Joint statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, and Mr. Mariano Rajoy, President of the Government of the Kingdom of Spain, on Franco-Spanish relations and on the policies to be pursued in response to the Eurozone crisis, in Paris on May 23, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

23 May 2012 · Franco-Spanish bilateral lunch and joint statement · Paris, France

Context
Hollande and Rajoy addressed press in Paris on May 23, 2012, following bilateral talks ahead of an informal European Council meeting on the Eurozone crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone crisis response, economic growth policies, budgetary consolidation, European banking system liquidity, Franco-Spanish bilateral relations, counter-terrorism cooperation, euro stability, structural reforms, debt sustainability, European Council priorities, market integration
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,218
87th percentile
Sentences
209
90th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 44%43%
  • Geopolitical 23%22%
  • Institutional 21%20%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

209 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I was pleased to host for lunch the President of the Spanish Government, Mr. Rajoy. We discussed our bilateral relations, which are excellent on all subjects, including the issue of security, which was rightly raised and will be one of the common concerns we will have in the coming months.

I also wanted to talk with President Rajoy about the informal European Council that will take place this evening, and we have positions that may converge, not on all subjects but on two major priorities. The first is to inject liquidity into the European financial system and to ensure that all European banks can be consolidated. We are also concerned about growth. Each of us is pursuing budgetary consolidation policies at our level, and Spain is making a significant effort. But we are also aware that growth must also be on our agendas; otherwise, how will it be possible to achieve results in terms of reducing deficits and controlling debt if there is no additional activity? This evening, as far as I am concerned, I will address before the European Council the two subjects: that of growth instruments in addition to what must be done on the budgetary front and the issue of liquidity to have a banking system that is solid and finally to be protected from speculations that can sometimes fuel the markets.

That is the meaning of our meeting, and it will be followed by a meeting that could take place by the end of the year because we consider it very important to coordinate.

Mr. Rajoy -- Hello everyone. Thank you very much, Mr. President, for those words. President Hollande has very well explained, very well summarized the content of our meeting. I will say pretty much the same thing in different terms, probably. I would like to start by saying that I am very pleased to be here today. I would like to thank President Hollande for the wonderful welcome that has been extended to me and to the Spanish delegation. Our bilateral relations, as the President just mentioned, have been excellent for a long time, and we are convinced that they will always be excellent in the future, so I will not prolong my statement in this regard.

I would also like to thank the President because after his election to the presidency, I called him to congratulate him, and he told me that France would continue its cooperation with all possible means in the fight against terrorism. Recently, a meeting was organized in Denmark between the French and Spanish Interior Ministers, and on May 29, the French Interior Minister will visit Spain, and he will, of course, be received as he deserves. So thank you for your cooperation, Mr. President.

It has been three years since the two countries have met in a bilateral summit. We have therefore agreed to hold a bilateral summit at the end of the year on issues that are of interest to our public opinions and that could help improve the situation of our populations. I believe that this meeting could take place at the end of the last quarter of 2012.

We also talked about today's European Council meeting. We discussed what is happening in Europe at the moment and what we could do to improve things in the future. I explained to the President, and I will do so now before you, trying to summarize my vision of things.

I believe that Europe is going through a difficult moment, and therefore efforts must be made to strengthen the euro. The euro, which is an integral part of our political project, the euro, which is an instrument that must serve to increase well-being, to increase jobs in all countries of the European Union. Spain's position is based on five points that I will summarize and on which there is a significant agreement with the position defended by France.

We have signed the budgetary pact. It has been integrated into our Constitution. We have already adopted an organic law regarding this budgetary pact integrated into the Constitution with the aim of achieving our deficit targets, 5.3% for 2013, 3%. This is the first element of our economic policy. And as President Hollande said, it is not enough to control the public deficit; it is important to implement policies that will stimulate growth. Reforms must be established so that economies are more flexible, more competitive. This must be done at the national level, and Spain has already begun its labor market reform, its financial system reform. We are working on our energy policy, our administration, and our various markets. Yes, we are in favor of budgetary control, but we must have policies that will lead us to growth.

Thirdly, we need growth policies at the European level, and in this regard, decisive steps must be taken for greater market integration.

Fourthly, and this is very important for Spain, we need financing, liquidity.

We need sustainability regarding debt. Some countries are making considerable efforts to reduce their deficit, but what we cannot do is live with too large interest rate differentials compared to other countries. Structural reform policies will bear fruit. Doubts about the euro must be dispelled; we must support countries that meet their commitments to the European Union, and there must be financing and liquidity for those countries. That is the main objective, and that is the urgency in the eyes of Spain.

