Speech by President Emmanuel Macron to the French community in Poland

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

3 February 2020

Context
Macron addressed the French community in Poland during a state visit on February 3, 2020, reviewing bilateral ties and celebrating 100 years of Franco-Polish diplomatic relations.
Main themes
Franco-Polish relations, French community in Poland, bilateral trade and investment, shared history and heritage, diplomatic relations centenary, French companies in Poland, military history and veterans, European partnership, cultural ties
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,213
87th percentile
Sentences
150
81st percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 39%37%
  • Ceremonial 23%22%
  • Economic 17%16%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Environmental 8%8%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

150 sentences in 12 paragraphs

Happy to see you again, Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers, Mr. Vice President, Members of Parliament, Ladies and Gentlemen, Mr. Ambassador, dear Frédéric, and Madame, thank you for welcoming us, very happy to see you again.

I am very happy, along with the entire delegation, to be among you, to see you again, to see many friendly faces I encountered a little over three years ago when I came for the first time but under different circumstances and at the end of a very busy day. We had numerous meetings, which I will quickly report to you as well. And I especially want to spend some time among you. But I had to first express some thanks and also take stock of our presence here, the situation of the French community, and all the work that is being done.

First, I want to thank those who came this evening, some of whom traveled from the other end of Poland; I was told that some came from quite far away, and I thank you for that; I am very sensitive to it. But I also want to thank your representatives here this evening, your deputy and president of the France-Poland Friendship Group in the National Assembly, Mr. Frédéric PETIT, all the consular advisors, Deputy Pieyre-Alexandre ANGLADE, who is very active on European issues, and also Senator Jean-Pierre LELEUX, president of the France-Poland Friendship Group in the Senate. They keep the bilateral relationship alive where they are, as I mentioned with the consular advisors, and they also sometimes respond to the difficulties you face. All the topics help to nurture things, and I am extremely sensitive to that. And I recognize the friendly face of the Commissioner in front of me, whom I greet, as we are fortunate to have a European Commissioner among us this evening. He is not infiltrated; he is invited. Thank you, dear Commissioner. You all know the history of the Franco-Polish relationship, and it has roots that go back a long way. I will not recount it here because you are sometimes its heirs; you keep it alive, you are, if I may say so, its vestals. It is the 100th anniversary of diplomatic relations that we celebrated last year; it is a relationship that goes beyond diplomacy, made up of emotions, shared heroes. I said that if Frédéric CHOPIN has his body in Paris, he has his heart in Warsaw, and we each pull the blanket over ourselves. Marie CURIE has the same issue, and we have thus multiplied, if I may say, our mutual romantic conquests. It is also a military history where Napoleon BONAPARTE allowed for the first recognitions and the birth of duchies, and where France can boast of never having been one of the powers that truly dominated or subjugated Poland. And where, conversely, General DE GAULLE, who was here 53 years ago as president, was a young soldier who came to fight in another context, and we will also celebrate those anniversaries. It is all this history that we celebrate, that we will continue to celebrate. I will return to this tomorrow in Krakow so that Polish students can measure the strength of this bond, so that we can also continue to keep it alive. That is why I invited Poland for the upcoming July 14, and it is also why we will be present for the celebrations of the Centenary of the Miracle on the Vistula on August 15, which will again be an opportunity to celebrate this brotherhood in arms. And I want to acknowledge, they must be here, but I cannot see them with the darkness or the lights in their faces, but the ministers earlier decorated some of the veterans, and I want to salute them here because some Polish veterans of the Second World War who were with us earlier and who fought for us were there and were decorated. In the same way, I want to celebrate some of the heroes who mark this bilateral friendship, including those who recently saved French men and women. This is the bilateral relationship that is inscribed in history and that you keep alive because this daily partnership has a cement, it is your presence.

More than 6,000 French men and women registered, half of whom reside in Warsaw. You are a strong community in business, higher education, scientific research, with many young people also coming to study and do international volunteering. And I know how much you can count on the support of the embassy, the consulate general in Krakow, our six honorary consuls, and our consular advisors. And I want to thank all the teams for this work this evening. There are more than 1,100 French companies present in Poland. I pointed this out earlier, feeling that I was almost disturbing President DUDA by reminding him of this reality of the numbers: industries, services, banks, commerce, energy, agri-food; I reminded him that we are the third-largest employer in the country. We have crossed the threshold of 20 billion euros in bilateral trade. We are the fourth-largest investor in Poland; I mentioned we are the third-largest employer, and we can still do better. First, because we have a bilateral trade deficit and because many things can still be pushed further. That is why the economic forum that took place this afternoon under the auspices of Bruno LE MAIRE and Elisabeth BORNE was important, and I want to thank all the French companies that participated, as well as the 42 foreign trade advisors and the Chamber of Commerce and Industry that keep this business community alive every day. And I hope that we can do even more; I will return to that in a moment.

