Speech delivered at the Closing Session of the Meeting on External Debt of Latin America and the Caribbean, held at the Palace of Conventions, on the

Cuba Fidel Castro · President of Cuba

3 August 1985 · Meeting on External Debt of Latin America and the Caribbean · Palace of Conventions, Cuba

Context
Castro delivered a closing address at a multi-day meeting on Latin American and Caribbean external debt held at Havana's Palace of Conventions in August 1985.
Main themes
Latin American and Caribbean external debt, debt unpayability, economic underdevelopment, unequal exchange, imperialism and U.S. influence, Cuba's international solidarity, historical continuity of debt crisis, regional economic disparity, ECLAC and multilateral dialogue, accusations against Cuba, trade union engagement, development gap
Duration
~150 min
99th percentile
Words
17,961
99th percentile
Sentences
707
99th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.26
79th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 53%52%
  • Geopolitical 24%23%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Social 8%7%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

707 sentences in 206 paragraphs

You should not be alarmed by the amount of papers and brochures I have here; it is simply for consultation in some cases.

Thank you very much, dear Tencha, for your kind and generous words.

On the first day, I called you distinguished guests, or esteemed guests; allow me today, after almost five days of intense and familiar work, to call you: Dear guests.

Carlos Rafael began to say this afternoon that I was going to summarize. I immediately protested against that word: summary. I believe that a summary could be made by Gabriel García Márquez in a long novel, given the multitude of ideas, expressions, and events that have taken place in these days. I will try to express some personal impressions and, at the same time, try to pinpoint some ideas, express my thoughts on the topic that brought us together these days.

I have a privilege, I understand, and it is the permission that Tencha has given me to speak, not without a time limit, because everything has a limit: your patience, my endurance, and even common sense, which advises against being too lengthy. Many of the brilliant, capable, and intelligent people who spoke in these days did not have that privilege. I understand what it must have been for them to restrict themselves to such a complex topic, to 12 minutes, 15 minutes, or 20 in some cases. But I have also gone through that experience; I have attended many events and have often had to stick to 8 minutes, 10 minutes, or 20 minutes, and I have not been able to do it as well as you have done here in these days.

I feel the need to respond to some of the accusations that have been made regarding Cuba's activity concerning this dramatic problem. One of the accusations that is made against Cuba is that it has an opportunistic position — that is a little phrase that our neighbors to the North like very much — and that we are trying to improve relations, improve Cuba's image, and a series of similar, truly far-fetched theories. I believe that the effort we are making around this is not justified by any attempt to gain image, and that is very far from our mentality; I think that all this talk of image, of propaganda, is typical of the system they represent, and they imagine that everyone who does something or makes something in this world does it for reasons of propaganda or image. As I told the trade union leaders of Latin America and the Caribbean in the previous meeting, and expressed recently at the July 26 event, "with image, you cannot even feed a little bird." I believe this is a problem that is too serious, and we should not let ourselves be confused or deceived, nor should we allow such insidiousness to prosper.

That is why I tried to find some background, since when we started talking about this problem, and I found a precedent from 14 years ago, it was precisely in Chile, when we visited the country, following the victory of the Popular Unity. On that occasion, among countless events, I was invited to make a brief visit to ECLAC, whose headquarters is in Santiago, Chile, and there a dialogue was improvised. From all those speeches, there are shorthand versions that were published, and I collected some words from that day, fourteen years ago! The debt of Latin America, no one knows if it would rise to 30 billion or 40 billion dollars at that time.

And I said:

"We have read in these days that Chile owes more than 3.5 billion. It is known that, for example, Uruguay owes a little more than 800 million and that this country has to pay already 80 million per year; it exports I don’t know if 190 or 200 million; it has to import at least that same figure for maintenance, for maintenance!, for a difficult maintenance under conditions where its basic products have problems in the markets. Not only problems of unequal exchange but even problems of markets. It is said that the Republic of Argentina owes about 5 billion. I do not know how much each of them owes. But what I wonder is how they are going to pay, how they are going to pay the United States, how they are going to satisfy the external debt with that powerful country, and how they are going to satisfy the dividends, and how they are going to maintain a minimum level of subsistence and how they are going to develop.

A very serious problem in reality, today, or tomorrow, or the day after tomorrow. A problem that leads us to the reality of our countries. A problem that leads us to the consideration of that famous GAP, that famous abyss, that famous difference, which increases as the distance increases between a car going at 10 kilometers and one going at 100, or a car going at less than 10 and another going at more than 150."

On November 29 of this year, it will be 14 years since those words. It seems to me that everything we have said since then has already been germinating concerns, worries, and a question that had no answer. We can ask ourselves if there is now an answer, and if the current situation resembles, perhaps, the situation of 1971.

Over the years, Cuba, in international organizations, has been raising these problems, and I feel the need to recall another material that I already used in the trade union meeting, and for that reason, I ask the almost 100 trade union leaders who remained here to excuse me for having to listen again to the same reference. This was expressed in 1979, at the United Nations, after the Sixth Summit of the Non-Aligned, which took place in this very room.

In September 1979, we went, as is traditional after the Summit, to the country that hosted it, to speak at the United Nations. Even then we said: "The debt of developing countries has already reached the figure of 335 billion dollars. It is estimated that the total payment for external debt services amounts to more than 40 billion each year, which represents more than 20% of their annual exports. On the other hand, the average per capita income of developed countries is now 14 times higher than that of underdeveloped countries. This situation is already unsustainable" — year 1979.

And at the end of that part of the presentation, we expressed:

"In summary, Mr. President and gentlemen representatives:

"Unequal exchange ruins our peoples. And it must cease!

"The inflation that is exported to us ruins our peoples. And it must cease!

"Protectionism ruins our peoples. And it must cease!

"The imbalance that exists regarding the exploitation of marine resources is abusive. And it must be abolished!" Subsequently, an agreement was reached on the Law of the Sea, which the United States refuses to sign along with a small group of allies.

"The financial resources that developing countries receive are insufficient. And they must be increased!

"Military spending is irrational. It must cease and its funds used to finance development!

"The international monetary system that currently prevails is bankrupt. And it must be replaced!

"The debts of countries with relatively lower development and in a disadvantaged situation are unbearable and have no solution. They must be canceled!

"Indebtedness overwhelms the rest of the developing countries economically. And it must be alleviated!

"The economic abyss between developed countries and countries that want to develop, instead of decreasing, is widening. And it must disappear!

"Such are the demands of underdeveloped countries."

The debt of the Third World was then 335 billion, around that figure. I started speaking in 1971 when it was only 35,000 for Latin America, and possibly the entire Third World did not reach 100,000. I continued talking in subsequent years on the subject. At the Seventh Summit Conference held in New Delhi in March 1983, a report prepared by Cuba on the serious international economic crisis was delivered to all delegations and sent to the heads of state of all countries, just as had been done with the aforementioned speech at the United Nations, both for underdeveloped countries and for industrialized countries.

We spoke again at that meeting on this topic; I even spoke at some length, among other problems, about what unequal exchange consisted of, how it affected us, and I cited some examples. Thus, we explained:

"In 1960, with the sale of one ton of coffee, 37.3 tons of fertilizers could be purchased. In 1982, with the same amount of coffee, only 15.8 tons of fertilizers could be obtained." We, the countries of the Third World, generally export coffee, cocoa, and other similar agricultural products, and import fertilizers from the chemical industry of the developed world. To produce coffee, fertilizers are needed, or to produce corn or other foods; however, more and more coffee must be delivered to obtain less and less fertilizers, and they do not want there to be hunger.

"In 1959, with the income obtained from the sale of six tons of jute fiber, a 7-8 ton truck could be purchased. By the end of 1982, 26 tons of jute were needed to acquire the mentioned truck.

"In 1959, with the income obtained from the sale of one ton of copper wire, 39 X-ray tubes for medical use could be purchased. By the end of 1982, with that same ton, only three X-ray tubes could be acquired."

We are exporters of jute, copper wire, tin, and other minerals. Copper is exported by Peru, Chile, and other countries as a main line, or they export aluminum or other raw materials. And when all the products we export are compared with those we import, the same thing happens. So, we import sophisticated equipment, X-rays, industrial machinery, electronic devices, chemical products, etc., which are produced in the industrialized world, with very high wages; while we, with what wages do we produce our exports, if here it has been talked about minimum wages of 30 or 40 dollars a month in Peru, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile? On that same occasion, I cited other examples; I do not think more are needed to grasp the idea of the tragedy we are suffering with this ruthless plundering.

Among the things we raised there in New Delhi in March 1983 were:

"To fight tirelessly for peace, to improve international relations, to stop the arms race, to drastically reduce military spending and demand that a considerable part of those substantial funds be dedicated to the development of the Third World.

"To fight relentlessly for the cessation of unequal exchange, which depresses real export incomes, unloads on our economies the cost of inflation generated in the developed capitalist countries, and ruins our peoples.

"To fight against protectionism, which multiplies tariff and non-tariff barriers and prevents access to the markets for our exports of basic products and manufactured goods.

"To fight for external debt to be canceled for the large number of countries that have no real possibility of paying it and for the burden of its service to be drastically alleviated for those who, under new conditions, could meet their commitments."

When at the United Nations, four years earlier, I had made this same formulation, it was the most applauded point by the majority of the countries represented there; even industrialized countries, some of them understood that such a situation could not continue to be tolerated. These are the same ideas raised over the years; the problem was foreseen, it was foreseen and it was foreseen.

