Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, notably on France and NATO, the withdrawal of French troops from Afghanistan, Franco-American relations, and European construction, in Chicago on May 21, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

21 May 2012 · NATO Chicago Summit · Chicago, United States

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the NATO Chicago Summit on May 21, 2012, summarizing France's positions on Afghanistan, NATO reform, and European growth.
Main themes
French troop withdrawal from Afghanistan, NATO alliance reform, European defense, missile defense shield, Franco-American relations, European economic growth, eurobonds, ISAF membership, Afghan army funding, Franco-Afghan treaty, European Council, situation in Mali
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,369
88th percentile
Sentences
164
84th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
12.8
54th percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

164 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The Chicago Summit has just concluded with a final meeting that includes partners from non-member operations of the Alliance, and if I were to assess this summit, I believe that on three objectives our interests have been well taken into account in a process that should be one of the evolution of the Alliance.

The first issue was to determine what could be reserved for European Defense in the new posture and new concepts. You know that at the time when the decision was made to reintegrate military command, I denounced the fact that the counterpart of European Defense had not been truly affirmed with sufficient strength.

We note on the occasion of this summit that the intention to give greater scope to this European Defense will allow us, after evaluating our presence in military command, to develop as much as possible the presence of Europeans and especially their good organization within the framework of the Alliance.

The second issue was to know whether our reservations regarding the missile shield had been sufficiently taken into account to be lifted, both in terms of political control of the decision, complementarity with deterrence, risks of financial drift, and even the necessity of dialogue with Russia. We consider that there have also been significant progress in this area that allows us, with the necessary vigilance, to give our agreement to the continuation of this program.

Finally, and this was where we were most expected, to ensure that our decision to withdraw French combat troops from Afghanistan by the end of 2012 could not only be understood but at the same time could also be for France a non-negotiable element. On this issue, which was a campaign commitment, I believe that we were able to assert our point of view while providing our Allies with the necessary guarantees, namely that we remain full members of ISAF. To be precise, combat troops will be withdrawn by the end of 2012. After 2012, that is to say in 2013, only the essential elements for training actions that we will define within the framework of the treaty we signed with the Afghans, more precisely that France and Afghanistan signed by their respective presidents in January, will remain. We will have elements related to this training for the police and for the Afghan army's leadership, and we will also have human resources that will be absolutely essential for the repatriation of our equipment, which we know will take more time.

Finally, beyond 2014, we will still be with the Franco-Afghan treaty in civil support for development action, education, health, and the emancipation of women to accompany the Afghan people.

Regarding a possible contribution that has been requested to enable the Afghan army to have the financial means for its development, we have been approached with this request. We will study it, especially in light of the international control of the aid that will be considered.

That is what I could tell you beyond all the bilateral contacts I have had with the heads of state present here, that Foreign Minister Laurent FABIUS has had on his side, as well as Defense Minister Mr. Jean-Yves Le DRIAN. I believe that this summit has been useful for the Alliance, useful for France, and I think it has allowed us to advance both the concepts that the Alliance wished to promote and at the same time the interests that we consider essential for France.

I am ready to answer all your questions. Earlier, I also spoke with some of your colleagues about the situation in Mali. I also condemned the heinous attack that occurred in Yemen, including these objects, I can answer you.

QUESTION -- A quick question looking ahead to Wednesday. What do you expect from this first European Council? Will there perhaps be a confrontation with Germany over eurobonds, and can you also speak about your position on Mr. SCHÄUBLE's presidency of the Eurogroup? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- You are wonderful, the press. We are in an event after the G8, the NATO summit in Chicago, and already you are taking us to Wednesday. You do not imagine that I will answer your questions, but we will indeed have an informal European Council on Wednesday. If it is called informal, it is because everything will be on the table and we can discuss all the proposals that each of us may bring for growth, and all instruments, all orientations, all ideas will be welcome. I am not preparing this informal council with the French government with a view to conflicts, but rather in a process that allows Europe to regain the growth dimension that it has lacked until now. That is what I will tell you at this stage; I will not talk about eurobonds to avoid upsetting anyone before we discuss them directly on Wednesday, but that will not be the only topic, nor will nominations be on the agenda of the informal European Council.

QUESTION -- Beyond Chicago, what assessment do you draw from your American trip? You said on Saturday that it was partly already successful, that the mandate was partly fulfilled. On the right in Paris, several voices are rising, notably that of former minister Pierre LELLOUCHE, who says that you are barely "walking on water" these days. The same question related to this: why were you absent for a few minutes this morning at the beginning of Mr. OBAMA's speech?

THE PRESIDENT -- Regarding the fact that I "walk on water," I believe I have not tried that yet, but there is little risk that I will engage in it, and I think we must remain aware of realities and not respond to controversies coming from our country.