Fifthly, I believe that at the European level, and President Hollande and I completely agree on this, we must work towards greater economic, budgetary, and political integration, and these are the elements that I will present at the European Council meeting. It is an informal meeting. We will not make decisions, but it is somewhat the prologue to a Council that will take place at the end of June 2012, during which I hope we will make important decisions on these equally important issues.

Thank you once again, Mr. President Hollande. You have treated us very well. Thank you for your kind welcome once again.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, we would like to ask you both a question. Do you agree to support today in Brussels an intervention by the European Central Bank aimed at helping countries like Spain? And we would like to know if you have been able to discuss the situation of Spanish banks? What is your position on the need or not for these banks to be able to use the European rescue fund? Thank you.

Mr. Rajoy -- Regarding your first question, you want to know if at the European Council meeting we will talk about the European Central Bank or not. What I will say in Brussels, and I have just summarized it for you, I do not want to tire you with this, but I repeat my four or five points: control of public spending, reform for growth, reform for growth at the European level, fourthly liquidity, the sustainability of debt, and financing. Yes, I will address these issues because Europe must provide answers. It must do so. We cannot continue to live with such differences in borrowing rates; these differences in borrowing rates could prevent us from achieving the objectives we have set for ourselves regarding the deficit. This is very important in my eyes; it may be the most important element. There are many important things, but this is the most important.

Then, the second part of your question regarding Spanish banks: know that in Spain, we are dealing with banks as we have done with public spending. We have published our figures on public spending and public deficits. Our work will be a work of transparency regarding all financial entities so that we know exactly. We had to nationalize Bankia, a very important Spanish bank, and in the coming months, independent evaluators will say what the situation of banks in Spain is. Tests have been carried out. It may be necessary to recapitalize some Spanish banks. I do not think this amount will be very large, but know that the government has no interest and does not wish to use any of the funds from the European Union or any other organization. Our goal is to convey a clear, intelligible message regarding the financial system, which cannot be called into question since there is no reason to call it into question.

THE PRESIDENT -- Regarding the role of the European Central Bank, I believe that this will be part of the discussions we will have to conduct in the coming weeks, both to bring about growth, which is its mode of intervention in the markets, independently, and also on how to provide liquidity, which it has already begun to do since banks can draw from the central bank at a particularly low interest rate.

Then, would it be desirable for the European Financial Stability Facility to play a more important role than it does today for banks that would call upon it? Why not, without going through the states, and this is also part of the discussions we will have in the coming days, in the context of the informal European Council this evening, this question of liquidity will be raised, and in the European Council in June, I hope there will be decisions that also go in this direction because the more fluid our financial system is, the stronger it is, and then we can have better growth conditions. We must inject more liquidity and have more robust financial institutions; that is the meaning of a growth policy as well.

QUESTION -- A question to Mr. Rajoy and Mr. Hollande: are the issues of eurobonds and the financial transaction tax two unconditional points for the success of the negotiations that begin this evening, first question? A question then to the French President: how do you approach tonight's summit? Will the discussions be more difficult with European partners than they were with G8 and NATO partners? Finally, one last question, but I am not sure you can answer it, Mr. Hollande: We have just learned that Arnaud Montebourg was convicted for insults against employees of Sea France -- perhaps you are not aware, but I wanted to have your reaction?

THE PRESIDENT -- You are not obliged to respond about Mr. Montebourg, but you can speak freely about eurobonds.

Mr. Rajoy -- I do not want to have a problem with anyone. You were asking me specifically about the financial transaction tax. I do not know if this will be the subject of a debate this evening. We are in favor of this financial transaction tax, but it is important that this tax does not impose a cost on individuals, commissions for individuals. It must not be imposed by one or two countries; this could create problems in the markets. It should be adopted by a majority of countries.

Regarding eurobonds in the short term, I insist on what I said; it is very important to first resolve the problem of debt financing and liquidity. Another debate that needs to be had within Europe is that of more Europe and the debate on European integration. The European process is old; France and Germany started this project with the ECSC. Then there was the Treaty of Rome in 1957, and European construction has advanced little by little, step by step, but now I believe we need to start thinking about deepening the process of economic, financial, and political integration. In this debate, in my opinion, eurobonds will be included. But I do not believe this is a question that will be resolved by the Council this evening. The urgent thing, in my opinion, is to resolve the issue of liquidity and financing of debts. Then, Europe will indeed have to organize a debate on the course to follow. Where is Europe going? Where does it want to go?