By the end of 1982, external debt was reaching 600 billion dollars, that is, it was already going from 10 to 10, from 30,000 to 300,000, then to double 300,000, and then to triple. Now it is exactly triple, and the problem has reached crisis levels. Now Latin America alone owes more than what the entire Third World owed in 1979. That is to say, the crisis matured, it worsened terribly, it became unbearable, and that is the reason why these same ideas, more adapted to each new reality, because the tone is changing, the tone is changing from one occasion to another, the first time it is said: "The debts of countries with relatively lower development and in a disadvantaged situation are unbearable and have no solution. They must be canceled!", and then another tone is used.

"To fight for external debt to be canceled for the large number of countries that have no real possibility of paying it," — in 1983, it is already talking about a large number of countries — "and for the burden of its service to be drastically alleviated for those who, under new conditions, could meet their commitments." The problem was worsening more and more, and there came a time when it became clear to us that no one could pay it, except for very few exceptions.

At that time, we thought that Venezuela or Mexico should be among the countries where the debt should be alleviated; but then we realized that oil countries like Nigeria, Venezuela, and Mexico had fallen into such a situation that those countries could not be excluded from the slogan of canceling the debt also for them; ultimately, it was valid for all Third World countries.

I do not intend to offend anyone by proposing that the debt of all Third World countries be canceled, because I am thinking that we are fighting for something just, for something reasonable; this is not intended, far from it, to offend anyone, but to include everyone in a claim that we have been asking for many years for a part of the countries, when the situation was not as grave as it is today. Today all prices have fallen, even those of oil.

It is true that the drastic increases in oil prices that occurred in the middle of the last decade affected the crisis, but they were not the cause of the crisis, and the best proof is that many oil-exporting countries are suffering from the crisis. The oil situation worsened it, but who was responsible for the oil crisis? The industrialized capitalist countries abandoned coal mines and began to waste a low-cost fuel; transnational companies were making enormous profits while maintaining the supply of a cheap fuel that competed with coal, competed with everything, at what cost? Practically every five years, global fuel spending doubled, and what nature took hundreds of millions of years to create, these consumer societies were liquidating in 100 years. Fuel was being depleted, squandered, huge cars, and carelessly designed facilities consumed it without limits; what could be saved after the energy crisis, when they proposed to save it, and at the same time they began to think about coal again, and to extract oil from certain wells that had been abandoned. But they are also the ones responsible for the oil crisis, with their wastefulness, with their senseless and irrational system of squandering the human and natural resources of the world.

We do not ignore it, yes, the oil situation influenced, worsened; but the culprits were exactly the same.

The only change from 1979 and 1983 to 1985 was reaching the logical conclusion that when the Third World owed almost a trillion dollars, no country in the Third World could be excluded from the call to annul the debt.

Now, I ask if any of those who have taken it upon themselves to challenge the fact that Cuba cares about these issues and has raised them where they needed to be raised, so many times, if just one of those who are challenging that Cuba be the host of a meeting to discuss these problems, or that someone speaks about a problem —as if ideas were also private property, just like a capitalist industry; and I understand that ideas are not the private property of anyone —; if just one of them spoke about the problem 15 years ago, 10 years ago, 6 years ago, 5 years ago, 3 years ago, or 3 months ago, because here one man did demonstrate that three years ago he spoke about the problem, which was Miguel Angel Capriles; he demonstrated it with his editorial from January 1983, in which he raised the problem in quite similar terms. Capriles said here that he was a businessman and that he was a capitalist, I hope no one suspects that he is a communist, or that he said that out of demagoguery or to improve his image. It is possible, even, that many laughed at the editorial at that time, but I feel respect, and in this case for a man who was not our friend, who has been a strong adversary and critic of our Revolution; I bow and feel respect for a man who raised the problem three years ago in the terms in which he raised it, because he had vision, he became aware of the problem quite early. He did come to the dialogue, he had no objection to coming, participating, and speaking here.

Who among those who challenged, or did not want to come to avoid playing into Castro's hands, has spoken a word about the problem, and when did they speak?

In fact, some have spoken in these days; some, in a rush, have been talking about the problem. Is it out of an old, deep-seated concern? No! They are scared because Castro is talking about the problem, and they even say: "What a pity that a communist is the one talking about this problem!" Well, no, because Capriles is not a communist, and Cardinal Arns is not a communist. And I am glad if talking about the problem has served, at least, for many who never even thought about the problem to now talk about the problem. I am glad! Because what is needed now is for everyone to talk about the problem.

I want to clarify, on the other hand, that we are not against any government; or I can say, with full propriety, that we are not against any democratic government.

Fortunately, at this moment, the number of countries governed by a Constitution, in a democratic process or democratic opening, are the majority. This is, in part, the result of the struggle of the Argentine people, the Uruguayan people, the Brazilian people, three very important countries that have changed the correlation of democratic forces in our region. That process is the result of the struggle of those peoples and the crisis, the two things came together. Those who ruled and governed repressively realized that the countries were becoming unmanageable.

That is to say, the crisis helped the process, and, in turn, the democratic processes can now help the fight against the crisis. Because many proposals that we have made were practically impossible to make when the correlation of forces was favorable to military dictatorships. Today we can say that the majority are governed by constitutional norms, that there are electoral, democratic processes. Each one has their ideas: how much is real democracy and how much is formal democracy, but we are not discussing that. I believe that no one disputes the positive nature of the recent processes of democratic opening, and we all long for the moment when we can say: There is also a democratic opening in Chile. And it will come, we do not doubt it —Pinochet is the only crazy one of that plague that still endures, who believes that his country can be manageable under those conditions—, no matter how much imperialism helps him, and tries to alleviate his situation at the cost of indebting Chile more and more.

We are not against the development of any democratic process; on the contrary, we are concerned that this economic crisis, if it does not have a correct solution, can make the survival of those democratic processes impossible.

We are not against the Cartagena Group at all. The only objection we have to the Cartagena Group is that it has not included all the countries of Latin America and the Caribbean, like this meeting in Havana, so that everyone is present. The argument is used that they are the main debtors, but this world is not made up of main and non-main, because in the United Nations all countries, big and small, have one vote. And this battle may need to be taken to the United Nations, to the OAS, to twenty places, and those votes are needed. The solution may be for the current Cartagena Group to lead, for a coordinating committee to be established, made up of the founders of the Group, and for others to join. It cannot be explained or justified well why there is no country from Central America in the Cartagena Group, despite the fact that the per capita debt of several of them is greater, and why there is no Caribbean country in the Cartagena Group, except the Dominican Republic. Jamaica is not there, Trinidad and Tobago are not there, many other countries are not there.

In our meeting, we were very concerned that each country spoke; it does not matter if it had 250,000 inhabitants or 100,000, these are countries that have their anthem, their flag, their sovereignty, their rights, and they must be respected.

That is the only objection we have publicly raised against the Cartagena Group. And we understand that our battle helps the struggle of that group. We have nothing against it, and we are willing to support them in their struggle to find a correct solution to this problem.

We are not against SELA, far from it; Cuba was one of the first countries to participate in the founding of SELA.

When, at the initiative of President Luis Echeverría of Mexico, that Latin American economic organization was created, one of the first countries that was spoken to, and that first gave its support, was Cuba. We are in SELA, we support it, and we agree that SELA, which is a Latin American and Caribbean organization, plays a role in the search for a correct solution to this problem.

We agree and support the idea of a meeting of heads of state, which was first proposed by President Alfonsín of Argentina, following his visit to Mexico; then President Febres Cordero proposed it, even suggesting that the Galapagos Islands, a world heritage site, be the venue for it; and then President Alan García, who has just taken office in Peru, proposed it. Three presidents have raised it. You supported it, and we enthusiastically support the idea of a meeting of heads of state.

You know that we have no sympathy for the OAS; but, even if the OAS meets, as they say it will meet, as it is claimed that it is calling the ministers of Finance and Economy of the hemisphere to a meeting in Washington for September, magnificent! Let them meet there, let them sit the United States right in front, yes, in the dock, let them discuss with it, let them present the realities and demand solutions. If the OAS ever served any purpose in its entire life, and served precisely for this, it is worth all that it has cost and the shame it has meant for this hemisphere. Even the OAS!

We are not in conflict with anyone, and all the steps we have taken we have taken knowing that this struggle helps other countries. And it is not that our positions are radical for being radical, I do not believe that our positions are radical or maximalist, as they say. Some have said they are maximalist, no, on the contrary, they are very realistic. Others say they are illusory; the deluded ones are the others, those who believe that this has a solution in another way.

They blame me for saying that the debt is unpayable. Well. The blame should be placed on Pythagoras, Euclid, Archimedes, Pascal, Lobachevsky, the mathematician of your choice, from antiquity, modern or contemporary. It is mathematics, the theories of mathematicians that demonstrate that the debt is unpayable.

I have to talk about that and I want to substantiate why I think it is unpayable and how none of the technical formulas being discussed solve the problem. But before proceeding, I wanted to inform you that today there was a false alarm here, in this room, in light of the news that the United States had decreed a blockade or punitive economic measures against Peru.

This afternoon a cable arrived that tries to explain the situation, and it says:

"Peruvian Foreign Minister Alan Wagner downplayed the announced suspension of U.S. economic and military aid to Peru and emphasized that it is a minor issue, magnified by the international press.

"In statements to the press, after a meeting with the U.S. Ambassador in this capital, David Jordán, the Foreign Minister stressed that it is a deficiency of the news agency that spread the information and related it to matters that have nothing to do with the case. He added that the application of the Brooke-Alexander Amendment is a legal device that the United States implements automatically when there are delays in debt payments. He indicated that, indeed, Peru owes Washington about $100,000, part of its arrears, which will be paid immediately, and noted that this debt is not of great significance and is the result of an administrative error by the previous government that was supposed to pay it.

"Wagner insisted that this has been a minor problem, which has no political implications, and that it should not be given greater significance." Had we known this earlier, we could have spared ourselves some of the anxieties expressed here today.

