Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, notably on the implementation of the growth pact and on the European banking union, in Brussels on October 19, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

19 October 2012 · Press conference on the implementation of the growth pact and the European banking union · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on October 19, 2012, outlining key outcomes on growth, banking union, and international affairs.
Main themes
Growth pact implementation, European banking union, financial transaction tax, EU-China trade relations, European Council conclusions, structural funds and EIB, enhanced cooperation, Syria and Mali situations, youth employment, banking supervision and recapitalization
Duration
~42 min
91st percentile
Words
5,024
91st percentile
Sentences
227
91st percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
2.90
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

227 sentences in 58 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - From this morning, which ended early and also started early, we can retain four points.

The first is that there was a discussion -- it was necessary -- to establish the position of the European Union in favor of a partnership with China, especially in light of a renewal of its leadership. The main idea we have put forward is that of coherence. Europeans have good relations with China; they must take all the positions that can be occupied in this vast space, thanks to competitiveness, and at the same time, do so with rules, particularly those of reciprocity, and ensure that we rebalance our exchanges as well as our mutual investments and avoid any competition -- beyond what the economy justifies -- that would lead each state to seek an advantage at the expense of another.

No, we must approach China with clear ideas and common positions. The conclusion to be drawn is that the Commission and the Council will indeed synthesize what we must carry together regarding the trade dossier with China.

The second point I want to highlight from this morning is the implementation of the growth pact. You know how much I insisted in June for a sum to be released and resources mobilized -- 120 billion, the EIB, the "project bonds," the structural funds. I therefore wished for an evaluation of this process so that we could not lose time, and indeed do so both on the side of the Commission and on the side of the European Parliament. I must note that there is involvement from all institutions.

Regarding the EIB, the increase in capital is now in its final phase, and this will allow for the raising of a number of funds that will mobilize 60 billion euros through leverage. On the structural funds, there is the Commission's willingness to redeploy them to what can be most useful for growth. Regarding the "project bonds," we ourselves have made proposals for France, but we can think that 4 to 5 billion euros could be mobilized thanks to this new instrument.

There are also evaluations that have been made regarding a number of sectors where France is particularly in need of impulses: the digital sector, communications, and infrastructure.

Finally, on competition and competitiveness rules, we reiterated our principles, and on trade exchanges, we insisted on reciprocity, which must allow the European economy to have stronger positions in trade negotiations.

The third point is the financial transaction tax. There are currently 10 countries that have submitted their request. Enhanced cooperation has therefore been accepted by the Commission. I have asked that this same Commission not waste time and, on the contrary, accelerate the procedure so that the financial transaction tax can come into effect at the beginning of 2013.

The allocation of the funds that will be generated by this tax in the countries participating in enhanced cooperation -- we will necessarily have to discuss this: a portion, which is France's position, must be pooled, that is to say allocated to infrastructure works, which will complement the growth pact, or it could be both, to a fund that could be dedicated to youth training because I think it is very important that the "employment" dimension can be linked to the financial transaction tax.

This tax, in reality, aims to take a levy on speculation -- or at least on financial exchanges that are not all speculative -- but it primarily aims to generate resources that must support growth and employment. Therefore, the member countries of this enhanced cooperation -- which is intended to expand -- could indeed demonstrate this.

Finally, the fourth point on which the European Council has expressed itself is the situation in Syria and Mali. Two different subjects but which call for international mobilization. In one case, Syria, we have reiterated the pressure we must exert for the transition to take place, and there was unanimity regarding what is our duty, even if this unanimity is not found, as you know, in the United Nations Security Council. In contrast, for Mali, Europe's position is the one I presented myself during the United Nations General Assembly and which was reflected in resolution 2071 of the Security Council, which now needs to be implemented. It now depends on the Africans for a second resolution to be deliberated in the Security Council allowing for this intervention in Northern Mali.

That is the essence of what this morning has allowed us to draw as conclusions. I want to return briefly -- and then I will leave the floor to you for questions -- to what was decided yesterday, namely the implementation of the banking union with an important date -- on January 1, the entire legal framework will be implemented and completed -- allowing this banking supervision to find its bodies, to enable its mobilization, and to lead to the recapitalization of banks in 2013.

