Joint press conference of Messrs. François Hollande, President of the Republic, Martin Schulz, President of the European Parliament, José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, Herman Van Rompuy, President of the European Council, and Mses. Angela Merkel, Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, Dalia Grybauskaite, President-in-Office of the European Union, on European efforts for youth employment, in Paris on 12 November 2013.

France François Hollande · President of France

12 November 2013 · Youth employment summit; joint press conference · Élysée Palace, France

Context
Hollande addressed a joint press conference at the Élysée Palace following a summit on European youth employment with EU leaders and Angela Merkel on November 12, 2013.
Main themes
Youth unemployment, youth guarantee, European cooperation, job training and apprenticeships, employment integration, business creation, European funding and financial instruments, multiannual financial framework, public employment services, national implementation plans, growth and competitiveness, solidarity
Duration
~48 min
94th percentile
Words
5,807
94th percentile
Sentences
324
96th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.4
26th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

324 sentences in 102 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT:

“Ladies and gentlemen, a summit for youth employment was held this afternoon here at the Élysée. It reflects a mobilization that is commensurate with the stakes: that of all the heads of government who were represented here and also of the European institutions, the Council, the Commission, the European Parliament, the European Investment Bank, and social partners.

The issue at stake is the future of a generation, one that has been affected by unemployment for years and which the crisis has further placed in a situation of doubt, even despair. There are six million young unemployed in Europe. That is too many, far too many.

Following the initiative taken by Angela MERKEL in July in Berlin, we decided to hold this summit to prepare, as much as possible, for the implementation of the programs we have determined at the European level, which we want to translate into national plans as soon as possible.

The purpose of this summit is both to evaluate the systems, state by state, country by country, that work so that they can be transposed, and to mobilize, as much as possible, all funding directed towards youth employment.

We have defined a timeline and an objective with three priorities.

The timeline is the next two years. The objective is to implement the “youth guarantee.” The “youth guarantee” is what will allow every young person to have access to a job, training, or support, that is to say, a solution. We want to achieve this objective through three priorities:

The first is training, apprenticeships. Training for future jobs, utilizing all forms of alternation to mobilize all systems to qualify young people.

The second priority is integration into employment, particularly for the young people who are most in difficulty, those who are furthest from the labor market. This also requires mobilizing all instruments to reach those who are forgotten, those who are excluded, to bring them back to employment.

The third priority is the creation of activities and the creation of businesses. This concerns all young people, those who are in a number of our neighborhoods and who are often the most dynamic, those who have diplomas and who may have the desire to start a business, provided that we offer them simplification and financing.

So we have a timeline, priorities, and we also have financial instruments. These financial instruments are already partly found in the European budget and can be further amplified in what is called the “multiannual financial framework,” that is to say, the upcoming European budgets.

There are 6 billion euros that have been allocated with the Youth Employment Initiative, which adds to the funding from the European Social Fund and also to the interventions of the European Investment Bank.

The whole issue is to act quickly. A decision was made during this summit. It is that all countries that have sent their program for the implementation of the youth guarantee to the European Commission will be able, starting January 1, to have access to the corresponding funding.

In conclusion, if there are three words to remember from our summit, they are: speed, because there is urgency; solidarity, because we cannot abandon a generation; and finally, quality, because we must offer jobs and training that correspond to real prospects for young people.

To succeed, we need this mobilization, we need growth. That is what we must do, at the European level and at the national level: support activity, create wealth, improve our competitiveness. That was also the purpose of the summit for youth employment.

I will now give the floor to Angela, since she organized the previous summit and insisted, in particular, on the mobilization of public services for employment.”

ANGELA MERKEL, CHANCELLOR OF THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY:

“Dear François, dear colleagues. I would like to thank François HOLLANDE for taking up the initiative we launched in Berlin and for continuing this second conference.

Why do it outside the normal rhythm of European meetings? Because it is a national responsibility to combat youth unemployment. On one hand, we have European decisions regarding financial matters; on the other hand, we have the obligation to spend money so that it reaches young people. We all know that the fate of Europe is shaped by the perspective we offer to young people. That is why we had a debate today.

We were informed about the initiatives and activities of the labor ministers. They have created a network to establish the frameworks and legal foundations of labor administrations, public employment services, and to implement structural reforms. We have before us a network of public employment services. The head of our “Pôle Emploi,” for example, provided us with a report today. These public employment services in Europe have created a network and agreed on a plan, a roadmap to apply the best methods used in different nations to benefit the various actors from the best experiences.

