Statements by Emmanuel Macron, Filippo Grandi, and António Vitorino

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

22 July 2019

Context
Macron addressed a joint press conference with UNHCR and IOM chiefs on July 22, 2019, outlining France's humanitarian response to the Libyan refugee crisis.
Main themes
Refugee crisis in Libya, humanitarian protection, voluntary and assisted return programs, Mediterranean crossings, asylum policy, trafficking network dismantlement, France-Niger cooperation, UNHCR and IOM partnerships, European Union coordination, African Union cooperation, South-South transit, OFPRA protection program
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,243
78th percentile
Sentences
108
67th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
15.2
78th percentile
Syntax
3.18
70th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 31%29%
  • Institutional 24%22%
  • Social 22%20%
  • Ceremonial 21%19%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

108 sentences in 14 paragraphs

Well, I wanted to thank our friends for being here today, the Director General of the International Organization for Migration, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, and the European Commissioner for Labor who worked this morning with the Ministers of the Interior, Foreign Affairs, and their counterparts. The ministers can join us. They then worked with us this afternoon. There was, this morning, European work, and this afternoon work on the situations that make up your daily life and that concern us greatly. I will simply say a few words after these thanks for your commitment and the commitment of your institutions, and to tell you how much we stand by your side. We have a priority, which is above all a humanitarian priority, which is the situation today in Libya. We have indeed witnessed bombings of refugee camps. We had again this morning attacks against the camps and buildings of the UNHCR, an extremely concerning situation that threatens the lives of refugees every day, women and men who are in Libya and who want to build a future in countries they have often fled for political reasons that may justify their eventual asylum, sometimes for economic and social reasons, but who are in a situation of great vulnerability. In the face of this situation, I draw several conclusions. The first is an urgent request from France to the Libyan authorities to put an end to the confinement and the situations currently constructed on the ground regarding these populations and to allow, in connection with the UNHCR, the IOM, and all the forces present, that these people who are in transit, waiting, can be put to safety according to protocols that have indeed been proposed by the aforementioned international organizations. The second thing is that we can resume what we launched right here at the end of August 2017, then in Abidjan in November 2017, in connection with the International Organization for Migration, the African Union, and the European Union, and in close coordination with the UNHCR, which is a program allowing the voluntary and assisted return of people who are currently refugees in Libya to their country of origin, which is what is called South-South transit. Many people have often been abused by trafficking networks that promised them mountains and wonders, and find themselves in situations of modern slavery or great risk in Libya. This is what we have managed to put in place. Several thousand people have then returned to their country of origin thanks to this program. The second operational conclusion is that we will relaunch this program and commit, with the European Union and our European partners, to finance, in close connection with the African Union, such a program that will also allow these populations to be sheltered by returning to their country of origin, especially when we talk about women and men who are not in a true asylum-seeking situation but who have rather fled for economic or social reasons. The third thing is that we will strengthen our means and our cooperation with Niger, with which we have absolutely exemplary cooperation, to improve precisely the control and dismantling of trafficking networks, because, as we know, they are numerous, the Agadez route being one of the most exposed routes. Niger is a country with which we cooperate very well, I think particularly of the work we can do bilaterally, whether it is Germany, France, or the European Union, and so we will relaunch very concrete actions with Niger to improve the effectiveness of our programs. Finally, on this subject, I had announced, in August 2017, a program for the protection of individuals, with specific missions from OFPRA in connection with international organizations. I had committed to a program of 10,000 protections. We are about to finalize this program, and France, alongside Germany and Spain, is the country that cooperates and contributes the most to this effort, which is a legitimate effort, allowing women and men who have the right to asylum to be put under protection without taking all the risks and crossing the Mediterranean. This program has shown its effectiveness. France has met this commitment, and so not only will we finalize it, but I wish to make new commitments here so that we can continue this protection of these populations, which, I believe, is also an effective response, and I hope that our European partners can accompany us in this effort, which is also an effective and proportionate response because we are talking about women and men to whom we owe asylum and who are threatened in their country. Then, in the face of this situation, this is the second aspect after the strictly Libyan aspect, we discussed the situation this summer regarding the crossings of the Mediterranean, so all the stakeholders at this afternoon's meeting will coordinate with NGOs to be able to act effectively, that is to say, in a way that is both humane, humanitarian, and effective regarding the crossings, avoiding all the risks taken, and that is all the work we have put in place for cooperation with the Libyan coast guards, which has shown its effectiveness subject to the first points I just mentioned. It is then to ensure that no risk is taken for any vessel whatsoever and by any organization whatsoever on these crossings, and that finally, we have an appropriate response at the European level. In the face of this issue, I believe in responsibility and solidarity. We must respect humanitarian rules and maritime law, and therefore when a boat is in international waters or leaves Libyan waters and takes on refugees, it must find refuge in the nearest safe port. This rule is a necessity, it is a legal necessity and a practical necessity. We must not ask these boats to take risks, to put at risk women and men who are sometimes in extremely precarious situations seeking protection. In the face of this, it is evident that political situations have emerged in Europe, which have strained things and sometimes created extremely tense situations. I believe that the only way to resolve them effectively is through cooperation. I regret that some have decided not to attend the meeting of the Interior Ministers this morning, which was initiated after the Helsinki meeting by the ministers, because we never gain anything from non-cooperation. On the other hand, I want to say here that we must strengthen the effectiveness of our solidarity among Europeans. When a vessel arrives in any state in Europe, which is the state of first entry, to protect women and men, today and since the beginning of our commitment, France is among the countries that have cooperated the most and provided, through OFPRA, missions to seek this protection for those who are entitled to it. The difficulty is that until now, the mechanism was not sufficiently stable, not sufficiently visible, and the burden for the states of first arrival could seem unbearable. The conclusion of this morning's meeting is that, in principle, 14 member states at this stage have given their agreement on the Franco-German document presented by the Finnish presidency in Helsinki. Among these 14, 8 member states have actively agreed to their cooperation and thus their participation in these stable mechanisms, which will allow the Commissioner, in such a case, to activate these requests, and the response of 8 member states to be part of the solidarity that is necessary. Beyond that, what I wish is that we can move forward effectively so that all member states participate in this effort. I reiterate, for my part, this will be a key element of the upcoming financial perspectives. Europe is not the map when it comes to solidarity. We cannot have states that tell us: "I do not want your Europe when it comes to sharing the burden, but I want it when it comes to accessing structural funds." That will not last. In any case, I will not validate financial perspectives that go in this direction. But we need, in the short term, to be much more effective, so we will continue the diplomatic and persuasive work with the ministers to convince as many member states as possible on this mechanism, and we will strengthen the work, under the authority of the Commissioner, with all the competent services, including Frontex, to allow mechanisms for the return to the countries of origin of those who do not have the right to asylum to be much faster and much more effective than we have today. Otherwise, it is an undue burden for the countries of first entry, and we know that this has been, for years, the problem of Italy, denounced from the beginning of the Mare Nostrum crisis by Prime Minister Renzi at the time, and to improve the responsiveness of our systems with the UNHCR and the IOM to allow the organization of our work and the voluntary return of those who will not have the right to asylum in Europe, and to prevent the burden from returning to the countries of first entry. What I mean by that, in essence, is that we have consolidated the short-term distribution mechanism, that we wish to go further and anchor it in hard European law but that we also want to go further by holding all member states accountable, the existing community structures, and improving the effectiveness of our voluntary or forced return policies to the countries of origin. This is essential to improve both the effectiveness and the solidarity we owe to the countries of first entry. This is what we also owe to the European countries that have shown their sense of responsibility and courage in recent months. I think particularly of Malta, and I want to pay tribute to Malta and its Prime Minister, who have not ceased, during the crisis of recent months, to provide an extremely pragmatic response and have allowed Europe, I must say, to remain dignified. Now, I also put things in proportion. We are not in the situation of 2015 on the central Mediterranean route. While we were truly facing extremely strong migratory pressure in 2015, we are talking, under the control of the Commissioner, of about 40,000 arrivals since the beginning of the year, which is much more modest, by this route. So we are, on this issue, in a situation that is extremely different and that allows us to have a pragmatic response. Those are the few words I wanted to say. France's commitment is complete to pursue both a humane, effective policy that corresponds to our principles without being a policy of laxity, responsibilities but which above all allows us to uphold humanitarian law, international law, to respond to a humanitarian crisis that we are experiencing today in Libya in a conflict zone, to allow Europe to respond to these principles and also not to let populism rise anywhere. It is this equation that we must collectively solve. I thank again the authorities present today for the constant work we do together and I want to reiterate France's commitment here. Commissioner, I will now give you the floor.

