which we are collectively achieving. This slightly reduces the conviviality, which means that the cocktail that was planned at the end of the meeting will not take place out of caution, but it also shows that we can continue to move forward, see each other, and advance the issues that matter to us. I really wanted to start by thanking the three testimonies and the three successes, it must be said, that were expressed here, but also the entire ecosystem and all the different leaders of the French Tech communities that I saw earlier.

Thank you very much to the entire community and to French Tech, to the Secretary of State for Digital, to Tech in France, to France Digitale, to Syntec Numérique, to Bpifrance, to Station F, to all the funds in the ecosystem and all these actors. I am not exhaustive, but in just a few years, a kind of map of tenderness, of mobilization, of commitment has been structured to make France a place that creates, develops, and is transforming the world. And that has enormous value. And it is your ability to do always a little more than just your job, but also [to do it] with all the administrations that are present and whom I thank for continuing to push, to innovate, that allows, I believe I can say, to have the results that are ours.

So the results are there, and fundamentally, to try to see how we project ourselves into this recovery, we need to look at where we are today, how we held up during the Covid period, and how we can try to do better tomorrow.

We have results. On many items, and the issue of unicorns has just been mentioned. I completely share what Alexandre said, it is not the final objective, it is an intermediate objective to mobilize you. When we started from zero, and everyone was telling us in Europe, "you can't have unicorns, not in France either," it was a good objective.

Should that be the objective on which we stop? Absolutely not! So, the goal of 25 to be achieved remains. We have managed to create 13. We must continue to move forward.

After all, what does that show? That we remain the country in continental Europe that creates the most start-ups, but that we have now become a country in continental Europe that knows how to develop and grow them in terms of valuation. And that was not a given five years ago. So, we need to know where we come from and where we have arrived and that we must not stop there. Absolutely not. We must continue on this path. But in terms of funds raised, which is also a good indicator, we were at 2.6 billion euros in 2017, we moved to 5 billion in 2019, with increasingly larger tickets. 2.7 billion euros in the first half of 2020. So, despite the difficulties, even as neighboring markets in the UK and Germany were suffering a bit from their difficulties in the first half of the year, we have rather consolidated our results. So, on this aspect, which was, I would say, our historical weakness, especially compared to the British, we are starting to catch up. We have even caught up part of it and we are managing to raise more and more with increasingly significant tickets. And that is what you have collectively managed to consolidate. How?

First of all, because there have been several initiatives and different mobilizations. First, Bpifrance and the historical funds of the French ecosystem, whose friendly faces I recognize and salute. We have managed to develop with the Tibi funds and out of the 6 billion euros of investment announced, we have 24 unlisted funds that are now labeled, including 9 in health. We have 9 listed funds that have been set up. Here too, Bpifrance, business angels, and historical funds are mobilizing, with institutional players being mobilized to go further. We have managed to mobilize international actors with initiatives like Choose France or the Scale Up Tour. And so, we have truly succeeded before the crisis and maintained during the crisis an ecosystem that allows for fundraising, which consolidates the financing of the French ecosystem. And so, we have kept our capacity to innovate and we have strengthened ourselves in this area.

In addition, we have our ability to create exits, and here too, everything that has been done to highlight the journeys, to recognize the start-ups of the Next 40 to the French Tech 120. We have started to initiate exits on the market and not just MNF, which is also important for many, and on this, we know that we still have many challenges to meet.

The second point I wanted to emphasize, we mentioned it earlier with some, we are creating jobs and it is true that this is where the comparison with the traditional economy can sometimes be harsh. When we talk about unicorns, we talk about valuation. But then, when we look at the number of employees, we are not facing large groups. But I think it is very important to say, to emphasize. Fred [Mazzella] said it earlier in the small meeting we had before [with the presidents of the Capitals and French Tech Communities]. We need to go much further. Here, the French ecosystem is increasingly a job creator. And the more we manage to continue to innovate, to continue to finance growth, to attack the French market, the European market, and the global market, the more we create jobs in our territory as well. And digital, which has long been seen as a sector that destroyed jobs in traditional sectors, especially for our actors, is an ecosystem that is increasingly creating these jobs and creating them across the national territory.

