Transcript of Emmanuel Macron's speech at the Senate during the national conference of territories

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

18 July 2017 · National conference of territories · Senate, France

Context
Macron addressed the inaugural National Conference of Territories on July 18, 2017, outlining his vision for reshaping relations between the state and local authorities.
Main themes
Territorial diversity and unity, decentralization, role of the state and local authorities, equality of opportunity across territories, local elected officials, rural and urban disparities, identity and daily life, globalization and homogenization, republican unity, democratic participation
Duration
~70 min
97th percentile
Words
8,436
97th percentile
Sentences
278
94th percentile
Readability
36
27th percentile
Grade
15.5
79th percentile
Syntax
3.24
77th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 46%45%
  • Economic 24%23%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Technological 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 3%

278 sentences in 110 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Mr. President of the National Assembly,

Mr. President of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials,

Ladies and gentlemen in your ranks and qualities,

I am very happy to be among you today because, as you have just reminded us in your remarks, what we are going to talk about is fundamentally about the daily lives of the French people and their future, and nothing else. In truth, we choose the term "territory" for lack of a better word. The French speak very little of territory; it is a word we use, but the French speak of their countryside, their mountains, their forests, the sea, their city, their village, their plains, their suburbs, the diversity that makes up their daily lives. And that is, in essence, the heart of the subject that is thus posed to us.

We are in a country that has been built by norms, by language, by the State, by taxes, it must be said, its administration, and whose great vectors of homogeneity have been imposed from above. However, our country is made up of multiple geographies; we remain eminently a country of terroirs and geographers, and in a globalization that tends to homogenize everything, the attachment of our fellow citizens to their daily lives and the reality of their territory grows stronger every day.

The challenge we face is not new, but it is becoming stronger every day; it is to reconcile the unity of the Republic that has made us, this globalization that sometimes disrupts great balances and in which we must advance, and the diversity of these territories that is constitutive of our identities, of our deep identity. And that is the entire challenge we face because this plurality of situations is lived by our fellow citizens in their daily lives, and they do not have the same daily life depending on whether they live in a very rural territory, a metropolitan suburb, a medium-sized provincial city, or whether they are in an overseas territory or a mountainous area, and we know this well.

The temptations of the extremes that you have mentioned are fueled by the daily documented feeling, it must be said, that our approach is monolithic, unilateral, univocal, and based on the principle of equality on which our Republic was built; we must today consider, in a way, a form of particular attention to an equality of opportunity among territories because the equality that creates uniformity no longer ensures equality of opportunity across our entire territory today.

It is this sensitivity that feeds the anxieties, the uncertainties that I know are numerous and – it is my deep wish – that our collective action in the coming years must allow us to resolve.

This territorial sensitivity is precisely this ability to listen to the millions of voices that express themselves every day throughout the mainland and overseas, this living and demanding democracy that weaves this common thread. I want to pay tribute here to the civil servants of the State and local authorities, as well as to local actors without whom nothing would be possible in this regard. And I also want to particularly thank, as you recalled in your opening remarks, the local elected officials because for a very large majority of them, their activity is almost voluntary, and for all of them, they have decided to dedicate a significant part of their lives to the public interest, without counting their hours when it comes to listening, acting, reweaving this link while taking risks, and on this point, as you mentioned, I indeed wish that we can bring this reflection already begun on the status of local elected officials to fruition, particularly regarding their responsibilities to respond to what constitutes the daily life of these elected officials today.

If we are together today, it is not to adjust once again the laws of decentralization to contemporary realities or to try to explain to the French in some way that their lives should conform to our administrative and institutional organizations. It has been too long since we have reasoned this way; I believe that our fellow citizens no longer see the end of it, we ourselves are confronted with the dissatisfaction, in a way, of this endless work, at least within sight, and in this regard, the philosophy that underpins this National Conference of Territories is rather to redefine the role of the State and local authorities in the daily lives of French women and men and to adapt this role to the transitions that our country must face.

To do this, we need to rethink deeply the interaction between the State and the said local authorities; we know the analyses perfectly well and we share them, but what we are establishing today with this Conference is a forum for exchange, consultation, and decision-making.

This conference will meet every six months under the presidency of the Prime Minister; it is composed of members of the government, representatives of local authorities, presidents of existing consultation bodies, and representatives of Parliament; it will address a number of transversal or territorial themes that will be dealt with over time; it must in no case lead to the re-centralization of subjects that fall under the daily dialogue between representatives of the State and local authorities in the territories, but from these negotiations, a pact of trust will emerge between the State and the territories defining for the next five years the respective commitments we must make.

