Speech delivered at the closing of the First Congress of the Institute of Animal Science, in the Ambassador's Hall of the Habana Libre Hotel, on the

Cuba Fidel Castro · President of Cuba

13 May 1969 · First Congress of the Institute of Animal Science · Ambassador's Hall of the Habana Libre Hotel, Cuba

Context
Castro addressed the closing of Cuba's First Congress of the Institute of Animal Science at the Habana Libre Hotel in Havana on May 13, 1969.
Main themes
Livestock development, milk and meat production, animal science research, Cuban agricultural policy, food security, economic underdevelopment, cattle breeding, revolutionary priorities, scientific knowledge development, sugar exports versus livestock strategy
Duration
~114 min
99th percentile
Words
13,650
99th percentile
Sentences
574
99th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
11.5
38th percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
70th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 53%52%
  • Institutional 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Technological 5%5%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Not in focus 1%

574 sentences in 233 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen;

Cuban colleagues and companions:

I can imagine the hard work that all of you have put in during these four days. However, as I come to take this podium, I have the impression that the work or responsibility that falls on me tonight is equally arduous.

It is customary to invite someone to these events to summarize or to close them. It is not easy for me to summarize an event of a scientific nature, such as this congress that has taken place. However, I find myself in the position of having to fulfill this task. I must carry it out with a deep sense of responsibility.

We cannot overlook the fact that this event has a certain external significance, and this event also has significance within our country, and that present at this event, and having been present at this congress, is not only a large group of distinguished researchers from abroad, but also hundreds of colleagues who carry out their tasks in the agricultural sector of our country.

And, of course, the subject that has been discussed at this congress is of vital importance to our country.

It is necessary that we orient ourselves well; it is necessary, above all, to avoid leaving this congress disoriented. And my duty —as I understand it— tonight is to speak precisely to explain and to try to orient us.

I have had some personal connection with this institution, which is the Institute of Animal Science. How is it organized and why? The reasons were obvious: our people faced the problem that is generically called development, and that more specifically had to do with the fundamental need to live, in certain cases even to survive, to confront serious food problems arising from both our underdevelopment and external circumstances that imposed an economic blockade on our country.

And our people could not count on any accumulated scientific knowledge in those circumstances. They could count on very little experience, with very few technicians, with very few scientists, and some who claimed to be such were not precisely deep connoisseurs of these fields nor could many of them be in a position to serve the people under those circumstances.

The country faced the need to develop the economy, to develop its agriculture, to develop its food sources, to develop the technical and administrative cadres to carry out that task; and, above all, to develop the knowledge, experience, and techniques to adequately resolve those problems.

Livestock in our country counted a number of animals, of some millions of heads, but for the most part it was a livestock mass that had developed over centuries, more or less adapted to the conditions of our climate, but poorly productive in terms of meat and milk. The number of milk-producing animals in our country, of dairy breeds, was very small. Most of the cattle were, as we commonly call them, Zebu or Brahman, some nuclei of animals known as Criollos, and a few thousand heads of Holstein cattle, a few heads also of Brown Swiss. And, in short, they could not meet the milk needs of our population.

In past times, the people did not have access to those products, they had no means to acquire them. Many times there was an excess of milk, and in times of drought, the problem was not solved with hay, silage, or food reserves, but rather the problem was usually resolved by milk distributors adding water to the milk.

The new situation posed the need to produce not for a market, but the need to produce to satisfy the requirements of our population. Logically, all productive capacity could not reach the purpose of supplying milk and meat to the population of our country. And among those two mentioned elements, for us the most important was to solve the problem of milk supplies.

I have read a good part of the conferences and the papers that have been presented at this congress, and I found it appropriate to state what the number one objective was. There has been talk, of course, about the development of meat production and the purpose of developing meat exports, and obtaining foreign currency from those exports. That is true. But for us, the fundamental objective of the development of our livestock has to do, first and foremost, with the purpose of satisfying the needs of the people. That is to say, for us, the first thing in the development of the livestock mass is simply the consumption needs of the people and the raising of the standard of living of our people.

The development of sugar agriculture has to do with exports and the increase of exports. But in the strategy of livestock development, the first thing is the satisfaction of the needs of the people for milk, first of all, and for meat, second.

So it is necessary to keep this in mind so that it is understood where the effort that the Revolution is making in this field is directed.

And being that the primary objective, we encountered practically unsolvable problems. We found, first of all, that our livestock mass lacked milking potential; and secondly, we encountered the problem that the few cows that could satisfy those needs were often undernourished and our country did not have the means for importing concentrates for those animals.

In the order of priorities, there were very urgent needs. Many times it was the need for medicines for the population, for example: needs for medical equipment, with limited resources, that would compete with the possibilities of acquiring concentrates for the feeding of our scarce dairy herd.

We faced the need to find solutions to this problem. First, how to increase the dairy livestock mass; and second, how to increase, or improve, or how to satisfy the food needs of that mass.

Our country had never been a grain producer nor a soybean producer. Two problems presented themselves: lack of tradition in those crops and adverse climatic conditions for those crops. The climatic conditions derived from the circumstances that in our country there are certain periods of long droughts and that the rains generally come abruptly.

It is not the case of what happens in many temperate climate countries, where the land is prepared before winter and a part of it is even sown before winter; it is not the case that at the moment the snow melts, the land is already plowed and ready for sowing, with the necessary moisture to sow large areas of grains. In our country, the land must be prepared and one must wait for the first downpour, and when that downpour comes, it can come with general rains, and long before those areas can be sown, the grass has already grown.

Moreover, such circumstances of rainfed agriculture would require, under those conditions, a huge number of machines.

The experience derived from sowing approximately half a million hectares of sugarcane in a period of 15 months for the 1970 harvest teaches us abundantly how difficult conditions that task had to develop under, and how on many occasions, resorting not to mechanized plowing but to animal traction, using oxen, the land had to be prepared and sown.

In the conditions of our climate, the problems are known, for example, of pests and diseases; in the conditions of our climate, the weeds are known, the struggle against weeds and the struggle against pests.

The use of herbicides was completely unknown, the use of irrigation was yet to be fully developed. The fight against diseases was also another field where experience was lacking. And apart from that, our country has to face some natural phenomena. I spoke of drought. But at other times we are affected by excess rain, floods, and at other times, we are affected by cyclones.

So we had all those natural problems: droughts, floods, cyclones; and also a lack of machines, a lack of irrigation, a lack of experience, a lack of herbicides, a lack of high-yield seeds, and a lack of means and knowledge in the fight against pests.

Sugarcane agriculture developed under the conditions of the past because it was a type of crop that in one way or another resisted those conditions; it resisted drought, which of course affected production but did not kill the plantation, sometimes it resisted certain excesses of moisture, it was a plant that, due to its duration cycle, compensated in some times of the year for the adverse conditions of other times. It is also a plant resistant to diseases, which, in the midst of a very backward agricultural technique, allowed for the maintenance of a certain agricultural production to sustain the national economy.

So those were the adverse circumstances: the lack of a livestock mass with milking potential, the lack of resources to import concentrates, and, moreover, adverse natural conditions to produce concentrates in this country.

From very early on, we were aware of that situation, from very early on efforts were made to develop techniques and research.

And it was those circumstances in agriculture and livestock, as in other fields, that led us to the effort to try to answer the question: What type of livestock are we going to develop? How should we feed it? How are we going to produce, first of all, the milk that our population needs, that our children need, that the elderly need, that the sick need, and finally, that the rest of the population needs? With what livestock mass? How were we going to feed it? That question had to be answered.

