Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the measures taken to resolve the Eurozone crisis and on budgetary policy in France, in Brussels on June 29, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

29 June 2012 · European Council summit on the Eurozone crisis · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference in Brussels on June 29, 2012, following the European Summit to outline measures agreed upon to resolve the Eurozone crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone crisis resolution, growth pact, banking union and supervision, financial transaction tax, stability mechanisms, EFSF and ESM instruments, European Investment Bank recapitalization, structural funds, economic and monetary union, project bonds, Spain and Italy debt concerns, European Council outcomes
Duration
~51 min
94th percentile
Words
6,060
94th percentile
Sentences
271
94th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
10.6
27th percentile
Syntax
2.98
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

271 sentences in 67 paragraphs

Good evening,

I had three objectives in coming to this European Summit, which was announced, as often, as a summit of all dangers or all hopes.

The first objective was to prioritize growth. The second objective was to have the eurozone adopt measures capable of having rapid effects on the markets regarding states that were seen as threatened. And the third objective was to establish a medium-term framework for deepening the economic and monetary union.

I believe that this summit, which was lengthy, was able to result in a comprehensive and coherent agreement.

First, there is the growth pact, which in my eyes was meant to complement the budgetary pact. This is a decision made by the heads of state and government. It is a decision that will have consequences in a short timeframe since the European Parliament, the European Commission, and the European Council, in an institutional compromise, have decided to implement it quickly. This represents 1% of GDP, 120 to 130 billion euros, but above all, this pact introduces new instruments. The first is what we call "project bonds," which will be intended to be generalized across the entire European Union. The second instrument was already known, which is the recapitalization of the European Investment Bank, which will have a strong leverage effect. And finally, there is the mobilization of structural funds that had not been engaged or consumed. This is the first achievement of this European Council.

There is a second achievement that fits into the logic of growth, which is that for at least 30 years, there has been an inability for the European Union to decide where the seat of the competent jurisdiction in this area would be regarding patents. And we have found a solution; the seat of this jurisdiction will be in Paris. The first president will be French, even though there was, as in any compromise, the acceptance that Germany would keep one chapter out of eight for one of its local jurisdictions and England two out of eight. So that was what I wanted to put at the heart of the discussion, and it found itself at the heart of the decision, the growth pact.

Another very important achievement of this Council, even if it was not the longest to elaborate, is the decision made in enhanced cooperation to create a tax on financial transactions, and a date has even been set, meaning that by the end of the year, this tax will be defined and implemented.

The third objective was to introduce stability mechanisms. And there was first progress in what we call the banking union, but at this stage, let us call the step that has been taken, banking supervision. A timeline has been set, and by the end of 2012, this supervision will be a reality. It will allow for the direct recapitalization of banks as soon as the European Central Bank has carried out this supervision. This new step will allow for better control of the European financial system, but we have gone further or more precisely faster, particularly regarding Spain, where direct recapitalization is planned without increasing the debt of the Spanish state. For states that, like Italy, but Italy is not the only country concerned, have made efforts to restore their public accounts, who have met a number of commitments and who could call upon mechanisms like the EFSF or the ESM, there too, a decision has been made that will allow for the full use of these instruments without imposing additional adjustments on these states, provided they have respected what is called the country recommendation. And that is what I wanted, for the instruments to be fully, quickly, and effectively used to respond to market movements. And I note that the European Central Bank has agreed to intervene as an agent of the EFSF and the ESM in the markets, which will also be a powerful means of controlling a number of movements.

The objective was also to have a roadmap for the economic and monetary union; it is displayed. Around, moreover, a formula that I myself stated here, in any case, which only commits France, it is solidarity-based integration. We can progress; at each step, there must be additional solidarity.

That is the assessment I draw from this European Council. An important step has been taken, significant progress has been made. Priority has been given to growth. New instruments have been developed: "project bonds." And for the states that decide, the tax on financial transactions. New measures have been decided: the recapitalization of the European Investment Bank, the mobilization of structural funds. And effective interventions in the markets allowing for stability have also been found. For all these reasons, I believe we have a coherent framework: growth pact, banking union, budgetary union, support mechanisms, and the willingness to deepen the economic and monetary union.

I can now answer your questions.