Regarding Mr. OBAMA's speech, I heard it perfectly since I arrived after a meeting with Mr. BAN KI-MOON and after some traffic jams at the moment when the Secretary-General spoke, and then Mr. OBAMA on the substance. I am not just talking about the words of welcome; I am talking about the substance of the morning's speech.

On what Mr. BAN KI-MOON told me, this allows me to mention the situation in Syria and its consequences for Lebanon. There was a common concern that what is unfortunately happening in Syria could have consequences for neighboring countries. I spoke about this yesterday with the Turkish President, and it was about what could happen in Lebanon since there has been some violence, and you know that, in addition, there are French forces present as part of UNIFIL in southern Lebanon, and we must pay all necessary attention there.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, I allow myself to project onto the coming week, on the negotiations for growth in Europe. You say that everything will be on the table. You emphasize investments, while the Germans talk more about structural reforms. I would like to know if you would be willing to introduce more flexibility in the labor market in France on this issue?

THE PRESIDENT -- That the Germans come to the subjects that are dear to them is normal; everyone comes with what they think is their solution. In a conversation since I sit next to Ms. MERKEL, we were able to have some exchanges. In a conversation again last night, she pointed out to me that there has been a very significant German trade surplus for several years, which is largely due to investment and modernization efforts. It is true that I have been made aware of the conclusions of reports coming from the European Commission -- I am not just talking about budget deficits, but also about the problem of the competitiveness of the French economy -- which in recent years, I remind you that we have only been in power for a week, but there has been a loss of competitiveness and a deterioration of France's position in trade. So I can hear what a number of our European partners may say to improve investment capacity, to be more concerned about restoring the competitiveness of businesses; all of this is part of the subject. That does not mean labor market flexibility, which has actually been largely relaxed in France in recent years. I am in a process where I do not prohibit anyone from making proposals. Just as I mention eurobonds, it is entirely legitimate for the Germans to mention structural reforms. The approach that must be ours for Wednesday evening, the informal council that will be the first step, there will be others, is that everyone, apart from what we know to be the budget pact, the stability pact, these are questions we will return to; here we are talking about growth. Everyone should come with their proposals, their initiatives, their experiences, and at the end of the discussion, I am not talking about Wednesday; I am talking about what we will have to do for the European Council at the end of June, we should be able to draw practical conclusions, and we will see the necessary legal instruments to translate this desire for growth into European texts.

QUESTION -- Several questions on the subject of the financial contribution requested from France starting in 2014. Is there the idea or not at all of a form of compensation? In other words, does the fact of accelerating the withdrawal of troops in a certain way commit you more to being supportive for the future? Secondly, is the amount requested in the order of what seems to have been accepted by Germany, that is to say about, I believe, 200 million dollars per year? Thirdly, you say that to engage France, you would need more guarantees on the control of expenditures. Can you be a bit more precise, explaining why for some countries this is acceptable today and not for you?

THE PRESIDENT -- Because we are France, and first of all, there is no compensation. We consider that our mission in terms of actions, of combat is over, that the Afghan forces will take back possession of the Kapisa area, and that we are in the process that was decided in Lisbon, that is to say, the transition. I will not go back over the history of the intervention in Afghanistan and the change of nature that occurred in 2008; I simply take the facts as they are today. There is a transition that is planned. For the Allies, it is essentially in 2014 that it will occur. For others, by the way, the transition has already taken place. Several countries have already withdrawn their combat forces, so we have decided to do so. This will culminate in the end of 2012, and there is no compensation to be paid or imagined. We have done more than our duty, and I remind you of the French losses: 83 men who lost their lives, many wounded. I want to salute their courage and sacrifice here and also express my solidarity with their families. We made this decision; our Allies made it, and it will be executed for after 2014. We have been approached like all partners with a request for contribution. We have not responded. Simply, on principle, we can look at it. We have not set a specific amount; we are not bound by what Germany or other countries may do, and we have one condition, which is to know whether any contributions, including those we might make, will indeed be controlled.

QUESTION -- The Iranian press in recent days has said that you dismissed your Iranian negotiator, the political director of the Quai d'Orsay, Mr. AUDIBERT. How do you interpret this press campaign, which is clearly based on inaccurate information?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, there is a maneuver and manipulation, and you were right to ask me the question since it will allow me to clarify this press operation, although the press has little to do with all this. Mr. Jacques AUDIBERT, who is actually present here, is our negotiator. He has been mandated, and he will be present at the meeting in Baghdad, and we have worked in close liaison throughout this period with the ministers concerned, and I trust him completely to have the necessary firmness in this negotiation.

QUESTION -- One never knows. We have been witnessing, at least for a few days, the establishment of a diplomatic method. The question I was asking myself was whether there is a subject, a file on which you would like France and you to weigh all your weight and influence, and if so, which one?