Part of the answer consisted of developing research. But to develop research, we lacked research centers and we lacked technicians and experience in research.

Thus arose the initial idea of a center to investigate issues related to animal nutrition and the development of livestock.

But, on the other hand, it was not possible for our country to wait for a long process to develop the techniques to answer the question of how we were going to solve the problem. It was necessary in practice, and in a certain way with urgency, to take certain steps to solve the problem, starting from the few existing experiences and from the existing conditions in our country.

Thus, the Institute of Animal Science was organized, thus in the search for technicians, contacts were made with certain technicians, and thus the institution was organized, the relevant arrangements were established, and work began in this institution.

We must say that it has a certain peculiarity. The working methods were discussed with the technicians: they were granted broad powers for research. It was assumed that the government would have some participation, some interest in the research and that, of course, efforts would be made to reconcile the directives, ideas, and viewpoints of the researchers endowed with broad powers, with the immediate interests of the country, in order to resolve its most urgent needs.

The institute was established, where the revolutionary government had a representative, a representative whose fundamental objective was to facilitate the establishment of the material bases for work and to serve as a liaison with it.

We must say frankly that after the institute was created, the minimum of relations was maintained between the government and the institution. Certain hypotheses arose. A thesis emerged from the direction of the Institute of Animal Science about how the problem of livestock nutrition in Cuba should be resolved. It was proposed that this feeding should be fundamentally based on grains, that is, fundamentally based on corn and sorghum.

We must say that our position was at odds with that thesis. But nevertheless, we maintained our purpose that the institution develop its research with broad freedom.

We saw how those investigations developed in that direction towards the search for a solution to feeding through grains. And although we had the deepest conviction that this was not the way, we accepted that the relevant tests be carried out, we respected the right to freedom of research of the researchers, and we settled for at least a small part of the effort being directed in another direction.

Sometimes we respectfully requested, we expressed through our Cuban colleagues our interest in certain research. And although we did not believe that corn and sorghum were the way, we nevertheless saw as positive the effort being made to obtain higher-yield hybrids, to import pure lines that would allow for greater production of corn or other plants or other grains, which, although they would not, in our opinion, solve the problem of livestock, would still constitute a step forward in our agriculture and, moreover, contribute to the development and training of Cuban technical cadres.

That is why, in our view, what we fundamentally expected from the Institute of Animal Science was not the solution to the nutritional needs of our livestock, but that it would fundamentally contribute to the training of a large group of Cuban technicians who, later on, through one path or another, with a more or less correct orientation, would contribute to the further development of livestock in our country.

No resources were spared for the Institute of Animal Science. Magnificent irrigated lands, among the few that existed in our country, were made available to it in the heart of the province of Havana; more than 1,000 hectares of land, material means, buildings, equipment, human resources, and ample facilities for exchange and for all activities at that center were provided. And numerous valuable colleagues from our university were made available to the institute, young people who were finishing their studies and who went to that center to work on research, but mainly to train as researchers.

This history needs to be presented because if we do not, we run the risk that if we stick to mere courtesies, to a hundred percent delicacy in everything that is said, we will all leave a little confused. And I will say it frankly: we would leave without even knowing what has been attempted to resolve in this country and where the founded hopes are to solve those problems. We would leave without understanding many things.

Now, why did we not believe that grain was the solution for our country? There are numerous reasons. Some we have previously outlined.

First of all, our climate is not the ideal climate established by nature for the cultivation of corn. I say this simply. It is true that in corn, as in many other varieties of plants, adaptations have been achieved that have allowed, through selection and genetics, the acquisition of varieties that can withstand climatic conditions that were not the climatic conditions where it arose naturally.

All the problems previously enumerated presented themselves: droughts, the need to plow enormous expanses of land, the need to employ thousands of machines for that purpose, the need to have the means: herbicides, chemical or mechanical means to cultivate that corn; it was necessary to develop the varieties first and test them exhaustively before embarking on that path; it was necessary to know what we were going to do with the non-irrigated lands; how we were going to address the problem in the non-irrigated lands, which were almost all the agricultural soils; how we were going to suddenly plant all that corn at the beginning of spring; how we were going to resolve it in those vast regions of the country that had drainage problems; how we were going to solve the soil problems, if many of the best lands were already occupied by sugarcane agriculture; how we were going to solve the problem of cyclones.

Why did our country need to engage in agriculture that forced it to plow enormous expanses of land every year to plant corn? Why should our country adapt to a technique of animal nutrition that was perfectly explainable and justifiable in temperate climate countries in Europe, in most of the United States, where they have long winters, where they have the possibility of plowing large expanses of land, and even the need to do so to seek maximum utilization per unit of land in a reduced period of time?

Why renounce the magnificent advantages that, on the other hand, a country in our climate had? Why renounce the advantages that our tropical or subtropical climate allowed us? Why renounce the advantages that the absence of harsh winters, the absence of snow, and the possibility of maintaining growth throughout the year of other species, of other perennial plants, offered us, which do not require us to plow the land every year and which, on the other hand, allow us to have and take advantage of all the benefits of our climate? Why did we not take advantage of all the advantages of exploiting pastures in the conditions of our climate?

The comparison could not be resisted, by any means. There are species of artificial pastures whose production extends indefinitely, whose productivity even increases year by year, that can withstand droughts, that regrow quickly when the rains begin, and that under irrigation conditions and adequate levels of fertilization allow for almost uniform production throughout the year.

If we also had the possibilities, with the small number of our machines destined for other crops — primarily sugarcane — and also for the direct production of other foods; if we had the opportunity to develop a truly economical way of exploiting the livestock, why embark on a technique that was much more costly, that required many more resources and in the conditions of our country was much less secure?

Thus, two opinions were opposed: the view that the solution came through grains and the view that the solution came through pastures. Thus, a sort of ideological contest arose in the field of science, if you want to say science; if you prefer in the field of practice, or in the field of realities. However, we did not stifle, we did not prevent the experience and tests from continuing to develop to find solutions through grains. We managed — by requesting, insisting — that some of the research on pasture be conducted, some.

We read the work presented here by engineer Quintana on experiences in meat production through pastures: the napier test, the planting of napier and alfalfa, the planting of guinea grass with kudzu. And we remembered perfectly how we managed to have that research done.

There was resistance in the institute to conducting that research, and we had to obtain some hectares of land and ask some Cuban colleagues to carry out the research anyway.

I was very pleased, however, to see how, after all, one of the presentations related to meat production from pastures was presented among the animal science works.

Of course, a very curious thing. The fundamental objective of that research was to know how much productivity in meat could be achieved through pastures from one hectare of land. And we maintained the view that, under the conditions of our climate, one hectare of certain forages with adequate levels of irrigation and fertilization tripled the productivity of one hectare dedicated to corn.

To our great surprise, we saw that the objective of the research was barely mentioned; that the conclusion of how much meat is produced per hectare was not drawn, but it practically became a comparative test of various breeds in their response to grazing. And there it speaks of F-1 Brown Swiss with Zebu, F-1 Holstein with Zebu, and some pure Zebu, which had different responses to the different tests. And I remember perfectly well that when that test was conducted, F-1 of that type and F-1 of the other were not selected; it was not a breed test. If it turned out to be a breed test, it was because when the cattle were brought in for the test, commercial Zebu, more or less pure Zebu, and some F-1 came.

It was a surprise for us that a test aimed at demonstrating the superiority of pasture over grains ultimately became a test to determine which breed responded best to grass feeding. The fundamental objective was practically relegated, forgotten.

Subsequently, tests began to be conducted with molasses.