There are also bilateral agreements between Germany, Greece, and Spain, for example. The cooperation between the heads of public employment services is already very concrete work because they are the direct interlocutors of young people to offer them qualifications.

What is also important is the presence of social partners who take on their responsibilities, for example, in the area of working conditions. But on the other hand, it is also clear that politics does not create jobs: it is businesses that create jobs by providing the necessary framework conditions.

We also witnessed the presentation of the results of the European Investment Bank, which provides loans and has already taken the necessary initiatives. What is important now is that the European Parliament votes on the multiannual financial framework. Then, it is very important that the different nations present their plans to the European Commission so that funds can be released in favor of young people. And we, the member states of the European Union, are of course doing our utmost to create a framework for growth, because without growth there will be no new jobs, and that is what young people are suffering from.

Thank you for taking another step forward, thank you for this Parisian initiative. I feel that, to improve national activities, we have made a step, we have launched an initiative. We have also launched a very trusting cooperation in the interest of young people. Thank you.”

DALIA GRYBAUSKAITE, PRESIDENT IN OFFICE OF THE EUROPEAN UNION:

“I would like to add a few words perhaps, in light of our experience from the presidency, from the very first days of our presidency.

The issues of youth employment and youth unemployment have immediately become a major priority, particularly during all our European Council meetings starting in September. All of this will be finalized in December.

I would like to say that it is not, of course, to contradict what Angela has said. But my experience is that jobs can also be created by young people for young people, not necessarily by politicians. We need men and women in politics, but it is so that they create the right framework and incentives. And we can do this by implementing policies; at least in Lithuania, we have been able to prove it.

I wanted to tell you that, during the Council of Social Affairs in particular, we have made many decisions since October in Vilnius, the Council for Competitiveness, the ministers of Economy, Finance in ECOFIN for the financing of SMEs in particular. Together with the Commission, we have developed instruments with the European Investment Bank, of course.

We are also preparing for the December Council on telecommunications, and we will study youth employment particularly in the field of telecommunications training. We will identify a number of aspects related to the Internet and focus on this issue, which is truly a red line for all member states.

Of course, to succeed by the end of the year, all member states at the national level need to receive, to benefit from a certain acceptance from the European Commission of our national programs for youth employment in order to benefit from the agreed six billion. I am therefore very happy to tell you and to acknowledge this evening that this day has truly been a success, like all previous initiatives.

Thanks to the Parliament and the Commission, all together, we have found an agreement on the budget for 2013-2014. This will allow us to finalize all of this; we hope for a very quick vote from the European Parliament on the multiannual financial framework for the next seven years. This is a question for cohesion, agriculture, youth employment. For all these issues, money will be available starting January 1 if the member states are ready to absorb it. Thank you.”

MARTIN SCHULZ, PRESIDENT OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT:

“Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen. I have nothing to add to what the President of the Republic and Madam Chancellor have said about the content of our conference. I share the opinion that this conference is a signal in itself, because the heads of government and state and the European institutions show that they take youth unemployment seriously, the figures of which in some member states of the European Union exceed 50%. This is the challenge of the European Union.

This concerns not only young people, but also their families, their parents, and it is a societal problem. If we have an immediate mechanism available to save the monetary economic system, we must also be able to give a chance, a sustainable and credible perspective to the next generation. I therefore find that today’s summit and the conference in Berlin are signals of crucial importance.

The European Parliament will undoubtedly adopt, next week, the financial perspectives for the years 2014-2020 and the annual budget for the year 2014, to reassure the European institutions and the member states that need the money. This money will be available. I assure you. I cannot speak for all the members of the European Parliament, but I believe I am brave enough to assure you that the majority of the members of the European Parliament will adopt these two projects next week.”

JOSE MANUEL BARROSO, PRESIDENT OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION:

“First of all, I would like to join, of course, in thanking President HOLLANDE for organizing this European conference, a conference that in my opinion has been a great success. It has allowed for the confirmation of certain objectives with, now, a much more advanced state in terms of structuring, not only between member states but also with European institutions and also with social partners. In fact, there is nothing more urgent today than to ensure that we can offer our youth real prospects for the future. And our priority there, of course, is to have concrete results. It was on this urgency and with this spirit of concreteness that we had this meeting today.