At the heart of this project, I place our desire that every reform, every plan, every initiative launched by the government to implement public policies, for which responsibility is shared between the State and the territories, involves the concerned local authorities upstream. This conference, for all these reasons, Mr. President of the Senate, could not for its first meeting be held anywhere other than here in the Senate, which, under Article 24 of our Constitution, as you recalled, ensures the representation of local authorities of the Republic. That was my wish, and I thank you for accepting it and for welcoming us so perfectly.

The desire to establish this Conference stems from a simple reality that will structure my remarks. We have unprecedented transitions to experience; they require us to rethink deeply the role of the State; they require us to reconsider the method between the State and local authorities, and they inevitably lead us to rethink also the method and the realities of our financial relations.

**

Our time is indeed that of transitions. It is the challenge at the heart of all the public policies we must conduct; the relationship of the French with work, school, the environment, family, mobility, and leisure is changing profoundly, and this is due to the evolution of mentalities, knowledge, behaviors, and technologies, and therefore we cannot maintain the organizations, the reflexes, sometimes the pace that characterized a world that preceded these changes. We would make a historical diagnostic error if we thought that these transitions are the same everywhere and for everyone; on the contrary, they adopt, depending on the place, geography, and age groups, territorial and social dynamics that are profoundly different and whose consequences are profoundly different, but for each of these transitions, we must think about this equality of opportunity that I mentioned and move beyond the frameworks of thought that have sometimes been ours.

What rural areas demand is not charity, it is not to be compensated; it is to have the same chances of success; it is to have the same chances of success as other territories of the Republic where this is not the case today, because they no longer have the essential infrastructures for success in this changing world and the reality of useful public services in their daily lives.

The challenges are thus profoundly different depending on the territories, but with common demands across all these territories, this territorial equality of opportunity and the transitions we are experiencing have the characteristic of increasing individualization and differentiation by territory, whether in terms of digital technology or environmental transition; they reinforce these trends that are already at work.

Take the energy transition: it strengthens local production, the profound deconcentration of organizations where we were organized today in a very state-centric model with hyper-centralized production.

Take the digital transition: it gives the capacity to reproduce on the ground in a very differentiated manner; it allows for the redeployment of work perspectives in the territory, teleworking, but also 2.0 teleworking, which will completely change congestion phenomena if we go all the way with the necessary equipment, the capacity to do 3D printing or all modes of additive production, and precisely to enable all territories to meet these challenges. The industry of the future is emerging in all your territories, breaking down the distinction that had been made between industry and services. That time when entire territories were somehow condemned to build a future of services, where industries had deserted, is over.

It is false! Digital technology is reweaving links between industry and services, allowing for industrial productions to be brought closer to the ground, if we give ourselves the means.

All this to say that the reference points within which we have built public action until now have profoundly changed and lead us to rethink deeply the challenges of our territory, but at the same time, they have also very profoundly increased the disparity of situations and starting conditions.

I will not be exhaustive, but we can see well that the challenges are profoundly different depending on the types of territories.

Enclosed rural territories, whether in plains or mountains, face a challenge of access to essential infrastructures, whether it be road or rail infrastructures or digital infrastructures, and have to fight against the desertification of public services.

Our coastlines and mountains are experiencing increasing conflicts of use between potential economic development, the wishes of certain tourism or economic actors, and the wishes of their inhabitants. And the same people, by the way, who say they want a bright future for their territory are often the first to oppose certain projects when their inhabitants see, in the reality of their daily lives, the said conflict of use.

Territories affected by economic transformations and shocks related to globalization over the past twenty years face the challenge of the decline of our industrial footprint and, with it, the accumulation of economic and social difficulties, and have a need for the State, for aid, for redistribution that is very different from other regions of the Republic.

Medium-sized cities, for their part, must invent a new model of growth outside the metropolises, relying on sectoral advantages at a level they can establish, but also building, in connection with other medium-sized cities, a different cultural, economic, and educational policy. Thus, they will build renewed attractiveness.

Metropolises, finally, are obviously not exempt from these great transitions; they are even at their heart; they are today, in many respects, the winners of this globalization that favors the effect of centrality and metropolization, but they have to manage essential problems of pollution, congestion of spaces, which also requires working on new investments, the organization of the city of tomorrow.

How can we not mention the overseas territories that are often confronted with a cumulative number of difficulties that I have just mentioned but with extreme diversity because under this common denominator where they are often confined, what is common between Mayotte, Guyana, Guadeloupe, and Réunion? A distance perhaps from the Hexagon, but profoundly different economic, industrial realities, geographical tensions, and sometimes migratory tensions between these said territories. This is what has led the government to organize the Overseas Assizes in the fall, which will allow for a shared diagnosis and a roadmap for each territory to lead to concrete actions.