QUESTION - You place a lot of hope in the growth pact; you are optimistic today. But when we look at the progress report that was submitted by the European Commission, we get the impression that things are not going as well as that, that the timelines are very long, that the EIB projects or the "project bonds" will only come to fruition in the first half of 2013; regarding the structural funds, there is a problem identifying projects in a number of member states... I would like to know if you are still as optimistic today that the growth pact will produce its effects.

Second question, if you allow me. The Commission is short of liquidity on a number of its community policies. It will present an additional budget in a few days. Is France ready today to give its agreement for the Commission to finalize its budget, which means more funding coming from France?

THE PRESIDENT - I will immediately respond to the last part of your question. We have not been approached by the Commission on anything. So, not being the subject of any request from the Commission today, I do not see how I could respond in one way or another. What I do know, however, is that we have to discuss budgetary perspectives and that the next European budget must also integrate this dimension of growth, not only in the mass of expenditures but in the structuring of what Europe must engage in for the coming years. We cannot, at the same time, wish for growth and have a European budget that is disconnected from this objective.

When I hear a number of proposals -- not necessarily here, but there are some in France -- asking us to make savings on the European budget, what would that mean? It would mean that we would probably contribute less but that there would not be the leverage effect of what the European Union can represent in terms of growth.

Regarding the timelines, the European Council in June decided on the increase in the capital of the European Investment Bank, and that will be done by the end of the year. It could not go any faster.

Regarding the "project bonds," there are already projects that have been selected. We can think that there will be about 4 to 5 billion euros in the coming months.

Regarding French requests, we have already identified 2.5 billion in projects that can be financed thanks to this growth pact in the coming months, and we have asked the regions, you know in a relationship we have established through a contract, to mobilize for the structural funds. It is true that what takes the longest is, paradoxically, the structural funds, whereas it is ultimately the European procedure on the budgetary level that should be the easiest to implement. So we have insisted, I have done so on my side, that the structural funds can be not only better thought out but more quickly put to use.

QUESTION - A question to return to what you said yesterday about Greece. You made a statement, you said that there are still perhaps questions about Greece's situation in the eurozone and perhaps about, I don't know if it's its membership, could you perhaps clarify? Is it Greece's difficult situation within the eurozone that still poses problems for you, or is it the very fact of Greece's membership in the eurozone? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Let us be clear, at the moment there is a discussion. It is in its concluding phase between the Troika and Greece. The position we adopted late last night is to note that there has been progress, that the efforts are there, that there are still some clarifications to await but that the process is going in the right direction, to the point that we reiterated that Greece's future is in the eurozone.

I myself have spoken with the Greek Prime Minister; a visit on my part has been considered. The date has not yet been set, but it is indeed the sign I want to send. It is a sign of confidence towards Greece and of the conclusion that must now be brought, and I hope, during the next Eurogroup once the Troika's report has been presented.

QUESTION - Can you tell us if it is true that you wish to eliminate the reduced VAT rate in the restaurant sector and return to a normal VAT rate?

THE PRESIDENT - But have I made a statement in this sense? There is a budgetary debate, based on the draft finance law that was presented to the Council of Ministers; this provision is not included. There is a discussion that is underway between the Minister of Commerce and the profession to evaluate the reduction of VAT that occurred under the conditions you know, and it is at the end of this discussion, evaluation, that any potential decisions can be considered, but for now that is not the case. We need to see if the VAT reduction has had effects as presented by the profession, to evaluate it and draw conclusions.

QUESTION - Two questions if you allow me. The first on the banking union, we want to say to you "all that for this" because honestly, meeting for almost two days to repeat exactly what you concluded in June, we find it hard to understand the interest of such European Councils. So I wonder if there is not simply a Franco-German disagreement that you should have resolved beforehand?

Second question if you allow me, you did not talk at all about the VAN ROMPUY report and the four presidents that outlines the future of the eurozone and which notably proposes a eurozone budget and a political deepening of the eurozone. We still do not quite know what France wants in this area; you are deferring the debate further, and we would like to have some clarifications on your vision for the future of the eurozone. What type of institutions? Do you envision a eurozone Parliament? A Commission president elected by universal suffrage? A eurozone Commission? In short, a bit more precision. Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, I have already expressed myself last night. Last night I returned to these elements, but just for you, I am ready to hold another session.

