Interview with Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, in "Le Monde" on August 20, 2014, on the government's economic policy and foreign policy.

France François Hollande · President of France

20 August 2014

Context
Hollande gave a newspaper interview to Le Monde on August 20, 2014, addressing France's sluggish growth, rising unemployment, and his government's economic reform agenda.
Main themes
Economic policy reform, responsibility pact, unemployment and growth, demand stimulation, housing and investment, regulated professions reform, apprenticeships and training, social dialogue, European austerity, purchasing power, tax reform, competitiveness
Duration
~33 min
86th percentile
Words
3,992
86th percentile
Sentences
272
94th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.65
10th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
60th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

272 sentences in 86 paragraphs

- Aren't the poor growth figures, much lower than expected, and the unemployment rate, which keeps rising, proof of the failure of your economic policy? Shouldn't it be changed?

I have set a course, which is that of the responsibility pact. The objective is clear: to modernize our economy by improving competitiveness and supporting investment as well as employment. Today, just because the economic situation is more difficult in France and Europe, we must not give up. On the contrary, we must go faster and further. To those who say that we need to revise the strategy even though the measures have just been voted on, I respond that any rowing back or zigzagging would make our policy incomprehensible and would not produce results.

- What new measures will you take this fall to boost growth?

I want to accelerate reforms to raise the level of growth as quickly as possible in four areas: first, regarding housing, I have asked the Prime Minister to present a stimulus plan. It will address taxation, procedures, and financing.

Next, regarding investment, discussions will be held in September with all financial institutions to encourage them to lend more to SMEs, to better direct savings towards the productive economy, and to ensure financing for major collective projects, such as the energy transition, which is a lever for green growth.

On regulated professions, Arnaud Montebourg will present a bill in September on purchasing power aimed at increasing competition in the services offered to consumers, lowering prices, and combating the maintenance of certain rents and privileges. It will include measures to simplify urban planning regulations and will adapt the regulations on the opening of stores on Sundays.

Finally, reforms will be initiated to develop apprenticeships, alternating training for long-term unemployed individuals, and to modernize social dialogue.

- How will you proceed on social thresholds?

My method is negotiation. On one side, employers must understand that better representation of employees in SMEs is essential. On the other side, everyone must acknowledge the need to lift a number of barriers and reduce the effects of thresholds. But let social partners move forward. If they reach an agreement, it will be transposed into law, as we did for the labor market and vocational training. If not, the government will bring it to Parliament.

- Is the employer community playing its part in the responsibility pact?

The pact is a contract in which everyone must respect their commitments. The government has kept its side: to improve the competitiveness of businesses, it has freed up 40 billion euros over three years. The unions that chose to join the pact obtained commitments in terms of jobs. I therefore expect employers to fully embrace the logic of the pact, to make full use of the tax credit for competitiveness and employment to invest and hire, and not to distribute dividends or make other demands.

- Since 2012, you have emphasized supply-side policy. Many economists agree that the problem is also, if not primarily, demand. How do you plan to stimulate demand in France?

The diagnosis is clear: there is a demand problem throughout Europe. The eurozone is experiencing a trade surplus, insufficient investment, and a growth rate that does not allow for a decrease in unemployment. This is mainly due to the austerity policies pursued for several years. If there is to be support for demand, it must therefore be done at the European level, and that is what France will advocate in the upcoming discussions with our partners. But I do not intend to shift the blame onto Europe, as our country is facing a supply problem.

When I arrived in 2012, I found a trade deficit of nearly 70 billion and an industry with the lowest profit margins in the last thirty years. Any measure to stimulate activity through budgetary means would therefore have resulted in worsening our public debt and deteriorating our foreign trade. I chose to prioritize productive recovery. This is a vital issue for France. Does that mean nothing should be done to support consumption? No. Because efforts have been made over the past two years, we will return a portion of that starting this year, in terms of tax cuts, and even more in 2015.

- On August 6, the Constitutional Council censored the part of the responsibility pact concerning reductions in employee contributions. What replacement measure will you find to restore purchasing power to the lowest-paid employees?

I have taken note of this decision. It is a great principle of my presidency: I never pass judgment on those who judge. I have therefore asked the government to carry out two major reforms: one will aim to make the income tax scale fairer and simpler, particularly for the lower brackets, that is, for low and middle-income taxpayers. The other will merge the employment bonus and the active RSA to encourage a return to work and improve the remuneration of precarious employees. Both reforms will be initiated as part of the finance law to achieve an improvement in purchasing power equivalent to what was initially planned.

- You stated in July 2013: "The recovery is here." You also said: "I will bring the deficit down to 3% in 2013." You finally said: "I will reverse the unemployment trend by the end of 2013." None of these predictions turned out to be accurate. Is the credibility of your word not compromised?

