Interview with Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, in "La France agricole" on February 26, 2014, on agricultural policy.

France François Hollande · President of France

26 February 2014 · Interview in La France agricole on agricultural policy

Context
Hollande gave an interview to 'La France agricole' in February 2014, discussing the outcomes of CAP negotiations and French agricultural policy priorities.
Main themes
Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) reform, French agricultural policy, CAP budget and funding, flexibility for member states, rural development, aid rebalancing, euro and monetary stability, regional autonomy, future agriculture law, livestock and cereal production, competitiveness and ecological performance
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,829
73rd percentile
Sentences
179
86th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
2.64
9th percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
72nd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

179 sentences in 44 paragraphs

The CAP negotiations were concluded at the European level in 2013. What is your assessment of this?

"France succeeded in convincing Europeans that agriculture was a future investment. A year ago, everything suggested that agriculture would become the variable adjustment in European negotiations. Many of our partners indeed wanted to reduce the Union's budget in general and agriculture in particular. Others absolutely wanted to keep structural funds, which could be at the expense of agricultural policy. However, not only did we preserve the overall European funding for agriculture, but we also strengthened France's position compared to that of its neighbors. For the first pillar, our envelope is preserved. For the second, we obtained an improvement of more than 10% in the resources that will be dedicated to rural development. The profession, in its diversity, recognized what had been achieved at the end of this negotiation.

Isn't this at the cost of too much flexibility in the means left to member states to implement this reform?

I claimed this flexibility because it was in France's interest. It will allow us to better couple aid to production, to better support the diversity of our agriculture, livestock, and cereal production, and to strengthen our specific means of action for difficult areas. France has a strong and diverse agriculture that has no equivalent in Europe. I therefore wanted a CAP that could adapt to each sector and each territory. But this flexibility must have limits, red lines, because I am not in favor of the renationalization of agricultural policy that some of our partners might wish for.

Have you not granted too much autonomy to the Regions, at the risk of depriving us of a national policy?

No, because the rules will remain national, whether it concerns direct aid or the general framework for setting up, supporting fragile territories, or modernizing farms. On the other hand, the Regions will be able to intervene within the framework of the second pillar to adapt rural development actions and amplify the budgetary resources allocated to farm investment.

What do you say to those who demand an exit from the euro?

That they completely misunderstand the reality of French agriculture and ignore the difficulties it faced when the common market operated without a single currency. I have not forgotten the competitive devaluations when, in the spring of 1995, the lira lost 20% of its value. I remember the breeders in Corrèze whose revenue from the sale of calves to Italy had decreased accordingly. And I remember that Jacques Chirac had to negotiate under difficult conditions provisions allowing French breeders to get through this period.

I also think of the monetary compensatory amounts that constituted taxes on French products shipped to Germany to compensate for the structural weakness of the franc compared to the mark. This situation was untenable, unmanageable, incomprehensible, bureaucratic. Therefore, it would be suicidal for French agriculture to return to national currencies, and I do not see French farmers making choices contrary to their interests. Today, half of our exports still suffer from exchange rate fluctuations, those of the dollar or the Chinese currency. So fortunately, the other half of our exports benefits from monetary stability within the euro zone. Farmers know well where their future lies: in exchange rate stability and the maintenance of the euro.

Will there be an additional step in the "rebalancing" of aid?

We have stabilized European funding for agriculture for the next seven years. Few economic sectors have such visibility. As part of the national implementation, I wanted to gradually rebalance aid by one billion euros out of the nine that our country receives each year under the CAP. The course is set for the next seven years, even if throughout this period, regular evaluations with the profession will measure the effects of our decisions. What are our choices? First, convergence, that is to say, reducing the gaps between the levels of public aid that were based on historical references dating back more than twenty years. Then, rebalancing aid without destabilizing sectors and territories. We wanted to strengthen animal production but without weakening the cereal sector. It is about creating a favorable dynamic for all our agricultures. We found the right balance by better taking employment into account in the redistribution of support by helping more farms located in difficult areas. I stand by these priorities.

How will the future agriculture law be articulated with the CAP? What is its political significance?

The purpose of the future agriculture law is not to establish other objectives than those I have just recalled. It is to give them even more visibility and scope. What have we sought? First, to improve the long-term competitiveness of our agriculture by combining economic and ecological performance. Because farmers do not need lessons. They are aware of their responsibility. They must be encouraged and supported to implement this agro-environmental complementarity. We also want, through this text, to promote the establishment of young farmers, which is essential for employment, but also to ensure the emergence of new activities for farmers, particularly regarding the processing of biomass and the energy recovery of agricultural waste.