You said it very well, in the hexagon as well as overseas, with a distribution that is becoming increasingly balanced and a model that is becoming increasingly broad across the territory.

Next, we are managing to maintain and even strengthen our performance in terms of innovation. For me, this is an important element. When I look at the innovation rankings that have been released recently, France has moved up to twelfth place with a very significant leap forward. The Shanghai ranking has seen us progress very strongly because we have managed to reorganize our actors, mainly public, to give scale, global visibility, and better performance to our major actors, organizations, universities, and campus logics, which is very important for you. This has been highlighted in the success factors, and this is really a consolidation of our traditional strengths [and it is] something we have managed to reorganize in recent years, on which we must go much stronger. And that is indeed the purpose of the [research programming] law that will arrive in Parliament, which is both a historic investment in funding but also a reorganization of pathways and a reorganization of our system on the ground, to be much more effective and attractive, because you are in talent sectors, that is something we have also managed to consolidate.

And then we have managed, I believe, in recent years, to build a public-private partnership ecosystem. This is the second element you mentioned earlier in the success factors. I believe that the presence of several actors from this ecosystem shows it, and I thank them for that. An effective regulatory ecosystem, the CNIL, the ACPR, and several others.

But I think it is very important to also have this penetration, this dialogue between an innovation ecosystem that, historically, was somewhat foreign to regulators and to have the independent administrative authority in charge of freedoms, which works in a partnership manner. And we have managed to do this on many subjects. I am not exhaustive regarding all regulators, but regarding sectoral regulators like the major national actors, we have created a much stronger national regulatory ecosystem while also advancing on a European ecosystem with, for example, the European regulation we have managed to build on data.

Next, we have set up a public ecosystem. You said it very well about working with our administrations. I had the opportunity to say one of the previous times, the Urssaf is your friend, and there you go! What has developed with all the administrations is also very important, both because it sometimes allows us to succeed in gaining efficiency, but also for us, for our administrations, to transform models. We saw it during the Covid crisis, it was very well illustrated, and we continue to see it every day, and I believe that it is a strength, we are at the beginning, but that is something we have started to crack, and then we have a cybersecurity ecosystem that is also very strong. The work of ANSSI, our national agency, is very important. I believe that it is a strength. We have gained in velocity, we have gained in reactivity, we are recognized, the work of ANSSI is recognized for all actors, big or small, when they are attacked. And the cyber issue is going to become an increasing issue for all of you. We know that there are no sustainable communities, there is no creation of sustainable value, there is no sustainability if we cannot continue this movement. I am not exhaustive in what I am saying here. But all of this is the collective work that has allowed us, on each of the items, the capacity to innovate, the capacity to attract talent, and to consolidate the capacity to finance, to have this ecosystem, to profoundly transform things. All of this has fertilized the reforms we carried out at the beginning of the term, mainly on the fiscal front: the flat tax, the transformation of the ISF, the research tax credit, but also the French Tech visas and others, to attract capital and talent based on the attractiveness models we know.