Q - Mr. President, I would like you to explain to us a little bit about what happened during the night, if you will, because we had the impression at the end of the night, as external observers, that there was indeed an agreement that had been reached, particularly regarding Spain and Italy, Mr. Monti echoed this. And then since this morning, particularly Ms. Merkel seems to have a slightly different view of things. Can you tell us what your own view is on this agreement? Thank you.

R - During the night - and it was long - decisions were made and a communiqué was drafted and approved. This communiqué was not called into question in the early morning, nor even at lunchtime. It was simply recalled that this was done within the framework of the orientations and mechanisms that are now known, EFSF, ESM, and with the procedures that Europe already has in the eurozone. I believe that when we achieve this compromise, everyone must support it. Both those who can benefit from it and those who may have to answer for it before their Parliament, this is the case for Ms. Merkel, she went before the Bundestag to have the ESM adopted. And so we must show cohesion, and that was the case, including at the end of the morning when we recalled what I just said, the instruments, all the instruments, the procedures, all the procedures, and the willingness to implement them flexibly and effectively. And I think, I give you a personal position, no one should say "I won or I lost." What was at stake was Europe; it is Europe that has won. And it is the eurozone, in particular, that has been strengthened and reinforced, and that was the only objective.

Q - During your presidential campaign, you emphasized your objective, your ambition, to renegotiate this treaty; today, what assessment do you draw regarding this objective from this summit? And then a second question, how to interpret the coincidence between the announcements of significant spending cuts in France at the ministerial level, 7% for next year, and this summit; is it a pure coincidence in light of the debates obviously on budgetary rigor?

R - First, I announced during the presidential campaign that I wanted to renegotiate what had been decided in order to include what was not there, growth and stability measures as well as a medium-term vision. I believe that this summit has allowed for this renegotiation to be achieved. That is why it was long. That is why the eurozone worked all night and on a timeline that was not planned. And that is why this summit was very important. Certainly, regarding growth, we had already done the work for several days, but on stability measures, on banking supervision, we have made very significant progress. Not everything is complete yet. The steps of the monetary and economic union are not yet implemented, but I believe that Europe has been reoriented as it should have been.

You then ask me if there is a link between the framework letters that have been sent for the preparation of the 2013 budget and what we decided here. I must recall that during the presidential campaign, I always said that we had a trajectory for the recovery of public finances: 3% by the end of 2013 and balance by the end of 2017. We actually had a debate between my opponent and myself about whether it was 2017, which I stated, or 2016, which he claimed. I said 2017. I also knew that growth would be affected by austerity policies. That is the case. The growth figures that have been made public do not stem from my own actions. I remind you that I was only invested on May 15. The growth figures that have been revealed pertain to the first quarter. The Court of Auditors, which will issue its report, will do so regarding the execution of the budget on May 1 or June 1. Therefore, the preparation of the 2013 budget must necessarily take into account the commitments I made in this context of slowed growth, which I hope will not be a sustainable environment. That is why there are growth measures that are decided at the European level.

But I will also stay on this subject regarding the reductions. The 7% is not a 7% budget cut; it is the operating credits that have been planned at that level. I believe there are indeed savings to be found without it being through mechanical rules. I am against the rule of one out of two for the non-replacement of civil servants retiring or measures that would appear simply as the result of mechanics or automatism. Regarding the staffing of the public service, there is no change from what I said during the campaign since I spoke of the creation of positions in a number of ministries, particularly National Education, Justice, and security with the police and the national gendarmerie. I remind you that one in two civil servants works in education. With the objective of stabilizing the staffing of the public service, what we will create in a number of ministries, we will not be able to create in other ministries. There will necessarily be efforts to be made in other ministries, but the objective is the stability of public service staffing, whereas until now it was the rule of not replacing one civil servant out of two, thus reducing staffing. For those who do not see the change, I am ready to give particular lessons.

Q - Mr. President, do you confirm that you will indeed have the budgetary pact ratified at the French level soon, the first question of course? You also talk about the tax on financial transactions by the end of the year; with whom? How many countries? And who will not be involved? And with what disadvantages?

R - To make enhanced cooperation, we need to be nine. I must say that Ms. Merkel is committed to this enhanced cooperation. She affirmed it in her own country, confirmed it in Rome, and maintained it strongly in the discussion during this summit. We will do it with the countries that are willing. We are in the process of finding them, and we will move quickly since the European Council has authorized us to make this enhanced cooperation. The more of us there are, the better it will be; we will also have to define the base of this tax and its rate. We do not have time to lose, and it will be submitted to the French Parliament at the same time as all the other texts.