"The Peruvian Foreign Minister added that the decision of President Alan García's government to allocate only 10% of its exports to pay the external debt is a matter that everyone knows and has had no negative effects on relations with the United States.

"For his part, the U.S. Ambassador stated that it is a small error of appreciation regarding the information disseminated by international news agencies" —these wretched agencies that do nothing but create alarmism. "Jordán added that Peru owes the United States about $100,000 that it has committed to pay, it is an easy matter to resolve and has nothing to do with the economic policy applied by the Peruvian government. He reiterated that it has all been a misunderstanding, because the news was poorly focused and unrelated matters were connected that have nothing to do with this issue. The news is false and the relations between both countries are good, concluded Jordán."

These Americans are sincere people, no one doubts it, their government is a model; it was all a misunderstanding, a misfocus, a mistake. And what happened —my assessment, that is why I was waiting, when some comrades were impatient to know Peru's reaction— is that it was a tripwire, a provocation, a trap, a banana peel thrown in the path. Because they apply the Brooke-Alexander Amendment when they want, when it seems appropriate to them, and here they rushed. This conference is being held here and apparently they have gotten nervous. Just a few days ago was the inauguration of the new government of Peru, they do not apply the measure to the previous government, and instead they apply it immediately to the new government when it declares that it will not negotiate with the IMF and that it will reduce debt payments to 10% of exports. So, what a coincidence? An immediate measure: all military and economic aid suspended.

I truly believe that the new government of Peru acted with calm and did not let itself be provoked; but the intentions are clear. Who knows them better than us!

I wanted to explain this before proceeding, because I will also have to talk about the 10% formula.

I said that the mathematics demonstrated that the debt was unpayable, as a rule, but I believe that the rule has no exceptions. And believe me, I listened with great respect and will continue to listen with great respect to the arguments of all those who think it is possible to pay, and believe that it is possible; but I do not share that view. For some countries, there is no need to discuss; but for the few that might seem possible, I say it is equally impossible.

But what do these numbers mean? Sometimes they need to be translated into something. One day I thought to calculate how many years it would take to count the external debt of Latin America if an individual were to count the debt at one dollar per second. Do you know how many years? Eleven thousand five hundred seventy-four years. But then I asked myself how long it would take to count what had to be paid in interest over the next 10 years. Do you know how long it takes an individual, counting at one dollar per second, 24 hours a day? Twelve thousand eight hundred sixty years. But if they say we are exaggerating, that we have put one person to count, at one dollar per second, we say: no, put 100 people.

How long would it take? One hundred twenty-eight years. How can you pay in 10 years what 100 people, counting at one dollar per second, would take more than a century to count? Moreover, if all the guests at the dialogue here present, who are more than a thousand, were to start counting, it would take them more than 10 years to count it.

Another day I thought to do the calculation per hectare. Latin America owes 175 dollars and 30 cents per hectare, almost what a hectare costs, and has to pay in 10 years — just in interest, when I say it has to pay in 10 years, I mean only interest, not capital — 194 dollars and 80 cents per hectare.

I calculated how much it owed per square kilometer and the figure came to 17,530 dollars per square kilometer, and there are more than 20 million square kilometers. How much does Latin America have to pay in the next 10 years per square kilometer? Nineteen thousand four hundred seventy-eight dollars per square kilometer, just in interest. Look, we have heard about landowners, about exploiters, I do not know anyone who charges so much for land rent! How much does each inhabitant owe? Some more and some less, as you know. But on average, they owe 923 dollars per inhabitant, 390 million inhabitants. How much do they have to pay in interest, not capital? One thousand twenty-five dollars per inhabitant in the next 10 years. The cost of living, as can be seen, becomes truly unbearable if just to breathe we already have to pay 1,025 dollars on average each of us.

There are countries, like Costa Rica, that are not very large, that owe 100,000 dollars per square kilometer. How do they pay? Well, it would take a small gold mine, or almost a large gold mine per square kilometer to obtain the foreign currency to pay, because it is not that they owe Costa Rican pesos, or sucres, or bolívares, what they owe is dollars!, which must be acquired in the international market by exporting things, if they can produce them, if they have a market and if they are paid what they are worth. None of that exists: they have no goods, they do not have many goods — it is a developing country — nor are they paid what they are worth, nor do they have a market. So I say that if someone proves to me that Costa Rica can find a gold mine per square kilometer and finds 50,000 gold mines, then: well, yes, maybe. Especially if it is in nuggets and pure, it is possible to pay; in gold stones like those that appear in the river.

I did another calculation. In a continent where it is claimed that there is such hunger, that there are people who consume 1,200 calories and less than 1,200 calories per day, where there are so many malnourished, where there are 110 million unemployed and underemployed, where there is malnutrition — as you have pointed out — where 70% of the population lives at or below the lower limits of poverty, I calculated, with what has to be paid in interest, how the population of Latin America could be fed. The calculation showed that each of the 390 million — I did the calculation based on 400, there are 10 million more, in case the mice eat a little of that food — could be given, at current wheat prices, 3,500 calories and 135 grams of protein every day, for 17 years.

They ask a continent full of underemployment, of poverty, to pay in 10 years, just in interest, the equivalent of 3,500 calories and 135 grams of protein daily, much more than what is needed to live, for 17 years, just in interest. Does it make sense, does it have logic, does it have rationality? Well, that is the reality, what the numbers demonstrate.

The problem is that the facts show that it is not easy to pay that — as I said — it requires a market, and where are the markets? The International Monetary Fund says: "Everyone export," but what are they going to export? Ah, more coffee, more cocoa, more sugar, more meat? No, if they are going to be paid less and less for that. And export to where, if protectionism multiplies every day with tariff and non-tariff measures; every day there is a country affected: today Mexico, yesterday another, tomorrow another. Mexico's exports were affected by about 3 billion dollars this year, by removing certain tariff preferences. Just like that, in one fell swoop, they were taken away.

One of the representatives from Colombia spoke today about coal mines and, indeed, a large open-pit coal deposit is an important wealth. But I also know that when the price of coal dropped from 50 dollars to 39 dollars, they are already proposing a protective measure of nine dollars per ton in the United States so that that Colombian coal does not reach the power plants in the eastern United States, where around 79 plants are potential buyers of that coal, the coal companies in the United States have already begun to demand a tax. And it can perfectly happen that a country makes a huge effort, a huge expense and when it starts to export the coal they impose a tariff of nine dollars, because those gentlemen have much more importance and weight in the United States Congress than a Latin American country.

In the United States, only in relation to Japan — since the war is among all of them, not just with us — there are more than 80 proposed protectionist measures in that country's Congress against Japan. They are desperate, in the effort to get rid of the competition, they no longer know how to resolve the tangle and invent protectionism once again. They are applying harsh protectionist measures to sugar producers. Here the Martinican spoke of a mill that closed, the Panamanians know that the Bayano mill, which they built there next to a large dam for electricity and irrigation, a modern mill, has been closed for four years.

Of course, if in 1981 the United States imported 5 million tons of sugar, in 1984 it imported only 2.7, this year it imports 2.6 and in 1987 it will possibly be importing 1.7. How can the economy of some countries that produce sugar withstand the reduction of the market from 5 million tons to 1.7 in six years with subsidized sugar?

It was the same market that was taken from us when they distributed sweets everywhere; our quota, in exchange for the isolation of Cuba, why do they forget those things? We do not want to remember them, but it happened, it is sad but it happened. And now they snatch the quota away. Have they made a socialist revolution? As far as I know, no, unless I am misinformed by these news agencies. They take those measures, and they ask our countries to increase exports to seek dollars when they close the markets, they say: "everyone export," and they close the markets. Where are they going to export to?

Yes, we know that in the world there are millions of needs, but those who have them do not have money to satisfy them. And they demand dollars from Latin American countries to pay the interest on the debt, no one discusses the capital anymore, nor do they care, because they know that every eight or nine years they recover the capital and recover it again, and in 30 years they recover it three and a half times. They can forget about the capital, that with the interest alone they solve the problem.

Where are they going to export? Moreover, the International Monetary Fund comes and says: "reduce imports." But how are they going to increase exports, if as was said here — and everyone knows — certain inputs, equipment, spare parts are needed to increase production and boost exports? And if they managed that miracle, some countries achieved it for one year, that cannot be achieved much more than one year, the stock of raw materials, parts, equipment runs out, they need to be replaced. I am no longer talking about development; that lasts a year, as long as a lightning bolt. They say, however: "Yes, import less." Where are they going to get to increase exports; and if they increase them, where is the market; and if they increase them and there is a market, what price are they paid? We know that in 1984 Latin American countries exported goods worth 95 billion dollars; look at that effort, raising production from 75 billion to 95 billion, and with depressed prices. That same purchasing power they would have achieved in 1980 with 75 billion, with 22% less goods. They worked, they killed themselves producing more; they went to export it, and they are given the same purchasing power that they were given for 22% less goods four years earlier. What country and what economy can adapt to those catastrophes and those effects?

And then the International Monetary Fund comes and says: "No, also, remove the tariff barrier." They advise everyone the Chicago recipe or something similar. The International Monetary Fund has always belonged to the Chicago School, it seems. "Remove the barriers, compete!" The competition that Rodomiro Tomic spoke about yesterday, between the lion and the lamb. When I passed by there I asked him: Rodomiro, how did you say, between the lion and the seal? He says: "No, no, no, do not misrepresent me, I said between the lion and the lamb, and between the shark and the seal." Correct, two excellent examples that our friend Tomic put forth in his brilliant speech yesterday.

