Joint press conference of Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, Mr. Mario Monti, President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, President of the Spanish Government, and Mrs. Angela Merkel, Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, on the resolution of the Eurozone crisis, in Rome on June 22, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

22 June 2012 · Joint press conference on the resolution of the European Council (Rio+20 / European Council summit)

Context
Hollande addressed a joint press conference in Rome on June 22, 2012, with Merkel, Monti, and Rajoy ahead of the EU Council summit on the Eurozone crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone crisis resolution, economic growth agenda, budgetary discipline, job creation and investment, European banking union, financial market stabilization, EU growth package, structural reforms, European single market, financial transaction tax, long-term European integration
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,459
81st percentile
Sentences
169
85th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

169 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Today we have new instruments available, including for countries facing difficulties, which now have opportunities that did not exist before. However, we agree that what has been done so far is not enough. Especially regarding economic growth, greater stability in the euro area, and providing European citizens and markets with a clear image and medium- and long-term prospects for the European Union.

One point on which we all agree is the need to revive investment growth and job creation. We must achieve this through structural reforms at the national level to strengthen competitiveness, and we must also do this through a new agenda at the European level. I believe this is a step forward, a progress we have made in European culture and politics over the past few years. We acknowledge that growth cannot be solid if there is no budgetary discipline. On the other hand, budgetary discipline risks not being sustainable from an economic and political perspective if it is not accompanied by sufficient opportunities for growth and job creation. We are working to develop a program at the European level. We are working intensively on this as a member of the European Council, collaborating with President VAN ROMPUY and President BAROSO as well, and with all our partners to achieve concrete commitments.

At the next European Council, we will support a series of actions to revive the economy, investments, and jobs, to increase competition in Europe, and to better realize the European single market, which is a great asset that we have not yet fully exploited. We want there to be a set of packages for growth at the European level, amounting to about 1% of the EU's GDP. This means approximately 130 billion euros.

We are also working, within this vision of packages for growth, to take into account the quality of public spending composition that considers the value of certain investments. We have renewed our common commitment to respect sound macroeconomic discipline, which is essential for the stability and solidity of a financial system capable of supporting investments in the real economy and reviving employment. Increasing the capital of the EIB, more efficient use of community resources to strengthen growth and competitiveness, I will not provide you with an exhaustive list.

We also place great importance on the report being prepared by the group composed of President VAN ROMPUY, President BAROSO, President DRAGHI, and President JUNKER, on the long-term perspective of European economic integration. This is very important, as I mentioned, both to involve European citizens in such an important endeavor, but also to send a clear message to the markets about the irreversibility of this great project, which has so far been a tremendous success and is called "Euro." We also attach great importance to the mechanism for stabilizing financial markets, of course. I will stop there. I thank my colleagues for the contributions they made during this very constructive meeting, and I will now give the floor to the President of the French Republic, François HOLLANDE.

THE PRESIDENT -- First, I would like to thank President Mario MONTI for his invitation here to Rome and for his initiative. This meeting prepares for the European Council that will take place on June 28 and 29. This European Council must mark progress to restore confidence in the euro area and in Europe. And I believe that our meeting today has been useful in achieving this goal. First, we have come together on the essential growth package. A figure has been given: 1% of European GDP should be mobilized, with a timeline that should be as close as possible to the mechanisms we wish for, meaning we must be able to mobilize this funding in the shortest possible time. 1% of GDP is about 120 to 130 billion euros, and I think that is a good target.

Next, we have found common ground on a shared vision of economic and monetary union, on a roadmap that will require, at each stage of the Union—monetary union, banking union—tools that correspond to this desire to work together.

The third objective is to ensure that we fully utilize all the mechanisms that exist today to stabilize the markets, to restore confidence, and to combat speculation. Therefore, the European Council, if we achieve these objectives, can be an important step for Europe. We can add to this, I will continue to work in this direction, and I believe there is a good reception for this proposal, the financial transaction tax.

