Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on community institutions, the situation in Ukraine, Iraq, and Syria, and on economic policy at the European level, in Brussels on August 30, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

30 August 2014 · European Summit · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the Brussels European Council on August 30, 2014, covering EU institutional appointments, the Ukraine crisis, and economic policy.
Main themes
EU leadership appointments, Ukraine crisis, sanctions and dialogue with Russia, European Council summit, Syria and Iraq situation, Donald Tusk presidency, Federica Mogherini appointment, European economic policy, Russia-separatist involvement, Normandy format diplomacy
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,334
88th percentile
Sentences
201
89th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.96
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

201 sentences in 53 paragraphs

The European Summit this evening was to invest two personalities, one to lead the foreign policy of the European Union, the other to preside over the European Council. And it was undoubtedly the quickest decision one could imagine, as the debate was reduced to a few minutes given how much preparation had been done in advance.

This was all the more necessary as the European Council was taking place in a particularly heavy international context, with what is happening in Ukraine but also in Syria, Iraq, and what occurred in Gaza over several weeks. It was also important to show that all the Council's attention should be focused on the economic situation and the appointments that need to be set to address it in the best way, in the interest of the peoples and of Europe itself.

Regarding the appointments, there have been numerous consultations for several days, if not several weeks. I had hoped that a consensual approach could be found for the presidency of the European Council.

For the position of High Representative, several countries had set as a condition that, since the presidency of the Commission was held by Jean-Claude JUNCKER, who is a friend but a member of the EPP, it was a socialist's turn to hold the position of High Representative. Just this morning, I gathered the social-democratic leaders of Europe to discuss the economic situation, obviously regarding Ukraine but also concerning the issue of appointments. And we had agreed to support Mrs. MOGHERINI.

For the presidency of the European Council, this consensus approach could not be a partisan affair; it was about choosing a personality who could unite and embody. Unite beyond their own party or political family, unite beyond geography, and also unite to embody, embody Europe in all its dimensions, embody Europe in the expression of its values, embody Europe in its political demands. Several personalities could fit this profile, and it was Donald TUSK on whom the consensus was reached. Why? Because first, he has experience; he has been the head of his government for 7 years. Then because he has a history that is that of Solidarnosc, also because he represents a large country, Poland, with which France has had long-standing historical and human relations. And finally, because in this context, there was a concern to balance the geography of European representation.

The President of the Commission is Luxembourgish, the High Representative is Italian, the President of the European Central Bank is Italian, so there was a desire to place at the head of the European Council a country that has recently joined the Union, 10 years ago, and which by its history embodies enlargement, but an enlargement that is not simply an extension, an enlargement of the values of Europe, and Poland particularly represents them. That is why it was ultimately quite easy after the attempt in July to choose the two personalities who will embody the European Union with the President of the Commission for the coming years.

Thus, the main focus of the debate was on Ukraine. Why? Because there is an even stronger tension than there was a few days or weeks ago. We received President POROCHENKO, and his testimony was useful. Everything suggests that not only is Russia helping the separatists, which is not new, but that important, sophisticated materials have been provided, and there is likely, even if the evidence has not yet been gathered, the presence (let's say) of advisors, to say more, Russians with the separatists.

As a result, there is an escalation, and there must be an appropriate European response. This response is both firmness and dialogue, and that is what France has always done since the beginning of this crisis. Firmness means sanctions that not only must be pronounced, they have been, but applied fully, sustainably, as long as necessary. Then, these sanctions can be increased; the European Commission and Mrs. ASHTON have been asked to work on this and to provide a response within the week, so that the 28 can express themselves. That is firmness. But there is always the possibility of dialogue, since on Monday there will be a meeting of the contact group. Interesting elements have already occurred in Minsk; President POROCHENKO met with President PUTIN, and I myself spoke with the Russian president. So dialogue is always possible, but there must still be a basis for dialogue and, above all, there must be a conclusion. That is why there must be no loss of time. There can be no suspension of this dialogue or a postponement on the pretext that the Russian president is making a trip, while there are deaths happening right now in Ukraine and there could be many more in the coming days.

Sanctions are not meant to punish; they are meant to prevent, to bring the Russians, the Russian authorities back to dialogue. You know that we have been talking about a Normandy format since June 6; this format is still possible, and I have indicated this to Vladimir PUTIN. And this format can only be valid if there is an outcome to the discussion and negotiation. There are still major risks of escalation; we have already reached a particularly dangerous point, which must be the ultimate point. Beyond that, what is it? It is the chain of military operations, it is the unleashing of armed forces, it is one provocation leading to another, and it is an overflow that will become increasingly difficult to contain.