In my opinion, the field where the Institute of Animal Science has made its most important, serious, and practical effort has been in researching the most correct way to use molasses in the feeding of cattle, in the feeding of pigs, and even the use of sugar in poultry meat production.

In that area, there were some experiences in Cuba, some production had been developed based on molasses with urea; but there was a lack of research on the appropriate levels of molasses consumption, the levels of urea, the antagonisms that could arise in the metabolism of molasses, in the waste that could occur in the other components of the diet, the percentage of molasses that could be given to cattle fed with pastures, or innovations, such as preparing the diet mainly based on molasses and with a minimum of forage.

We understand that progress was made in that field, a lot of progress, and it began to be in part a principle of correct orientation when sugarcane began to be seen as a plant capable of seriously contributing to animal nutrition. The concepts related to corn and maize began to be abandoned a bit, to start giving more importance to molasses-based feeding.

Of course, I have read Dr. Preston's work where he outlines the importance and possibilities of using sugarcane and molasses in livestock feeding. We agree with that view; it is a correct view; although we do not agree with some of the foundations of his thesis.

I do not know if in a certain sense his assertion that certain "political or social" circumstances made it difficult to apply a grain-based technique for feeding livestock; if that assertion refers to another country or if that assertion refers to our country. Because I say clearly that here there are no "social" obstacles nor are there "political" obstacles to developing livestock feeding based on corn, if it could be proven that corn could really solve our problems.

But what can be proven — and we have no doubt about it — is that corn is not the solution to our problems at present, and that it will take a long time before it could become so.

First of all, varieties, techniques, and solutions will have to be developed to ensure that one hectare of corn can produce the nutrients that one hectare of sugarcane produces. It is enough to say that sugarcane is, of all the plants known to this moment, the one with the greatest capacity for assimilating sunlight and converting it into nutrients; it has the greatest capacity.

It is enough to say that with the techniques known in our country, with irrigation and with the appropriate levels of fertilization, with the appropriate varieties that exist in our country, it is perfectly possible to obtain about 19 tons of total molasses per hectare per year with sugarcane, and it also produces the straw, produces the top — which is the green part of the plant — also produces the bagasse, which has many uses and will have uses of great economic importance for our country in the future.

I do not believe that here it has ever been achieved, never, not even with the best hybrids, nor do I believe that the institute has ever been able to obtain, under optimal conditions of magnificent land under irrigation, more than five tons of corn per hectare. And this forces constant plowing of the land and planting it. It is not like sugarcane, which is planted, can grow for two years; that once it reaches a certain development does not need to be cleaned, because the weeds do not need to be cut except every two years and yields in two years of about 38 tons of total molasses per hectare. And that is why I said about 19 tons of nutrients per hectare per year, with an energy content practically equivalent to that of corn, leaving aside the scant amounts of protein that corn possesses.

And it is, of course, indisputable that one hectare of sugarcane can produce for our country four times, five times what the best corn that has ever been planted and harvested in Cuba can produce.

That is the comparison between sugarcane and corn.

Now, sugarcane also has molasses as a byproduct, the byproduct after sugar is produced, in certain quantities. For example, for a production of 10 million tons of sugar, approximately 3.5 million tons of molasses will remain.

But the use of sugarcane directly for the production of molasses for livestock feeding can also be contemplated, and in that way, our country envisions it for the future. Because, assigned to sugarcane a certain area of 1,700,000 physical hectares, the production of sugarcane will progressively increase as irrigation expands, as the conditions in which sugarcane is cultivated change, and through the increase in production per hectare, so that by 1980 the country, in the 1,700,000 physical hectares that will be assigned in the total area of our island, will be able to produce sugarcane for 10 million tons of sugar and also enough sugarcane to produce another 10 million tons of sugar.

However, it is not contemplated to produce 20 million tons of sugar; it is contemplated to maintain sugar production at a reasonable level, according to market needs, and, however, to allocate those surplus amounts of cane for livestock feed. Thus, our country will be able to have 14 to 15 million tons of honey in 1980, in addition to the 10 million tons of sugar.

It will be necessary to expand the country's sugar industry in the coming years for these purposes.

And we see in that resource the nutritional supplement for our livestock.

But, of course, the reason for this policy is that so far, as a nutritional supplement for milk and meat production, cane surpasses any other plant we can use in our country.

Later, I will explain why I say "nutritional supplement," because from cane and honey not only calories come out, but proteins can also come out. And we in our country have a torula plant that converts four to five tons of final honey into one ton of torula yeast, with 55% protein.

Thus, cane is — it is easily understood — the plant adapted to our climate in which we have the most experience, which constitutes our corn, our sorghum, our soy; that is, capable of serving for the feeding of cattle, pigs, and chickens, using part honey, part sugar, part yeast obtained through a fermentation process, and certain amounts of animal protein.

On that basis, our future production of pigs, chickens, and livestock as a supplement to pasture is fundamentally conceived. It is not because "sugar does not constitute — as Dr. Preston claims — a basic necessity for human diet nor a luxury item, nor because a social opinion that demands from women a graceful slenderness and the growing number of tests links sugar to heart deficiencies..." the reason why we must dedicate cane to livestock and not to produce sugar, because it is a better business to dedicate it to livestock than to sugar; according to his criteria.

We cannot accept this assertion in this congress — and I say this here with all due respect and, moreover, I say it with deep sorrow — because this is a distinctly European argument.

The issue of women's slenderness can be applied in England, France, Italy, Belgium, Sweden, in many countries where the needs and consumption of sugar are saturated; but this argument cannot be applied in Asia or Africa or Latin America, nor can it be applied to billions of people in the world who are consuming less than five kilograms of sugar per capita per year, who suffer from undernutrition, who suffer from protein and calorie deficits, and who are the reason why in many of those regions the average life expectancy does not reach 30 years.

And we truly belong to that underdeveloped world and we feel identified with its needs. And we feel identified with its needs, and we are very aware that unfortunately there is not an excess and it will take many years for there to be an excess of sugar in the world.

I do not defend this thesis as it was defended by capitalists in the past, who were offended and insulted when sugar was touched upon. We cannot think with that criterion. We have a broad market for sugar, both internal and external; all our sugar is sold and even more sugar than we can produce; and the 10 million tons of sugar are sold, they have markets. And many times sugar also becomes, through exchange, wheat; and our sugar also becomes through that same route corn.

Our climatic conditions are those of a sugar-producing country, not a cereal-producing country. Cereal-producing countries can be those that have large expanses of land, they can be those countries that can achieve maximum productivity per person through machines to cultivate the enormous expanses to produce wheat and to produce corn. Our country is a relatively small country that has to seek crops of maximum value per hectare. And it will never be possible to compare corn with any of the many crops that, due to our natural conditions, have economic values per hectare four or five times higher than the average corn of the United States.

Our country does not have excess land. It is not Australia, it is not Canada, it is not the United States, it is not Argentina — to mention a certain number of countries — it is a relatively small country that has to seek the maximum productivity per person, yes, but also combined with the maximum productivity per hectare. And cane is one of the crops that we, whether dedicating it to sugar or dedicating it to honey, will have for us a high economic value and high productivity per hectare that, in addition, is in accordance with our tradition, that is in accordance with our industrial and agricultural experience in that sense.

And, logically, that is the reason why we, if we see that the industrial products of cane can be a complement to the diet of our livestock, think of cane, once market needs are satisfied, to produce the dietary supplement for our herds, both of cattle and pigs and birds. That is the fundamental reason.

There cannot be another reason. It cannot be in any way a problem of women's slenderness in Europe. And furthermore, allow me to refute the thesis of slenderness, because Cuban women are known as slender and graceful women and have one of the highest per capita sugar consumption rates in the world.