You have understood, through this diversity of situations, I want to express that these great transitions we have to experience impose on the State not to guarantee perfect equality, which is impossible, the dreamed uniformity, which can turn into a nightmare, but rather to fulfill its role and ensure equality of possibilities and opportunities and to enable each territory, given its starting constraints, to succeed in the transitions that are underway and that shape the contemporary world in which we must evolve.

That is why the State must reinvent its role in the face of this transition; the State must now act in a differentiated manner, taking into account these territorial realities, and in other words, it must stay as close as possible to local needs and expectations, not fearing to give more to those who have less, and to redesign the concrete freedoms that we need.

This is why, from the very first months of my term, I wanted us to pragmatically revisit several public policies in order to inject more freedom for the territories, allowing local authorities the freedom to define the relevant school schedules in their area and investing in schools with the splitting of classes in CP and CE1 in REP and REP+ zones, a reform that will be largely deployed from this school year. This is a policy of territorial differentiation, and local actors bear the responsibility for it.

It is with the same spirit that the State will invest more in daily transportation to enable isolated French citizens to regain physical mobility, without which there is no social mobility. On this point, it is particularly essential to create links between major urban areas and their surrounding territories, especially between metropolitan areas and remote rural areas, as this is where the first territorial fractures are formed, rather than by promising uniform large-scale plans that essentially sum up all the promises made across all territories and are never funded, but rather to build through a participatory method what will be a real mobility plan conceived in contact with the territories and which will precisely respond to daily needs.

This method has been chosen; by the end of summer, the Minister of Transport will launch preparatory work for a mobility orientation law that will offer a precise year-by-year programming funded over five years. A Transport Infrastructure Orientation Council, an expert and dialogue body among all stakeholders, will follow the implementation of this programming with the Minister of Transport, and you will of course be involved.

But what does this method lead to? To having a truthful discourse on transport infrastructure and to taking into account this diversity of territories. There will be a time for dialogue, we will look at the needs, and there will be decisions under the supervision of the Prime Minister because we cannot promise TGV lines and local airports to all of France. This could certainly bring me immediate applause, but I would simply return to you in a few years, and the same applause would turn into legitimate reproach, and I fear that we have done this too often. Therefore, what will be decided at the end of this consultation is a law that will associate each project with its funding.

It is with the same mindset that I have committed to full coverage for all French citizens in very high-speed broadband. I wish to accelerate this timeline to achieve coverage in high and very high-speed broadband by the end of 2020. On this subject, with many of you during the previous term, we built solutions to try to cover the gaps, to catch up on delays, to push operators; this is the first thing that feeds the extremes, the first thing. I say the end of 2020, I confirm to you, and not 2022, you heard correctly, because if I say 2022, I am not sure I will be in a perfect position to respond. If I say the end of 2020, I know I will still have 2021 to catch up on delays.

Because we have collectively learned over time. First, we promised to cover town centers; we quickly realized that covering the town center did not equate to covering the municipality, thanks in particular to the Senate; I remember that amendments were made that allowed for the deployment of relay antennas and thus led operators to have additional constraints. Is that still sufficient? Not entirely; deployments are not fast enough, operators today still hesitate in the least profitable areas, so we must take new incentive and constraint measures regarding telecommunications operators by the end of the year.

Next, we must also look at the nature of the plan that has been conceived by the State to consider technological complementarities. It is impossible to keep the promise of bringing fiber to all homes in the Republic; that is not true; this promise is technologically and financially untenable. However, we must and can play on the complementarities between fiber and mobile, particularly mobile internet. We can deploy so-called Femto cells, and we can leverage the complementarity with satellite deployment, which is at the heart of the State's strategy in this area. This technological reconfiguration must also be supported. Finally, the State will allocate a portion of the large investment plan to this priority where it is necessary, where deficiencies are observed, to substitute for failing operators.

Acting in a differentiated manner also means focusing on certain priorities by territory. Thus, we will ensure that the evolution of public services in rural areas does not lead to an increase in territorial fractures. I have specifically requested that primary education in rural areas be made more attractive, for example, by amplifying very promising local experiments around boarding schools, and this is what the Minister of National Education will present in the coming months. We must do more for equal access to knowledge and excellence.

