Interview with Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, in "Le Nouvel Observateur" on October 10, 2013, on the challenges and priorities of European construction.

France François Hollande · President of France

10 October 2013

Context
Hollande gave an interview to Le Nouvel Observateur on October 10, 2013, discussing European priorities, immigration, populism, and the upcoming European Parliament elections.
Main themes
European construction challenges, Lampedusa humanitarian disaster, immigration and refugee policy, rise of populism and nationalism, European Parliament elections, eurozone stability, European solidarity, anti-European sentiment, Frontex and border security, Arab Spring support, economic crisis and austerity, democratic values
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,183
61st percentile
Sentences
163
83rd percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.54
5th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
53rd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

163 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Q - Mr. President, the most dramatic news in Europe is the humanitarian disaster in Lampedusa. How do you respond?

R - This tragedy calls for a response from all of Europe. It must learn from it. The Union cannot tolerate seeing people die off its shores in appalling conditions, fleeing misery or wars. Those individuals came from Eritrea via Libya, others from Tunisia or Egypt! In the coming days, I will propose a policy to our partners that will revolve around the triptych of prevention, solidarity, protection:

- Prevention through better cooperation with countries of origin and better reception of refugees as close as possible to conflict zones.

- Solidarity through a much more active Euro-Mediterranean policy by further amplifying support for the countries of the Arab Spring.

- Protection with a strengthening of border surveillance, which is the role of the European agency Frontex, and a more effective fight against smugglers.

Q - The European elections are approaching. Can we fear a defeat for Europe in this election?

R - The European Parliament could, in next May, be largely composed of anti-Europeans. This would be a regression and a threat of paralysis. Therefore, I advocate for understanding the meaning of this election. It is not about voting for or against Europe. It is about choosing between two European projects: prolonged austerity or sustainable growth, competition or regulation, the single market or investment policies, short-termism or ecological transition.

And then we must claim what Europe has been able to achieve: it has overcome the financial crisis; the eurozone is still here; the banking union will protect us from new shocks, and the European Central Bank has acted quite well in consultation with the community institutions. Europe has held firm.

But today, we are not asked to hold firm, but to move forward, which is very different!

In the face of extremism, the best response is to hold our heads high. Who can imagine that a return to national borders will protect against immigration? The role of Schengen is to set rules that are the condition for freedom of movement. If we need to strengthen them, I am ready. But again, the solution is European. Similarly, who can claim that Europeans would live better without the single currency? They would compete against each other through wild devaluations, and that would be the end of the single market. Not to mention speculation on sovereign debts. We must emerge from this crisis positively: the status quo is a certainty of failure.

Q - Is the greatest risk not seeing the rise of these very charismatic populist parties with very simple discourses, which speak to the ears of the French, Greek, Belgian, and Italian people?

R - It is a risk. But democracy has never been a "long quiet river." It has overcome many perils. And it has always won. It is by doubting itself, by yielding on its principles, by compromising its values that it weakens. And it is by being proud of its successes that it can convince others to continue the adventure!

Q - How do you explain the rise of these nationalist sentiments: is it the fault of the economic crisis?

R - That would be too simple. Nationalism is a trend that emerged two decades ago. It stems from a lack of perspective and collective dynamism. The fear of decline adds to this. Europe is a continent steeped in history. Some countries painfully confront globalization.

And let's speak frankly: the opening of borders and thus immigration. What fuels populism is also the relationship with Islam. There are also fears among workers regarding industrial restructuring, the fear of many in the face of the rise of emerging countries, and conservatism partly linked to the aging population. Xenophobia does the rest. Therefore, exiting the crisis is necessary, but much more will need to be done to reduce national egos and identity aspirations.

Q - Is Europe responsible?

R - Yes, to the extent that its leaders struggle to rise above their national issues. However, the European idea must be claimed more strongly. Certainly, it is not easy with twenty-eight! Hence my desire to start from a hard core with the eurozone and to move faster with the countries that freely choose to do so.

But Europe must also have more confidence in itself. Do we remind ourselves enough that it is the world's largest economic power? When I was elected seventeen months ago, Europe was seen as the sick continent of the world. Today, it has recovered but has not quite started walking again. The response is not just economic: the Union must become more aware of its role in the world. On rights, freedoms, development, the environment, and security. Are we capable of carrying our own convictions on each of these issues?

Q - Three days in Brussels to reinvent Europe. One hundred personalities will debate. What is your idea for reinventing this increasingly unpopular Europe?

R - Europe has overcome the eurozone crisis thanks to the introduction of mechanisms of solidarity and stability. This is an important step. The challenge of growth and employment remains. But Europe is a spirit. However, it is not with criteria, procedures, and disciplines that we will convince the peoples. Fighting against populism will not come from calling for a retreat to nation-states or invoking the United States of Europe. It is by being European that we will instill confidence in Europe, that is to say, by providing a perspective, a meaning, and thus, a content. The time is not for institutional changes but for political choices.

Q - If you had to cite three concrete measures to be taken in the coming months?

R - First, youth! Europe must be an opportunity for new generations, wherever they live on the continent. It must direct its budget priorities towards training, mobility, culture with new technologies, and employment. Europe cannot accept that in some countries, nearly 40% of those under 25 are outside the labor market. If Europe does not reconnect with new generations, the idea that founded it is lost.