And I certainly believe that you will perfectly understand our duty, as I said earlier, to try to orient ourselves and to logically clarify some issues. And all of you may think or have reasons to think that this does not constitute an impertinence on our part. But if we are really going to take our guests seriously, and if we are really going to take science seriously, it is our duty to expose things not with a sectarian spirit, not seeing a scientific micro-world, but seeing all the realities, seeing the macro-world of the problems of humanity and of man and of our country!

I do not want in any way to use political words. You will have noticed that I try to avoid anything that can be qualified here as politics. It is not an act of agitation. I do not want to introduce here, among people who may have different political views, political arguments. I wish to present rational arguments, I wish to express objectives. And these objective and rational arguments I believe are exactly applicable to one country as to others. That some countries cannot apply them is a misfortune. But for us, rational things are a possibility — it is a fortune! — and we have the possibility to do truly rational things for the benefit of our country. And by the way, I also believe that rational things we do here, solutions we find here, can also be applied to other peoples under conditions equal to ours.

Let us say that, along with the desire to solve the problems of our country, we also harbor the noble purpose of being modestly useful in one way or another to many people in the world who have very similar problems to ours. Look for a geography and you will see where hunger is in the world, where undernutrition is and where poverty is! And we, who have had to live in a climate of this type, under conditions similar to other very numerous peoples, can also allow ourselves to harbor that feeling, that appreciation for our work, which is not the work of a selfish nationalism or of a selfish people that only thinks of solving its problems, but aspires to what is useful and positive for it can also be useful and positive for other countries.

In this congress, it can be perfectly appreciated how little weight pasture had. Corn had a great weight. Maize had a great weight. All of that had weight here. But how many works have been presented on pastures? How many works aimed at investigating what is the appropriate type of pasture, or which among the numerous varieties of pasture are the most suitable for our climate conditions? What are the ideal levels of fertilization for our pastures? What is the real load that can be sustained under adequate conditions by a hectare of pasture with irrigation and certain levels of fertilization? Pasture means for us in these times the magnificent possibility that livestock works for man and not man works for livestock. It is not that we refuse to work for livestock. Man has to do a certain part of the work for livestock, because livestock helps man. But it is that our country still has to cut tens of millions of tons of cane by hand every year, because it does not have machines for that.

Logically, our main objective must be to mechanize the cultivation of cane, first of all. Before mechanizing a hypothetical corn, it must mechanize the cultivation and cutting of cane, it must dedicate many resources to that in order to free hundreds of thousands of hands that can participate in the industrial development, in the social development of our country. And today cane employs the bulk of our machines, and will employ the bulk of our machines, and will employ the bulk of our mechanization resources in the coming years.

Logically, we should not mortgage ourselves in seeking a technique to produce meat that is more expensive, that requires greater amounts of investment, that requires additional machines, when we can perfectly take advantage of grazing.

We should have done an intensive, in-depth study of grazing techniques at the Animal Science Institute. We should have done an intensive study on pastures, on the productivity of our pastures, on productivity in meat and, above all, on productivity in milk. Because you will have also noticed that milk is practically forgotten in animal science research.

And I speak a truth: review the program, review all the works, and you will see that meat received much more attention thinking about hypothetical meat exports, when the needs for milk in this country were to be resolved, since if we want to give one liter of milk per capita to our people we need to produce about 8 million liters of milk daily.

And before thinking about exporting meat we must think about stopping importing milk. And our country, to maintain a quota of milk consumption for all children and all elderly people and a small quota of milk for the population, has to import millions in foreign currency every year in milk. And we had to think about solving the milk problem. But milk received minimal attention, just as pastures received minimal attention, at the Animal Science Institute.

Honesty compels us to clarify these points, honesty compels us to express these truths. We could remain silent, pretend that we have had great successes, praise the grand work of the institution, when simply there are many very weak points.

And we do engage in self-criticism. And in doing self-criticism, I consider myself one of the main responsible parties, one of the main culprits. I have had to see quite a bit, I have been very interested in the problem of agricultural research, we placed great hopes in the institute. Its successes could have reached us very closely as Cuban revolutionaries, as the Cuban government. But we must say that we cannot either magnify or boast of having achieved great successes when research in animal science has also really, alongside successes, had great deficiencies. And milk research has occupied a minimal place.

But I will demonstrate more. I will demonstrate how that incorrect orientation, I will demonstrate how that underestimation of the importance of milk influenced research. And something even more incredible: it influenced the results.

Before continuing, I must say that since last year the comrades from the institute wanted to hold this congress. And we were afraid of this congress. And we asked them not to, not to hold the congress last year, that we had a lot of work in other fields, that we still had very few things to exhibit. And we finally managed to convince them to postpone it to this year.

This year we also did not agree with the congress. We did not. But invoking the promise of the previous year, invoking the argument of the postponement, they insisted on the congress. And we certainly had fears. The country is engaged in an enormous task at this moment: in preparing the 1970 harvest of 10 million, in planting all the canes, in cleaning, in the crops, in fertilizations and in finishing the current harvest under an early spring. Our country is immersed in a huge hydraulic plan, for drainage, for irrigation. Because while I spoke to you at the beginning that this did not exist, I can tell you that in a period no longer than five years the vast majority of the agricultural lands of this country will be under irrigation.

I can tell you that this year about 2 billion cubic meters of water will be incorporated into irrigation, and that next year about 3 billion cubic meters more will be added, and that hydraulic studies are considerably advanced, that 10,000 machines are working in this country, building roads, making canals, constructing reservoirs, creating irrigation systems, drilling wells, precisely to solve one of the great natural inconveniences of this country, which are the cyclical droughts that create so many difficulties for our agriculture. Ten thousand machines —and more than 60,000 men with those machines— are working on this entire plan.

We are immersed in a huge amount of tasks that occupy the time and energy of all the comrades working in the agricultural sector. But the congress took place. I do not know why it came up here and it was stated that the congress "was not what it was supposed to be." And indeed, the congress has not been what the organizers of the congress envisioned.

First, it started with the idea of an "annual" congress, and I believe that is ridiculous. We can almost apologize for allowing ourselves to organize one now when we are just starting; how can we talk about an annual congress?

Secondly, all the organizations that work in agriculture conduct research, and Animal Science is not the only organization that does research. There are other research efforts. No one has designated Animal Science as the Supreme Pontiff of agricultural research in Cuba. Universities conduct research, many other institutions in our country conduct research. And logically, certain treatment issues, certain misunderstandings, and certain disrespect led to comrades from other organizations feeling very hurt. They felt hurt, they felt mistreated, certain works were even rejected, they felt like victims of certain disdain, and simply refused to collaborate.

But here, at the inauguration of this event, Dr. Preston spoke of it not being what he thought it should be and that he disagreed.

If that issue was addressed here, let us exercise the same right to provide this explanation of what really happened.

Another comrade in the inaugural speech —in this case, the representative of the Cuban side— spoke of "misunderstandings," of "obstacles to science," and who knows how many other things. The responsibility touches us very closely because it was the comrade representing the government in the institution who spoke.

I imagine that some of you might be asking yourselves: But what is this? What "obstacles" are those? What "misunderstandings" are those? What problems are those? And why are these issues brought up at the inauguration of the congress?

Well, they were brought up. And if they were brought up at the inauguration, they must also be brought up at the closing.

It was said, in one of those speeches, that the political part was ending and science was beginning. I do not know how to classify what we have: whether it is science, or politics, or even —for some perhaps worse— petty politics, a mean thing. Of course, I do not know how to distinguish the difference between science and politics, except that politics, in addition to being science, is an art.

