Press conference of Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, notably on the situation in Syria and Mali and on Iranian nuclear issues, in New York on September 25, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

25 September 2012 · Press conference · New York

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the UN General Assembly in New York on September 25, 2012, covering Syria, Iran, Mali, and development issues.
Main themes
Syrian civil war and alternative government, Iranian nuclear sanctions, Sahel security and terrorism, UN Security Council reform, development financing, financial transaction tax, drug and arms trafficking, climate change conference, death penalty abolition, decriminalization of homosexuality, UN reform
Duration
~37 min
89th percentile
Words
4,459
89th percentile
Sentences
241
92nd percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

241 sentences in 65 paragraphs

I would first like to extend my sincerest apologies for the delay, which is not solely due to my own will, as the speech I was supposed to deliver around 12:00, 12:30, was only given just now, which has delayed our meeting. I have been here since last night. My first meeting was with the Secretary-General of the United Nations, with whom I had dinner along with the ministers accompanying me, primarily Laurent Fabius.

Already last night, we discussed the three major topics: Syria, Iran, and the Sahel. In my remarks, I wanted to revisit these by highlighting the role of the United Nations, which sometimes allows us to make progress, as we will see regarding the Sahel, sometimes helps us to apply pressure, as we can say for the sanctions that will need to be decided again regarding Iran. But also, a Security Council that, being blocked, does not allow for the decisions that are awaited for Syria. This brings us back to the question of UN reform, which is an old theme, an old debate, but whose relevance we can clearly see today. On the one hand, we need to expand the Security Council, to make it more representative of the reality of the world, and at the same time, to hold the permanent members accountable for their own responsibilities.

I also wanted to take this opportunity to make a call for development. France has therefore taken several initiatives.

The first is to make ourselves available for the conference that could find the most important decisions on climate. This is scheduled for 2015.

The second initiative is regarding innovative financing. Just as UNITAID was able to mobilize funds through the tax on airline tickets, which is credited to Jacques Chirac, we can think that the tax on financial transactions, one that the Europeans, not all, but enough for a strengthened cooperation, and the alliance between France and Germany has worked perfectly, could be the instrument that would serve to finance development and also the fight against pandemics and health crises.

Finally, I wanted to emphasize several issues that are not sufficiently mentioned, including at the United Nations. The first issue is drug trafficking. We are not starting from scratch. A number of decisions have been made, referred to as the "Paris Pact." But we must go much further in the fight against trafficking that destabilizes certain states. Producer states, I will not name them, you know them, but also transit states, and this relates to the question of the Sahel. In the Sahel, terrorists engage in both drug trafficking and arms trafficking, and sometimes other trafficking. The fight against trafficking, drug trafficking, arms trafficking, must be a major concern for the world and certainly a priority for France.

I also mentioned the protection of fundamental freedoms, particularly the death penalty, the abolition of the death penalty, which remains an issue for France that must be addressed. This does not only target the poorest countries. Then, the decriminalization of homosexuality because we cannot accept that there are, again, a number of legislations that are an infringement on human rights.

These are the main issues I wanted to highlight to open this press conference. I am at your disposal for questions.

QUESTION -- Welcome, Mr. President. You just told us that France will be able to recognize the provisional government of Syria. Qatar has proposed a no-fly zone. Is this one of the first two countries you wish to contact in the context of the meeting with the friends of Syria at the end of the week?

THE PRESIDENT -- Regarding Syria, France was one of the first countries to wish for an alternative government to be formed, bringing together all the components that are currently engaged in the fight against the regime. This idea, which was not initially received as it should have been, because there are many groups, is in my view a stimulus for things to move much faster and for this government to be constituted with representative personalities, one of whom could be the head of government. This would be a powerful means, including at the Security Council, in relation to countries that today defend not the regime but the status quo, thinking that there could be a risk after Assad's collapse. This would be proof that we could provide that there is a solution for post-Assad.