First of all, regarding the banking union, there has been progress, and I ask you to acknowledge it. That is to say, at the European Council on June 29, many decisions were made, and regarding the banking union, it was said: supervision is envisaged for the end of the year. The very important point of the European Council in June is that it linked supervision and the recapitalization of banks. Direct recapitalization by the ESM. That was, in my view, the major element of the European Council in June, which is a significant European Council, which has changed the game, not just for the growth pact but for the intervention mechanisms of the European Union and notably of the eurozone. It is because of this council that we can now move forward with a firmer, more assured, and even faster step.

What is the change brought about by the Council this night which, I agree with you, could have been shorter? But if you want me to talk to you one day about the European Councils in particular, I will do so. I think we can go faster. But you know, we are 27, and there are a number of heads of state and government, including myself surely, who each time try to insist on one aspect or another... But here, the main point was to say it is no longer about considering, it is no longer about wishing, it is about deciding. It was not enough to say it is decided! There also had to be a date allowing us to say that all the legislative elements, I emphasize legislative, that fall under the European Council, will be in place by the end of the year. A specific date was even added following a discussion and in full agreement with the President of the European Central Bank, that is to say, the one who will be the supervisor. We all committed to having it by January 1st. The date is important. It is not a general, vague calendar, it is January 1st.

Does this mean that on January 1st, or January 2nd, a recapitalization of the banks could take place? No, because, again, this is not a concession that would have been made, it is a direct consequence of the decision. For there to be recapitalization, there must not only be the legislative framework but also the competent bodies to decide and have the evaluations that allow for supervision. One thing is to organize supervision, another is to carry it out, the supervision, to detect the banks that might deserve to be supported and recapitalized.

Another very important point that was agreed upon in the European Council, and that was not self-evident: is that all banks are considered, without distinction, even if, it is true, there was a clarification made so that the national supervisor can continue to play its role under the authority of the central supervisor. There is direct supervision. What does direct mean? It means that there is an authority, the European Central Bank, and then national supervisors who are of course directly involved in the direct supervision. This was a point, and you know it well, you recalled it, of debate with the Germans who, for historical reasons, for institutional reasons as well, are extremely attentive to ensuring that regional banks can always be controlled by a national supervisor, without having to refer to a direct supervisor. It was agreed that all banks were therefore in the scope but, this applies to Germany as well as to all other banking establishments in all countries, with a role granted to the national supervisor of each country.

THE PRESIDENT - It was agreed that all banks were therefore in the scope but, and this applies to Germany as well as to all other banking establishments in any country, with a role granted to the national supervisor of each country.

So I think this is a Council that may have been too long, but after all, it is not the first, and it is certainly not the last. Because I believe that the next one that is coming will allow you to have several nights, depending on the modalities you adopt for each of you, there is not necessarily a rule of unanimity, there can be "opt-outs" and so from this point of view you will do what you want. But it is going to be long. Because I felt, during this Council, it was longer than it should have been to reach what was already a point of agreement between Germany and France, but it was long because it is the whole debate between those who are in the Eurozone and those who are not. And another debate is to know, and I come to Mr. QUATREMER's question, what we want to do regarding the budget. The VAN ROMPUY report, and it was partly taken up in the conclusions, mentions budgetary capacities that Eurozone countries could give themselves to intervene, act in a number of areas.

An illustration, I have already said, is the tax on financial transactions, but there could be a budgetary capacity for the entire Eurozone. Immediately the reaction of the countries that are not members of the Eurozone is to say "but if you have a budgetary capacity that would mean you are withdrawing from the European budget to create another budget alongside." No. And I reassured these countries. There is a European budget.

This European budget, we must determine together, set its size, its distribution, its allocation, with concern for cohesion funds, structural funds, agricultural policy. It is our budget, a budget for 27, tomorrow for 28. And in parallel, if the countries of the Eurozone decide to seek resources to carry out actions that concern them, it is not in substitution, it is in addition.

What is my position? I am in favor of having a Eurozone that structures itself, not in opposition to the rest of Europe but in advance of the rest of Europe and that can have actions that are its own. This is already the case since we manage a currency. It is also the case for banking supervision even if we ensure to involve the other countries. And so to structure this Eurozone, I proposed, within the framework of existing treaties, that there be a Eurozone council that meets much more regularly and that there be a strengthening of the Eurogroup.