Similarly, I have committed, and we will do it, to double the number of health houses in rural areas to guarantee access to care, and we will work on establishing a territorial strategy for access to care that ensures enhanced accessibility through innovative means; I am thinking particularly of the deployment of telemedicine. The Minister of Solidarity and Health will be particularly in charge of this project, while structural reforms, which will take time, will be undertaken to reopen the numerus clausus that have created, as we know well, the current scarcity of medical personnel in the territories.

In terms of education and health, I do not wish to go backward or to reconstruct what has sometimes been unraveled; I want to move towards more innovation and propose a shared assessment of needs. This assessment must be conducted by the end of the year to build a joint action plan between the State and the territories. What is certain is that the territories, particularly the most rural ones, can no longer be the variable of economic adjustment. That is why, by then, there will be no more closures of classes in primary schools.

In terms of the environment, local authorities are also essential partners in implementing the recently announced Climate Plan, and our objective will be to deploy all positive energy territories in the coming months in a partnership logic with all the territories that support them.

For the State, as you have understood, in this context that I have just described, the primary challenge is the fight against territorial fractures; the State and local authorities must work together to build this cohesion of territories, Mr. Minister, to promote their complementarity and to organize solidarities. Regions, departments, metropolitan areas, and municipalities must all play their part in building this alliance between territories to promote their best complementarity.

It is because I am aware of certain challenges regarding the situation of downgrading of medium-sized cities and their rurality that I want us to draw inspiration from what has been done in other times very appropriately for cities with the ANRU. This idea has been put forward by others besides me, particularly in recent campaign times, and I think it is a good idea to consider the opportunity of a National Agency for Territorial Cohesion. This agency would be tasked with working directly with the regions because it is not about recentralizing what has been given to certain local authorities, and thus it must be a new type of agency that works directly with the regions, which thinks about the support, particularly in public engineering, that is essential in rural and peripheral territories, and which creates a logic of a single window and simplification of projects for rural territories and struggling medium-sized cities.

This agency would aim to simplify for all those elected or project holders in the territory who want to successfully carry out their projects and who are currently confronted with our own administrative complexity, the multiplication of windows, and sometimes, it must be said, our own inconsistencies. I therefore wish that, in direct connection with you and under the authority of the Prime Minister, a very precise reflection be conducted so that this agency comes into being, which will allow us to respond very effectively and in direct connection with the Minister of Territorial Cohesion and under his authority to these challenges. We need an agency logic because it is a project logic that this rural France, this medium-sized city France, carries today, which wants to succeed and for whom slowness and complexity are almost even more unbearable than for large cities and metropolitan areas.

For medium-sized cities, the priority is to revive city centers; I wish in this regard for the government to engage in a strengthened and cross-cutting action to relaunch employment, commerce, housing, and to put city centers back at the heart of their territory. To do this, it is necessary to establish a global intervention policy in connection with the region; the funding that the State has today is too fragmented, has been subject, as we know well, to successive cuts, and must be largely delegated to the regions, with the State providing support to them to also have a much more global approach to all the tools available, whether in priority neighborhoods or medium-sized cities. The range of tools to address their difficulties in education, employment, commerce, transport, digital, and culture must be simplified and consolidated. And it will be asked of the prefects to appoint alongside them local personalities, entrepreneurs, association leaders, cultural managers, officials capable of driving this movement in direct connection with local elected officials. This mobilization of local actors in support of elected officials around concrete projects and the provision by the State of the necessary tools for the emancipation of these territories will lead to a contractualization for a minimum duration of five years.

Finally, in metropolitan areas, the State will support innovation and research projects whose development is essential for the economy and the influence of France. It will particularly support all digital and environmental transition projects currently carried by metropolitan areas, and the State will be particularly present through the large investment plan. It is also in terms of transport and housing, of course, that the State must rethink its policy. I mentioned earlier regarding transport with a desire to concentrate our funding on daily infrastructure, which means the essential renovation works in all metropolitan areas where investments have not been made for several years, leading to problems of urban congestion and sometimes insecurity for users.

Regarding housing, we must also provide a differentiated response. We know well that policies aimed at encouraging the construction of housing everywhere in the territory with extremely costly fiscal tools no longer work. The French State is one of those that spends the most on housing; however, as is often the case, we have a demand subsidy policy and not a supply policy; we spend two points of GDP on housing policies. To what end? To support the increase in prices and to make households solvent who otherwise would not have access to these policies.

The heart of the problem lies – as we know – in two or three metropolitan areas in France: Greater Paris, Lyon, and the Swiss border, and primarily the Aix-Marseille metropolitan area, where prices have increased significantly in recent years. In these territories, we must strongly facilitate the creation of new housing, support the metropolitan areas that implement these policies, release our land much more quickly than we have done, without seeking to make capital gains, and establish a limitation on appeal procedures and all deadlines that are additional costs.