This whole set produces results that you have just illustrated, that I have just recalled. All this transformation has held during the Covid crisis and it has held for several reasons. First and foremost: you. I have often said, the entrepreneur, generally speaking in the world, but it is particularly true for French entrepreneurs, is a plant that does not need to be watered, but that requires stability. And I believe that the fact that we have given you stability on key issues for a long time has allowed you to also show your resilience. You do not belong to categories that ask for aid. That is not part of your DNA, for that matter. But you have fought and you have been extraordinarily resilient. It must be said, in your defense, that Covid loves digital. We have been able to see that. Just look at the valuations of major internet groups. It is a very good period, as Covid reduces the capacity to interact physically. It is very hard for jobs that rely on conviviality or anything physical. It is rather good for what is digitized. We will still have to succeed in resisting in the post-Covid period. But you have held on. And you have held on because you have made very good use of the mechanisms put in place, I commend the mobilization of Bpifrance and what Minister [Bruno Le Maire] has managed to establish. The state-guaranteed loans, the partial unemployment mechanisms have been very well utilized. And that was made for that. They allowed for resistance. And so, I think, in addition, to add a point, it was said earlier in the meeting we had with the communities, I think that many French Tech communities during this period learned, perhaps for the first time for some, to withstand crises. For the first time and not just to be in growth logic, which also allowed for accelerated common learning and resilience because many entrepreneurs who had experienced previous crises taught a lot to young entrepreneurs for whom it was the first exogenous crisis. I think that when we come out alive or strengthened from these moments, it is also a factor of acceleration in learning. We are there, and we can be proud of what has been done, of the resistance.

Now, how do we together take the next steps? I am convinced, as Alexandre [Yazdi] said, that we must not stop there at all and think that the objectives set yesterday still hold. We need to reinvent them today and try collectively to go much further and much stronger.

First, because we will give ourselves the means to do so, and then because I think that in this capacity we have to project ourselves, to reinvent ourselves in this world, what we have called the world after, but which will fundamentally be the world of life with the virus, probably for semesters, maybe years, and the world after, I think we have the recipes to invent something where we are collectively stronger.

The first thing is that we will be there. The Minister of Economy and Finance and the Secretary of State announced it. We will be there for investment, for commitment to the future alongside you. This is the famous France Relance. And France Relance shows one thing: we are collectively convinced that if we want to succeed, not just to return to how things were before, but to collectively reinvent ourselves, now is the time because there is an opportunity, I would say philosophically, there is even an anthropological need and there is a market availability for investment. Not just in resisting the crisis, but in accelerating the transitions that were already underway. And so, France Relance and its famous 100 billion euros will be deployed in many sectors where you are key players. Because digital technology is not a sector in itself. Everything being done on hydrogen, energy, and transformations will engage many actors like you in the disruption of traditional models, and you are concerned by all these sectoral plans.

But more specifically, there are 7 billion euros being allocated precisely for the transformation of our startup ecosystem and French digital technology. 3.7 billion to support startups and accelerate capital investment. We know we need it. We will have to do it defensively and offensively. Much more offensively, particularly with Bpifrance and its funds, whether direct funds or fund-of-funds. But we will invest precisely to multiply the effort. This is what the Secretary of State has advocated, and it will help accelerate the work being done and will also help you seek capital elsewhere in industrial partnerships. And for me, what is the purpose of the capital we are putting in at this stage? To grow for you much faster but also to seek industrial partners more quickly, not just financial ones from outside, who can help you continue to increase capital, but who, at the same time, provide you with opportunities to access other markets.

We will invest 300 million euros in training. We also need this at all levels to continue consolidating what we do. Many actors have done this in the private sector, and we continue to develop it in the public sector, what we are doing with the CAPES, the aggregation, and the various fields. We need to continue transforming, to provide training opportunities at all levels, and so we will invest to accelerate the initiatives that have been taken. We will also allocate 800 million euros to everyday digital technology and access because we need this as well; I will return to this in terms of inclusivity, to accelerate both the deployment of digital infrastructure across the territory and the training of all our fellow citizens, who are increasingly being asked to access digital technology and who, if we do not make this training effort, will remain marginalized from the model, which is not sustainable economically, socially, or democratically.

