Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, notably on the European banking union, in Brussels on October 18, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

18 October 2012 · European Council · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on October 18, 2012, following discussions on the banking union and Greece.
Main themes
European banking union, banking supervision, European Central Bank, Greece and eurozone stability, legislative framework, bank recapitalization, ECOFIN role, European Council decisions, market confidence, single market rules
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,403
88th percentile
Sentences
183
87th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
11.6
41st percentile
Syntax
3.16
68th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

183 sentences in 60 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I congratulate you on your patience, but the European Council has taken the time it deemed appropriate to address what will be the Banking Union.

It was our intention, as expressed during the Council on June 29, to implement the first step, namely supervision, by the end of the year.

We have therefore, during this Council, confirmed and clarified what we decided last June.

Confirmed: it is indeed banking supervision.

Clarified: it will be implemented starting January 1, once the legislative framework has been adopted.

As of January 1, it will be up to the Central Bank to create the bodies, mobilize the personnel that will be dedicated to supervision, and then, once these resources have been allocated, to proceed not only with supervision but also with what is related to it, namely the recapitalization of banks.

I believe that the strength of the European Council of June 29 has had effects that we can measure today, namely not only the growth pact but also a stability that has returned to the markets, which has also been complemented by rules for intervention by the Central Bank. This European Council is once again reflected today through the Banking Union.

There was another topic that was discussed. This is the case of Greece, and the actors of the European Council, heads of state and government, considered that there had been substantial progress and that the Troika was close to an agreement, even if it has not yet been reached and there are still points to clarify. If these conditions are met, then Greece will be able to remain in the eurozone, which is our intention.

These are the two main topics on which we debated extensively. I would say on the first, Greece, the debate was short because we were all convinced that there had been progress, that there was a willingness on the part of the Greek government, that there were still a few points to settle, which will indeed be handled by the Eurogroup in the coming weeks.

I return to the Banking Union. What do we have left to do by the end of the year since there is a legislative framework to adopt? It will be up to the ECOFIN, that is to say, all the ministers of Economy and Finance of the member countries of the Union, to specify as much as possible the legislative framework and to get into all the details.

The legislative framework will be submitted for opinion to the European Parliament and can therefore be adopted during the December Council. Then, the date has been clearly specified, it is a very important point, it is on January 1, 2013, that the modalities will have been clarified and that the European Central Bank will therefore be the supervisor of the countries of the eurozone, once an agreement has been reached with the countries that are not members of the eurozone, in order to respect the rules of the single market. As of January 1, it is the European Central Bank that will put in place all the means allowing this supervision to become effective.

I consider that this Council has been consistent with that of June, has been able to translate it, and has been an important step towards the Banking Union. I had said, moreover, that the only agenda of this Council, apart from the case of Greece which was mentioned in the context of the eurozone, was the Banking Union, and this Banking Union is being established in an even faster timeframe than was anticipated in June. I remind you that in June, it was simply envisaged for the end of the year. This time, it is no longer envisaged for the end of the year; it is scheduled to come into effect within the legislative framework on January 1. This does not mean that the mechanism itself will come into effect on January 1; that will be during the year 2013, but the legislative framework, with the supervisor, will be in place on January 1.

QUESTION -- You clearly stated that the legislative framework would be in place on January 1, 2013, but effectively, banking supervision will not be in place until later in the year. So, my first question is, are you not afraid that, for example, the markets will think that Europe is still falling behind and is unable to implement the measures it has announced? And secondly, clearly, regarding Spain, particularly Spanish banks, will they be able to be recapitalized as early as January 1?

THE PRESIDENT -- So, let’s be clear. Europe is not falling behind; it is getting ahead of what it had set as its own agenda. It was not possible to go faster, in fact. How to adopt a legislative framework before the end of the year? It is very important that Europe has translated the commitment made during the Council in June and ensured that by January 1, 2013, the legislative framework is effective. But, you are right, the legislative framework in 2013 is not yet the mechanism itself in its effective translation. There, it will take several weeks, several months, and we have said during the year 2013, and the sooner the Central Bank implements these means, the sooner the recapitalization of banks will occur if necessary.

Your second question concerns Spain. Another procedure has been found for Spain, since it is through the EFSF that resources have been made available to Spanish banks but via the State. Regarding Spain, the question must be posed differently, no longer for the banking sector, but for the State itself. Is Spain planning to submit a plan? This topic was not discussed at all this evening.

QUESTION -- Do you consider that this evening represents a compromise? Were there concessions on both sides to reach this agreement? I think, for example, of Germany accepting oversight over all these banks, including regional banks? And, has there perhaps been a compromise or concessions from France or other countries regarding the timeline?