That is why in the autumn, a bill will be brought forward by the Government that will allow, in all these tense areas, to create a supply shock that will enable – I hope, in two to three years, that is certainly the objective we must have – a significant reduction in the cost of housing in these territories.

We will also strengthen – as I committed to – the funding of the ANRU to help the most disadvantaged neighborhoods.

On this point, allow me a particular word about the Grand Paris. I do not want to present hasty conclusions here; I will see each and every one of you. We have started this work with the Prime Minister. This autumn, after thorough consultation with the relevant stakeholders, I will propose the foundations of the Grand Paris which today – I must tell you honestly – is at a standstill, due to overly complex structuring.

The idea of the Grand Paris deserves better than what we have collectively made of it – it must be said – on both sides, for political reasons and for uncertain balances. But if we want the Grand Paris to succeed on the scale of international competition, if we want to generate wealth to then distribute it harmoniously across the territory, we need to drastically simplify the structures. To this end, I will convene a Territorial Conference of the Grand Paris that must be re-founded around an ambitious development project for the first French metropolis, within the Capital region, and lead to a stabilized and effective institutional organization.

Finally, regarding the role of the State – you mentioned it – I wish for us to strengthen decentralization and to give local representatives of the State more leeway, particularly in budgetary and human resources matters, but also in daily dialogue with local authorities, to adapt State policies to the needs of the territories and those of our fellow citizens.

It will be the responsibility of the Prime Minister in the coming months to carry this project forward. But it is fundamental. You spoke of legislative inflation, rightly so. But we are co-producers of it. Why? In a previous life, I was a minister. How many of you pass on to government ministers this or that word, completely justifiably and rightly so, because a local problem is not resolved by the prefect? A legislative amendment is put forward to resolve the issue in a particular department, because there is no other way than to go and resolve it with the minister. Thus, six months later, creating the same problem, but in reverse, in the neighboring department, which will lead to a roughly symmetrical amendment, reverting to the first, from another equally inspired elected official.

This choreography that leads to a certain stammering, we know it by heart. Because we have progressively dispossessed field officials of the legitimate power that should be theirs. Because we have dispossessed prefects, field services of this power of appreciation and dialogue with local elected officials. When the norm is not modified, then there are delays. How many times, while processing a file that you have given them, do you say I will send it back to Paris, it will take six months?

I want us to move away from this fascination with circular politics to have a strategy policy at the central level; when strategies are clear, they do not need to look at the slightest tightening in each department of our country.

Then, there must be a legitimate ex-post control, a capacity for appeal; our central administrations must experience this reform and this profound transformation. There are too many circular officials and not enough officials who help on the ground.

Therefore, this decentralization will be conducted, and prefects will thus be able – which is not the case today, regardless of this decentralization – to have local adaptation power of regulations, particularly following the Simplification and Right to Error bill that will be presented in the coming weeks by the Government.

**

All of this, the State can and must do. That is why it must consent to a complete paradigm shift. But beyond this role of the State, I deeply believe that in the vast majority of cases, the territories actually know better the organization that is most relevant for them. We must therefore build this Girondin pact, which I mentioned a few weeks ago, which, without breaking national unity, will give the territories the means to act in a shared responsibility.

After years of numerous and sometimes contradictory reforms – I reassure you, Mr. President, I have heard that you wish for this – it is not my intention to recreate a grand institutional evening. We would waste time, energy, and I fear that in this matter, the perfect scheme does not really exist. This means that there will therefore be no new major reforms of institutions or local authorities and levels of local authorities. But I am open to legislative adaptations that will allow us to correct elements of aberration that arise from the ground, on water, I have heard you, on school transport, I thought I heard some of you. On all these subjects, we will proceed pragmatically with the necessary adaptations.

On the other hand, I wish that we can, based on ground logics, proceed with necessary reorganizations. The reform conducted has clarified levels of competence, that is a fact. It has restructured territories and a mapping that you know perfectly. But it has not gone to the end of the elements of simplification that are nevertheless necessary if we want to have a more rapid and less costly public action. Again, I wish that we can simplify things together.

The State will take its responsibilities by rationalizing its services and decentralized agencies to increase the effectiveness of its action. I wish that all local authorities can do the same. Where local authorities wish to do so and if the mergers are in line with the general interest, we will support them. We will not impose, but we will offer freedoms, I am thinking in particular of the creation – if desired – of new municipalities, of mergers that are supported by the authorities, of the wishes for rapprochement of certain departments, if they are desired by them, with this conviction that when the logic is driven by the territories and corresponds to the simplification of territorial organization, to the dynamics of living areas, employment, and economic basins, it is relevant.

