Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, notably on economic growth, regulation of the financial system, and cohesion of the Eurozone, in Los Cabos (Mexico) on June 20, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

20 June 2012 · G20 summit · Los Cabos, Mexico

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the G20 summit in Los Cabos, Mexico on June 20, 2012, outlining France's three key objectives for the meeting.
Main themes
Economic growth, eurozone cohesion and stability, financial system regulation, financial transaction tax, Greece and Spain banking crisis, G20 summit outcomes, tax havens and tax evasion, commodity price stability, youth employment, banking and budgetary union, IMF resources, trade and competitiveness
Duration
~29 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,517
82nd percentile
Sentences
185
87th percentile
Readability
57
80th percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
2.84
27th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

185 sentences in 58 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT -- I will tell you what I think of this G20 at this stage and what can be expected from it. Then I will answer your questions, that is the simplest. I have three objectives for this G20. The first is to put growth at the heart of our discussions. The second objective is to continue the work that has been underway for several years on the regulation of the financial system. The third objective is to send a message of stability to the market, particularly regarding the cohesion of the eurozone.

On these three objectives, I believe that the first, putting growth at the heart of our debates, has been achieved. Yesterday's meeting, which was lengthy, was mainly devoted to the observation that growth is slowing everywhere, not just in the eurozone or in Europe. China, which had very high double-digit growth, is now experiencing a slowdown, and there is also concern in the United States regarding year-end activity.

So, this is a realization that has been present for several weeks and has been confirmed. I had already, along with others, brought the objective of growth to the G8; it is now the case in the G20, with unanimity at least to acknowledge it. Regarding solutions, we must consider that countries with a current account surplus, meaning those with an overbalanced foreign trade, must make an effort to support domestic demand. And countries that are in deficit and facing competitiveness issues must make an effort to recover, not just their public funds, but their export capacity.

On growth still, we emphasized that the relativity of commodity prices, particularly oil, is an additional constraint. And a number of countries, particularly producers, have also recognized the need for stability in commodity prices for both producers and consumers.

Finally, on trade, on support for employment, particularly for youth employment, there has also been a great convergence of views for most countries, including emerging countries, to place greater emphasis on this social dimension of growth.

On the second objective, that is to say, the regulation of the financial system. There has been progress; we will see to what extent since the deliberations are not finished, particularly through the institutionalization of the Financial Stability Board, which could eventually become a global organization for finance. The fight against what are called tax havens has been reaffirmed once again; thirteen countries deemed non-cooperative have been identified. Similarly, large multinational companies, which you will easily recognize as practicing tax evasion, will surely be called to order and more closely scrutinized.

Regarding financial regulation, it is true that the financial transaction tax, which until now appeared in the G20 communiqués, is no longer there. This means that if we want to move forward on the financial transaction tax, we should not seek unanimity. It is impossible, or else we are in the realm of wishful thinking. It will be the responsibility of a number of countries that are convinced of the usefulness of this instrument and its yield to move forward either within Europe, through enhanced cooperation, or, and this is not exclusive, by establishing a common tool with countries from several continents. The question of where the corresponding revenue will go will then be raised. We will discuss this again; it will be part of the discussions we will also have at the European Council at the end of June.

I now come to the third subject, the third objective of this G20, stability. Eyes were turned towards the eurozone. This does not mean that other monetary areas are stable. But there are questions.

The first regarding Greece has been partially lifted. A government must be formed today. Messages have been sent from both sides: the Greeks' desire to remain in the eurozone and to respect commitments; the Europeans' willingness, at least mine, to support Greece.

The second regarding Spain, that is to say, a country that has a banking problem and received support from Europe last week. Again, there has been great coherence among the eurozone countries, and a mechanism will soon be put in place.

Finally, there is a question regarding economic and monetary union and the European Council at the end of June. Everyone is aware of their responsibility. Therefore, there will be measures on growth, in line with what the G20 will conclude, and measures on stability.

