Joint press conference of Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, and Mr. Mario Monti, President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic, notably on the Eurozone crisis, in Rome on June 14, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

14 June 2012 · Joint press conference of Mr. François Hollande and Mr. Mario Monti · Rome, Italy

Context
Hollande and Monti held a joint press conference in Rome on June 14, 2012, discussing bilateral relations and the Eurozone crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone crisis, Franco-Italian bilateral relations, European growth and fiscal discipline, sovereign debt crisis, Greek elections and eurozone membership, common bond issuance, banking system support, investment and trade, European governance reform, budgetary discipline
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,642
83rd percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
2.96
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

159 sentences in 47 paragraphs

I would like to publicly congratulate him once again on his election and, on behalf of the Italian government and in my personal capacity, I extend my best wishes for his term in leading France, at a crucial phase for the world and particularly for the European Union.

France and Italy are two very close countries, not only geographically, but also through history, culture, and the way of life of our citizens. Within the great European family, we are united by very strong ties. I am therefore convinced that we will be able to organize a joint work program that is beneficial in the interest of our two countries and of Europe.

President HOLLANDE is visiting Italy for the first time today, and in fact, this is our first real bilateral meeting, even though we have already gotten used to meeting as we have seen each other and exchanged views several times at the G8, at Camp David, in video conferences, at the European Council on May 23... But today was actually the first real opportunity for a bilateral meeting. And today we primarily discussed bilateral issues that are very important and fortunately do not pose any problems. Because we have observed a very positive situation that requires a little attention to further improve and intensify our exchanges. Because the potential is enormous.

We will have a bilateral summit scheduled for the autumn. The two governments will meet, and on that occasion, we will revitalize the various topics of common interest in terms of the economy, infrastructure, and major joint projects, as well as in the cultural field, which is very important for our two countries.

We also share the goal of ensuring increased growth in investments and bilateral trade, which today already amounts to 70 billion euros per year. France and Italy are each other's second-largest trading partners, and reciprocal investments remain—especially considering the current situation—quite significant.

There is no need to go over all the different sectors because you already know them.

You will surely not be surprised to know that today we also focused, during our discussions, on the topic of European integration and the eurozone crisis.

We noted a very strong convergence of views on all the main issues on the table. We both gave a very positive assessment of everything that has been done so far at the European level to counter the crisis—including the recent intervention to support the Spanish banking system. And everything that has been done to address the crisis is important, even if it has not always been sufficient.

We agreed that the significant progress made in the governance of the eurozone is not enough to shield the euro from market turbulence. Therefore, action must be taken to strengthen the weak points of the system, and in our view, all of this involves actions on the real economy and actions on financial aspects.

We agreed on the importance of paying more attention to growth in the formulation of European policies and at the national level. Growth does not mean that we should set aside or neglect budgetary discipline. Our two countries have learned lessons from past decades. It is not a good idea to neglect budgetary discipline, but this discipline alone is not enough to achieve growth, development, and job creation.

Therefore, appropriate national and European policies must be considered. These policies need to be prioritized, and at the European Council on May 23, President HOLLANDE and I, without having agreed in advance, were actually in sync. We then discussed how to work at the financial level to strengthen the position of countries in relation to the market. We talked about proposals, proposals that the European Union is currently working on.

We then addressed the sovereign debt crisis, the tools that could restore market confidence in the most exposed countries, and we also exchanged our views on the hypotheses being studied regarding forms of common bond issuance and other proposals.

We agreed on everything concerning development; I had forgotten to mention it, but it is a central point of our respective positions. That is to say, the necessity to increase productive investments for the economies, whether they are investments financed by the private or public sector or in the form of public-private partnerships.

In three days, elections will be held in Greece: we of course discussed this topic, and I want to reaffirm my wish that Greece remains in the eurozone and that it respects its commitments. We believe that the Greek people have made significant efforts over the past few years, efforts that in normal situations would have required an entire generation.

The European Union and the eurozone are showing great solidarity. Our two countries, overall, contribute up to 40% of the assistance to Greece and to all countries in need. And Greece's commitment to budgetary consolidation and structural reforms is the best guarantee of a more prosperous future for this country within the eurozone.