Secondly, with whom to work? With everyone, that is to say with those who are friends of Syria -- I remind you that we gathered them at the beginning of July, Laurent Fabius took the initiative. There will be other meetings of the friends of Syria, we will be there -- and we must include all countries that want to contribute to the formation of an alternative government.

I also discussed this with President Morsi since you know that there was a four-party initiative taken, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Turkey, and Egypt. Again, we told him that we think this is a good initiative but that it must be added to others.

QUESTION -- You have called for the UN to protect the areas liberated by the opposition. Can you clarify what you wish? What do you mean by this protection? Would it involve military intervention? And of what kind?

THE PRESIDENT -- There are today liberated areas both in the North and in the South, which are sometimes occupied by the armed opposition, the Syrian Liberation Army, and sometimes also serve as refuges for those who have been displaced. We want the UN to ensure the security of these areas. Again, this falls under the Security Council, but we believe that it is both necessary to protect the populations and also a means to allow for a political transition process.

On this concept of liberated areas, we continue to work. Again, I received the King of Jordan, who alerted me to the considerable health risks in the coming weeks because part of the population, particularly in the south of Damascus, could be deprived of water and electricity during the winter. And so, we clearly see the urgency. We were the first, France, to engage in humanitarian aid. I remind you of what we did precisely in Jordan, by deploying a field hospital. We want to emphasize the areas that could indeed be protected as it is also about ensuring that refugees, those who could be deprived of water and electricity, have means of subsistence in the coming weeks.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, Mali is one of your priorities. You just reiterated that. You support the initiative of Africans to set up a force to allow Mali to regain its sovereignty over its entire territory and to fight against jihadist groups. Have you set a red line, limits on the aid that France could provide to these military efforts? We are currently talking about logistical support. Are you ready to go further to combat a threat that directly targets France? Are you ready, in short, to put men on the ground to achieve this objective?

THE PRESIDENT -- Mali is the subject I have been aware of since my arrival in office. The occupation of the North was already a fact, but it has become structured. It happened that for several weeks, due to the coup that had occurred, there were divisions within Malian political society, an impossibility to act despite our efforts. We have just crossed a very important step thanks to the action we have been able to take with others, which is that the President and Prime Minister of Mali have sent a letter officially seizing ECOWAS of the intervention requested by Mali to reclaim the North.

Tomorrow, we will have a meeting with the Secretary-General of the United Nations to organize what the response could be. It is the Africans who, through the African Union, through ECOWAS, will decide on this operation, not on its appropriateness, that is already established, but there will still need to be a Security Council resolution on which we are starting to work. There was already a first one, and we are preparing a second.

Then you ask me about what the support of France would be. It will be a political support, it will be a logistical support, it will be a material support, but it is up to the Africans to carry out the intervention and the reconquest of the North.

QUESTION -- Regarding Syria, you speak of UN protection for the liberated areas. The Emir of Qatar speaks of an Arab intervention force and no-fly zones. Have you spoken with Qatar? Is there any consultation on this? A second point, regarding sanctions on Iran, what will the new sanctions bring?

THE PRESIDENT -- We are of course speaking with Qatar but not only with Qatar. We are speaking with all those who have a role in protecting the population. I mentioned Jordan. I spoke about Turkey. We are talking with Lebanon, but it must be within the framework of the United Nations that we could engage this protection. You saw that earlier I referred to a UN decision regarding the protection of civilians. This could also be considered in that context because we are talking about civilians. It is up to the UN and all those who are friends of Syria to work on this so that we can ensure this protection of the liberated areas.

As for Iran, sanctions exist, they can and must even be strengthened. As long as Iran does not resolve to provide us with information, or even continues its enrichment programs, the sanctions must therefore be raised further, not, as I said earlier, to punish the great Iranian people but to compel the leaders to return to the negotiating table. Sometimes it is said that sanctions have no consequences. Today, the figures we are given estimate these consequences at about 50 billion euros. It has effects, not yet what we hope for, but we will go all the way, because if we were to give up imposing additional sanctions, what would that mean? It would mean that Iran could continue its program? But if Iran continues its program, it is a risk of access to nuclear weapons. Everyone knows that this will not be accepted, so it is a risk of war. Sanctions are what allows us to return to negotiation.