Who can contest that the international and European environment has deteriorated over the past year? The causes are known. They are linked to geopolitical uncertainties (Ukraine, Iraq) and the continuation of austerity policies in Europe. This has invalidated all forecasts made in 2013 for 2014, not just by the French government but by all international organizations. And as soon as I became convinced of this, I did not waste a single moment and launched the responsibility pact in January 2014. Credibility means not remaining motionless. It means adapting to circumstances but also remaining coherent.

- Economists, as well as your Secretary of State Thierry Mandon, in charge of state reform, are proposing to reschedule French debt. What do you think?

France has never borrowed on financial markets at such low rates. 1.4%: this is historic, with a minimal gap with Germany three times less than in 2012. This means that France's signature is reliable and respected, and that our companies can also finance themselves at particularly low rates. Despite the naysayers, this is proof of the seriousness of our policy. That is also credibility. And we therefore do not need to extend the maturity of our debt.

- In the spring, the episode of the PS rebels revealed a risk of cohabitation with a faction of the majority. Are you worried about the state of the majority for the upcoming parliamentary operations?

I know what cohabitation is. It has nothing to do with this. I have a fairly long experience of parliamentary life. I have drawn three conclusions from it. First, respect between the government and its majority must be mutual. Second, there is no escape. The judgment in 2017 will be based on the president, the government, and the majority. We will succeed together. Finally, the debate cannot bounce back on every piece of legislation. Choices cannot be re-discussed every time a quarterly index is known. Consistency is trust.

- Five months after Manuel Valls was appointed Prime Minister, what is your assessment of his actions?

I chose Manuel Valls to implement the policy I have set for our country. He is doing so with talent and energy, mobilizing the entire government with a team spirit, and he knows how to engage in dialogue with Parliament. We are working in full harmony and have as our only objective the success of France.

- A week before the PS summer university in La Rochelle, do you have a message for socialists?

That they remain united. This is the first condition for convincing. That they recognize what our victories in 2012 obligate us to do to be worthy of our task. That they understand and overcome defeats to be able to win in the end.

- Is there an institutional problem in France? What about your projects regarding proportional representation and the voting system?

Restoring the link between the French and their representatives is a major issue. For the past two years, the government has addressed this, particularly regarding the non-cumulation of mandates, transparency in political life, the independence of the judiciary, and territorial reform. Should we go further? I indicated during the campaign that I was in favor of introducing a portion of proportional representation. I am ready for that if a majority can agree on this direction, along with a reduction in the number of parliamentarians. But I want to highlight a French peculiarity that has become a real handicap: the difficulty in reaching a consensus on the evolution of our institutions, on secularism, as well as on immigration, security, and even major industrial issues.

Yet these are issues on which republican forces could find common ground. Some countries succeed in this through coalitions. That is not our tradition. However, this should not prevent us from overcoming oppositions and divisions when the general interest is at stake. That is why all republican forces, like major social actors, must be able to chart a long-term course together without abandoning any of their philosophical and political identity.

- Left-wing radicals threaten to leave the government if general councils are not maintained in rural departments: what do you say to them?

The territorial reform has been awaited for too long to give it up once again. The text was voted on by a large majority in the first reading. It creates large regions, clarifies competencies, simplifies our territorial organization, and will generate savings. A five-year period has been allowed for imagining solutions adapted to rural departments regarding general councils.

- During the Gaza war, demonstrations were banned. Do you think you will one day pay for this decision in the French Muslim electorate?

Demonstrations were banned when there was evidence suggesting that violence was to be feared and that groups were determined to provoke incidents. But I remind you that almost all demonstrations were authorized. Their cause was understandable, and the emotion was real, not just among Muslims. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is not a religious issue but a political one.

- Do you think there is a resurgence of anti-Semitism in France?

Yes, and not just in the past few weeks. There are very organized and active groups, particularly on social networks. Remember the slogans uttered during the "Day of Anger" demonstration, which had nothing to do with Gaza! It is important to educate, particularly in schools, but also to be firm against racism and anti-Semitism. One can express views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict without Jews in France or Muslims in France being its victims. It is important that we show a very high level of intolerance towards intolerance.

- Must a president or former president necessarily go through the "primaries" to run again?

For former presidents, I don't know. It is not for me to say. As far as I am concerned, this question is completely indifferent to me. My concern is not how I will arrive in 2017 to present a possible candidacy, but how to restore the country by then.

- Will the question arise in 2015? In 2016?

It is up to the Socialist Party to answer that.

- The tabloid press is showing you these days in a swimsuit. How do you react?

I will not tell you what I feel. You can imagine it. Beyond myself, it is the presidential function that must be respected. Everyone should understand this, regardless of commercial arguments.