We then discussed a number of international issues, particularly Syria. The atrocities committed by the regime are unacceptable and must be condemned in the strongest terms. We strongly support the actions of the UN envoy, Mr. Kofi ANNAN.

Rome—I am pleased to say—holds a fairly central position in preparing for the upcoming European decisions. We will have President HOLLANDE here in Rome again on June 22, along with German Chancellor Mrs. MERKEL and Spanish Prime Minister Mr. Mariano RAJOY, and on that occasion, we will delve more deeply into our respective visions on intervention tools for development and for strengthening the eurozone. And I have great confidence, even more confidence, in fact, after our conversation today. I am sure that Italy and France will be able to make significant contributions to the solid and harmonious development of our common European home.

Thank you, and I now give the floor to you.

THE PRESIDENT—Mr. Prime Minister, today I am making my first visit as head of state to Italy. I know your country well; I have built friendly relations with many, and I know what friendship between France and Italy represents, which is made up of economic relations, trade relations, cultural ties, but also great political convergences. I also appreciated your interventions at the G8 at Camp David, at the European Council, and I have a great deal of respect for the actions you are taking.

In this first official meeting, I want to recall what binds us together. First, a desire to deepen our relations, and we will have the opportunity to do so at the bilateral summit between France and Italy, which could be held in Lyon at the end of the year.

We could examine on that occasion both infrastructure projects: we have some, sort of project bonds ahead of their time, but also our trade exchanges. I would like to remind you that Italy is France's second-largest trading partner. We could also look at our joint industrial projects, as many French and Italian companies work in closely related fields and have relationships between French and Italian capital. And finally, we could further deepen our cultural and academic exchanges.

That covers bilateral relations.

I wanted, together with the Minister of Foreign Affairs, to also discuss with President MONTI the serious issue of Syria. France is mobilized and will remain so, regarding a situation that is unacceptable and worsening day by day. We wish for a further strengthening of sanctions, that Kofi ANNAN's mission be reinforced once again. We also wish to seek, together with Russia (and this could be one of our topics in Los Cabos), a political solution, that is to say, a political transition. And finally, we will convene the "Friends of Syria" group on July 6 in Paris, and I confirm here: we need Italy to participate in this search for a solution for Syria.

We also discussed other international situations: Iran, the Sahel. But what animated us for a good part of the afternoon was our common vision of Europe. I sent President VAN ROMPUY a document to prepare for the European Council at the end of June. In this document, I set out three principles.

The first is the indispensable growth if we want our economies to regain momentum and if we want to achieve our deficit reduction objectives—even if I do not oppose budgetary seriousness and growth. Budgetary seriousness is necessary for growth, and growth allows us to achieve financing objectives. That is the first principle, growth.

The second principle is stability. Europe needs instruments, mechanisms that allow for the support of banks and states that may find themselves at a moment and unjustly in turmoil—so that speculation is discouraged and the cohesion of the eurozone is strengthened.

The third principle is the deepening of the Economic and Monetary Union, that is to say, having a roadmap for the coming years that allows us to coordinate our policies, harmonize our tax systems, and implement structural policies that give Europe more capacity.

It is on these three principles that we found common ground. On growth, we share the same objective and, indeed, also a broad agreement on the instruments—whether it be the European Investment Bank, structural funds, project bonds. We will be able to find not only between our two countries but with others the conditions that will allow us to reach a consensus—for the European Council at least, we are seeking that. It is still necessary that the amounts involved are substantial. It is not about creating growth with public spending from each of our states, but it is also not about creating growth with a few resources that we would mobilize for the occasion. We need instruments that can be mobilized quickly to restore economic activity.

I also share the idea that we need financing for future investments and that, again, Europe should look at what the different states contribute, within the framework of these future financing to have a more flexible conception than today in terms of the classification of these expenditures.

Then, there is stability, and again we exchanged our ideas. We must continue to work to respond as effectively as possible to the challenge posed to us to provide means so that banks and states can be protected from speculation and so that guarantees are provided for virtuous states, so that they are not themselves called into question when they have made the necessary effort, as here in Italy, to restore public accounts.