A new instrument will be created by this law: the economic and ecological interest group (GIEE). It will allow stakeholders to come together around projects that concern an entire territory. Because agriculture does not concern only farmers; it concerns all of society, which must be proud to have access to exceptional food security and quality.

What signals should be given to farmers to encourage their entrepreneurial spirit, and what should be done regarding administrative simplification?

There is no need to instill a taste for entrepreneurship in farmers; they already have it. I want to give them all the means to succeed. A farmer is an entrepreneur who does not count his hours. Even if sometimes, his results do not match the time he invests and the effort he puts in. Hence the stakes of simplification. First, let us avoid over-transposing European directives. Our country complains about interventions from Europe, and at the time of transposing European texts, we have stubbornly made them even more complicated, heavier than those applied by our partners. Well, that is over. We will transpose what needs to be transposed, no more, no less. Then, the Minister of Agriculture has decided, with his colleague from the Environment, to introduce a simpler regime to accelerate decisions on the modernization of certain farms. He started with the most difficult: pig farming, where investment projects will fall under a registration procedure rather than an authorization mechanism. This represents a gain of four to six months. We will go in the same direction for other productions. Similarly, for methanization and waste recycling, all devices have been reviewed. Without questioning the principles that are ours, regarding health protection and working conditions. Nothing should weaken the safety of our food or our environment, but it is the responsibility of the State to encourage those who undertake, those who take risks, those who create jobs.

Do you want to go further on the cost of labor?

Regarding the cost of labor, the CICE (tax credit for competitiveness and employment) represents an important advance and it applies to the agricultural and agri-food sector. A solution still needs to be found for cooperatives, but the subject will be addressed within the framework of the responsibility pact. Regarding the reduction of family contributions, agriculture will necessarily be concerned, and with the recent holding of the General States, I am pleased that this sector is mobilizing in the spirit of the responsibility pact.

Does French agriculture have an export vocation, and how can it be encouraged?

France is a great agricultural nation. One-third of our production is exported. We generate a surplus of nearly 12 billion euros, and I emphasize that this surplus increased by more than 3% in 2013. This is good news for our agriculture and our country. France can hope for even better results given the expected global growth and the reputation of our products in China, the United States, Japan, Mediterranean countries, and everywhere in the world... Our export vocation is not in opposition to the agricultural interests of Mediterranean and African countries. On the contrary, we are building a real co-development strategy with them, and I have asked the Minister of Agriculture to promote it. We should no longer oppose French farmers to other farmers. We can build a partnership in the service of global agriculture.

Will the establishment of a minimum wage in Germany really change the game in terms of competitiveness?

It was about time that the Germans committed to this path and that progress has already been made in the slaughterhouse sector. Our neighbors across the Rhine indeed benefited from a substantial advantage in certain productions like pork. We must go further and resolutely commit to a social Europe and align our models within the euro zone. This is what we agreed upon during the Franco-German ministerial council held in Paris on Wednesday.

What do you think of Chinese investments in French agri-food?

China is primarily a considerable market that will open up to French agriculture, provided that we are present, attentive to Chinese demands, and capable of obtaining the lifting of trade barriers that may still hinder our operators. I have acted to ensure that the Chinese market for charcuterie is now open to French companies; this is a major advance. I am also attentive to the Chinese procedure regarding European wines, which directly concerns us. The potential is gigantic. China must feed a population of several hundred million consumers whose demands for diversity and quality are increasingly approaching ours.

Then, there is the question of Chinese investments that we must look at with attention but also interest. If I observe what has been done for milk, it is good news for Brittany to know that this Chinese company will create 300 jobs within two years, in partnership with a large French cooperative group. The majority of the production will be destined for the Chinese market.

Allow me to mention another country: Saudi Arabia. Thanks to the good relations we maintain with it, we have facilitated the influx of capital to the takeover of Doux with favorable consequences for employment. More and more markets are opening up to our producers. I think of Turkey for the beef sector. Everywhere I travel abroad, I am always concerned about the possibilities for development for our agricultural productions because it is in emerging countries that we have the most beautiful promises of development.

Regarding the nitrates directive, farmers feel that they are always being asked to wash whiter than white compared to our neighbors. What do you say to them?