Thank you, Mr. President. I will not take long; I just want to add a few words because I think the President of the Republic has been extremely clear. First, we at the UNHCR have three or four reasons to be pleased with the conclusions of today’s meeting, the conference this morning, and the discussions we had this afternoon. First, we certainly encourage Europe, and the Commissioner has really pushed for this and will play a crucial role in continuing to establish this solidarity and shared mechanism for people arriving in Europe, for those who have disembarked. This is a mechanism that IOM and UNHCR have discussed for a long time; it is now becoming a reality, and that is very important. It is obviously a European political decision to establish this mechanism; it is up to Europe to do so, but we are ready to play our role in supporting status determination, the voluntary return of those who are not recognized as refugees, etc. So we are ready to collaborate in this direction, and we hope that this sharing will be as broad as possible across Europe so that we can make progress on this issue. Secondly, we are certainly very pleased that the issue of rescues at sea has been addressed in the terms mentioned by the President of the Republic: it is essential to save lives at sea, and we are concerned — I admit it, I say it frankly — that the capacity for rescue in Europe has decreased in recent months, and we hope that the discussion this morning, where there were no opposing voices to the concept of rescue at sea, will be a step towards a more positive situation in this regard. Thirdly, we are pleased that the issue of detentions in Libya has been raised, particularly the detention of people who are disembarked by the Libyan coast guard, who intercept, as you know, as is their right, migrants and refugees in Libyan territorial waters. Our very great concern is that all these people, the vast majority of them, are sent or returned to detention centers that are centers of abuse and exploitation, which are at the heart of this human trafficking business that we all want to combat. Therefore, I think the pressure mentioned by the President of the Republic or the collaboration we must establish with the Libyan authorities to eliminate the very concept of detention and transform it into a concept of protection for refugees and migrants in Libya is very, very important so that we can continue to work in Libya with a clear conscience. Of course, I thank France very much, and I take this opportunity to thank France for the decision that has been made to continue the resettlement program for people in need of protection from Libya, through Niger, and perhaps other countries in the future. We are negotiating an agreement with Rwanda similar to the one we established with Niger, perhaps even broader. Therefore, this evacuation and resettlement mechanism, as we call it, is very important, especially for the most vulnerable cases. Finally, I would like to say that it is important not to forget that this whole phenomenon has its origins in conflict situations that often overlap with situations of poverty, climate emergency, and poor governance. Therefore, it is important not to lose, as was said this morning, the strategic dimension of this migration management. We must work urgently, and the decisions made this morning are very important and positive without losing sight of the more strategic aspect in this European debate on the resources to be invested in the coming years to address the root causes of forced population movements, to avoid political problems here but especially human problems for thousands of people. Thank you.