You know that the Commission already presented, in December 2012, a “youth employment” package, and notably this initiative called the “youth guarantee.” This has been approved by all our member states. Now it is up to the member states to implement it. That is why I called on the member states today to quickly finalize their action plans. We have already received some action plans, and we received the guarantee today that the different member states—all the member states—would send us the final plans for the execution of this “youth guarantee” in their own countries during the month of December.

We have also proposed measures that could have immediate effects. We have thus anticipated the implementation of the youth employment initiative by engaging, starting in 2014 and 2015, the six billion euros planned for this purpose. What we are going to do is “fund clouding.” The six billion euros, or even eight billion euros—the six billion euros that we have already allocated directly and which were approved during the negotiations at the European Council for the multiannual budget—we have decided to do the “fund cloud,” which means concentrating it on the first two years.

But we have already anticipated, in fact, even within the current framework before the next budget, because thanks to action teams in eight member states that have a higher youth unemployment problem than others, the reprogramming of 3.7 billion euros from the European Social Fund has already allowed 1.14 million young people to benefit from training, internships, and orientation services.”

The new cohesion policy will indeed allow us to develop this. Apart from the initiative for young people, we can use amounts we estimate at seven billion euros from the European Social Fund for actions that also aim at youth employment. I also welcome the agreement reached last night on the European budget for 2014. We are now awaiting the formal adoption of the budget for the next seven years next Tuesday in Strasbourg.

We are also offering four million young students and apprentices a mobility perspective through the ERASMUS+ program, a program that has 14.7 billion euros until 2020. This is the novelty: apart from the ERASMUS program for students that everyone knows in Europe, we now have an ERASMUS program for apprentices. This mobility will be an asset for young people also in terms of the labor market of tomorrow. Moreover, there is also cooperation among public services and there is the system called EURES: it is a network to allow member states to exchange their job offers across Europe.

Another initiative that the Commission has launched, for example: the European Alliance for Apprenticeship and the Global Coalition for Jobs in the digital sector, which aims to respond to what is expected. There are 900,000 job vacancies in this sector until 2015. It is important to emphasize: the role of businesses is essential because the fight against unemployment and youth unemployment is, of course, primarily a task for the member states, it is also a task for the European institutions, but it is a task for all our societies!

That is why I want to emphasize that the social partners have recently not only supported the "Youth Guarantee" initiative but have also agreed on a framework for employment, which I welcome because it is not every day that we see businesses and unions agree on a plan. This also shows the urgency in this area! The Commission has therefore committed, of course, to fully utilize all the means at its disposal, in this spirit of urgency and speed that the President of the Republic has highlighted.

In any case, it must be noted that the essential competencies and political, administrative, and financial means are in the member states. They must mobilize to avoid this lost generation. And mobilization has been precisely the watchword today in our meeting, and our message today is simple: we need concrete actions, we need results quickly. This will only happen if there is commitment from the member states. The bulk of the work remains to be done on the ground, in the member states, in our regions at the local level, also at the regional level. And there, we support the initiatives of these actors.

This is therefore a fundamental challenge. I believe that today we have more means, more commitments, and more of the sense of urgency that is necessary to achieve victory in this very important battle. Thank you."

HERMAN VAN ROMPUY, PRESIDENT OF THE EUROPEAN COUNCIL

"Good evening first of all Ladies and Gentlemen. First of all, I would like to thank President François HOLLANDE for organizing this conference. Youth unemployment is undoubtedly one of the most urgent issues for our Europe. That is why we are here today with more than 20 presidents and prime ministers and quite a few ministers of Employment and Education. In July, Chancellor MERKEL invited the member states to Berlin. Today, we meet again in Paris this November and we will meet again next spring in Rome.

I had already placed the theme of youth unemployment, which is much more than just a theme, at the forefront during the European Council in June. In October, we assessed the progress regarding our commitments for youth employment. We will continue to return to this issue at the European Council as many times as necessary. Because we simply cannot afford not to do so humanly, socially, economically, and politically.

During the European Council in June, the 28 presidents, prime ministers, and I, the president of the European Commission, called on all actors to mobilize to enable motivated young Europeans to find a job or continue their training. And today's conference once again confirms the level of mobilization and commitment.