Well, compete. Ah, they are going to compete with the robot machines from Japan and with automated production. That is why, as a Uruguayan told me, even the little factory they had making head ornaments was put to compete with a transnational from South Korea, and a few days later the factory was ruined, closed, and they found themselves importing head ornaments from South Korea. That is the recipe. They say: "Remove the tariff barriers," while they, the industrialized countries, raise them in relation to our products.

All these are realities that we must not forget. If we forget about unequal exchange, if we forget about excessive interest rates, if we forget about all the tricks and all the acts of piracy that they are committing, then one could start to dream one day, just one day, that the debt can be paid. But there are many other realities, and when we start from those realities, and I am talking to you about economic realities, it becomes impossible.

Now, do technical formulas solve? No, technical formulas do not solve, none. Precisely in the interview with "Excelsior" I try to explain different hypotheses, and on that occasion I established four hypotheses. Our friend Juan Bosch here started from those four hypotheses to explain the problem in Santo Domingo, what would happen with the Dominican debt. In none of the variants did the problem have a solution.

Now a new formula has been proposed. I had analyzed the one to pay with 20% of exports, and I demonstrated that it did not solve the debt problem. Now the formula has emerged, proposed by the new government of Peru, of 10%. Undoubtedly, it is a step forward to propose that formula in relation to what is happening, to propose that it will not be discussed with the International Monetary Fund and that it will be paid only with 10% of exports. It is known what Peru's exports are, exactly 3.1 billion dollars; imports, approximately 2.9 billion; debt, as we know, about 14 billion, it was explained here. Just in interest, more than 1 billion must be paid each year. The International Monetary Fund and imperialism do not like at all that someone proposes to pay with 10%. But would the 10% formula solve this problem? I am speaking only in economic terms, in arithmetic terms. It does not solve, and it is clearly demonstrated. I asked some colleagues to go to the computer and do the calculations — I, as you know, did not have time, because I was here meeting with you — and I pointed out four other hypotheses.

The government of Peru says it will pay 10% for one year. I say: fine, let it not be for one year, let Latin America apply the formula of paying only 10%, not for one year, but for 20 years, what would happen? Assuming there are 20 years of grace, no capital amortization, and only 10% of exports are paid for the interest on the debt, and even if these exports grew above 100 billion a year— they still do not export 100 billion, assuming they grew above 100 billion— that the interest payment did not exceed 10 billion annually, the interest rate approximately equal to the current one, and that no new loans are contracted, what would happen? After 20 years, what would the situation be? All of Latin America, applying this formula to all countries, would have paid, in 20 years, 200 billion dollars. And after 20 years— when the capital and interest are added and, in turn, the capitalized interest starts to accrue interest— with this 10% formula and assuming they never paid more than 10 billion a year, Latin America would owe— let me explain, because there is the million, the billion, and the trillion; in Spanish, a billion is a million million—: 1 trillion 849 billion 149 million dollars, more than five times what it owes today. That would be our bright future with this formula in 20 years, and we would have paid, in cash, 200 billion. What can be done with 200 billion well invested! I am talking about well-invested millions, not siphoned off, you know that.

A second variant, this is a miraculous variant: it assumes 20 years of grace, that the debt interest is paid with 10% of the value of exports, without a limit, even if it goes from 100 billion to 200 billion in exports a year and exceeds it; that the interest rate remains as it is now and that exports increase at the fabulous rate of 10% per year for 20 years. We could ask the Dominicans, any country, if they can absolutely increase exports, for 20 years, at an average annual rate of 10%, without receiving a single new loan.

What would happen after 20 years? Well, after 20 years, with that 10% of exports that increase by 10% per year, 572 billion 752 million dollars in interest would have been paid. And do you know how much would be owed in that fabulous and hypothetical case? 1 trillion 198 billion 715 million dollars, approximately four times what is owed today, another "brilliant" future. That is what the mathematics says: Pythagoras, Euclid, all those people I mentioned.

Another miraculous variant, that the interest is reduced to 6% and that, of course, no more than 10 billion is paid per year. As in the first variant, 200 billion would be paid in 20 years, and in the end— assuming that interest is established at half of what it is today— 786 billion 712 million dollars would be owed. A "brilliant" future, we have "escaped" total dependency. Someone would have to calculate how long it would take to count the debt in that hypothesis.

A fourth variant, the "perfect" one: that without a single cent of new loans they achieve the miracle of finding the markets, the prices, everything, to increase exports at an average rate of 10%, for 20 years, with 6% interest and paying the interest on the debt with no more than 10% of exports each year; that is the "super-optimal." What would happen after 20 years? They would have paid 427 billion 292 million dollars in interest and still the outstanding debt would be 444 billion 681 million. A fabulous thing, almost 100 billion more than what is owed now, a "brilliant" future!, after performing all kinds and all sorts of miracles. So it is not a whimsical thing.

If instead of 10% they set 5% of exports, the same thing happens and the debt grows more.

The problem must be understood well: the debt is a cancer, understand that it is a cancer that multiplies, that liquidates the organism, it ends the organism; it is a cancer that requires surgical operation. Any solution that is not surgical, I assure you, does not solve the problem. You cannot leave a single malignant cell; if you leave malignant cells, there is metastasis, the tumor reproduces and quickly ends the organism. It must be understood, it is already an irreversible disease.

Some spoke here of diseases, of viruses, of similar things. Monsignor Méndez Arceo spoke of the virus of anti-communist campaigns, others used other images. Well, there is nothing more similar to a cancer than external debt, and that is why, everything that is left of that malignant tumor, half, one-fifth of the malignant tumor, 1% of the malignant tumor, promotes its reproduction.

Imperialism has created that disease, imperialism has created that cancer, and it must be surgically excised, totally. I see no other solution. Everything that deviates from that idea simply deviates from reality, every technical formula in the face of these realities, every palliative does not tend to improve, it tends to aggravate the evil.

On the other hand, unequal exchange is increasingly unequal. I believe that even a first-grade child can understand this, if they are taught to count a little and given an idea of what a million is.

That is what any analysis of the situation demonstrates.

But well, how to solve this? It is clear that there is a cancer, it is clear that the problem must be resolved surgically, and one wonders where the resources for this operation will come from, which was the first thing I asked myself, meditating on this: Where are the resources? It is clear that there are resources in the world to solve this cancer that is affecting the lives of billions of people, and that kills! I am sure it kills more than human cancer, when we analyze all the children who die in the Third World in their first year of life, when we analyze all those who die in the first five years of life and those who die between 5 and 15 years, when we calculate the average life of many countries, as a consequence of undernourishment and malnutrition. And not to mention something terrible: the number of physical and even mental invalids. Yesterday it was mentioned here that tens and hundreds of millions of children grow up with their mental faculties limited by malnutrition problems.

Does human cancer cause so much damage? However, doctors recommend excision when there is cancer. This kills much more than cancer!

So, are there resources? Yes, there are resources, what are they dedicated to? To preparing the death of people, to war, to the arms race, to military spending. A trillion! In a single year, the world wastes, in the game of war and military spending, a trillion dollars, more than all the external debt of the Third World combined. Does it not have an elementary logic? Can any human being not understand it? Can any citizen, whatever their ideology, not understand that it would be worth it to liquidate this debt with a small part of military spending? Because we are not talking about the debt of Latin America, we are talking about the debt of the Third World. At most, and depending on the interest, 12% of military spending would be sufficient.

But, in addition, in military spending are the resources for the New International Economic Order, to establish a system of fair prices for all products of the Third World, to put an end to the ignominious method of unequal exchange. How much could all this amount to? Well, roughly, about 300 billion dollars a year, the purchasing power of Third World countries would increase, which are not going to save the money, they have too much hunger and too many needs to save the money, they will invest it in industries and spend it in some way. There would still be 700 billion dollars for military spending, which would be enough to destroy the world several times over, unfortunately, all of which constitutes an immense madness. In the world, those expenses exist. We must become aware that there are resources to solve this terrible cancer, which kills so many tens of millions and invalidates so many people every year, which makes so many millions of people miserable. That is why we associate the two things: the problem is not solved by canceling the debt, by abolishing the debt; we would be back to square one, because the factors that determined this situation are still present. And we have raised those two things very closely associated: the abolition of the debt and the establishment of the New International Economic Order.

We propose some other ideas, because this must be implemented. How to implement it? We must raise awareness; first, we have to raise awareness among ourselves, the countries of Latin America and the Caribbean; but we must raise awareness not only among ourselves, but in all the countries of the Third World, that is what can give us strength; to raise awareness even in industrialized countries; we must send a message to the public opinion of industrialized countries, to show them that what is happening is a great madness; we must direct a message to workers, to students, to intellectuals, to women, to the middle classes. They have other problems, and perhaps the cure for our problem can help to solve some of their problems.

It is very important to tell the public opinion of industrialized countries: these formulas that are proposed will not affect them, will not increase contributions, taxes, it is not necessary if resources from military spending are used.

We must send a message to depositors in banks. When they say that any of these formulas will ruin the World Financial System, we must tell them: No!, that is a lie. If the resources to solve the debt problem and the New Economic Order are taken from military spending, then no depositor will lose their money.

We must not forget that there are millions of them in the industrialized capitalist world, even workers, middle classes, professionals, many people, and they are told that the formulas being proposed will bring about the bankruptcy of the banking system and that those who have their money deposited in banks will lose it.

We must send a message to workers, whose scourge is unemployment, because it is the scourge of Europe, the scourge of the United States, and tell them: this formula would raise the purchasing power of Third World countries, industries would be more utilized and there would be more employment in industrialized countries.

Someone out there showed an article, which by the way, said: "Castro, Keynesian." I do not know if they are asking or stating. I will tell the truth: I did not even remember that Keynes had existed when I began to meditate on these realities. There may be a certain coincidence in the fact that the increase in the purchasing power of that enormous mass of needy people in the Third World will, of course, increase trade and increase exports, will increase employment in the developed capitalist world. Capitalism will not be saved! Because capitalism has no possible salvation; the problem for the Third World is that we do not die before capitalism does. That is the problem.