On integration, it will depend on what we put into the banking union and the budgetary union. And at each stage, it is normal that there is progress in integration.

But this G20 summit was not a European summit; it should not have been. It is a global summit with countries representing all continents. There was also a common will that emerged for this stability objective, particularly from countries that agreed to provide resources to the International Monetary Fund.

Beyond what was given as a figure. We spoke of 430 billion euros; it will be 456 or perhaps more. As the roundtable took place yesterday in this first meeting, each participant expressed their contribution, sometimes for small amounts, sometimes for larger sums, to endow the International Monetary Fund as much as possible.

I will also say the following to conclude. It is very important that we have mechanisms, a European fund called the European Stability Mechanism, which will take over from the EFSF, the International Monetary Fund. It is good that significant amounts are released; after that, it is a question of speed.

In the face of certain pressures, what makes a system effective is not its existence, but its ability to be implemented quickly. In any case, that is what I advocated during yesterday's meeting.

QUESTION -- Regarding European projects, has there been a rapprochement with Angela MERKEL? Have you met her already, or are we still in a form of power struggle as we have seen in recent days?

THE PRESIDENT -- I confirm that I met her. We were at the same table both in this first plenary meeting and then at dinner. And we were coherent because we had to affirm the will of Europeans to address all the questions arising in the eurozone. It is our responsibility; it is mine. We may have viewpoints that sometimes differ. What do we put on growth? What do we put on competitiveness? What structural reforms do we advance? But both Madame MERKEL and I are aware that Europe must have its own response. It must not be given to us from the outside, and that France and Germany, given their place in the European Union and their economic strength, must work together. There will therefore be several meetings. On the 22nd, we will meet in Rome, with four of us, and it will already be an opportunity to mark a number of convergences. There will, of course, remain a number of questions that will be submitted to the European Council; we will seek a compromise.

But I have the impression that on the growth package, things are progressing well.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, David CAMERON yesterday made an extremely sharp criticism of the decree on retirement at 60 and also of the 75% tax, arguing that it would roll out the red carpet for French companies to come and invest in Great Britain and pay their taxes. Do you consider this to be unfriendly or usual on his part?

THE PRESIDENT -- My responsibility at this summit is to ensure that there is confidence in Europe, coherence in the viewpoints expressed, and convergence in the actions to be taken. Therefore, I will not be distracted; I will not deviate in any way from the objectives I have set for myself because it is too important, because it is not just Europe that is watching us; it is the world that is concerned about the slowdown in growth, which may doubt a number of instruments. Nothing will make me deviate from my objective.

QUESTION -- In terms of competitiveness reforms. In terms of structural reforms, you have often been criticized for believing that growth could be financed by spending.

THE PRESIDENT -- Regarding these criticisms that may be made of France, I imagine they were made before I arrived. We have been here for barely a month, and even then, I would say a few days since a majority was largely found in the National Assembly. It is true that there are observations made about our competitiveness. The European Commission, in particular, has produced a report that is, shall we say, worrying regarding the loss of our market share over the past decade. Therefore, we will have to work on the recovery of our industry, our competitiveness. But this must again be done within an overall plan.

QUESTION -- Some, like Barack OBAMA, believe that we could help growth by revising the austerity plan imposed on Athens, while others, like Madame MERKEL, believe that we cannot relax, that there are commitments that have been made and that we must stick to them. Where do you stand?

THE PRESIDENT -- If I say in the center, I will be misunderstood. The Greeks have voted, and we were waiting for this moment. They said they wanted to remain in the eurozone and that they were ready to respect commitments. Europe must facilitate this process, not by calling into question the obligations that have been undertaken, but by ensuring that growth, that aid that may come from structural funds can be stimulated and mobilized. I position myself there. So, dialogue will begin; a coalition government will be formed. And it is with this government that will turn to Europe that the Union must work because we must now move quickly. The big issue for Europe is to move quickly. We are in this constant race between events, speculation, and political decision. Political decision must move faster than uncertainty.