- The first secretary of the PS, Jean-Christophe Cambadélis, stated that he deemed the abandonment of the objective of reducing the deficit to 3% "inevitable." Do you maintain this objective?

The objective is to continue reducing deficits. I remind you that public debt rose from 60% of GDP in 2007 to 90% in 2012. If I were to arrive in 2017 with a ratio of 120% of GDP, what would people say about me? Perhaps what they should have said about my predecessor. But today I believe that the pace of budgetary consolidation in Europe must be adapted to the exceptional situation we are experiencing, characterized by low growth and especially very low inflation.

- But Germany, through the voice of the Bundesbank and the chancellery, has suggested that there is nothing to reconsider.

I do not position myself in a face-to-face confrontation with Germany. This is a European debate. I am not asking for the rules to be changed, but for them to be applied with all the flexibilities provided by the treaties in cases of exceptional circumstances. We are there.

- Is the euro overvalued?

Yes. It had appreciated excessively in relation to the economic situation in Europe. The ECB is aware of this, and a rebalancing against the dollar is currently taking place. It is not yet complete.

- France has never been as weakened in the European Parliament and in the institutions of Brussels.

When you vote 25% for the National Front, a party that cannot form a group with others, you are weaker in the European Parliament. On the other hand, at the level of the Commission, France has requested an important position, and it will be heard. What interests us is that our commissioner exercises responsibilities in the economic field.

- Berlin does not seem willing to grant Pierre Moscovici the super-commissioner position you are asking for.

It is neither Berlin nor Paris that decides; it is the president of the Commission. I chose Pierre Moscovici. It will then be up to Jean-Claude Juncker to form his Commission and allocate responsibilities. He knows France's place in the European Union and what it can bring.

- The EU is dominated by conservatives and Germany. Are you building a social-democratic axis with Matteo Renzi?

I have political and personal relations with Matteo Renzi that allow us to act, not just in a duo, but with others. Next week, I will hold a meeting of social democrats in Paris to align our positions. But it would be a mistake to form a coalition against another within the European Council. The problems are not geographical, the South against the North, nor political, social democrats against conservatives. The issue is what we want to do together.

For France, Europe must be a protection: a protection of our interests, our rights, our values in the world, a protection to defend ourselves against threats, but also a protection against the excesses of globalization. I support Jean-Claude Juncker and his projects: the 300 billion euro investment plan, the common energy policy, controlling immigration at the European level, and finally a common foreign policy.

- Regarding Ukraine, there have been three waves of sanctions against Russia. Yet, Vladimir Putin has not changed his attitude. What should be done?

We need firmness and dialogue. Firmness, because Europe cannot accept the violation of a country's territorial integrity, because it cannot tolerate arms supplies and the blocking of border posts. The sanctions were necessary, and others will be if there is no change.

But at the same time, we need to engage in dialogue. I demonstrated this by organizing the first meeting between Vladimir Putin and Petro Poroshenko on June 6 in Normandy. And we are at a point where it is again possible to consider a meeting at the level of the Ukrainian, Russian, French, and German heads of government to find a way out of the crisis. This requires stopping arms deliveries, a ceasefire, border control, and political dialogue. Angela Merkel will go to Ukraine on Saturday. I am also in contact with the Russian president. We spoke on August 12. And I told him that if there was no quick resolution to the crisis, it would be very costly for the Russians, both economically and politically.

- Is it costly for Europeans as well?

Yes. A sanction has a price for both the one who imposes it and the one who suffers it. For Europe, it is a choice it assumes even if this situation has unfortunate economic consequences. All the more reason to find solutions based on respect for Ukraine's sovereignty.

- Did you expect the Russian sanctions on agricultural products?

There was already an embargo on pork and a number of products, under the pretext of very questionable health arguments. Compensation is needed for the farmers who are affected.

- France will deliver a Mistral-class warship this autumn. What will happen to the second ship planned for 2015?

Today, the level of sanctions does not prevent the delivery. It is the Europeans who decided this, not France. If there were to be additional tension and an impossibility to find a solution, we would have to deliberate. But for now, that is not the case. I remind you that this contract was signed in 2011 and was controversial at the time.

- And the two ships under option?

There is no discussion with the Russians regarding the two other Mistrals.

- In Eastern Europe and the Middle East, American leadership is being challenged. Some say that Barack Obama is not showing enough authority.