But this freedom of organization must not translate into an increase in territorial fractures, nor should it lead to an increase in our own complexity. That is why on this subject, I will have simple red lines. If we increase inequalities and imbalances by proposing mergers between territories that would constitute an island of wealth, in regions, in living areas that are already deeply unbalanced, it is not a good thing for the general interest. If we consider that the sense of History is then that we have created large regions, to reopen departmental houses of the region, I fear that we will not move towards relevant economies.

So, on these points, I will call for collective pragmatism, and the State will look very carefully at everything that does not increase inequalities and imbalances and everything that does not add to the multiplication of structures and redundancies. Everywhere that large regions want to contract with departments or metropolises to share competences as close to the ground as possible, if it seems relevant to them to be as close to the ground as possible, we will help them, we will support them. Everywhere they recreate administrative structures to deploy themselves in competition with other territories, it seems to me that we would inevitably create new costs together.

You understand, I wish to support, encourage initiatives, eliminate the still too many locks that constrain territories in their desire to organize better, with a view to more effective public action. This freedom will be left to local elected officials, in connection with the representatives of the State as well, to experiment with new public policies, new organizations of public services, but also to innovate in terms of land use planning, urban planning, and to define our territory of tomorrow.

The right to experimentation, in this regard, will be simplified. We will lift, in particular, the current obligation of a generalization of these experiments across the entire territory after two years – which is a terrible lock to allow this – and the differentiation of public action in the territories must now be accepted, because it is the price of this equality of opportunity.

If necessary, on this subject, I am ready to propose, within the framework of what I announced at the Congress, a revision of the Constitution to facilitate these evolutions and unleash energies.

I am also willing for the State to delegate, as needed, its competences in economic, social, or planning matters, if local interest justifies it. I particularly wish for the Government to continue the privileged partnership initiated with the regions in 2016 in terms of economic development and employment. I am ready, in this context, to consider new delegations of competences or transfers of structures to regions that wish for them.

This delegation could also be accompanied by a transfer of the regulatory power to adapt legal norms to local realities – you mentioned it – I think this is an evolution we must follow, watch, and support, if desired.

In this regard, the overseas collectivities have paved the way for these reflections, due to their specific constitutional status. I know that some of them, regarding overseas collectivities, wish to revisit the past constitutional amendments that we know perfectly; I am perfectly open to that. Beyond that, I wish that we can also consider in the mainland, in respect of the principle of equality, such adaptations.

I also ask the Government to assess with all of you the means to simplify and modernize the management of the territorial civil service, in the essential dialogue with the civil service unions, in order to better respond to their needs, which are different from those of the State. With a simple will: to have a territorial civil service that allows us collectively to meet the challenges I am discussing. It is not normal, when we seek to increase, for example, the point of the hospital civil service, that all civil services are drawn into the same movement. We must have a differentiated management of civil services, because their reality is different, because the management constraints that are then mechanically imposed on local authorities are not sustainable.

We will also need to ensure that all our responsibilities are taken in this matter. I know by heart the choreography of dupes that exists between us on this subject. Someone must take the responsibility to tell the truth. The Court of Auditors has said it. The hours worked are not fully in compliance with what is provided for the entire civil service or what is the private framework. We must put an end to this situation. Because it is unbearable for our fellow citizens who are not territorial public officials and because we do not serve the territorial civil service by protecting archaic practices. I tell you this frankly.

We will also need – I am convinced of it – to engage in a reduction of the number of local elected officials, as I indicated I wished to do for parliamentary elected officials. Our fellow citizens would not understand otherwise such a differentiated treatment. Fewer elected officials, but better protected, better paid, and freer in their actions.

Finally, the State must guard against – you said it, Mr. President of the Senate – the inflation of norms. So, I take note of your initial warning and I will not risk promising a moratorium. Since you said it yourself, it is in a way in this matter “the heotontimoroumenos,” it is the one who has the knife who is at the same time the called, and we never escape this infernal game.

On the other hand, I am in favor of us indeed conducting a general review of norms. I am in favor of us applying and having the Government take charge of the principle of two for one: for every new norm weighing on local authorities, two others must be abolished.

I wish in this regard that we strengthen the role of the National Council for the Evaluation of Norms, which must be much more involved upstream in the analysis of laws and decrees concerning local authorities.