If they continue to starve the Third World, if they continue to invest those huge sums in weapons, in a matter of days they can liquidate life on Earth. It is possible that before capitalism ends, humanity will end, and it would be worth putting a straitjacket on them, a small straitjacket, and saying: do not spend a trillion, spend only 600 billion, 700 billion. They still have money left for madness, for many of the madness they are doing.

I believe that the underdeveloped world, the Third World, could impose that, yes; are we going to give up the idea of fighting? Are we going to be pessimistic, are we going to believe that our opinion, our awareness, our will, even our ability to win public opinion in industrialized countries is of no value?

Because they have two problems and two great fears. The man of the Third World hardly has time to remember the war, because he is virtually dying every day; those in the rich world, who have many beautiful things, magnificent, excellent cities, great comforts, are more or less well-fed. They, however, have two great concerns: war and unemployment. I believe it is absolutely correct, it is the right tactic, to associate our problems, constituted by underdevelopment, poverty, all these social calamities that have been spoken of here, with the concerns of public opinion in the industrialized world: first and foremost, the danger of war, because they do have time to think about what a war could mean, and they see clearly that all this madness of accumulating more and more tens of thousands of nuclear weapons can lead, and undoubtedly if that is not stopped it will lead to a great disaster.

We can associate our concerns with concerns for peace and for unemployment that exists in the industrialized world. We must be able to transmit that message.

And there are many people in those countries who think. Not everyone is a transnational owner, not everyone is a warmonger; I believe that this struggle can help isolate the warmongers, the supporters of war.

Certainly, imperialism needs weapons. Someone raised here —I don't know if it was López Michelsen, or perhaps Capriles— whether we are proposing disarmament, the cessation of the arms race not only for the West but also for socialist countries. When the President of Ecuador, Febres Cordero, visited our country, and I was raising these issues, he asked me: "Does that mean that only the Westerners have to disarm?" "No, no." I said: "Look, if I were really proposing this with the idea that the West should disarm unilaterally while socialist countries continued to arm themselves, what I would be saying would not be honest, it would not deserve any respect".

What happens is that I know how socialist countries think; socialist countries have truly known war, much more than the public opinion in the United States has known it. The Soviet Union had 20 million dead in World War II; Poland had 6 million dead; Yugoslavia had one and a half million dead. The territory of the United States did not know war, it suffered only a few hundred thousand dead, it has no idea what war is, while the memory of the reality of war is very fresh in the consciousness of the countries of the socialist camp. They were never interested in war. They surrounded it with nuclear bases, they surrounded it with battleships, submarines, bombers, all kinds of weapons, and then some wonder why they arm themselves. It is as if they were asking us why we arm ourselves, with a neighbor like the one we have, threatening us every day. In reality, I tell them that a country like ours, what less can it do than prepare to sell its life dearly. And not only to sell its life dearly, but to thwart an aggression against the country!

Unfortunately, in our case, the uniform was also seen with much distrust, with much reservation and, in general, with fear, with hatred. Today every man and woman in this country has a uniform. I remember what the Bolivian priest said, with extraordinary and impressive honesty, about his impressions or preconceived ideas regarding Cuba. Of course, that reminded me of the poison that Méndez Arceo spoke of, because they are specialists in producing toxins with what he called the worst form of biological warfare. A happy image used to reflect what imperialist propaganda is! It is to sow poison everywhere, in large quantities. But today our people respect, not only respect, they want, they love the uniform; every man and every woman has it, because the exercise of arms is no longer that of a group, the exercise of arms is of the whole people, of all men and women fit to fight in this country, and the arms are in the hands of the people, they are also in the factories and in the workplaces! No one has to fear uniforms or weapons, because the enemy has imposed that need on us. I also say that if sometimes the function of the military is dishonorable, sometimes the function of the combatant, of the soldier, is very dignified and very honorable, especially and solely —we could say— as long as the cause of the soldier and the cause of the people are the same cause.

We also know what can be done with what is invested in weapons, and how hard it is to have to invest large sums in trenches, fortresses, tunnels, fortifications of all kinds, and to employ tens and tens of thousands of young men, and technicians, and equipment and resources in the task of defense. We know how many homes can be built with what we have to dedicate to that and how many schools.

We have built schools by the thousands: primary, secondary, technological, all the children and young people in this country have schools; however, we also want to build art schools, one per province, vocational and other professional schools. Our little program is moving forward little by little, because needs are never satisfied, they are unlimited; when you have resolved the school, the hospital, the medicines, then houses are lacking, and when you have the houses, other things are lacking, places for recreation, and you have to invest in that. When it has already reached a level of schooling of almost 9th grade, like the one our people have today, other cultural aspirations develop, and all the provinces want to have their art schools, their theater, music, and dance groups.

Wouldn't the resources we have had to spend on defense over these 20 years be much better invested in those things? What do we want weapons for? What does a socialist country need weapons for? What does it need an arms race for, what does it need wars for? Socialism, as I interpret it, and as all socialists interpret it, and as every true revolutionary interprets it, has nothing to do with weapons. One must be crazy to think that in today's world this contradiction can be resolved through weapons: the contradiction between socialism and capitalism.

The one who needs weapons is imperialism, because it is orphaned of ideas. To maintain this disgraceful system, to maintain all these situations that have been talked about here, it needs weapons, it has to maintain them through force; but if there are ideas, if ideas exist, those ideas can be defended and can be made to triumph; ideas do not need weapons, to the extent that they are capable of conquering the masses. The contradiction between socialism and capitalism cannot be thought to be resolved by force, one must be crazy to think that; and those who think that are the imperialists, which is why they maintain military bases all over the world, threaten everyone, intervene everywhere.

Where are the military bases of socialist countries? The United States has hundreds of military bases, and has fleets in all the oceans of the world. Here, Diego Garcia has been mentioned, and the Malvinas have been mentioned where they have installed a base, they want another one over there, for their crazy Star Wars, 4,000 miles from Chile, on Easter Island. Every day it is instrumenting the obsession of seeking an island, an islet, a piece of land, something, to maintain its system of dominance by force, a system of plunder over the world. Yes, there is a philosophy that the world must be kept under plunder, and since plunder cannot be maintained except by force, that explains this philosophy and this blind faith in weapons.

If socialism does not aspire to take anything from anyone, not a piece of land from anyone, nor to exploit the work and sweat of anyone, really, what does it need weapons for? Only imperialism, with its continuous aggressions and threats, is responsible for our spending on weapons.

I start from that conception and I know that all socialist countries know perfectly well what they can do with those resources that are dedicated to weapons. And when I say this with complete certainty, it is not that I have written a letter to the leaders of socialist countries asking them if I can raise this, or if they agree or not with this, but that the most elementary logic indicates to me, tells me, gives me the certainty that this is socialist thought, and I am sure that socialists, who do not have the problems that Third World countries have —although there are some socialist countries in the Third World— also have a huge concern for the dangers of war. I have no doubt, and I know it from the statements they have made and I know how they think, that socialist countries would also support the Third World in this struggle to resolve the economic crisis, the debt problem, and the New International Economic Order.

When we talk about abolishing the debt, we talk about all the debts that the Third World has with the industrialized world, I do not exclude socialist countries. When I talk about the New International Economic Order and fair prices, I do not exclude —far from it— socialist countries, and I am sure that for them it will mean sacrifices, but they will understand and support.

I mentioned here the issue of the Law of the Sea. I remember when that struggle began for Peru, for Ecuador, for Chile, for Mexico, socialist countries already had large fleets fishing in the high seas, we had even developed an important fleet. Historically, we fished in the vicinity of the coasts of Mexico, the United States, Canada, from all over, when the limits of economic waters were 12 miles. The 200 miles harmed us, however, we did not hesitate to support Latin American and Third World countries in that demand, in talking with socialist countries, in asking for their support, and socialist countries supported the demand for the 200 miles. Peruvians know this, Mercado Jarrín knows this, and those who were in those governments know this. And they were considerably affected, since they already had billions invested in large fishing fleets. We were affected and we were among those who defended the 12 miles the most. Now an agreement has been reached, but the United States wants to own all the seabed, outside the 200 miles, and demands the privilege that its transnationals, using and abusing their technologies, can exploit those resources without any restrictions to obtain cheap chrome, cheap minerals, even cheaper, to ruin even more the Third World that does not have those technologies to go to the Pacific Ocean, the Indian Ocean, or the Atlantic Ocean to seek minerals. What future awaits us?

In the agreements on the Law of the Sea, it is contemplated that investments benefit all countries. The United States does not want to accept it, just like some of its other allies.

I have no doubt that socialist countries will support this cause; now, it is very important that we are aware that this is not a struggle only of Latin America, it must be a struggle of the entire Third World, because that is what gives us strength. They have the same problems and some have it worse than we do, only that Latin America is the one that can lead this struggle, it is the one that has more social development, even more political development; a better social structure, millions of intellectuals, professionals, tens of millions of workers, peasants, a level of political preparation, speaks the same language.

Africans are in a more desperate situation: they owe almost 200 billion, but they are even worse off, more dependent on the food that is sent to them from time to time amid desperate famines, a situation even more terrible, if possible, than that of Latin America. But all Third World countries, those that fight in the United Nations, in the Group of 77, those that fought for the New International Economic Order, have an awareness of these problems.