This crisis is not simply for Eastern Europe; it is for the world when it comes to Europe, its borders, and a large country like Russia. There has been a long discussion because there is always the same question: are sanctions useful, effective, do they have an impact? But that is not how the subject should simply be posed. If there are no sanctions, what happens? It is military operations that will have to be carried out; who imagines that? And if nothing happens, if nothing is decided, then that would mean that with complete impunity a country can see its territorial integrity challenged, its unity severely affected, and that on the margins of Europe, with a country that is now associated with Europe, there are military operations being conducted? Therefore, the path, the solution, and I defended this position at the European Council, in full agreement with Angela MERKEL and others, is to move towards sanctions.

The other subject discussed, still on the international level, was Iraq, Syria, and the coordination of efforts to assist threatened populations and to also combat the Islamic State. You know that France has made a proposal, has taken an initiative: the conference that could be held, that will be held on Iraq and the fight against the Islamic State. The European Union, the European Council has approved this approach and this initiative. Similarly, it was deemed essential to continue humanitarian aid and to allow countries that want to and can, to provide arms to states, in this case Iraq, or to groups fighting against the Islamic State. So there was unanimity in the Council and a desire to take into account a threat that goes well beyond the region concerned, particularly with these fighters who leave our countries and then commit atrocities, acts of barbarism, and can return to commit others on our own territory.

We also talked about Libya. At the Conference of Ambassadors, I had wished for the United Nations to be seized of the appeal that had been launched by the Libyan Parliament, the only legitimate one, for the international community to take its responsibilities in Libya. In what form? First, to help rebuild the Libyan state and also to fight against the terrorist groups that destabilize this country. But not just Libya; the entire West Africa and even Central Africa, because there are links between all terrorist groups, notably Boko Haram with the terrorists located in the South of Libya.

There is also the Ebola dossier that was addressed by the European Council to help the countries there again, to ensure that they can face this epidemic. Their economy is very damaged by the obligations placed upon them to protect populations and to prevent certain exchanges. We want there to always be the possibility for these countries, of course, to fight against the disease, against its spread, but to still be able to live with an open economy, and that is the whole difficulty. We have also ensured to protect European nationals and to have, as much as necessary, the essential monitoring.

These are the subjects we addressed on the international level, but there is another that also calls for our concern, which is the low growth in Europe, very low inflation, and very high unemployment. This observation is undeniable; it is unfortunately general. And even if some countries are in recession, few but there are, we have seen in the second quarter that others are barely achieving 1 or 1.5% growth, the average is around 0.5, as we have seen in France for the second quarter, and everywhere, inflation has reached a historic low point. So there is indeed a European problem that could be characterized by insufficient demand. It is not a matter of denying the efforts that each country must engage in, particularly reforms to improve competitiveness, which is what I am doing in France with the government, or controlling our public accounts. But as much as there are supply problems that need to be addressed at the national level, at the European level it is a demand problem.

To be able to make the right decisions, there will be three major meetings that will take place. The first at the beginning of October in Italy, at the request of Matteo RENZI, who is currently holding the presidency of the European Union, the rotating presidency. There will be a Summit for employment, and thus growth, where we will take stock of what has already been planned, for youth employment in particular, or for the use of structural funds and what we still have to do. It will also be an opportunity to assess the economic situation and the first decisions of the European Central Bank that are expected for September.

There will be a second stage at the end of October, first a European Council on the 23rd, then a Eurozone Council, which is what I had requested to develop a strategy and ask the new Commission to prepare its proposals. They could be presented at a European Council in November, with Jean-Claude JUNCKER being able to then support the investment plan of 300 billion euros that he mentioned before the European Parliament, both the content of this plan, the timeline, and the financing.

I also mentioned the other responsibilities that must now be clarified by the President of the Commission. You know that there is the Eurogroup; the decision has been made to postpone this question at least until 2015. And then there is the composition of the European Commission and the responsibilities that may fall to the personalities that make it up. I remind you that France has presented Pierre MOSCOVICI and that I have argued, given what France represents in the European Union, that an economic responsibility should be entrusted to him. But it is up to Jean-Claude JUNCKER to make his choices, since he is the President of the European Commission and the President alone of the European Commission who has the capacity to decide. Then, it is the European Parliament that approves the entire college.

In conclusion, it was an important Council. Why? Because Europe was expected; it was a meeting. Would it be able to appoint its highest officials without these hours and hours of discussions, negotiations, trades, exchanges, compromises? It was able to achieve this because Europe is aware of its responsibility.

Then there was a second question: in the face of Ukraine, would it be the observation of lamentation but at the same time of powerlessness? No, Europe affirmed that there are situations that cannot be tolerated at its borders, or more broadly, not accepted in a country that has democratic institutions, where the people have voted, and where there is a rule that imposes itself, which is territorial integrity.