It is on this subject that the Prime Minister, alongside him, the Secretary General of the Government, will be responsible for ensuring that all texts are submitted to this filter. I also ask the Government to put an end to the insidious transfer of competencies in the future; I am thinking, for example, of the transfer of the responsibility for issuing identity documents to municipalities or the additional costs related to the application of environmental or accessibility standards, which, not being taken into account initially, do not receive any compensation.

The legislator must take into account, each time it establishes a mandatory standard, its administrative and financial impact on local authorities. One of the purposes of these semi-annual conferences will be to restore transparency and trust on this subject, so that the analysis of induced costs can be observed, measured, noted, and transcribed in our financial relations.

Finally, I wish that we do not over-implement European standards and that we aim, whenever a European standard is clear and precise, for its direct application. In this regard, we should systematically examine, particularly in cross-border regions, the standards in force among our European neighbors, in order to assess the effectiveness of our own standards and the nature of their applications.

You understand, the freedom that I intend to restore to the territories, that of organizing themselves, of functioning, is inseparable from the mutual trust that we must have in each other. It also relies on a shared responsibility imposed by the financial situation of the country. This is where I wish to conclude my remarks, on this shared financial responsibility. Everything I have just mentioned represents new freedoms that will be granted to you, a capacity to organize differently, to find leeway, and therefore also smarter organizations and economies.

***

But we must speak the truth here as well. We share the same responsibility towards our European partners as well as our fellow citizens. That of the sustainability of our public finances. This is true for the social and local government share of this expenditure. However, we know that the level of our public spending is too high, and the level of our mandatory levies is equally so. Therefore, we must undergo a double detoxification.

In this regard, this does not prevent us from preparing for the future. That is why the strategy that the Prime Minister outlined a few weeks ago for substantial savings in operational matters will also be accompanied by an investment plan that will allow us to invest in priorities, particularly with 10 billion euros from the major investment plan that we will launch in the fall, which will be dedicated to supporting your projects and with the intention of mobilizing more funds from the European Investment Bank for projects carried out by the territories.

But we need to share this constraint. So what is it? The Prime Minister mentioned it this morning; the State must make substantial savings to reduce public spending by 3 percentage points of GDP during this five-year term. This is the commitment made; we would still be above the average of the Eurozone, but it is a commitment that seems sustainable to me and, in any case, is the one that allows us to regain financial sovereignty, which, given our mutual shares, would lead local authorities to contribute to the reduction of the public administrations' deficit by 13 billion euros over the five-year term.

This is higher than we had anticipated because the situation we found was more degraded than we thought, but it is a share that corresponds to the share of local authorities in the overall public expenditure.

To allow for this improvement in the balance of public administrations, we will not proceed with a brutal reduction in grants; I committed to this, but it is a bet we are making together, and as the philosopher LEVINAS said, trust is the problem of the other. I trust you. The budgetary logic is to cut grants in 2018; we will not do that, but with a bet that local authorities in all their components will know how to take for 2018 their share of what is due to them in terms of reduced operating and investment expenditures without us having to go through the grants, considering that the grant is precisely what provides visibility, what allows for intelligent changes, what enables visibility and efficiency. But this assumes that, using all the levers I just mentioned, the elimination of unnecessary levels of local authorities, new regulatory flexibility, in terms of local public service, you can produce intelligent savings at your discretion.

But I want to get out of this duplicitous game that unites us in a kind of infernal tango that will lead us together to disaster!

On the other hand, for those who do not play the game, there will be a correction mechanism the following year; I tell you this right away because otherwise, it would be a game that favors the free rider, but I believe in the logic of trust; I therefore believe in our ability to make these intelligent savings.

Next, I do not underestimate the important and structural points of public expenditure that have now become unsustainable and create deep imbalances.

The first is the financing of individual solidarity allowances, which currently weighs unevenly on departments and puts some in a situation of significant financial tension. I am particularly thinking of the financing of the RSA, which has now reached its limits; there is an alternative on this subject that is available to us: either a recentralization of financing with a takeover by the State; or an improvement in compensation with a whole debate that you have already had in the past regarding the reference year, but inevitably also with the strengthening of horizontal equalization. I wish for this subject to be debated within the framework of these conferences.

My preference, I tell you outright, would lean towards the first option. Why? Because I believe that the RSA should be part of a continuum of employment policies, even if it means then contracting with regions that would like to have this employment policy, but I think that removing the RSA from the coherence of employment policies is not the logic in which we are more broadly inscribed, but I wish for you to have this full debate and for your work to reach a conclusion by next spring so that the 2019 Finance Bill reflects the decisions made. Until then, the emergency situations for certain departments will, of course, be taken into account by the government.