We are in discussion with the European Commission. We must avoid being condemned by the European Court of Justice and find a fair balance. That there are rules to observe in vulnerable areas, we fully accept and even advocate it. Our interest is to protect our space, our rivers, and our environment. But it cannot be a question of seeing France entirely classified as a vulnerable zone. I will not accept that our farmers have more constraints than others. Yes, we need to redefine vulnerable areas, but we must also take agronomic reality into account. I believe that it is on these bases that we will be able to conclude negotiations with the European Commission.

Is the ecotax buried?

The ecotax was created in 2009 as part of the Grenelle de l'environnement to finance our infrastructure. The idea was right, but the proposed rules caused misunderstanding. Some Regions, like Brittany, contest it due to their geographical situation. There is also a legitimate vigilance from the agricultural profession regarding transport both upstream and downstream of farms. Hence the need to reopen consultation with all parties to take into account certain specificities, particularly in the agricultural field.

Can we hope to move towards parity of pensions compared to other sectors?

I committed during the presidential campaign to ensuring that agricultural pensions reach 75% of the minimum wage for a full career by the end of my term. This promise will be kept. Having been elected in Corrèze for many years, I understand the sense of injustice felt by many elderly farmers who live on pensions that bear no relation to the duration and hardship of their work. It is a solidarity effort that the Nation must undertake. I do not forget the family helpers who, since 2011, have been affiliated with the supplementary pension scheme. They will benefit from free rights. In total, 800,000 people will be affected for an amount that will represent 1 billion euros until 2017. In the current budgetary context, it is an important gesture to dedicate such an amount to this effort. But I considered it my duty.

The issue of GMOs is at a standstill and muddles the functioning of European institutions — how do we get out of this rut?

Today in Europe, only a minority of countries is in favor of introducing GMOs. A majority of the European Parliament is opposed to them. The worst would be for us to be in a state of general confusion. I also perceive a concern regarding the trade negotiations underway with the United States, with the fear that GMOs will come back in through the American window after being chased out the European door. Therefore, we have a double clarification to make: in Europe and on a global scale. Regarding Europe, I hope we can find a text that provides legal certainty allowing countries that do not want GMO crops to have their choices respected. For the TC1507 corn, which is currently in the news, France has expressed its opposition to the authorization of planting. The same position applies to Mon810.

But won't they arrive through the "American window" via the trade negotiations with the United States?

We need, for our industry and our agriculture, to access markets that are currently partially closed to us. That is why I did not oppose the opening of trade negotiations between Europe and the United States. But I set conditions. The mandate given to the European Commission takes into account the specific nature of agriculture. I mentioned this to President Barack Obama. I am in favor of moving quickly, but I will not yield on the issue of food safety, nor on sensitive products such as meats and starch-based products in particular. Because it is no longer just a matter of competitiveness or trade distortion, but a requirement for safety and quality.

How do you plan to encourage green chemistry?

It is undoubtedly a perspective for the future. Green chemistry is part of the 34 industrial plans identified by Arnaud Montebourg and also of the breakthrough innovations defined by the Lauvergeon commission. The transformation of cereals also opens up immense possibilities. That is why we will support research in areas as varied as biopolymers, pharmaceuticals, and biofuels. Green chemistry is an asset for agricultural diversification and national independence. It is a vector for job creation and an essential issue for successfully transitioning to energy efficiency and valorizing waste.

The "1,000 cows project" in the Somme is controversial — do you see it as a model for the future?

Until recently, when I heard "a thousand cows," I thought of a plateau of a thousand cows in Limousin, a beautiful region whose animal production is a source of pride. What you are talking about is nothing of the sort. It is a factory. Not that we do not need large economic structures. But at that level, environmental and neighborhood issues necessarily arise. Decisions have indeed been made by the prefectural authority to enforce the law. At the same time, I refuse to pit different types of agriculture against each other because our model is based on their diversity and complementarity.

Should we legislate on the status of animals?

Our country has a talent for opening debates that pit us against each other anxiously... and I am not just talking about animals! We are actually united on a number of principles and values. In France, we love animals. And the first ones who love them are the farmers who care for them. A farmer who mistreats his livestock would destroy his own heritage. For good reason, many efforts have been made for animal welfare without the need to translate it into law. In the rural code, for instance, animals are already considered sentient beings. Why add other considerations? Because, to call things by their name, farming ultimately leads to the animal being slaughtered. Therefore, we must ensure that conditions are respected that do not cause them to suffer.

So you do not plan to abandon meat consumption?

I eat meat regularly and with pleasure! Many French people would probably like to be able to eat more of it. We must explain to children the origin of what we eat. It is our duty as parents and educators.