So I will continue to make these proposals and I believe they are receiving a certain echo. Because everyone is well aware that we must be together, at 27, at 28, but have a capacity and a responsibility. There is a responsibility to be in the Eurozone. I do not force anyone to enter. Moreover, I note that no one wants to leave. But no country can prevent the Eurozone from advancing as it sees fit. And that is very important.

Regarding the European Parliament, I discussed it with Martin SCHULZ. The European Parliament is the parliament of all of Europe. There cannot be several parliaments. But within the European Parliament, it is already planned, there can be, again for the questions that will concern the Eurozone, an organization within it to ensure that democracy is fully respected but that there is no division of Europe, I think that it is the right formula to have this presence within the European Parliament.

QUESTION - Mr. President, a current affairs question if you allow me. This morning, the future president of the BPI, Jean-Pierre JOUYET said that the BPI would not have the vocation to help "zombie companies" referring to sites like Florange. What do you think of this type of statement?

THE PRESIDENT - It happens that I listened to the radio this morning. So it was in response to a question he was asked, to know if, it was the journalist's word, it was the role of the BPI to take on "zombie companies" like Florange. Florange is not a zombie company first. Florange is part of Arcelor Mittal.

To my knowledge, Arcelor Mittal is not a zombie company, it is a large enterprise. Arcelor Mittal has not requested to benefit from the interventions of the BPI, so it is quite simple, on the Arcelor Mittal file, it does not fall under the BPI since by definition there is no request that has been addressed by Arcelor Mittal. On the other hand, what the President of the BPI said is that it is an offensive strategy that the BPI must engage in. It is not there to provide cash competitions to companies that would be in difficulties. It is there to lend long-term or to take equity stakes, own funds, in companies that may, at a certain moment, need these funds, because they have investment projects or because they may be in difficulties at a moment because they have a future and therefore it was very important that he gave this guiding line, because it is the one that will indeed be found in the bill.

QUESTION - This week in your interview with Le Monde you mentioned the date of 2014 for a political union, after the banking and budgetary union, notably... and then there is also the VAN ROMPUY report that you have touched upon... You now have the experience of European summits and you just mentioned their relative slowness or heaviness, do you think that this European methodology, this European functioning, is compatible with the ambitious objectives that are yours, and that are also shared... and if you allow me also a question on the budgetary debate this afternoon in Parliament, does the compromise found around taxation justify or not the end of the turmoil over the sale of companies? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - For the parliamentary debate, finally in the National Assembly, I think it resumes this morning, so we will have the conclusions during the day. It is the role of the Assembly, then of the Senate, to find the right adjustments. And I think that what has been proposed by the government goes in the right direction, that is to say to favor companies that again invest, can change hands at a certain moment, but that must be treated particularly at the level of capital gains. For the European question: the European Councils are at 27, soon 28, they necessarily have this heaviness, everyone defends their positions, so I will not here, on the pretext that I am newer than others, give a lesson. There will always be this impression of slowness.

The main thing is to find the right decision. I did not complain that we spent a large part of the night of June 28 and 29 to arrive at this change in the direction of Europe. I accepted to stay like you, until 3 a.m. to ensure that the banking union comes into effect as quickly as possible and under the best conditions. I have experienced, moreover, so many meetings that also lasted a very long time, for texts that did not always have a considerable impact... others will take care of that soon... so I fully accept this rule and this slowness. What matters is to make the right decisions. On 2014, why did I take the date of 2014, because it is a major electoral appointment, where we think that the European elections must have a meaning, or we think it is a formality, I believe they must have a meaning, that they must correspond to a choice of direction, to a choice of the European Commission and therefore to possibly some treaty evolutions.

Everyone knows that there will be no treaty modifications until 2014, I am not sure there will be any in 2014. But one thing is certain, we are not going to change the Treaties in the coming year. For example, on the banking union there is no treaty change on the budgetary union we have just voted on a treaty. What can this political union be? It will depend on what we have been able to do in terms of banking union, fiscal union, social union, it is a content. I am not going to change the treaties just for the pleasure of saying there will be a treaty. It is better that it does not bear my name. What matters is to put content. In terms of the organization of institutions, I told you, the main thing is that we can decide faster. Hence the importance I attach to the Eurozone. And also, that there are multiple speeds, everyone now accepts the idea of multiple speeds. There are even some who are going in reverse, that exists. You can identify them quite easily. There are multiple speeds, those who want to go the least far possible and the slowest possible, others want to go faster. We are in this, and we will do it with the countries that want to engage more. The Eurozone being by definition a zone, already, of coherence.