What I will propose is that all decisions concerning Europe be submitted to Parliament: the growth pact, banking supervision if necessary, the tax on financial transactions, and the budgetary pact. The whole will be submitted to Parliament because there is coherence, because there is a global agreement, because we have everything that can allow Parliament to make its choice without being asked to take one direction over another. And there will be a medium-term vision of what we want to do in Europe.

Q - You just said that you would submit this package of decisions to Parliament; it is practically complete. Can you tell us when you will submit it to Parliament?

R - When the texts are ready, they are not all ready yet. I will present them when all the texts are technically ready within a timeframe that will not be long, but that requires having them all. That is why it is also important that the European Parliament - I have discussed this with its president - can also, for its part, vote quickly on the European legislative texts concerning the growth pact. As for the growth pact, it is a decision of the heads of state and government that has legal force.

Q - To return to the question of future budget management, you will soon have the report from the Court of Auditors, and we learned this morning from INSEE that French debt had reached a peak of 89% of GDP; what is the extent of the efforts you will ask of the French?

R - Yes, you are right to remind us that we have revealed a figure that, once again, is that of the end of my predecessor's term, which means that our public debt is approaching 90% of national wealth, that is to say the figure I indicated during the campaign, showing that I have forecasts that are almost better than the official information I had as a candidate. This does not change the objectives I have set; it makes them even more necessary, that is to say, to position ourselves on the trajectory of reducing deficits by 2017, allowing for balance by that date.

I am not engaging in a reduction of the debt for European reasons; it is not based on a budgetary pact since it has not been voted on. It is based on the objective of reducing France's debt, so that we are not exposed to reluctant markets for our sovereign debt financing, and so that the state budget is not affected by a rise in interest charges. In this regard, I do not know what the medium-term effect of our European Council will be, but it is not without consequence on the debt burden. You see, this figure that has been made public does not change our perspective but ultimately makes it even more necessary.

Q - Mr. President, this morning we perceive from some commentators in Germany quite negative reactions or at least hesitations on the theme: "after all, the Chancellor has somewhat let things happen," do you not fear that there will be a kind of backlash against France, which would have participated in this strategy to bend Germany, and that German public opinion ultimately accepts poorly what is sometimes presented as a defeat?

R - I am really concerned that there are not those who shout "victory" and those who would have to justify some kind of defeat. What happened is a compromise, it is a dynamic, and Mrs. Merkel, like others, actively participated in this search and this desire to strengthen and consolidate the eurozone, and it is because France and Germany - including during the night - were together that we succeeded. It was not a pressure from one side to the other; it was a common conviction that we could, without calling into question the treaties, without having to invent other instruments, implement them effectively. That is why Mrs. Merkel can go before her Parliament and say: "I did not change the texts, I did not go beyond my mandate." We will commit to mobilizing the instruments in the service of stability, and I can go before Parliament and before the French people to say: here, I made commitments, I have kept them. I think that is what allows Europe to move forward, and I have ensured that we can all hold the same discourse, that is to say, that of strengthening the eurozone.

If Spain and Italy - we talked about it last night, since we spent part of our time together - exerted pressure during part of the night, they did not do it simply to obtain words in a communiqué; it was for the entire eurozone to emerge strengthened because it is not simply in relation to Spain or Italy that we must work, it is in relation to the credibility of the eurozone, and if we had only found solutions, I would say expedients, in response to emergencies, we would not have, in my opinion, achieved our objective.

Q - You spoke upon arrival of immediate measures so that this acts immediately. However, most measures will actually take effect rather towards the end of the year. Do you not fear that, ultimately, for the markets, there will be an effect that we see today and that will fade quite quickly? Regarding the measure that was adopted during the night, it specifically addresses Spain. When should we expect it to expand to other countries, and in such cases, will the 500 billion fund for the ESM be sufficient because if it were to concern all the banks in Europe - and we see the size of the banks in Italy - that seems quite little in the end? One last question briefly: Mrs. Merkel reiterated in her press conference her absolute opposition to eurobonds; are you disappointed by that?

R - What will be the effects of this summit on the real economy first? It will take time for growth measures to be implemented and create additional activity. We have therefore ensured that the European Parliament and the European Commission accelerate the pace of execution.