THE PRESIDENT -- A European agreement is always a compromise, and that is how I wanted to position France. Not as an ultimatum, not as a demand, but as a willingness to move forward together. I met with Mrs. MERKEL before the European Council, and we quickly agreed on what we could accept and wish for this European Council. We were on the same approach. I recall, this approach is as follows: to ensure that the legislative framework can be adopted by the end of the year, and secondly regarding banks, to take all banks, but to ensure that the national supervisor can have the capacity to do this work on behalf of the central supervisor, which has been reflected in the text we adopted this evening. I think Germany wanted there to be supervision that could be coherent, that is to say direct, it is the European Central Bank that ensures responsibility, but which could for a number of banks be initially carried out by a national supervisor, in coherence with the central supervisor.

Regarding the timeline, there was no compromise; we found ourselves on the same approach and the same position, that is to say to ensure that the legislative framework can be adopted by the end of the year. It was not a question for France to think that we could obtain the recapitalization of banks without a legislative framework. Supervision was the prerequisite for the recapitalization of banks; if there was no supervision, if there was no legislative framework, there would be no possibility to recapitalize the banks. That is why we established this timeline in perfect agreement with our German friends who understood that the Banking Union must involve steps, as did we, and that we could move as quickly as possible while also establishing quality supervision.

You remember when I met Mrs. MERKEL in Ludwigsburg, there was a debate about whether the French preferred speed while others preferred quality. We found the right compromise, to move as quickly as possible while ensuring the highest level of supervisory quality. From this point of view, a good agreement was reached this evening.

QUESTION -- At the end of the June Council, Spain hoped to recapitalize its banks directly without burdening the State's debt. Is this not ultimately a defeat for Spain today?

THE PRESIDENT -- No, Spain had agreed in June that banks could find support through the procedure that existed until then, namely the EFSF. Spain can still think that later, if necessary, a recapitalization of banks may be possible, but the prerequisite is supervision. There was no desire on the part of Spain in this discussion tonight to obtain a recapitalization of banks through a mechanism other than the one we were implementing.

However, I return to the Spanish case, because it is often raised with me. I am asked what France's position is. France's position regarding Spain is that as soon as Spain considers that it must request a plan, there is no reason to impose conditions that would add further austerity to austerity, while Spain is making all necessary efforts. But it is up to Spain alone to decide the appropriateness of requesting a plan and, of course, the timing of when it would consider doing so. For now, it has not made this request, and that would only apply to the State in this case.

QUESTION -- The German Chancellor has shown herself to be rather reluctant in recent hours regarding recapitalization and supervision. How do you explain that ultimately the compromise, according to what you just said, was relatively easy to reach?

THE PRESIDENT -- Listen, I cannot comment on a position, that of Mrs. MERKEL, but I found that as soon as I met her, she was in a mindset to be very precise, as she always is, that is to say to have steps, not to skip these steps, to respect a number of deadlines, but to move towards the Banking Union, and we easily found ourselves on the timeline as I presented it, that is to say January 1, 2013, the legislative framework adopted.

Mrs. MERKEL had made a speech about a commissioner who could have special powers. I know that this is a position that has also been put forward by Mr. SCHAUBLE; it is a German thesis that is quite respectable, but which was not discussed this evening.

In terms of budgetary union, this evening, this question was simply mentioned, through the report that Mr. VAN ROMPUY and the four presidents, plus the president of the European Parliament, must present in December. There will be a dimension on budgetary union that has been outlined; you will see it in the final communiqué, possibly through budget supplements, but which would not be a budget for the eurozone. And explorations that, for now, remain extremely general.

This evening, there was a very long debate, as you can easily understand, regarding the question of member countries of the eurozone, compared to those that are not. This was indeed the whole difficulty of the exercise. The problem was not between France and Germany; we had agreed from the start, but it was how to ensure that, as twenty-seven, we accept banking supervision with the European Central Bank for the eurozone, without the countries that are not members of the eurozone feeling either monitored by an authority they would not accept or excluded from the system. So, it was regarding the banking regulatory authority that the debates took place, the voting rights, the British being very sensitive to the preservation of their own decision, it took quite a while to reach that.

Then, regarding the question of what happens to countries that are not members of the eurozone in the deepening of the Economic and Monetary Union, there too, guarantees had to be given. And I come to this point which was very lengthy, which was to know whether the countries of the eurozone wanted to give themselves additional budgetary capacities. Would this undermine the process that will be discussed next month regarding the European budget itself?

It was very clearly established that any potential budgetary capacity that would be introduced in the deepening of the Economic and Monetary Union for the eurozone would be without effect, without impact, without link to the discussion on the budget of the twenty-seven. In other words, there is no question of having a budget for the eurozone that would be deducted from or subtracted from the European budget itself.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, you said that if Spain were to request assistance, additional austerity conditions should not be added. Not all countries seemed to be on the same page. Was this reaffirmed this evening?