QUESTION -- Has the victory of the left in France in the legislative elections allowed you to defend your positions or objectives more easily here?

THE PRESIDENT -- All participants congratulated me. This means they were informed of the situation arising from the French vote on Sunday. They were impressed by the scale of this majority and especially by the cohesion and coherence that could be given to the government and the President of the Republic. It matters to countries to know whether there is additional uncertainty related to a coalition that needs to be formed or whether there is stability through a solid and clear majority.

So, I answer you yes, it has been a support, and I thank the French people.

QUESTION -- A perhaps French-French question, do you wish for a woman to preside over the Assembly and be at the helm? Second question, to return to the attacks from Prime Minister Cameron, the fact that a British Prime Minister directly attacks one of your flagship measures and invites French companies to join Great Britain, is that not unfriendly? You who speak of the coherence of Europeans at the G20, is this coherence not undermined here?

THE PRESIDENT -- I will not answer you on the first question. On the second, everyone must be responsible for what they say; I am. And therefore, at a time when the cohesion of Europeans must be strong, I will do nothing that could undermine it. After that, regarding fiscal policies, we will make the comparison.

QUESTION -- There is also a power struggle between the American President and the German Chancellor. What is your analysis? Can we say that there is a winner? Is it austerity against demand that has won? Who won this match?

THE PRESIDENT -- I am not sure that we can speak of a match as is often done during European summits. What matters is to arrive at the right position. And in this G20, on growth, there has been a very great convergence. This does not mean that austerity in certain countries should not at some point be imposed when there have been considerable debts, but austerity cannot be the solution to find growth. That lesson has been given. If all monetary areas, all major countries practice austerity, it will not be possible to return to growth.

So this means that certain countries, either because they have restored their public funds over several years, or because they have trade surpluses, like China or major emerging countries that have reached a considerable economic level, must support their economic activities. The same goes for Europe. In Europe, if we want to achieve a return to balance for certain countries, others must not relax their discipline but stimulate their domestic demand.

So, you are asking me the question, is it through additional public spending that we will find growth? If it is about the spending of the State or the States, no.

But here, I come to the European debate at the end of June. What we need to imagine are instruments that allow us to mobilize savings, to mobilize funds, to increase the capital of a bank, in this case the European Investment Bank, so that there are investments that are sources of growth and virtuous in terms of their financing.

So there you have it for the match or the matches, there may be several matches, there are several partners, I think what matters is that there is a winning match for all participants.

QUESTION -- You mentioned the need to act quickly for the eurozone. Do you believe that guarantees were given from the perspective of G20 leaders during this Summit? Second question, regarding the outcome of the legislative elections in France, what lessons do you draw from it in terms of electoral analysis and the continuation of political operations in France?

THE PRESIDENT -- I will not speak about France here on the occasion of this Summit. I told you, the majority that was given for the government to conduct the policy of our country is a strong majority, a solid majority, a coherent majority, which moreover is not limited to the Socialist Party alone, and it is this majority that will allow for stability, confidence, and longevity. And this is an asset in economic competition.

Allow me to say this when I see many European countries or others that are governed by coalitions with permanent negotiations to determine whether this decision can be made or not. We were talking about Germany, Mrs. Merkel who is also in a coalition and moreover with an extremely demanding parliamentary system, often reminds us of this. This leads her to have discussions, even negotiations about her own position to pass, in particular, the budget. We have in France, through our institutions it is true, but also through the vote of the French, a capacity to act more quickly than others. That is what I wanted to say.

This allows me to link the situation in France and the position of the Head of State in major meetings, that of the G20, that of Rio, tomorrow and obviously the European Council.

QUESTION -- on the guarantees given...