THE PRESIDENT - You know, the most important issue before us is to have a reorientation of Europe. It is to allow Europeans to regain confidence in this very beautiful idea of European construction; it is also to give European economic actors more confidence in their own future. We are still seized by concerns coming from Greece, so I see well everything that remains to be done in a context that was not necessarily what we had anticipated, as we are now aware that what will happen in Greece on June 17, that is to say, the very day of the French legislative elections, as there are also legislative elections in France that will have a certain influence, well, what will also happen on June 17 in Greece will have repercussions on our own discussion for the reorganization of Europe and its growth dimension. Either the Greeks make the choice to assert their desire to remain in the eurozone while being supported to do so and to respect the commitments that have been made, then I think we can work very quickly for growth to return as soon as possible, or we are again seized by a period of uncertainty, and that will not prevent the European Council at the end of June from taking place with its agenda but with possible instability. So, you ask me what is today the most important subject, what is the issue that I want to carry with the government for the coming months, it is that of the reorientation of Europe.

QUESTION - Does the deteriorating situation in Mali and the region worsen the situation of our hostages? At this point, are negotiations with intermediaries broken off or continuing?

THE PRESIDENT - I will not make any comments on hostage situations because we are aware of the risks, and at the same time, we do not want to give those who might be listening any information that could be used by them. So, it is true that this Sahel region today creates a risk for all our nationals who must be very careful, and what has happened in Mali again today cannot be accepted, that the interim President could be attacked even if it has not had too many consequences, that there is still a questioning of the democratic process as it had been accepted by all parties is not, for France, bearable. So we are in full agreement with ECOWAS for Mali to regain its stability as quickly as possible. I am also in contact with the President of Niger on this matter.

QUESTION - Mr. President, France is in the process of leaving a rather heavy war in Afghanistan; at the same time, we have recently witnessed a shorter war in Libya and a military operation in Côte d'Ivoire, which are sometimes considered today as models of intervention for the future. I wanted to know what your opinion is, your conception, given the somewhat difficult budgetary context we are going through, of what future operations could be, the model of future interventions for France.

THE PRESIDENT - I remind you that these operations were conducted within the framework of the United Nations; that is our principle for deciding on an operation. Then, there are lessons to be learned from what happened in Libya; I mean tactical lessons, and indeed, the Alliance has been seized of this, and in the programs that will be launched on aerial refueling and drones, we do indeed have conclusions to draw. For the rest, if there were to be other operations, they will find their framework in the deliberations of the United Nations.

QUESTION - Hello, Mr. President, two questions. First, you briefly said today that there would be no more French soldiers in Afghanistan by the end of 2013. Does that mean there will be no more combat forces, but no trainers, no gendarmes, no French soldiers of any kind? And excuse me, just a second question still regarding Afghanistan: the Americans have also relied on French special forces for the entire anti-terrorism fight over these many years. Will French troops, special forces, continue these anti-terrorism operations in the coming years, or will that also stop? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, let’s be more precise. In 2013, there will still be personnel present, as I said, on Afghan soil, as part of the training actions we have decided and that we will need to specify. Then, we will need personnel to repatriate our equipment; I do not know how long that will take because we need to find routes and evacuation possibilities with security conditions that must be met and evacuation costs that are not too high. So we will take all precautions. After 2014, in any case, there will no longer be, that is the decision that has been made by NATO; there will be no more personnel except for a certain number of advisors, but NATO will no longer be responsible for them; it will be the United States regarding support for the Afghan army. For us, after 2014, there is no question of entering into any operation whatsoever.

QUESTION - Mr. President, when you say, because we are France, when you say that your choice for Afghanistan is non-negotiable, when you assert the sovereignty of France, do you recall during the presidential campaign the attacks from the UMP that said you would be a President who would undermine the independence and sovereignty of the country? Do you feel today, in light of this rich first international sequence, that you are giving them a slap in the face?

THE PRESIDENT - No, no, I do not engage in domestic politics here. This is not at all in relation to subjects that could still be raised for the legislative elections. Here, it was a matter of translating a commitment I had made and doing so both to mark our sovereign decision and at the same time to have it accepted by our Allies, to behave in an intelligent and loyal manner towards our partners in the Alliance. Therefore, the fact that the Chicago Summit was able to ensure that everyone could assert their decisions while remaining in the same operation, ISAF, allows us to find, I think, the right balance between what falls under an action and a decision of sovereignty and what also falls under a desire for partnership in the Alliance and loyalty regarding our commitments. This is what allowed our Allies to perfectly understand what we wanted and to accept it. And by the way, I noted a statement from General ALLEN saying that this decision in no way undermined the security and conditions of intervention of the Alliance.