On financial measures, stability measures, there are instruments that can be activated very quickly. The recapitalization of Spanish banks is underway or will take place. The mechanisms have now been clarified so that this does not weigh on Spanish sovereign debt, at least in a medium-term perspective, and so that it is under conditions that can avoid a privilege through the ESM since it will be the conditions of the EFSF that will be extended. This will have a rapid effect.

Then, if states - we mentioned Italy but it could be others - that have met all their commitments and also comply with the Commission's recommendations, what we call the "country recommendation," want to move towards instruments, they will be implemented immediately.

Everything is being done to ensure that there is speed in execution for both growth and stability. However, for banking supervision, to your second question, we will have to wait until the end of the year, even if there will be an interim report, I believe in October, for the European Central Bank on the eurozone - I emphasize on the eurozone - to ensure this banking supervision and allow, at that moment, to possibly recapitalize other banks than the Spanish banks.

Finally, on eurobonds, this will integrate into future solidarities, that is to say, as we move closer on the budgetary level, there will be a need for a European treasury and therefore, at that moment, eurobonds. This is a perspective; it could not be decided today, but it is included in the report of the four presidents.

Q - On banking union, there is no doubt that the future supervisory authority will be the European Central Bank. If that is the case, what will be the authority responsible for restructurings? It cannot be the European Central Bank since it is a political question. Are you going to create a second authority? And what about countries that are not in the eurozone, since they will not be subject to the ECB? On banking union, did you discuss the issue of a European deposit guarantee or has that been postponed?

R - On banking supervision, it must first be within the eurozone, and it is the European Central Bank that will lead it because it is equipped for that, because it can rely on each of the national banks, the Bank of France in our country, and everyone has a bank that reports to the European Central Bank; that is the European system.

It is the European Central Bank that is best equipped, best armed to carry out this banking supervision. Will this apply to all banks? My answer is yes. I am in favor, and we will still have to discuss it, but that is rather the general trend; it must be supervision over all banks. Why all banks? Because if some escape it, then we will find ourselves in the Spanish case where bad banks chase good ones, to borrow a famous law of monetary economics, Gresham's law, where bad money drives out good. We must take all the banks in the eurozone with supervision from the Central Bank.

Do the other 27 countries want banking supervision? It is not certain, and it may not be the European Central Bank since they are in the single market. Moreover, David Cameron reminded us that the 27 - at least for those who were not in the eurozone - wanted to be within the rules of the single market. We will see at 27 the regulatory authority for banks.

Then, you ask whether it is up to the Central Bank to carry out restructurings? No, it will indeed be up to another authority; we will see, but this time it will be more political.

Then, the question of deposit guarantees can only be resolved once there is banking supervision, so for 17, within the framework of the eurozone, and once we have made progress in the Union because deposit guarantees imply that each country guarantees not only the deposits in its own territory but everywhere in Europe. You see, we were talking about Mrs. Merkel; she would have conditions for ratification, if we took this provision, which would probably be difficult to meet. We will have to make progress on this; it is the necessary step, hence my idea of solidary integration. If we want integration, we need solidarity. Integration is banking union; solidarity is deposit guarantees. Who pays for the deposit guarantees? That too will need to be determined. Are they the states or are they the banks? That will be the subject of future discussions; I apologize for being so technical.

Q - Mr. President, still regarding Mrs. Merkel, she emphasized a few minutes ago that your cooperation during this summit had been good, particularly on the European patent and on the growth pact. In the context of this good cooperation, are you ready to lift your reservations on Mr. Schäuble's candidacy for the head of the Eurogroup, or do you consider that ultimately the nationality of this minister is a handicap in Europe for the eurozone?

R - Our cooperation has been useful since we found ourselves on many points, after a lot of work, after a lot of efforts, discussions. It was also necessary to lift a number of uncertainties or ambiguities. We found ourselves on growth - that was not so obvious. We found ourselves on the financial transaction tax - even if the pressure was not only external, there is also internal pressure related to the political situation in Germany. We also found ourselves on the discussion about measures to strengthen the eurozone with, as we know, starting points that were not necessarily identical. That was also the explanation for the result of the summit, but perhaps differently from the past. It is not France and Germany that arrived with a solution; it is France and Germany that, along with others, contributed to solutions. France and Germany playing their role, but the other countries, the European institutions as well, and that is probably why we were also long and far.