We know well, unfortunately, that employment reacts only with a certain delay to an economic recovery. The economic recovery is taking place. According to the latest forecasts, employment will increase in 2014 and 2015 by about 1% in the eurozone and in the European Union, even if unemployment will unfortunately still be too high. I know, of course, that we must be cautious with forecasts, but we can hope that, within 14 months, almost all eurozone countries will experience a positive trend regarding employment.

There is a perspective, there is hope. This is crucial after extremely difficult years. We know what we must accomplish to continue on this path, we agree on what needs to be done. What matters now is to implement it and to implement it quickly.

First of all, we must continue to reform labor markets to make them more job-intensive. The problem of structural unemployment predates the crisis. In 2008, the unemployment rate in the eurozone was 9%. Ten years before 2008, it was over 10%. So we remain, during a whole period of economic growth, with a very high unemployment rate.

Some countries have succeeded in the past in substantially reducing structural unemployment. Others have not at all. Youth will be the first to benefit from comprehensive employment policies. The labor market is a national competence and therefore a national responsibility. The role that the European Union can play is a facilitating role, through European budgets, a role of impetus, and the eight billion euros planned in the MFF testify to this.

Secondly, member states must finalize their plan for the "Youth Guarantee" as soon as possible. The president of the Commission and the president of the Republic have just said it; otherwise, community funding will not be able to benefit the most affected regions from January 1, 2014. This would truly be a missed opportunity.

Thirdly, we must follow up on our decisions from the European Council in October to ensure that youth have digital skills. Otherwise, by 2015, we could face a shortage of skilled labor in the digital sector of nearly 900,000 people, a paradox in a time of high unemployment.

Fourthly, we must also encourage entrepreneurship among young people. After all, starting a business is also an effective way to create jobs. The Union has also set up new initiatives.

Fifth and finally, we must ensure to strengthen the economic recovery we are witnessing today. Ultimately, the main solution to unemployment is economic growth. Monetary policy, more flexible budgetary policies, and now a stable currency contribute to this. But growth is not enough, and direct impact measures are necessary, especially for young people.

In conclusion, I intend to continue to do everything possible to maintain the necessary momentum and ensure regular follow-up at the European Council by March. When we meet again in Brussels and later in Rome, the European initiative for youth employment and the national implementation plans for the "Youth Guarantee" must be in place and, hopefully, already delivering their first results. This will be a good opportunity to take stock of where we stand and on the next actions. It is more than an opportunity; it is a duty, as our credibility is at stake, and a Europe of results will convince Europeans. Thank you."

QUESTION: "Mr. President of the Republic, Adrien GINDRE for BFM TV. The conference you organized today takes place in a very particular context, tense in Europe, in France in particular. You yourself were booed and whistled yesterday during the commemorations of November 11. Two questions: did you take this as a condemnation of your policy, of what you are doing, and could you, if necessary, review your team, your government as some in your own majority have asked you today?"

THE PRESIDENT:

"What efforts have I asked of the French for the past 18 months? First, to restore public accounts. They had been degraded. Secondly, to restore competitiveness because without competitiveness, there can be no growth or employment. Finally, to improve training and education. These are difficult efforts; I measure them and I know what they can represent. These are essential efforts. If I had not engaged in them, where would our country be now that recovery is on the horizon?

Then, what is the objective? The only objective I pursue is employment, especially for young people. For the past four months, the reversal of the unemployment curve has been achieved for young people in France. There are still too many in this situation. What I have to do with the government is to reverse the unemployment curve for the entire active population, that is, for the French. That is why I continue to ensure the course and this direction.

As for the insults and outrages that may have been uttered during this ceremony, which should unite, which must unite, and which brings together all the French, well, these insults, these outrages dishonor their authors."

QUESTION: "A question to the Chancellor. You are now meeting for the second time in just a few months at a very high level. If you allow me this comment, the announcements you are making are well-known announcements. So the question is, are we not at risk, especially because you are meeting at a high level, of ultimately provoking a kind of disappointment among young people? And if you allow me a second question as an economic journalist, the Banking Union, healthy banks, is very important for job creation. Can you say when the Banking Union will come into effect? When will this Banking Union be implemented?"

ANGELA MERKEL, CHANCELLOR OF THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY

"If you allow me to start with the second question, I am not in a position to answer very precisely because you, as an economic journalist, of course know the facts. In 2014, we will have the single banking supervision. Before that, there will be stress tests, that is, examinations of the banks; the finance ministers are working very intensively to prepare this directive on bank resolution before Christmas. Then, we need to resolve the question of direct recapitalization of systemic banks, and in the end, we will have the building, the edifice.