Finally, there was a last question: is Europe clear-sighted, is it aware that there is an economic problem that particularly affects it? This problem is called unemployment, it is called low growth, it is called insufficient recovery, it is called lack of demand, it is also called for several countries insufficient competitiveness or reforms that have not yet reached their objectives. So Europe this evening was at the rendezvous.

Good evening, Mr. President, François BEAUDONNET, FRANCE 2. A question about sanctions. In fact, I had understood that the European Commission had already prepared a number of sanctions. From what you said, I believe that is not the case; the European Commission would have a week to do so. Can you clarify how this will happen, what the timeline is, and how a potential decision will then be made? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT

These are good questions, so I will try to provide answers. First, yes, the Commission has been preparing a number of decisions for several weeks that were only to be taken if there was escalation. The second point is that the time given to the Commission is particularly short, one week. I remind you that in a few days there is the NATO meeting, so it would be better if the sanctions could be specified by the time we meet with non-European partners. The third point is whether this new scale of sanctions will need to be decided by a Council? Yes, not necessarily a European Council; it could be a Council of Ministers or a Council of Permanent Representatives. But there will necessarily be a meeting of Europeans to formalize a new scale of sanctions.

QUESTION

Catherine CHATIGNOUX, Les ECHOS. You mentioned three economic summits in the coming weeks. When do you think the potential question of adapting the pace of deficit reduction to the economic situation will be raised, or even discussed? Isn’t it going to be a bit late in relation to the preparation of the French budget for 2015?

THE PRESIDENT

European rules do not necessarily have to be viewed in relation to national calendars.

We have our own calendar; we are not asking for anything for ourselves in particular; we are asking that the flexibilities can be maximized in the application of the rules for the pace of deficit reduction. From there, in September, since we have this calendar for the presentation of our finance law, we will have discussions with the European authorities, with the Commission in particular. In October, the first meeting will be a finding that will likely reveal the exceptional nature of the situation, given the very low inflation. And as I told you, we will also have the decisions of the European Central Bank, which are normally expected in September. At the end of October, this will be a strategy that is that of Europe, meaning investment strategy, growth strategy, mobilization of funds for employment, use of loans from the EIB, perhaps others. President JUNCKER is currently thinking about how he can mobilize funds that are not really being used at the moment; I will leave him to advance on that, and it will be in the meeting in November.

Why is there this timeline? Because first, the European Central Bank must play its role; that is monetary policy. Then there are adjustments in terms of budgetary policy; there is the priority question of employment and what it justifies in terms of fund usage. And then it is after that we can define the economic strategy of Europe and with the corresponding means, hence the summit also in November with the new Commission. The whole problem was that in October, we were with a Commission whose mandate is ending, while the new one cannot yet put forward its proposals. That explains this timeline.

QUESTION

Mr. President, a question about the appointment of Mr. Donald TUSK. We understood your collective choice; you have adorned him with many qualities. What strikes observers here is that Mr. TUSK does not speak either English or French. As for the language of SHAKESPEARE, he told us very quickly earlier that he would amend that; he said nothing about the French language. This is the first time that for such a high-level position, the chosen individual does not speak any of the official languages of the European Union. My question is the following: does this fight for Francophonie in international institutions belong to a "has-been" struggle?

THE PRESIDENT

I do not understand the last word of your question, so I will ask for a translation. There are translators here, there are interpreters; it is a profession. I am in favor of maintaining employment; otherwise, it would mean that everyone should speak the same language, and which one would that be? Soon, you will tell us that we should only speak one language that would not necessarily be French, but that was not provided for in our treaties. So Mr. TUSK said he would learn other languages besides those he speaks, namely not only Polish but also German, and that he would have accelerated training in French and English. Of course, I am very sensitive to the use of the French language, but I did not want to make it a criterion because I consider that for a country like Poland, it would have been a form of hindrance, unless we say that one must absolutely speak English. So from there, I think that his first reaction, he knew that this observation could be made to him; I even wonder if it was not made to him by some heads of state or government, he immediately said that he would use the three months given to him for this accelerated training. But I will continue to speak to him in French.

QUESTION

Good evening, Mr. President, Camille LANGLADE, ITELE. You wanted to bring here the voice of social democrats to call for a shift in European policy, but the difficult week your government has just experienced and the displayed divisions within the Socialist Party today in La Rochelle, one of your ministers who is aligning with the dissenters who openly criticize your policy, does all this not contribute to weakening your voice and France's position in Europe?

THE PRESIDENT

I have the exact opposite feeling, not that we should rejoice in what happened in the past week, because these were necessary decisions, but they might not have been taken if behaviors had not justified them. But the clarification that occurred, the coherence, the cohesion, the message I wanted to convey, which is to continue on the line I had set, the pact of responsibility and solidarity, modernization but at the same time justice, all of this has been understood as rather a strengthening of the French position. In the same way that foreign policy, the one I express on behalf of France, serves Europe and allows us to mobilize our partners on major issues. We have shown this for Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Africa, and Ukraine. So I think France is fully in its role. And what I also did this morning by bringing together social democrats, for the second time, the social democrats having also entrusted me with this mission to ensure that we can find solutions today at the European Council, was an additional sign of confidence given to France and to the one who represents it.