THE PRESIDENT -- No, I will be clear. This is the position that France has defended since this idea has been circulating. The Spanish case, if I may say so, has not been mentioned at all. This means that Spain has not, at any point in the discussion, and I do not see why it would have, requested anything, neither as additional information nor as additional conditions. There has been no debate on Spain. Perhaps this will be discussed in the Eurogroup, I do not know, but Spain has made no request and nothing has been demanded of Spain in any way.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, you mentioned earlier that Mrs. MERKEL had given a speech about the commissioner with special powers, which is a respectable German thesis but which was not discussed this evening. Notwithstanding that, what do you think about this possibility that seems to be dear to Germany? Could it be something that will be discussed soon, in the future, and under what conditions? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- There are already sufficient procedures in what is called the fiscal treaty. We just ratified this text a few days ago, and there are still countries in the eurozone that have not voted for it. There is also the "six-pack," and soon there will be the "two-pack," which means that in terms of fiscal procedure, there is a whole arsenal, a whole set of procedures, mechanisms, and controls. As far as I am concerned, France's position is that there is no need to add more.

It would be different if we were to go further in budgetary union, which is outlined in the report of the four Presidents, that is to say, if additional resources were pooled or if eurobonds were created. Then, quite legitimately, there would be stricter controls to introduce, but we are not there yet. This is the constant position I have presented to you of solidarity integration; if there is even greater budgetary solidarity, there will be integration at a higher level as well. But that would require a treaty change because creating a super commissioner who would intervene in the preparation of budgets, or even correct those budgets, would require, as with eurobonds, a treaty change, so this perspective may exist but it is not currently on the agenda. I imagine that when Mrs. MERKEL made this presentation, it was for the future, but for now, the future has not been addressed except for banking union. This Council, as I said, was dedicated, and it was already very important, it had to be an essential step, only to banking union.

I return to the European Council of June, and we all agreed to acknowledge that it was a very important moment in European life, certainly one of the most decisive Councils in a long time. It had undoubtedly been preceded by others that had prepared mechanisms, notably the ESM, but there, the fact that we agreed on the growth pact, on stability, on the establishment of the ESM as quickly as possible, and that the central bank, which had already affirmed this during that council and confirmed it afterward, completed the system, all of this means that we are now in a position to act. But it was necessary for this system to be complemented by banking union since this crisis is both a crisis of banking behavior and excessive sovereign debts.

Excessive sovereign debts can find their solution through budgetary mechanisms, the fiscal treaty, so that states have behaviors that can lead to a reduction in deficits, which we are doing in France. But it is also necessary that sovereign debts do not have different interest rates depending on the countries. Hence the importance of having stability mechanisms. This is what could happen if the markets have the certainty that we are now robust enough to allow for the harmonization of interest rates, as interest rates have been able to decrease in Spain and Italy, and we must go even further in this direction. This is what pertains to the treatment of sovereign debts, to avoid worsening debts, to further burden deficits, it is the fiscal treaty.

For interest rates to decrease, there are the intervention mechanisms of the ESM and the central bank. But we also need to address the problem of banks to prevent banking failures from having consequences on states, and this is what is now underway with banking union. The direct recapitalization of banks is precisely what prevents states from being affected by the virus of a banking failure. We are in the process of resolving the problems that have paralyzed the eurozone for too long and made it vulnerable.

If the European Council in December confirms the decisions that have been made and, at the same time, Greece finally finds its answer and Spain has financing mechanisms that are restored to it, then we will have finished with what has weighed on the markets and on confidence in the eurozone to which banking union provides an additional element of credibility. That is why, as I said, I believe that the worst is over, but we are not finished since we have to rebuild confidence and regain growth.

This evening, I have further confirmation that the worst is over since we are in the introduction of all the regulatory mechanisms that were expected.

QUESTION -- You have partly answered in your last intervention, but to what extent will this future banking union, since European opinions are questioning the results of this Council, allow, in your view, to definitively distance the specter of the European crisis?

THE PRESIDENT -- First of all, the markets want predictability. It was very important that today's Council sent them a message that was not simply an expression of intention, of will, but the commitment to establish this banking supervision as of January 1 of next year.

What matters for a monetary zone is stability, speed in decision-making, and trust. All the procedures exist. In June, one could wonder whether the ESM would be able to come into force; there was uncertainty from the Karlsruhe court, there may have also been uncertainties regarding one ratification or another. That is over. The ESM has come into force. There was another doubt that could also have seized us, which was, "Is Greece going to exit the eurozone?" Today, we are still waiting for a definitive answer to this question, but we can see that there is a process that allows us to think that the answer will rather be Greece's maintenance in the eurozone, even if, let us be cautious, nothing is yet done.

There are no longer uncertainties on that side, neither on the mechanism nor on the failure of a country. But we also lacked this banking union, which is alongside budgetary union, alongside economic union, the indispensable pillar for the markets to regain confidence in the eurozone.