I sincerely believe that politics can be at the service of good or evil. If it is at the service of good, it is a revolutionary politics, just as science can also be at the service of good or evil. If it is at the service of good, it can be said to be a human, noble, revolutionary science, just as if science is put —as it has often been— at the service of evil, of war, of destruction, it must be called science at the service of politics, and of the worst politics, science at the service of crime.

And we really do not know how to distinguish between one science and another. Because without the science of a people that was capable of liberating itself, without the science of a people that has been able to make its revolution, without the science of a people that has been able to resist the blockade against a not insignificant enemy, an enemy that underestimated us, that belittled us, that believed that with a kick it would throw our people's Revolution away, that it would crush it; without that science there would be no Institute of Animal Science, without that science there would be no research. And it is just that if we place science in its rightful place and exalt it and support it, there should be no reason to make distinctions between science and politics. But, moreover, there is the science of truth, without any kind of simulation. And these topics and these problems were addressed here. So it is logical that these topics and these problems be sufficiently clarified.

Something more was reached. Because unnecessarily, gratuitously, other institutions were offended, other institutions were hurt. Because, why say that here at the first congress that took place in this country —as if we were some kind of Siboneyes, or something like that, a backward people— that at the first scientific congress of this country the President of the session —who was precisely the comrade President of the Academy of Sciences, because he was the one presiding over that session— was reading a newspaper. And just see what kind of congress that was, where the President of the institution was reading a newspaper.

What need was there to produce those wounds, to cause those grievances? And on top of that, we are told that here the Cubans were going to learn how to behave at an international congress, that we were going to learn how we would behave when we went abroad.

And we are really well arranged if the Cubans learn to behave that way at an international congress, starting by offending the country where the congress is being held, offending the people where the congress is being held!

Those things, unfortunately, happened. And they could not go unnoticed, and those things could not remain unanswered.

Strange things occurred at this congress, at this historic congress.

I will now even enter —if you allow me— into technical matters. And if you do not give me a 12-minute limit, I can talk to you about some issues that relate to the subject of this congress.

When I told you that our main problem and our question was the following: How are we going to solve the problems of milk in this country? And how are we going to solve them if we do not have dairy cows? You might say: Well, they will wait for the dairy cows they have to multiply, that is, they will wait for the Greek calends for there to be dairy cows, that they can milk, and in the meantime import —if they can— milk. Or they might say: Import hundreds of thousands of pure Holstein cows.

This country has imported pure cows as much as it could. There are different limitations: resources. But even with resources available, this country cannot buy cows just anywhere, because it has the blockade. This country can buy livestock in very few places. It has to transport it by ships, in specially adapted ships: it has to acclimatize it with all the problems that acclimatization poses. However, there are years when up to 2,000, 3,000 have been imported, making enormous efforts.

But we were not solving our problem that way. It was necessary to seek a solution. We had different pure breed yards of dairy cattle. Those yards were expanded; yards of other dairy breeds that did not exist were imported, and they were subjected to tests. They were not tests of high rigor and scientific level, but they were tests of crossing a sufficient number of animals and testing them in our feeding conditions, testing them in our pastures and observing the results.

Moreover, the dairy cattle of which we had the largest number of bulls was Holstein. And we began to make mass crossings when we had enough positive indications of the results of crossing Holstein with Zebu. The milking character of the first predominated widely in the F-1s, which also retained much of the resistance of the Zebu. We also crossed Brown-Swiss with Zebu as much as possible, Jersey, we even crossed Shorthorn, Red Polled, Ayrshire —forgive me if I do not pronounce it in pure English— and all breeds of dairy animals were crossed with Zebu and already, even, there are results from those crossings and from milk production. We have hybrids of all dairy breeds with Zebu.

And we have been able to verify, and we fortunately know, what is the only way in these circumstances for the country to have milk.

But, moreover, the country already has half a million F-1s, mostly crosses of Holstein with Zebu. Half a million that in the next two years will be in production and will increase Cuba's milk production fourfold.

We partially agree with what Dr. Willis claims that it is not only genetics that is fundamental for milk production; that it is necessary to solve the problem of livestock feed. Very correct.

We do not agree with Dr. Willis that genetics is not that important. And I say that you can improve feeding as much as you want, achieve the optimal, and we will see how much milk a Zebu cow produces. And if there is no milking potential in the cow, and we can only obtain it through those crossings, then there will be no milk even if there is feed for the livestock. For us, genetics was indeed very important, and we understood that clearly. That is why, unfortunately, we know that some technicians, even Dr. Willis, blame me for being the Director of genetics in Cuba, and comment on where a Prime Minister has been seen dealing with such matters, and that I know nothing about it, in which he may have a great part of the truth, I do not deny it. But see it for an interest that is the interest of this people! And I certainly do not believe that it constitutes a fault or a crime that in our responsibilities to the people we concern ourselves with these issues, we try to study, we try to know even a little, and we try to find solutions. A painful necessity of our country where scientists are not abundant, where technicians are not abundant, and where the men who have to assume the responsibility of finding solutions to these problems often do not even find the correct advice to arrive at such a solution!

We are not intruders in the field of science, or genetics. We are men compelled by circumstances to seek solutions, and we never stop listening to anyone who can present us with something reasonable, something clear. We do not pretend to be scientists. That would be absurd. Unfortunately, the countless obligations we have in many ways would prevent us from even dedicating ourselves to that hypothetical aspiration. We aspire to have the minimum knowledge to be able to evaluate the reports, or the theses, or the advice that may be given to us.

We cannot accept scientific rulers, that is, specialized in a science as in ancient times: the ideal man of Plato, studying all his life so that after knowing a little of everything, or all the little that was known, he could dedicate himself to the tasks of government. But it is the duty of any man in public responsibility to try to have the minimum of knowledge to be able to evaluate what scientists, technicians, specialists, may indicate in one sense or another.

And the path taken by the country has been that of massive crossing of a breed of dairy cattle with Zebu, to produce the hybrids known as F-1, with which to have a mass with milking potential; crossings that displeased Drs. Willis and Preston.

Now then —amazing!—: a paper was presented here —and I believe this is one of the fundamental issues— (and this is a thesis that we are willing to discuss with anyone, to submit it before a tribunal of scientists; I am willing to discuss it as much as you want, with all the necessary foundations, with Drs. Preston and Willis), this thesis presented at the congress on the hybrid of Holstein and Zebu. We are not scientists, but the evidence we have is so overwhelming that not even a scientist raised to the fifth power could really defend that thesis.

Simply the thesis that was presented at this congress, and that was signed by Drs. Preston and Willis, is the proof of production of comparative breeds between Holstein and the hybrid of Holstein with Zebu. Results: breed effect, five replicas, which means five mistakes; 15 animals of one, 15 of the other; age of calving: 27.5 for Holsteins, 24 for F-1s; milk yield in lactation: 1,961 kilograms for Holsteins, 370 for F-1s; fat: 3.1 for Holsteins, 3.3% for F-1s. Duration of lactation: 250 days for Holsteins, 72 for F-1s. Dry cows at 100 days: none for Holsteins. Dry F-1 cows at 100 days: 80%. That was presented here, even though it was called "interim." Because I would not dare to present something "interim" that does not have a minimum of conviction about its validity. It is not about presenting just to present. And yet this thesis was presented by a member of the institute and signed by the chief geneticist of the institution and by its director.

Now then: Can this be sustained? No, this cannot be sustained. Can this be investigated and verified? Yes, this can be investigated and verified: the nature of this presentation, the error that this presentation entails, the low quality and superficiality of the research, the mistake that this presentation entails, the disorientation that this presentation entails for livestock farmers in this country, and for those who work in livestock, for those who already possess half a million F-1 cows.