António Manuel de CARVALHO FERREIRA VITORINO

Thank you, Mr. President of the Republic. I would first like to commend the initiative of the French Republic to gather here today in Paris the interior and foreign ministers of the European Union and to support the conclusions we have reached, especially the idea of creating a mechanism for currently 8 plus the possibility of reaching 14 member states to support operations for the collection, rescue, redistribution, and return of migrants crossing the Mediterranean to Europe. It is essential that European public opinion is well aware that we are no longer experiencing a crisis of arrivals: the figures show a significant drop in arrivals in Europe. On the other hand, we are experiencing a crisis of deaths because the number of deaths in attempts to cross the Mediterranean is very high, and even one death would be too many. Therefore, you can count, Mr. President, on the support, commitment, and engagement of the International Organization for Migration to help European states and European institutions ensure respect for the lives of those trying to cross the Mediterranean and to guarantee protection for those entitled to international protection and the return to their country of origin for those who do not have the right to remain on the European continent. The second point I would like to make is that I truly hope that the very clear message you conveyed today, Mr. President, is well heard by the Libyan authorities: the situation of detention in Libya must end, which is unsustainable from both a humanitarian and political perspective. We have prepared together with the UN High Commissioner for Refugees to present concrete proposals, concrete solutions that allow for the protection and humanitarian support of migrants and refugees currently in detention camps in Libya. Finally, Mr. President, we believe that the approach pursued by France to support European initiatives is the best proof that multilateralism is alive and can be effective. You can count on IOM, on the (inaudible) system to ensure that the multilateral system produces results that respect fundamental rights, international order, and public safety. Thank you.

Unidentified speaker

Good evening. I would like to commend President MACRON's initiative because it is his initiative to organize a meeting here today in Paris to collectively respond to the migration challenge. I support the Franco-German initiative aimed at convincing as many member states as possible to show solidarity towards the member states on whose coasts rescued migrants are disembarked. To be effective, this must be part of a comprehensive approach that also involves combating smugglers, assisting migrants in third countries, ensuring the return of those who do not have the right to remain in Europe, and opening legal pathways such as resettlement. We must act in a united manner within the European Union but also with third countries. I am optimistic: we managed to face a major crisis in 2015 when we were neither prepared nor coordinated. Today, this is no longer the case. I count on the political will of all. Mr. President, once again, I must thank you for your initiative.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, thank you, ladies and gentlemen.

Emmanuel MACRON

But this will be part of the NGOs with which there will be a structured discussion following this meeting.

Emmanuel MACRON

Well, it has been said by our friends from UNHCR and IOM, I think we need, we need rescue capacities today. After that, there is a charter that has been established on good cooperation precisely with NGOs, and so I think this charter must be followed, but I think, and then we must collectively organize our work. We have a coordinator (inaudible) who is in charge of this subject; he was present with us at the meeting, we discussed it, and there will be, under the authority of the ministers in connection with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, the International Organization for Migration, and the European Commission, a dialogue with all the NGOs operating in the Mediterranean.

Emmanuel MACRON

But I tell you, it is good if it is within this framework. There you go. I think we need rescue capacity because none of us wants people to be subjected to impossibility, to the greatest risk, and that must be done within a framework of structured cooperation as we have defined, in respect of the Charter and in connection with all the countries that take their responsibilities, with France at the forefront, along with the international organizations mentioned earlier. Thank you.