In Latin America, almost a single language is spoken. It is true that there were interpretations in French, English, Portuguese; those who speak Portuguese, who constitute an important part of the Latin American population, listened perfectly in Spanish and understood, and we understood them when they spoke Portuguese; and even some of the English-speaking countries, like Belize and Curacao, where they speak Papiamento —I think that is the name of the language they speak— even Haiti spoke Spanish here. So the communication that exists in this region does not exist in any other region of the Third World: neither in Asia, nor in Africa, nor anywhere else. Undoubtedly, the region of the world that is in the best conditions to wage this struggle is Latin America; it would be very difficult in Africa to hold a meeting like the one that has been held here, or anywhere else in the Third World. That is to say, there is a greater political development, a better social structure for this struggle, and Latin America has much more potential, not only economically but also politically.

These are basic principles. It is not just a single idea, it is not just the idea of abolishing the debt; this is associated with the idea of the New Order. In Latin America, it is also associated with the idea of integration, because even if the abolition of the debt is achieved, if the New Economic Order is reached, without integration we would still remain dependent countries. If Europe cannot conceive of living without integration, how can these countries, numerous countries of various sizes and levels of development, some larger than others, conceive it? Brazil, of course, has more possibilities, but even Brazil needs integration; Brazil needs the rest of Latin America and the Caribbean, and the rest of Latin America and the Caribbean needs Brazil. All the countries of this hemisphere need integration, that is why we talk about economic integration, which is another of the points we have highlighted. That is essential, elementary. These are basic ideas. The problem of when and how all this will be implemented is another matter. I believe that to the extent that these ideas come out of the ivory towers; to the extent that these ideas become the ideas of the masses, of public opinion, of the people; to the extent that these ideas become the ideas of workers, of peasants and students, of intellectuals and of the middle classes of Latin America, these ideas, sooner or later, will triumph, among them the idea of economic integration.

It is clear that if, at a historical stage, those who are responsible for advancing in a certain direction do not move forward, the masses will surpass them, advance, and carry out historical objectives.

Another essential idea is the following, the idea of unity that we have been proposing from the very beginning: unity within countries and unity among countries; within countries, where there are minimal conditions for unity, and today, fortunately, these exist in most countries of Latin America, not in all, as I have explained very carefully. No one envisions unity with the tyranny of Pinochet, or with that of Stroessner, and there are some other cases, but they are not so abundant. It is the idea of unity within, because internal strength is needed to wage this struggle, and unity among the countries of Latin America, and among all the countries of the Third World, because external strength is needed. Seeking unity with certain industrialized countries, and I am sure that this struggle could count on the support, even, of numerous industrialized countries, those that are not centers of global power and that, in a way, have also been affected by the monetary and adventurous policies of the current administration of the United States government.

Rather, I believe that if this struggle is carried out consistently, the United States will be left isolated, with a few partners, the same ones who oppose sanctions against apartheid in South Africa, the same ones who oppose signing the Agreements on the Law of the Sea. I am sure that if this struggle is carried forward to the last consequences, they will be left isolated; that is why they will try to divide by all means, to intimidate, to threaten. It is not surprising that in their nervousness they have thrown the banana peel they threw at Peru, and the provocation they have just made against that country.

Now, an important issue was raised here, which is why I felt the need to elaborate. Díaz Rangel raised —and this is the second time he has tricked me, because he did the same at the union meeting, posing a question from the podium; I say trick in the good sense, not in the imperialist sense of the word— the question related to dialogue, whether or not to engage in dialogue; I myself started to review a bit what I said about this; I know what I said, but I wanted to see it precisely, since I spoke more broadly on this topic, what I said.

When talking about these problems in the interview with the newspaper "Excelsior" —you have it, because you have received many materials; there are abundant pamphlets of those and you had access, although I am sure you did not have much time, I believe that even Díaz Rangel has not had it, because if he had read it well, he would not have raised the question here, he would not have asked about the matter — I said:

"Economic blockade of the Third World, or intervening for debt issues, as they did in the first decades of this century in Haiti, the Dominican Republic, and other countries; repartitioning the world again to ensure the supply of raw materials and markets, as happened in other times, is today absolutely impossible.

"The struggle for such a rational demand as the solution to the external debt problem and fair economic relations between the countries of the Third World and the industrialized world is so essential for the survival and future of the peoples of Latin America that it would undoubtedly count on the support of all social strata and generate great internal unity in all countries; as well as, certainly, a great unity of all Latin American countries, and would count, without the slightest hesitation, on the enthusiastic and determined support of all developing countries in Asia and Africa.

"I have no doubt that even numerous industrialized countries will support these claims. I also have no doubts that the ideal and most constructive thing is that these problems be resolved through political dialogue and negotiations. It would be the way to carry out, in an orderly manner, essential solutions. If not, there is no doubt that a group of countries" —pay attention to this idea, it is very important— "driven by desperate situations, will be forced to adopt unilateral measures. It is not desirable for that to happen; but if it does, I have no doubt that that group will be joined by all the other countries in Latin America and the rest of the Third World".

This idea is reiterated in an interview with an academic and a U.S. legislator, from which they will publish a book, especially with the economic parts; it is also printed. Here it says:

"...the industrialized countries do not have at this moment any rational, effective formula to face the crisis, they do not have it.

"I believe that the main difficulty lies in the misunderstanding of the nature and gravity of the problem. (...) it would even help (...), the companies that trade with those countries, the companies that produce goods for those countries, and the states of the creditor countries would not suffer any economic damage but, on the contrary, would increase their levels of employment and the utilization of their industrial capacities; their banks would not suffer losses, their taxpayers would not have to pay additional taxes.

"If this is understood, if there is awareness of this, I believe that the path to the solution would be considerably facilitated, through dialogue, through agreements between the industrialized countries and the countries of the Third World. And as I told you earlier, the only thing that is affected is the insane arms race, the frantic madness of weapons and war, and that, unfortunately, is in very small volume. It is a healthy measure, because we would begin to overcome the most shameful and dangerous disease of our time. If the New International Economic Order, proclaimed and agreed upon by the United Nations, is applied as an indispensable complement to the cancellation of the debt, it would indeed imply a greater reduction of military spending.

"If success is not achieved in this, what will happen? Instead of being reached through a negotiated agreement between the parties, the countries of the Third World will impose it, do not doubt it for a moment. The essence is this: materially it is impossible to pay the debt and its interests; for this reason, as elementary as it is understandable, it cannot be paid, it would cost rivers of blood to impose on the peoples the sacrifices that this would imply, in exchange for nothing. No government would have enough power to achieve it. It is a matter that is well worth analyzing, discussing, and resolving by mutual agreement between creditors and debtors, and we must not forget for a moment that the initiative is now in the hands of the nations to whom such a monstrous sacrifice is demanded.

"If the debtor countries of the Third World are forced to unilaterally declare a suspension of payments, the industrialized countries will be left with no alternative course of action. An economic blockade, an invasion of the Third World, a new repartition of the globe, as in past centuries, to secure raw materials and markets, or to collect the debt, any rational person understands that this is simply impossible. They could not even economically blockade a single country or group of countries that declared a suspension of payments, because it would immediately provoke the solidarity of others.

"We are a large family, and times have changed a lot. Some madness has been left behind, and others, like several of those we have analyzed in this interview, will not take long to follow."

That is to say, we have not declared war on the industrialized countries; we are telling them what is happening and what is going to happen. I say: It is preferable that they become aware of this and that we sit down to talk, but not to talk about paying the debt —understand this well—, to talk about the New International Economic Order. To impose a debt abolition on them is not strictly necessary to talk, but to discuss the New Economic Order it is essential to talk, and if the bases are clear, we can talk about both things: how the debt will be abolished, in what way. We have offered remedies for them, for their banks. They should be grateful that we say: well, this is going to happen, and we are proposing solutions for their own problems.

I still think that the ideal would be for them to become aware. But do I think they will? Of course, now they are more worried than ever, they have really begun to worry, and it is good, it is very good that they are worried; the bad thing is that they remain completely indifferent in the midst of this tragedy.

If they are aware, if they understand this well, and that the debt is unpayable, we can sit down to see what elegant, compassionate way can be given to the abolition of the debt.

If they do not become aware, if the situation continues to evolve along the path it is taking, what we have been proposing will happen —and we already see certain signs—: some countries, desperate, will make unilateral decisions, and then they will have the solidarity of the rest of Latin America and the Third World. That is certain, I have no doubt about that.

The memory of the Malvinas is still fresh, how despite the terrible internal political situation in this country, the peoples of Latin America did not hesitate to support the Argentine people, nor did the peoples of the Third World; right here in this hall there was a meeting of Non-Aligned Foreign Ministers during those days of the war, discussions were held with all of them, the Argentine Foreign Minister came here, we talked with the representatives of the countries of the Third World, and almost unanimously they supported the Argentine people in the Malvinas issue.

And in the struggle over the Malvinas, no one had anything to gain or lose economically; it was a sentimental, affective issue, a matter of principle, a repudiation of colonialism. But in this problem that has to do with the life and death of all the peoples of Latin America and the Third World, if a group of desperate countries, or even a small group of countries with some economic weight initiate that battle, they will support it, I have no doubt, the rest of Latin America and the Third World, ten times more than they supported Argentina in the wake of the Malvinas war.

As part of this struggle, we have been in contact with the countries of Africa and with the countries of the Third World. All these materials with which they have burdened you have been sent to the United Nations, many of them have been sent to the heads of state, to the heads of state of the industrialized countries and to the heads of state of the countries of the Third World. We have been working and fighting, trying to form a consciousness that guarantees solidarity. And today there were already signs, solidarity with Peru was almost unleashed. Because let no one have the slightest doubt, not the slightest doubt, that if imperialism takes measures of that kind against Peru or any other country that finds itself in a situation to take unilateral measures, even if those measures are not radical, and they adopt economic measures against that country or against any other in similar conditions, those countries will have all our solidarity, and I am sure they will have the solidarity of all of you, of Latin America and the Third World. I have no doubts about that.