We also have strong educational cooperation, and I discussed earlier with the Prime Minister the situation of the French high school René GOSCINNY in Warsaw. It is an institution of excellence, with more than 750 students from kindergarten to high school, known and recognized in Warsaw, which has just celebrated its centenary. I also want to salute the management and educational community of the high school who work daily for the success of their students, with a 98% success rate at the baccalaureate in 2019, and who are a true example of this excellence. The opening of a Polish international section next school year also shows a desire for rooting, and I hope that we can go further in the framework of the strategy we have wanted with the Minister of Foreign Affairs and his colleague from the Ministry of National Education, which is part of the reform we have carried out of the AEFE, that is to say, to have more students, also allowing it to be a lever to develop French. And I am convinced, Mr. Ambassador was there, that we will finalize the agreements that will allow the project of reunification of the sites, which will complete what we wish to do here in good intelligence with the authorities. I also take this opportunity to salute the staff of the French Institute in Warsaw, the Alliances Françaises, the decentralized cooperation centers that carry out training actions that contribute to the influence of our country and that are also an indispensable link in this cooperation. We work hand in hand with, as I said, the Polish authorities so that all these projects move forward, and I want to thank all those who are engaged on these educational and cultural issues. I also want to salute the parents of students who have been involved since the creation of the French high school in the management of the institution, who are involved daily, and to whom we owe a lot. All these thanks remind us of both the depth of our relations, their vitality, and your role. Because I come here, and I am pleased to see you again, but it is what you keep alive every day that makes this possible, which is the trace of our country, the vitality of the link between these women and men. I know that some are finishing their studies, others have found love here, some have been here for several generations; there are as many stories as there are faces, but there is always the role that is yours to keep the bilateral relationship alive at an extremely important moment for it and for our Europe. So the objective of our visit today was precisely to strengthen what exists and to open a new chapter, because the last few years have sometimes been marked by misunderstandings, conflicts, perhaps, disagreements for sure, and I deeply believe that, for our two countries as for Europe, we need to open a new chapter. That is what we have tried to do and what I will continue to pursue tomorrow in Krakow. We know what has caused the hesitations of recent years, sometimes the setbacks, contradictions, or frustrations, in a situation where Poland has sometimes seen the United States more as an ally than its European partners. I will not revisit the Caracal incident here, out of respect for Jean-Yves LE DRIAN, who, I believe, made 13 or 14 visits as Minister of the Armed Forces at the time. We explained ourselves in 2017 with President DUDA. But there are things that were not acceptable between allies, between member countries of Europe. When contracts are concluded, they must be honored. It is true that things were slowing down in that area.

On the climate front, there were hesitations. And on the principles of Europe, I had the opportunity to tell the President, the Prime Minister, and during the press conference, it is clear that European values have been shaken or continue to be shaken by difficult decisions that, moreover, are the subject of positions and procedures led by the European Commission, the Court of Justice, the Council of Europe, behind which France stands not because it has judged another member state; that is not our role, and we have no lessons to give to anyone, but because it is our values that are at stake. But we must not stop at this kind of tipping point, this latency, this hesitation. Ultimately, my conviction is that by re-engaging in the bilateral relationship and re-engaging Poland even more in a European adventure, it seems to me that we can do more, better, and succeed in showing Poland and its people that its future is built in this relationship and in a reinvestment in Europe, and not in decisions that could marginalize it within Europe; I believe that is the deeply important role of France, and to do it in the name of history and with the strength of history, because our common history is a history made of freedom, courage, and common struggles. That is what I tried to convey today and what I hope we can advance on a bilateral level, being aware of our disagreements, without any naivety, but by re-engaging this new chapter. On the subjects of disagreement, the principles, the upcoming justice reform, I said, we support the Commission. I hope that the work that President VON DER LEYEN will re-engage with the Commission will allow us to move forward and find a positive outcome. I think that is desirable for everyone.