Then, Parliament must vote on the provisions. This is, of course, an intense legislative process that follows, but regarding the directive on the resolution of European banks, this is a first step, and at that moment we will have a common standard. When we look at the various legislative projects in the Union, I must say that we have followed a fairly considerable pace for the creation of this Banking Union. It is exemplary; these are not very simple questions. My conviction: the eurozone has demonstrated its ability to act, and all those who are not part of it have also contributed.

Regarding the conference now, this is not the only conference where we already know the first results in advance. But I consider this conference to be very important. Why? Because we, as heads of state and government, must look very concretely, very precisely at the existing structures in our countries to know what is the right method to qualify young people, to qualify the workforce, how to create the necessary conditions to create jobs.

This is already a value in itself because it is an encouragement for those who do the concrete work, because it constitutes a confirmation of the work of businesses, and because it is very concrete work to know where young people are sought, where they can be recruited, and what this means for the agenda of the European Union.

It is therefore very interesting, and we really need to pay attention to see, in twenty-eight countries where the structures are very different, how we try to harmonize them. When we talk about competitiveness, of course, the efficiency of state structures, this efficiency is also very important, and I think we can make progress. I always learn things; I always draw very satisfactory lessons."

DALIA GRYBAUSKAITE, PRESIDENT OF THE EUROPEAN UNION

"I will simply add a more practical point. During traditional councils, we do not really have the time to focus on very specific, very particular topics. However, this is really very important, and it is a very positive framework that we have created this year to come together, discuss it, and give our directives to governments so that they prepare what we would like to see them do. Then we can present ourselves at the next Council with other topics and having emphasized what we can do in other sectors, with other instruments for youth employment.

The idea is to create this framework that allows not only to create jobs, to create positions, but also to enable them to create their own jobs. We have talked about start-ups. We see that youth can do a lot if we help them, if we give them a leg up, or at the very least if we do not hinder them. So, this is a new momentum, a new opportunity for us to come together at the highest level. So yes, it is timely and it is important. It is an important element of our new relationships, of our new way of making decisions, and I believe that this forum can be used for other topics, if they appear to be particularly urgent and important."

QUESTION: "We are on the eve of the European elections, and Europe suffers from a degraded image in several of our countries. In terms of employment, in France, for example, citizens do not understand why there is social dumping, why wages are not the same in Europe, nor are social charges. Do you intend to address this issue, perhaps to reassure, provide explanations, find solutions?

And then I have a second question, still on the eve of the European elections. Yesterday, we talked about the commemorations of November 11, where far-right supporters booed the President. Do you think that populism is a real danger and that it risks weighing heavily at the time of the elections, or do you think there is still time to explain to voters that populism may not be the answer? Thank you."

THE PRESIDENT:

"Who wants to answer this question? As far as work is concerned..."

ANGELA MERKEL, CHANCELLOR OF THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY

"As we are here, I think I can say that we will do everything in our power, even if we belong to different political parties, to strengthen the European Union and Europe. One hundred years after the outbreak of the First World War, we are saying precisely 'yes to Europe.' Because for the first time, people can be sure that there will be no more such dramas, that they will not be repeated. We still have a lot of work ahead of us, but Europe is the direction we must pursue."

THE PRESIDENT:

"Perhaps Jose Manuel, on employment issues, perhaps on the posted workers directive."

JOSE MANUEL BARROSO, PRESIDENT OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION

"Very well. It is important, we have indeed discussed a bit today. It was not the direct question, but since there was an impact on employment issues, we discussed the problems of the 'posted workers' directive.

In fact, what is happening is that we have freedom of movement in Europe. This is something that Europeans value highly. A European today is a citizen of their country, but they are also a citizen of all of Europe. They can move, they can study, they can live, they can work in another country. This is a great civilizational progress that has not been achieved anywhere else in the world, except in Europe: to have this capacity to enjoy this freedom.

The European Treaty is based on the four freedoms: the freedom of movement, of course, of goods, but also of services, capital, and people. And we want to maintain this principle very much. But it is true that there are sometimes abuses! Abuses, for example, in terms of posted workers. Today, we talked about this, about the 'posted workers' directive' which was developed a few years ago precisely to avoid these abuses. It stipulates that a worker, when they are in a country that is not their own, must have the salary, leave, rest period, and job security in the country where they work. And that the essentials, regarding pensions and insurance, are in the country of origin.