QUESTION -- Regarding Mali, does support for a military intervention pose even greater risks to French hostages? Is this intervention also a message to the kidnappers, namely that France would not be willing to yield to all financial demands?

THE PRESIDENT -- The hostages, unfortunately, have been held for more than two years, that is to say before the occupation by terrorist forces in northern Mali. Then, we believe that the necessity of freeing our hostages must not come at the cost of renouncing to ensure the integrity of Mali. That is why we spare no effort to find our hostages while also fulfilling our international obligations to fight against terrorism and also against the occupation of a state, part of a state, by groups that call themselves fundamentalist.

I have therefore met, as you know, with the families of the hostages, and that is the message I conveyed to them, saying that we would do everything to free our nationals.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, to return to the protection of the liberated areas, concretely how do we protect these liberated areas? Does this mean that we need a no-fly zone, that the United Nations is considering this? What does it mean to logistically support those who hold the liberated areas?

THE PRESIDENT -- First of all, we now have an assessment of the situation in Syria, meaning that there is a different situation perhaps from what existed a few weeks or months ago. Parts of Syrian territory are now in the hands of the opposition or have been reclaimed by the population or from which the authorities in Damascus have withdrawn. We have this knowledge of the territory, and we must therefore begin to protect these areas. This will be done through logistical support, as you mentioned, can this be done through a no-fly zone? For now, we are not there yet, but we are working on it with our partners so that we can do it effectively.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, I wanted to return to another question. President Obama strongly condemned the anti-Islam video that provoked the terrible incidents we know. But he also said that the American Constitution guarantees freedom of the press and expression. I would like to know your feelings about these words and statements from President Obama and what your position is?

THE PRESIDENT -- I approved these words because they were those of President Obama, President of the United States, but they could be those of all heads of state and government who, in a democracy, must uphold freedom of the press while ensuring that no one feels threatened in our respective countries for their religion or beliefs.

So we do not have the same rules in different countries. For us, it is secularism that allows us to ensure this respect. He also had this phrase that I found accurate, which is that images and films circulate through multiple channels, through technology, without the need to place responsibility on states.

This is what we must remind ourselves each time: freedom of the press means that those who are journalists, who are cartoonists, can do things without asking for permission. But I must say that, for France, even though there has been a debate on this subject, we have seen the maturity with which representatives of the Muslim faith have reacted in France. The failure of all the demonstrations, which were moreover prohibited, has demonstrated this.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, I am a journalist at the New York Times. You have already said twice that it is up to the Security Council to guarantee security in the liberated areas of Syria, but the UN, and in particular the Security Council, has not managed to agree on anything regarding Syria for 18 months. How will the members of the Council overcome their differences to authorize this type of protection?

THE PRESIDENT -- If we have not managed to make a decision until now, it is because two countries in particular have blocked three times through the use of the veto. So we must approach this differently. That does not mean we will not return to the Security Council when we deem it necessary, but it means ensuring the protection of civilians, which the General Assembly can also wish for. And then, there is what the neighbors can do as they are directly concerned, and what we can provide them in terms of assistance in all forms.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, we know that Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas will ask the UN on Thursday to recognize Palestine as a non-member observer state at the UN. How does France view this request? What is France's position? Will France play a more significant role in reviving negotiations between the Palestinians and Israel?

THE PRESIDENT -- First, I do not know when Mahmoud Abbas will make this request. I will see him this afternoon, so I will know more. If he were to go in this direction, it could only be after the General Assembly, so it will take time, and it will depend on the resolution he submits. I believe that nothing should prevent negotiation. That is the objective of France. It is to ensure that the process, which is currently stalled, can resume.