Then, on the strategic level, we had a discussion, and I believe that our vision is compatible with Poland's interests. Our vision is simple: the Atlantic Alliance does not exhaust all of our common security, and we have to work on NATO and European defense to build the collective security of Europe. These are the two pillars of the collective security of our continent, of our European Union. That is what we believe in. Sometimes, our discourse has been caricatured. Sometimes, it has been disruptive; I am aware of that. But I said earlier, our bilateral relationship will be strong, and the European idea will be strong here when Polish women and men are sure that it is Europe that protects and defends them, and perhaps especially so. Moreover, our American ally asks nothing more than for us to re-engage, he who wants to spend less on our defense and considers that our neighborhood is not his. That is why I believe in what we have launched for now two and a half years, a strengthened cooperation in defense, a European defense fund to intervene, and this European intervention initiative to bring our common cultures closer and work together. I have also heard Poland's desire to eventually join this European intervention initiative. In this context, we need to be coherent. That is what I told my interlocutors. We also need to strengthen bilateral ties on the industrial level and on the operations to be carried out together. I believe that in the coming weeks and months, from Lebanon to the Sahel to the Baltic Sea, we have common theaters of operations that can be deployed. I know that the Minister of the Armed Forces has worked on this with her counterpart, and I also know that we have projects. There is a Polish interest in the future tank that we are developing, among others, with the Germans, and there are also many projects on which we need to act for greater European cooperation and thus bilateral cooperation. I deeply believe that this vision we carry is essential; it is compatible with Poland's security, with a bilateral and European ambition.

In this context, and I would say within the framework of this first geostrategic and defense pillar, I had the opportunity, of course, to address the Russian question which has also raised many questions, sometimes anxieties given the history and geography, if I may say so. These anxieties are legitimate because recent years have not contributed to reassuring. But here too, I have told my interlocutors and I believe very deeply, I have said it and I will say it again tomorrow, France has not suddenly become pro-Russian, any more than it has to be anti-Russian, but France is pro-European and Europe has a geography and a history, and this cannot be viewed without integrating Russia and without trying to reintegrate it into a framework of trust and security that we need to rebuild. If we consider that Europe does not exist outside of NATO or independently of NATO or with its own voice within NATO, these three realities being true and compatible with each other, but if Europe does not carry its own voice regarding Russia and if we take refuge in the caricature that is sometimes made of ourselves, that is to say being the visible face of American influence in this part of the globe, we will never be able to move forward. Who, today, suffers from economic sanctions, frozen conflicts, the impossibility of stabilizing a framework of trust in Europe, if not Europe itself and the Europeans? Not those who live on the other side of the world and who push us to go further in this direction. So we need to seek ways and means to rebuild trust without any naivety. I have said it, I speak to you from a place, having lived in the past as a candidate for the presidential election enough adventures with our friends to have no naivety. But we need to re-engage in a dialogue of trust with Russia, to do so on cyber issues, on space issues, on the frozen conflicts in the region, obviously on the Ukrainian crisis, but also on the major security issues that concern us and concern Poland above all. I mentioned two earlier. The first is the Ukrainian crisis. Look at the results. We have re-engaged in a demanding dialogue, but we have reopened this path. For the first time in 5 years, we have been able to make progress within the framework of the Minsk process, hold a Normandy summit in Paris in November, and advance on the Ukrainian crisis as we had not done for years. We are not at the end of the road, but it shows the useful effect of such an approach. The other point on which this approach is essential is that of arms control. Look closely at the last 10 years, they have led to the dismantling of major international treaties, which were often bilateral treaties dating back to the Cold War that ensured the security of Europe, the last being the so-called INF treaty. Russia no longer respected it, the United States decided to end it without consulting us. Who are the victims of this new international order without law? We, Europeans. Who are the first victims? Poland, so close to the border, and which the Iskander missiles, which were not covered by the INF treaty, can hit overnight. We must therefore rebuild in this demanding dialogue a framework of trust that allows for arms control in the region. It is in our interest. I tell you this so that you can grasp how the French approach towards Russia fits into this desire for greater European sovereignty in military and defense matters, but also in preserving the interests of all our allies, particularly Polish, and how the current situation does not fulfill this objective. This is, for me, the first axis of this new chapter that we have to write in bilateral and European terms.

The second axis is on major climate and energy issues. This is a tremendous challenge for all of us, extraordinarily anxiety-inducing for many, and I would say even more difficult perhaps in Poland than elsewhere, with a tremendous injustice that must not be denied, which is that if Poland depends so much on coal, it is not a sovereign decision it made at the time but a decision imposed by those who, here, had the yoke. We cannot ignore this situation and suddenly tell Poland: "more than 80% of your electricity is produced with coal or hydrocarbons, go ahead, switch." You know better than I do, there are millions of citizens engaged in these sectors, entire regions, it is a whole model that needs to change. Nevertheless, none of us have a choice, and this climate ambition is at the heart of our project. France is fully committed to the green pact that was proposed by the Commission a few weeks ago. I had the opportunity to say it, I completely identify with it and it has taken up many of the campaign commitments we have made. It is ambitious and proposes, in Europe, to move towards carbon neutrality by 2050, to invest massively in new technologies, to have a carbon inclusion mechanism at our borders to preserve our competitiveness, and to increase the cost of CO2 to enable this transition. Simply, we will need to support Poland, and we will do so in two ways that, by the way, reflect this desire for both bilateral and European cooperation, by supporting the idea of a just transition fund and doing everything to ensure that this fund can benefit the poorest regions and countries as much as possible, which need it for this transition. This is absolutely key for Poland to be able to commit to this path of carbon neutrality and make these changes. And the second thing is by cooperating economically and industrially to build nuclear energy in Poland, because Poland has made this choice and because it is very difficult, even today impossible, to move from 80% coal to a mix that is completely renewable given the intermittency of this energy. The nuclear component that Poland wishes to acquire, France has a role to play in terms of technology, industry, and strategic cooperation, so that it integrates into its energy mix. We have started discussions and we will continue them. But this energy and climate axis is, for me, the second major aspect of this bilateral relationship and dialogue.