THE PRESIDENT -- The issue of the European Council this evening, which is therefore informal and does not have to make decisions at this stage, is to put all ideas for growth and liquidity on the table, for each country to come with its proposals. There are many. Some will insist on structural reforms, on market integration, on the financial transaction tax. For my part, I will return to what Europe can do very quickly, in the next twelve months, what it would be capable of initiating as measures without weighing on the states to promote activity, employment, and so that as countries recover in terms of their public accounts, they can also be supported by a more active growth policy coming from Europe.

Among the proposals that I will put on the table, there will also be euro-bonds, not to be in conflict with others; everyone must come with the best of spirits since it will be at the end of June that we will have to find solutions and find them together. It would be a shame not to go all the way with the proposals.

Regarding euro-bonds, what is the idea? It is not simply to create euro-projects or "project bonds" that will also be proposed, but to think about a mode of financing that would allow the member states of the Union, which have made the necessary efforts to restore their accounts, to access financing at the lowest possible interest rates and to protect them from speculative phenomena or doubts from certain markets.

Is it acceptable that some sovereign debts, in order to be financed, are forced to consent to interest rates of over 6%, while other countries, undoubtedly better regarded, can access financing at interest rates close to zero within the same monetary and budgetary union?

Therefore, I am in favor of discussing and retaining this instrument within the framework of the work program set for us in this European Council.

QUESTION - Will tonight's discussion be more difficult than that within the G8?

THE PRESIDENT - The game may be more difficult than at the G8. At the G8, there were already participants who at the outset might not have necessarily been on our theses and who, in fact, did not come but who considered that growth should be a dimension of the policies we had to engage in. At the NATO summit, we put forward our proposals and decisions in good intelligence with our Allies. In the same way, we must, in this perspective of the European Council at the end of June, convince and seek compromises. As much as I am for budgetary seriousness and we will have to meet our commitments to reduce deficits for 2013, I also believe that growth is a condition for achieving these objectives and that we cannot accept a eurozone where growth would be zero in 2012 and weak in 2013; therefore, we have to implement policies. In each of our countries, reforms have been undertaken by states for several years that will be carried out by us, but also a growth policy at the European level, and there we will have all the proposals that will add up to one another and will allow us to have this dimension of growth that is lacking. I therefore wish for a growth pact to be proposed and retained at the end of June. I will tell you more when I have had this informal meeting tonight, even if I must already say that it will not be decision-making. That is to say, we will simply have an exchange of views.

QUESTION - Hello, Mr. President, you speak of the judges of the Supreme Court. I do not know if you have discussed this with the leader of the Opposition, if you have reached an agreement with the leader of the Opposition. I know you spoke on the phone; did you share any information regarding today's summit in Brussels? And a question for both of you now: it seems that the Eurogroup has asked the government to prepare a contingency plan for Greece's exit from the eurozone. Could you tell us about that? This is information that has just come in. And what is your opinion on a possible exit of Greece from the eurozone?

THE PRESIDENT - On the topic of the Opposition, I cannot respond either.

MR. RAJOY - Yes, I know that the Constitutional Court has unanimously requested that its members be renewed, and I think they are right. Next Friday, I will meet with the leader of the opposition, and I am convinced that we will reach an agreement and soon we will renew the members of the Constitutional Court. Regarding the European Council, yes, I have discussed it with him, with Mr. DURAN as well, and it is important that I speak with all political groups in the coming days. There is agreement on the most important matters. Spain's European policy has been the result of agreements. We agreed together for the return to the Euro in 1986 to join the European Union. We have had agreements between the Popular Party and the Socialist Party to reform the Constitution, for example. So I do not think there is a difference once again, since we have never had a difference on European issues. There may be questions of detail, but generally speaking, we agree on the substance.

Regarding the information you just gave us, I have not heard of this information. What I want is for Greece to continue to be in the eurozone. That is what is best for Greece and for Europe; that is my wish.

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, I can only respond to the second question. Regarding Greece, I will do everything I can in my position to convince the Greeks to choose to remain in the eurozone while respecting the commitments that have been made. And I will do everything to convince the Europeans who may doubt the necessity of keeping Greece in the eurozone.

This is not just an issue for the Greeks. It is not simply an issue for the eurozone. It is an issue for Europe and for the conditions of growth in the world. Because it may seem disproportionate, but if there were to be a crisis in Greece that rebounds with the elections scheduled for June 17, it would necessarily have an impact on the conditions of growth in Europe and thus on the rest of the world. I do not want to overestimate the subject, but I do not want to underestimate it either. Have I been made aware of work coming from the Eurogroup to discuss or develop plans in case Greece exits the eurozone? My answer is no. I have no information, and in fact, I do not seek any because that would suggest that I am preparing for that outcome. I refuse that, and if I can address the Greeks through your intermediary, it is to tell them the confidence they must have. Including since the elections took place in France on May 6, regarding the attitude I will have towards Greece, but also with the requirements posed by the commitments that have been made between Greece and Europe. But there should be no doubt about Europe's intentions and Greece's intentions. We must be together. And for the rest, I do not have to prepare another scenario than that.