And then, we will implement an investment of 2.3 billion for the transformation of the State and businesses and, if I may say so, the acceleration of what is being done in our public services to digitize much faster, to transform practices, to equip, to invest, and also to train, similarly for our SMEs and sometimes our mid-sized enterprises because we know that one of the weaknesses of France, which still remains despite the very positive assessment I have made, is that we have a structure of SMEs, sometimes very small enterprises of a historical type, that have digitalized less than many of our neighbors. This is a vulnerability for them and is linked to a cultural element, as well as rigidities in terms of financing, which is, if I may say so, a brake on their development and also a brake on our performance. And so, in this 2.3 billion, we are also investing to accelerate this transformation. So we will be there while we need to accelerate the entire ecosystem I mentioned earlier to move much faster on the work being done with administrations, with regulators, and the work being done in certain key sectors. I will mention a few of them where we will also invest heavily with France Relance: quantum, artificial intelligence, cybersecurity, because these are sectors where there is a need for strong public investments, because we know they are very capital-intensive, because we know they are critical, and if we want a strong and sovereign ecosystem, we need to invest much more at the French and European levels. We know we need breakthrough investments and that we cannot ask the private sector alone to carry this burden. In fact, no ecosystem in the world is financed solely by the private sector, neither the Americans nor the Chinese.

And so, we must also be much stronger in the investments we will make in these verticals. The strategy we will, if I may say so, consolidate in the coming months means that, based on this and everything we have acquired, we can dream much higher and much stronger because we are investing, I am convinced, in the right place, in an ecosystem that is ready, and at the same time, as I mentioned earlier, we are investing in fundamental research and technological research through the law that will simplify many mechanisms, but also through public investment upstream. And so, it is a continuum that is extremely coherent. This is the first pillar that, in the post-Covid era, tells us: we all accelerate and we take responsibility with the ecosystem. The second pillar is to consolidate the historical strengths of the French model. And I believe we are at a turning point in this post-Covid exit where we have talked a lot, we were talking about it as early as March, about the post-Covid era. This post-Covid time will last. We all need to be clear about this. There is no need to deceive ourselves. And so, in any case, this world we are reinventing, which will likely be a gradual exit because the virus will continue to circulate. But we must have even more strength to think about this post-world or this transitional world. I believe we must collectively carry the French strengths that we had somewhat forgotten or that until now were seen as burdens.

Let me explain. If we want to succeed given the transformations underway, we need to have regulatory stability and a well-regulated ecosystem. This is our strength. And we have succeeded in recent years in gaining simplicity, in having experimentation, in bringing our regulatory ecosystem closer to the private ecosystem. We need to accelerate on this, to strengthen it.

But let us not forget one thing: having a regulated ecosystem is an unprecedented strength because all democratic systems will regulate their digital technology, sooner or later. We have started to do this, and we are relatively mature on this point. What we need to continue doing is to simplify and accelerate because you need speed. And so we must gain in speed, but the infrastructures are there. And so I think that if we want to succeed, we must increasingly multiply the procedures for rescript, multiply partnership procedures, succeed in innovating in terms of regulation to gain regulatory speed collectively, in simplicity. But this is a strength of the French model if we can get past this hurdle.

The other thing is equipment. France is a country of networks, of equipment, historically roads, water pipelines, and now digital equipment. Thanks to the New Deal, we must finalize, and this is one of the objectives, one of the KPIs of the Secretary of State in the coming months; we are also accelerating his objectives, so 3G/4G everywhere and high-speed mobile internet. But we must go further, stronger. I think we will accelerate this, and obviously, we will move to 5G. I want to be very clear: France is the country of Enlightenment, it is the country of innovation, and many of the challenges we face in all sectors will be met through innovation. And so we will explain, debate, dispel doubts, and put to rest all the false ideas. But yes, France will take the turn of 5G because it is the turning point of innovation. And I hear many voices rising to explain to us that we should address the complexity of contemporary problems by going back to the oil lamp, but I do not believe in the Amish model. And I do not believe that the Amish model can solve the challenges of contemporary ecology. And so we will continue to equip, innovate. But simply, innovation must not be only technological; it must also be societal and social, and we must face fears head-on. There are fears related to these innovations. We must dispel them by telling the truth, finding the right compromises, and explaining, measuring through informed citizen debate.