For a long time, we complained about American hyperpower and its multiple interventions. We would be in a poor position to reproach Barack Obama for being too timid. But I believe that the international situation is the most serious we have known since 2001. The world must fully grasp this. We must face not just a terrorist movement like Al-Qaeda, but a quasi-terrorist state, the Islamic State. We can no longer limit ourselves to the traditional debate of intervention or non-intervention. We must consider a global strategy against this group that has structured itself, that has significant funding and very sophisticated weapons, and that threatens countries like Iraq, Syria, or Lebanon. I will therefore soon propose to our partners a conference on security in Iraq and the fight against the Islamic State.

- France has decided to deliver sophisticated weapons to the Kurds in Iraq. Why give the Kurds what was refused to the Syrian rebels?

Who tells you that we have not given weapons to the rebels, that is to say, to the democratic opposition? The international community bears a very serious responsibility for what is happening in Syria. If, two years ago, there had been action to establish a transition, we would not have had the Islamic State. If, a year ago, there had been a reaction from the great powers commensurate with the use of chemical weapons (by Bashar Al-Assad), we would not have faced this terrible choice between a dictator and a terrorist group, while the rebels deserve all our support.

- What weapons has France delivered to the Syrian rebels?

Equipment in accordance with European commitments. We do not do this simply to support the Kurds or Iraqis; we act for our security. We are facing a real threat from jihadists who are involved in operations of appalling barbarity and who may at some point return to strike. Among them, there are French nationals.

- By arming the Kurds, are we not risking accelerating their march towards independence?

I have ensured that these deliveries are made in full agreement with the authorities in Baghdad so that there is no doubt about the use of these means and that the framework remains that of the unity of Iraq. France has been a pioneer; it has convinced Europe of its choices even if we are the only ones, along with the United States, to have done so for now.

- The war in Gaza has resulted in 2,000 deaths, including about 1,900 Palestinians. At the very beginning of the war, your statement on July 7 seemed to give Israel a blank check. Would you do the same today?

I have expressed myself throughout this conflict and I have reiterated our principles; they are constant: the security of Israel, the protection of civilians, and the necessity of finding a solution for Gaza. We are at a key moment. France supports the Egyptian mediation. The truce is extremely fragile, as we have unfortunately seen in recent hours. In any case, Mahmoud Abbas and the Palestinian Authority must be considered the main interlocutor. Gaza can no longer remain in the situation we have known. The objective must be demilitarization and at the same time the lifting of the blockade.

- You mean disarmament of Hamas?

Demilitarization can only take place under the aegis of the Palestinian Authority. France can be useful with Europe on the lifting of the blockade, at the Rafah crossing point. Likewise, France will participate in the conference for the reconstruction of Gaza; it will assert this obvious fact: Gaza must be neither an open-air prison nor an armed base. Otherwise, the same causes will produce the same effects.

- Laurent Fabius spoke of "imposing" a solution. Should pressure be exerted on Israel?

We must do everything to ensure that negotiations resume between the Palestinian Authority and Israel to find a way out of the conflict. We know the parameters; it is the two-state solution living in security side by side, which is the only one that has a future. In the event of failure, the international community will have to take its responsibilities.

- Regarding Africa, you launched two wars announced as "short" in 2013 in Mali and the Central African Republic. They are prolonging. Was there a miscalculation?

In Mali, a terrorist state wanted to establish itself, as in Iraq and Syria today. Our intervention has eradicated most of this threat without completely eliminating it. Today, it is no longer a matter of intervening directly but of controlling trafficking, securing areas of the territory, and allowing political dialogue with the Tuaregs. But today, my greatest concern is Libya. The African heads of state invited to the commemoration ceremonies of Liberation on August 15 repeated this to me: be careful about what is happening in Libya. The intervention of 2011 was not sufficient because it was not prolonged. I did in Mali what was not achieved in Libya.

In the Central African Republic, we intervened to prevent genocide and to stop a religious confrontation that would have provided a perspective for terrorist movements. Here too, it is taking longer than expected, but we have completed the largest operations and prepared a transition.

- France finds itself in the position of "gendarme of Africa." It is ironic for a socialist president!

When the gendarme is used to maintain a dictator or to defend mercantile or even personal interests, it is Françafrique. That is not our approach. It aims to fight against terrorism in compliance with international law; we only intervene when we are called upon. We do not conceive our action without a perspective of democracy and development. Finally, we do not act alone: in Mali as in the Central African Republic, Africans have accompanied us, and we have succeeded in bringing in the Europeans.

- You are the president who has made the most use of military force. This is unexpected.

The president is the head of the armed forces. Every time I decided to resort to force, it was because the essential was at stake; each time our armed forces have responded perfectly. That is why I maintained the credits of the military programming law. Because the French military tool is a very important element for our security and for peace. We are the only country in Europe to do this at this level. But to maintain our influence and ensure our international standing, we must have a strong economy. And that is the purpose of the policy I am conducting for employment, for growth, but also for our place in Europe and our rank in the world.