QUESTION - Yes, hello, two small questions and one more general one, Mr. President, Mr. Prime Minister. Do you think that, speaking of liquidity, the ESM should be the point of passage to inject liquidity into the banking system? Should it go through that module? Finally, Mr. VENIZELOS thinks that Greece should need a little more time to reduce its debt. Do you agree? How much time should be given to Greece to reduce its debt?

And finally, more generally, you are meeting for the first time. You are both quite new in your positions. Looking back at your predecessors, why has this crisis lasted so long? What would be the original sin that means you are still grappling with this crisis? Thank you.

MR. RAJOY - There are faster instruments than the European funds or the ESM, which will come into effect soon but is not yet in force. There are faster instruments to solve financing or liquidity problems. Regarding Mr. VENIZELOS, I will repeat what I said earlier: I am firmly convinced that what Greece should do best is to remain within the eurozone. I know that Greek citizens have suffered enormously from the measures that have been taken and that cause them suffering, but this will bear fruit soon, and I am convinced that Greece will find its way back to employment and growth, which will improve the lives of all Greeks; I have no doubt about that. I am convinced that Europeans want, we want Greece to stay with us. We will therefore act accordingly.

So why has this crisis lasted so long? Many people have commented on this, a great number of analyses have been made, many comments have been formulated, but I will not give you a lecture on the subject. What I want to say is that, as in life, one must have certainties, and in times of crisis, Europe needs certainties regarding the euro and regarding the future. The euro is part of the Spanish political project, of the European political project. We know that the euro will be in our lives forever. We must be convinced that there will be no defaults. Therefore, there must be procedures to support the public debts of the different nations. What we need today is to give that confidence, to provide securities to put an end to the rumors and stories that are told here and there. The day we provide the certainty of security, I am convinced that the eurozone crisis will be over.

THE PRESIDENT - Should we allow the European Financial Stability Facility to intervene more than it does today? That is its purpose: to ensure stability. Should it have a banking license? That will be part of the topics that need to be debated. Should it be linked to the European Central Bank? That is also one of the questions that deserves to be asked. So just as states have to do their duty regarding their banking system, there must also be liquidity support from the European Central Bank.

But once a fund has been established that will transform into a European solidarity mechanism, we must have a use of these funds or this mechanism that allows banks to finance themselves properly.

Regarding Mr. VENIZELOS's position, it consists of saying: "allow us to respect the memorandum but also more flexibility." I prefer to say there is the memorandum and then there is everything we can already do today to support growth in Greece, to provide more structural funds, to help the population live under better conditions with direct interventions from Europe without undermining the obligations that Greece must respect regarding the signature that has been given. But we cannot let the Greeks think that there will be no support and assistance. There will be, as long as they choose to give their participation in the eurozone a consistency and strength that will give confidence to Europeans.

You ask why, for the past two and a half years, there have been so many European councils, and ultimately so many disappointments regarding a number of issues that still come up in the debate, particularly Greece. I think we have a problem with the decision-making mechanism within the European Union.

There have certainly been instruments created; I mentioned the European Financial Stability Fund, the European Solidarity Mechanism. There has been an intervention from the European Central Bank. But we must go faster, stronger. There cannot simply be a budgetary dimension, which has been the one chosen through the treaty you know, but we must add to it a growth pact and also a medium-term commitment. Europeans must know where Europe is going. There must be political direction, there must be steps that must be taken, and then objectives that must be set. And if there is, I note this through a number of local or national elections that are succeeding each other in Europe, if there is distrust, it is precisely because Europe, which is our project, has not responded quickly enough to a number of problems. Particularly that of unemployment, economic activity, and also our common future. So that will also be part of what I will say tonight. Tonight at the European Council, we must reflect on economic issues: how to restore growth? On financial issues: how to inject liquidity? But also regarding political issues. What do we want to do together in Europe? What project do we carry? And political issues because I do not want Europe to be overtaken by populisms that thrive on the idea that we should no longer help the south and that, in southern countries, thrive because people can no longer bear being subjected to austerity policies. So there is a democratic issue, there is a political issue of utmost importance that must be debated, including in this European Council. Thank you, in any case, dear President, for being present in Paris before these very important meetings.

Thank you all.