How? First, by supporting the Palestinian Authority, including financially, as it is in a very degraded state, not due to its own actions but due to a number of withdrawals of donations. Secondly, by ensuring that there can be the lifting of certain preconditions on the Israeli side. The Palestinians themselves have lifted preconditions. I will continue to tell them that this negotiation must take place without preconditions.

Finally, there will be a number of initiatives that I imagine will be taken after the American elections.

QUESTION -- Do you prefer Mitt Romney or Barack Obama?

THE PRESIDENT -- What do you think?

QUESTION -- Are you sensitive to the fact that Mitt Romney, in his campaign meetings, constantly criticizes socialist Europe?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, that is why I will refrain from saying anything. Because you can imagine, if a socialist were to support one of the two candidates, what it could cost him. If I were to hold back, I could support Mitt Romney. I will not do so, however.

QUESTION -- Last question, Mr. President. Do you disapprove of the fact that Barack Obama, during his stay in New York today, did not meet any of the leaders of the international community? Do you have anything to say about that?

THE PRESIDENT -- No, I think everyone understands. Barack Obama is campaigning. He came to give a speech, a speech that corresponded to the expectations placed on the United States during this period, and we will have the opportunity for other meetings. What matters is to be able to see him after November, I imagine.

QUESTION -- Your ambassador to Syria was on the radio last week. He said that you instructed him to get in touch with the rebels, including the insurgents. And on that, he said that one possibility would be to arm the rebels in the long term. He did not provide the context, but that it was being evaluated by France. In what context could this happen?

THE PRESIDENT -- Which ambassador are you talking about? There can be several.

QUESTION -- Mr. Chevalier, the former ambassador to Syria.

THE PRESIDENT -- Regarding weapons, you know our position. There is an embargo. We respect it. However, we provide non-lethal material. We have said this, and we are ensuring that those who supply weapons, because there are some, to the Syrian regime can be denounced and prevented.

QUESTION -- You are going to see the Lebanese Prime Minister. Are you still concerned that Iran, through Hezbollah, is helping to extend the Syrian conflict into Lebanon? And what are you going to tell him?

THE PRESIDENT -- This question is indeed related to the previous one. It is clear that we have all the evidence that Iran is intervening through material means and human resources in Syria, and that is unacceptable. I will see the President, and that only makes sense in relation to this general reflection. I will see the Lebanese Prime Minister. I had already met the President, and France's will is that Lebanon be protected as much as possible from this conflict because there could indeed be interests on the part of the Syrian regime to destabilize Lebanon. For now, that has not been the case, or more precisely, the Lebanese have managed to respond in the best possible way. I will therefore support all the efforts of the Lebanese President, the Lebanese Prime Minister, including his opposition, to ensure that this spirit of national unity is preserved.

QUESTION -- You spoke about the reactions to the film and the cartoons. Last year, all member states, including France, signed a resolution stating that there should be legal provisions that sanction incitement to criminal violence. What can be done to ease tensions? Could we be more sensitive to the requests of Muslim leaders around the world to stop this movement?

THE PRESIDENT -- We must especially distinguish between what pertains to the press, its freedom, the caricature that can touch on all beliefs, and what constitutes incitement to hatred and violence. It is this confusion that would be extremely dangerous and would not serve anyone. This does not mean that we cannot sometimes lament certain excesses. But what is very important is to be able to enlighten peoples, regardless of their religion, about what the rules are in a democracy, which ultimately serve as protection for all. It is this separation that must be clearly established. On the other hand, incitement to hatred, calls for violence, intolerance, and demonstrations that come, including in our countries, to challenge property, even people, cannot be tolerated or accepted. I believe that the countries in democratic transition, which I spoke about, have had reactions that have been well understood as precisely not yielding to these provocations, as was the case in Libya.

I want to commend the Libyan authorities who, unfortunately, after the tragedies of Benghazi, have fought more against terrorist groups or groups that may have had some influence on what happened in Benghazi.

QUESTION -- This was your first speech at the United Nations General Assembly. How did you feel, how did you experience it? On the other hand, you are in New York abroad, away from France during a complicated week in the hexagon, not only with unemployment figures, the threshold of 3 million unemployed being crossed tomorrow, the budget being announced on Friday, how are you experiencing this stay?