There are no hidden cards up the sleeve here. This is an open, clear, and transparent strategy, and part of this strategy has been to create awareness; one of the fundamental objectives of disseminating all these materials is to create awareness for solidarity. And I am sure, I have total confidence that that spring will not fail. Imperialism may play with banana peels, but at any moment imperialism itself will slip on its own banana peel.

There is another essential idea, and here Capriles demonstrated that he grasped the essence of the problem when he said: "If we impose a suspension of payments or a moratorium, they will have to sit down to discuss." He really saw the essence of the idea.

So, how is this going to be implemented, how will it evolve? Formulas are beginning to emerge. It was even mentioned here that a theorist of imperialism proposed a Marshall Plan. When I read that, I laughed, because I said: The problem is so big that at least twenty Marshall Plans are needed, not just one. And they do not have the money for that, unless they abandon their warlike madness. Formulas of all kinds have already begun to appear, as can be seen.

Of course, it is an essential idea that if they do not want to discuss the problem amicably, they must be forced to discuss the problem. That means that the initiative is on the part of the countries of the Third World. I remember that when I went to the United Nations —and they owed 335 billion at that time—, we were proposing, within the formulas of the United Nations, resources equivalent to an additional 300 billion dollars for development in the 1980s. At that time we were asking: please, look, the situation is serious, resources are needed, these problems must be resolved. But they turned a deaf ear, until this unsustainable situation was created.

Now, as we explained on one occasion, we are not asking, but now we are giving, and it is not so difficult to keep our arms still, not to put our hands in our pockets to extract resources, and not to allow ourselves to be looted any longer. But we must not use weapons for that, nothing, they cannot use them against the countries of the Third World, nor does the Star Wars program help them collect the debt; the debt cannot be collected with space weapons, nor with nuclear weapons, with nothing can they collect the debt. As we said at the United Nations, bombs can kill the hungry, the uneducated, the sick, but they cannot kill hunger, ignorance, disease, or poverty.

This is once again a struggle of spirit, of conscience against technology, and all their technology in the face of the reality of more than 100 countries in this situation, which have every right, which have every reason, is really of no use to counteract our united action. This is what we are proposing.

And, of course, this will be resolved. The ideal is a prior consensus. But will the prior consensus of the debtor countries of Latin America arrive before the crisis breaks out? The ideal is a prior consensus and a discussion with the creditors, but will that happen? The most likely development of events is that serious crises will break out and from those crises they will then show interest in negotiating; that is the most probable outcome. No one can predict with certainty; but I have never really believed that this prior consensus will occur before the crisis, although I do not see it as impossible. It may be that as the situation worsens, that prior consensus among the debtors will occur; it is possible; it is not impossible, but I do not see it as very likely.

Now, if this struggle continues, if the masses become aware, if every citizen of our countries understands the problem, the possibilities of influencing and creating favorable conditions increase; a government alone cannot wage this struggle, then it could influence the idea that they meet, that they adopt a policy, and that a firm and correct decision is made beforehand.

In short, I have explained all this so that you know how we think and that it is not a war declared in advance, but we know well the selfishness of the exploiters, of the looters, and we glimpse the possible course of events, although no one can assure it; however, we must be prepared for everything, we must be prepared, that is very important.

I have fundamentally spoken about the economic aspect of the problem; I will not extend much further, because there were really three other very important aspects left.

We say: it is unpayable. But unpayable for mathematical, economic reasons does not imply a moral, legal, or political judgment of the problem. But we also say: it is a political impossibility. The governments are not in a position, in any country in Latin America, to apply those measures of the International Monetary Fund, in none; they cannot do it by blood and fire. Pinochet tries it and is seen to be engulfed in a growing crisis. Today the news of the resignation of the chief of the carabineros, who had been in office for many years, was announced due to the brutal murder of three Chilean citizens who were kidnapped and slaughtered.

Coincidentally, we had received three days ago a letter from the family of one of the victims, who left four children aged 11, 6, 4, and 2 years; they sent an impressive letter, with a self-portrait and an impressive poem that he made, and it seemed that it was made for him. These factors, yes, three victims, but already Pinochet trembles, the regime shakes before the protest of world opinion and especially the protest of the people, the anger of the people, the irritation of the people. He will not be able to remain in power much longer.

The governments of democratic openness, how could they apply those measures under conditions where living standards have been reduced by half in many of them? From Mexico, a country with a stable constitutional regime, news arrives that in the last 18 months the purchasing power of the population has decreased by 33% and in the last 30 months, by 50%. We see the heroic efforts that the Mexican government is making to try to get out of the crisis and pay the debt; however, throughout 1985, the essential balance of its trade balance has steadily decreased.

The trade surplus of the three main exporting countries, Brazil, Mexico, and Argentina, which in 1984 was almost 30 billion, this year 1985 will barely reach 20 billion, and they have to continue paying interest amounting to 12 billion for the first, approximately 12 billion for the second, and from 4 to 5 billion for the third. It is a very difficult, unmanageable situation.

It is very difficult for democratic governments to indefinitely apply the measures imposed by the International Monetary Fund, increasingly worse measures. It would mean a political crisis in the countries to attempt it; if Pinochet, by killing, cannot do it, how could a democratic government achieve it without destroying itself? It is a political impossibility, simply, to collect that debt, to demand from the people the sacrifices required for the payment of that debt.

We said it is a moral impossibility. It is almost unnecessary to elaborate on that element that was so raised here, that was raised so forcefully by everyone, and especially by the Christians. It is one of the points that we have been raising.

Yes, there may be cases, and we admit it, in which some useful investment was made with those credits; a small part of the total debt was invested in useful things; but we all know that a large part was invested in weapons, was squandered, was misappropriated, was wasted, and we also know that a large part was embezzled, did not even reach Latin America. I believe it was comrade Líber Seregni who pointed out that Latin Americans had 160 billion dollars deposited abroad, and that is a conservative estimate; it may be more. The money flees under those economic conditions, with constant inflation, a weakened currency, an overvalued dollar, high interest rates in the United States, not a cent remains, nothing remains.

Even today, 10 billion dollars are still fleeing every year, ten billion dollars! But in those years there was a country — I believe it was Venezuela — where in a period of time, according to the World Bank, for every dollar of loan received, a dollar and 23 cents left; that is, not only did the dollar that arrived or did not arrive in Venezuela leave, but from the reserves or exports of Venezuela, a dollar and 23 cents left to be deposited abroad.

Will that money return? What are the appeals for it to do so? With this picture will it return? And who can dream of creating those ideal, perfect, so attractive conditions that the money, generous, returns to the countries on its own, walking, swimming, even swimming against the current of the Gulf? No one believes that, nor does anyone imagine it. It is utopian. All those things are indeed idealistic, all those things are indeed utopian, and not what we are proposing.

What happened to that money? Who are they going to collect it from now? Here, heartbreaking examples were given, like when Edgardo Enríquez asked from this podium if he has to pay the money that was given to Pinochet to murder his children, to murder his grandson, and to murder and disappear other loved ones.

Here it was also eloquently stated by the indigenous comrade from Ecuador when she asked: What had they received in their communities, a school, a hospital, or something similar? Now they had to pay.

Many people explained all those moral aspects. Someone said, I believe it was the one from Belize, that English law established that gambling debts are not paid, expressing a legal element. I cited the example of someone borrowing 1,000 dollars, going to a casino, spending it, and then wanting to collect the 1,000 dollars from his five-year-old son. This, from a moral point of view, is unsustainable, and it is very important because it is not just that it cannot be done. It cannot be done is a fairly strong argument, but it should not be done is an even stronger argument. As was said here and repeated, it is against the most elementary human rights.

So much is said by Westerners about human rights, and it turns out that with their methods — and I have told some Americans — they kill thousands of people every day. Who is to blame for that million children who die in Latin America before reaching one year of age? Right here, in this room, at a meeting of pediatricians, the Director of UNICEF said that if Latin America had the levels of sanitation and health that children in Cuba have, an infant mortality rate no greater than 15 per 1,000 — we reached that index last year — born alive in the first year of life. As we have significantly reduced the mortality rates from one to five years, between five and fifteen; as we have prolonged the life levels that are already on par with those of the United States; as we are competing with them in health indices despite being Cuba a Third World country, due to the efforts of our doctors, of our nurses; because the Revolution has taken care of health and because there are no malnourished children, as there are no children who are barefoot, nor beggars, nor drugs, nor prostitution, nor gambling in our country. These successes are known.

In a conversation with Frei Betto not long ago, I told him: if the Church were to establish a society governed by its own principles, it would create a society more or less like the one we are building, because I do not think it would accept prostitution, nor gambling, nor drugs. What can have more moral strength than the human work of a revolution, which spares women the tragedy of prostitution, a terrible stain in our countries like drugs, gambling, and begging? We, as a byproduct of a Revolution that has brought justice to the people, have eradicated those social calamities, just like unsanitary conditions, illiteracy, and unemployment.

Well, what did the Director of UNICEF say? That if the countries of Latin America had the health levels of Cuba, 800,000 children would be saved every year, eight hundred thousand children! And if the Director of UNICEF, an agency of the United Nations, says this, I ask: And who kills those 800,000 children under one year old every year? And who kills other millions of children between 1 and 15 years? And who reduces life averages to 40, 45, and 50 years in so many places and for centuries? It has been happening and continues to happen to the shame of all of us. It is exploitation, colonialism yesterday, imperialism today, and do those lives not count? And the millions who grow with mental retardation or physical defects, who causes all that, who is to blame, who is responsible?

If we are going to analyze these problems logically and with principle, it is imperialism.