QUESTION - A question about the organization that you mentioned, which you obviously led for eleven years. Harlem DESIR was designated first secretary last night with just under 70%, 28% for Mr. MAUREL and a very low participation, of about 50%, what do these figures inspire in you?

THE PRESIDENT - I will not comment myself on the results of the Socialist Party congress. Even if I am interested in it. But you remember what I said: I, as President of the Republic, will not behave as a party leader. Harlem DESIR is indeed a first secretary of the Socialist Party, a true first secretary of the Socialist Party. He is not a delegate, he is fully the first secretary. He must take charge of this great organization that the country needs. I am not saying that the majority needs it, France needs a great socialist party that plays its full role of proposal, support, debate, and I know that Harlem DESIR has all the qualities for that.

Regarding participation, for one militant out of two to come to vote when he has already made a choice at the level of a motion and that the stakes were not, let’s say, mysterious regarding its outcome, I find that quite honorable.

Finally, the score he achieved is quite appreciable. If he had done more, it would have been suspicious, if he had done less, it would have been worrying. He achieved the right result.

QUESTION - Two very small questions, if you allow me. One, about Greece, what message? You have always said that you are the President of recovery, the social President. How do you distinguish yourself regarding Greece from your predecessor? Are you not a little bit held hostage by the markets? Are you obliged to do everything to ensure that Greece returns to the markets, that Greece implements a program of very strict austerity, what differentiates you? A second question, very quickly. According to Paris-Match, the Louis GALLOIS report on the competitiveness of companies contains a plea in favor of shale gas. Will you reconsider your position? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - You are asking me a lot of questions that have little to do with the council, but that is the rule. I have not read this report; by definition, I am not even sure it is written, since it is submitted on November 5. So I do not know what it contains. And it is a report that engages its author, which does not engage the government, and not the President of the Republic; it serves to make decisions. And there will surely be many elements to take from this report.

Regarding Greece, what I want, what I have set as an objective, since the Greeks have made a lot of efforts, that Mr. Samaras' coalition government has made commitments, I now want it to be decided quickly, that is to say, that the funds that are planned can be unlocked in the coming weeks after the Troika report.

What is going to change, you ask me compared to what was before, simply that now the question of Greece's presence in the Eurozone should no longer be raised, should no longer be raised, which will be, I think, despite all the difficulty, all the suffering of the Greek people, at least, if we achieve this result, a guarantee.

THE PRESIDENT - Alright, the last question.

QUESTION - You mentioned the summit in November. What is the French position on the European Union budget for the 2014-2020 outlook? What arbitration will you make between the CAP, regional policy, and research?

THE PRESIDENT - You are anticipating what we will spend our nights discussing together. But first, it is about having a sufficient budget. And we will have a position that is quite close, France and Germany, allowing for both the financing of structural funds and that of the CAP. Of course, there will be tensions, discussions for this distribution, but as far as I am concerned, it is about having a reasonable envelope that will allow us to finance our commitments and our priorities. Regarding the CAP? It is, as I said, the stability of the CAP budget.

QUESTION - Mr. President, in this long struggle, in this long and slow struggle to obtain a tax on financial transactions, would you say today, at the moment of the launch of enhanced cooperation, that there is continuity, I would say, of efforts and persuasion between your predecessor Nicolas SARKOZY and you? One of your ministers said in Luxembourg recently that the file was stuck and that you have relaunched it. And regarding the allocation of the tax, you have emphasized the employment dimension a lot and less the solidarity dimension with the countries of the South.

THE PRESIDENT - That is a position we have taken in France, and that I have indeed wished on a global scale, that a part of the tax could also be for solidarity and for the fight against pandemics. Regarding the idea of the tax on financial transactions, it has been circulating for a long time, and my predecessor had also mentioned it. From that point of view, there is continuity. After that, it happens that my responsibility is to bring the tax on financial transactions to fruition. The approach we have initiated and which is now materialized is to create enhanced cooperation. I must also say that if there had not been an agreement between France and Germany on this issue, Germany having taken this position under the known domestic political conditions, if there had not been that agreement, there would not have been, in my opinion, this enhanced cooperation. There you go, ladies and gentlemen, thank you for your participation, we will see each other next month.