THE PRESIDENT -- First, I want to reassure you, I will return to France. I will not settle here for more than two and a half days, three days, and I will be back by Thursday morning to prepare the presentation of the budget on Friday and ensure that all the measures we have already undertaken, those we are preparing, particularly for employment, can be implemented. But it was very important for me to come here to New York for this speech. What would people have thought if I had not done it?

Moreover, it was the first speech since, I remind you, I have only been elected for four months. I could not give last year's speech, but I will give next year's. It was very important for me to come because it was essential for the member countries of the UN to know well what France's position is.

And in addition, I wanted to make several announcements. The first was about the Sahel because it can be a concrete translation of our commitment and our work in favor of this region of Africa.

The second was about innovative financing; I wanted the United Nations podium to clearly hear what our priority is and how we want to finance development. It is both a French tradition; I recalled what had been initiated by my predecessors, and it is a will that I carry through not only the tax on financial transactions but its allocation for development and for the fight against health scourges.

As for the rest, you know, in the functions that are mine, there is a part, on diplomacy, on international life, on defense, to which I dedicate the necessary time; it is useful time because France must be present around the world. This does not exempt me from doing my duty to conduct France's policy. I have set the course for recovery; we have the obligation, I will return to this, to restore the economy, competitiveness, and public accounts. This must be the guiding thread with the attention that I have to improve the lives of our fellow citizens. That is to say, I do nothing that could divert me from this objective. That is the meaning of the mandate that is mine. But I will have the opportunity, upon my return to France on Thursday, to answer all your questions about domestic policy.

QUESTION -- Regarding what you said about the Security Council, you mentioned Germany, Japan, India, and Brazil, which deserve to sit there. You also spoke of African countries that should sit there. Do you have an idea of which countries should become permanent members? The President of Egypt, whom you just met, had very strong words against the Security Council in Tehran a few days ago. He said it does not represent the world. What is your response to that?

THE PRESIDENT -- I said it, the Security Council, in its current form, does not reflect what the world is today. New economic powers have emerged. There are countries that represent very large populations. There are continents that are asking to take their place. So the reform of the Security Council is more than ever on the agenda.

I mentioned the four countries that have long made the request and that France has always supported; I mentioned Africa, which is asking for two permanent members. We also see the constraints. We are not going to make the Security Council a replica of the General Assembly. This discussion must take place. This reform of the UN is very important. Can we immediately reach the objective? Are there not transitional phases, rotations? Everything must be put on the table. The worst thing is to remain with what we know today.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, the world's leading oil producer, Saudi Arabia, is on our side, with the West, in the Iranian crisis. The Iranians scare them in the Syrian crisis. But at the same time, the Saudis have long played a double game by financially supporting Islamic movements, Salafist movements that are at war against the West, against Israel, against the United States. Is it not time to tell the Saudis some home truths?

THE PRESIDENT -- Every time I meet heads of state or government, I warn them about what a complacent attitude towards movements whose intentions we cannot be sure of could be, including regarding Syria, where we must not, under the pretext of supporting the Syrians to free themselves from Bashar al-Assad, immediately provide material that could then be turned against the populations and against states. It is a principle of absolute vigilance that we have established with all our interlocutors who, sometimes out of haste, might have this reflex.

I also mentioned this in relation to the Sahel because sometimes there can be humanitarian causes that can be exploited by movements, which then use this aid to act in a way that is contrary to peace. Generally speaking, we really must be uncompromising because what is happening in the Sahel, I return to this, is not just the destabilization of Mali, it is the entire region. It happens that this region is one where there are weapons as a result of what happened in Libya, where there is drug trafficking, hence the importance of the objective I have set to combat trafficking, and where there are poor populations who may be tempted to rally to these causes or captured to serve as human shields. Therefore, there is an absolute necessity to warn the states that want to finance a number of causes.

So, ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much for all these questions.