This will require imagination and innovation to find these financial instruments, and we will continue to work on that. Finally, there is the deepening of the monetary union. You know the ideas that drive me, particularly for the financial transaction tax based on enhanced cooperation, bonds that we can call euro bonds, euro bills, amortization funds; this refers to different realities, but we need new instruments that will require more integration. That is what we have exchanged and worked on. We have a new meeting scheduled, this time with our German and Spanish friends. This will be an additional step. I also want to say a word about Greece, since there is an election scheduled for the 17th; this is not the only one in Europe, but I will only speak about the election in Greece. I completely share what Mario MONTI, the Italian Prime Minister, has said.

The Greeks are sovereign; it is they who must decide, and we must respect them. They have made considerable efforts over the past few months to meet the level of what was requested, given what had unfortunately been left by previous governments. And today they must reaffirm their commitment to the euro and to their commitments.

But I also say this: Europe must do its duty in terms of growth concerning Greece. And I have advocated, I think we can also agree on this, that structural funds should be quickly provided to Greece so that it can also benefit from growth. We have confidence in the Greek people; the Greek people must have confidence in Europeans, but at the same time, everyone must respect their commitments.

Finally, a word about what awaits us. We have several meetings after the 17th. It’s Los Cabos, where I will again, along with others, put the theme of growth on the agenda because it is slowing down everywhere in the world, including in emerging markets. So we have a commitment that must be reaffirmed at this G20 meeting to make growth our objective, but also to respond to new challenges that will also be raised at Rio+20 in Brazil. It is the challenge of international solidarity, of a development agency for the environment, a specialized agency of the UN, and then there will be this meeting on the 22nd and the European Council on the 28th and 29th. A lot of work awaits us. And so we need clear ideas, strong ideas to create the necessary cohesion. I do not want an Europe that is seen as the sick continent.

We have economic power, we are a group of countries with a great history, with all the conditions to ensure our future. But we must make efforts ourselves, and not be a source of concern but rather a matter of pride. Well, that is what we have to do, we Europeans. The answer is on our side. Both because we are aware that our continent has all the capacities to prepare for its future, and because we must have an impact on the fate of the planet. That is why I was happy to make these remarks here in Rome. The President of the Italian Republic is waiting for us, so we will be able to answer questions on that occasion. Unless there are one or two questions. You know, the French press always wants to ask questions.

QUESTION -- Hello, the rescue plan for Spanish banks has been insufficient to reassure the markets, more needs to be done. You yourself agree with this. Several options are on the table. What options do you agree on? And above all, second question, these options have been on the table for a long time for some, but Ms. MERKEL has often been reluctant. So, what chance do you both have of convincing the Chancellor, where others like Mr. SARKOZY have struggled to do so in recent months? Finally, I have a question about domestic politics, also for the President: a tweet has caused controversy in France, in Italy, etc. Does the First Lady have the right to contradict your position or to contradict the position of the Socialist Party regarding the election in La Rochelle?

THE PRESIDENT -- I do not think President MONTI will be able to answer that question.

MR. MONTI -- Can I listen?

THE PRESIDENT -- But I will not answer it either, here and on this subject. However, regarding Spain, there was an important meeting that took place on Saturday, which allowed for a solution to be found. It still needs to be implemented. Can we, with the Chancellor, further improve the arrangements? Yes, I said, that is part of the agenda of the European Council. On growth, we need to take measures, on financial stability as well. There are several ideas, you know, that have been put on the table, beyond euro bonds or euro bills which are more medium-term, but there is the intervention of the European Stability Mechanism, there is the deposit guarantee, banking supervision, what is called the Banking Union, there is the banking license that could potentially be granted to the European Stability Mechanism which would give the necessary power to overcome a number of financial movements. So, these issues will be present at the European Council on the 28th and 29th. And we must all – this will also be the subject of the preparatory meeting in Rome – put in place all the instruments that can, with or without a treaty modification, be effective. There is a principle, it is effectiveness and at the same time cohesion. The idea is to find mechanisms for virtuous states, for those who make the effort and who cannot be exposed to speculation.