Then, on the Eurogroup, it was supposed to be normally on the agenda, and it has been postponed to the next Eurogroup meeting; therefore, I cannot commit on that. There is currently no discussion that has been initiated between France and Germany or between France and other countries; we will therefore have to decide on that. One idea among others - but one that had rather been favored before this summit, but I do not want to commit to it because I know there are also situations of domestic politics - would have been to extend Mr. Juncker for a few months, but for now, nothing has been decided. So it was a hypothesis that existed before the summit, but it assumes that Mr. Juncker himself wishes it. For now, we have not gone further.

Q - I would like to understand where France stands regarding the budgetary pact. Earlier, you said it had not been voted on, but if I understood correctly, the growth pact adds to the budgetary pact, so concretely what does that mean? What will France do about it?

R - I explained it. The government will present to Parliament the entire European package with the budgetary pact, the growth pact, the financial transaction tax, and the banking supervision measures. There is a global package; there is a coherent framework. Then, it will be up to the parliamentarians to decide.

Q - Mr. Mario Monti stated - last night - that it was not his intention at this stage to call on the mechanism that had been agreed upon during the night? Do you find that to be a fair assessment, or would you be inclined to urge Mr. Monti to request the activation of the mechanism? Can this mechanism - since you have pointed out that it could serve other countries - serve, for example, Ireland and Portugal, countries that will soon exit assistance and have made a lot of efforts? Is this also an exit door for these countries?

R - Yes, it is a provision, a mechanism that is primarily respectful of the treaties we know and that applies to any country that is not in a situation of imbalance and therefore requires a program of specific adjustments, a stability program, and you mentioned two that would exit this program and would need to resort to this instrument. They could do so without needing to undergo another program as long as they have respected what we call the country recommendation.

As for Mr. Monti's decision to resort to it or not, that is his freedom. He can do it or he can choose not to, he may not feel the need, it all depends on what the interest rates will be. Often, when an instrument is defined, it can have a consequence, which is not to be used. If the announcement of this instrument causes interest rates to fall, then why resort to it? But it still needs to exist for interest rates to decrease, and that is perhaps the bet of what we decided in this European Council, to set in motion mechanisms so that they may not be used but are powerful enough that, if a state uses them, they can be effective. That is the whole balance, I would say all the intelligence; one must never presume, but in any case, the whole issue of these mechanisms: rapid, effective, flexible, and deterrent.

Q - We know France's reluctance regarding the continuation of integration, but you committed today to more integration. When will you explain to the French the need to submit the French budget to Brussels' control, for example? How will you explain this new federal leap to the French people?

R - The French budget has always been subject to binding rules, the stability pact. What was often the practice is that France escaped these constraints and there was not the necessary discipline. We must respect more the rules that we accept from Europe.

As for the federal leap, we are not there yet. We have to implement what exists today, and when I see the reluctance of many countries to go further, I tell myself that France is often ahead. We have to make budgetary choices that are those that France decides sovereignly. Let me explain: if we want to reduce our deficits, it is not because we want to submit to Europe, which moreover gives a vision of Europe that is extremely depressing and negative. We want to reduce our deficits because, as was recalled earlier, the level of public debt in relation to national wealth has reached a dangerous point, dangerous in terms of the burden it can represent, also dangerous because it can create vulnerability for us.

Q - Mr. President, precisely to continue on this question, in the package that you will submit to the French Parliament, the ratification of the budget treaty, in the budget treaty, there is a very specific article that involves the introduction into the internal law of each country of a golden rule of constitutional value. Will this be part of the package you submit to Parliament? Will you request a meeting of Congress to amend the Constitution and bring it into compliance with this article of the treaty?

R - Here too, I committed during the campaign not to put in the French Constitution a rule that would set the pace for reducing deficits. That is not how I conceived the deficit reduction project. On the other hand, we will have a budget programming law voted on, perhaps of an organic nature, but we will have a budget programming law voted on to restore the balance of our public finances.

Regarding the amendment of the Constitution, we will ask the Constitutional Council what needs to be done, but our idea is not to integrate the programming law into the Constitution; the programming law by definition is a law.

Q - A week ago, you reacted to press reports announcing a 2.5% reduction in civil servants, and you called them implausible. Was that meant to be taken ironically, which was not necessarily understood, and if not, has what was implausible become reality with the framework letters sent to the various ministers?

R - Precisely, that is not the reality since there will be stability...