Now, is it that we are upset because an investigation has been conducted that yields an adverse result? No. What truly upsets us is that a presentation has been made that is a denial of reality, leading to a completely false conclusion.

If it is said that it will be the technicians who will judge the presentations and the value of the presentations, here are the technicians. And in the reality of the facts, I do not ask to be believed, I do not ask to be believed. I have no right to ask the technicians from other countries who visit us to believe me.

I can ask the Cubans, of course, who know that we do not deal in lies or demagoguery. But as for the researchers from abroad, we have no right but to submit the facts to the test. And I believe this is very important, because Latin America has tens of millions of cattle of this type; other countries have hundreds of millions. And we ask ourselves: How can they solve the problem of milk supply if they are not precisely going down that path, if they want to seek a solution to the problem that is adequate, correct, quick, urgent, because hungry stomachs cannot wait forever for solutions?

And what does reality, the facts, tell us? In the National Genetics Directorate, not testing with 15 cows per replica, but working with a large population of animals, what was demonstrated? In the face of these data presented here in a presentation, defended, upheld as a thesis about why, what phenomenon, it did not occur to anyone, except for comrade Teresa Planas from the National Genetics Directorate, to ask whether that was true or not. There were questions about why that was happening, whether it was because they took the calf away early or whether they inherited the lack of milking temperament from the Zebu, and that by taking the calf away, the cow dried up before 100 days.

Honestly, seeing that, I felt pity that at a congress, on a specific topic — and I do not say that all the other topics were the same, I do not say that, because I must say with all honesty that there were magnificent presentations here, magnificent presentations — but I say that on this topic, I felt pity that the congress was caught up in superficial disquisitions of that nature.

In the tests carried out by the National Genetics Directorate, what was the production of the F-1? The National Genetics Directorate has farms in different parts, and the response everywhere has been absolutely different.

Here are the data.

For example, in Cartagena, Las Villas, in the first group: average milk per cow: 2,723 liters, F-1, first lactation; fat: 3.65.

The average of the other group: 2,459 liters per cow; fat: 3.84.

Days of lactation in the first group: 273; days of lactation in the second group: 294. Maximum days of lactation, 381, minimum of 195 days; in the second group: maximum of 448, minimum of 172 days. Average fat produced per cow: 97 kilograms in lactation.

Now, let’s look at the comparison: milk in the ICA: 370; milk in those two genetic centers: 2,591.

The difference is too overwhelming, too great to go unnoticed.

Fat, ICA test: 11.1; test from the National Genetics Directorate: 97 kilograms. Percentage of fat in the ICA: here it says 3 — I do not remember if it appeared there as 3.3 — fat in the National Genetics Directorate: 3.74.

Duration of lactations. According to the ICA test, 72 days; duration of lactation in the centers of the National Genetics Directorate, 283 days.

Now, there is a phenomenon: the thesis that is defended here and is tried to be justified by its descent from Zebu, is that the cows had a short duration and that they produced milk in a short period of time and dried up.

What do all the data from the National Genetics Directorate demonstrate? Simply the parameters of dairy cattle: in the first month, 14.1% of total production is produced; in the F-1 it was 12.4%.

Second month, normal parameter: 14.1%; F-1, 12.4%.

Third month, 12.7%, normal parameter; F-1, 11.6%.

Fourth month, dairy cattle, normal parameter: 11.4%; F-1, 10.9%.

Fifth month, dairy cattle, normal parameter: 10.2%; F-1, 10.7%.

Sixth month, dairy cattle, normal parameter: 9.3%; F-1, 9.8%.

Seventh month, dairy cattle, parameter 8.3% of its total production; F-1 — in the seventh month! — 9.2%.

Eighth month, normal cattle, 7.4%; F-1, 8.9%.

Ninth month, normal dairy cattle, 6.7%; F-1, 7.6%.

Tenth month, dairy cattle, 6%; F-1, 6.5%.

The facts demonstrate that the F-1, in the conditions of our country, produces in the last months a higher percentage of its total production than what typical dairy cattle produce in the last months.

And here the thesis was upheld that the cows dried up before 100 days.

Now, there are even more interesting data.

Here we have a whole lot — previously we spoke of two groups.

Well: here is another group: a number of 199 animals. They have not finished their lactation, they are barely in the middle of their lactation period, offspring of not just one bull, offspring of 12 different bulls.

Here are the data. At 143 days they have an average production of 9.1 kilograms of milk daily, and they have already produced per cow 1,303.7 kilograms. They are F-1, first lactation.

But there is another group of animals about which we have quite a bit of information because they were among the first crossings that were made. We have witnessed the entire development of this program, we know it quite well, because it was precisely from the facts that helped us find a solution to the milk problem.

This is a lot of 45 F-1 cows. They are in Bijiritas. Here they are by their names, their numbers. All these cows exist in reality, they are producing milk now, they can go to verify — those who harbor any doubt — how the measurements have been made, how these results have been obtained, what basis they have, and all those animals and all those centers are at the disposal of all visiting researchers in our country.

Here we have a total of 45 F-1 cows (Zebu-Holstein) analyzed in their first lactation. We can observe the following:

From a total of 45 F-1 Zebu-Holstein females, daughters of Rosafé Signet, analyzed in their first lactation, we can observe the following:

a) They have reached 244 days of lactation, 37 females — of which 10 are still in production — which represents 82.2% of the total females.

b) At 305 days of lactation, 20 cows reached — of which seven are still in production — representing 44.4% of the total females.

c) The average age at calving was 28 months, therefore they were gestated at an average age of 19 months. We should note that the age interval at calving is between 25 and 34 months.

d) The average total days of lactation, including those that are still lactating and those that dried up prematurely, is 284 days. We must take into consideration that we intentionally dry the cows at seven months of gestation.

e) The average production achieved is: 45 cows, in total lactation, 11.8 kilograms per cow, with an average production of 3,352 kilograms in lactation, including the cows that dried up prematurely, that is, from the total average.

Thirty-seven cows, in 244 days of lactation, average daily production: 13 kilograms, 3,168.3 kilograms in the period.

Twenty cows that reached 305 days of lactation: 13.1 kilograms, 3,995.7 kilograms in the period.

Number of cows that did not reach 100 days: four, 8.9%: the Animal Science experiment, 80%.

Cows that dried up between 100 and 190 days: one, 2.2%; cows that produced between 200 and 300 days: 19, 42.2%; between 300 and 399 days: 18, 40%; 400 or more days: three, 6.7%. From which it is inferred that 88.9% of the animals exceed 199 days, for an average production per lactation of 3,708.3 kilograms of milk.

Average fat, 4.1%.

Now: here are the cows that dried up, that did not reach 100 days, four cows. Even the names: one is called EIsa, another is called Victoria, another is called Claudia, and another was named after an artist — we will not mention her so she does not get upset.

There is another cow that produced for 182 days — did not reach 200. It is the fifth cow, named Polvacera; she dried up at 182 days.

Now, I mention the names because what happened to them in the second lactation? We will see what happened with those that dried up first and those that did not dry up.

In the first lactation, of 45 cows, only seven of 45 produced less than 2,000 kilograms. The average of Animal Science was 370 kilograms, and here only seven gave less than 2,000.

Thirty-nine of 45 gave more than 2,000 kilograms: 84%; 25 of 45 produced more than 3,000 kilograms: 55%; 16 of 45 produced more than 4,000 kilograms: 35%; 8 of 45 produced more than 5,000 kilograms: 17%. That is, 8 of 45 exceeded 5,000 kilograms, and only 7 of 45 fell below 2,000. There were more that exceeded 5,000 kilograms than those that fell below 5,000 kilograms. Three of 45 surpassed the figure of 6,000 kilograms in lactation, and one — still lactating — is close to producing 7,000 kilograms of milk.