If I want to summarize what we have done today, we, the four main economies of the euro area, and without prejudging what other countries may decide for themselves, have affirmed common objectives and have given this growth perspective concrete content. We are also aware that we must send a sign of cohesion, a sign of consistency, a sign of stability, and a sign of solidarity, and I think that is what we have done today.

MADAM MERKEL -- Thank you, Mr. President of the Council, I would also like to thank you for this meeting you have organized here today. I think this meeting has truly come at the right time for the representatives of the four largest economies in the euro area. We want to make it clear that we are doing everything to ensure that the euro, our currency that we benefit from together, can withstand the future and remain, as it has been for 10 years, a "stable euro."

To achieve this, we must overcome a number of problems. Some things have already been done. Countries have already undertaken reforms, and above all, we have developed common instruments of solidity and instruments of solidarity.

Now, in light of the current debate, we need to address the issue of growth and employment. We must tackle these themes, since we have first dealt with the budget pact and thus with fiscal stability, we must therefore truly build for the future more solidity, and I agree with the 1% of European GDP that must be invested in growth, an additional investment. I think this is truly the right signal, the one we need.

I am pleased that the four people present here have said that we are calling for the introduction of a financial transaction tax, because the citizens of our countries feel that it is the financial crisis that has caused the crisis, and that we are not yet sufficiently equipped to fight it, and we must solve the problem in the long term. This is a message we want to send today. We must come closer at the political level, especially in the euro area since we have a single currency. When you have a single currency, you need to conduct a coherent policy.

This is a lesson we have learned from the last two years, and there is what I call political union. We want to work towards a closer political union. Herman VAN ROMPUY, José BAROSO, and others will make proposals on this, but the four countries present here, and Germany certainly, want to contribute so that these themes can be addressed in our countries and so that we can say: Europe is coming closer. The lesson to be learned from the crisis is not that we need less Europe but more Europe. Thank you for allowing us to send this signal here today, and thank you for your hospitality.

MR. RAJOY -- Thank you very much and hello to everyone. I would first like to thank President Mario MONTI for his initiative, for his welcome, for his hospitality. Thank you, Mr. MONTI. As those who preceded me have pointed out, this meeting has been very pleasant; we have sincerely addressed the themes that concern our countries and the entire European Union. Since almost everything has been said, I will simply highlight five themes on which I have noticed significant agreement, and I will conclude with three comments that are particularly important to me.

First, I note that there is agreement on the need to control public deficits, not to let public debt grow too much in our respective countries. Second, there is agreement on making structural reforms at the national level to improve flexibility and competitiveness in our economy, and thus to achieve stronger economic growth. Third, everyone has mentioned proposals to be made at the European Council. That is, the urgency of implementing structural reforms at the European Union level. Fourth, all participants in this meeting expressed their willingness to trigger all necessary mechanisms to achieve financial stability in Europe. And finally, we have made an important bet for the future of Europe. We want more Europe, more economic union, banking union, and fiscal union.

I would like to make the three comments that I believe summarize this meeting today. First, we have all noted that the euro is now irreversible. It is the most important project that Europeans have launched in recent years. Second, there was agreement among all to say that we will implement all necessary mechanisms to achieve financial stabilization of the euro area. And finally, we have all committed to better ensure greater European integration at the banking, economic, fiscal, and political levels. Thank you very much.

MR. MONTI -- I have asked the spokesperson of the Italian government to lead the question-and-answer session.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, given the message that has emerged today, expressed by the four powers that represent the majority of European GDP, what can we expect from the conclusions of the next summit in Brussels?

MR. MONTI -- When you say "President," that applies to several people!

QUESTION -- No, I am addressing you.

MR. MONTI -- The European Council, we are not alone there. There are us, and there are others. It is a different entity. We are here to actively contribute to building a strong, progressive consensus that is conducive to growth and stability. And the European Council is under the leadership of its president, Herman VAN ROMPUY.