QUESTION

I had a question regarding the various conflicts that are ongoing at our borders. On Ukraine, have you had a bilateral meeting with President POROCHENKO? Is there a request for the delivery of military equipment that was made to France, is this a request you could or will be able to fulfill? On Iraq, regarding the delivery of military equipment, are we continuing to supply material to the Kurds? And on Libya, what could be the type of international intervention that we could undertake, knowing the difficulty of the subject?

THE PRESIDENT

Three questions, so I will respond. First question: have I had a bilateral meeting with President POROCHENKO? No, no one has had a bilateral meeting since the Council was taking place. Some, notably the President of the European Council, the President of the Commission, have had meetings with Mr. POROCHENKO. I have spoken with him several times on the phone, so we talk. But there has been no request for military assistance. There is a request for humanitarian assistance, which has been addressed to the European Council.

Regarding military assistance, we cannot today think that it would be fruitful, useful, given that there are operations underway. What we must ask for is a ceasefire; it is not to maintain a conflict, it is to stop it. And that is what we are telling the Russians: to stop supplying equipment and weapons. From there, there has been no request that has been signified to us.

On the other hand, for Iraq and Syria, I mean for the Iraqi state and for the groups that are fighting, what is called ISIS, yes, there is a request that has been made to us, and you know that France has responded. I even think that France has responded not only first but perhaps still today, truly for the weapons that have been delivered, the only one. I know what the United States is doing elsewhere; here I am talking about European countries.

But European countries will now follow and will provide the necessary means. To coordinate these efforts, the Conference on Iraq will be the right response, the right framework. Because it is not simply about providing weapons for the sake of weapons, or even humanitarian aid that would not necessarily be well-targeted. That is why I wanted this Conference, and now we are on track to hold it, as soon as the Iraqi government has been formed.

On Libya, it is not a military intervention; it is about enabling the state, what remains of it, the government, the only legitimate one, the Parliament that has been elected, to have the support of the UN to reconstitute all the institutional forms, all the administrations that are necessary for there to be security and for there to be functioning in the country.

For now, there had been requests for police cooperation that have never been carried out; the same goes for military cooperation. It is no longer possible to leave Libya in this situation. Moreover, and it is true, there is the concentration of terrorist groups in southern Libya, and on this we must coordinate our intelligence services.

QUESTION

Mr. President, to return to domestic policy, you spoke earlier of clarification, of strengthening France's position in Europe. So tonight I would like to invite you to a clarification, because some time ago, in May 2013, when you were asked about your policy, your political line, you told us: I am a socialist who wants to make France succeed. A few months later, in January, I took up the terms of your press conference; you admitted to being social-democratic. So the question, you can guess it: are you today social-liberal, as it is said?

THE PRESIDENT

No, I have not changed my line. The same line has applied since I defined what the economic policy of France should be in the wake of the GALLOIS report. But not just its economic policy, its industrial policy, its social policy, its policy for restoring public accounts. I provided a framework, on January 14 of this year, with the pact of responsibility, so that there could be visibility, clarity on the reductions in labor costs for companies, on taxation for households, so that everyone clearly understands the meaning of what we decided, and that there is no misunderstanding, but especially no changes, no inconsistency, that could prevent the full measure of the political choices that are mine.

After that, regarding "socialist," "social-democrat," I gathered this morning socialist and social-democratic parties. Being social-democratic is being socialist. And in my view, being socialist is being social-democratic. But what I want to succeed is France. I need to have a party in the majority that is in unison with what I propose. This does not prevent debate; it does not cut off discussion; but it must be conducted in the perspective that I have defined. Because the French need clarity. And at the same time, all those who trust the left must also understand that this policy is made for the success of France and is also in line with my commitments, those I made before the French people.

Here is what I had to say. And today, at the European Council, since I was sitting on behalf of France, I made sure that it was in line with my commitments: that is to say, both to be able to redirect the construction of Europe, to put it, as I did as early as June 2012, on the path of growth and employment, and not to make austerity the horizon of the European Union, which would ultimately lead to despair among the peoples. At the same time, my commitments also include making the reforms that are essential for the country, that is to say, the reforms that have not been made for ten years, twelve years: those on competitiveness, improving the situation of businesses, but also tax justice and restoring public finances.

So there you go, it is possible to defend France and remain faithful to one's political commitment. Mine, you have known for a long time, and I do not change it. And I do not need to play with words: I said that I was a social democrat, I have always been, it is because I am a socialist. Thank you.