What happens sometimes? Unscrupulous companies exploit these workers. They make workers work in a country, for example, here in France, under conditions that are not those that French workers can benefit from. This is an abuse, it is illegal. We believe that this must be pursued with determination. The Commission even presented, in 2012, another directive to strengthen the enforcement of this directive, the 'Enforcement Directive,' to ensure that these abuses no longer exist.

Today, I said once again that it would be important, and it is within the framework of the priorities that have already been accepted at the level of heads of state and government, to conclude this directive. We must make an effort to avoid precisely certain situations that are, by the way, an exception but can be exploited by what you have rightly called populists, which can harm the image of Europe.

Europe protects. Europe has rules. We are in a Europe of rules. There is no other place in the world. It is certainly not in Asia, certainly not in America, certainly not in Africa. You have so many rules to guarantee the social market economy, to guarantee a social model like the one we have. Europe protects but, of course, there are abuses. So, let us fight against abuses. And that is why I made a call today to the Council but also to the European Parliament to find a decision on this directive because I know well that in some countries, for example, here in France but not only in France, in some countries, this is becoming a major issue.

To conclude the answer to your more general question, I express all my support for what Chancellor MERKEL has just said and congratulate her because, in the campaign in Germany, she said exactly this: she links the future of Germany to the future of Europe.

I believe that if Europe is doing poorly, we need national leaders to embrace Europe as their project. Europe is not just them in Brussels or Strasbourg. Europe is all of us, in all our capitals. If moderate political forces, center-left, center-right want to win the battle for Europe, they must not leave the initiative to extremist forces, they must have the courage to explain what we can do together, as we did today precisely in this summit for employment: to show that Europe is part of the solution.

Europe is not the problem. The problems we have were not created by Europe. They were created by other causes. So, let us work together but by showing, as the President of the European Council said, what is above all a national responsibility: the question of the labor market is a national responsibility.

As the President of the European Council also said, some countries have responded very well to this! Some countries have made reforms! They do not have a youth unemployment problem, some of our countries; others have immense problems! So it is not Europe that created the problems, it is different policies that created the problems. So, let us work together so that Europe can support national efforts.

But let us not, please, place on Europe all that is not necessarily Europe's fault. I believe this is very important, precisely for the reasons you mentioned, to avoid the rise of populism or extremism that want to threaten what is a great project of peace.

Next year, we will talk about the beginning of the First World War. Europe received the Nobel Peace Prize last year. We must be proud to be Europeans and not always put Europe as the scapegoat sometimes for other difficulties that exist at other levels."

THE PRESIDENT:

"Europe was built, was established, was made against extremism. I will not allow, we will not allow extremism to undo Europe. But we cannot stop at these proclamations. Europe must be a protection, a prosperity. It must be a hope. It must give additional strength to the nation-states. If I wanted to illustrate my point, youth employment is a responsibility of each of the countries. It is not Europe that is responsible for employment policies. If Europe can, through its budget, through its instruments, through its structures, particularly to finance measures for youth, then it is fully within its mission.

A second illustration, the so-called posted workers directive, the principle is good. Allowing the free movement of workers is valid in both directions. At the same time, we cannot accept abuses, the sometimes questionable, deplorable uses that some employers can make of these facilities. Therefore, both Europe and the nation-states will fight against these abuses and against these methods that ultimately harm the European idea. Because we cannot accept that Europe is seen as responsible for everything. Because Europe depends first and foremost on the will of citizens and notably through their vote, for each of the governments that compose it and for the European Parliament."

QUESTION: "A very concrete question. In the document I read today, there is no reference to the four months regarding the youth guarantee. I would like to know if you confirm the commitment to implement the youth guarantee within a period of four months? That is to say, to offer young people a job or training within a maximum period of four months after the end of their studies, after the start of the unemployment period. Thank you."

THE PRESIDENT:

"That is the objective we have set. Starting from January 1, everything will be done by each of the countries that have presented a program and by European credits to achieve this objective: to ensure that every young person can have either a job, or training, or an apprenticeship, or support. In France, we have already started to do this, even before the European credits are available from January 1. Thank you."