And then, for me, there are three key elements in the French model today that we must value and accelerate if we want to succeed. This is what I would call education, health, and climate. Education: we have one of the best educational systems in the world. It has its flaws; we still have weaknesses. We have invested a lot, and we continue to invest in the French educational model to improve its performance. But we have a very high-quality public education system, from age 3 to higher education. This is an element of attractiveness. You are a talent economy; the sector needs to attract talent. We must value this element. What other economy in the world allows talents to educate their children in public schools with exceptional quality throughout their lives? France. And we have not said it enough, emphasized it enough, or valued it enough. When they have salaries that may be double those on the West Coast, they have a model that is hyper-selective on a monetary basis for their children. And so we must update the cost of this education throughout life. For us, it is zero; it is a strength, it is a strength of attractiveness for innovation, and it is a strength of attractiveness over time.

The second element is health. We had reinvested 8 billion euros in our healthcare system, which was already one of the most efficient in the world, 8 billion euros per year with the famous Ségur. It was legitimate, and it adds to a new modernization of our system and our historical strengths. But our healthcare system, too, is not only one of the best in terms of research and support, but it is fair and is almost free with an extraordinarily reduced co-payment. This is an element of attractiveness, and it must be valued. In a world where we have seen the panic related to the epidemic, we do not have a system of health exclusion. And I tell you this because for years and years, we had a shameful social model, and we looked at the social model only through its cost. We said it was a terrible factor of non-competitiveness, non-attractiveness. False. We have corrected our fiscal biases, but now we must make our historical social model a lever of attractiveness for all talents from around the world. Because this model has no equivalent, and because our attractiveness and the consolidation of our ecosystem will not happen by degrading this model. There is no democratic path in this direction. You will not convince any French person to finance tomorrow's investments by degrading the educational and social model. Simply, we must finally make it an element of talent attractiveness. And this is fundamental.

The third point is climate. We have initiated the climate transition. We French and we Europeans believe in the Paris Agreement. We all know the efforts this requires. We have begun deep transitions in electricity and energy production but also in how we move and live, with many constraints, and with sometimes social upheavals that we have experienced in the country. Now we are accelerating things because 30% of the investment plan will be on this transition. This is an enormous strength, and we must value this French and European strength regarding climate. Because in your ecosystem, all talents believe in it and want to believe in it. And because especially they are entering an ecosystem that is sustainable, which is not the case for a Chinese or American ecosystem today.

For me, this triptych is a triptych that, when we speak to the intelligence of people and thus to those you need — financiers, actors, talents in all sectors — is an enormous element of attractiveness, and at the same time something that will make us stronger because it rests on our historical foundations.

The third element that makes me optimistic about the recovery is the fact that this moment of transition is the moment when we can accelerate the transformation in terms of inclusivity. This was mentioned earlier by several of you, but we can clearly see that our societies are searching for meaning. They realize that there cannot be a world in which we work in a company whose sole objective is to make profit and accumulate wealth; and then we can return to a society whose objectives would be social inclusivity, gender equality, peace in all neighborhoods of the Republic, and the fight against climate change. This model no longer works. Yesterday, we celebrated the 50th anniversary of Friedman’s paper; the model is dead, it no longer works. Therefore, the model must be changed. And it should not be changed by — this is my major disagreement with some — tax laws or rules in a single country. Just as socialism in one country did not work, inclusivity in one country does not work. We must transform global markets through inclusivity that we place at the heart of the company. This is the social and environmental responsibility of the 21st century, profoundly transformed and accelerated. And I deeply believe that our ecosystem is ahead in this regard. Therefore, we must promote it, invest in it, and go all in. That is why the minister is with us today, and I commend her presence, and I think it is a very strong signal. It is that you are the actors of this transformation, at least those who will enable it to flourish. And this is also what makes the actors of European French Tech, our global French Tech, but all European tech ecosystems, in my opinion, ahead. It is that these values today are not carried or are carried late and haphazardly by the American digital giants, and even less so by the Chinese digital giants.