The second point on this subject of local finances is, as you mentioned, Mr. President of the Senate, the housing tax. Let us also speak the truth; is the housing tax a good tax? No, it is a tax that does not take into account the contributory capacities of citizens, not because it is local or not local; it is simply like that; it does not consider the contributory capacity of our citizens, and it is therefore socially unjust more than all others, and it is territorially unjust because it happens to be higher in peripheral cities or provincial town centers than in large cities. This is the truth as it is measured; I invite you all to acknowledge it. Therefore, it increases the social and territorial injustice that I mentioned earlier. So, it is not a good tax, and this is not because it is territorial; we are not going to set up a camp against camp on taxes. There is one thing that should unite us: it is to seek to collectively lower them by making spending smarter. So this tax is not good!

Next, I hear your argument that it is good to have a tax that remains in contact with the citizen. Yes, but I have bad news for you; for a significant part of our population, this link has not existed for many years; that is also the truth, which moreover increases visibility for the municipalities that are most in difficulty, which concentrate the challenges and the poorest populations that have weakened this link. So, it is a double whammy, if I may say so. Now, I hear the promise to review the cadastral rental values. I fear that some have already tried this; to be honest with you, I understood that this reform has been on the table for about forty years, that perhaps some of you in this room had attempted to vote on it, had started to do the simulations, and had realized that a third of the municipalities would lose out, and therefore preferred not to implement it.

That is the truth, so I propose that we collectively save time by not trying to redo battles that have already been fought, already lost, and that objectively do not allow us to respond to the challenges of our fellow citizens.

So, in the short term, starting next school year, there will be successive phases of a suppression for 80% of the housing tax for our fellow citizens over three years, with a mechanism for relief that allows for financial compensation for the local authorities without losing their rate freedom. This will be done progressively; these Conferences will also allow for sharing financial information every six months and ensuring that the changes during this period in the base and therefore the new residents you may have are well compensated in said evolution since I am aware of your legitimate concerns on the subject, informed by the past.

My wish is that we go further because yes, a tax that would ultimately be paid by 20% of the population is not a good tax, but I do not wish to, in a way, as has been done for decades, shift the burden of proof onto our fellow citizens. I return it to us; therefore, at the same time as we do this, and starting now, I wish for us to open, within the framework of a working commission that must involve you and not just be an administrative commission, a deep reflection on the overhaul of local taxation and in particular, as a substitute for the housing tax, with simple principles, that we can achieve the same financial result ultimately, that we maintain the fiscal autonomy particularly of municipalities, that we keep the link for the civic virtue that you mentioned between the inhabitants and the municipality, and that we consider possibly a share of national tax that could be allocated to municipalities, a share of CSG or CRDS, which is at least a proportional tax, which is smarter than the current housing tax.

But let us take the time to revisit this overhaul of local taxation; let us give ourselves until next spring, in the case of this commission, to conduct this in-depth exercise that is essential, but I wish, on the one hand, that we keep the commitment made because it is necessary in terms of purchasing power and territorial justice, and I wish that we carry out this in-depth overhaul of local taxation, which is equally essential.

***

There you have it, Ladies and Gentlemen, what I wanted to share with you today. I am not exhaustive, but I have already been lengthy because the subject is vast and the task ahead of us is vast, as you have understood; that is why I wanted, at the beginning of this term, to come with the Prime Minister and several eminent members of the government to present these views and this methodical will.

I believe in trust. We have tried distrust too much in this country, and we have seen that it does not work, so we are not taking much risk. I believe in the ambition of the profound reforms that we must carry. I want to carry them for the State through what I have committed to, and I expect you to carry them for the local authorities; it is essential. Those who think that the status quo would protect them are mistaken, believe me! It will not protect them from the changes that will happen anyway and will not protect them any more from anger because people are clear-sighted.

I believe in respect, in shared respect. The transparency that we will establish between us will ensure this at every moment, but I wish, as you have understood, that through this trust, this shared responsibility between us, we can together meet the challenges.

Each of the challenges you carry is a piece of mine. I will never shirk my responsibility by saying: it is such a municipality. It is a game; people no longer believe in it; it is the same: we are all in the same boat for our fellow citizens; we either succeed or we do not, and therefore your problems are mine at every moment, but believe me, my problems are also a bit yours! I want you to be convinced of this! For all these reasons, to succeed in these transitions, our ambitions must be considerable.

That is why I wish, Ladies and Gentlemen, that we collectively rise to the challenge of the project we are carrying, and I hope that this National Conference of Territories will allow us to succeed in this bet of trust, efficiency, and respect so that our common action, which is the shared public action, enables the country to succeed and gives the French people what they deserve.

Long live the Republic and long live France!