THE PRESIDENT -- It is about speed. You know, what is difficult to understand for some countries is the functioning of Europe. This means that it is also difficult to understand even for Europeans and even for European heads of state and government. It is true, I said it, Europe with 27 and a Eurozone with 17, with decision-making processes that sometimes require treaty modifications, or decisions that must go through the European Parliament, this is called democracy, this is also called a process of integration. We must ensure in the coming months, this will also be an issue for the meeting at the end of June, that democracy is strengthened but at the same time that decision-making is facilitated. It is really the economic and monetary union that must find its political outlet.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, I would like to ask a question about your policy in France because it is also a flagship measure of your project. Some in the majority today doubt that it is possible to implement the right to vote for foreigners in local elections since you do not have the 3/5 majority and that a referendum would be risky. What do you think about it?

THE PRESIDENT -- No one imagined that we could have the 3/5 majority. I am willing to think that the French wanted to give me all the means to govern but to that extent, so the question is not altered by what happened last Sunday.

QUESTION -- You met President HU Jintao, it was the first time you saw each other, can you tell us how it went? And sorry to come back to this, but did you have a little chat with David CAMERON, did you speak? You said you had seen Mrs. MERKEL, that you were sitting at the same table. Was there a little more with Mr. CAMERON?

THE PRESIDENT -- I acknowledge the skill of your question and I want to commend this way of returning to the subject. So, I will talk to you about the Chinese President. It is not true that we met for the first time, our relationship was older. Eleven years ago, he remembered and so did I, we met in Paris. There you have it for the prior history of our relationship. I tell you everything.

Then regarding the quality of the exchange, yes, there was a willingness on both sides - given the arrival of a new president in France -- to continue and especially to amplify economic, commercial, industrial relations with China, as well as cultural and academic relations. The Prime Minister will be informed of this exchange, the Minister of Foreign Affairs will go to China soon and I will have the opportunity to go to China after we have continued this strategic dialogue.

QUESTION -- Did you discuss the issue of Syria?

THE PRESIDENT -- I mentioned the issue of Syria.

The Chinese President did not want to go into too much detail about Syria. We know China's traditional position of non-interference in the affairs of countries. On the other hand, we also talked about Iran since there is this negotiation in Moscow that is currently not evolving. But it was not the time to go into detail on international issues. It was really on the bilateral relationship that we spent the majority of the exchange.

QUESTION -- In discussions between Barack OBAMA and the main European leaders, is growth at the center of the debate?

THE PRESIDENT -- Growth was not a topic of debate, there was really a very strong convergence. From this point of view, the objective is achieved because the situation demands it and because positions, those of Mr. OBAMA, those that I can defend are widely heard. Emerging countries are even more sensitive because they, who thought they were invulnerable to what was happening in Europe and the United States, are finding that it affects their level of activity, notably China or Brazil and even India. The Prime Minister, who is a renowned economist, made a particularly clear intervention on this. It is not on growth that the exchange will take place with Barack OBAMA and the Europeans, it is rather what I was telling you about the mechanisms that allow us to combat speculation. It is not acceptable that countries that are making efforts like Italy, that are restoring their public accounts have interest rates that are around 5 points today on their sovereign debt. It is not acceptable that Spain, which has just received the promise of support, has interest rates around 7%, so it is on this that we must show a much faster capacity for intervention.

No, on this, I felt that there was a common will for the IMF to be used wherever it is called.

QUESTION -- The Americans and emerging countries consider that the role of the IMF is rather to intervene elsewhere than in developed countries.

THE PRESIDENT -- Especially when it is the emerging countries that provide a number of loans or capital. They also do this to modify the balance in decision-making within the IMF but it is true that the IMF is not there to bail out the Eurozone. It may happen that it associates itself with it, we saw it for Greece, we may see it for other countries, we will see, but that is not its vocation.

QUESTION -- To continue on Barack OBAMA, do you mean that he can be an ally for you to convince the Germans to let the central bank...

THE PRESIDENT -- I do not want to, unlike others, to put anyone in difficulty or in accusation, or in difference. You see, it is a state of mind, it is a nobility of soul, it is a sense of responsibility, so with Germany it would be, in my opinion, the worst method today to want to force. It is a work of persuasion that we must have and with the concern to respect the procedures.

Thank you.