But gender equality, equal opportunities regardless of origin, the inclusion of practices across all territories, the inclusion of our youth in the opportunities offered to them, are at the core and must remain at the core of the model that is ours, both in the development of our ecosystem and in what it will also succeed in innovating in the rest of the economy, in its capacity to shake up the rest of the economy. And the Tech for Good initiatives we have led to try to pull the global ecosystem in this direction, to the Tech for Value initiatives you have launched and that must continue to be developed, through Les Déterminés and everything that has been done as an initiative by all of you, we need to continue this.

But above all, if we want to differentiate ourselves and if we want the creation of the upcoming economy and the model in which we believe not to be something anecdotal that is simply a sector for urban hipsters from certain neighborhoods but to engage the country, which is what we believe very deeply, the demonstration must now be made — which is already a reality on the ground — that these creations, these consolidations, this transformation through digital technology touches all of France, all levels of skills, all metropolitan and overseas territories, and that it carries the values we believe in. And I think that this is a tremendous lever for acceleration towards a more inclusive world, to accelerate the transformation we believe in, but also to have an ecosystem that is not only an ecosystem that creates value but that is also meaningful.

I also find that the examples you provided earlier showed this: there is always something very strong because your employees, like the founders you are, are united by this. They are also communities of meaning and commitment. And I think that this corresponds very deeply to what the economic and social model of the 21st century is. Our fellow citizens believe in this model much more than in one where, in a way, the employee would have objectives that are no longer the same as those of the consumer or the citizen. That is over. People want to find a unique sense and commitment. And I think that through the digital ecosystem, what we can do is accelerate this.

And then my last point is the European model. And this ties in with what several of you have said. I believe that as we accelerate French investment, we must better leverage our historical strengths by showcasing them and that we must accelerate our transition towards greater inclusivity; this exit from the crisis must lead us to be more European. This is what we managed to do in July with the European agreement, but it is vital for you. This was very well articulated by Alexandre [Yazdi] just now: your market is often national, and the European market in digital is an addition of domestic markets. So we will not do this overnight, I will be honest. Even if we build a single digital market, we have started to lay the foundations, the real difficulty is that what you need is not simply a single digital market but unique markets in all sectors. Because you are not just digital. You always have verticals that seek in all sectors. But we must accelerate this consolidation because it is what allows you to access critical mass much faster and more strongly. And so, yes, the European battle is a battle for the acceleration of this model and its transformation. Therefore, we will continue to work to open markets, in the right sense of the term, that is to say, to remove barriers that are obstacles to creating opportunities for our entrepreneurs, to eliminate bad regulations, and to build at the European level the right regulations.

I believe in a European digital market that is a market that removes barriers, that prevents actors from having a real European market right away, but that at the same time builds the regulations that citizens need to protect their privacy, to protect their data, to protect their security. And so, at the same time as we talk about simplification, acceleration, we also talk every time we talk about Europe about sovereignty. And true sovereignty is built at the European level. And if we want our ecosystem to be sustainable, it must be sovereign, and we have several battles to fight on this issue. But we know that we have two: a technological battle over 5G and many other issues also in software where we must not depend on any non-European power if we want to be sovereign at the European level. We also have this battle over the cloud because today we have lost it, let’s be clear, and we must reopen it. Because if we want to sustainably control our ecosystem, if we really want to be sovereign at the European level, we must reopen this issue. We will not resolve it in two months or six months. But for me, in the moment that is opening up, this is obviously where we must raise our ambition.

So here are some perspectives I wanted to share with you to tell you everything we have been able to do together, that we have held on to, but above all for me these four pillars on which we must build the future. Our recovery plan, our ability to consolidate on the historical French model and, in essence, to transform it based on its historical strengths, our ability to truly build inclusivity and the meaningful enterprise of the 21st century. The term CSR must not remain a marginal activity, and it is you who can place it at the heart of the system, and the ability to build a European strategy. These are the four convictions for the future that, I believe, will allow us to go much faster and much stronger. And now, I am ready to answer all your questions or engage in discussion.