We have considered that if four countries as important as ours, and also different in terms of their situation, find a line of convergence among themselves, this could greatly contribute to creating a consensus at the European Council. This is therefore something we offer to Herman VAN ROMPUY and our colleagues, on the eve of this major meeting.

We hope that the work done over these months will bear fruit, because let us not forget that each of the heads of state and government present here has, with their government, advanced Europe.

Europe is something important, solid. Certainly, Europe is not always very dynamic in the short term. We must help it evolve, and therefore after the contribution we have made today, we expect the conclusions of the European Council to be even stronger and more credible than those of previous Councils, regarding a growth perspective for the European Union. We want these conclusions to set a clear line for medium- and long-term economic, financial, and banking integration, along with certain elements of political integration.

And we hope that the conclusions of the European Council, and the solidarity that will create the conditions for them, will reinforce the expectations of financial markets and will help them understand that the euro is here to stay and that we truly want it.

QUESTION -- A question addressed to the President of the French Republic: Mr. President, you have put growth on the European agenda, but you have had to push back eurobonds to a 10-year perspective. And you are preparing a drastic plan to reduce the deficit. In the end, doesn't German-style austerity end up prevailing over growth? And furthermore, regarding European integration, are you ready to accept some loss of sovereignty?

THE PRESIDENT -- You are always better informed than I am! I consider that eurobonds should be a perspective, and not in 10 years. As integration progresses, eurobonds will be a useful instrument for Europe. And I will continue to work in this direction and to frame this mechanism within a perspective.

Secondly, growth: who could have said, just a few weeks ago, that it would be so much on the agenda of a European Council? We met at the G8 (Mario MONTI, Angela MERKEL, and I were present), then we had the G20, and before that, there was an informal European Council... And growth, given the situation, has become the priority.

Does this mean that states must give up their budgetary discipline objectives? Some have been pursuing this policy for a long time and are not worse off for it. Others are making considerable and sometimes difficult efforts for public opinion.

As for me, I believe that there is a need for budgetary discipline. In France too. This means that it has not been done as much as it should have been until now. And I will not comment on French policy, at least not the past one.

But wanting growth is precisely to ensure that budgetary discipline is not austerity. I am against austerity. And at the same time, I am aware that we must send a message of coherence and stability, thus of confidence. This is what we are doing today, and this is what the European Council must measure. Its role is both to send a very concrete message of support for growth. 130 billion euros can be mobilized. It is also to send a strong message of full utilization of stability mechanisms. Finally, it is to define a medium-term vision for Europe, allowing for solidarity of which eurobonds are an illustration.

Sovereignty concessions will be considered based on the elements of solidarity that we can find. There cannot be a transfer of sovereignty if there is no improvement in solidarity and coherence.

QUESTION -- Have concrete decisions been made regarding Brussels, and have you set certain indications on your part?

MRS. MERKEL -- As we said, we have prepared the European Council. We are four here, and of course we will introduce our ideas into the debate at the Council, we will discuss them with our partners, and there is a good chance that others will consider our opinion reasonable. But it is important that the President of the Council, Herman VAN ROMPUY, knows what the member states think, what we are ready to do, what we can contribute. For example, regarding the increase in the capital of the EIB, national parliaments must weigh in. And that is why we are contributing to growth.

I think the most important message today is this: we say that growth and sound finances are two sides of the same coin. Sound finances are a condition, but this condition is not enough if there is no growth that allows for job creation. And this is one of our most complex problems in Europe, and we hope to make progress on this point, and I emphasize that the four representatives here have said they could consider introducing a financial transaction tax.

And then, the third message is that we need more Europe for this. We need solidarity and, on the other hand, competitiveness, cooperation, cohesion, and when solidarity is necessary, there must also be control.