MR. MONTI -- I will add a few words, simply to respond to the question regarding Ms. MERKEL. For a few months – I started before President HOLLANDE – and therefore for a few months, I have had the pleasure and the opportunity to collaborate and exchange with Chancellor MERKEL both in the context of bilateral meetings and at the level of European Councils, and I think we have an interest in identifying ever better solutions for European construction both in terms of growth and stability, and development, and integration. In my view, we cannot talk about member states that would be blocked and member states that should move and advance. To my knowledge, I have always been able to observe in Europe an attempt, a search for common positions and I know that Ms. MERKEL just like President HOLLANDE, myself and the other heads of government, we are all constantly looking for solutions for Europe so that, to quote President HOLLANDE, these solutions are more effective.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, today the ECB highlighted Italy's ambitious objectives but also the public debt that continues to rise. The Bank of Italy has expressed its concerns. There have been important auctions with high yields. My question is: how can we avoid the spiral that also affected Spain at a time when our yields are also high? And, we wanted to ask you: we have heard a lot about this idea of moving towards an economic rather than a political union; how much of your national sovereignty are you willing to give up for this goal and do you also share the opinion of the Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund, Christine LAGARDE, that there are only three months left to save the euro? Thank you.

MR. MONTI -- I will perhaps respond very quickly and then the ball will pass to President HOLLANDE who must then go to the Quirinal.

The fact that Italy's public debt is significant is quite well known, we know this, it has not escaped us and Italians and international organizations are aware of the remarkable progress made by Italy in recent months to have a more virtuous behavior in terms of public finances if I may borrow that adjective from President HOLLANDE.

On the other hand, you have raised a real problem which is the following: how can a country like Italy today, and here I think of the forecasts of the European Commission, and therefore a country that has a public deficit that this year will be half of the average deficit of the European Union in relation to GDP and which next year will have a structural surplus because it is one of the few European countries that will have this structural surplus – and every time there is a disturbance in the financial markets, Italian interest rates are more affected than others? The spread rises and all this only has negative repercussions on the state accounts for businesses, which can give citizens and public opinion the unpleasant feeling that the measures we have adopted are not the right ones or that they are not sufficient, that their scope and size are not sufficient when the opposite is true. What we are doing is sometimes heavy but our choices are going in the right direction as recognized by the international entities that observe us, including in terms of size and scope. Because I just mentioned the figures of our public deficit and when President HOLLANDE looked more than I did at the issue of stability, I think he meant that we need to improve the functioning mechanisms of the European financial system and the euro area, so that no one can benefit for free and therefore to prevent non-virtuous behaviors from being rewarded with stable, normal interest rates, but so that virtuous behaviors are not penalized by interest rates that are outside of normality.

THE PRESIDENT -- Before the eurozone crisis, interest rates on the sovereign debts of the different member countries of the zone were almost identical. It was the crisis that caused the disparities. Some can be justified given the situations of public finances, the risks on sovereign debts. Other disparities are not justified. When a country makes the effort to recover, manages to have a structural surplus, there should not be interest rate disparities compared to other countries considered virtuous for longer. So we do have a problem in the eurozone. And it is this problem that needs to be addressed, otherwise how can we convince public opinion of the effort to be made if there is no reward for the effort? This is a subject that we will need to include in the debate on stability.

Then on the forecasts that are made, frankly, it has been two and a half years that it has been regularly announced that the euro is saved and that often the same people announce that it will be threatened. I do not engage in speculation in every sense of the term. I believe that the duty of Europeans, those who are in the eurozone, is to preserve the single currency and to work to make it as strong as possible – I mean not necessarily at a high parity level but the most robust in relation to market shocks and as long as we have not put in place stable, durable, effective instruments, procedures, mechanisms with a sufficient amount, we will always be vulnerable. This is the time to do it, and there have been too many European Councils that have announced that the solution was found for me to be satisfied at the next European Council with half measures.

Thank you.