Q - That is a figure that your Prime Minister included in his calendar.

R - I will be as precise as he was. The number of civil servants will not decrease overall. Am I clear? The number of civil servants will not decrease, but as we will create jobs in a number of ministries: education, justice, police, gendarmerie, well, in other ministries we will not replace all the civil servants who retire since we must maintain this stability of numbers. That, in some ministries, overall, it may decrease by 2.5%, in other ministries, it will progress as well since, in 2013, there will be stability in the number of civil servants. I cannot be clearer; if you still have implausibilities to clarify, I am ready to respond. So, where a norm has been set, it is for the other ministries that are not prioritized. However, those that are prioritized represent in the civil service more than the majority since it is education, police, gendarmerie, where there are, if I may say, the large battalions. So your question was very useful and pertinent. I thank you for asking it.

Q - Beyond the technical aspect of the interventions that were decided today, I noticed in your press conference last night, strong understandings regarding the problems of Spain and Italy, and ultimately the final agreement seems to take these problems and positions into account. Do you believe that from a political point of view, this summit is characterized by a new balance at the European level? Will this summit be perceived in the coming months as a summit that produced a new political and European balance, particularly in the relations between France and Germany and in the relations between France and southern Europe?

R - France is a bridge. It allows for gathering through its geographical position, its economic position as well, its political position, and the weight of history. And so it should not contribute to confrontation; it should promote rapprochement, particularly between northern Europe and southern Europe. It happens that France is both in the north and in the south, which helps. Then, I think that Ms. Merkel and I have made sure to prepare this summit not just between the two of us - I received her, it was Wednesday evening - but also among four, even more. I must commend the role of the President of the European Council, Mr. Van Rompuy, the President of the Commission, Mr. Barroso, and the President of the European Parliament, Mr. Martin Schulz, who was very helpful in showing that the Parliament was entirely at the service of Europe for the implementation of growth measures. It is this method that allowed us to find not a new balance but a new result. Furthermore, there are good personal relations with Mr. Monti and even with Mr. Rajoy, who is not of the same political sensitivity, but we also had a shared awareness.

I insisted, as did Ms. Merkel, on the stakes of the European Council. The stake of the European Council at the outset was growth, and I could have stopped there saying, "Listen, I wanted growth to be set as the first priority of the European Council, there are 130 billion euros, mission accomplished, we can end the European Council." Here, it must be said that Spain and Italy reminded us of the reality; the stake of this European Council was to strengthen the eurozone, not simply to come to the aid of Spain and possibly Italy, it was to show that the eurozone was coherent enough, organized, and capable of implementing instruments to be in a new relationship with the markets. This awareness took place all night; it was long because we had to find the right effectiveness in the use of these instruments. And the President of the European Central Bank, in his place and in complete independence, also stated his responsibility and availability.

Q - A question precisely about the instruments, about the flexibility granted to the use of the EFSF. How far does it go in the sense that until now unanimity applied, so is this principle of unanimity lifted?

R - So the EFSF is still unanimity. The EFSF had an advantage and a disadvantage. The advantage was that there was no seniority rule, that is to say, no privilege. A disadvantage is that it is by unanimity. The ESM has an advantage that it is not by unanimity and a disadvantage, there was seniority, hence the lifting of seniority for countries, in this case Spain, which will go through the EFSF, and which having gone through the EFSF, will be able, when they enter the ESM - we do not know when because it is not ratified yet - to have the lifting of seniority. That is what was decided; I think that is what is effective. Then, in the future, there will only be the ESM, so there will no longer be unanimity. But there may be the precedent that has been created. The problem is that the ESM is not yet in place. You know that in Germany, there is also a challenge before the Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe, so it may take a few more weeks.

In the meantime, what do we do? That was the question that was posed. In the eurozone, what do we do between the moment when a country, Spain, to name it, wishes to have support while the ESM is not in place? What was resolved last night within the eurozone is this transition. And that is what allows Spain to be stabilized.

Q - You are part of the generation that does not have an emotional relationship with Algeria; will you adopt a more pragmatic relationship with this country?

R - I have relationships with Algeria because I spent part of my administrative life there, eight months. I have returned often. There will be relationships that cannot be only pragmatic with Algeria, which are always relationships where the past, history, culture, and even personal lives are intertwined. We will have strong relations with Algeria.

Thank you very much.