Often Europe has had in the past a stability and growth pact that it did not respect. The problem is not that we do not have rules in Europe; the problem is that we have lost trust because we ourselves too often have not respected our rules. And if we succeed, and for that we need more Europe, the good news today is that everyone is now committed to moving together in this direction.

THE PRESIDENT -- I will respond according to an old French tradition to a question that was not asked of me: Angela MERKEL speaks of the financial transaction tax; it is true that we agree on this tax and that it can only be considered in the form of enhanced cooperation. And I will ensure with my partners that the European Council allows us to pursue this enhanced cooperation so that we can implement the financial transaction tax as quickly as possible.

We are discussing this right now.

MRS. MERKEL -- The finance ministers already discussed this yesterday, and we will continue this at the Council.

QUESTION -- Question for Chancellor MERKEL and President RAJOY. Do you agree that the rescue funds should be used to buy bonds in troubled countries, and if so, will there be conditions, and what would those conditions be? And what would the main lines be? And if the answer is negative, why couldn't the European Central Bank inject money directly into the banks, when France and Italy, Madrid, OBAMA, and the IMF have already asked it to do so?

MR. RAJOY -- The last part of the question was not directed at me directly but rather the first. I believe that at this time the Fund can buy debt on the markets under the conditions that were decided at the time, so I have nothing to add. To say that it is an objective reality, it is the ESM that can do it, and the ECB can do it in exceptional circumstances.

In any case, I believe it is not worth going into details. But the most important thing we decided today, and I already mentioned it earlier, is that we all committed to using all necessary mechanisms to achieve financial stability in the European Union. This outcome is very satisfactory for me; it is a strong commitment to the irreversibility of the euro, and I believe that everyone now understands where we are headed. Moreover, we have decided to move towards what could be called greater overall integration.

That is why I leave this meeting very satisfied: for the people who were with me, for all of you, and for having been here in Rome, the most beautiful city in the world.

THE PRESIDENT -- That is debatable!

MRS. MERKEL -- In any case, it is a very beautiful city!

I would like to respond to the second part of the question. It is not about allowing or not allowing something. The ESM, the EFSF, are mechanisms of solidarity. Each state contributes to it through its guarantees, and this allows us to help countries in difficulty. But I said that responsibility and control must go hand in hand. That is to say, for the taxpayer in Germany, France, or Italy, I must be sure that there is a guarantor. And that is the Spanish state, because it is the Spanish state that can tell its banks: "you must exchange this or that, you must do this or that differently." If I lend money to a Spanish bank (or to another bank; I do not want to emphasize Spain), I cannot tell it what it must change in its behavior. I am the German Chancellor; I am not responsible for a bank. And so this is not possible under the treaties. It is not that I do not want to do it, but the treaties are written that way. The states are the partners in these treaties, and it is under these conditions that we created the EFSF and ESM funds, and it is in this way that we will continue.

So, you speak of President OBAMA: but we are -- the European Union -- a structure that exists nowhere else in the world. And then we are 17 with a common currency, but we have 17 parliaments, each with its state sovereignty. We have given up certain elements of sovereignty to Brussels, and now we must create the political structures that go with our single currency. And as the French President said, we must be able to do more things together, and therefore, I repeat, control and responsibility must go hand in hand.

MR. MONTI -- I think the time allotted for this press conference has ended. I would like to make two observations to conclude.

First, if the insistence on rules in European construction may seem exaggerated to you, I invite you not to forget that, nearly ten years ago in 2003, Germany and France, with the authorization and complicity of the Italian Presidency, had deviated from the euro rules, and it took almost ten years to regain credibility that had not been undermined by Greece or Portugal but by two of the most powerful countries in the eurozone.

Second point: today everyone wished for more Europe. And this is manifested today in Rome, where the European Constitution was signed, and I am very grateful to my colleagues who, by their presence today in Rome to discuss together new measures for the construction of Europe, have shown, once again, that all roads lead to Rome.

Thank you.