QUESTION -- Have you mentioned the social situation, the social crisis that seems to be becoming increasingly serious in Southern Europe, in Spain, Portugal, and Greece?

Has the debate on an additional deadline for the 3% been raised to relaunch growth in Europe?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, the social situation has been mentioned. First of all, by the countries concerned. It is not for me to speak on behalf of the President of the Spanish government or the Greek Prime Minister, but they described what the situation was in their countries, notably the Greek Prime Minister regarding the protests that took place today and which were mourned by the death of one of those protesting against the measures that are currently being imposed on the population.

Secondly, many intervened, not just the heads of government of the countries most affected by the social crisis, but we are all affected by the economic crisis since we are all interconnected. There is no division; there should not be a division within Europe. I fight for there to be no barriers, no borders, no walls between countries that supposedly are doing well or less badly than others and those that are in recession. We are all concerned. Several heads of government, beyond my own interventions, insisted on the risk of recession but also on political and social difficulties, and what lessons to draw from this regarding growth and deficit perspectives? Should we give up on achieving our objectives? No, but at the same time, we have rules within the European Union, which are to consider that it is in relation to the structural deficit that it is appropriate to reason. But, to answer your question very precisely, this issue of deficits, growth and its consequences, recession and its impacts, was not addressed as such during our discussions. Everything was focused on banking union. That will come later if necessary; the objective is first to restore confidence because that is the prerequisite for growth. It is also to ensure that countries that are affected by very high interest rates can be relieved of this burden as soon as possible, which will allow them to regain maneuvering room. Because what is absurd is that countries that are required to respect deficit reduction bear, moreover, higher interest rates than others. This means that there is almost a rent for the countries deemed the most virtuous, a rent since those countries have very low or even negative interest rates while the countries making the most efforts and already affected by recession bear very high interest rates. With banking union, with the rules of the ESM, with the mechanisms provided by the European Central Bank, we will be able to reduce interest rate differentials.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, do you plan to go to Oslo next December to receive the Nobel Peace Prize as Herman VAN ROMPUY invited you to do today?

THE PRESIDENT -- Those who will receive the Nobel Peace Prize are the three presidents, that is to say, the President of the European Parliament, the President of the European Council, and the President of the European Commission. The heads of state and government have been invited. I spoke about it with Mrs. MERKEL in our meeting, and if all the heads of state and government have the same intention, then yes, we will go.

But it is not us who will receive this prize.

I would say that this prize rewards those who made Europe: the heads of government, the heads of state of the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s, and even 1980s, those who led the community institutions, presidents of the European Parliament, presidents of the European Commission. The heads of state today, the heads of government who are in office, have only one duty: to pull Europe out of the crisis, to give confidence to the people, to open up hope. That is the prize they must seek, and that prize requires surely efforts but also a great sense of European interest.

What has been demonstrated by our predecessors is a capacity at a moment to prioritize Europe over a national issue or a history that may have been painful, or an interest.

Do we still have that will, that capacity, that sense of the European ideal? That is the whole question.

I find that, for several months, there has been an acknowledgment of this European interest; it is difficult, it is tough, it is long, but it is happening. I believe that this Nobel Prize, which has been awarded for the past, obliges the heads of state and government of the present to be aware of their responsibility for the future. It is a prize that honors, it is a prize that obliges.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, less than a month ago, here in Brussels, the Chinese Prime Minister spoke of two regrets with Europe before retiring: first, recognizing the status of a market economy and second, lifting the arms sales embargo. These two regrets of this Prime Minister have often been discussed, but there has never really been any progress within the European Union. What are your views and what is France's attitude? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- France's attitude is that Europe should speak with one voice with China on a number of issues, those you mentioned, and others in the commercial and monetary fields, with the utmost respect for China, and with the greatest sense of interest for Europe. Avoiding dispersion, Europe is a great power that must speak with as much coherence as possible to a great country like China. This is what we will agree on tomorrow.

QUESTION -- This is a topic that I think has not necessarily been addressed at the European Council, but your Minister for Productive Recovery is featured today, since it is the 19th, on the cover of Parisien Magazine wearing a "made in France" striped shirt while showcasing a "made in France" blender and a "made in France" watch. Does this prompt any comments from you? Is this the new dress code for the Council of Ministers next week? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- I see that he is ready to wear all the necessary clothing to promote French products. I think it's good, not just to be in a patriotic assertion, but to promote French production as it has appeared in the presidential campaign, and not just through my own expression; I remember that Nicolas SARKOZY, François BAYROU, and others had spoken about it.

What needs to be done? Improve our competitiveness, ensure the preservation of a number of industrial tools, create the public investment bank... I find it very good that Arnaud MONTEBOURG is fully committed to the accomplishment of this mission.