The third is our economic and industrial policy. You are the artisans of it, but we have much to do together on a bilateral and European level because, first of all, we have the same vision of things. The idea, and I commend the Polish commissioner who worked under the previous mandate when she was in charge of industry, and Commissioner BIENKOWSKA did a lot on this subject, and I know that the new commission will continue to work on this matter, we need to find, at the European level, a real industrial, commercial, climate, and technological sovereignty policy that is coherent. This means that we need to take control of our future and decide on our choices. In terms of industrial policy, we are not in a closed world, we know how to deal with competition among ourselves, but our competitors are American, Chinese, they are giants and we must integrate these dimensions when we look at our concentrations. This also means having a regulatory policy in the major sectors that allows us to have champions whether in digital, energy, or others. Then we need a coherent trade policy in this regard. We cannot simply be an open market to all winds, we need to defend our interests, develop our standards, and in the trade policy that we will have to define, implement a trade policy that is coherent with the climate agenda. We cannot ask our industrialists to evolve, to change and open our borders to industries coming from the other side of the world that do not make the same efforts. This is also an element of sovereignty. And then we need to regain technological sovereignty and I commend the decision, the communication presented by the European Commission last week on 5G. We talked a lot about it with Prime Minister MORAWIECKI, which is an important element of a Europe that decides to establish standards, a common approach to avoid being the theater of influence games and to do everything to ensure that our two major industrial players, our two major equipment manufacturers help on the most strategic issues to have a sovereign Europe in technological terms. And behind that means that we have a lot to do on all these subjects and a lot to build on a bilateral level. The forum I mentioned earlier, which the Minister of Ecological and Solidarity Transition and the Minister of Economy chaired, is a lever for this re-engagement of the bilateral relationship within the framework of a policy that we want to be stronger in industrial and economic terms.

I do not want to be longer here before you but I wanted to reiterate some of the major axes that I came here to defend. I believe that by re-engaging Poland within this framework, with the requirement that is ours, we can on the one hand do more on a bilateral level and on the other hand, at a time when Brexit has marked these last days a new phase and where Great Britain is leaving our European Union, re-engage a strategic partner like Poland at its rightful level in the European adventure, that is to say as an actor in the energy and climate transition, as a partner in the geostrategic and defense relationship, as a major player in economic and innovation terms. I believe that this new page, if we manage to carry it, will mark something profoundly new and fruitful both bilaterally and in European terms. When I look at the history of the last decades, it seems, and under your control, that there has long been here, I reiterated earlier, the feeling of a form of abandonment by Europeans. Europe, particularly Western Europe, had let a curtain fall and Poland be dominated by others. And perhaps there was after Poland joined the European Union the feeling of humiliation, of vexation. The status was not the same, it was necessary to imitate a model that existed, that of Western Europe, do we have our rightful place? And on this feeling, on these two feelings, a form of irredentism, of nationalism perhaps, of closure sometimes has grown. I believe it is up to all of us, and I say this to each of you wherever you are in this beautiful country, to show that one can be proud of Poland and deeply European. And that this pro-European sentiment should ultimately guide our future destinies. This is not written and I have neither irenicism nor naivety. But if we show that through this attachment, this anchoring, this new strategy we protect better, we defend better the interests of Poland because it is in Europe and because it is European, I believe we will have done something useful. And I believe above all that you will live even happier there and we will live together in this beautiful Europe longer. These are some of the words, the convictions that I wanted to share with you after this first day and before perhaps meeting some of you in Krakow tomorrow, meeting our students. I wanted to thank again the ministers who accompany me and the parliamentarians who keep this relationship alive, to thank you Mr. Ambassador, Madam, and to thank each and every one of you for the incredibly important role you play every day for this relationship.

Long live Franco-Polish friendship, long live the Republic, and long live France!