Naturally, this herd produced a little more, exceeded 3,000 kilograms. But the other herds have all been above 2,500 kilograms.

What happened in the second lactation? Two of those that dried up prematurely dried up again in the second lactation; that is, of three, two — Victoria and Polvacera — dried up again, proving to be unproductive.

Well. And with the others? Because there are 22 already in second lactation.

First of all, between calving, what frequency is occurring? An average of 360 days between calving. Which is a proof of the reproductive capacity of these animals: 360 days between calving, and that average is maintained.

In the second calving, 20 of these cows — there were 22, two were excluded — are between 158 days and 8 days: the one with the most time has already 158 days, the one with the least time 8 days.

Average daily production of these 20 cows, accumulated average: 19.5 kilograms, nineteen point five kilograms! The last week, between May 5 and 11, the average: 18.5.

In our opinion, this lot of cows will average in lactation between 4,000 and 4,500 liters of milk.

So that eliminating one of every ten — and in any livestock herd with an average production of more than 15 liters, selection is always made — here, eliminating one of every ten, average milk yields can be obtained almost equal to the average yield of Holland, a country in a temperate climate, with a livestock tradition.

The F-1, the cross of Zebu with Holstein, in second lactation, can reach in this test averages between 4,000 and 4,500 kilograms, eliminating one of every ten; with a fat percentage not lower than 4%.

We can say that lots of registered Holstein cows, imported in optimal conditions, have approximately this average in the first lactation with three milkings. A lot of imported, registered, selected heifers, with three milkings, is producing approximately that amount. And a non-selected lot of F-1, from which only one of every ten has been removed, in the second lactation, with two milkings, has a milk production equal to that of registered Holsteins in first calving.

And these are things that can be seen, can be observed by the participants in this congress.

Then, what factor could have determined such a presentation? Certainly, I do not think it is a deliberate thing, a dishonest thing. What factor has determined that Animal Science presents that type of replica, disorienting, false, confusing? Simply subjectivism, the subjectivism that has led in research to more than one mistake, due to superficial and negligent treatment of the problem.

Here are other data.

Here a work was presented by Dr. Willis on the mortality of different breeds. Dr. Willis wanted to demonstrate that European breeds can surpass the Brahman in tropical climate conditions.

And how did he demonstrate it? A herd of 30 Santa Gertrudis, 30 Criollas, 30 Charolais and another of Zebu. And the result of his tests: the mortality of fine Zebu in the ICA was 9.6%. However, in the genetic centers of the National Genetics Directorate, fine Zebu: of 1,833 calves, mortality 361. A third of the dead in the ICA. In commercial Zebu: mortality 2.68%; in Santa Gertrudis: 6.09% — in the ICA: 6%; these are the only two figures that coincide —; Charolais: mortality in the centers of the National Genetics Directorate, 6.77% — in the ICA: 3.5%; it is already a European cattle: they die less in the ICA, they die more in the National Genetics Directorate —; Criollo, the test was not done in genetics — in the ICA it resulted in 6.6% — in the National Genetics Directorate; F-1 of Zebu-Holstein: 2.48%; Zebu-Brown-Swiss: 2.63%; Zebu Shorthorn: 2.31%; Zebu-Charolais: 2.83%; Zebu-South Devon: 1.54%.

Now, how many animals did the ICA test? With a few dozen. In the National Genetics Directorate, 1,833, 1,715, 1,895 Santa Gertrudis, simply with thousands of animals, thousands of animals! Then, the hypothesis that Brahman, whatever its defects, turns out to be less resistant than Charolais to climate conditions is yet to be demonstrated.

There is another phenomenon, another fact, the percentage of births, in which it is also intended to demonstrate the superiority of Charolais in the conditions of our climate.

In the centers of the National Directorate of Genetics, 72.2% of 234 females were gestated, with 2.1 inseminations per gestation; in Santa Gertrudis, of 3,059 females, 65.5%, with 3.2 inseminations per gestation; in Cebú, of 1,175, 55.1%, with 2.5 inseminations per gestation; in Charolais, of 796 females, 52.5%, with four inseminations per gestation. Result: at ICA, Charolais offers the maximum reproductive capacity; here, in thousands of animals — although in this case there were about 796 — it turned out to be the one with the lowest reproductive capacity.

Of course, here in Cuba we have a Charolais herd. The researcher himself acknowledges its quality. We should be very pleased if the results were those because that herd is a lot of pure Charolais, it is a herd that has been preserved and developed in our country. But certainly, in the interest of reality, it cannot be stated now that Charolais is more fertile than Brahman: although in terms of conversion, Charolais is indisputably superior to Cebú.

Of course, even though here in these data from the National Directorate of Genetics it concerns thousands of animals, a definitive answer could still not be given; and it could not be given. Factors that could be influencing this fact would have to be further analyzed.

Moreover, it is observed that the birth rate of Cebú is low. However, the F-1, the hybrid of Holstein with Cebú, has a high reproductive capacity, a high percentage of gestations, and minimal mortality.

However, the genetic data were taken for calves over six months: at ICA, for three months. It is true that mortalities occur mainly in the first three months, but there are always some mortalities between three and six; and this mortality data was taken at six months.

It is simply indisputable that subjective factors have been influencing the research. And here are the data.

Dr. Willis presented another thesis that the resistance capacity of Cebú is a consequence of its productive incapacity. And with all due respect, we disagree with that point of view.

I believe that if one calmly starts from that axiom, from that dogma, one would stop looking in a direction that, in our opinion, needs to be explored, which is to investigate what factors make Cebú resistant, that make it resistant to heat; the factors that make it resistant to certain insects, factors that exist, that need to be investigated.

And it is simply a matter of seeking hybrid combinations, even the possibility of developing some new types of cattle that, through genetics, incorporate those characteristics that make Cebú resistant to the conditions of our climate, combining them with those characteristics that make dairy breeds more productive. The F-1 Holstein-Cebú is a good example.

Now, what policy do we follow? We cross again with Holstein, but we do not do it thinking of maintaining hybrid vigor; simply because our policy is to continue crossing with the pure animal to increase the mass of pure animals and then seek the hybrid. Just as we are now looking for the Cebú cow and Holstein bull, in the future we will seek the hybrid of the Cebú bull and Holstein cow.

Because among the crossings that have been made, a very interesting fact has been demonstrated: the offspring of the Holstein cow with the Cebú bull is much stronger, much more vigorous than the offspring of the Holstein bull with the Cebú cow.

That is to say, you can also notably verify this: animals that have reached weights of up to 1,300 pounds in a year, offspring of Cebú bulls with Holstein cows.

The country aims to develop new breeds if possible. We agree with Dr. Willis's thesis about the importance of hybrid vigor, the importance of heterosis in crossings; his thesis of maintaining heterosis to seek animals with better conversion. We are not against that thesis, because our policy is to seek meat production starting from dairy animals.

Gentlemen, this country does not aim to have millions of cows producing only meat.

We understand that it is in our interests to develop dairy animals. And at a given moment, when the mass stabilizes — because currently our mass is growing, females are not being sacrificed, that mass is increasing — in the future we will produce meat by inseminating approximately two-thirds of the mass with meat bulls and the rest with dairy bulls. That is to say, we will seek to replace pure cows, as well as F-1s, with one-third of the livestock, and inseminating the F-1s with meat bulls. New breeds superior to the F-1 could emerge, and that is what we are working on, but for now, for a long period, we understand that no animal will surpass the F-1. That is why we are also looking for the crossing of the Cebú bull and Holstein cow. In the future, we aspire to have approximately 30% of pure Holstein animals and 70% hybrids, because we understand that no other animal at this moment surpasses, in the conditions of our climate, the F-1 of Holstein with Cebú.