QUESTION - Mr. President, regarding missile defense, just for pedagogical purposes for those who read or listen to us, when you say that you have obtained the principle of a political role in the decision, it is on the decision to respond to a potential missile launch coming from a threatening power. But how is this political control exercised before and then in the very short time frame between the launch of a missile and the retaliatory strike?

THE PRESIDENT - These modalities will be discussed. You are absolutely right. There must be an authority that decides. It is precisely to have this entire procedure that we wanted it to be clearly stated that this was done within a framework of partnership. So, it is not just the United States that could decide.

QUESTION - Alongside the sessions, there were also many bilateral meetings. Could you tell us which ones impressed you the most, and at this stage, have you sensed a certain complicity or, let’s say, with certain heads of state, the feeling that you can also rely on them, that you have a convergence of views on a number of points?

THE PRESIDENT - We had many bilateral exchanges. The one that was most important to us was with President KARZAI since we were in the process of transferring our combat forces in the Kapisa area, and it was very important to have, on the Afghan side, this same willingness to have the Afghan army take control of this territory. In the same way, I had to confirm to him that we would have the treaty signed by him and Mr. SARKOZY ratified by the French Parliament. It was also useful for us to see the cooperation actions we could engage in education and health. This was indeed an element of the discussion: health. The question of women and also democratization and political dialogue. And you know how difficult it is since one of the intermediaries who was to enter into contact with the Taliban was executed. So that was the meeting most linked to the Summit itself. Then, we had with the Secretary-General of the United Nations, I have given the essentials because there is the situation in Syria, in Iran, and we wanted to have an exchange. Then, I will not list everything we did, but there will surely be an initiative taken with Poland, precisely within the framework of what is called the Weimar Triangle, and I also discussed it with Ms. MERKEL, who is also very proactive on this subject. Then many of our European partners in the context of preparing the informal council wanted to have our point of view, Danes, Austrians, who partly support what we propose. So I will not compromise them here. But that was also useful for that preparation. Finally, we have been invited to many countries; I do not know if we will be able to respond to everything, but it is true that there was a fairly strong expectation, as often, I mean as always after a change, whether some rejoice or lament it, there was a very strong desire to establish links with us. That is why these two days spent here in Chicago, apart from what we had to obtain or monitor at this summit, were quite precious for allowing exchanges that we might have taken months to have if we had stayed in France.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you just said that the change allows for things. Do you think it has been easier to negotiate or talk with the United States because Barack OBAMA is in an election campaign?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, there are always moments that are more conducive than others. I think Barack OBAMA had a double objective: to ensure that the G8 could be a success, particularly regarding issues like Syria and Iran; I return to Iran, and that we could have a convergence of views, which indeed was the case, and he also wanted growth to be an element of the debate, not to please one or the other, but simply because he prefers to have a well-functioning global economy rather than financial crises bouncing back, hence the interest we had regarding the situation in the eurozone. In the same way, on the question of oil prices, he is directly interested in everything that can be done to avoid price volatility in an electoral context, but that also serves us. So there was a happy coincidence between us, who have just arrived, and him, who would like to stay. Then in Chicago, I think he wanted, and we did too, for a consensus to be found and for the Alliance to demonstrate its coherence and cohesion, which was the case. This made our position all the better understood, if not integrated. I do not say that it was pleasing because the risk was that others could seize our initiative to make equivalent choices, but we also had to remain in ISAF, which gave the guarantee that our Allies wanted and that Barack OBAMA also asked us for, which did not pose a problem. In our first meeting at the White House, as soon as we arrived in the United States, it was on this question that we discussed the most, and we reached it all the more quickly because preparatory work had been done by our teams that had cleared up all misunderstandings. What could those misunderstandings be? It was to know if we were remaining in ISAF; we answered yes, and if we would have actions other than combat ones. We answered, we will look at them, but as for training, we are already committed by the bilateral treaty. So we are ready for that. And once these positions were affirmed, it is true that the agreement was very easy to find. To stay on your question, there was a coincidence of interest, of situation that allowed us to assert a number of our priorities during this long presence here in the United States, first at the G8 and these two days in Chicago.

QUESTION -- I just wanted to ask you how you explain that the Allies seem to have so easily accepted the accelerated withdrawal from Afghanistan, and particularly I am thinking of the Americans? Do you imagine in your discussions that the Americans might eventually want to accelerate their own...?

THE PRESIDENT -- This question has already been asked of me, and I want to be very clear. I answered Ms. Valérie NATAF about what seemed to me to be the elements that ultimately led to the agreement. At no point did I feel, to answer your question, that the Americans wanted to accelerate the process, so I do not want to imply that there was an agreement that was made easier because the Americans were preparing to do the same thing; no, that is not the case.