The second challenge is the fight against climate change. Europe, in the aftermath of the war, was a reference in terms of democracy. Today it must be a reference in ecological terms. It must set an example by accelerating the energy transition and hastening the shift towards a low-carbon economy. France is ready to host the climate conference in 2015. It will spare no effort to convince the European Union to confirm the objectives for reducing CO2 emissions.

Finally, Europe must make room for the digital economy. This effort must focus equally on the manufacturing of products as well as on content and usage. Hence the major role of cultural industries and the "cultural exception" that I have advocated in the trade negotiations with the United States.

Mastering the tools, but also protecting data. This is an issue of independence.

Q - We have seen you on Mali, but where is Europe in these conflicts? Where is it in Syria? In Lampedusa?

R - This raises the question of Europe's presence and influence in the world. The United States no longer intend to remain the world's gendarmes - I do not blame them for that. Europe must draw conclusions for itself! First, promote a more coherent external action.

Then, strengthen European defense by setting objectives in terms of operations, capacity, and industrial base. This will be the subject of the European Council next December. Finally, support the countries of the South, particularly Africa, so that they ensure their own security. This will be the purpose of the summit that France will organize in Paris at the beginning of December, with all African heads of state and the presence of the EU. There is no need for treaties or procedures to achieve this; it is a matter of will.

Q - Shouldn't there also be more charismatic personalities at the head of Europe?

R - Ask those who chose them! Let us not be unjust about individuals; it is a matter of political choices.

Q - Do heads of state appoint people who do not overshadow them?

R - That is not a good calculation.

Q - Do you find Herman Van Rompuy, the President of the Council, too pale?

R - Herman Van Rompuy has been very valuable during the period we have gone through. He facilitated compromises between the main states. He succeeded, on the budgetary issue, in finding a way forward. He presided over the European Council in June 2012 with great finesse, which was decisive for exiting the eurozone crisis.

Q - So it is Barroso who is to be criticized?

R - The Commission is a college. And it implements a program that the European Parliament and the heads of state and government who appointed it asked it to undertake. This will be the challenge of the upcoming European elections to ensure its renewal.

Q - François Hollande wanted to change Europe. Is it not Europe that changed François Hollande?

R - In May 2012, I never thought that, by the magic of my own election, Europe would change in a single day. I had set three priorities: growth, financial regulation, and youth employment. A year and a half later, let us look at things objectively.

1. The growth pact decided in June 2012 is being implemented with the European Investment Bank, which has found new resources, and the European Central Bank, which has introduced new instruments. This was the condition to close the "all austerity" chapter. I note that growth is returning in Europe. It is fragile, but it is the trend of recent months.

2. Financial regulation has advanced. Because necessity has made law. The banking union, that is to say, the supervision of all financial institutions in Europe, is in place. The ECB is responsible for it in the eurozone, and by the end of 2014, another phase will begin with the resolution of banking crises. With such a system, the scenario of 2008 would have been avoided. This is an important achievement.

3. Youth. A year and a half after prioritizing this issue, it is now the dominant discourse within the European Council. Mrs. Merkel partly campaigned on this theme. And a European meeting was held in Berlin to introduce the "youth guarantee." It will be followed by a meeting of the same level in November in Paris.

Q - Are you not disappointed by the modesty of the stimulus effort, the slowness, the delay?

R - To resolve the sovereign debt crisis, adjustment policies were necessary. But there was an excess of zeal. The recession was prolonged beyond what was necessary. Thus, after the shock of the subprime crisis, the recession lasted eighteen months; after the budget crisis, four years. Let us learn from this!

Q - Is the difference in weight between Germany and France greater than ever? Is France still capable of holding its role in the Franco-German couple? Does it still have the ambition?

R - The Franco-German couple is a necessity. It is both the product of history and the condition for Europe to move forward. Regardless of the political leaders at the head of these two countries, this common conception has always prevailed. Does this mean that these two countries must have the same industrial structures, the same economic policy, and the same social relations? No. The real problem lies in the fact that Germany has a specialization that leads it to have a surplus in its foreign trade, while France has been dragging a structural deficit in its trade balance for ten years. My obligation is to converge our two economies and reduce competitiveness gaps.

Q - Will there be a change in Berlin when the grand coalition is installed?

R - I certainly do not want to meddle in the political life of our German friends, but there will surely be European consequences depending on the compromise that will be found. What I am sure of is that Mrs. Merkel is convinced of the necessity to take an initiative with France and to support growth and employment more.

Q - That is to say?

R - To establish an economic government for the eurozone, ensure a stable presidency of the Eurogroup, coordinate policies more, complete the banking union, harmonize tax systems, and finally introduce the financial transaction tax. But also to ensure better social convergence with the generalization of the minimum wage.

Q - Moving forward with "the countries that want to," who does that target?

R - Today, we must start from the eurozone, which represents the largest area of solidarity to strengthen our economic and political capacity on certain issues (energy, infrastructure, digital, defense), and establish enhanced cooperation with the countries that wish to do so.

I do not exclude anyone, but I believe that Europe cannot simply wait for all twenty-eight to agree. The United Kingdom intends to discuss its future presence or participation. This should not prevent those who wish to move forward from doing so.