The fact that there are 110 million unemployed and underemployed, who is to blame for that? We must start looking for the culprit. It is not enough to just point out the numbers and statistics, but to ask why and also to ask how much longer this situation can be endured.

The collection of this debt and the unjust system of economic relations is the most flagrant and brutal violation of human rights that can be conceived. Here it was said that this debt is paid, who knows how many times, with what they steal from us. Just last year, they stole 20 billion from us through that unequal exchange, 10 billion through capital flight, 37.3 billion in interest, and from 4 to 5 billion due to the overvaluation of the dollar. That is 70 billion in a single year, 70 billion looted; 10 billion entered, from investments, some loans, and 70 billion left, which can be accounted for. And the damage caused by protectionist measures, dumping, and all those practices carried out against our countries is not accounted for.

Can a continent have a future under those conditions? Can such a system have justification? Moreover, from a moral point of view, it was the Third World, and especially Latin America, that financed the development of Europe and the United States for centuries. From those gold and silver mines that Guayasamín spoke of here, from Potosí and many other mines, where not just 4 million, as he said, perished over the centuries in Potosí. In Mexico alone, in the early years of the conquest, from 6 million inhabitants, the population was reduced to 2 million; 4 million only in the first years following the conquest, due to exploitation, mistreatment, enslavement, and even due to the diseases brought by Europeans. It is not 4 million, it is tens and tens of millions who have given their lives to slave labor, and not only children of Latin America, but also children of Africa.

In the United States, slavery lasted almost a century after the famous Declaration, where they solemnly and hypocritically proclaimed that all men are born free, equal, and that the Creator grants them the right to liberty and life. Rights yes, but for white Europeans, not rights for the slaves, the free men brought from Africa and enslaved in this hemisphere; not for the Indians who were exterminated even after the famous Declaration of Independence and after their evident truths.

Who financed the development of the United States itself? It was the slaves and indirectly our peoples, the Indians and Blacks of Latin America and the Caribbean who, by financing Europe, also financed them. And now we continue to finance them; historically, the countries of the Third World have financed the developed capitalist world. So, why can this debt not be abolished? Now they demand that we pay. It reminds me of what the comrade from Haiti said, that the slaves had to indemnify the enslavers for their freedom. They brought them from Africa, separated them from their families, treated them in the worst way a human being can be treated, exploited them, killed them in a thousand different ways, and then spent about 100 years paying the colonizers indemnity for their freedom. Well, I believe that we must conquer our freedom and not indemnify any of our oppressors.

Here, arguments have been discussed, even legal ones. López Michelsen spoke of impossible execution; at other times we have mentioned reasons of force majeure; but, in short, to all these moral, political, and economic reasons, a set of legal reasons can be added: Who contracted? Who holds sovereignty? By what concept can it be said that the people committed to pay and received or arranged those credits? If most of those credits were arranged with military, repressive dictatorships, without any popular consultation. Do the debts or commitments made by the oppressors of the peoples have to be paid by the oppressed? Where is the philosophical moral foundation of that conception or idea?

The parliaments were not consulted, the principle of sovereignty was violated; which parliaments have intervened in this indebtedness and were aware of this? Who knew about the discussions, where did they vote? They mortgaged our countries to such an extent that more than 17,000 dollars are owed per square kilometer in Latin America and the Caribbean, and who mortgaged them? One would have to ask, did the peoples mortgage them? Who exercises sovereignty, who holds sovereignty, how can there be commitments behind the back of the people's sovereignty?

Here, the continuity of this effort has been discussed. Yes, there will be continuity, not because we create an organization here, no, what was proposed has been strictly fulfilled, not a declaration, no; there have been many by countries, but the call has been strictly fulfilled. This is a movement. Soon there will be a meeting of parliamentarians in Uruguay, from October 10 to 13, to discuss external debt. What a magnificent integrative, unifying opportunity for the parliaments to go there to discuss a debt that they did not approve, and analyze the problem.

I believe that we must give, first of all, great support to that parliamentary meeting, understanding the enormous importance of that event. It seems to me that it will be the next event of great significance to raise awareness around these problems. So, wherever this issue is analyzed, the reasons are very solid, very strong, irrefutable; it is, moreover, a problem that affects everyone very closely, much more than any other problem, because the women expressed it here, the workers expressed it, the peasants, the middle classes, everyone has expressed how this situation affects each one of them.

We have not been raising subversive slogans. We have not been proposing social revolution; on the contrary, we have said: we cannot wait for socialism to come first to solve this problem; this problem is urgent, immediate, it must be resolved. To resolve it, we must unite everyone, all layers, except for the insignificant minority that is sold to international financial capital, that is sold to imperialism. Everyone fits here, even the industrialists who spoke in this room, or bankers, businessmen, farmers, everyone fits. That is the good thing about this struggle, that it can be and must be a very broad struggle to resolve these problems that cannot wait for our peoples to have a socialist consciousness, for all the subjective factors to come together, which are behind the objective factors at this moment, even if we advance quickly, nor would it be, in my opinion, prudent, at a time when a decisive battle is being fought for the independence of our peoples. Because, how can a government and a country be called independent if it has to go every month to discuss with the International Monetary Fund what it has to do in its own house? It is a fiction of independence, and we see this as a struggle for national liberation, which can truly unite, and for the first time in the history of our hemisphere, all social layers in a struggle to achieve their true independence.

We cannot set socialism as a prerequisite. We are not recommending socialism, of course, nor are we dissuading it, do you understand? What does not seem correct to me is to make that the center of the struggle. I believe that in any case this profound crisis will bring a heightened awareness to our peoples. I do not believe that we will move away from socialism; as the masses become aware, I believe that we are getting closer to the perspectives of a more just society; but it would be erroneous now to set the objective of socialism; this is an urgent problem that must be resolved; I believe that if there is an awareness, if the workers, the peasants, the students, the intellectuals, the businessmen have a clear awareness of the problem, we can isolate the traitors, those who are in the service of imperialism and win this battle.

I imagine that the governments will take measures so that not a cent escapes. I can say that here in this country in 26 years of Revolution not a cent, not a currency, has escaped, in 26 years. There is no under-invoicing, nor over-invoicing, nor anything like that. But well, that is not what we are proposing; measures must be taken, within the current conditions, to avoid waste, the flight of currencies, and all that; but we, as a rule, in all this problem have avoided analyzing issues related to the internal affairs of each country. We are proposing the general principle of unity, of unity among countries, unity among the countries of the Third World, but we avoid suggesting internal measures and it is correct to act this way; it would make no sense, nor would it be prudent for us to start making recommendations about what we believe should be done internally. It does not mean that we have renounced our revolutionary ideals, nor our socialist conception, but —I repeat— in essence, we see this as a great struggle for national liberation against powerful forces, and that we can generate enough forces to carry this struggle forward.

We will see how the coming months unfold, what the evolution of events is, because the crisis cannot hold out much longer. I believe that awareness must be formed rapidly.

Here, admirable words have been spoken, very encouraging messages have been received. To those who say that our proposals are radical, here is the letter from Cardinal Arns, from São Paulo, you heard it. If you allow me, I will dedicate a few minutes to read again the essential points, because I believe that after all the debate they have even more value.

"First, there are no real possibilities for the Latin American and Caribbean people to take responsibility for the burden of paying the colossal debts incurred by our governments. It is not even viable to continue paying the high interests at the expense of our development and well-being.

"Second, the debt problem, before being financial, is fundamentally political, and as such it must be addressed. What is at stake is not the accounts of international creditors, but the lives of millions of people who cannot suffer the permanent threat of recessionary measures and unemployment that bring misery and death.

"Third, human rights demand that all men of good will on the continent and in the Caribbean, all responsible sectors, unite in the urgent search for a realistic solution to the external debt problem, as a way to preserve the sovereignty of our nations and safeguard the principle that the main commitment of our governments is not to the creditors, but to the peoples they represent.

"Fourth, the unwavering defense of the principle of self-determination of our peoples requires the end of the interference of international organizations in the financial administration of our nations. Considering that the government is a public matter, all documents signed with such organizations must be immediately made known to public opinion." Yes, and we can ask for more: that the discussions of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank be broadcast on radio and television for the world to see, as we have done with our dialogue.

"Fifth, it is urgent to establish concrete bases for a New International Economic Order, in which the unequal relations between rich and poor countries are abolished and the Third World is assured the inalienable right to govern its own destiny, free from imperialist interference and exploitative measures in international trade relations."

They say that the theses I am defending are radical, well, I fully subscribe to this five-point program of that illustrious son of Brazil, Paulo Evaristo, Cardinal Arns! I hope they no longer say that the ideas are extremist. And I would only add a sixth point, which is the economic integration of Latin America; and a seventh point that is perceived in its intention: This is a struggle for the peoples of Latin America and the Third World, for the lives of 4 billion people who suffer and endure the consequences of this inhumane and unjust economic order.

No document has been produced, nor is it necessary. This was not intended to produce a document, but to raise awareness, to take consciousness; let us say, that was the fundamental objective of this dialogue. And I truly believe that we have taken a consciousness, a strong consciousness. Even those of us who have been in this for a long time feel more strengthened, more convinced, more secure of the justice, after having heard dozens and dozens of brilliant interventions from people who have demonstrated here great talents. And it has truly been an unprecedented gift to our people, which allowed them to follow closely, day by day, hour by hour, minute by minute this dialogue. We really feel deeply grateful.

What we need is that awareness. No church emerged from a document. The independence of the peoples of Latin America did not emerge from a document either, but at a certain hour, at a certain moment, the churches, the great spiritual and political movements arose from a spiritual or political crisis and from a consciousness. Now we are in the midst of the crisis and we have acquired a consciousness.

I am sure, as you are, that our movement, our struggle, will move forward and we will achieve victory.

Thank you very much.