We have all the other crossings, not in such a large number but they are being born, they are already entering the first lactation. In the same way, work is being done on all the crossings of all the meat animals, including all the Europeans we have been able to import, precisely because I believe that without starting from any dogma, we must test, we must investigate.

If one starts from the dogma that if Cebú gives milk it will not resist, then one will not work in that direction.

But if we had asked the Animal Science Institute: tell us, dear researchers, how are we going to solve the milk problem? There would still be no other answer than this answer: that the F-1 dries up at 72 days and produces 370 liters of milk, exactly the milk of a Cebú. That is to say, the moral: to give up hope for many years of having milk in this country.

And I believe that this issue is not a matter of little importance. It interests us and it interests the scientific researchers who are concerned with answering the most pressing question of these times: how are we going to feed billions of human beings living in the underdeveloped regions of the world.

What will be the answer to the question of how to solve the milk problem? We do not say that we have the last and definitive word; but we do expose the basis of our hopes to solve it, on what fact it is based, and what we believe is so far the best known solution, a solution that is precisely the opposite of the thesis presented here regarding the comparison of the F-1 with the pure breed, regarding the comparison in productivity of these two breeds.

We must say that regardless of these discrepancies, very serious work has been presented at this congress. Unfortunately, we cannot see them all, because logically one does not have a copy of the works and discussions from one moment to another. We saw a significant number of them. We must say that we consider the study presented by various researchers to be serious. We admit, as is fair to say, that the research presented here by Dr. Preston regarding the use of honey in meat seemed to us to be serious research.

We must honestly recognize that serious and useful research for the country has been done. We must also say that another of Willis's presentations regarding meat productivity, the quality of meat from different breeds, is very interesting; we follow those investigations with interest, we follow their conclusions regarding Criollo cattle with interest. He is struck by the fact that there was no hybrid vigor between Criollo and Cebú, and it is logical, because what is good about Criollo — descendant of the first little cows brought by the Spaniards — is what has Cebú blood. And that is why all the other breeds produced F-1s of great hybrid vigor, and that hybrid vigor was not produced with Cebú, because what is good and resistant about Criollo has been inherited precisely from Cebú.

We do not have dogmatic positions on any of these issues. But we do believe that the comrades who work in livestock have been present here, and we could not allow them to leave with the impression that they have worked in vain. If it were true, we would tell them: We have worked in vain and we will start again; but that is not the case.

And here there are many comrades... We have examined the results here in genetic centers, but the results already in dozens of F-1 dairies are similar. Productions of up to 9 liters on average, fed with grass without concentrates.

Here interesting experiments with honey have been presented, in which honey has been used ad libitum. I think it is correct as an experiment, but it will not be a solution for us in the future. It must be done to study how it behaves, how it metabolizes in different proportions, that honey is interesting. But our country will have in 1980 much more than 15 million heads of cattle, it will have millions of heads of pigs as well, it will have considerable production of eggs, of poultry. If we use honey as a dietary supplement, as a supplement to our livestock fundamentally fed based on grass, which is how we conceive it so far, I believe there will be a long way — a very long way — before it justifies stabling our livestock and using thousands and tens of thousands of machines to bring them food. The feeding will fundamentally be based on grass and honey as a complement, or honey derivatives, like torula, accompanied by some type of animal protein. Why? Because even if we dedicate in 1980 7,500 million arrobas of sugarcane — which is the sugarcane necessary to produce 10 million tons of sugar — to cattle, honey ad libitum could never be given to our livestock because it simply would not reach, it simply would not reach. And gentlemen, we have to condition our technique to our possibilities and to our economic and social objectives. We are not an individual capitalist; we do not have market limitations. Here no one will ever be paid 370 dollars as in Europe for slaughtering a cow, when still in Europe they do not consume more than one liter of milk per capita, due to market problems for milk. We believe that the optimum of human need will far exceed one liter, it will even exceed two liters, because our limit is not the market, but the need, our limit is optimal consumption, and we do not have problems with internal markets, and we do not have problems with external markets, that is why we will expand our livestock production to the maximum, we will dedicate no less than 3,200,000 physical hectares that are already assigned, the vast majority of which will have irrigation, with a load per hectare of more than five animals. Here it was talked about how many New Zealand had... If one at the beginning, said Cooper, if four now. Gentlemen, here the plans made in livestock are never less than 5.5 animals per hectare, never less! And it has been demonstrated that up to eight animals per hectare can be had in pasture fattening, with irrigation and with the appropriate levels of fertilization.

Our agriculture should account for adverse factors. We had cyclones, floods, droughts, weeds... But these last factors can be controlled and the fruit crops that can be affected by cyclones, protected with adequate windbreaks: opening new lands for production with powerful machines; when that is controlled, when weeds are controlled, when droughts are controlled, no climate can compete with the tropics in food production per hectare, no climate! In Europe they have to fight against fewer factors, but they will never be able to count on the amount of light necessary to compete with one hectare in the tropics in any sense. Against corn is sugarcane, there are pastures, there are different varieties of grass. There will always be some differences. Our problem will be to try to minimize pasture production between the spring period and the so-called dry season, which will no longer be dry, but in any case some plants grow more in one period than in the other. We are studying all those problems and I believe that these should be the things studied in the institute.

The institute has not been prohibited from researching about corn, maize, sunflower, all things, in short: everything. But we hope that the institute will carry out a series of important investigations: that pastures are considered, that dairy cattle are considered. And we will never have a dogmatic position, the ears of the Revolution will always be open to the truth, to the results, to the research; they will always be open to any positive idea, there will never be dogma in this area. And if through maize — which we do not believe — one day it is unequivocally demonstrated, against the points of view of the Revolution, that it is the way, there will be no political obstacle — that disappeared in our country — there will be no social obstacle, there will be no whim, there will be no dogmatism: maize will be accepted. We simply require that the solutions persuade us in reality, in the facts. That is the position of the Revolution.

We believe that there has been intense work at ICA. We believe that the comrades who have been training have made a great effort. It pains us to have to expose things that, logically, may constitute for some a bit of concern, a bit of sorrow, but it is our duty.

Many of the works have called our admiration. We have been especially struck by the magnificent work of Dr. Sutherland on metabolism in the rumen, his theses, his ideas; it is truly interesting research.

On this occasion, we have had the great honor of having Professor Synge at this congress. For many years, we in our country have wished to have the visit of Professor Synge, because we were particularly interested in what he could guide us on, how he could help us regarding precisely that problem that was the subject of Sutherland's presentation here.

We have had great satisfaction, as well as having among us numerous specialists, some of the most eminent in the socialist field.

We hope that such visitors, we hope that our distinguished visitor Synge understands and knows to excuse us, to excuse us that this congress may be somewhat sui generis, different, that it did not conclude in an act of solemnity, in which our point of view was expressed with complete frankness, with total clarity and with all honesty. Here everyone has spoken with complete freedom! Here everyone has the freedom to express what they believe, their opinion against us, to criticize us even, to say whatever they please about us. And we simply accept it as part of the revolutionary work, that even sometimes hurtful things are said to us, we know it and we accept it. We are not bothered by that, we never call attention to it, we never interrupt.

We respect the right of others to express their points of view. And in the name of that right is that we too tonight have expressed ours.

Thank you very much.